The present invention relates to an accommodative intraocular lens (IOL) and its method of implantation into the eye. Specifically, it relates to an IOL which is suitable for implanting into the capsule of an eye through a small incision to replace the natural crystalline lens after its removal and to restore accommodation in the eye. It also relates to a method for implantation of an IOL such that the IOL or at least its optic body is restricted inside the capsule. As a result, the restriction of the IOL causes a change in the shape of the IOL or at least its optic body, which in turn causes a change in the diopter power of the IOL. This change in IOL shape and its diopter power by various degrees of restrictive conditions provide the eye of a patient with improved far vision and/or near vision. Thus, it restores the accommodation of an aged human eye.
A healthy young human eye can focus an object in far or near distance, as required. In order for the lens to focus on an object at a distance, zonules exert their force to stretch the natural crystalline lens so it becomes gradually thinner until the lens focuses on the target object. This state of the eye, with its focus on a distant object is frequently called the unaccommodative state. On the other hand, when near distance vision such as reading a newspaper is required, zonules relax to release their pulling force such that the natural crystalline lens becomes increasingly thick until it focuses on the target object in the near distance. This state of the eye is called the accommodative state. The capability of the eye changing back and forth from near vision to far vision is called accommodation. As we age, a young healthy eye gradually loses its capacity for accommodation. Around the age of 40, the gradual aging of the human natural crystalline lens increases its rigidity to a level where people start to feel the gradual loss of accommodation. By 50, near vision becomes so difficult that reading glasses usually are required. This naturally occurring process of aging, whereby the natural crystalline lens loses its elasticity, thus resulting in the gradual loss of near vision, is called presbyopia.
Since presbyopia happens to most people around the age of 50, there have been tremendous efforts in scientific and industrial fields to find a solution for restoring accommodation. A simple and direct approach is to replace the aged rigid lens with a soft, malleable lens. In order to do this, ophthalmologists have to preserve the integrity of the capsular bag as much as possible. As shown in
Alternatively, Wang et al. in U.S. Pat. No. 5,316,704 discloses a process for deforming a full size hydrogel IOL into a rod shape which allows for insertion using a small incision. After it is positioned inside the capsule, the rod absorbs water to hydrate into an enlarged elastic form reassuming the original lens configuration of a full capsule size. However, Wang et al. is silent on whether and how his full size expansile IOL can be utilized as an accommodative lens. Separately, Zhou in U.S. Pat. No. 5,702,441 discloses a method for rapid implantation of shape transformable IOLs, including full size IOLs, through a small incision. Nevertheless, Zhou is completely silent on whether or not his method can be used for an accommodative IOL. Lastly, Zhou et al. in PCT publication WO 01/89816 A1 discloses an ophthalmic device, including full size IOLs, made from crystallizable elastomers and a method of implantation for such ophthalmic devices, including accommodative IOLs.
In addition to full size IOL designs, such as those described above, other designs for accommodative IOLs have also been taught in the literature. Numerous U.S. patents, such as U.S. Pat. Nos. 6,391,056; 6,387,126; and 6,217,612 disclose accommodative IOLs with a common design feature, i.e., the effective lens power of a given diopter is dependent on the location of the lens optic body along the optical axis. In other words, if the lens optic body shifts posteriorly along its optic axis, i.e., shifting away from the cornea, the eye can see distance vision, equivalent to the unaccommodative state. If the lens optic body shifts anteriorly, the eye can focus on a near object, equivalent to the accommodative state of the eye. In these cases, the lens diopter power does not change; it is the shifting of its location along the optic axis inside the eye which provides the eye with a new method for achieving near or distance vision. Ultrasound imaging technique has shown that the lens optics can shift along the optic axis within a range of about 1 mm. This approximately relates to an optic power shift of about 1 diopter. Usually, an effective accommodative lens requires a focus power change of 3 diopters, in order to permit a patient to perform near vision tasks, such as reading a newspaper, without difficulties.
