The present invention relates to acoustics and to improvements in audibility and intelligibility of speech for an audience. More specifically, the present invention relates to an acoustic system for improving acoustic quality in a room for speech.
In rooms which are intended to be used for presentations and/or giving lectures etc, such as a class room or a conference/meeting room, it is desired to provide acoustics which are ideally suited for facilitating the transmission of sound, particularly speech, to the intended audience. The teachings herein pertain particularly to ordinary rooms as defined in ISO 3382-2. Acoustic quality for speech in an ordinary room encompasses not only speech intelligibility for the audience but also speaker comfort, i.e. the perceived comfort that a person speaking receives in the room. In: “Measurement and prediction of voice support and room gain in school classrooms”, D. Pelegrin-Garcia, J. Brunskog, V. Lyberg-Åhlander, A. Löfqvist, published in J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 131 (1), January 2012, is speaker comfort discussed and a parameter for quantification introduced. The parameter voice support is related to sound strength G. There is probably an optimum value but more investigations are needed.
Early reflections of the sound waves are generally considered favourable for the acoustic quality in a room for speech while late reflections are considered detrimental. A standardized measurement parameter of such early reflections is speech clarity C50, where the relationship between sound reflections before and after 50 ms are observed and where the former is considered early reflections and thus beneficial. Another parameter that is of importance is reverberation of different frequencies of sound, where excessive reverberation or reverberation time, T20, of certain sound frequencies can cause discomfort and/or reduce intelligibility of the speech. Moreover, as mentioned, the sound strength G is also of importance. All these factors/parameters are affected by the general design of the room as well as of if for instance a sound absorbent ceiling is provided in the room.
In view of that stated above, the object of the present invention is to provide an acoustic system that alleviates some of the problems with prior art solutions and improves speech intelligibility and speaker comfort in a room provided with a sound absorbent ceiling.
To achieve at least one of the above objects and also other objects that will be evident from the following description, an acoustic system having the features defined in claim 1 is provided according to the present disclosure. Preferred embodiments of the system will be evident from the dependent claims.
More specifically, there is provided an acoustic system for improving speech intelligibility, the acoustic system comprising a room having a first zone and a second zone. The system further comprising a ceiling of the room, the ceiling comprising a plurality of ceiling tiles. The ceiling tiles comprises a first group of ceiling tiles having sound absorbing properties and a second group of ceiling tiles having sound diffusing properties. The first group of ceiling tiles comprises ceiling tiles being arranged in the second zone and the second group of ceiling tiles comprises ceiling tiles being arranged in the first zone and being configured for reflecting sound to the first zone and to the second zone. The sound diffusing second group of ceiling tiles arranged in the first zone provides early reflections to both the first zone, which may be a presentation zone, which improves speaker comfort. Further still, the early reflections provided to the second zone, which may be an audience zone, improves the speech clarity and sound strength in the second zone which improves speech intelligibility. Moreover, reverberation time for octave frequency bands which are considered relevant for speech intelligibility are also reduced.
The ceiling may be a suspended ceiling, a direct fixed ceiling or a free hanging ceiling unit.
In one embodiment, the ceiling comprises a grid of profiles supporting the ceiling tiles.
The second group of ceiling tiles may further cover at least 5% of a ceiling area of the ceiling. The second group of ceiling tiles may further still cover at the most 25% of a ceiling area of the ceiling. The aforementioned ratios provide a desired balance where the overall sound absorbing functionality of the first group of ceiling tiles is maintained while the second group of ceiling tiles provides a significant improvement in speech intelligibility and improved speaker comfort.
The first group of ceiling tiles may comprise ceiling tiles mounted in the second zone.
The second group of ceiling tiles may further be hollow having a front surface provided with at least one opening facing the room. The volume of a hollow portion of the ceiling tile may be between 0.02 m3 and 0.04 m3, preferably approximately 0.03 m3. The hollow shape of each second group ceiling tile and the at least one opening form a resonance chamber in each second group ceiling tile that allows it to absorb octave frequency bands which for instance the first group of ceiling tiles are less efficient at absorbing. The overall acoustic properties of the acoustic system are thus improved.
