This invention is in the field of lithium batteries. This invention relates generally to techniques for stabilizing lithium metal anodes by creating an artificial solid-electrolyte interphase material over the lithium metal, associated electrolytes, and electrochemical cells.
Batteries including lithium metal as an anode are generally regarded as not rechargeable. Decomposition of liquid electrolytes can occur during recharging, which may damage or degrade the cells. Additionally, dendrites can form on the lithium anode, risking short-circuiting of the battery.
The present disclosure relates to electrodes and electrochemical cells with protective components allowing use of lithium metal (or other alkali metal) as an anode, even in secondary (i.e., rechargeable) batteries. The protective component may correspond to a layer of an interface material over or coating an alkali metal anode, such as an artificial solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) material.
In an aspect, the present disclosure provides electrodes, which may be useful as an anode of an electrochemical cell. For example, an electrode of this aspect comprises an alkali metal or a substrate for alkali metal deposition; and an interface material on a surface of the alkali metal or the substrate. The alkali metal may be lithium, sodium, potassium, cesium, etc. The interface material may comprise a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups.
The interface material may comprise, correspond to, or act as an artificial solid-electrolyte interphase. The interface material may have a chemical formula of AxMyQz. A may correspond to a metal or combination of metals. Q may correspond to a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens. M may correspond to one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups. The values for x, y, and z may represent the relative amounts of A, M, and Q, respectively in the interface material and may be from 0 to 1 or between 0 and 1. The chalcogen (Q) or combination of chalcogens may be one or a combination of sulfur, selenium, or tellurium. The metal (A) may be an alkali metal, such as lithium, sodium, potassium, or cesium. The one or more elements, the one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups (M) may correspond to an element less electronegative than the chalcogen or the combination of chalcogens. The one or more elements, the one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups (M) may correspond to an element having a similar electronegativity to the chalcogen or the combination of chalcogens. Useful examples include, but are not limited to, one or a combination of tellurium, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, bismuth, carbon, germanium, tin, lead, gallium, indium, molybdenum, tungsten, titanium, vanadium, copper, silver, gold, zinc, or cadmium. In some examples, the interface material comprises Li2TeS3, Li3SbS4, Li2CS3, LixMoySz, or LixWySz.
In another aspect, electrochemical cells are provided. The electrochemical cells described herein may be primary and/or secondary electrochemical cells. An example electrochemical cell of this aspect comprises a positive electrode, such as a positive electrode that can reversibly store and release alkali metal ions; an electrolyte; and a negative electrode. The negative electrode may comprise the electrodes described above. For example, the negative electrode may comprise an alkali metal or a substrate for alkali metal deposition; and an interface material on a surface of the alkali metal or the substrate. The interface material may correspond to that noted above and may comprise a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups.
Any suitable positive electrode useful with alkali metal or alkali metal ion batteries may be used with the electrochemical cells described herein. For example, the positive electrode may be a conversion-based or insertion-based cathode. Optionally, the positive electrode comprises an oxygen-based electroactive material, a sulfur-based electroactive material, a selenium-based electroactive material, a layered-oxide cathode material, LCO (lithium cobalt oxide), NMC (lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide), NCA (lithium nickel cobalt aluminum oxide), a spinel-based cathode material, LMO (lithium manganese oxide), LNMO (lithium manganese nickel oxide), a polyanion-based cathode material, or LFP (lithium iron phosphate).
Any suitable electrolyte used with alkali metal or alkali metal ion batteries may be used with the electrochemical cells described herein. For example, the electrolyte may be a solid or liquid or mixed-phase material that conducts alkali metal ions and blocks passage of electrons.
Optionally, the interface material is formed in situ after assembly of the electrochemical cell. Optionally, the interface material is formed in situ during operation when an electric field is applied between the positive electrode and the negative electrode. Optionally, the interface material is formed in situ during one or more charging or discharging operations, such as during an initial charging or discharging operation, or within a few or several charging or discharging operations, such as within 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 charging and/or discharging operations.
In embodiments, the interface material may be fabricated prior to assembly of the electrochemical cell. As an example, in some cases, the interface material may be fabricated on a negative electrode prior to assembly, such as ex situ by a deposition or coating process on an alkali metal electrode or a negative electrode current collector. For example, a solution-based coating method can be used, such as a drop-casting technique in which a solution of a poly-chalcogen-sulfide, like a polytellurosulfide, or a suitable precursor, is deposited onto an alkali metal or current collector foil to form the interface material thereon. As another example, a vapor deposition coating method can be used, such as where a layer of Li2TeS3 or a precursor material, such as TeS2/Li2Te, is deposited by chemical vapor deposition onto an alkali metal or current collector foil to form the interface material thereon. As another example, a vapor deposition coating method can be used, such as where a layer of Li3SbS4 or a precursor material, such as Sb2S5, is deposited by chemical vapor deposition onto an alkali metal or current collector foil to form the interface material thereon
Such an ex situ prepared negative electrode with an interface material thereon can then be used in any suitable electrochemical cell system with any desired cathode chemistry. Alternatively, in some cases, the interface material may be fabricated on a negative electrode prior to assembly through in situ fabrication in another electrochemical cell, and then that negative electrode with the interface material thereon can be used in the assembly of a different electrochemical cell, optionally using a different chemistry. For example, the interface material may be generated in an alkali metal-sulfur battery system (e.g., with a sulfur cathode) and then the alkali metal negative electrode with a coating layer of the interface material thereon removed from the alkali metal-sulfur battery system and incorporated into a different electrochemical cell incorporating an alkali metal-metal oxide cathode. In this way, the negative electrode can have the layer of interface material pre-fabricated thereon at the time of assembly of the different electrochemical cell.
In a further aspect, methods are described herein, such as methods of producing an interface material, such as on a negative electrode of an electrochemical cell. An example method of this aspect comprises introducing an additive into a component of the electrochemical cell during assembly; and forming the interface material in situ after assembly of the electrochemical cell. The interface material may again correspond to those described above and may comprise, for example, a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups. The electrochemical cell or the anode may be based on alkali metal plating and stripping, for example.
