Patent Application
20220267841
The instant application contains a Sequence Listing which has been submitted in ASCII format via EFS-Web and is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety. Said ASCII copy, created on Dec. 8, 2016, is named TWIN-001_ST25.txt and is 11,778 bytes in size.
Duplex Sequencing enables extreme improvements in the accuracy of high throughput DNA sequencing by separately amplifying and sequencing the two strands of duplex DNA; thus, amplification and sequencing errors can be eliminated as they will typically occur on only one of the two strands. Duplex Sequencing was initially described with asymmetric (i.e., non-complementary) PCR primer binding sites introduced into Y-shaped or “loop” adapters ligated to the ends of DNA fragments. The asymmetric primer binding sites present within the adapters themselves result in separate products from the two DNA strands, which enables error correction from each of the two DNA strands. Use of asymmetric primer binding sites may not be optimal in some circumstances; for example the free ends of the Y-adapters can be prone to degradation by exonucleases, and these free ends can also anneal to other molecules, resulting in “daisy-chaining” of molecules. Moreover, Duplex Sequencing with Y-shaped adapters or “loop” adaptors are most readily applied with paired-end sequencing approaches; alternative approaches applicable to single-end sequencing would simplify broader application of Duplex Sequencing on a variety of sequencing platforms.
Accordingly, an unmet need exists for approaches to Duplex Sequencing that do not involve use of asymmetric primer binding sites.
Herein are described alternative and superior approaches to Duplex Sequencing that do not require use of asymmetric primer binding sites. Instead, asymmetry between the two strands can be introduced by creating a difference of at least one nucleotide in a DNA sequence between the two strands within an adaptor or elsewhere in the DNA molecule to be sequenced, or by differentially labeling the two strands in other ways, such as attachment of a molecule to at least one of the strands which enables physical separation of the two strands.
In a first aspect, the present invention relates to a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences for use in sequencing a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule including a first adapter nucleic acid sequence and a second adapter nucleic acid sequence, in which each adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a primer binding domain, a strand defining element (SDE), a single molecule identifier (SMI) domain, and a ligation domain. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence.
In embodiments of the first aspect, the two adapter sequences may include two separate DNA molecules that are at least partially annealed together. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be linked via a linker domain. The linker domain may be comprised of nucleotides. The linker domain may include one or more modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecules. The one or more modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecule may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. The linker domain may form a loop. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, the primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, at least one SMI domain may be an endogenous SMI, e.g., is related to a shear point (e.g., using the shear point itself, using the actual mapping position of the shear point (e.g., chromosome 3, position 1,234,567), using a defined number of nucleotides in the DNA immediately adjacent to the shear point (e.g., ten nucleotides from the shear point, eight nucleotides that start seven nucleotides away from the shear point, and six nucleotides starting after the first incidence of “C” after the shear point)). In embodiments, the SMI domain includes at least one degenerate or semi-degenerate nucleic acid. In embodiments, the SMI domain may be non-degenerate. In embodiments, the sequence of the SMI domain may be considered in conjunction with the sequence corresponding to randomly or semi-randomly sheared ends of ligated DNA to obtain an SMI sequence capable of distinguishing single DNA molecules from one another. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes a primer binding site. In embodiments, each SMI domain may be located distal to its ligation domain. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes between about 1 to about 30 degenerate or semi-degenerate nucleic acids. The ligation domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the ligation domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, each ligation domain may be capable of being ligated to one strand of a double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, one of the ligation domains includes a T-overhang, an A-overhang, a CG-overhang, a blunt end, or another ligateable nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, both ligation domains comprise a blunt end. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains includes a modified nucleic acid. The modified nucleotide may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains includes a dephosphorylated base. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains includes a dehydroxylated base. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains has been chemically modified so as to render it unligateable. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence differs by and/or may be non-complementary at at least one nucleotide from the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, at least one nucleotide may be omitted from either the SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or from the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid by an enzymatic reaction. The enzymatic reaction includes a polymerase, an endonuclease, a glycosylase, or a lyase. The at least one nucleotide may be a modified nucleotide or a nucleotide including a label. The modified nucleotide or a nucleotide including a label may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a self-complementary domain that may be capable of forming a hairpin loop. The end of first adapter nucleic acid sequence distal to its ligation domain may be ligated to the end of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence that may be distal to its ligation domain, thereby forming a loop. The loop includes a restriction enzyme recognition site. In embodiments, at least the first adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes a second SDE. The second SDE may be located at a terminus of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes a second SDE. The second SDE may be located at a terminus of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the second SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence differs by and/or may be non-complementary at at least one nucleotide from the second SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, at least one nucleotide may be omitted from either the second SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or from the second SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid by an enzymatic reaction. The enzymatic reaction includes a polymerase, an endonuclease, a glycosylase, or a lyase. The second SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the second SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be directly linked to the second SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to a first SDE. The first SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the SMI domain. The first SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 3′ to the SMI domain. The first SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the SMI domain and may be located 3′ to the primer binding domain. The first SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 3′ to the SMI domain which may be located 3′ to the primer binding domain. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the ligation domain. The 3′ terminus of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes the ligation domain. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes, from 5′ to 3′, the primer binding domain, the first SDE, the SMI domain, and the ligation domain. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes, from 5′ to 3′, the primer binding domain, the SMI domain, the first SDE, and the ligation domain. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a modified nucleotide or a non-nucleotide molecule. The modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecule may be Colicin E2, Im2, Glutithione, glutathione-s-transferase (GST), Nickel, poly-histidine, FLAG-tag, myc-tag, or biotin. The biotin may be Biotin-16-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxyuridine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallylcytidine-5′-Triphosphate, N4-Biotin-OBEA-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallyluridine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-7-Deaza-7-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxyguanosine-5′-Triphosphate, Desthiobiotin-6-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, 5′-Biotin-G-Monophosphate, 5′-Biotin-A-Monophosphate, 5′-Biotin-dG-Monophosphate, or 5′-Biotin-dA-Monophosphate. The biotin may be capable of being bound to a streptavidin attached to a substrate. In embodiments, when the biotin is bound to a streptavidin attached to a substrate, the first adapter nucleic acid sequence is capable of separating from the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes an affinity label selected from a small molecule, a nucleic acid, a peptide, and a uniquely bindeable moiety which may be capable of being bound by an affinity partner. In embodiments, when the affinity partner is attached to a solid substrate and bound to the affinity label the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the affinity label is capable of being separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the affinity label. The solid substrate may be a solid surface, a bead, or another fixed structure. The nucleic acid may be DNA, RNA, or a combination thereof, and optionally, including a peptide-nucleic acid or a locked nucleic acid. The affinity label may be located at a terminus of an adapter or within a domain in the first adapter nucleic acid sequence that may be not completely complementary to an opposing domain in the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a physical group having a magnetic property, a charge property, or an insolubility property. In embodiments, when the physical group has a magnetic property and a magnetic field is applied, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group. In embodiments, when the physical group has a charge property and an electric field is applied, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group. In embodiments, when the physical group has an insolubility property and the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences are contained in a solution for which the physical group is insoluble, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is precipitated away from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group which remains in solution. The physical group may be located at a terminus of an adapter or within a domain in the first adapter nucleic acid sequence that may be not completely complementary to an opposing domain in the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes at least one phosphorothioate bond. The double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence may be DNA or RNA. In embodiments, each adapter nucleic acid sequences includes a ligation domain at each of its termini. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially single-stranded. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be single-stranded. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be single-stranded.
In a second aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least one pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences of the first aspect and a second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences in which each strand of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences includes at least a primer binding site and a ligation domain.
The second aspect further relates to a composition including at least two pairs of adapter nucleic acid sequences the first aspect, in which the SDE of a first adapter nucleic acid sequence from a first pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences differs from the SDE of a first adapter nucleic acid sequence from at least a second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences.
The second aspect also relates to a composition including at least two pairs of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect, in which the SMI domain of a first adapter nucleic acid molecule from a first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules differs from the SMI domain of a first adapter nucleic acid molecule from an at least second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules.
In embodiments of the second aspect, the composition further includes an SMI domain in each strand of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequence. The composition may further include a primer binding site in each strand of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid molecule from the first pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules may be the same length as the SMI domain of the first single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecule from the at least second pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid molecule from the first pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules may have a different length than the SMI domain of the first single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecule from the at least second pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes one or more fixed bases at a site within or flanking the SMI. In embodiments, at least a first double-stranded complexed nucleic acid including a first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect is ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and a second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect is ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. The first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may be different from the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules. The first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules includes a first SMI domain and the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules includes a second SMI domain. In embodiments, the composition includes at least a second double-stranded complexed nucleic acid.
In a third aspect, the present invention relates to a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences for use in sequencing a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule including a first adapter nucleic acid sequence and a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In the third aspect, each adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a primer binding domain and a single molecule identifier (SMI) domain.
In embodiments of the third aspect, at least one of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes a domain including at least one modified nucleotide. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence further comprise a domain including at least one modified nucleotide. In embodiments, at least one of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes a ligation domain. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may include a ligation domain. The at least one modified nucleotide may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. The two adapter sequences may include two separate DNA molecules that are at least partially annealed together. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be linked via a linker domain. The linker domain may be comprised of nucleotides. The linker domain may include one or more modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecules. In embodiments, at least one modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecule may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. The linker domain may form a loop. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the primer binding domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, at least one SMI domain is an endogenous SMI, e.g., is related to a shear point (e.g., using the shear point itself, using the actual mapping position of the shear point (e.g., chromosome 3, position 1,234,567), using a defined number of nucleotides in the DNA immediately adjacent to the shear point (e.g., ten nucleotides from the shear point, eight nucleotides that start seven nucleotides away from the shear point, and six nucleotides starting after the first incidence of “C” after the shear point)). The SMI domain includes at least one degenerate or semi-degenerate nucleic acid. The SMI domain may be non-degenerate. The sequence of the SMI domain may be considered in conjunction with the sequence corresponding to randomly or semi-randomly sheared ends of ligated DNA to obtain an SMI sequence capable of distinguishing single DNA molecules from one another. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the SMI domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes between about 1 to about 30 degenerate or semi-degenerate nucleic acids. The ligation domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially complementary to the ligation domain of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, each ligation domain may be capable of being ligated to one strand of a double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, one of the ligation domains includes a T-overhang, an A-overhang, a CG-overhang, a blunt end, or another ligateable nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, both ligation domains comprise a blunt end. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes a primer binding site. In embodiments, at least the first adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes an SDE. The SDE may be located at a terminus of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second adapter nucleic acid sequence further includes an SDE. The SDE may be located at a terminus of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be non-complementary to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be directly linked to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence differs by and/or may be non-complementary at at least one nucleotide from the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The least one nucleotide may be omitted from either the SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or from the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid by an enzymatic reaction. The enzymatic reaction may include a polymerase or an endonuclease. The at least one nucleotide may be a modified nucleotide or a nucleotide including a label. The modified nucleotide or a nucleotide including a label may be an abasic site, a uracil, tetrahydrofuran, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A), 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G), deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole, 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine, iso-cytosine, 5′-methyl-isocytosine, or iso-guanosine. The SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may comprise a self-complementary domain that is capable of forming a hairpin loop. The end of first adapter nucleic acid sequence distal to its ligation domain may be ligated to the end of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence that is distal to its ligation domain, thereby forming a loop. The loop may include a restriction enzyme recognition site. The primer binding domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the SMI domain. The domain including at least one modified nucleotide of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the SMI domain. The domain including at least one modified nucleotide of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 3′ to the SMI domain. The domain including at least one modified nucleotide of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the SMI domain and may be located 3′ to the primer binding domain. The domain including at least one modified nucleotide of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 3′ to the SMI domain which may be located 3′ to the primer binding domain. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be located 5′ to the ligation domain. The 3′ terminus of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may include the ligation domain. In embodiments, the first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes, from 5′ to 3′, the primer binding domain, the domain including at least one modified nucleotide, the SMI domain, and the ligation domain. In embodiments, the first adapter nucleic acid sequence includes, from 5′ to 3′, the primer binding domain, the SMI domain, the domain including at least one modified nucleotide, and the ligation domain. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a modified nucleotide or a non-nucleotide molecule. The modified nucleotide or non-nucleotide molecule may be Colicin E2, Im2, Glutithione, glutathione-s-transferase (GST), Nickel, poly-histidine, FLAG-tag, myc-tag, or biotin. The biotin may be Biotin-16-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxyuridine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallylcytidine-5′-Triphosphate, N4-Biotin-OBEA-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-Aminoallyluridine-5′-Triphosphate, Biotin-16-7-Deaza-7-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxyguanosine-5′-Triphosphate, Desthiobiotin-6-Aminoallyl-2′-deoxycytidine-5′-Triphosphate, 5′-Biotin-G-Monophosphate, 5′-Biotin-A-Monophosphate, 5′-Biotin-dG-Monophosphate, or 5′-Biotin-dA-Monophosphate. The biotin may be capable of being bound to a streptavidin attached to a substrate. In embodiments, when the biotin is bound to a streptavidin attached to a substrate, the first adapter nucleic acid sequence is capable of separating from the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The second adapter nucleic acid sequence may include at least one phosphorothioate bond. The double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence may be DNA or RNA. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes an affinity label selected from a small molecule, a nucleic acid, a peptide, and a uniquely bindeable moiety which is capable of being bound by an affinity partner. In embodiments, when the affinity partner is attached to a solid substrate and bound to the affinity label the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the affinity label is capable of being separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the affinity label. The solid substrate may be a solid surface, a bead, or another fixed structure. The nucleic acid may be DNA, RNA, or a combination thereof, and optionally, including a peptide-nucleic acid or a locked nucleic acid. The affinity label may be located at a terminus of an adapter or within a domain in the first adapter nucleic acid sequence that may be not completely complementary to an opposing domain in the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, either the first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a physical group having a magnetic property, a charge property, or an insolubility property. In embodiments, when the physical group has a magnetic property and a magnetic field is applied, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group. In embodiments, when the physical group has a charge property and an electric field is applied, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is separated from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group. In embodiments, when the physical group has an insolubility property and the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences are contained in a solution for which the physical group is insoluble, the adapter nucleic acid sequence including the physical group is precipitated away from the adapter nucleic acid sequence not including the physical group which remains in solution. The physical group may be located at a terminus of an adapter or within a domain in the first adapter nucleic acid sequence that may be not completely complementary to an opposing domain in the second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially single-stranded. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence or the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be single-stranded. The first adapter nucleic acid sequence and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence may be single-stranded. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains includes a dehydroxylated base. In embodiments, at least one of the ligation domains has been chemically modified so as to render it unligateable.
In a fourth aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least two pairs of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect in which the SMI domain of a first adapter nucleic acid molecule from a first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules differs from the SMI domain of a first adapter nucleic acid molecule from an at least second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules.
In embodiments of the fourth aspect, the SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid molecule from the first pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules may be the same length as the SMI domain of the first single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecule from the at least second pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules. The SMI domain of the first adapter nucleic acid molecule from the first pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules may have a different length than the SMI domain of the first single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecule from the at least second pair of single-stranded adapter nucleic acid molecules. In embodiments, each SMI domain includes one or more fixed bases at a site within or flanking the SMI.
In a fifth aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least a first double-stranded complexed nucleic acid including a first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and a second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule.
In embodiments of the fifth aspect, the first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may be different from the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules. The first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may include a first SMI domain and the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may include a second SMI domain. The first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may include a first SMI domain and the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule of the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules includes a second SMI domain. In embodiments, the composition includes at least a second double-stranded complexed nucleic acid.
