Acoustical sound proofing material with improved fracture characteristics and methods for manufacturing same

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 9388568
  • Patent Number
    9,388,568
  • Date Filed
    Friday, April 6, 2007
    17 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, July 12, 2016
    8 years ago
Abstract
A material for use in building construction (partition, wall, ceiling, floor or door) that exhibits improved acoustical sound proofing and fracture characteristics optimized for efficient installation. The material comprises a laminated structure having as an integral part thereof one or more layers of viscoelastic material which also functions both as a glue and as an energy dissipating layer; and one or more constraining layers, such as gypsum or cement-based panel products modified for easy fracture. In one embodiment, standard paper-faced wallboard, typically gypsum, comprises the external surfaces of the laminated structure with the inner surface of said wallboard being bare with no paper or other material being placed thereon. The resulting structure improves the attenuation of sound transmitted through the structure while also allowing installation of the sound proofing material as efficiently as the installation of standard material when the sound proofing material is used alone or incorporated into a partition assembly.
Description
BACKGROUND

Noise control constitutes a rapidly growing economic and public policy concern for the construction industry. Areas with high acoustical isolation (commonly referred to as ‘soundproofed’) are requested and required for a variety of purposes. Apartments, condominiums, hotels, schools and hospitals all require walls, ceilings and floors that are specifically designed to reduce the transmission of sound in order to minimize or eliminate the disruption to people in adjacent rooms. Soundproofing is particularly important in buildings adjacent to public transportation including highways, airports and railroad lines. Additionally, theaters and home theaters, music practice rooms, recording studios and others require increased noise abatement for acceptable listening levels. Likewise, hospitals and general healthcare facilities have begun to recognize acoustical comfort as an important part of a patient's recovery time. One measure of the severity of multi-party residential and commercial noise control issues is the widespread emergence of model building codes and design guidelines that specify minimum Sound Transmission Class (STC) ratings for specific wall structures within a building. Another measure is the broad emergence of litigation between homeowners and builders over the issue of unacceptable noise levels. To the detriment of the U.S. economy, both problems have resulted in major builders refusing to build homes, condos and apartments in certain municipalities; and in cancellation of liability insurance for builders.


Various construction techniques and products have emerged to address the problem of noise control, such as: replacement of wooden framing studs with light gauge steel studs; alternative framing techniques such as staggered-stud and double-stud construction; additional gypsum drywall layers; the addition of resilient channels to offset and isolate drywall panels from framing studs; the addition of mass-loaded vinyl barriers; cellulose-based sound board; and the use of cellulose and fiberglass batt insulation in walls not requiring thermal control. All of these changes help reduce the noise transmission but not to such an extent that certain disturbing noises (e.g., those with significant low frequency content or high sound pressure levels) in a given room are prevented from being transmitted to a room designed for privacy or comfort. The noise may come from rooms above or below the occupied space, or from an outdoor noise source. In fact, several of the above named methods only offer a three to six decibel improvement in acoustical performance over that of standard construction techniques with no regard to acoustical isolation. Such a small improvement represents a just noticeable difference, not a soundproofing solution. A second concern with the above named techniques is that each involves the burden of either additional (sometimes costly) construction materials or extra labor expense due to complicated designs and additional assembly steps.


More recently, an alternative building noise control product has been introduced to the market in the form of a laminated damped drywall panel as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 7,181,891. That panel replaces a traditional drywall layer and eliminates the need for additional materials such as resilient channels, mass loaded vinyl barriers, additional stud framing, and additional layers of drywall. The resulting system offers excellent acoustical performance improvements of up to 15 decibels in some cases. However, the panel cannot be cut by scribing and breaking. Rather than using a box cutter or utility knife to score the panel for fracture by hand, the panels must be scored multiple times and broken with great force over the edge of a table or workbench. Often times, the quality of the resulting break (in terms of accuracy of placement and overall straightness) is poor. The reason for the additional force required to fracture the laminated panel is because the component gypsum layers have a liner back paper (or liner fiberglass nonwoven) that has a high tensile strength. Tests have shown that scored panels of this type require approximately 85 pounds of force to fracture versus the 15 pounds required to break scored ½ inch thick standard gypsum wallboard and the 46 pounds of force required to break scored ⅝ inch thick type X gypsum wallboard. This internal layer (or layers, in some cases) must be broken under tension via considerable bending force during a typical score and snap operation.


In many cases, the tradesman is forced to cut each panel with a power tool such as a circular saw or a rotary cutting tool to ensure a straight cut and a high quality installation. This adds time and labor costs to the panel installation and generates copious amounts of dust which act as a nuisance to the laborers and adds even more installation expense in the form of jobsite clean up.


A figure of merit for the sound reducing qualities of a material or method of construction is the material or wall assembly's Sound Transmission Class (STC). The STC rating is a classification which is used in the architectural field to rate partitions, doors and windows for their effectiveness in blocking sound. The rating assigned to a particular partition design as a result of acoustical testing represents a best fit type of approach to a curve that establishes the STC value. The test is conducted in such a way as to make it independent of the test environment and yields a number for the partition only and not its surrounding structure or environment. The measurement methods that determine an STC rating are defined by the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM). They are ASTM E 90-04, “Standard Test Method Laboratory Measurement of Airborne Sound Transmission Loss of Building Partitions and Elements,” (publication date Apr. 1, 2004) and ASTM E413-04 “Classification for Sound Insulation,” (publication date Apr. 1, 2004) used to calculate STC ratings from the sound transmission loss data for a given structure. These standards are available on the Internet.