Accommodative lens designs with a multiple optic lens assembly have been disclosed in several U.S. Pat. Nos 6,423,094; 5,275,623; and 6,231,603. In these designs, the optic diopter power of the assembly is dependent on the distance between these optic lenses. The optic diopter of an individual lens does not change during the accommodation-unaccommodation process.
There is a need for an IOL which can replace the aged presbyopic crystalline lens with or without cataract and can restore the accommodation of the lens. The accommodative lens of the present invention was designed with its predetermined initial optic diopter targeted at an individual patient's refractive error. Once it is implanted inside the capsule, the accommodative IOL of the present invention is sufficiently soft so that it interacts with and responds to the eye muscle movement in such a way that its optic diopter increases (for near vision) or decreases (for far vision), as needed.
The primary object of the present invention is to provide an accommodative IOL for an aged eye with or without cataract. The accommodative IOL is made with predetermined initial optic diopter power and optic resolution. The initial optic diopter of the IOL is targeted for correcting the individual patient's refractive error. The most important feature of the present accommodative IOL design is that it engages with the capsular bag once it is positioned inside the capsule after the aged natural lens is removed. Because the IOL or at least its optic portion is made from a soft material and it has at least one dimension equal to or preferably larger than the corresponding dimension of the capsule, it will change its shape, such as lens curvature or central thickness, according to its engagement force with the capsule. This interaction between the IOL and the capsule allows the IOL to increase or decrease its surface curvature, and thus its diopter power for achieving near vision or far vision, as needed.
Another object of the present invention is to construct the accommodative lens from a biocompatible shape memory material of appropriate softness. The shape memory material will allow the IOL to be implanted through a small incision while the appropriate softness will allow the IOL to change its shape in response to the eye muscle force. Too hard a material will not allow the IOL to change its shape in response to the eye muscle force. Generally speaking, materials suitable for the present application should have softness at least 5 times softer than a typical soft foldable IOL now in the marketplace. This means the proper softness for the accommodative IOL of the present invention has a durometer of no greater than about 5 Shore A, and preferably about 1 Shore A or less.
A further object of the present invention is to provide a method for implanting the accommodative IOL wherein the method comprises (a) providing an accommodative IOL in its first configuration with a predetermined first optic diopter power targeted for the patient's specific refractive errors, and having at least one dimension larger than the corresponding dimension of the patient's capsule; (b) removing the aged natural human crystalline lens from the patient; (c) implanting the IOL inside the capsule wherein the IOL changes from its first configuration to a second configuration due to the restriction of the IOL inside the capsule, resulting in a change in the IOL's optic power from its first dioptic power to a second dioptic power. When the zonules place varying amounts of stress on the capsule during the normal vision process, the lens moves between its first and second diopter strengths. Accordingly, the interchange between the first diopter and the second diopter provides a mechanism for adjusting far vision and near vision. Thus, it restores accommodation for an aged eye.
These objects and others can be achieved as demonstrated by the lenses taught in the following description and preferred exemplary embodiments.
Throughout the disclosure, a “small incision” usually means an incision size in the range of about 3-4 mm for cataract surgery. The first generation of IOLs were made from rigid material, such as poly(methyl methacrylate) with an optic body of approximately 6 mm in diameter. These rigid lenses usually require at least a 6 mm incision in the cornea for implantation into the eye. Since foldable elastic materials were used for the preparation of IOLs, the 6 mm optic body can be folded in half and can be inserted through an incision of about 3-4 mm.
