This disclosure relates to acoustic radiating devices that include both active drivers and passive radiators, in which positions and characteristics of the active drivers and passive radiators are selected to reduce unwanted vibrations coupled into acoustic structures and to reduce device size.
In one aspect, an acoustic device includes a first passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a first wall of the acoustic enclosure and is configured to move parallel to a first axis that extends through a center of mass of the first passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the first wall in response to a pressure change in the acoustic chamber. The acoustic device also includes a second passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a second wall of the acoustic enclosure and is configured to move parallel to a second axis that extends through a center of mass of the second passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the second wall in responsive to a pressure change within the acoustic chamber. The acoustic device further includes a first active driver assembly disposed in an opening in the first passive radiator diaphragm and a plurality of second active drivers assemblies each disposed in an opening in the second passive radiator diaphragm. Each of the second active driver assemblies is laterally offset from the second axis. A moving mass of the first passive radiator assembly is substantially equal to a moving mass of the second passive radiator assembly.
Embodiments may include one of the following features, or any combination thereof. The lateral offsets of the second active driver assemblies can be selected to avoid an interference with the first active driver assembly. The first and second axes may be parallel or colinear. The acoustic device may further include a compliant coupling mechanism that couples the first active driver assembly to the second passive radiator diaphragm or to at least one of the walls of the acoustic enclosure. The first and second walls may be parallel to each other. The mass of the first active driver assembly may be substantially equal to a sum of the masses of the second active driver assemblies and the mass of the first active radiator diaphragm may be the same as the mass of the second active radiator diaphragm.
In another aspect, an acoustic device includes an acoustic enclosure having walls defining an acoustic chamber, a first passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a first wall of the acoustic enclosure and configured to move parallel to a first axis that extends through a geometrical center of the first passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the first wall in response to a pressure change in the acoustic chamber, and a second passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a second wall of the acoustic enclosure and configured to move parallel to a second axis that extends through a geometrical center of the second passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the second wall in responsive to a pressure change within the acoustic chamber. The first and second walls of the acoustic enclosure are parallel to each other. The acoustic device further includes a first active driver assembly disposed in an opening in the first passive radiator diaphragm and having a geometrical center on the first axis, and a plurality of second active drivers assemblies each disposed in an opening in the second passive radiator diaphragm. Each of the second active driver assemblies has a geometrical center that is laterally offset from the second axis. A sum of the moving mass of the first passive radiator diaphragm and the mass of the first active driver assembly is substantially equal to a sum of the moving mass of the second passive radiator diaphragm with the masses of the second active driver assemblies.
Embodiments may include one of the above and/or below features, or any combination thereof. The lateral offset of each of the second active driver assemblies may be equal to the lateral offset of each of the other second active driver assemblies. The acoustic device may further include a compliant coupling mechanism that couples the first active driver assembly to the second passive radiator diaphragm or to at least one of the walls of the acoustic enclosure.
In another aspect, an acoustic device includes an acoustic enclosure having walls defining an acoustic chamber, a first passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a first wall of the acoustic enclosure and configured to move parallel to a first axis that extends through a center of mass of the first passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the first wall in response to a pressure change in the acoustic chamber, and a second passive radiator diaphragm disposed in an opening of a second wall of the acoustic enclosure and configured to move parallel to a second axis that extends through a center of mass of the second passive radiator diaphragm and orthogonal to the second wall in responsive to a pressure change within the acoustic chamber. The acoustic device further includes a first active driver assembly secured to a surface of the first passive radiator diaphragm and configured to radiate acoustic energy in a direction parallel to the first axis and through an opening in the second passive radiator diaphragm, and a plurality of second active drivers assemblies each disposed in an opening in the second passive radiator diaphragm. Each of the second active driver assemblies is laterally offset from the second axis and configured to radiate acoustic energy in a direction substantially parallel to the first axis. The moving mass of the first passive radiator assembly is substantially equal to the moving mass of the second passive radiator assembly.