A second figure of merit for the physical characteristics of construction panels is the material's flexural strength. This refers to the panel's ability to resist breaking when a force is applied to the center of a simply supported panel. Values of flexural strength are given in pounds of force (lbf) or Newtons (N). The measurement technique used to establish the flexural strength of gypsum wallboard or similar construction panels is ASTM C 473-06a “Standard Test Methods for the Physical Testing of Gypsum Panel Products” (publication date Nov. 1, 2006). This standard is available on the Internet.


The desired flexural strength of a panel is dependant upon the situation. For a pristine panel, a high flexural strength is desirable since it allows for easy transportation and handling without panel breakage. However, when the panel is scored by the tradesman (for example, with a utility knife) for fitting and installation, a low flexural strength is desirable. In that case, a low value indicates that the scored panel may be easily fractured by hand without excessive force.


Accordingly, what is needed is a new material and a new method of construction to reduce the transmission of sound from a given room to an adjacent area while simultaneously minimizing the materials required and the cost of installation labor during construction.


SUMMARY

In accordance with the present invention, a new laminar structure and associated manufacturing process are disclosed which significantly improve both the material's installation efficiency and the ability of a wall, ceiling, floor or door to reduce the transmission of sound from one architectural space (e.g. room) to an adjacent architectural space, or from the exterior to the interior of an architectural space (e.g. room), or from the interior to the exterior of an architectural space.


The material comprises a lamination of several different materials. In accordance with one embodiment, a laminar substitute for drywall comprises a sandwich of two outer layers of selected thickness gypsum board, each lacking the standard liner back paper, which are glued to each other using a sound dissipating adhesive wherein the sound dissipating adhesive is applied over all of the interior surfaces of the two outer layers. In one embodiment, the glue layer is a specially formulated QuietGlue™, which is a viscoelastic material, of a specific thickness. Formed on the interior surfaces of the two gypsum boards, the glue layer is about 1/32 inch thick. In one instance, a 4 foot×8 foot panel constructed using a 1/32 inch thick layer of glue has a total thickness of approximately ½ inches and has a scored flexural strength of 22 pounds force and an STC value of approximately 38. A double-sided wall structure constructed using single wood studs, R13 fiberglass batts in the stud cavity, and the laminated panel screwed to each side provides an STC value of approximately 49. The result is a reduction in noise transmitted through the wall structure of approximately 15 decibels compared to the same structure using common (untreated) gypsum boards of equivalent mass and thickness.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

This invention will be more fully understood in light of the following drawings taken together with the following detailed description.



FIG. 1 shows a laminar structure fabricated in accordance with this invention for reducing the transmission of sound through the material while providing superior fracture characteristics.



FIG. 2 shows a second embodiment of a laminated structure containing five (5) layers of material capable of significantly reducing the transmission of sound through the material while providing superior fracture characteristics.



FIG. 3 shows flexural strength results for one sample embodiment of a laminar material constructed in accordance with the present invention.



FIG. 4 shows flexural strength results for several examples of drywall materials including typical drywall, laminated panels in current use, and the present invention.



FIG. 5 shows a wall structure wherein one element of the structure comprises a laminar panel constructed in accordance with the present invention.



FIG. 6 graphically shows detailed results data of sound attenuation tests for an example embodiment of this invention and a typical wall of similar weight and physical dimensions.





DESCRIPTION OF SOME EMBODIMENTS

The following detailed description is meant to be exemplary only and not limiting. Other embodiments of this invention, such as the number, type, thickness, dimensions, area, shape, and placement order of both external and internal layer materials, will be obvious to those skilled in the art in view of this description.


The process for creating laminar panels in accordance with the present invention takes into account many factors: exact chemical composition of the glue; glue application process; pressing process; and drying and dehumidification process.



FIG. 1 shows the laminar structure of one embodiment of this invention. In FIG. 1, the layers in the structure will be described from top to bottom with the structure oriented horizontally as shown. It should be understood, however, that the laminar structure of this invention will be oriented vertically when placed on vertical walls, doors or other vertical partitions, as well as horizontally or even at an angle when placed on ceilings and floors. Therefore, the reference to top and bottom layers is to be understood to refer only to these layers as oriented in FIG. 1 and not in the context of the vertical use of this structure. In FIG. 1, the assembly numerated as 100 refers to an entire laminated panel constructed in accordance with this invention. A top layer 101 is made up of a paper or fiberglass-faced gypsum material and in one embodiment is ¼ inch thick. In one embodiment sixty (60) pound paper eighteen (18) mils thick is used. The resulting panel is ¼ inch plus eighteen (18) mils thick. Of course, many other combinations and thicknesses can be used for any of the layers as desired. The thicknesses are limited only by the acoustical attenuation (i.e., STC rating) desired for the resulting laminar structure and by the weight of the resulting structure which will limit the ability of workers to install the laminated panel on walls, ceilings, floors and doors for its intended use.