The at least one opening may further have an opening surface area of between 200 mm2 and 300 mm2, preferably approximately 260 mm2. The aforementioned surface area together with the structure and volume of the hollow portion of the second group ceiling tiles provides improved absorption of low sound frequencies, typically below 500 Hz, more preferably approximately 125 Hz.
Moreover, the second group of ceiling tiles may be configured to absorb sound having a sound frequency below 500 Hz, preferably approximately 125 Hz. Sound frequencies below 500 Hz, especially around 125 Hz, are typically difficult for a regular sound absorbent ceiling tile, such as those of the first group, to absorb. Furthermore, such low frequencies are not considered beneficial for speech intelligibility. The second group of ceiling tiles thus reduces such undesired low sound frequencies thus complementing the first group of ceiling tiles.
In one embodiment, the presentation zone covers a presentation position from which a speaker, i.e. a person, is intended to address an audience. Furthermore, ceiling tiles from the second group of ceiling tiles may be arranged directly above the presentation position. Having second group ceiling tiles arranged directly above the speaker provides a significant increase in the early reflections that the speaker can receive which improves speaker comfort.
Ceiling tiles from the second group of ceiling tiles may further be arranged covering an area of the suspended ceiling from the presentation position extending towards the second zone. Further still, ceiling tiles from the second group of ceiling tiles may be arranged in the audience zone. Extending the second group of ceiling tiles from the first zone towards and even into the second zone increases the early reflections and the sound strength that can be provided to the second zone.
Ceiling tiles from the first group of ceiling tiles may further be arranged in the first zone.
The second group of ceiling tiles may comprises ceiling tiles having a front surface facing the room having a shape selected from the group comprising: a single curved convex front surface, a double curved convex front surface, a multi-faceted convex front surface, an asymmetric at least partially inclined front surface, an asymmetrically curved convex front surface, an inclined concave front surface, an at least partially curved concave front surface and a multi-faceted concave front surface.
Generally, all terms used in the claims are to be interpreted according to their ordinary meaning in the technical field, unless explicitly defined otherwise herein. All references to “a/an/the [element, device, component, means, step, etc]” are to be interpreted openly as referring to at least one instance of said element, device, component, means, step, etc., unless explicitly stated otherwise. The steps of any method disclosed herein do not have to be performed in the exact order disclosed, unless explicitly stated.
The above, as well as additional objects, features and advantages of the present invention, will be better understood through the following illustrative and non-limiting detailed description of preferred embodiments of the present invention, with reference to the appended drawings, where the same reference numerals will be used for similar elements, wherein:
The present invention will now be described more fully hereinafter with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which currently preferred embodiments of the invention are shown. This invention may, however, be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided for thoroughness and completeness, and fully convey the scope of the invention to the skilled person.
The room 102 has a first zone A and a second zone B, the separation of which is indicated by the dashed line in the
The second zone B is the intended target of the sound emitted from the first zone A, and is thus preferably an audience zone B.
The system 100 further comprises a ceiling 104, the ceiling 104 comprising a pluraliy of ceiling tiles 110, 112. The ceiling 104 may be a suspended ceiling 104 as is illustrated in
The ceiling tiles 110, 112 further comprises a first group of ceiling tiles 110 having sound absorbing properties. The first group of ceiling tiles 110 may be conventional ceiling tiles 110 and may in one embodiment be manufactured from a mineral fibre material. Rooms provided with sound absorbing ceiling tiles presents certain difficulties for achieving a desired acoustic for achieving high speech intelligibility and speaker comfort. It has been realized that sound absorbing ceilings reduces the sound strength of higher octave frequency bands which are considered important for speech intelligibility, while such ceilings provides less sound absorption for lower sound frequencies that may be detrimental to speech intelligibility.