Embodiments may include one of the above and/or below features, or any combination thereof. The acoustic device may further include a compliant coupling mechanism that couples the first active driver assembly to the second passive radiator diaphragm at the opening in the second passive radiator diaphragm through which the acoustic energy from the first active driver assembly radiates.
The above and further features and advantages may be better understood by referring to the following description in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which like numerals indicate like structural elements and features. The drawings are not necessarily to scale and are instead primarily intended to illustrate principles of features and implementations.
An acoustic device, such as a loudspeaker system, may include one or more passive-radiator transducers. Unlike an active loudspeaker transducer, which may include a sound-producing diaphragm that moves in response to receipt of an electrical signal by the active transducer, a passive radiator is a non-electrical device that includes a sound-producing diaphragm mounted to an enclosure such that the diaphragm moves in response to variations in the air pressure of an acoustic volume defined by the enclosure. In one class of implementations, an enclosure having a passive radiator also includes an active driver that indirectly moves the passive radiator by producing air-pressure variations in the acoustic volume. In this way, a single electrical signal may drive an active driver and indirectly drive a passive radiator.
It is known that two or more passive radiator assemblies may be mounted to walls of an enclosure, such that the diaphragms of the passive radiator assemblies provide a greater effective radiating area than would a single radiator diaphragm. In such a design, all passive radiator diaphragms may be moved by air pressure variations produced by the active drivers. Herein, the term “effective radiating area” of an audio transducer is used to identify a total surface area of the transducer (or of a diaphragm of the transducer) that moves air in order to produce a sound wave.
A frequency response, efficiency, mechanical resonance, or other characteristic of a passive radiator may be a function of a moving mass of the passive radiator. In general, increasing a moving mass of a diaphragm of a passive-radiator assembly will modify the passive radiator's frequency response. This can be advantageous when increased low-frequency output is a design goal.
In certain cases, it may be desirable to limit the size or weight of a loudspeaker system that contains one or more passive radiator assemblies and active drivers. Although adding mass to one or more of the passive-radiator diaphragms may improve a performance characteristic of the loudspeaker, doing so may add an undesirable weight to the loudspeaker system.
One way to address this issue is to couple an active driver to a passive radiator diaphragm at a hole, or opening, in the diaphragm. Such a coupling results in a passively driven moving mass that is equal to the combined moving mass of the passive radiator diaphragm and the mass of the active driver. Coupling the active driver to the passive radiator diaphragm allows the moving mass of the passive radiator to be increased without incurring an addition of unnecessary weight to the loudspeaker.
In one example, a speaker system designed to produce low-frequency output might employ this technique by sealing a “woofer” active driver assembly at a hole formed in a passive radiator diaphragm. The woofer creates variations in air pressure within the speaker enclosure that produce motion of the passive-radiator diaphragm. In such implementations, the passive radiator assembly has a total moving mass equal to the sum of the moving mass of the passive radiator diaphragm and the mass of the active driver assembly. Sound output is produced by the motion of the passive radiator diaphragm and the motion of the active driver diaphragm resulting from application of the electrical signal to the active driver.
Although such a technique may reduce the overall weight of such a loudspeaker system, it may not resolve other issues inherent in a loudspeaker that incorporates one or more passive radiators. For example, the motion of a passive radiator diaphragm applies a reaction force to the loudspeaker enclosure. At frequencies at or near a resonance frequency of the passive-radiator assembly, these reaction forces may be relatively large and may cause unwanted vibrations of the enclosure.
This application incorporates by reference the disclosures of application Ser. No. 12/056,872, filed Mar. 27, 2008, now issued as U.S. Pat. No. 8,189,841; application Ser. No. 10/623,996, filed Jul. 21, 2003, now issued as U.S. Pat. No. 7,133,533; and application Ser. No. 13/600,967, filed Aug. 31, 2013. These disclosures are directed, in part, to the mounting of an active driver to a passive radiator diaphragm and to the mounting of passive radiators so that the passive radiators are acoustically in phase and vibrate mechanically out of phase to thereby reduce unwanted vibrations of the enclosure.
