1. Field of the Invention
Embodiments described in the present disclosure relate generally to the field of acoustic insulation for buildings and other architectural applications.
2. Description of Related Art
In the field of thermal and acoustic insulation for walls, ceilings, floors, and doors used in buildings and other architectural structures, insulation materials are often placed in the interior cavities of framed partitions. Example interior cavities include the volume between studs in a gypsum wallboard wall assembly or the interior cavity created by a multi-leaf door panel. These insulation materials are manufactured as a thick batt or blanket comprised of many layers of fine diameter fibers bonded into a three dimensional matrix with a binder or binding agent. The batt is generally homogeneous with regard to material, fiber orientation, and density, and acoustic material properties. In some cases the exterior surface or surfaces of the blanket or batt may be laminated with or clad by a covering layer on one or more exterior surfaces to facilitate handling, installation, or for water vapor management. Examples of such clad insulation products are “Kraft-Faced” and “ComfortTherm” fiberglass manufactured by Johns Manville of Denver Colo., and “CertoPro” and “Kraft Faced” fiberglass by CertainTeed Corporation of Valley Forge, Pa. While these materials and structures may provide an efficient thermal insulation, they typically lack the ability to enhance the acoustic attenuation at select frequencies due to a homogeneous design that provides a limited broadband sound attenuation. Even in cases where the insulating batt is clad with a covering layer on its outermost surfaces, sound attenuation performance is not improved. A covering layer in the outermost surface does not enhance the acoustic performance of the insulation in a system involving a partition with a cavity. In fact, current insulation manufacturers do not specify different levels of performance for their products according to their exterior covering or lack thereof.
Therefore, there is a need for enhanced acoustic and thermal insulation materials and methods to be used in architectural applications to enhance sound attenuation in the cavity of acoustically rated partitions used in buildings and other architectural applications.
An insulation batt for use in building structures according to embodiments disclosed herein may include a batt having an air flow resistive layer of material provided between portions of insulating material.
These and other embodiments are further described below with reference to the following figures.
Noise control is a rapidly growing economic and public policy concern for the construction industry. Areas with high acoustical isolation (commonly referred to as ‘soundproofed’) are desirable and required for a variety of purposes. Apartments, condominiums, hotels, schools and hospitals all require rooms with walls, ceilings and floors that reduce sound transmission thereby minimizing, or eliminating, the disturbance to people in adjacent rooms. Soundproofing is particularly important in buildings adjacent to public transportation, such as highways, airports and railroad lines. Additionally, facilities such as theaters, home theaters, music practice rooms, and recording studios require increased noise abatement. Likewise, hospitals and general healthcare facilities have begun to recognize acoustical comfort as an important part of a patient's recovery time. One result of the severity of multi-party residential and commercial noise control issues is the widespread emergence of model building codes and design guidelines that specify minimum Sound Transmission Class (STC) ratings for specific wall structures within a building. Another result is the broad emergence of litigation between homeowners and builders over the issue of unacceptable noise levels. In response, major builders have refused to build homes, condos and apartments in certain municipalities; and there is widespread cancellation of liability insurance for builders. The International Code Council has established that the minimum sound isolation between multiple tenant dwellings or between dwellings and corridors is a lab certified STC 50. Regional codes or builder specifications for these walls often require STC 60 or more. Such high performance levels are difficult to achieve and field tested designs often fail to perform to the required levels. The problem is compounded when a single wall or structure is value-engineered to minimize the material and labor involved during construction.
One common feature in building panels used in walls, ceilings, floors and other construction applications is a notable deterioration of the noise attenuation quality of the panel at low frequencies, particularly at or around 125 Hz. It would be highly desirable to have a building panel that is optimized in sound attenuation and vibration transmission properties such that vibration frequencies from about 50 to about 125 Hz (“problem frequencies”) are highly suppressed.