Optionally, the additive may be introduced into or included in the electrolyte. For example, the interface material may be formed in situ by partial or complete reduction of one or more components of the electrolyte, including the additive, on a surface of the negative electrode. As an example, the additive may comprise a chalcogen-based composition dissolved or present in the electrolyte. Example additives include, but are not limited to organotellurium additives, such as diphenyl ditelluride, polytellurosulfide species, thiomolybdate species, or thiotungstate species.
Optionally, the additive may be introduced into or included in the positive electrode. For example, the interface material may be formed in situ by reaction of the additive with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component, and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode. As an example, the additive may comprise a chalcogen-based composition dispersed or present in the positive electrode. Example additives include, but are not limited to, Te, Li2CS3, (NH4)2MoS4, or (NH4)2WS4.
Optionally, the additive may be introduced onto the polymer separator as a coating. For example, the interface material may be formed in situ by reaction of the separator coating with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component; and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode. As an example, the additive may comprise a chalcogen-based coating on the separator, such as a tellurium coating.
Optionally, the additive may be introduced into or included in the negative electrode or in the negative electrode current collector. For example, the interface material may be formed in situ by reaction of the additive with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component, and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode. In some cases, the interface material may be formed in situ by direct reaction or reduction of the additive on a surface of the negative electrode. As an example, the additive may comprise a chalcogen-based coating on the negative electrode or negative electrode current collector, such as a tellurium coating.
In embodiments, the electrochemical cell comprises a positive electrode comprising a sulfur-based active material and the additive, an organic liquid electrolyte, the negative electrode. In some examples, the additive is tellurium or a tellurium composition, such a tellurium sulfide compound. In some examples, the additive is molybdenum or a molybdenum composition, such as a thiomolybdate, such as (NH4)2MoS4. In some examples, the additive is tungsten or a tungsten composition, such as a thiotungstate, such as (NH4)2WS4. In some examples, the negative electrode corresponds to a lithium plating and stripping electrode. In some examples, the interface material comprises Li2TeS3, Li3SbS4, Li2CS3, LixMoySz, or LixWySz, where x, y, and z are each independently between 0 and 1.
Optionally, methods of this aspect may further include disassembling the electrochemical cell, at least in part, to remove or separate the negative electrode with the interface material thereon and incorporating the negative electrode with the interface material thereon into a different electrochemical cell. In this way, the negative electrode in the different electrochemical cell can have a coating or layer of the interface material thereon at the time of assembly and incorporation into the different electrochemical cell. This may also allow the different electrochemical cell to use a different chemistry, which may be incompatible with in situ formation of the interface material or may not include components or additives permitting formation of the interface material in situ.
Without wishing to be bound by any particular theory, there can be discussion herein of beliefs or understandings of underlying principles relating to the invention. It is recognized that regardless of the ultimate correctness of any mechanistic explanation or hypothesis, an embodiment of the invention can nonetheless be operative and useful.
Described herein are electrodes, electrochemical cells, methods of making electrodes, and methods of making electrochemical cells. The electrodes described herein have an interface layer or material that can stabilize reversible alkali metal deposition. The interface material may correspond to or be a solid-electrolyte interphase that can allow alkali metal ions to transmit through and be deposited below the interface material. The interface material can prevent dendrite formation and/or decomposition of the electrolyte at the electrode, enabling use of lithium metal safely in a secondary (e.g., rechargeable) electrochemical cell (e.g., as an anode). The interface material may comprise a combination of one or more metals, one or more chalcogens, and one or more other elements or organic functional groups. An example interface material may comprise lithium thiotellurate (Li2TeS3) and/or lithium telluride (Li2Te). Other examples include, but are not limited to Li3SbS4, Li2CS3, LixMoySz, or LixWySz, where x, y, and z are independently between 0 and 1. The interface material may also allow electrochemical cells to exhibit low- or no-excess lithium thereby providing weight advantages. In some cases, such a configuration can limit the mass of the anode to only that which is electrochemically useful. For example, “anode-less” electrochemical cells are described which may include no or zero anode active material (e.g., zero excess anode active material), such as when fully discharged. Some advantages of these anode-less electrochemical cells may include improvements in gravimetric energy density or volumetric energy density, such as when compared to conventional cells including an anode, such as with a typical or excess amount of active material. Another advantage of an anode-less electrochemical cells is that such a cell has no self-discharge, since the cell can be assembled or correspond to a discharged state. Further, anode-less electrochemical cells can be advantageous since metallic lithium may not be used generally and, particularly, this configuration may also preclude the use and handling of thin lithium foils.
The interface material may be particularly useful for sulfur-based electrochemical cells, such as a lithium-sulfur electrochemical cell. Sulfur-based electrochemical cells are particularly advantageous because the interface material can be easily prepared by including additives in the sulfur (cathode) component of the electrochemical cell and then preparing the interface material in situ during operation or cycling of the electrochemical cell.
Although the present description may describe use of the interface material with sulfur-based electrochemical cells like lithium-sulfur electrochemical cells, the interface material is generally useful with any alkali metal electrochemical cell and is not specific to sulfur cathode cells. It will be appreciated that, although the present description describes preparation of a lithium anode with a protective coating of the interface material, alkali metal anodes with a protective coating of the interface material can be prepared and used in the same way as lithium-based systems by substituting the other alkali metal (e.g., sodium, potassium, or cesium, etc.) for lithium. It will further be appreciated that electrodes including a protective coating of the interface material can be used in other alkali metal electrochemical cell systems beyond sulfur-based cathode systems (e.g., Li2S), such as any conventional alkali metal-ion (e.g., Li-ion) cathode system, such as those comprising an oxygen-based electroactive material, a selenium-based electroactive material, a layered-oxide cathode material, LCO (lithium cobalt oxide), NMC (lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide), NCA (lithium nickel cobalt aluminum oxide), a spinel-based cathode material, LMO (lithium manganese oxide), LNMO (lithium manganese nickel oxide), a polyanion-based cathode material (e.g., phosphate-, sulfate-, silicate-, borate-, etc. based cathode materials or combinations thereof), or LFP (lithium iron phosphate).