In a sixth aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least one pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect and at least one pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect.
In a seventh aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least a first double-stranded complexed nucleic acid including a first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and a second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule.
In an eighth aspect, the present invention relates to a method of sequencing a double-stranded target nucleic acid including steps of: (1) ligating a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences of the first aspect to at least one terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule, thereby forming a double-stranded nucleic acid molecule including a first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence and a second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence, (2) amplifying the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence, thereby producing a first set of amplified products including a plurality of first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequences and a plurality of its complementary molecules, (3) amplifying the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence, thereby producing a second set of amplified products including a plurality of second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequences and a plurality of its complementary molecules, in which the second set of amplified products may be distinguishable from the first set of amplified products, (4) sequencing the first set of amplified products, and (5) sequencing the second set of amplified products.
In embodiments of the eighth aspect, the at least one terminus may be two termini. The amplification may be performed by PCR, by multiple displacement amplification, or by isothermal amplification. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence has an identical structure to the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments of the eighth aspect, the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence includes in 5′ to 3′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence, (b) a first strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments of the eighth aspect, the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence may include in 3′ to 5′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence, (b) a second strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence may be different from the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence has a first SMI domain and the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence has a second SMI domain in which in which the first SMI domain may be different from the second SMI domain. In embodiments of the eighth aspect, the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence may include in 5′ to 3′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence including the first SDE, (b) a first SMI domain, (c) a first strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (d) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments of the eighth aspect, the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence may include in 5′ to 3′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence including the first SDE, (b) a second SMI domain, (c) a second strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (d) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments, the consensus sequence for the first set of amplified products may be compared to the consensus sequence for the second set of amplified products and a difference between the two consensus sequences may be considered an artifact.
In a ninth aspect, the present invention relates to a method of sequencing a double-stranded target nucleic acid including steps of: (1) ligating a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences of the third aspect to at least one terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule, thereby forming a double-stranded nucleic acid molecule including a first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence and a second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence, (2) amplifying the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule, thereby producing a first set of amplified products including a plurality of first strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecules and a plurality of its complementary molecules, (3) amplifying the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecule, thereby producing a second set of amplified products including a plurality of second strand adapter-target nucleic acid molecules and a plurality of its complementary molecules, (4) sequencing the first set of amplified products, thereby obtaining a consensus sequence for the first set of amplified products, and (5) sequencing the second set of amplified products, thereby obtaining a consensus sequence for the second set of amplified products.
In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the second set of amplified products may be distinguishable from the first set of amplified products. The amplification may be performed by PCR, by multiple displacement amplification, or by isothermal amplification. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the method further includes, after step (1), a step of contacting the double-stranded nucleic acid molecule with at least one enzyme (e.g., a glycosylase) that changes the at least one modified nucleotide to another chemical structure. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule may be identical to the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule may be different from to the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. In embodiments, a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences may be ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and a primer corresponding to a portion of the DNA sequence of the target DNA molecule may be utilized to amplify the DNA molecule. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence includes in 5′ to 3′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence which includes the at least one modified nucleotide or the at least one abasic site, (b) a first strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence includes in 3′ to 5′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence, (b) a second strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule may be different from the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. The pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule has a first SMI domain and the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid sequence has a second SMI domain, in which the first SMI domain may be different from the second SMI domain. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the first strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence includes in 5′ to 3′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence including the at least one modified nucleotide or the at least one abasic site and the first SMI domain, (b) a first strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence including the second SMI domain. In embodiments, when the at least one modified nucleotide may be 8-oxo-G, and the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a cytosine at a position corresponding to the 8-oxo-G. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, the second strand adapter-target nucleic acid sequence includes in 3′ to 5′ order: (a) a first adapter nucleic acid sequence including the first SMI domain, (b) a second strand of the double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (c) a second adapter nucleic acid sequence including the second SMI domain. In embodiments, the at least one modified nucleotide may be 8-oxo-G, the second adapter nucleic acid sequence includes a cytidine at a position corresponding to the 8-oxo-G. In embodiments, during the amplification of step (2) or step (3), the at least one abasic site may be converted upon amplification into a thymidine in the corresponding amplified product, resulting in introduction of an SDE. In embodiments of the ninth aspect, during the amplification of step (2) or step (3), the at least one modified nucleotide site encodes an adenosine in the corresponding amplified product.
In a tenth aspect, the present invention relates to a method in which distinguishable amplification products may be obtained from each of the two strands of individual DNA molecules, and the consensus sequence for the first set of amplified products may be compared to the consensus sequence for the second set of amplified products, in which a difference between the two consensus sequences can be considered an artifact.
In embodiments of the tenth aspect, the amplified products may be determined to have arisen from the same initial DNA molecule by virtue of sharing the same SMI sequence. In embodiments, the amplified products may be determined to have arisen from the same initial DNA molecule by virtue carrying distinct SMI sequences that may be known to correspond to each other based upon a database produced at the time of and in conjunction with SMI adaptor library synthesis. In embodiments, amplified products may be determined to have arisen from distinct strands of the same initial double stranded DNA sequence via at least one nucleotide of sequence difference that was introduced by an SDE.