The gypsum board in top layer 101 typically is fabricated using standard well-known techniques and thus the method for fabricating the gypsum board will not be described. Next, the bottom face of gypsum layer 101 is an unfaced (without paper or fiberglass liner) interior surface 104. In other embodiments, surface 104 may be faced with a thin film or veil with a very low tensile strength. In one, embodiment this thin film or veil can be a single use healthcare fabric as described more completely below in paragraph 21. Applied to surface 104 is a layer of glue 102 called “QuietGlue™. Glue 102, made of a viscoelastic polymer, has the property that the kinetic energy in the sound which interacts with the glue, when constrained by surrounding layers, will be significantly dissipated by the glue thereby reducing the sound's total energy across a broad frequency spectrum, and thus the sound energy which will transmit through the resulting laminar structure. Typically, this glue 102 is made of the materials as set forth in TABLE 1, although other glues having similar characteristics to those set forth directly below TABLE 1 can also be used in this invention.









TABLE 1







Fire-Enhanced (FE) Quiet Glue ™ Chemical Makeup









WEIGHT %












COMPONENTS
Min
Max
Preferred
















acrylate polymer
30
70
41



ethyl acrylate,
0
3.0
0.3



methacrylic acid,



polymer with ethyl-2-



propenoate



hydrophobic silica
0
1.0
0.2



paraffin oil
0
3.0
1.5



silicon dioxide
0
1.0
0.1



sodium carbonate
0
3.0
0.6



stearic acid, aluminum
0
1.0
0.1



salt



surfactant
0
2.0
0.6



rosin ester
0
20
7



Zinc Borate
0
25
12



Melamine Phosphate
0
10
6



Ammonium
0
10
6



Polyphosphate



Hexahydroxy methyl
0
5.0
1.5



ethane



CI Pigment Red
0
1.0
0.02



Dispersion



water
10
40
23



2-Pyridinethiol, 1-
0
3.0
1



oxide, sodium salt











The preferred formulation is but one example of a viscoelastic glue. Other formulations may be used to achieve similar results and the range given is an example of successful formulations investigated here.


The physical solid-state characteristics of QuietGlue™ include:

    • 1) a broad glass transition temperature below room temperature;
    • 2) mechanical response typical of a rubber (i.e., elongation at break, low elastic modulus);
    • 3) strong peel strength at room temperature;
    • 4) weak shear strength at room temperature;
    • 6) does not dissolve in water (swells poorly); and
    • 7) peels off the substrate easily at temperature of dry ice.


      QuietGlu™ may be obtained from Serious Materials, 1259 Elko Drive, Sunnyvale, Calif. 94089. As mentioned above, other formulations of a viscoelastic glue may be used.


Gypsum board layer 103 is placed on the bottom of the structure and carefully pressed in a controlled manner with respect to uniform pressure (pounds per square inch), temperature and time. The top face of gypsum layer 103 is an unfaced (without paper or fiberglass liner) interior surface 105. In other embodiments, surface 105 may be faced with a thin film or veil with a very low tensile strength. The maximum very low tensile strength for the thin film or veil is approximately six (6) psi but the preferred very low tensile strength for this material is as low as approximately one (1) psi. In one embodiment this thin film can be a fabric such as a single use healthcare fabric as described more completely in paragraph 21. Such fabrics are typically used for surgical drapes and gowns.


Finally, the assembly is subjected to dehumidification and drying to allow the panels to dry, typically for forty-eight (48) hours.


In one embodiment of this invention, the glue 102, when spread over the bottom of top layer 101, is subject to a gas flow for about forty-five seconds to partially dry the glue. The gas can be heated, in which case the flow time may be reduced. The glue 102, when originally spread out over any material to which it is being applied, is liquid. By partially drying out the glue 102, either by air drying for a selected time or by providing a gas flow over the surface of the glue, the glue 102 becomes a pressure sensitive adhesive, much like the glue on a tape. The second panel, for example the bottom layer 103, is then placed over the glue 102 and pressed against the material beneath the glue 102 (as in the example of FIG. 1, top layer 101) for a selected time at a selected pressure. The gas flowing over the glue 102 can be, for example, air or dry nitrogen. The gas dehumidifies the glue 102, improving manufacturing throughput compared to the pressing process described previously wherein the glue 102 is not dried for an appreciable time prior to placing layer 103 in place.


In FIG. 2, two external layers of gypsum board 201 and 203 have on their interior faces unfaced surfaces 206 and 207, respectively. Attached to these are glue layers 204 and 205 respectively. Between the two glue layers 204 and 205 is a constraining layer 202 made up of polyester, non-woven fiber, or another low tensile strength material suitable for the application. The tensile strength of this constraining layer can be a maximum of approximately ten (10) psi but preferably is from approximately one (1) to three (3) psi.


Examples of materials for the constraining layer 202 include polyester non-wovens, fiberglass non-woven sheets, cellulosic nonwovens, or similar products. The tensile strength of these materials varies with the length of the constituent fibers and the strength of the fiber/binder bond. Those with shorter fibers and weaker bond strengths have lower tensile strengths. A good example of such materials are the plastic-coated cellulosic nonwoven materials commonly used as single use healthcare fabrics, known for their poor tensile strengths. Single use healthcare fabrics are available from the 3M Corporation of St. Paul, Minn., DuPont of Wilmington, Del. and Ahlstrom of Helsinki, Finland. The preferred maximum very low tensile strength for these materials is approximately six (6) psi but the preferred very low tensile strength for these materials is approximately one (1) psi. The weight of these materials can vary from a high of approximately four (4) ounces per square yard down to a preferred weight of approximately eight tenths (0.8) of an ounce per square yard. Alternate materials can be of any type and any appropriate thickness with the condition that they have acceptably low tensile strength properties. In the example of FIG. 2, the constraining material 202 approximate covers the same area as the glue 204 and 205 to which it is applied.