In a loudspeaker that includes two passive radiators, it is possible to mount the passive radiator assemblies in opposing walls of the enclosure such that the diaphragms respond to variations in pressure of an acoustic volume enclosed by the enclosure with motions that are acoustically in phase but mechanically out of phase. If the two passive radiators have dissimilar physical properties, the passive radiators may not respond in an identical way to a same pressure variation. This may result in each passive radiator assembly exerting a different reaction force on the enclosure. These uneven forces may create undesirable vibrations in the enclosure. Such passive radiators are described herein as being “unbalanced.”
This undesirable effect may be reduced or avoided by balancing the passive radiator assemblies such that the two assemblies have equivalent physical characteristics. By way of examples, a physical characteristic of an assembly can include moving mass, effective radiating area, total suspension compliance, or combinations thereof.
In the loudspeaker described above, where an active driver is coupled to one passive radiator diaphragm, balancing may be performed by coupling an active driver having similar physical characteristics to the other passive radiator diaphragm. In particular, if the two passive radiators have similar moving masses and radiating areas, and the two active drivers have similar physical masses, the two active-driver/passive-radiator combinations will have similar moving masses and thus be properly balanced. Other balancing of active drivers may also be desirable, such as providing equal moving masses, compliances, diaphragm radiating areas, motor force, and damping.
The described arrangement may require a large acoustic enclosure. Typical active drivers include a motor which has a certain depth related to the motor force generated and the required excursion of a diaphragm that is coupled to the motor. In most implementations, the motor extends behind the diaphragm and into the acoustic chamber. In some examples where two passive radiators are mounted on opposite sides of an enclosure and each passive radiator diaphragm has an active driver attached, the motor structures of the active driver assemblies that protrude into the enclosure may interfere with each other. This may be problematic in a loudspeaker using a small enclosure where the passive radiator diaphragm radiating area is a large proportion of the surface area of the enclosure wall in which it is mounted (for example, greater than 40% of the area). Because an active driver assembly generally protrudes into an internal cavity of the enclosure, a small enclosure may not provide clearance sufficient for two active driver assemblies to be mounted on opposite walls of the enclosure such that their motor structures can be positioned back-to-back within the enclosure without interference.
Some of the acoustic devices disclosed herein address this problem by replacing at least one of the active driver assemblies with two or more smaller active driver assemblies, such that the smaller active driver assemblies in aggregate have similar physical characteristics and exhibit a similar acoustical performance as the single larger active driver assembly. This means that the two or more smaller active driver assemblies coupled to one passive radiator diaphragm have a similar total moving mass, effective radiating area, total suspension compliance, motor force, or an equivalent combination thereof, as the single larger active driver assembly coupled to the other passive radiator diaphragm. Because the smaller active driver assemblies protrude less into the interior of the enclosure, replacing a single larger active driver assembly into two or more smaller active driver assemblies that together have a moving mass similar to that of the larger active driver assembly may be sufficient to satisfy space constraints of a small enclosure. Additional benefit may be obtained by positioning the smaller active driver assemblies at locations that are laterally offset from the center of the diaphragm so as not to interfere with the larger active driver assembly in the opposite wall of the enclosure. A lateral offset, as used herein, means a perpendicular separation from an axis that extends through the center of mass of the diaphragm and typically through the geometrical center of the diaphragm.
The top wall 102 includes a hole to accommodate a passive radiator assembly that includes a diaphragm 120. The perimeter of diaphragm 120 is mechanically coupled to the top wall 102 by a flexible surround 110 which in turn is coupled to a frame 114 which is secured to the top wall 102. The frame 114 is a rigid structure to which other components may also be mounted. The surround 110 allows the diaphragm 120 to move axially (vertically in the figure). In the example of
Diaphragm 120 has two holes or openings. An active driver assembly 130 having an active driver 142 is positioned in each hole and is coupled by a frame 140 of the active driver assembly 130 to the diaphragm 120 by a mechanism (not shown). The frame 140 may be part of a basket (not shown) that includes other structure, such as spiders, to which other components of the active driver 142 may be attached. The coupling mechanism may include a gasket, an adhesive bead, or another mechanism that creates a substantially airtight and substantially rigid seal between frame 140 and diaphragm 120. Each active driver 142 is an audio transducer that produces sound waves in response to a received electrical signal, and is distinguishable from each passive radiator which produces sound waves in response to variations in acoustic pressure within acoustic chamber 150.