In an eleventh aspect, the present invention relates to a method in which distinguishable amplification products may be obtained from each of the two strands of individual DNA molecules, and the sequence obtained from an amplified product corresponding to one of the two initial DNA strands of a single DNA molecule is compared to an amplified product corresponding to the second of the two initial DNA strands, and a difference between the two sequences may be considered an artifact.
In a twelfth aspect, the present invention relates to a method in which indistinguishable amplification products may be obtained from the two strands of an individual DNA molecule when the sequence obtained from an amplified product corresponding to one of the two initial DNA strands of a single DNA molecule is compared to an amplified product corresponding to the second of the two initial DNA strands and no difference between the two sequences is identified.
In embodiments of the twelfth aspect, the amplified products may be determined to have arisen from the same initial double stranded DNA molecule by virtue of sharing the same SMI sequence based upon database produced at the time of and in conjunction with SMI adaptor library synthesis. In embodiments, the amplified products may be determined to have arisen from distinct strands of the same initial double stranded DNA sequence via at least one nucleotide of sequence difference that was introduced by an SDE. In embodiments, the method further includes a step of single-molecule dilution following thermal or chemical melting of DNA duplexes into their component single-strands. The single-strands may be diluted into multiple physically-separated reaction chambers such that the probability of the two originally paired strands sharing the same container may be small. The physically-separated reaction chambers may be selected from containers, tubes, wells, and at least a pair of non-communicating droplets. In embodiments, the PCR amplification may be carried out for each physically-separated reaction chamber, preferably using primers for each chamber carrying a different tag sequence. In embodiments, each tag sequence operates as an SDE. In embodiments, a series of paired sequences corresponding to the two strands of the same initial DNA may be compared to one another, and at least one sequence from the series of products may be selected as most likely to represent the correct sequence of the initial DNA molecule. The product selected as most likely to represent the correct sequence of the initial DNA molecule may be selected at least in part due to having the smallest number of mismatches between the products obtained from the two DNA strands. The product selected as most likely to represent the correct sequence of the initial DNA molecule may be selected at least in part due to having the smallest number of mismatches relative to the reference sequence.
In a thirteenth aspect, the present invention relates to a composition including at least two pairs of adapter nucleic acid sequences, in which a first pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences includes: a primer binding domain, a strand defining element (SDE), and a ligation domain, in which a second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences includes: a primer binding domain, a single molecule identifier (SMI) domain, and a ligation domain.
In a fourteenth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded complexed nucleic acid including: (1) a first pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences including: a primer binding domain, and an SDE, and (2) a double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (3) a second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences including: a primer binding domain, and a single molecule identifier (SMI) domain, in which the first pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may be ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and the second pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may be ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. In embodiments of the fourteenth aspect, the first pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences and/or the second pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences may further include a ligation domain.
In a fifteenth aspect, the present invention relates to pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences for use in sequencing a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule, including a first adapter nucleic acid sequence and a second adapter nucleic acid sequence, in which each adapter nucleic acid sequence includes: a primer binding domain, an SDE, a ligation domain, in which the SDE of the first adapter nucleic acid sequence may be at least partially non-complementary to the SDE of the second adapter nucleic acid sequence.
In a sixteenth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded circular nucleic acid including a pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and ligated to a second a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule.
In a seventeenth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded circular nucleic acid including a pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and ligated to a second a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule.
In a eighteenth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded circular nucleic acid including a pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the first aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and an annealed pair of primer binding domains ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule, in which the annealed pair of primer binding domains may be ligated to the pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules.
In a nineteenth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded circular nucleic acid including a pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules of the third aspect ligated to a first terminus of a double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and an annealed pair of primer binding domains ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule, in which the annealed pair of primer binding domains may be ligated to the pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules.
In a twentieth aspect, the present invention relates to a double-stranded complexed nucleic acid including: (1) a pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences including: a primer binding domain, a strand defining element (SDE), and a single molecule identifier (SMI) domain, (2) a double-stranded target nucleic acid, and (3) an annealed pair primer binding domains, in which the pair of adapter nucleic acid molecules may be ligated to a first terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule and the annealed pair primer binding domains may be ligated to a second terminus of the double-stranded target nucleic acid molecule. In embodiments of the twentieth aspect, the pair of adapter nucleic acid sequences and/or the annealed pair primer binding domains further includes a ligation domain.
Duplex Sequencing is additionally described in WO2013142389A1 and in Schmitt et al, PNAS 2012, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Any of the above aspects and embodiments can be combined with any other aspect or embodiment as disclosed here in the Summary, in the Drawings, and/or in the Detailed Description, including the below specific, non-limiting, examples/embodiments of the present invention.
Other features, advantages, and modifications of the invention will be apparent from the Drawings, Detailed Description, and claims. The foregoing description is intended to illustrate and not limit the scope of the disclosure.
The above and further features will be more clearly appreciated from the following Detailed Description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
Duplex Sequencing was initially described with use of asymmetric primer binding sites for separate amplification of the two DNA strands. Herein are described alternative and superior approaches to Duplex Sequencing that do not require use of asymmetric primer binding sites. Instead, asymmetry between the two strands can be introduced by creating a difference of at least one nucleotide in DNA sequence between the two strands within an adaptor or elsewhere in the DNA molecule to be sequenced (e.g., a mismatch, an additional nucleotide, and an omitted nucleotide), replacement of at least one nucleotide with a modified nucleotide (e.g., a nucleotide lacking a base or with an atypical base), and/or inclusion of at least one labeled nucleotide (e.g., a biotinylated nucleotide) which can physically separate the two strands. Table 1 illustrates exemplary options for assembling adapters for Duplex Sequencing as disclosed in the present invention.