FIG. 3 shows flexural strength test results for an embodiment wherein the interior surfaces (104 and 105) the gypsum sheets 101, 103 do not have an additional facing material such as paper. The sample tested was constructed consistent with FIG. 1, and had dimensions of 0.3 m by 0.41 m (12 inches by 16 inches) and a total thickness of 13 mm (0.5 inch). A three point bending load was applied to the sample according to ASTM test method C 473, bending test method B. The measured flexural strength was 22 pounds force.


The flexural strength value of the finished laminate 100 significantly decreases with the elimination of the paper facings at surfaces 104 and 105. FIG. 4 illustrates the relationship of two laminate embodiments and typical gypsum wallboard materials. As seen in FIG. 4, the currently available laminated panels G1 to G4 (QuietRock® 510) have an average flexural strength of 85 pounds force when scored. QuietRock® may be obtained from Serious Materials, 1259 Elko Drive, Sunnyvale, Calif. 94089.


In comparison, scored typical prior art gypsum sheets (F1 to F4 and E1 to E4) with interior paper faced surfaces, have an average flexural strength of 15 pounds force for ½ inch thick and 46 pounds force for ⅝ inch thick respectively. These prior art laminated panels can be scored and fractured in the standard manner used in construction but lack the acoustic properties of the structures described herein. The other prior art structures shown in FIG. 4 (A1-A4 to D1-D4 and G1-G4) have an average peak load at fracture above fifty pounds force and thus are unacceptable materials for traditional fracture methods during installation. Of these prior art materials, QuietRock® (G1-G4) has improved sound attenuation properties but can not be scored and fractured using traditional scoring and breaking methods. The present invention (represented by H1 to H4) has a scored flexural strength of 22 pounds force as shown in FIGS. 3 and 4 and thus can be scored and fractured in the standard manner used in construction while at the same time providing an enhanced acoustical attenuation of sound compared to the prior art structures (except QuietRock®).



FIG. 5 is an example of a wall structure comprising a laminated panel 508 constructed in accordance with the present invention (i.e., laminate 100 as shown in FIG. 1); wood studs 502, 504, and 506; batt-type insulation 512; and a ⅝ inch sheet of standard gypsum drywall 510, with their relationship shown in Section A-A. FIG. 6 shows the results of sound testing for a structure as in FIG. 5, wherein the panel 508 is constructed as shown in FIG. 1. Sound attenuation value (STC number) of the structure is an STC of 49. It is known to those practicing in this field that a similar configuration with standard ⅝ inch drywall on both sides of standard 2×4 construction yields an STC of approximately 34. Accordingly, this invention yields a 15 STC point improvement over standard drywall in this particular construction.


In fabricating the structure of FIG. 1, the glue 104 is first applied in a prescribed manner in a selected pattern, typically to 1/32 inch thickness, although other thicknesses can be used if desired, onto the top layer 101. The bottom layer 103 is placed over the top layer 101. Depending on the drying and dehumidification techniques deployed, anywhere from five minutes to thirty hours are required to totally dry the glue in the case that the glue is water-based. A solvent-based viscoelastic glue can be substituted for the water-based glue. The solvent-based glue requires a drying time of about five (5) minutes in air at room temperature.


In fabricating the structure of FIG. 2, the method is similar to that described for the structure of FIG. 1. However, before the bottom layer 203 is applied (bottom layer 203 corresponds to bottom layer 103 in FIG. 1) the constraining material 202 is placed over the glue 204. A second layer of glue 205 is applied to the surface of the constraining material 202 on the side of the constraining material 202 that is facing away from the top layer 201. In one embodiment the glue layer 205 is applied to the interior side of bottom layer 203 instead of being applied to layer 202. The bottom layer 203 is placed over the stack of layers 201, 204, 202 and 205. The resulting structure is dried in a prescribed manner under a pressure of approximately two to five pounds per square inch, depending on the exact requirements of each assembly, although other pressures may be used as desired.


Accordingly, the laminated structures of this invention provide a significant improvement in the sound transmission class number associated with the structures and thus reduce significantly the sound transmitted from one room to adjacent rooms while simultaneously providing for traditional scoring and hand fracture during installation.


The dimensions given for each material in the laminated structures of this invention can be varied as desired to control cost, overall thickness, weight, anticipated moisture and temperature control requirements, and STC results. The described embodiments and their dimensions are illustrative only and not limiting. Other materials than gypsum can be used for one or both of the external layers of the laminated structures shown in FIGS. 1 and 2. For example, the layer 103 of the laminated structure 100 shown in FIG. 1 and the layer 203 of the laminated structure 200 shown in FIG. 2 can be formed of cement or of a cement-based material in a well known manner. The cement-based material can include calcium silicate, magnesium oxide and/or phosphate or combinations thereof.


Other embodiments of this invention will be obvious in view of the above description.