Without wishing to be bound by any theory, the interface material may be generated upon reaction or deposition of certain materials at the anode interface. For example, inclusion of tellurium as an additive in a sulfur electrode of an electrochemical cell may allow for generation of an interface material comprising tellurium and sulfur during operation or cycling of the electrochemical cell. As will be appreciated, polysulfide shuttles can transfer material from the cathode to the anode in a sulfur-based battery system. This aspect can be exploited to intentionally create an interface material at the anode where an additive material from the cathode is shuttled to the anode by way of polysulfides.
The interface material may have a chemical formula of AxMyQz, where A is a metal or a combination of metals, M is one or more elements or one or more organic functional groups or a combination of one or more elements and one or more functional groups, and Q is a chalcogen or a combination of chalcogens. Each of x, y, and z can represent a relative molar amount of A, M, and Q, respectively and can vary from 0 to 1. Chalcogen Q may be one or a combination of sulfur, selenium, or tellurium. Component M can be or comprise an element or elements less electronegative than the chalcogen Q, or in some cases M can be or comprise an element or elements having a similar electronegativity to the chalcogen Q. Examples of component M can comprise or include, though are not limited to, tellurium, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, bismuth, carbon, germanium, tin, lead, gallium, indium, molybdenum, tungsten, titanium, vanadium, copper, silver, gold, zinc, or cadmium. Component A may be an alkali metal, such as lithium, sodium, potassium, or cesium.
As noted above, “anode-less” electrochemical cells are described, which may correspond to an electrode with a substrate for alkali metal deposition, over which an interface material can be positioned. During operation of such an electrochemical cell, alkali metal may be deposited on the substrate and/or beneath the interface material.
The electrodes described above and depicted in
At block 430, the interface material is formed in situ after assembly of the electrochemical cell. For example, as indicated at block 435, the interface material may optionally be formed by reacting the additive, included in the cathode, with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary or intermediate electrolyte component, which can then be partially or completely reduced on or at a surface of the negative electrode or a component thereof, as indicated at block 470. As indicated at block 440, the interface material may optionally be formed by reacting the additive, included in the separator, with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary or intermediate electrolyte component, which can then be partially or completely reduced on or at a surface of the negative electrode or a component thereof, as indicated at block 470. If an additive is included in the electrolyte, the interface material may optionally be formed partial or complete reduction on or at a surface of the negative electrode or a component thereof, as indicated at block 470.
In some cases, the interface material can be formed on the negative electrode prior to assembly of the electrochemical cell. For example, the above described methods and techniques can be used to prepare the interface material on a negative electrode, such as in situ in an electrochemical cell, with the electrochemical cell then disassembled to use the negative electrode in another electrochemical cell. Such a configuration may be useful to allow preparing the interface material on the negative electrode, such as in an alkali metal-sulfur electrochemical cell system, and then allowing the negative electrode with the interface material to be used in another electrochemical cell chemistry (e.g., with an alkali metal cobalt oxide type cathode or other non-sulfur-based cathode).
In other cases, the interface material on the negative electrode can be formed using a solution coating technique, which may be performed ex situ of any electrochemical cell. For example, a negative electrode comprising a lithium metal and/or copper foil current collector can receive a coating of a Li2TeS3 interface material by subjecting the negative electrode to a solution-based technique in which a polytellurosulfide solution is drop-cast onto the negative electrode. Other similar solution-based coating techniques may be used, such as roll-to-roll coating techniques, immersion coating techniques, or the like. In some cases, a voltage may be applied between the negative electrode and a reference electrode in contact with the solution to facilitate reaction of the polytellurosulfide in the solution to form the interface material on the negative electrode.
In other cases, the interface material on the negative electrode can be formed using a vapor deposition technique, which may be performed ex situ of any electrochemical cell. For example, a negative electrode comprising a lithium metal and/or copper foil current collector can receive a coating of a Li2TeS3 interface material by subjecting the negative electrode to chemical vapor deposition of Li2TeS3 or a precursor, such as TeS2/Li2Te. As another example, a negative electrode comprising a lithium metal and/or copper foil current collector can receive a coating of a Li3SbS4 interface material by subjecting the negative electrode to chemical vapor deposition of Li3SbS4 or a precursor, such as Sb2S5.
The invention may be further understood by the following non-limiting examples.
For lithium-sulfur batteries to achieve their promising energy density, it is valuable to stabilize lithium deposition and improve cyclability while reducing excess lithium and electrolyte. This example describes introducing tellurium into the Li—S system as a cathode additive to significantly improve the reversibility of lithium plating/stripping by forming a tellurized sulfide-rich SEI layer on the lithium surface. A remarkable improvement in cyclability is demonstrated in anode-free full-cells with limited lithium inventory and large-area Li—S pouch cells under lean electrolyte conditions. Tellurium reacts with polysulfides to generate soluble polytellurosulfides that migrate to the anode side and form stabilizing lithium thiotellurate and lithium telluride in situ as SEI components. A significant reduction in electrolyte decomposition on the lithium surface is also engendered. This work establishes engineering a stable sulfide-rich SEI layer as a viable strategy for stabilizing lithium deposition and preserving electrochemical performance under limited lithium and limited electrolyte conditions as a robust evaluation framework for realizing practically viable Li—S batteries.
The lithium/sulfur couple holds tremendous potential for enabling the next generation of high-energy density rechargeable batteries, combining the large gravimetric capacities of sulfur (1,675 mA h g−1) and lithium (3,861 mA h g−1). While there has been substantial progress towards solving the numerous issues with sulfur cathodes, a large excess of lithium metal and liquid electrolyte may still be useful for enabling long cycle life. A typical Li—S cell with a 4 mg cm−2 sulfur cathode and 0.75 mm thick lithium-metal foil anode may have a lithium to sulfur (Li/S) capacity ratio of 20 or even higher. The electrolyte to sulfur (E/S) ratio in such a cell might also exceed 20 μl mg−1 of sulfur. These unrealistic values, representative of literature, can lead to overstated electrochemical performance and compromise system-level energy density. Reducing excess lithium and electrolyte while maintaining reasonable capacities and cyclability is useful to Li—S batteries achieving commercial viability.