The ceiling tiles 110, 112 further comprises a second group of ceiling tiles 112 having sound diffusing properties. The second group ceiling tiles 112 will be described in more detail in relation to
The first group of ceiling tiles 110 comprises ceiling tiles being arranged in the second zone B and the second group of ceiling tiles 112 comprises ceiling tiles being arranged in the first zone A and is configured for reflecting sound to the first zone A and to the second zone B. In the embodiment shown in
The second group of ceiling tiles 112 thus provides early sound reflections to the second zone B, in which the audience is positioned. The first group of ceiling tiles 110 absorbs sound particularly well in the medium to high speech sound frequency ranges, i.e. from 500 Hz and above. The second group of ceiling tiles 112 particularly diffuses and improves reflection of sound having sound frequencies of 500 Hz and above, thus compensating for the sound absorbtion of the first group of ceiling tiles.
The comfort for an eventual speaker in the presentation position 116 is improved by the early reflections indicated in
In
Speech clarity C50 is, as mentioned above, the relationship between early and late reflections and is more specifically defined by the following formula, in which h= measured impulse response:
Table 1 below shows the corresponding measured C50 values in dB that is plotted in the diagram of
The first graph 200 shows how the C50 dB level varies with changing frequency when only absorbent ceiling tiles of the first group 110 are fitted, while the second graph 300 shows the corresponding C50 dB levels when ceiling tiles 112 from the second group are arranged above the presentation position 116 in the first zone A. Combining sound absorbing ceiling tiles 110 from the first group with sound diffusing ceiling tiles 112 from the second group provides an increase in C50 over the entire measured spectrum in the near position 118, i.e. between 125 Hz to 4000 Hz.
The octave frequency bands of 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz have shown to be particularly important for speech intelligibility and a significant dB increase between these sound frequencies is achieved in the near position 118 by the acoustic system 100 presented herein.
Table 2 below shows the corresponding measured C50 values in dB that is plotted in the diagram of
The first graph 200 shows measured C50 dB levels in the far position 120 when only sound absorbing ceiling tiles 110 from the first group is arranged in the ceiling 104. The second graph 300 shows corresponding C50 dB levels in the far position 120 when ceiling tiles 120 from the second group are fitted to the ceiling 104 in the first zone A above the presentation position 116. For the far position 120, an even more significant improvement is achieved in speech clarity between the octave frequency bands of 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz.
The second group of ceiling tiles 112 should preferably cover at least 5% of a ceiling area of the ceiling 104 and at most 25% of the ceiling area of the ceiling 104. While also smaller or larger area portions of the ceiling 104 area may be covered by ceiling tiles 112 of the second group, the above limits provides desired functionality of the sound diffusing/reflecting properties of the second group of ceiling tiles 112 whilst avoiding an undesired reduction of the sound absorbing properties of the first group of ceiling tiles 110.
It can be seen that the reverberation time T20 is reduced for the important frequencies 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz. This is a non obvious effect of the provision of the ceiling tiles 112 of the second group to the acoustic system 100. In most applications, adding diffusors to an acoustic system generally causes increase reverberation time. However, in the context of the teachings herein where diffusors are combined with absorbent ceiling tiles 110 from the first group, can improvements be achieved also in reverberation time T20 for the most important octave frequency bands.
This extends also to
Also in the far position 120 can a decrease in the reverberation time T20 be observed for the frequencies 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz compared to a prior art acoustic system where only sound absorbent ceiling tiles 110 of the first group are used.
As can be seen in
While the increase in sound strength G compared to the prior art system is not as significant in the far position 120 as it is in the near position 118, a noticeable increase is still achieved for the desired frequencies of 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz.
By arranging the second group ceiling tiles 112 in individual longitudinal rows, the ceiling tiles 112 can be allowed to be spread out over a larger area of the ceiling 104 and thus provide sound diffusion/reflection over a larger area without exceeding the preferred area limits defined above. The rows may further extend longer into the second zone B while keeping within the preferred area limits.
Turning now to
To achieve a desired diffusion/reflection of sound waves, the front surface 114 shown in
The curved front surface 114 of the ceiling tile 112 in
The ceiling tile 112 shown in
The second group ceiling tile 112 may be hollow and having a volume of a hollow portion 124 of the ceiling tile 112 of between 0.02 m3 and 0.04 m3, preferably approximately 0.03 m3. The weight of the ceiling tile 112 can thus be reduced. The hollow portion 124 is further especially beneficial if the second group ceiling tile 112 is provided with an opening 122 in the front surface 114, as is illustrated in
The opening 122 should be arranged such that it faces the room 102 and have an opening surface area of between 200 mm2 and 300 mm2, preferably approximately 260-270 mm2. The opening 122 will allow the second group ceiling tile 112 to function as a resonating absorbent and with the volume of the hollow portion 124 specified above together with the opening 122 surface area will especially low sound frequencies be absorbed. Particularly sound frequencies below 500 Hz, more preferred between 100 Hz and 200 Hz, even more preferred approximately 125 Hz.