Claims
  • 1. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the gypsum board is unclad;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda cement-based board over said viscoelastic glue, said cement-based board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an outer surface and the second of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an inner surface; whereina scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, paper-clad surface of the gypsum board has been scored.
  • 2. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure of claim 1, wherein the cement-based board comprises a calcium silicate board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 3. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 1, wherein the cement-based board comprises a magnesium oxide-based board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 4. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 1, wherein the cement-based board comprises a phosphate-based cement board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 5. The structure of claim 1 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 6. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low tensile nonwoven-clad surface, having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda cement-based board over said viscoelastic glue, said cement-based board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an outer surface and the second of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an inner surface; whereinsaid structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 7. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 6, wherein the cement-based board comprises a calcium silicate board.
  • 8. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 6, wherein the cement-based board comprises a magnesium oxide-based board.
  • 9. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 6, wherein the cement-based board comprises a phosphate-based cement board.
  • 10. The structure of claim 6 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 11. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the first gypsum board is unclad;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda cement-based board over said viscoelastic glue, said cement-based board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an outer surface and the second of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an inner surface; whereina scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface of the gypsum board has been scored.
  • 12. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 11, wherein the cement-based board comprises a calcium silicate board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 13. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 11, wherein the cement-based board comprises a magnesium oxide-based board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 14. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 11, wherein the cement-based board comprises a phosphate-based cement board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 15. The structure of claim 11 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 16. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low tensile nonwoven-clad surface, having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda cement-based board over said viscoelastic glue, said cement-based board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an outer surface and the second of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an inner surface;wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 17. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 16, wherein the cement-based board comprises a calcium silicate board.
  • 18. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 16, wherein the cement-based board comprises a magnesium oxide-based board.
  • 19. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure as in claim 16, wherein the cement-based board comprises a phosphate-based cement board.
  • 20. The structure of claim 16 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 21. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the first gypsum board is unclad;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the second gypsum board is unclad;a scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, paper-clad surface of one of the first and second gypsum boards has been scored.
  • 22. The structure of claim 1 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 23. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the first gypsum board is unclad;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the second gypsum board is unclad; whereina scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, clad surface of one of the first and second gypsum boards has been scored.
  • 24. The structure of claim 23 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 25. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface, having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface; whereinsaid structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 26. The structure of claim 25 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 27. A laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface, having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch;a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; anda second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface;wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 28. The structure of claim 27 wherein the viscoelastic glue is a fire enhanced glue comprising up to 25% of a zinc borate compound by weight.