These challenges may originate with the intrinsically low Coulombic efficiencies of lithium-metal anode. The low reduction potential of lithium (−3.04 V vs SHE) can cause the electrolyte to undergo irreversible decomposition on the lithium surface to form a solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI). This can be severely exacerbated by the high surface area of lithium undergoing mossy deposition mechanisms under practical current regimes. Combined with the formation of electrochemically inaccessible or “dead” lithium, these side reactions can lead to rapid depletion of the available electrolyte supply and lithium inventory. Employing a large excess of lithium and electrolyte can becomes useful to compensate for these losses. The consequent tradeoff between energy density and cyclability can be addressed by improving the reversibility of lithium-metal anode. In Li—S batteries, the presence of soluble and highly reactive polysulfide intermediates in the ether-based electrolyte can acutely impact lithium deposition and render its characteristics fundamentally distinct from other systems. This may necessitate bold new strategies towards improving lithium deposition in Li—S batteries that account for their unique chemistry and ensure compatibility with polysulfide species. Stabilized lithium deposition can also help substantially mitigate the safety concerns associated with lithium dendrites causing internal shorting and catastrophic failure of the battery.
This example demonstrates that introducing elemental tellurium)(Te0 as an additive in the sulfur/Li2S cathode leads to a dramatic improvement in the reversibility of the lithium-metal anode. Both anode-free full-cells (limited lithium) and large-area pouch cells (limited electrolyte) show significant improvement in cyclability. Te0 is solubilized by polysulfides to generate polytellurosulfide species (Li2TexSy) that migrate to the anode side. Their reduction on the deposited lithium helps form a novel bilayer SEI structure in situ, comprising lithium thiotellurate (Li2TeS3) and lithium telluride (Li2Te). Compared with Li2S, which is the corresponding SEI component in a control system, the tellurium-containing SEI species confer considerable advantages for stabilizing lithium deposition. This example opens a new paradigm for addressing the challenge of improving the reversibility of lithium-metal anodes in Li—S batteries and demonstrates a viable approach towards eliminating excess lithium and electrolyte while maintaining cyclability.
Anode-free Full Cells and the Role of a Sulfide-rich SEI. In this example, the anode-free full-cell configuration (Ni∥Li2S) is used to effectively investigate the dynamics of lithium deposition. Assembled in the discharged state, it employs a fully-lithiated Li2S cathode paired with a bare nickel foil current collector (
The rapid capacity fade of the anode-free Nil Li2S full-cell (0% excess lithium) compared to the Li∥Li2S half-cell (3300% excess lithium) at C/5 (1 mA cm−2) clearly demonstrates the irretrievable loss of lithium inventory with cycling and the impact of limited lithium inventory on electrochemical performance (
Introducing Tellurium into the Li—S System. One potential pathway to engineering a stable sulfide-rich SEI layer is to replace the binary sulfide species (Li2S/Li2S2) with ternary sulfide species of the general formula LiaXbSc, where X is a high-oxidation state cation of an element less electronegative than sulfur. By appropriately choosing element X, the properties of the reduced-sulfur SEI components could be modified towards stabilizing lithium deposition. One particularly attractive candidate element for X is tellurium. Tellurium and sulfur share a similar chemistry as Group 16 chalcogens and form ether-soluble catenated compounds, potentially enabling facile incorporation of tellurium into the sulfide-rich lithium SEI. However, tellurium has lower electronegativity than sulfur and forms more polarizable ions due to its larger size and enhanced shielding effect, potentially enabling higher Li+-ion conductivity of the tellurized sulfide-rich interphases on lithium surface.
A possible approach to forming the tellurium-containing reduced-sulfur SEI components is substituting tellurium for some of the sulfur atoms in the polysulfide (Li2Sn) chain and allowing their reduction on the lithium surface. In attempting to synthesize tellurium-substituted polysulfide species, we discovered that elemental tellurium)(Te0 spontaneously reacts with ethereal solutions of polysulfides to form soluble polytellurosulfide (Li2TexSy) species.
These results allow for formulation of a straightforward strategy for incorporating tellurium in situ into the sulfide-rich lithium SEI and evaluate its impact on lithium deposition in Li—S batteries. Elemental Te is added to the Li2S cathode in a 1:10 molar ratio (hereafter designated as Li2S+0.1Te) and investigated in the anode-free Ni∥Li2S full-cell configuration. It is anticipated that polysulfides generated from Li2S cathode would react with Te0 additive, forming polytellurosulfides that migrate to the anode side and form Li2TeS3 on the deposited lithium. The proposed mechanism is illustrated in
Effect of Tellurium on the Performance of Anode-free Full Cells. The effect of tellurium additive on electrochemical performance of anode-free Ni∥Li2S full-cells at C/5 rate (1 mA cm−2) is seen in
From
Bilayer Tellurized and Sulfurized Lithium SEI. The successful stabilization of lithium deposition with the introduction of tellurium as a cathode additive in the Li—S system begs the question of how it impacts the composition of the SEI layer formed on lithium surface. The deposited lithium in the anode-free Ni∥(Li2S+0.1Te) full-cell after 30 cycles was analyzed by XPS (
This is confirmed by depth profiles obtained using ToF-SIMS (
Effect of Tellurium on Electrolyte Decomposition. The impact of the unique bilayer tellurized and sulfurized lithium SEI on the morphology of the deposited lithium can be seen from scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images (
The difference in the exposed surface area of the deposited lithium between the two cases should also engender a difference in the amount of electrolyte that can ingress into the void spaces and decompose on the lithium surface. To confirm this, the deposited lithium in the Ni∥Li2S full-cells after 30 cycles was analyzed with ToF-SIMS (
Effect of Tellurium on Lean-electrolyte Performance. The severe side reactions between lithium and electrolyte is a primary reason for premature failure of lithium-limited and electrolyte-limited Li—S batteries, accounting for rapid depletion of lithium inventory, drying up of electrolyte supply, and formation of highly resistive interphases. The alleviation of electrolyte decomposition on the lithium surface with Te additive promises enhanced electrochemical performance under lean-electrolyte conditions. To confirm this, large-area (39 cm−2) pouch cells were assembled with a lithium anode, a high-loading sulfur cathode (5.2 mg cm−2), and a low E/S ratio of 4.5 μl mg−1 (