The herein-described adapter designs and approaches for Duplex Sequencing are not dependent upon use of Y-adapters with complementary SMI sequences.
Some designs are directly applicable to single-end sequencing. The approaches disclosed herein share two general features: (1) each single stranded half of an individual duplex DNA molecule is labeled in such a way that the sequences that ultimately derive from each of the two strands can be recognized as being related to the same DNA duplex and (2) each single strand of an individual duplex DNA molecule is labeled in such a way that the sequences that ultimately derive from each of the two strands can be recognized as being distinct from those derived from the opposite strand. The molecular features that serve these respective functions are herein entitled Single Molecule Identifier (SMI) and Strand Defining Element (SDE).
This is the first disclosed introduction of strand-defining asymmetry via different versions of an internal non-complementary “bubble” sequence. One such embodiment involves introducing a non-complementary “bubble” sequence that is not located within the amplification primer sites; distinct sequences from the two strands of the “bubble” will then result in separate labeling of the two strands.
Disclosed herein is how strand-defining asymmetry can similarly be introduced into adapted DNA molecules through use of modified DNA bases as an SDE. In examples, asymmetry is introduced by including one or more nucleotide analogs that result in a complementary sequence initially, but which can subsequently be converted to a non-complementary sequence.
Also disclosed are ways in which non-Y-shaped asymmetric adaptor designs can be applied to sequencing platforms which require a different primer sequence on opposite ends of each DNA molecule.
Herein are disclosed alternate ways in which different types of SMI tags and SDEs can be distributed among two different primer-site containing adaptors for the benefit of maximizing read-length and SMI tagging diversity.
Also disclosed herein are additional designs for Duplex Sequencing adaptors that comprise Y or loop-shaped tails which are readily amenable to paired-end sequencing, but where SMI tags are not complementary sequences, and therefore allow significant design flexibility.
Demonstrated here is how such introduction of such asymmetry enables distinguishing products from the two DNA strands for purposes of error correction by Duplex Sequencing. Moreover, demonstrated herein are descriptions of how some embodiments facilitate performing Duplex Sequencing on single-end read platforms.
Further disclosed are methods for introducing primer sites and the SMI sites and the SDE sites for Duplex Sequencing with a single adapter to form a circular adapter-DNA molecule complex.
Additionally disclosed is a wholly different approach to introduction of an SDE that relies on asymmetric chemical tagging which allows physical/mechanical separation of paired strands into distinct reaction compartments for independent analysis, rather than differential sequence-based molecular tagging of the two strands.
Disclosed herein are examples of adapter designs specifically for the Ion Torrent™ (Life Technologies®) sequencing platform.
Disclosed herein are variants of adapters that can be ligated to both single strands at each end of a duplex molecule, as well as designs that allow single-stranded ligation followed by “nick translation” that retains both the necessary SMI and SDE elements in the final prepared molecule.
Disclosed herein is how an SDE can be incorporated into a DNA molecule itself in a way that is independent of adapter ligation.
Finally, disclosed herein are streamlined alternate algorithmic approaches for Duplex Sequencing that can be used with any Duplex Adaptor design that eliminates the need for preceding Single-Stranded Consensus Sequence (SSCS) generation.
In some embodiments, a portion of a nucleotide sequence may be “degenerate”. In a degenerate sequence, each position may be any nucleotide, i.e., each position, represented by “X,” “N”, or “M”, may be an adenine (A), cytosine (C), guanine (G), thymine (T), or uracil (U) or any other natural or non-natural DNA or RNA nucleotide or nucleotide-like substance or analog with base-pairing properties (e.g., xanthosine, inosine, hypoxanthine, xanthine, 7-methylguanine, 7-methylguanosine, 5,6-dihydrouracil, 5-methylcytosine, dihydouridine, isocytosine, isoguanine, deoxynucleosides, nucleosides, peptide nucleic acids, locked nucleic acids, glycol nucleic acids and threose nucleic acids). Alternately, a portion of a nucleotide sequence may be not entirely degenerate such that the sequence includes at least one pre-defined nucleotide or at least one pre-defined polynucleotides and positions that may be any nucleotide or one or more positions that includes only a subset combination of possible nucleotides. A subset combination of possible nucleotides could include: any three of the following: A, C, G, and T; any two of the following: A, C, G, T, and U; or U plus any three of the following: A, C, G, and T. Such subset combinations could additionally include or be substituted with any other natural or non-natural DNA or RNA nucleotide or nucleotide-like substance or analog with base-pairing properties. The stoichiometric ratio between any of these nucleotides in a population of molecules could be approximately 1:1 or any other ratio; herein such a sequence is referred to as “semi-degenerate”. In certain embodiments, a “semi-degenerate” sequence refers to a set of two or more sequences, wherein the two or more sequences differ at at least one nucleotide position. In embodiments, a semi-degenerate sequence is a sequence in which not every nucleotide is random with respect to its adjacent nucleotides (immediately adjacent or within two or more nucleotides). In embodiments, the term degenerate and semi-degenerate, as used herein, may have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this application belongs and as commonly used in the art to which this application belongs; such art is incorporated by reference in its entirety.