  • 29. A method of forming a laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: forming a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the first gypsum board is unclad;placing a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; andplacing a second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the second gypsum board is unclad;wherein a scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, clad surface of one of the first and second gypsum boards has been scored.
  • 30. A method of forming a laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: forming a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch or less;placing a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; andplacing a second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface.
  • 31. A method of forming a laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: forming a first gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, fiberglass nonwoven-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface having a tensile strength of approximately one pound per square inch or less;placing a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; andplacing a second gypsum board over said viscoelastic glue, said second gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces of said second gypsum board comprising an inner, low-tensile nonwoven clad surface;wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 32. A method of forming a laminated, sound-attenuating structure which comprises: forming a gypsum board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces comprising an outer, paper-clad surface and the second of said two surfaces comprising an inner surface, wherein the entire inner surface of the gypsum board is unclad;placing a layer of viscoelastic glue on the second of said two surfaces; andplacing a cement-based board over said viscoelastic glue, said cement-based board having two surfaces, the first of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an outer surface and the second of said two surfaces of said cement-based board comprising an inner surface; whereina scored flexural strength of the laminated structure is about 22 pounds per ½ inch thickness of the structure;the scored flexural strength being the flexural strength of the laminated structure after the outer, paper-clad surface of the gypsum board has been scored.
  • 33. The method of forming the laminated, sound-attenuating structure of claim 32, wherein the cement-based board comprises a calcium silicate board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 34. The method of forming the laminated, sound-attenuating structure of claim 32, wherein the cement-based board comprises a magnesium oxide-based board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
  • 35. The method of forming the laminated, sound-attenuating structure of claim 32, wherein the cement-based board comprises a phosphate-based cement board; and wherein said structure is appropriate for use in walls, ceilings, floors or other building partitions to attenuate sound.
US Referenced Citations (152)
Number Name Date Kind
2811906 Chappell Nov 1957 A
3092250 Knutson et al. Jun 1963 A
3106503 Randall et al. Oct 1963 A
3160549 Caldwell et al. Dec 1964 A
3215225 Kirschner Nov 1965 A
3336710 Raynes Aug 1967 A
3399104 Ball, III et al. Aug 1968 A
3424270 Hartman et al. Jan 1969 A
3462899 Sherman Aug 1969 A
3468750 Pfeifer et al. Sep 1969 A
3513009 Austin et al. May 1970 A
3579941 Tibbals May 1971 A
3642511 Cohn et al. Feb 1972 A
3728209 Sugaike et al. Apr 1973 A
3828504 Egerborg et al. Aug 1974 A
3879248 Kest Apr 1975 A
3960580 Stierli et al. Jun 1976 A
4003752 Osohata et al. Jan 1977 A
RE29157 Petersen et al. Mar 1977 E
4112176 Bailey Sep 1978 A
4117197 Krejci et al. Sep 1978 A
4134956 Suzuki et al. Jan 1979 A
4156615 Cukier et al. May 1979 A
4174229 Boberski et al. Nov 1979 A
4311767 Kennedy Jan 1982 A
4347912 Flocke et al. Sep 1982 A
4364017 Tokunaga et al. Dec 1982 A
4375516 Barrall Mar 1983 A
4487793 Haines et al. Dec 1984 A
4488619 O'Neill Dec 1984 A
4557970 Holtrop et al. Dec 1985 A
4618370 Green et al. Oct 1986 A
4642951 Mortimer Feb 1987 A
4663224 Tabata et al. May 1987 A
4678515 Green et al. Jul 1987 A
4685259 Eberhart et al. Aug 1987 A
4759164 Abendroth et al. Jul 1988 A
4778028 Staley Oct 1988 A
4786543 Ferm Nov 1988 A
4924969 K'Heureux May 1990 A
4956321 Barrall Sep 1990 A
4967530 Clunn Nov 1990 A
5016413 Counihan May 1991 A
5026593 O'Brien Jun 1991 A
5033247 Clunn Jul 1991 A
5063098 Niwa et al. Nov 1991 A
5110660 Wolf et al. May 1992 A
5125475 Duchame et al. Jun 1992 A
5158612 Savoly et al. Oct 1992 A
5183863 Nakamura et al. Feb 1993 A
5240639 Diez et al. Aug 1993 A
5256223 Alberts et al. Oct 1993 A
5258585 Juriga Nov 1993 A
5304415 Kurihara et al. Apr 1994 A
5334806 Avery Aug 1994 A
5342465 Bronowicki et al. Aug 1994 A
5368914 Barrett Nov 1994 A
5439735 Jamison Aug 1995 A
5473122 Kodiyalam et al. Dec 1995 A
5474840 Landin Dec 1995 A
5502931 Munir Apr 1996 A
5535920 Blair, Jr. et al. Jul 1996 A
5585178 Calhoun et al. Dec 1996 A
5601888 Fowler Feb 1997 A
5603192 Dickson Feb 1997 A
5629503 Thomasen May 1997 A
5643666 Eckart et al. Jul 1997 A
5644880 Lehnert et al. Jul 1997 A
5664397 Holz Sep 1997 A
5674338 Parker et al. Oct 1997 A
5691037 McCutcheon et al. Nov 1997 A
5695867 Saitoh et al. Dec 1997 A
5768841 Swartz et al. Jun 1998 A
5824973 Haines et al. Oct 1998 A
5867957 Holtrop Feb 1999 A
5910082 Bender et al. Jun 1999 A
5918437 Dobija Jul 1999 A
5945208 Richards et al. Aug 1999 A
5945643 Casser Aug 1999 A
5954497 Cloud et al. Sep 1999 A