Under these cell design and testing conditions, the addition of Te has a dramatic effect on the cyclability of the pouch cell. In contrast to the control cell without any additive, which fails within 25 cycles, the pouch cell with tellurium additive shows stable cycling for nearly 100 cycles (
Discussion Why is lithium deposition successfully stabilized by introducing tellurium into the Li—S system? Answering this question requires comparing the properties of the binary sulfide (Li2S) SEI components formed in the control system with the ternary sulfide (Li2TeS3) and telluride (Li2Te) SEI components formed with the addition of tellurium. In contrast to ionic Li2S, the Te—S bond in Li2TeS3 has significant covalent character due to the small electronegativity difference between sulfur (2.58) and tellurium (2.1). This reduces the electron density on the sulfur atoms, which is expected to reduce the diffusion barrier for lithium ions. Compared to insulating Li2S (bandgap=3.39 eV), Li2TeS3 is a red-colored semiconductor (bandgap=0.97 eV). Despite the narrow bandgap, there is no evidence to suggest deposition of metallic lithium due to electron tunneling through Li2TeS3. One the other hand, the implied partial electron delocalization in Li2TeS3 might contribute to an alleviation of the non-uniform electric fields that cause mossy lithium deposition. Li2Te also possesses similar advantages as Li2TeS3 over Li2S. It has a bandgap of only 2.52 eV. The larger size and higher polarizability of telluride anions compared to sulfide anions is also expected to lower the diffusion barrier for lithium ions. This leads to significantly higher ionic conductivity of Li2TeS3 and Li2Te over Li2S, which (i) makes Li+-ion flux on the surface more uniform, leading to a smooth, planar, and dense lithium deposition, and (ii) mitigates electrochemical inaccessibility of lithium enclosed by SEI layer, reducing “dead” lithium.
These results open the possibility of achieving comparable results with other LiaXbSc ternary sulfides as reduced-sulfur lithium SEI components. Here, X is an element less electronegative than sulfur, and can be chosen from transition metals, metalloids, and non-metals. The properties of LiaXbSc, especially Li+-ion conductivity and covalent character, depend strongly on the electronegativity difference between X and sulfur, thereby conferring similar advantages as Li2TeS3 over Li2S. Another advantage is the potential for in situ formation of LiaXbSc SEI components, obviating the considerable technical challenges with ex situ fabrication of artificial SEIs. Broadly, LiaXbSc ternary sulfides can be explored as a class of artificial SEI layers for improving the reversibility of lithium deposition in lithium-metal batteries.
This example demonstrates the successful stabilization of lithium deposition in Li—S batteries using a simple inclusion of elemental tellurium (Te0) in the sulfur/Li2S cathode. Improved electrochemical performance is demonstrated under realistic lithium-limited (anode-free Ni∥Li2S full-cell) and electrolyte-limited (Li∥S pouch cell) conditions. The stabilizing tellurium-containing SEI components (Li2TeS3/Li2Te) are found to form in situ through the generation of soluble polytellurosulfides, shedding light on the novel chemistry of tellurium in polysulfide-rich electrolytes. The addition of tellurium is facilely extensible to most sulfur/Li2S cathode designs. This represents a significant step towards resolving the fundamental trade-off between energy density and cyclability in Li—S batteries. The stabilization of lithium deposition with tellurium also alleviates the potential safety concerns associated with dendrite growth and consequent risk of internal shorts.
This example also establishes a comprehensive and robust new framework for evaluating lithium deposition in Li—S batteries, and broadly, lithium-metal batteries. By utilizing limited lithium inventory and limited electrolyte supply to constrain electrochemical performance, the impact of different stabilization approaches on reversibility of lithium plating/stripping can be effectively determined. Limited lithium inventory can be achieved using thin lithium foils, or more elegantly, anode-free full cell configuration. Limited electrolyte supply is most reliably achieved in large-area pouch cells. Using this framework will elucidate the complex degradation mechanisms that underlie premature failure of lithium-metal anodes. This will expedite progress on critical cell design, testing, and performance parameters, bringing Li—S batteries closer to commercial reality.
Methods. Li2S Cathode Preparation. Commercial multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT, Sigma Aldrich) and commercial lithium sulfide (Li2S, Sigma Aldrich) was ball-milled together in a 1:4 ratio into a slurry in a PTFE bottle. A 1:1 (volume) mixture of 1,3-Dioxolane (DOL, Sigma Aldrich) and 1,2-Dimethoxyethane (DME, Sigma Aldrich) was used as the slurry medium. The ratio of Li2S/CNT composite to added ethereal solvents was 1:20. The PTFE bottle was filled halfway through with zirconia balls of 2-5 mm diameter for ball-milling, while the rest was used for the Li2S/CNT composite and the ethereal solvents. The tellurium (Te, Sigma Aldrich) cathode additive was added to the slurry mixture in a 1:10 molar ratio with Li2S. The PTFE bottle was then sealed with electric tape and ball-milled for 24 h at 75 rpm on a long roll jar milling system (US Stoneware 802CVM). This created a fine, uniform, well-dispersed slurry. The slurry was then drop-cast between two pieces of 7/16 inch dia. carbon paper (Avcarb P50) for a final loading of 4 mg cm−2 of Li2S. They were then dried in the glove box ambient to yield binder-less, free-standing Li2S cathodes.
Sulfur Cathode Preparation. Ketjenblack (KB, EC-600JD, AkzoNobel) was melt-diffused with sulfur (sublimed, 99.5%, Alfa Aesar) in a 1:9 weight ratio by heating a well-ground mixture to 150° C. for 6 h to obtain the S/KB composite. This composite was dry ball-milled with Te such that the S/Te molar ratio was 10:1 to obtain the S/Te/KB composite. Aqueous slurries were made using a binder consisting of polyethylene oxide (average MW ˜4,000,000, Sigma Aldrich) and polyvinylpyrrolidone (average MW ˜1,300,000) in 4:1 wt. ratio. The Te-based slurry consisted of 85% S/Te/KB composite, 9% binder, and the rest as conductive carbon. The control S slurry consisted of 62.5% S/KB composite, 9% binder, and the rest as conductive carbon. These ratios ensured the same sulfur content for fair a comparison. These slurries were doctor-blade cast on carbon coated Al-foil (MTI corporation) and dried in-vacuo for 24 h to obtain cathodes having a sulfur loading of 5±0.5 mg cm−2.