Various construction techniques and products have emerged to address the problem of noise control, but few are well suited to target these selected problem frequencies. Currently available choices include adding gypsum drywall layers, resilient channels and isolated drywall panels, and mass-loaded vinyl barriers with additional drywall panels; or cellulose-based sound board. All of these changes help reduce the noise transmission incrementally, but not to such an extent that identified problem frequencies would be considered fully mitigated (i.e. restoring privacy or comfort).
Embodiments disclosed herein are designed to be installed into building partitions with an open cavity, such as a stud framed wall or ceiling. According to some embodiments, an insulation batt or blanket may be sized to completely fill the cavity from stud to stud, the insulation batt including an intermediate airflow resistive layer generally parallel to the partition surfaces. The batt or blanket according to some embodiments may include a plurality of insulating portions made of fine diameter fibers. Fibrous materials used in some embodiments may include fiberglass, rock wool, mineral wool, polyester fibers, or denim/cotton fibers. According to some embodiments, one or more intermediate airflow resistive layers have a mass and an air flow resistance that are optimized to improve the transmission loss for specific frequencies in the noise spectrum.
Embodiments of insulation batts consistent with the present disclosure may be wrapped around structural elements of buildings to enhance sound and thermal isolation. For example, ducts used in heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems may be wrapped or covered with insulation batts consistent with the present disclosure. In general, ducts carrying fluids (e.g. air or water) for different purposes in a building may be wrapped by insulation batts according to the present disclosure. Typically, ducts carrying fluids in buildings are a conduit of noise and undesirable vibrations, especially when the duct is fabricated with a hard material such as metal or vinyl. Thus, embodiments of the present disclosure may substantially eliminate the noise and vibration transmitted by these conduits, insulating the duct from other building elements.
The intermediate resistive layer separates the insulating matt or blanket into at least two portions parallel to the partition surfaces. In some embodiments, the two portions may have equal or nearly equal thickness. In some embodiments the portions of insulating material on either side of the resistive layer may have different thicknesses. Further according to some embodiments more than one intermediate resistive layer may be included in the insulating matt, resulting in three, four, or more layers of insulating material separated by a plurality of intermediate resistive layers.
In embodiments consistent with the present disclosure, the noise spectrum is a spectrum of sound frequencies that are desired to be attenuated. Typically, these frequencies are in the range from about 50-60 Hz to 1000 Hz. When installed into a wall assembly in exactly the same manner as traditional materials, insulation batts as disclosed herein may deliver approximately 3 dB of noise isolation improvement, between about 200 and 5,000 Hz.
Insulating materials used in some embodiments may include fiberglass mats, mineral wool or rock wool batts, cellulose insulation, or natural fiber batts using fibers made from denim or cotton. For example, some embodiments may use insulating materials from a denim fiber batt such as provided by Bonded Logic, Inc. of Chandler, Ariz. A denim fiber batt is formed from ground up denim jeans, bonded together with a PET (Poly-ethylene Terephthalate) binder to form a three-dimensional (3-D) batt.
Some figures of merit for this invention and for the components of the assembly are specific airflow resistance and airflow resistivity. Specific airflow resistance is the quotient of the air pressure difference across a material's area, divided by the volume velocity of airflow through the material specimen. This is equivalent to the air pressure difference across the specimen divided by the linear velocity of airflow measured outside the material when tested per ASTM test method C522. The units of specific air flow resistance are Pa.s/m, also known as ‘mks rayl.’ Airflow resistivity is the quotient of the specific airflow resistance of a homogeneous material divided by its thickness. Its units are Pa.s/m2, termed mks rayl/m. The airflow resistance measurement method is defined by ASTM C522 “Standard Test Method for Airflow Resistance of Acoustical Materials.” This standard is available online at the ASTM web page, and is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety for all purposes. According to embodiments disclosed herein, a high value of specific airflow resistance is desirable in order to reduce sound transmission through pressure waves traveling in the air contained inside a partition cavity.