6077613 Gaffigan Jun 2000 A
6123171 McNett et al. Sep 2000 A
6133172 Sevenish et al. Oct 2000 A
6213252 Ducharme Apr 2001 B1
6238594 Turpin et al. May 2001 B1
6240704 Porter Jun 2001 B1
6266427 Mathur Jul 2001 B1
6286280 Fahmy et al. Sep 2001 B1
6290021 Strandgaard Sep 2001 B1
6309985 Virnelson et al. Oct 2001 B1
6342284 Yu Jan 2002 B1
6381196 Hein et al. Apr 2002 B1
6389771 Moller May 2002 B1
6391958 Luongo May 2002 B1
6443256 Baig Sep 2002 B1
6443257 Wiker et al. Sep 2002 B1
6632550 Yu Oct 2003 B1
6672426 Kakimoto et al. Jan 2004 B2
6676744 Merkley et al. Jan 2004 B2
6699426 Burke Mar 2004 B1
6715241 Gelin et al. Apr 2004 B2
6747074 Buckingham et al. Jun 2004 B1
6758305 Gelin et al. Jul 2004 B2
6790520 Todd et al. Sep 2004 B1
6800161 Takigawa Oct 2004 B2
6803110 Drees et al. Oct 2004 B2
6815049 Veeramasuneni Nov 2004 B2
6822033 Yu Nov 2004 B2
6825137 Fu et al. Nov 2004 B2
6877585 Tinianov Apr 2005 B2
6913667 Nudo et al. Jul 2005 B2
6920723 Downey Jul 2005 B2
6941720 Deford et al. Sep 2005 B2
7041377 Miura et al. May 2006 B2
7068033 Sellers et al. Jun 2006 B2
7181891 Surace et al. Feb 2007 B2
7197855 Della Pepa Apr 2007 B2
7254894 Halpert Aug 2007 B1
7255907 Feigin et al. Aug 2007 B2
7486543 Kang et al. Feb 2009 B2
7745005 Tinianov Jun 2010 B2
7883763 Tinianov Feb 2011 B2
20020009622 Goodson Jan 2002 A1
20030006090 Reed Jan 2003 A1
20030018826 Chaudhry et al. Jan 2003 A1
20030070367 Gelin et al. Apr 2003 A1
20040005484 Veeramasuneni et al. Jan 2004 A1
20040016184 Huebsch et al. Jan 2004 A1
20040168853 Gunasekera et al. Sep 2004 A1
20040213973 Hara et al. Oct 2004 A1
20040214008 Dobrusky et al. Oct 2004 A1
20050050846 Surace et al. Mar 2005 A1
20050080193 Wouters et al. Apr 2005 A1
20050103568 Sapoval et al. May 2005 A1
20050130541 Shah Jun 2005 A1
20050136276 Borup et al. Jun 2005 A1
20050263925 Heseltine et al. Dec 2005 A1
20060048682 Wagh et al. Mar 2006 A1
20060057345 Surace et al. Mar 2006 A1
20060059806 Gosling et al. Mar 2006 A1
20060108175 Surace et al. May 2006 A1
20070094950 Surace et al. May 2007 A1
20070102237 Baig May 2007 A1
20070107350 Surace et al. May 2007 A1
20070175173 Babineau et al. Aug 2007 A1
20080264721 Tinianov Oct 2008 A1
20090000866 Tinianov Jan 2009 A1
20090107059 Kipp et al. Apr 2009 A1
20090239429 Kipp et al. Sep 2009 A1
20090280356 Tinianov et al. Nov 2009 A1
20100047461 Colbert Feb 2010 A1
20100116405 Kipp et al. May 2010 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (17)
Number Date Country
2219785 Oct 1996 CA
1894474 Jan 2007 CN
1154087 Nov 2001 EP
1485551 Oct 2005 EP
2267844 Dec 2010 EP
61-277741 Dec 1986 JP
63-060747 Mar 1988 JP
09-203153 Aug 1997 JP
10-46701 Feb 1998 JP
2002-266451 Sep 2002 JP
2003-221496 Aug 2003 JP
2004-042557 Feb 2004 JP
9321402 Oct 1993 WO
WO 9634261 Oct 1996 WO
WO 9719033 May 1997 WO
WO 0024690 May 2000 WO
0050707 Aug 2000 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (61)
Entry
CertainTeed, “QuietRock 510 Installation Instructions”, Jul. 2010, (date accessed Aug. 13, 2014), https://www.certainteed.com/resources/CTG—2823—QR510—Installation—E.pdf.
Notification of Transmittal of the International Search Report in corresponding International Application No. PCT/US08/59540 dated Aug. 15, 2008 (1 page).
International Search Report in corresponding International Application No. PCT/US08/59540 dated Aug. 15, 2008 (2 pages).
Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority in corresponding International Application No. PCT/US08/59540 dated Aug. 15, 2008 (9 pages).
Noise and Vibration Control Engineering: Principles and Applications, Edited by Leo Beranek and Instvan Ver, Chapter 11, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1002, (12 pages).
Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Edited by Cyril Harris, Chapter 32; Structureborne Sound Isolation, Chapter 33; Noise Control in Buildings, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1991, (36 pages).
“Green Glue is your soundproofing solution and noise reduction material”, www.greengluecompany.com (2 pages)
Acoustical: A Sound Approach to Testing, www.archest.com/pages (2 pages).
STC—Sound Transmission Class—Discussion and Use, www.sota.ca/stc—info.htm (3 pages).
ASTM International, Designation: C 1396/C 1396M-04, Standard Specification for Gypsum Board (7 pages).
Barbara C. Lippiatt, National Institute of Standards and Technology. BEES 3.0, “Building for Environmental and Economic Sustainability Technical Manual and User Guide”, Oct. 2002, (198 pages).
Takada, et al., Effect in Reducing Floor Impact Noise of Recycled Paper Damper Members, Bulletin of Tokyo Metropolitan Industrial Technology Research Institute, No. 2 (1999) [certified English translation] (13 pages).
Architectural Acoustics, M. David Egan, J. Ross Publishing (Reprint 2007) p. 211; originally published McGraw-Hill, 1988 (5 pages).
Hastings, Mardi C.; Godfrey, Richard; Babcock, G. Madison, Application of Small Panel Damping Measurements to Larger Walls, Proc. SPIE vol. 2720, p. 70-76, Smart Structures and Materials 1996: Passive Damping and Isolation (7 pages).
Van Vuure, A.W.; Verpoest, I., Ko, F.K., Sandwich-Fabric Panels as Spacers in a Constrained Layer Structural Damping Application, Composites Part B 32 (2001) 11-19, Elsevier Science Ltd. (9 pages).
Noise and Vibration Control, Revised Edition, pp. 306-315, Institute of Noise Control Engineering, 1988, Beranek, Leo L. (editor) (9 pages).
Noise and Vibration Control, Chapter Fourteen, Damping of Panels, Ungar, Eric E., pp. 434-473, McGraw-Hill, 1971, Beranek, Leo L. (editor) (7 pages).