Electrochemical Measurements. The Li2S cathodes were assembled into Li∥Li2S half-cell and anode-free Ni∥Li2S full-cells in CR2032 coin cell format inside an argon-filled glove box for electrochemical measurements. Two pieces of Celgard 2325 tri-layer separator were used in all cases. The electrolyte used was 1 M lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (LiTFSI, Sigma Aldrich)+0.1 M lithium nitrate (LiNO3, Acros Organics) in a 1:1 (volume) DOL/DME cosolvent. The electrolyte amount was not controlled for the investigations with limited lithium inventory to isolate any effects of electrolyte loss and obtain reliable results. Lithium foil (Sigma Aldrich) or nickel foil (MF-NiFoil-25u, MTI Corporation) was used without modification as the anode substrate in Li∥Li2S half-cell and anode-free Ni∥Li2S full-cells, respectively. All cells were rested for 6 h before measurements. The cells were cycled at C/5 rate between the voltage limits of 2.8 and 1.8 V. The initial charging step was done at C/20 rate, with a 20-hour time limit and a 4 V voltage limit. Ni∥Li half-cells were assembled with Ni foil on the anode side and a lithium-metal disc of 7/16 inch diameter on the cathode side. Coulombic efficiency was determined by plating and stripping 1 mA h of Li with a 2 V voltage limit. Every cycle was followed by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements in the frequency range of 106 Hz to 10−1 Hz. Cyclic voltammetry (CV) data were collected in the potential range of 2.8 to 1.8 (or 1.2) V at different scan rates (0.05-0.2 mV s−1). All electrochemical measurements were conducted with an Arbin battery cycler or a Biologic VMP-3 potentiostat.
Pouch-cell fabrication and testing. Single-stack soft-packaging pouch cells were fabricated with the electrodes having a dimension of 8.1 cm×4.8 cm (˜39 cm2). The cells were assembled in a glove-box with the blade-cast cathode, Celgard 2500 separator and Li-metal attached to Ni-foam as the anode. Electrolyte was injected such that the E/S ratio was maintained at 4.5 μL mg′. The cells were sealed and removed from the glovebox for testing. They were rested for 6 h before galvanostatic cycling. The cells were cycled at C/20 rate between the voltage limits of 2.5 and 1.65 V with a 20-hour time limit for 3 cycles to activate the cathode, before being tested at C/10 rate for the rest of the cycles.
Materials Characterization. The nickel foils with the deposited lithium in the anode-free Ni∥Li2S full cells and half cells were harvested after carefully disassembling the cells, rinsing with excess DOL/DME cosolvent to wash off any soluble products, and drying inside a glove box ambient. A FEI Quanta 650 FE-SEM was used for obtaining the SEM images. A Kratos Axis Ultra DLD Spectrometer was used for X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) characterization. The samples were transferred to the XPS instrument with an air and moisture-sensitive stainless-steel transfer chamber. A monochromatic Al Kα source of energy 1468.5 eV at 12 kV and 10 mA was used for collecting the spectra, with a 20-eV pass energy and 0.1 eV step size. The charge neutralizer was switched off to avoid any effect on peak positions or line shapes. An attached Ar gas cluster ion source operating in monoatomic mode was used for sputtering the surface with Ar+ ions. A TOF. SIMS 5 spectrometer (ION-TOF GmbH) was used for time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectroscopy (ToF-SIMS) characterization. The analysis chamber was maintained with an ultrahigh vacuum at a pressure less than 2×10−9 mbar. The measurements were done in the negative mode with a 500 eV Cs+ ion beam used to sputter the deposited lithium and generate the secondary ions (or molecular fragments). For depth profiling, a pulsed (20 ns) 30 keV Br+ ion beam was used in the high current mode. The sputtering area was 300×300 μm2, while the analysis was conducted over 100×100 μm2.
Calculation of Lithium Inventory Loss Rate. In an idealized full cell with a limited lithium inventory (say N/P ratio≈1), Coulombic efficiency (CE) may be used as a perfect predictor of capacity fade. Assuming that there is no capacity loss at the cathode, the fraction of initial capacity retained after n cycles is
Here GCE is a geometric mean of CE values up to n cycles, and CE is taken to be a fraction of 1. If Coulombic efficiency is assumed to be a constant throughout the n cycles, the formula reduces to
This allows calculation of the number of cycles n before the capacity falls below 50% of initial capacity at different values of Coulombic efficiency CE using the formula
However, these formulas assume that there is no “cross-talk” between the two electrodes and the electrodes are stable during rest. This assumption is not true for systems containing soluble redox mediators that shuttle between the two electrodes, leaking active material and free electrons. Li—S batteries, with soluble polysulfide intermediates, are the perfect example of such systems. In all investigations of anode-free Li—S full cells, there are wide discrepancies in the predicted cycle life based on CE values and the actual cycle life observed. For instance, the average CE for the anode-free Ni∥Li2S full cell in
However, the actual capacity fade observed in the anode-free Ni∥Li2S full cell can be used to derive a parameter analogous to Coulombic inefficiency (100-CE). This is the Lithium Inventory Loss Rate (LILR). It can be defined using the formula
In this example, the cycle number at which 50% of the initial capacity is reached is used as n. In addition, the initial capacity is taken at four cycles. This is due to the observation that the initial losses in capacity (first three cycles) appear to be engendered at the Li2S cathode. The calculation for LILR can then be simplified to
These calculations use two simplifying assumptions. First, it is assumed that the lithium inventory loss in each cycle is a fixed percentage (LILR) of the electrochemically active lithium in that cycle, and this percentage is constant across all cycles. This assumption generally holds true in the “stable cycling” region of the anode-free full cell, prior to failure. Second, the entirety of capacity loss is assumed to come from lithium inventory loss. The cathode is assumed to cause no losses in capacity. This is not necessarily the case, since Li∥Li2S half cells, whose performance is reflective of the Li2S cathode, show a measurable loss in capacity with cycling. If cathode losses are accounted for, the actual LILR value will be smaller than the calculated one. Nevertheless, the approximate LILR value is a useful parameter for comparing performance of different anode-free full cells.