A figure of merit for the sound attenuating qualities of a sound rated partition is its Sound Transmission Class (STC). The STC number is a rating which is used in the architectural field to rate partitions, doors and windows for their effectiveness in reducing the transmission of sound. The rating assigned to a particular partition design is a result of acoustical testing and represents a best fit type of approach to a set of curves that define the sound transmission class. The STC measurement method is defined by ASTM E90 “Standard Test Method Laboratory Measurement of Airborne Sound Transmission Loss of Building Partitions and Elements,” and ASTM E413 “Classification for Sound Insulation,” used to calculate STC ratings from the sound transmission loss data for a given structure. These standards are available online at the ASTM web page, and are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety for all purposes.
Building partitions that may benefit in STC performance by using insulation blankets according to embodiments disclosed herein include many typical lightweight 25 gauge steel framed wall assemblies. For example, a single stud wall assembly with a single layer of type X gypsum wallboard on each side and a common homogeneous fiber insulation batt (fiberglass, mineral fiber, or cotton fiber) provides inadequate acoustical performance. Such a single stud wall has been laboratory tested to an STC 48, which is below building code requirements (STC 50, 60, or more). The rating of such walls is limited by poor transmission loss at 125, 160 and 2500 Hz. In many cases, sound absorption performance is about five to ten decibels lower than it is at other, nearby frequencies. For example, at 200 Hz, the wall performs about 6 decibels better (higher transmission loss) than it does at the adjacent measurement frequency, 160 Hz. The subject batt insulation with an air resistive substructure according to embodiments disclosed herein improves the STC of a sound rated partition at these target frequencies. In one embodiment, an insulation batt with a single air resistive layer having a mass of about 1 kg/m2 and an airflow resistance of between 200 and 900 mks rayls can improve the transmission loss across a broad frequency range from about 200 Hz to about 5,000 Hz. The STC rating for a wall using this insulation embodiment improves by 3 points to an STC 51, which is building code compliant for a sound rated partition.
A figure of merit of a material used for thermal insulation in architectural applications is the R-value. The R-value is a reciprocal of the measure of a system or assembly's thermal transmission, or the rate of heat transfer through the system. Therefore, the higher the R-value the lower the amount of heat loss, and the product is a better insulator. The units of R-values may be given as hr·ft 2·° F. /Btu (inverse of a British thermal unit—Btu—per hour, per square feet, per degree Fahrenheit). Conversion to MKS units is through: 1 Btu/(hr·ft2·° F.)=5.666 W/(m2 K) (Watts per meter squared, per degree Kelvin). R-values are defined according to the insulation resistance test set forth by the American Society for Testing and Materials in the Annual Book of ASTM, incorporated herein by reference in its entirety for all purposes.
The air flow resistance (expressed in mks rayls) of the interlayer material used in portion 103 (“air flow resistive layer”) is a parameter that may be used to optimize the noise attenuation properties of blanket 100, according to some embodiments. The interlayer material for airflow resistive layer 103 can be selected to enhance broadband or select frequency transmission loss.
The mass of resistive layer 103 may influence a maximum noise attenuation frequency. For example, the higher the mass of airflow resistive layer 103 the lower the noise frequency experiencing maximum attenuation. The positioning of airflow resistive layer 103 may also be adjusted according to the desired noise attenuation. According to embodiments consistent with the present disclosure one or more airflow resistive layers 103 may be placed in various locations along the z-direction of the batt. This is described in detail below, in conjunction with
In some embodiments, insulation batt 100 includes an airflow resistive layer 103 having a mass of about 2 kg/m2 and an airflow resistance of between 700 and 900 mks rayls. Such insulation batt improves the transmission loss performance across a target frequency range of 100 Hz to 250 Hz.