The bottom wall 104 similarly has a hole in which a passive radiator assembly is mounted. The passive radiator assembly includes a diaphragm 170 that is mechanically coupled to a flexible surround 112 which in turn is coupled to a frame 118 that is secured to the bottom wall 104. Surround 112 allows diaphragm 170 to move axially and substantially parallel to axis 99. Diaphragm 170 may be any surface that may move axially in response to variations in air pressure within acoustic chamber 150, and may assume any shape known to those skilled in the art, such as a cone, a surface with a hyperbolic cross-section or other known curved cross section, or a flat circular, rectangular, or oval surface.
The diaphragm 170 has a hole or opening in which a woofer or other active driver assembly 164 is disposed. The frame 166 of the active driver assembly 164 is rigidly secured to the diaphragm 170 and a sealing or coupling mechanism (not shown) may be disposed between the diaphragm 170 and the frame 166. The sealing or coupling mechanism can include a gasket, an adhesive bead, or another mechanism that creates a substantially airtight seal between the frame 166 of the active driver assembly 164 and the diaphragm 170.
Active drivers 142 may create variations in air pressure within acoustic chamber 150 that move the diaphragm 120 and the diaphragm 170 in response to a first electrical audio signal applied to the active drivers 142. Similarly, active driver 160 may create variations in air pressure within acoustic chamber 150 that move the diaphragm 120 and the diaphragm 170 in response to a second electrical audio signal applied to the active driver 160.
In the example shown in
In a second mode, the larger active driver 160 and the two smaller active drivers 142 receive substantially identical electrical audio signals at lower frequencies, but at higher frequencies, the two smaller active drivers 142 receive one or more electrical audio signals distinct from an electrical audio signal received by the larger active driver 160, and the signal received by the larger active driver 160 is rolled off at higher frequencies.
When an acoustic device comprises multiple passive-radiator diaphragms, failure to balance the moving masses of the passive radiators may result in vibrations that produce undesired artifacts, such as buzzing, rocking motions, and/or “walking” of the acoustic device when it sits on a surface while producing sound. Balancing may be performed by adjusting a mass of each radiator or by adjusting a distribution of mass of each radiator, as will be described in more detail.
Examples and implementations described herein accomplish balancing by mounting multiple active driver assemblies 130 in the diaphragm of the passive radiator 120 such that a mechanical characteristic of the combination of diaphragm 120 and active driver assemblies 130 is balanced with an analogous mechanical characteristic of the diaphragm 170 and active driver assembly 164.
The mechanical characteristic may comprise a total moving mass, an effective mass, a distribution of mass, a mechanical resonance, a compliance of a sealing or coupling mechanism, or combinations thereof. The balancing may be performed by selecting a mass of each active driver assembly 130, a lateral position of each driver assembly 130 relative to the axis 99 of the diaphragm 120, or a compliance of a surround.
A resonant frequency of a passive radiator moving mass with the compliance of the volume of air with which it interacts is a function of the passive-radiator diaphragm area as well as the acoustic volume and the moving mass of the passive radiator. A larger area passive-radiator tuned to the same resonance frequency as a smaller area passive radiator, for the case where each is coupled to a similar active driver and acoustic volume, has a greater moving mass than the smaller passive radiator.
Increasing a passive radiator's moving mass may be problematic if it is desirable to keep the total weight of an acoustic device less than a certain value or within a certain weight range, such as in a portable speaker system. There exists a trade-off between the beneficial effects of increasing the passive-radiator diaphragm radiating area and the drawback of requiring increased moving mass for maintaining the same resonance frequency.