The terms “full size lens” and “full size IOL” are used herein interchangeably. They mean an artificial lens which mimics the natural crystalline lens shape with a lens diameter in the range of about 8-13 mm, preferably in the range of about 9.5-11 mm. The central lens thickness of a full size biconvex (symmetrical or asymmetrical) lens is normally in the range of about 2-5 mm and can be adjusted according to the individual patient's refractive error. A symmetrical biconvex lens means the anterior and posterior surfaces have an identical radius while an asymmetrical biconvex means the anterior surface has a different radius than the posterior surface, such as in the case of a human crystalline lens. Because such a full size lens has a large optical diameter, it usually does not have edge glare, halo or any other optic defects typically associated with a small optic body lens. In addition, a fill size lens can avoid lens decentration, a problem associated with a regular IOL having a 6 mm optic body.
Capsulorhexis is the opening surgically made by puncturing, then grasping and tearing a hole in the anterior capsule. In a regular extracapsular cataract extraction (ECCE) procedure, a capsulorhexis is made in the anterior capsule and the cloudy cataract lens is extracted by phacoemulsification. Obviously, the accommodative IOL of the present invention can be used for patients after cataract surgery. It can also be used for patients with only presbyopia, but without cataract.
The term diopter (D) is defined as the reciprocal of the focal length of a lens in meters. For example, a 10 D lens brings parallel rays of light to a focus at {fraction (1/10)} meter. After a patient's natural crystalline lens has been surgically removed, surgeons usually follow a formula, based on their own personal preference, to calculate a desirable diopter power (D) for the selection of an IOL for the patient to correct the patient's preoperational refractive error. For example, a myopia patient with −10 D undergoes cataract surgery and IOL implantation; the patient can see at a distance well enough even without glasses. This is because the surgeon has taken the patient's −10 D near-sightedness into account when choosing an IOL for the patient.
The term “dimension of a patient's crystalline lens” is used herein interchangeably with the term “dimension of a patient's capsule.” The dimension of a patient's crystalline lens in the accommodative state or unaccommodative state can be measured using well-known modern techniques.
Shape memory materials are stimuli-responsive materials. They have the capability of changing their shape into a temporary shape under an external stimulus. The stimulus can be, for example, a temperature change or the exerting of an external compression (or stretching) force. Once the external stimulus is eliminated, the shape memory material will change back into its initial shape. A recent review paper of “Shape-Memory Polymers” was published in Angewandete Chemie, International Edition 41(12) 1973-2208 (2002), and is herein incorporated by reference.
The accommodative IOL of the present invention, in one of the preferred embodiments, is made from a shape-memory material and has a sufficient optic resolution and a predetermined optic diopter power tailored for a specific patient's refractive error. The accommodative IOL has its initial first configuration with its first diopter (D1). The most important feature of the present accommodative IOL design is that the IOL in its first configuration engages with the capsule once it is implanted inside the capsule after the aged natural lens is removed. Because the IOL or at least its optic portion is made from a shape-memory material with an appropriate softness, the interaction of the IOL with the capsule will force it to change into a second configuration having a second diopter (D2). The degree in the lens shape change as well as the diopter change is dependent on its softness and its engagement force with the capsule.
In order to demonstrate the teaching of the present invention, an example is given as follows. A full size accommodative IOL, such as the one in
While the above example is only intended for illustrating the teachings of the present invention, it is possible that modified or alternative IOL designs can also be used for achieving the accommodation. For example, the alternative two-part lens design shown in
In accordance with another preferred embodiment of the present invention, there is a full size accommodative IOL which can be made from two different materials having different properties, such as softness or refractive index. For example,
In accordance with another preferred embodiment of the present invention, there is a method for implanting the accommodative IOL into the capsule after the aged crystalline lens is removed. The method comprises (a) providing an accommodative IOL, made from a flexible optical material, in its first configuration having a corresponding first optic diopter (D1) and resolution predetermined for a patient's specific refractive error, and at least one dimension equal to or (preferably) larger than the corresponding dimension of the patient's capsule; (b) removing an aged human crystalline lens surgically; (c) implanting the accommodative IOL into the patient's capsule wherein the IOL changes from its first configuration to a second configuration due to the restriction of the IOL inside the capsule. This results in a change in the IOL's optic power from its first diopter (D1) to a second diopter (D2). The difference between D1 and D2 is generally in the range of about 1-5 diopters, preferably in the range about 2-4 diopters, most preferably about 3 diopters.