Noise and Vibration Control Engineering, Principles and Application, pp. 466-479, John Wiley & Sons, 1992, Beranek, Leo L. and Ver, Istvan L. (editors) (9 pages).
Nashif, Ahid D.; Jones, David I. G.; Henderson, John P., Vibration Damping, pp. 290-305, John Wiley & Sons, 1985 (18 pages).
Architectural Acoustics, Principles and Practice, John Wiley & sons, 1992, Cavanaugh, William J. and Wilkes, Joseph A. (editors) (332 pages).
Fire Resistance Design Manual, Sound Control, Gypsum Association, GA-600-94 (14th Ed.) (107 pages).
Fire Resistance Design Manual, Sound Control, Gypsum Association, GA-600-97 (15th Ed.) (120 pages).
Fire Resistance Design Manual, Sound Control, Gypsum Association, GA-600-2000 (16th Ed.) (139 pages).
Noxon, Arthur M., The Chain is as Strong as Its Weakest Link, an article written for the first Hong Kong HiFi Show, 1993, Translated and Published in Chinese, http://www.acousticsciences.com/articles/chain.htm (7 pages).
Quiet Lightweight Floor Systems, Reprint from Sound and Vibration Magazine, Jul. 1992, by David A. Harris, Building & Acoustic Design Consultants (7 pages).
Joyal, Brian, Constrained-Layer Systems Provide Weight-Efficient, High Level Damping (4 pages).
Dynamat materials http://web.archive.org/web/20010525113753/www.admteschusa.com/Dynamat.html Jun. 12, 2007, ADM Tech—Dynamic Control (15 pages).
Noise Killer: Pro Damping Compound Materials http://www.tnt-audio.com/clinica/noise.html May 18, 2007, 1998 (3 pages).
Waybackmachine search results for Jan. 1, 1996-Jun. 12, 2007 (1 page).
Frankovich, David, The Four-Fold Method of Noise and Vibration Control (8 pages).
Renninger, Jennifer, Understanding Damping Techniques for Noise and Vibration Control (8 pages).
Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) Noise and Vibration Control, UFC 3-450-01. May 15, 200, Department of Defense (156 pages).
United States Gypsum, Architectural and Construction Services, Design Data for Acousticians, Feb. 1986 (4 pages).
A Study of Techniques to Increase the Sound of Insulation of Building Elements, Wyle Laboratories, Prepared for Dept. of Housing and Urban Development, Jun. 1973 (12 pages).
DB-Ply materials Sound Reducing Panels from Greenwood Forest Products, Inc., Apr. 24, 1997 (9 pages).
DB-Rock materials OMNI Products, Inc. (3 pages).
ASC WallDamp materials from Acoustic Sciences Corporation http://web.archive.org/web/20021013031149/www.asc-soundproof.com/index-walldamp . . . May 18, 2007 (21 pages).
Sounddown Viscoelastic Glue DG-A2, Soundown Corporation (2 pages).
Nordisk Akustik A/S materials, http://web.archive.org/web/200206240933724/www.nordisk-akustik.dk/html—uk/prod03.ht . . . Jun. 11, 2007 (4 pages).
IES 2000 Dampening and Visocelastic Membranes (Jul. 2, 2003) Atlanta.com/product (pp. 1-6).
Waybackmachine search results for Jan 1, 1996-May 3, 2006 (1 page).
“Damping of plate flexural vibrations by means of viscoelastic laminae” by D. Ross, E.E. Ungar, and E.M. Kerwin—Structural Damping, Section III, ASME, 1959, New York (41 pages).
Vandersall , H. L., “Intumescent Coating Systems, Their development and Chemistry” J. Fire & Flammability, vol. 2 (Apr. 1971) pp. 97-140 (45 pages).
English Language Abstract, JP Patent First Publication No. 09-203153, Aug. 5, 1997, (2 pages).
A Study of Techniques to Increase the Sound of Insulation of Building Elements, Wyle Laboratories, Prepared for Dept. of Housing and Urban Development, Jun. 1973 (16 pages).
Field Sound Insulation Evaluation of Load-Beating Sandwich Panels for Housing, Final Report, Prepared by Robert E. Jones, Forest Products Laboratory, Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Aug. 1975 (53 pages).
Sound Studio Construction on a Budget, F. Alton Evererst, McGraw-Hill, 1997 (7 pages).
Wood Handbook/Wood as an Engineering Material, United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, General Technical Report FPL-GTR-113, Mar. 1999 (24 pages).
Transmission Loss of Plasterboard Walls by T. D. Northwood, Building Research Note, Division of Building Research, National Research Counsel, Ottawa, Canada (10 pages).
A Guide to Airborne, Impact, and Structureborne Noise Control in Multifamily Dwellings, U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Prepared for the National Bureau of Standards, Washington, D. C., Jan. 1963 (5 pages).
Transmission Loss of Leaded Building Materials, Paul B. Ostergaard, Richmond L. Cardinell, and Lewis S. Goodfriend, the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 35, No. 6, Jun. 1963 (7 pages).
Dictionary of Architecture & Construction 2200 illustrations, Third Edition, Edited by Cyril M. Harris, Professor Emeritus of Architecture Columbia University, McGraw-Hill, 2000 (7 pages).
Dictionary of Engineering Materials, Harald Keller, Uwe Erb, Wiley-Interscience by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2004 (4 pages).
Chamber Science and Technology Dictionary, by Professor Peter M. B. Walker, W & R Chambers Ltd and Cambridge University Press, 1988 (3 pages).
Ross Marty, CPed, CO, “Data support use of P-Cell in diabetic footwear”, CMP Media LLC, Mar. 1, 2003.
Office Action mailed Feb. 26, 2013 in related Japanese Application No. 2010-502345.
Examination Report mailed Mar. 5, 2013 in related European Application. No. 09743797.4.
Extended European Search Report and Search Opinion mailed Jan. 30, 2013 in related European Application No. 08745548.1.
Final Office Action mailed Feb. 26, 2013 in related Japanese Application No. 2009-185945.
Office Action mailed Feb. 26, 2013 in related Japanese Appl. No. 2010-503215.
Machine translation of JP 2004-042557A by Japanese Patent Office web site.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20080245603 A1 Oct 2008 US