Figure Captions.
The strategies described in this Example provide additional embodiments of artificial SEI layers with the general formula AxMyQz for stabilizing lithium deposition.
Taking inspiration from the in situ formation of Li2TeS3, ammonium tetrathiomolybdate ((NH4)2MoS4 or ATTM) and ammonium tetrathiotungstate ((NH4)2WS4 or ATTW) were used as cathode additives in the Li—S system to engender the formation of a stabilizing SEI layer on the lithium surface with the general formula LixMoySz and LixWySz, respectively. These additives function in a similar manner to tellurium, by reacting with polysulfides (Li2Sn) to generate soluble thiomolybdate and thiotungstate species, which further reduce on the lithium surface to form LixMoySz and LixWySz. The formation of these Mo and W enriched sulfides as artificial SEI layers can stabilize lithium deposition and enhance lithium cycling efficiency.
Several anode-free Ni∥Li2S full cells that contain no excess lithium inventory were prepared, including cells with ATTM as a cathode additive, ATTW as a cathode additive, and no cathode additive. These cells were cycled to observe their capacity as a function of cycle number, which is shown in
Another strategy inspired by the in situ formation of Li2TeS3 is the in situ formation of lithium trithiocarbonate (Li2CS3) on the lithium surface. This can be achieved by the simple substitution of Li2S with Li2CS3 in the cathode of anode-free full cells. The use of Li2CS3 as the cathode active material can generate soluble species during cell operation that reduce on the lithium surface to form Li2CS3 as an artificial SEI layer. This can helps realize dense, homogenous, and reversible lithium deposition and can significantly extend cycle life in anode-free full cells. Li2CS3 can be facilely generated by a simple reaction of Li2S with carbon disulfide (CS2).
As used below, any reference to multiple aspects (e.g., “Aspects 1-4”) or non-enumerated group of aspects (e.g., “any previous or subsequent aspect”) is to be understood as a reference to each of those aspects disjunctively (e.g., “Aspects 1-4” is to be understood as “Aspects 1, 2, 3, or 4”).
Aspect 1 is an electrode comprising: an alkali metal or a substrate for alkali metal deposition; and an interface material on a surface of the alkali metal or the substrate, the interface material comprising: a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups.
Aspect 2 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material comprises, corresponds to, or acts as an artificial solid-electrolyte interphase.
Aspect 3 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material has a chemical formula of AxMyQz, wherein A is the metal or combination of metals, wherein Q is the chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens, wherein M is the one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups, wherein x is from 0 to 1, wherein y is from 0 to 1, and wherein z is from 0 to 1.
Aspect 4 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the alkali metal is lithium, sodium, potassium, or cesium.
Aspect 5 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the chalcogen or combination of chalcogens is one or a combination of sulfur, selenium, or tellurium.
Aspect 6 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the metal is an alkali metal.
Aspect 7 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the metal is lithium, sodium, potassium, or cesium.
Aspect 8A is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the one or more elements, the one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups is or comprises an element less electronegative than the chalcogen or the combination of chalcogens.
Aspect 8B is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the one or more elements, the one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups is or comprises an element having a similar electronegativity to the chalcogen or the combination of chalcogens.
Aspect 9 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the one or more elements is one or a combination of tellurium, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, bismuth, carbon, germanium, tin, lead, gallium, indium, molybdenum, tungsten, titanium, vanadium, copper, silver, gold, zinc, or cadmium.
Aspect 10 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, comprising a component of a secondary electrochemical cell or a rechargeable battery.
Aspect 11 is the electrode of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material comprises Li2TeS3, Li3SbS4, Li2CS3. LixMoySz, or LixWySz, wherein x, y, and z are independently between 0 and 1.
Aspect 12 is an electrochemical cell comprising: a positive electrode that can reversibly store and release alkali-metal ions; an electrolyte; and a negative electrode comprising: an alkali metal or a substrate for alkali metal deposition; and an interface material on a surface of the alkali metal or the substrate, the interface material comprising: a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups.
Aspect 13 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the positive electrode is a conversion-based or insertion-based cathode.
Aspect 14 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the positive electrode comprises an oxygen-based electroactive material, a sulfur-based electroactive material, a selenium-based electroactive material, a layered-oxide cathode material, LCO, NMC, NCA, a spinel-based cathode material, LMO, LNMO, a polyanion-based cathode material, or LFP.
Aspect 15 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the alkali metal is lithium, sodium, potassium, or cesium.
Aspect 16 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the chalcogen or combination of chalcogens is one or a combination of sulfur, selenium, or tellurium.
Aspect 17 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the metal is an alkali metal.
Aspect 18 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the one or more elements, the one or more organic functional groups, or the combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups is or comprises an element less electronegative than the chalcogen or the combination of chalcogens.
Aspect 19 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the one or more elements is one or a combination of tellurium, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, bismuth, germanium, tin, lead, gallium, indium, molybdenum, tungsten, titanium, vanadium, copper, silver, gold, zinc, or cadmium.
Aspect 20 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrolyte is a solid or liquid or mixed-phase material that conducts alkali-metal ions and blocks passage of electrons.
Aspect 21 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is fabricated prior to assembly of the electrochemical cell.
Aspect 22 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is fabricated ex situ prior to assembly of the electrochemical cell using a vapor deposition technique or a solution coating technique.
Aspect 23 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ after assembly of the electrochemical cell.
Aspect 24 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ during operation when an electric field is applied between the positive electrode and the negative electrode.
Aspect 25 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ during one or more charging or discharging operations.
Aspect 26 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, comprising a secondary electrochemical cell or a rechargeable battery or a component thereof.