In order to help in understanding the teachings of the present invention, the following example is given to illustrate the method of implantation for a full size accommodative IOL. It is not intended to limit the scope of the present invention. In step one, a patient's refractive error is measured and the accommodative IOL is decided to have a predetermined diopter power (20 D, for example) for the correction for the patient's refractive error in distance vision. The patient's crystalline lens dimensions are also measured. For example, the diameter of the natural crystalline lens is 9.5 mm in its accommodative state and 10 mm in its unaccommodative state. Accordingly, a full size IOL with a diameter of about 10 mm and with a diopter of 20 D is selected to address the patient's far vision need. In step two, the natural crystalline lens is surgically removed, preferably through a small incision and a small capsulorhexis. In step three, the IOL is implanted into the eye, preferably through a small incision. In this case, the accommodative IOL with a diameter of about 10 mm is forced into a capsule with a 9.5 mm diameter in its accommodative state. Because the IOL is made from a soft material, the compression force by the capsule will cause the IOL to change from its first initial configuration of 10 mm diameter into a second configuration with a reduced diameter but increased lens thickness. This second configuration IOL has a second diopter (D2=23 D, for example) higher than D (D1=20 D) in the first configuration. Once the patient's eye focuses on a target in distance (unaccommodative status), zonules stretch the capsule to a larger diameter than that in the accommodative state. Consequently, the IOL will become thinner due to its elasticity and shape-memory properties, and possibly also in part due to the stretching of the IOL by the capsule, providing a lower diopter power (20 D again, for example) for distance vision. It may also be possible that further stretching of the IOL by the capsule leads the lens diopter power to a level smaller than 20 D. Therefore, the IOL of the present invention provides interchangeable diopters, successfully restoring the accommodation for an aged human eye.
For the same hypothetical patient given in the example described in the previous paragraph, it is also feasible to select an accommodative IOL with a diameter of 9.5 mm and with a diopter of 23 D. When such an IOL is selected, the accommodative IOL is referred to as being in the accommodative configuration while the selection of the IOL described in the previous paragraph is referred as being in the unaccommodative configuration. When the IOL selected is in the accommodative configuration, it is dependent on the zonules' stretch to cause the IOL to change from its first configuration with first diopter (D1=23 D) to the second configuration with the second diopter (D2=20 D, for example, in this particular case).
The method for the implantation of the present accommodative IOL will ensure the IOL to be engaged with the capsule at all times. When the eye is in the accommodative state, the reduced capsule diameter will force the IOL into its second configuration with a second diopter suitable for the near vision. Once the eye becomes unaccommodative, zonules stretch the capsule to an increased diameter, the accommodative IOL inside the capsule will also increase its diameter mainly due to its elastic property. Accordingly, the IOL becomes thinner and its diopter becomes smaller, suitable for far vision. This accommodation to unaccommodation can be switched back and forth repeatedly, just as in a young accommodative natural eye. It is well known that presbyopia patients still have active zonular stretching movement. It is the natural crystalline lens, which becomes too rigid to change its shape when zonules stretch or relax, which causes the presbyopic condition. The present invention overcomes that problem.
The measurement of the natural crystalline lens dimensions in its accommodative or unaccommodative states can be made with estimation by several literature methods such as the Scheimpflug slit image technique (Dubbelman, Vision Research, 2001; 41:1867-1877), and IR video photography (Wilson, Trans. Am. Ophth. Soc. 1997; 95:261-266), both of which are incorporated herein by reference.