In the illustrated example, active driver assemblies 130 are coupled to passive-radiator diaphragm 120. Coupling active driver assemblies 130 to passive-radiator diaphragm 120 adds the mass of the driver assemblies 130 to the total moving mass of diaphragm 120. Increasing the mass of diaphragm 120 with the masses of driver assemblies 130, which already contribute to the total weight of acoustic device 1000, reduces or eliminates the extra mass that must be added to diaphragm 120 in order to tune the passive radiator assembly to a particular low frequency.
When a passive radiator diaphragm vibrates, the moving mass produces a force. In a speaker system that includes only one passive radiator assembly, this force might be great enough at frequencies at or near a resonance frequency of the passive radiator assembly to induce undesirable vibrations in the enclosure. This undesirable effect may, however, can be reduced or eliminated by configuring such a system with a second passive radiator assembly that is in a balanced arrangement. The two assemblies are considered to be balanced if the two assemblies have similar inertia, such that the vibrations each induces to an enclosure tend to cancel each other. Similar inertia may exist when the two assemblies are configured such that their diaphragms have similar surface areas and that the assemblies have similar moving masses. Thus the acoustic device examples described herein comprise two passive radiator assemblies each having one or more active driver assemblies coupled to the passive radiator diaphragm wherein the passive radiator assemblies have a similar radiating surface area and a similar total moving mass.
As shown in
In one general case, if the moving masses and effective radiating areas of the two passive radiator assemblies are similar, then active driver assemblies 130 and active driver assembly 160 are selected such that a combined mass of active driver assemblies 130 is equal to a moving mass of the active driver assembly 164. If a close match is not possible, balancing may still be implemented by adding a small mass to one or more of the passive radiator diaphragms 120 or 170. More generally, it should be noted that the moving masses of the two passive radiator diaphragms 120 and 170 (without active driver assemblies) do not have to be equal and that the sum of the masses of the active driver assemblies in one passive radiator diaphragm do not need to equal the sum of the one or more active driver assemblies in the other passive radiator diaphragm. Rather, the masses of the passive radiator diaphragms may be different and the sums of the active driver assembly masses in each diaphragm may be different as long as the combination of the moving masses of a diaphragm and its active driver assemblies is balanced to the combination of the moving masses of the other diaphragm and its active driver assembly.
Passive radiator assemblies may be balanced even when active driver assemblies in a passive radiator diaphragm are not identical in mass. In such cases, a moment between a center of a passive radiator assembly and a center of mass of an active driver assembly secured to the diaphragm of the passive radiator assembly need to be balanced with the moments similarly defined for one or more other active driver assemblies secured to the same diaphragm. For two active driver assemblies coupled to the diaphragm, if one of the active driver assemblies is smaller and lighter than the other active driver assembly, that smaller and lighter assembly should be laterally positioned farther from the center of mass and geometrical center of the passive radiator diaphragm 120 than the other active driver assembly. When properly positioned in this manner, rocking is prevented.
In another example, active driver assemblies 130 comprise an active midrange driver and an active tweeter driver, both mounted to a same passive-radiator diaphragm. In yet another example, in which all active or passive assemblies reproduce lower frequency energy (i.e., energy that may excite the passive radiator assemblies at their tuning frequency), the acoustical outputs of the active drivers 142 are also balanced with the acoustical output of the active driver 164. In this example, the pair of active drivers 142 creates the same internal acoustic pressure as the single active woofer driver 160. In contrast, if the pair of active drivers 142 do not produce the same acoustic output as the single active driver 160, the two drivers 142 can be made to balance with the active driver 160 by altering an amplitude or other characteristic of one or more of the electrical audio signals supplied to one or more of the three active drivers 142 and 160.