This is especially beneficial when considering the second group of ceiling tiles 112 in combination with the absorbing ceiling tiles 110 from the first group, as the first group of ceiling tiles 110, which are preferably conventional sound absorbing ceiling tiles 110, are particularly efficient at absorbing sound in octave frequency bands with higher frequencies while generally less effective for sound with a lower frequency. Such low octave frequency bands as between 100 Hz and 200 Hz are further not desirable for improving speech clarity/intelligibility, the second group of ceiling tiles 112 will thus complement the first group of ceiling tiles 110 in absorbing these frequency bands and thus providing an improved total acoustic property of the acoustic system 100.
The ceiling tile 112 shown in
The lateral and longitudinal extension of the ceiling tile 112 is generally limited, especially when the ceiling tile 112 is supported by grid of profiles 106. Typically, the ceiling tiles 110, 112 have the following modular dimensions: 600 × 600 mm or 1200 × 600 mm, in order to fit in existing grid of profiles 106. Achieving both a desired interior volume and a desired shape of the front surface 114 can thus be problematic whilst also having to consider the standardized modular dimensions of the grid of profiles 106. Providing a second hollow portion 128 removes some of the limitations that the above relationships could otherwise present in shaping the second group ceiling tile 112. The second hollow portion 128 is applicable to all embodiments of the second group ceiling tile 112 disclosed herein.
In one embodiment, as shown in
The opening(s) 122 allows sound waves to transfer to the inside of the hollow portion 124 (and optionally the second hollow portion 128) whereby frequencies below 500 Hz, preferably approximately 126 Hz, can be absorbed, as mentioned above. The volume of the hollow portion 124 together with the thickness of the ceiling tile material that constitutes the front surface 114 and the area of the opening(s) 122 defines the resonance frequency of the ceiling tile 112 according to the following formula:
fr=resonance frequency, S=area of opening 122, L=length of the channel formed by the opening 122 from outside to inside of front surface 114, V=volume of hollow portion 124 or hollow portion and second hollow portion 128 combined.
The volume of the hollow portion 124, or of the hollow portion 124 and the second hollow portion 128 combined, is preferably between 0.02 m3 and 0.04 m3, preferably approximately 0.03 m3. The thickness of the material in the ceiling tile 112 that forms the front surface 114 is between 2 mm and 5 mm, preferably approximately 3 mm, which defines the length channel formed by the opening 122. The opening 122 total surface area is, as mentioned, between 200 mm2 and 300 mm2, preferably approximately 260 mm2.
The second group of ceiling tiles 112 will thus complement the first group of ceiling tiles 110 in absorbing the undesired low frequency bands of below 500 Hz thus forming an improved acoustic system. The second group of ceiling tiles 112 further facilitates diffusion of sound and provides increased early reflections to both the first zone A and to the second zone B, which increases speech clarity C50, increases sound strength G and reduces undesired reverberation time T20 particularly for the desired octave frequency bands of between 2000 Hz and 4000 Hz.
What is further shown in
An improved acoustic system 100 that improves speech intelligibility and speaker comfort by enhancing desired octave frequency bands and absorbing undesired octave frequency bands is thus provided.
It is to be realized that while each embodiment of the second group ceiling tile 112 is described separately above, the ceiling 104 could be provided with any combination of the different embodiments of the second group ceiling tiles 112. For instance, ceiling tiles 112 as shown in
It will be appreciated that the present invention is not limited to the embodiments shown. Several modifications and variations are thus conceivable within the scope of the invention which thus is exclusively defined by the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20170667.8 | Apr 2020 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2021/059780 | 4/15/2021 | WO |