One requisite for the accommodative IOL in the present invention is the selection of a shape memory material with appropriate softness. All the IOLs currently on the marketplace have a durometer hardness of at least 25 Shore A. For example, the best selling lens is Alcon's ACRYSOF® family IOLs with the durometer of 45 Shore A (Source: Product Monograph by Alcon Surgical). Similarly, soft silicone IOLs have a durometer of 38-40 Shore A (Christ et al, U.S. Pat. No. 5,236,970) and a relatively low durometer hardness for silicone IOL material was disclosed to be 28-30 Shore A in U.S. Pat. No. 5,444,106 by Zhou et al. Materials suitable for the present invention should have a hardness in durometer Shore A at least about 5 times softer than those used in the regular IOL applications. This means the durometer hardness desirable for the accommodative IOL will be no greater than about 5 Shore A, preferably about 1 Shore A or less. Suitable materials for the preparation of the accommodative IOLs of the present invention include, but are not limited to, acrylic polymers, silicone elastomers, hydrogels, composite materials, and combinations thereof.
The following examples are intended to be illustrative of, but not limiting of, the present invention.
A synthetic human capsule (
Into a fused silica mold is added a pre-gel prepared from the mixture of stearyl methacrylate (54% by weight), lauryl acrylate (45% by weight), and 1% of UV absorber, 2-(2′-hydroxy-5′acryloxypropylenephenyl)-2H-benzotriazole, as well as 0.075% of crosslinker, ethylene glycol dimethacrylate. The mold is placed in a pre-heated oven at 110° C. for 16 hours. After the mold is taken out from the oven and cools down to room temperature, the mold is placed in a refrigerator for about 2 hours. The mold is then opened, and a white or translucent solid IOL is carefully removed from the mold. In this way, two different dimensions of accommodative IOLs are prepared. The first group has a diameter of 9.0 mm, central lens thickness of 3.0 mm, and edge thickness of 1.0 mm with an optical diopter power of 27 D, while the second group has a diameter of 9.9 mm, central lens thickness of 2.3 and edge thickness of 1.0 mm with an optical diopter power of 15 D. The durometer hardness of the lenses from both groups is 4 Shore A.
The first group lens has its initial diopter power of 27 D (resolution efficiency of 45.1%) measured with a Meclab Optical Bench using 550 nm wavelength light, 150 mm collimator, 3 mm aperture and 1951 US Air Force Target. The IOL has a central lens thickness of 3.0 mm, lens diameter of 9.0 mm, and edge thickness of 1.0 mm, as measured with a Nikon V12 optical comparator. The same measurement method is used for Example 4. After this lens is implanted into the simulated human capsule described in Example 1, the resolution and diopter power are measured again. It is found that the lens in the capsule has changed its diopter power. The new diopter power in the capsule is 30 D, a shift of 3 D from its initial diopter. The resolution efficiency of the lens inside the capsule is 40.3%. The diopter increase in this case is due to the fact that the lens edge thickness (1.0 mm) is larger than its corresponding dimension of the capsule (about 0.2 mm). This oversized edge thickness forces the soft IOL to move some of its volume toward the central lens area where it has the least resistance due to the presence of the capsulorhexis. Consequently, the central lens thickness has been increased and so has the lens diopter power.
The second group lens has diopter power of 15 D (resolution efficiency of 51%) with a central lens thickness of 2.3 mm, lens diameter of 9.9 mm, and edge thickness of 1.0 mm. After this lens is implanted into the simulated human capsule described in Example 1, the resolution and diopter power are measured again. It is found that the diopter power of the IOL inside the capsule is 20 D with a resolution efficiency of 40%. The big diopter shift (5 D) in this case is due to the fact that both the lens diameter (9.9 mm) and the lens edge thickness (1.0 mm) are oversized in comparison with the corresponding dimensions of the capsule (9.3 mm and about 0.2 mm respectively). The restriction force by the capsule causes the IOL to change from its first configuration into its second configuration which has a central lens thickness of about 3.0 mm and equatorial diameter of 9.5 mm.
This application is based up and claims priority from U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/523,504, filed Nov. 18, 2003, incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60523504 | Nov 2003 | US |