The physical properties of airflow resistive layer 103 may vary depending on the material used in airflow resistive layer 103 and the specific application needs. According to embodiments consistent with the present disclosure, airflow resistive layer 103 may have an airflow resistance of about 200 to 900 MKS rayls. In some embodiments, airflow resistive layer 103 may have an airflow resistance of about 200 to 600 MKS rayls. Further according to some embodiments, airflow resistive layer 103 may have an airflow resistance of about 100 to 500 MKS rayls.
The materials used to make airflow resistive layer 103 may vary depending on the specific needs of a given application. Airflow resistive layer 103 may be formed of a woven fabric of selected airflow resistance. In some embodiments, airflow resistive layer 103 is formed from a nonwoven sheet of selected airflow resistance. Some embodiment consistent with the present disclosure may provide airflow resistive layer 103 formed of a semi-porous paper of selected airflow resistance. Further according to some embodiments, airflow resistive layer 103 may be formed of a perforated film of selected airflow resistance.
In some embodiments, insulation batts consistent with the present disclosure are formed of nonwoven fibers on either side of an intermediate air flow resistive layer (see
In some embodiments, insulation batt 400 is designed in such a way that a distance exists between resistive layer 403 and either of wallboard panels 451 and 452. It is desirable to have a portion of fibrous matt (such as 401 or 402) be provided a minimum thickness to separate airflow resistive layer 403 from panels 451 and 452. Such a separation prevents acoustic coupling between panels 451 and 452, and airflow resistive layer 403.
According to embodiments consistent with the present disclosure, studs 460-1 through 460-3 may be formed of wood. In some embodiments, studs 460-1 through 460-3 are made of metal such as a steel sheet formed into a hollow shape (see
According to embodiments consistent with the present disclosure, the ceiling plane 560-1 and 560-2 may also be formed of a continuous sheet consisting of gypsum drywall or wood.
Curve 601 corresponds to embodiments consistent with wallboard 450 having insulation batt 400 as in a prototype Insulation A, test sample no. TL11-350, resulting in an STC value of 51. The average density of the insulation batt used in the embodiment corresponding to curve 601 is 1.7 pcf. Curve 602 corresponds to embodiments consistent with wallboard 450 having insulation batt 400 as in prototype Insulation B, test sample no. TL11-351, resulting in an STC value of 50. The average density of the insulation batt used in the embodiment corresponding to curve 602 is 1.7 pcf. The insulation batt used in curves 601 and 602 employs embodiments of the acoustic enhancing substructure as shown in the present disclosure.
For prototype Insulation A, a resistive layer such as airflow resistive layer 103 (see
Curves 611, 612, and 613 correspond to a wall structure with 25 gauge steel studs 460 and a single Type X gypsum board in each of wallboards 451 and 452, such as described above in relation to curves 601 and 602. However, curves 611, 612, and 613 make use of an insulation batt in the cavity formed between studs 460-1 through 460-3 and wallboards 451 and 452 as in the prior art. Thus, insulation batts as used to obtain curves 611, 612, and 613 each have a single piece of insulation material, without an airflow resistive interlayer. For example, a single piece of insulation batts used to obtain curves 611, 612, and 613 may be as either one of portions 101 and 102 (see
Curve 621 corresponds to a wall structure with 25 gauge steel studs 460 and a single, Type X gypsum board as wallboards 451 and 452, such as described above in relation to curves 501 and 502. However, structures resulting in curve 621 have no insulation batt in the cavity formed between studs 460-1 through 460-3 and wallboards 451 and 452. The test number for curve 621 is TL11-346, and the resulting STC value is 41.
Insulation batt 750 may include portions 701 and 702 formed from an insulating material and separated by airflow resistive layer 703, as shown in
Embodiments disclosed herein are illustrative only and not limiting. One of regular skill in the art will recognize that other embodiments consistent with the present disclosure may be possible. The present disclosure is limited only by the following claims.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/538,744 filed on Sep. 23, 2011, under 35 U.S.C. 119(e).
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61538744 | Sep 2011 | US |