In embodiments, the sequences need not contain all possible bases at each position. The degenerate or semi-degenerate n-mer sequences may be generated by a polymerase-mediated method, or may be generated by preparing and annealing a library of individual oligonucleotides of known sequence. Alternatively, any degenerate or semi-degenerate n-mer sequences may be a randomly or non-randomly fragmented double stranded DNA molecule from any alternative source that differs from the target DNA source. In some embodiments, the alternative source is a genome or plasmid derived from bacteria, an organism other than that of the target DNA, or a combination of such alternative organisms or sources. Random or non-random fragmented DNA may be introduced into SMI adaptors to serve as variable tags. This may be accomplished through enzymatic ligation or any other method known in the art.
As used in this Specification and the appended claims, the singular forms “a,” “an” and “the” include plural referents unless the context clearly dictates otherwise.
Unless specifically stated or obvious from context, as used herein, the term “or” is understood to be inclusive and covers both “or” and “and”.
The terms “one or more”, “at least one”, “more than one”, and the like are understood to include but not be limited to at least 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149 or 150, 200, 300, 400, 500, 600, 700, 800, 900, 1000, 2000, 3000, 4000, 5000 or more and any number in between.
Conversely, the term “no more than” includes each value less than the stated value. For example, “no more than 100 nucleotides” includes 100, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 91, 90, 89, 88, 87, 86, 85, 84, 83, 82, 81, 80, 79, 78, 77, 76, 75, 74, 73, 72, 71, 70, 69, 68, 67, 66, 65, 64, 63, 62, 61, 60, 59, 58, 57, 56, 55, 54, 53, 52, 51, 50, 49, 48, 47, 46, 45, 44, 43, 42, 41, 40, 39, 38, 37, 36, 35, 34, 33, 32, 31, 30, 29, 28, 27, 26, 25, 24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, and 0 nucleotides.
The terms “plurality”, “at least two”, “two or more”, “at least second”, and the like, are understood to include but not limited to at least 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149 or 150, 200, 300, 400, 500, 600, 700, 800, 900, 1000, 2000, 3000, 4000, 5000 or more and any number in between.
Throughout the specification the word “comprising,” or variations such as “comprises” or “comprising,” will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated element, integer or step, or group of elements, integers or steps, but not the exclusion of any other element, integer or step, or group of elements, integers or steps.
Unless specifically stated or obvious from context, as used herein, the term “about” is understood as within a range of normal tolerance in the art, for example within 2 standard deviations of the mean. About can be understood as within 10%, 9%, 8%, 7%, 6%, 5%, 4%, 3%, 2%, 1%, 0.5%, 0.1%, 0.05%, 0.01%, or 0.001% of the stated value. Unless otherwise clear from the context, all numerical values provided herein are modified by the term “about”.
Although methods and materials similar or equivalent to those described herein can be used in the practice or testing of the present invention, suitable methods and materials are described below. All publications, patent applications, patents, and other references mentioned herein are incorporated by reference in their entirety. The references cited herein are not admitted to be prior art to the claimed invention. In the case of conflict, the present Specification, including definitions, will control. In addition, the materials, methods, and examples are illustrative only and are not intended to be limiting.
Unless otherwise defined, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this application belongs and as commonly used in the art to which this application belongs; such art is incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Any of the above aspects and embodiments can be combined with any other aspect or embodiment as disclosed in the Summary, Drawings, and/or in the Detailed Description sections, including the below examples/embodiments.
Disadvantages from Using Y-Shaped Adapters for Duplex Sequencing
Duplex Sequencing with Y-shaped adapters is most readily performed with paired-end sequencing reads, as originally described (WO2013142389A1 and in Schmitt et al, PNAS 2012, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety). However not all sequencing platforms are compatible with paired end sequencing reads. When using previously-described Y- or loop-shaped adaptors where asymmetric primer sites are located in the single-stranded region opposite the adapter's ligateable end, Duplex Sequencing with single-end sequencing reads requires the sequencing read to fully extend through the DNA molecule. This is necessary to capture the SMI tag sequences at both ends of the molecule, which is required to able to distinguish sequencing reads from the two derivative strands. This requirement is illustrated as follows.
A previously-described Y-shaped Duplex Sequencing adaptor is shown in
As originally described (e.g., WO2013142389A1), SMIs are used to distinguish individual molecules within a large pool. It is necessary to have a sufficiently large population of these encoded in the adapter library such that it is statistically unlikely that any two DNA molecules will be labeled with the same SMI sequences. Also, as previously described, the fragmentation sites introduced during library generation can be function as endogenous SMIs in certain situations, either independently, or in combination with a exogenous SMIs encoded in adapter sequences. In the present disclosure, only exogenous SMI domains are shown in examples of different adapter designs; however, it is understood (and included in the present invention) that exogenous SMI domains can be substituted with, or augmented by, DNA shear points acting as endogenous SMIs.