Aspect 27 is the electrochemical cell of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the negative electrode comprises the electrode of any of any previous or subsequent aspect.
Aspect 28 is a method of producing an interface material on a negative electrode of an electrochemical cell, the method comprising: introducing an additive into a component of the electrochemical cell during assembly; and forming the interface material in situ after assembly of the electrochemical cell, wherein the interface material comprises: a metal or combination of metals; a chalcogen or any combination of chalcogens; and one or more elements, one or more organic functional groups, or a combination of one or more elements and one or more organic functional groups.
Aspect 29 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrochemical cell is based on alkali metal plating and stripping.
Aspect 30 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the additive is introduced into an electrolyte of the electrochemical cell, such as where the additive is optionally a polytellurosulfide, a thiomolybdate species, or a thiotungstate species.
Aspect 31 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ by partial or complete reduction of one or more components of the electrolyte, including the additive, on a surface of the negative electrode.
Aspect 32 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the additive is introduced into a positive electrode of the electrochemical cell, such as where the additive is optionally tellurium, an alkali metal trithiocarbonate (e.g., Li2CS3), a thiomolybdate (e.g., ammonium tetrathiomolybdate), or a thiotungstate (e.g., ammonium tetrathiotungstate).
Aspect 33 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ by: reaction of the additive with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component, and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode.
Aspect 34 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the additive is introduced onto a polymer separator of the electrochemical cell as a coating.
Aspect 35 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ by: reaction of the coating with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component; and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode.
Aspect 36 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the additive is introduced into a negative electrode or negative electrode current collector of the electrochemical cell.
Aspect 37 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ by: reaction of the additive with one or more electrolyte components to form a secondary electrolyte component, and partial or complete reduction of the secondary electrolyte component on a surface of the negative electrode.
Aspect 38 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the interface material is formed in situ by: partial or complete reduction or reaction of the additive on a surface of the negative electrode.
Aspect 39 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrochemical cell comprises: a positive electrode comprising a sulfur-based active material and the additive, wherein the additive is tellurium; an organic liquid electrolyte; and the negative electrode, wherein the negative electrode corresponds to a lithium plating and stripping electrode, and wherein the interface material comprises Li2TeS3.
Aspect 40 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, further comprising: disassembling the electrochemical cell to separate a negative electrode with the interface material thereon; and incorporating the negative electrode with the interface material thereon in another electrochemical cell.
Aspect 41 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrochemical cell comprises or corresponds to a secondary electrochemical cell or a rechargeable battery or a component thereof.
Aspect 42 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrochemical cell comprises: a positive electrode; an electrolyte; and a negative electrode comprising the electrode of any of any previous or subsequent aspect.
Aspect 43 is the method of any previous or subsequent aspect, wherein the electrochemical cell comprises the electrochemical cell of any of any previous or subsequent aspect.
Zhang, S. S., Fan, X. & Wang, C. A tin-plated copper substrate for efficient cycling of lithium metal in an anode-free rechargeable lithium battery. Electrochim. Acta 258, 1201-1207 (2017).
All references throughout this application, for example patent documents including issued or granted patents or equivalents; patent application publications; and non-patent literature documents or other source material; are hereby incorporated by reference herein in their entireties, as though individually incorporated by reference.
All patents and publications mentioned in the specification are indicative of the levels of skill of those skilled in the art to which the invention pertains. References cited herein are incorporated by reference herein in their entirety to indicate the state of the art, in some cases as of their filing date, and it is intended that this information can be employed herein, if needed, to exclude (for example, to disclaim) specific embodiments that are in the prior art.
When a group of substituents is disclosed herein, it is understood that all individual members of those groups and all subgroups and classes that can be formed using the substituents are disclosed separately. When a Markush group or other grouping is used herein, all individual members of the group and all combinations and subcombinations possible of the group are intended to be individually included in the disclosure. As used herein, “and/or” means that one, all, or any combination of items in a list separated by “and/or” are included in the list; for example “1, 2 and/or 3” is equivalent to “‘1’ or ‘2’ or ‘3’ or ‘1 and 2’ or ‘1 and 3’ or ‘2 and 3’ or ‘1, 2 and 3’”.
Every formulation or combination of components described or exemplified can be used to practice the invention, unless otherwise stated. Specific names of materials are intended to be exemplary, as it is known that one of ordinary skill in the art can name the same material differently. It will be appreciate that methods, device elements, starting materials, and synthetic methods other than those specifically exemplified can be employed in the practice of the invention without resort to undue experimentation. All art-known functional equivalents, of any such methods, device elements, starting materials, and synthetic methods are intended to be included in this invention. Whenever a range is given in the specification, for example, a temperature range, a time range, or a composition range, all intermediate ranges and subranges, as well as all individual values included in the ranges given are intended to be included in the disclosure.
As used herein, “comprising” is synonymous with “including,” “containing,” or “characterized by,” and is inclusive or open-ended and does not exclude additional, unrecited elements or method steps. As used herein, “consisting of” excludes any element, step, or ingredient not specified in the claim element. As used herein, “consisting essentially of” does not exclude materials or steps that do not materially affect the basic and novel characteristics of the claim. Any recitation herein of the term “comprising”, particularly in a description of components of a composition or in a description of elements of a device, is understood to encompass those compositions and methods consisting essentially of and consisting of the recited components or elements. The invention illustratively described herein suitably may be practiced in the absence of any element or elements, limitation or limitations which is not specifically disclosed herein.
The terms and expressions which have been employed are used as terms of description and not of limitation, and there is no intention in the use of such terms and expressions of excluding any equivalents of the features shown and described or portions thereof, but it is recognized that various modifications are possible within the scope of the invention claimed. Thus, it should be understood that although the present invention has been specifically disclosed by preferred embodiments and optional features, modification and variation of the concepts herein disclosed may be resorted to by those skilled in the art, and that such modifications and variations are considered to be within the scope of this invention as defined by the appended claims.
This application claims the benefit of and priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/992,069, filed on Mar. 19, 2020, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under Grant No. DE-SC0005397 awarded by the Department of Energy. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2021/022971 | 3/18/2021 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62992069 | Mar 2020 | US |