The present invention relates to a layer system comprising at least one molybdenum nitride layer, wherein the layer has the characteristic very good sliding properties of hexagonal molybdenum nitride, but at the same time an “appropriate” hardness, which is between 2600 HV and 3700 HV (Vickers hardness) or between 26-27 GPa and 37-38 GPa (indentation hardness HIT).
The present invention also relates to a method for the surface treatment of components, wherein at least one surface of a component is coated according to the invention and preferably subsequently post-treated using a brushing method so that enhanced sliding properties as well as reduced wear and tear of the counter body are achieved in tribological applications.
The use of molybdenum nitride layers or molybdenum nitride-based layers for coating components is well known in the prior art.
Ramm for example discloses in DE102010053751 A1 that coating systems with a molybdenum nitride layer for coating components resp. sliding elements can be used. This document teaches that coating the component surfaces with a molybdenum nitride layer enables both the coefficient of friction against steel as well as steel-smearing on the coated component surfaces to be reduced. The XRD diffraction pattern in FIG. 4 of document DE102010053751A1 shows that the disclosed molybdenum nitride layers predominantly have a cubic structure, which refers to the gamma or zeta phase of molybdenum nitride. In addition, it is stated that these layers have a layer hardness of approx. 3000 HV and were deposited by means of a PVD arc process using molybdenum targets in a reactive atmosphere of nitrogen, with a coating temperature of 450° C., a nitrogen pressure of 3.5 Pa and a negative substrate bias voltage of −20 V were used. The friction coefficients were determined both for coated surfaces that were subsequently polished as well as for coated surfaces that were subjected to no post-treatment after the coating. Ramm in DE102010053751 A1 also suggests a further layer consisting of molybdenum monoxide or molybdenum oxinitride and which is used as the uppermost layer of the coating. It is further noted that the growth of various phases of molybdenum nitride can be well regulated by the adjustment of pulse parameters if the molybdenum nitride layer is deposited for example by means of pulsed spark evaporation and/or using a pulsed bias voltage.
Ürgen et al. report in Surface and Coatings Technology 94-95 (1997) 501-506 about molybdenum nitride layers which have been deposited by means of PVD arc evaporation of molybdenum targets in a reactive nitrogen atmosphere. Molybdenum nitride layers having different phases were produced by varying the nitrogen pressure, the coating temperature of between 450° C. and 500° C. being maintained and a negative substrate bias voltage of −50 V being used. Ürgen reports that the formation of the cubic gamma phase (γ-Mo2N) of molybdenum nitride was enhanced by using a low nitrogen pressure of 0.4 Pa or 0.8 Pa and the formation of the hexagonal delta phase (δ-MoN) of molybdenum nitride was enhanced by using a higher nitrogen pressure of 1.2 Pa or 1.8 Pa. The layers comprising γ-Mo2N had hardness values of 30000 N/mm2 to 36000 N/mm2, while the layer comprising δ-MoN had higher hardness values of approximately 38000 N/mm2 and higher. Tribological tests with subsequently polished molybdenum nitride layers showed that molybdenum nitride layers with higher nitrogen content have better wear properties, lower friction coefficients and a decreased tendency to form cracks.
Maier proposes in DE102012207814A1 to coat components, in particular sliding elements, with a protective coating which has a main layer whose main components are molybdenum and nitrogen, wherein preferably the main layer is to be formed as a molybdenum nitride layer, the protective coating is to be deposited by means of a PVD arc method to the component, and the main layer is to be flattened after the layer deposition by fine grinding and/or lapping and/or honing and/or polishing. Nevertheless, Maier does not disclose clear coating parameters for the deposition of the molybdenum nitride layer as a main layer. It is only mentioned that the main layer may have a nitrogen content of preferably 20-60 at %. However, a lower nitrogen content of 25-40 at % is preferred. In particular, a nitrogen content of 30-35 at % is most preferred. It is additionally noted that the hardness of the main layer is preferably between 1500 HV and 2200 HV, in order to ensure a particularly high mechanical stability of the component. Since Maier proposes a combination of low hardness and low nitrogen content for the main layer, it can reasonably be concluded that a molybdenum nitride layer containing at least essentially gamma phase (γ-Mo2N) as a main layer is best suited for the coating of sliding elements.