In one example, proper balancing is achieved in a speaker system with identical passive radiator assemblies, each of which has a same radiating area and a same moving mass; and coupling similarly identical active drivers to each passive radiator assembly. In some applications, however, when a design or cost constraint bars such a configuration, the examples described herein allow proper balancing to be achieved when a system includes heterogeneous passive radiators or active drivers.
As shown in
Examples described herein address this problem by instead providing in the diaphragm 120 of one passive-radiator assembly multiple smaller active driver assemblies 130 so that the multiple active driver assemblies 130 in aggregate have a moving mass similar or equal to that of active driver assembly 164 and so that the smaller active driver assemblies 130 are offset from the axis 99. As a result, the extension of the structures of the smaller active driver assemblies 130 into the acoustic chamber 150 does not interfere with the extension of the structure of the larger active driver assembly 164 into the acoustic chamber 150.
In some implementations, such as the example shown in
Compliant coupling mechanism 280 may also reduce a tendency of loudspeaker 2000 to vibrate or rock at frequencies near a resonance frequency of a passive radiator assembly, as loaded by other components of acoustic device 2000. This tendency may result from an inability to completely balance the two passive radiators assemblies.
Compliant coupling 280 may take any form known to those skilled in the art of speaker design to compliantly couple two moving masses or to compliantly couple one moving mass to a fixed mass. Such a form may include an adhesive, a spring, or another coupling mechanism that substantially constrains movement of diaphragm 120 to motion along axis 99.
A compliant coupling mechanism 381 couples active driver assembly 364 to two enclosure walls 101 such that the coupling does not substantially constrain motion of diaphragm 370 along axis 99, but substantially restricts motion of diaphragm 370 along other axes, such as a side-to-side motion or a rocking motion. Alternatively, the compliant coupling mechanism 381 can couple the active driver assembly 364 to non-moving portion of acoustic device 3000. Because the active driver assembly 364 has substantial mass relative to the total moving mass of the combined passive radiator assembly and active driver assembly 364, and because the center of mass of the active driver assembly 364 is generally displaced from the plane of the passive radiator surround element 312, the tendency of the acoustic device 3000 to rock in an undesirable fashion is increased. This rocking is similar to what would occur for the acoustic device 2000 of
By limiting undesired off-axis motion, a compliant coupling mechanism 381 may reduce undesirable vibrations or rocking motion that may result, for example, from an inability to balance the two passive radiator assemblies. In some implementations, undesirable vibration or motion may further result from an inability to use a flexible surround 110 that completely eliminates side-to-side motion parallel to a plane of the diaphragm 120, or from design constraints that result in an inability to eliminate an enclosure resonance or to eliminate a condition that produces uneven pressure on a diaphragm 120 or 370, such as turbulence within acoustic chamber 150.
The compliant coupling mechanism 381 may take any form known to those skilled in the art of speaker design that may compliantly couple one moving mass to a fixed mass. Such a form may include an adhesive, a spring, or another coupling mechanism that substantially constrains movement of diaphragm 120 to motion along axis 99. In the acoustic device of
Unlike earlier examples described above, each active driver assembly 430 includes a back enclosure 490 that acoustically isolates the active driver 142 from the volume of air in acoustic chamber 150. In one example, each active driver 142 is fitted into the top of cup-shaped back enclosure 490 and the active driver assembly 430 is sealed and rigidly coupled to the passive radiator diaphragm 120.
In this example, each enclosure 490 completely seals the rearward side of active driver 142 to acoustically isolate the active driver 142 from acoustic volume 150. Each active driver assembly 430 thus produces acoustic output into the exterior environment of acoustic device 4000, but does not contribute substantial pressure variations within acoustic volume 150 that would otherwise exert a significant force on passive radiator diaphragms 120 and 170.
In the illustrated example, the total moving mass of the active driver assemblies 430, including the mass of the back enclosures 490, contributes to the moving mass of the passive radiator diaphragm 120. As described above, undesirable vibrations and rocking of acoustic device 4000 may thus be reduced by proper selection of the mass and position of each active driver assembly 430 to achieve balancing of the two passive radiators.