Kazmanli et al. also report in Surface and Coatings Technology 167 (2003) 77-82 about the deposition of molybdenum nitride coatings by means of a PVD arc method, wherein molybdenum targets are evaporated in a reactive atmosphere of nitrogen. Kazmanli teaches in a manner similar to Ürgen that the formation of pure γ-Mo2N is basically enhanced by using a low nitrogen pressure, for example of 0.8 Pa or 0.4 Pa, and the formation of pure δ-MoN is enhanced by using a higher nitrogen pressure of for example 1.9 Pa. However, Kazmanli also reports about the formation of mixed gamma and delta phases by using a medium nitrogen pressure of for example 1.2 Pa or 1.5 Pa. Kazmanli furthermore teaches that the bias voltage and the substrate temperature during deposition of molybdenum nitride layers can play an important role. A high negative bias voltage of for example −250V to −350V should result in an increase of the energy of the Mo ions, which could enhance the formation of the gamma phase. A low negative bias voltage of for example −50V to −150V, however, should allow for the formation of the delta phase. Kazmanli additionally reports that molybdenum nitride layers which were deposited at a substrate temperature of 300° C. to 380° C. exhibited the formation of the delta phase whilst molybdenum nitride layers which were deposited at a higher substrate temperature of 410° C. to 510° C. exhibited the formation of a mixture of gamma and delta phase, wherein for the deposition of both variants a a nitrogen pressure of 1 Pa and a negative bias voltage of −150° V were used. The hardness values of the investigated molybdenum nitride layers were approximately 3372 HV for the gamma phase layers, approx. 5085 HV for the delta phase layers and approx. 4750 HV for the mixed gamma and delta-phase layers.
Hanbey Hazar in Materials and Design 31 (2010) 624-627 similarly reported on molybdenum nitride layers which were deposited on diesel engine parts by means of an Arc-PVD method and using a coating temperature of 300° C., a current of 125 A, a coating pressure of 0.4 Pa and a negative bias voltage of −100V. It is not specified whether only nitrogen gas or a gas containing nitrogen was introduced into the coating chamber during the coating process. Unlike Kazmanli, Hanbey Hazar reports about molybdenum nitride layers with delta phase but with a layer hardness of 2000 HV, which is much lower than that which was reported by Kazmanli.
According to the teaching of the documents cited above, the coating of sliding elements with molybdenum nitride layers which are deposited by means of arc PV, and the subsequent polishing of the coated surfaces are advantageous.
However, there is no clear indication as to whether to improve gliding properties, a molybdenum nitride layer with exclusively or mainly γ-Mo2N, or a molybdenum nitride layer with exclusively or mainly δ-MoN, or a molybdenum nitride layer with both γ-Mo2N and δ-MoN is most suitable.
At the same time, it is also not clear what hardness values for which phase are truly achievable and best suited.
Likewise, it is not clear which parameters should be used to deposit a predetermined combination of a certain phase or a certain mixture of phases of molybdenum nitride and a certain layer hardness.
Regarding the subsequent polishing of the surfaces coated with molybdenum nitride layers, it is not clear how a polishing process for the treatment of component surfaces can be used industrially. This mainly because the use of such methods in industrial production for the treatment of coated components with complex shapes, as for example piston pins and piston rings, is very expensive and complex.
For the use of a simple and cheaper process, which the brush method for example is, which would be well applicable for the treatment of components coated with molybdenum nitride in an industrial production environment, it would be desirable or necessary for the molybdenum nitride layers to be easy to brush and that they should tend rather to have a reduced hardness, which is preferably not higher than 3700 HV.
Again, however, is not desirable for many tribological applications to have a coating hardness that is too low. Therefore, the hardness of the molybdenum nitride layers should possibly be equal to or preferably greater than 2600 HV.
It is an object of the present invention to provide a molybdenum nitride layer and a method for its preparation, wherein the layer has very good sliding properties and at the same time a “reasonable” coating hardness which is preferably not lower than 2600 HV and not greater than 3700 HV.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide an economical process for the post-treatment of molybdenum nitride layers.
The object of the present invention is achieved by providing a coating as in claim 1, a coating method as in claim 13, and a brushing process for the post-treatment of the coated surfaces as provided in claim 15.
The present invention relates to a coating comprising at least one Mo—N based hard material layer, which at least largely comprises the hexagonal phase of the molybdenum nitride δ-MoN, wherein the intensity ratio of the two peaks (δ-MoN 220)/(δ-MoN 200) is ≥3, preferably ≥10, more preferably ≥30.
The inventive Mo—N based hard material layer is preferably deposited as the uppermost layer of the coating.
In certain applications, it has been found that it may be advantageous if the coating includes only one or more Mo—N based hard material coatings. However, the hard material layer system may also include layers of other materials which may serve, for example, as adhesive layers or support layers, or as other types of layers.
According to a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the Mo—N based hard material layer preferably consists essentially of molybdenum nitride.
According to a another preferred embodiment of the present invention, the Mo—N based hard material coating has a Vickers hardness between 2600 HV and 3700 HV or an indentation hardness HIT between 27 GPa and 38 GPa.
According to a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the Mo—N based hard material coating has residual stresses resp. compressive stresses between −1 Pa and −9 Pa.
Preferably, the residual stresses are between −2 Pa and −8 Pa.
According to yet another preferred embodiment of the present invention, the surface of the Mo—N based hard material coating is subsequently treated by means of a brushing process.
Preferably, the Mo—N based hard material coating thus post-treated has a surface roughness that is characterized by Rpkx<Rvkc.
A coating according to the present invention is preferably produced by means of PVD techniques.
Preferably, at least the Mo—N based layer of a coating according to the present invention is deposited on a substrate surface in a vacuum coating chamber by means of arc evaporation of at least one target comprising at least largely molybdenum in an atmosphere containing at least largely nitrogen gas, wherein the coating temperature during at least most of the deposition time of the Mo—N based hard material layer is maintained under 300° C.
The coating temperature during the deposition of the Mo—N based hard material layer is preferably ≤280° C., more preferably ≤250° C., even more preferably ≤225° C.
In the frame of the present invention, the term coating temperature is to be understood as the the temperature of the substrates to be coated during the deposition of the Mo—N based hard material layer.
Preferably, during at least during most of deposition time of the Mo—N based hard material coating, if possible only nitrogen gas is admitted into the coating chamber. Minimal amounts of other gases (e.g. minimal amounts of argon or krypton or oxygen or carbon or hydrogen, etc.) should in principle not a problem for the production of the inventive layers.
Preferably, during at least during most of deposition time of the Mo—N based hard material coating, a negative bias voltage is applied onto the substrate to be coated.
Preferably, for the deposition of the Mo—N based hard material layer, only targets are used that consist essentially of molybdenum
Surprisingly, the process parameter window as regards the selection of process parameters such as nitrogen pressure and bias voltage for the deposition of the inventive Mo—N based hard material coatings is significantly large when using a coating method according to the present invention.
The invention will be described in more detail on the basis of the following figures and examples:
In the frame of the present invention, when reference is made to the formation of the gamma phase of molybdenum nitride (γ-Mo2N), this should rather be understood as the formation of a cubic phase of the molybdenum nitride, i.e. the formation of the gamma or the zeta phase or even the formation of a mixture of the two cubic phases both gamma as well as zeta.
The zeta phase (ζ-MoN) is also a cubic phase of the molybdenum nitride like the gamma phase, but which in comparison with the gamma phase (γ-Mo2N) comprises more nitrogen. The nitrogen content in the zeta phase can even go into the super-stoichiometric range (more N than Mo). In XRD diffraction patterns, the gamma phase can hardly be distinguished from the zeta phase, because these two phases, as mentioned above, are cubic. Therefore, the formation of these two phases can be detected accurately only if, for example, a detailed analysis of the chemical composition is made. However, if multiple phases are present in the layer, an accurate determination of the gamma or zeta phase is very difficult. That's why in the present description of the invention, many mentions were made γ-Mo2N, whereas it could just as well be the ζ-MoN. Since the currently existing references from the literature with respect to XRD diffraction patterns of cubic phases of molybdenum nitride always use the term γ-phase, reference is made in the present invention to the gamma phase and not simply to a cubic phase of molybdenum nitride, although it also is may be the zeta phase.