Although
The passive radiator diaphragm 570 on the opposite side of the enclosure from the active drivers 142 does not have any holes or openings, and does not have an exposed acoustic driver. Instead, the woofer 560 is mounted in a frame 590 which is directly coupled to the inner surface of the passive radiator diaphragm 570. The woofer 560 and frame 590 are part of a woofer assembly 564. The frame 590 has openings 550 (only one shown in the figure) that allows acoustic radiation from the back side of the woofer 560 to pass into and pressurize the acoustic chamber 150. The frame 590 may be a rigid structure having a significant number of openings 550 or disposed around the frame perimeter or circumference so that acoustic energy is not significantly obstructed or attenuated. A compliant coupler 580, which may be similar to the compliant coupling elements described above for other acoustic devices, is used to couple the woofer assembly 564 to the passive radiator diaphragm 520.
A number of implementations have been described. Nevertheless, it will be understood that additional modifications may be made without departing from the scope of the inventive concepts described herein and, accordingly, other embodiments are within the scope of the following claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3666041 | Engelhardt | May 1972 | A |
4207963 | Klasco | Jun 1980 | A |
4379951 | Gabr | Apr 1983 | A |
4903300 | Polk | Feb 1990 | A |
4924963 | Polk | May 1990 | A |
5216210 | Kammer | Jun 1993 | A |
5657392 | Bouchard | Aug 1997 | A |
5809154 | Polk | Sep 1998 | A |
5850460 | Tanaka | Dec 1998 | A |
6031919 | Funahashi | Feb 2000 | A |
6169811 | Croft, III | Jan 2001 | B1 |
7113607 | Mullins | Sep 2006 | B1 |
7133533 | Chick | Nov 2006 | B2 |
8031896 | Chick et al. | Oct 2011 | B2 |
8189841 | Litovsky | May 2012 | B2 |
8638975 | Jeffery | Jan 2014 | B2 |
8837763 | Millen | Sep 2014 | B1 |
9369817 | North | Jun 2016 | B2 |
20010024508 | Croft, III | Sep 2001 | A1 |
20010031061 | Coombs | Oct 2001 | A1 |
20050018868 | Chick | Jan 2005 | A1 |
20050157900 | Litovsky | Jul 2005 | A1 |
20070000720 | Noro | Jan 2007 | A1 |
20070081687 | Hayashi | Apr 2007 | A1 |
20070092096 | Litovsky | Apr 2007 | A1 |
20070201712 | Saiki | Aug 2007 | A1 |
20070291965 | Noro | Dec 2007 | A1 |
20080292117 | Guenther | Nov 2008 | A1 |
20090245561 | Litovsky | Oct 2009 | A1 |
20100027815 | Burge | Feb 2010 | A1 |
20100111343 | Hsu | May 2010 | A1 |
20110284315 | Litovsky | Nov 2011 | A1 |
20130195311 | Sahyoun | Aug 2013 | A1 |
20130213628 | Litovsky | Aug 2013 | A1 |
20130213730 | Litovsky | Aug 2013 | A1 |
20140029782 | Rayner | Jan 2014 | A1 |
20140064522 | Litovsky | Mar 2014 | A1 |
20140193005 | Riggs | Jul 2014 | A1 |
20140334657 | Guenther | Nov 2014 | A1 |
20140348350 | Barrentine | Nov 2014 | A1 |
20140348351 | Barrentine | Nov 2014 | A1 |
20140355806 | Graff | Dec 2014 | A1 |
20150195629 | Sumitani | Jul 2015 | A1 |
20150281844 | Stabile | Oct 2015 | A1 |
20160094909 | Johnston | Mar 2016 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2009120467 | Oct 2009 | WO |
Entry |
---|
U.S. Appl. No. 98/594,358, filed Nov. 26, 2013, Litovsky, et al. |
International Search Report & Written Opinion in counterpart International Patent Application No. PCT/US16/14660, mailed on Apr. 29, 2016; 12 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160219362 A1 | Jul 2016 | US |