For the XRD investigations in the context of the present invention, the following equipment and measurement programs were used:
XRD Device:
For the examples and analyses, specimens from high-speed steel 1.2842 90MnCrV8 and sliding elements made of various high-speed steels, as well as standard piston pins (for the experiments with coated and subsequently brushed piston pin surfaces) were coated in an arc facility of the company Oerlikon Balzers Coating AG. In all examples, molybdenum targets were evaporated by means of arc PVD in a nitrogen atmosphere. The process pressure resp. the nitrogen pressure was maintained constant by controlling the flow of nitrogen gas in the coating chamber. A bias voltage was applied to the substrates to be coated. The same arc coating sources and arc current values were used for all processes. Only the coating temperature, the nitrogen pressure and the bias voltage were varied according to the information in
The Mo—N based hard material coatings produced in examples 1, 2 and 3, which were deposited according to the invention using a coating temperature of 200° C.+/−15° C., comprise at least for the most part the delta phase of molybdenum nitride. Even if a low N2 pressure of 1.5 Pa (as indicated in
On the other hand, the XRD diffraction patterns of the layers produced according to examples 4, 5 and 6, in which a coating temperature of 300° C. or higher was used, show a cubic structure which indicates the formation of the gamma and/or zeta phase of molybdenum nitride (see XRD diffraction patterns of a Mo—N based layer according to example 5 (5) in
In
The coating temperature for the deposition of a Mo—N based hard material coating according to the present invention is at least 50° C., more preferably at least 100° C., most preferably at least 150° C.
Furthermore, the inventors have found that by using a coating temperature not higher than 200° C.+/−50° C. even Mo—N layers can be produced according to the invention if a nitrogen pressure of less than 1.5 Pa, or more than 6 Pa and/or a negative bias voltage is lower (in absolute value) than −20 V or greater (in absolute value) than −120V is used.
Further details of embodiments or preferred embodiments of the present invention:
According to the invention a bias voltage of −10V to −150V is preferably used.
According to the invention a nitrogen pressure of 1 Pa to 6 Pa is preferably used.
As already mentioned above, the inventively produced Mo—N layers exhibit the characteristic hexagonal structure of the delta phase of molybdenum nitride. At the same time, the layers produced according to the invention exhibit a Vickers hardness between 2600 HV and 3700 HV or an indentation hardness HIT between 26-27 GPa and 37-38 GPa.
According to a preferred embodiment of a coating with at least one Mo—N layer according to the present invention, the inventive Mo—N layers have an e-modulus between 300 GPa and 500 GPa, preferably between 330 and 470 GPa, more preferably between 350 and 450 GPa.
According to another preferred embodiment of a coating according to the present invention, the inventive Mo—N layers exhibit residual compressive stresses of −1 GPa to −9 GPa, preferably of −2 GPa to −8 GPa.
According to yet another preferred embodiment of a coating according to the present invention, the inventive Mo—N layers a indentation hardness HIT greater than 28 GPa and lower than 37 GPa.
During tribological tests, the inventors have found that inventive Mo—N layers with a Vickers hardness of 3000 HV to 3600 HV or an indentation hardness HIT between 30 GPa and 36 GPa are particularly well suited for certain applications.
Particularly outstanding gliding properties were found for example in the inventive Mo—N layers which had a HIT hardness of 34 GPa to 35 GPa, a yield point of 31 GPa to 32 GPa and an e-modulus of 350 GPa to 450 GPa.
As mentioned above, the Mo—N layers are preferably treated by means of a brushing process in order to achieve a good surface finish suitable resp. surface roughness, which is especially important for tribological applications in which good gliding properties are required.
The increase in roughness in/on layers which are produced by means of cathodic arc vaporization (arc evaporation or arc PVD), is very marked due to the occurrence of macro-particles (droplets or spatters) from the cathode (target). A post-treatment, for example by polishing or brushing or micro-beams, does not produce a significant reduction in roughness in all layers produced by cathodic arc evaporation. This is because the integration of spatters in the layer occurs at different degrees of stability and because for this reason the layers let themselves be post-treated more or less well.
In the case of the inventive Mo—N based hard material coatings, the post-treatment by brushing works very well however.
This is illustrated in
In
The high Rvkx value compared to the Rpkx value enhances the formation of oil lubrication pockets that ensure good lubrication especially with small amounts of oil.
In order to achieve low wear and tear of the counter body, a Rpkx<0.3 μm, preferably <0.2 μm, more preferably <0.15 μm is sought.
According to a particularly preferred embodiment of the present invention, the Mo—N layers have a nitrogen content of 45 at % to 55 at %.
The measured ratio in atomic % between nitrogen and molybdenum content in the inventive layers which during operation of molybdenum targets as cathodes in an arc PVD process using an arc current of 220 A, a coating temperature (=substrate temperature) of 200° C., a negative bias voltage of −20V and a nitrogen pressure of 3 Pa, was nearly 50:50.
According to a further embodiment of the present invention, an adhesive layer deposited as an interface between the substrate to be coated and the molybdenum nitride layer. As the adhesive layer in this context, Cr and/or CrN are particularly well suited layers, preferably with a thickness of less than 60 nm, depending on the application particularly preferably between 10 nm and 50 nm.
According to a highly preferred embodiment of a method according to the present invention, the inventively produced Mo—N hard material layer is deposited as the outermost layer of the coating by means of arc evaporation of molybdenum targets in a nitrogen atmosphere and subsequently post-treated by means of a brushing method until a surface roughness with Rpkx<Rvkx is achieved.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10 2013 018 007 | Nov 2013 | DE | national |
PCT/EP2014/003151 | Nov 2014 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2014/003200 | 12/1/2014 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2015/096882 | 7/2/2015 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6617057 | Gorokhovsky | Sep 2003 | B2 |
20090026292 | Davies | Jan 2009 | A1 |
20130303414 | Ramm | Nov 2013 | A1 |
20150011444 | Ramm | Jan 2015 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
10 2010 053 751 | May 2012 | DE |
10 2012 207 814 | Nov 2013 | DE |
Entry |
---|
Hazar “Characterization of MoN coatings for pistons in a diesel engine” Materials & Design 31 (2010) p. 624-627. |
Urgen et al “Characterization of molybdenum nitride coatings produced by arc-PVD technique” Surface and Coatings Technology 94-95 (1997) p. 501-506. |
Sarioglu, et al., “Measurement of Residual Stresses by X-ray Diffraction Techniques in MoN and Mo2N Coatings Deposited by Arc PVD on High-speed Steel Substrate”, Surface and Coatings Technology, Elsevier, Amsterdam, NL, Bd. 190, Nr. 2-3, Jan. 21, 2005. |
Kazmanli, et al., “Effect of Nitrogen Pressure, Bias Voltage and Substrate Temperature on the Phase Structure of Mo-N Coatings Produced by Cathodic Arc PVD”, Surface and Coatings Technology Elsevier, Switzerland, Bd. 167, Nr. 1, Apr. 1, 2003. |
International Search Report for PCT/EP2014/003200 dated Jul. 27, 2015. |
Written Opinion for PCT/EP2014/003200 dated Jul. 27, 2015. |
Mirescu, C.R. and Capitanu, L.; “Surface Topography Characterization: A pragmatic approach,” SISOM 2012 and Session of the Commission of Acoustics; available at http://www.imsar.ro/SISOM_Papers_2012/SISOM_2012_R_13.pdf, retrieved Apr. 11, 2018; pp. 240-254. |
Romanian Academy, Department of Technical Sciences; “The Annual Symposium of the Institute of Solid Mechanics SISOM 2012 and Session of the Commission of Acoustics,” Bucharest, Romania, May 30-31, 2012; available at http://www.imsar.ro/Sisom_2012.pdf, retrieved Apr. 11, 2018; 21 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20170029930 A1 | Feb 2017 | US |