After adaptors are ligated to each end of a double-stranded DNA fragment from a library, the structure will appear shown in
Following PCR, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand is shown in
The double stranded PCR product derived from the “bottom” strand is shown in
The differing arrangements of α and β relative to A and B in the “top” strand and “bottom” strand products should be noted. With paired end sequencing reads (i.e., reading from both primer site A and B for each PCR product), it is possible to distinguish products derived from each strand because the α tag appears in the A read and β in the B read of one strand and the reciprocal case occurs in the other strand. See,
Use of paired-end reads, as described above, makes Duplex Sequence correction possible. However, with use of only single-end sequencing reads (i.e., only reading from primer site A or primer site B but not from both for a particular molecule), it is only possible to obtain Duplex Sequences if the sequencing reads are sufficiently long to capture the SMI sequences at both ends. If using sequencing primer A, full length sequencing reads (i.e., long enough to include both SMI sequences) derived from the different strands will yield the two sequences shown in
To illustrate this, the two types of sequences produced when using a non-full length single ended sequencing reads from primer A are shown in
The need for “read-through” of the full DNA molecule when using single-end sequencing can create technical challenges on some sequencing platforms where read-length is limited.
For Duplex Sequencing to be compatible with sub-full length sequencing reads with single-end sequencing, alternative adapter designs are necessary. In the absence of paired end sequencing reads and asymmetric primer sites on Y-shaped adapters, some other form of asymmetry must be introduced into adapted DNA molecules to be able to distinguish the strands. Examples of such design are disclosed below.
Introduction of Strand-Defining Asymmetry with a Non-Complementary “Bubble”
Disclosed in
Following ligation of adapters similar to those shown in
After PCR amplification, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand is shown in
Because the primer site sequence is the same at both ends of the molecule in this example, two different types of sequence sequencing reads will be obtained from single-ended sequencing reads of the PCR product of each strand depending on which single-stranded half happens to be sequenced. The read derived from the “top” strand PCR product is shown in
For analysis, as shown in
A similar outcome can be achieved by switching the order of the SMI and SDE sequences. One example of such an adapter is shown in
As articulated above and in WO2013142389A, in some embodiments, SMIs contained within the adapter sequences can be omitted in lieu of endogenous SMI sequences comprising the shear point sequences of the DNA molecule itself. The structure of one such adapter design would entail that shown
In some applications, the orientation shown in
In other applications, the orientation shown in
As a specific example of how this approach would be brought into practice, consider the Ion Torrent™ sequencing platform, which can use the following pair of adaptors:
Asterisks “*” represent phosphorothioate bonds.
The sequencing primer anneals to Adapter A, and thus sequence information is read out from the DNA fragment starting from the 3′ end of Adapter A. Adapter A can be converted to a form applicable for the approach diagrammed in
G 3′
C 5′
NNNN refers to a degenerate or semi-degenerate four-nucleotide sequence; MMMM refers to its complement; and a G-C base-pair is included downstream of the degenerate sequence to facilitate ligation, although other forms of ligation domains may be used.
In this illustration, adapter P1 and adapter A are both ligated to the target DNA molecule to be sequenced. For simplicity, the same adapter ligated to both ends of the DNA molecule can be ignored. However Ion Torrent™ adapters utilize a different adapter on each end of the molecule. Upon initial ligation, an individual DNA molecule may be ligated with adapters in various configurations, for example A-DNA-P1, A-DNA-A, or P1-DNA-P1. The correct configuration of A-DNA-P1 can be utilized for the sequencing reaction by virtue of being amplified in an emulsion PCR with primers directed against sites A and P1. Alternatively, other methods known in the art for selecting only molecules ligated to two different adapters can be used.
Upon amplification and sequencing, the following products will be obtained:
Note that these correspond to products X-α-DNA and Y′-α-DNA as shown in
Products from the two strands can then be matched together for data processing via Duplex Sequencing as originally described (see, e.g., WO2013142389A1). Specifically, a consensus can be made from reads which begin with the sequence GCGC NNNN to obtain the consensus of the “top” strand. A separate consensus can be made from reads beginning with the sequence TATA NNNN to obtain the consensus of the “bottom” strand. The two Single-Strand Consensus Sequences can then be compared to obtain the Duplex Consensus Sequence of the starting DNA molecule. An alternative data processing approach is disclosed below; see, “Alternative data processing scheme for Duplex Sequencing”.
The above approach enables Duplex Sequencing on platforms utilizing short reads which are not capable of paired-end reads, as in this embodiment, DNA sequence information is only needed from one of the two ends of the DNA fragment.
An alternate embodiment of this approach would be to introduce the asymmetry into the SMI sequence itself via use of a double-stranded, non-complementary or partially non-complementary SMI. While the SMI sequences themselves will not be complementary, products arising from the non-complementary SMI sequences could be determined to have arisen from the same starting double-stranded DNA molecule by virtue of having been pre-determined to form pairs.
As a specific example of this embodiment, consider a series of Ion Torrent™ “Adapter A” molecules having the following sequences:
GCAGC 3′
CGTCG 5′
GCAGC 3′
CGTCG 5′
GCAGC 3′
CGTCG 5′
GCAGC 3′
CGTCG 5′
For simplicity, only four adapters are listed above, although in practice it may be desirable to have a larger pool of such adapters. Note that, in this example, a complementary sequence is included downstream of the non-complementary sequence to form a double-stranded region that will facilitate ligation to the DNA molecule.
Individual DNA fragments are ligated to individual adapters, which results in asymmetric labeling of the two DNA strands. In particular, upon sequencing, the sequence of the “top strand” of the starting DNA molecule will be labeled with the sequence in the “top strand” of the adapter. The sequence of the “bottom strand” of the starting DNA molecule will be labeled with the reverse complement of the sequence in the “bottom strand” of the adapter.
As a particular example, the two DNA strands ligated to Adapter 1 will be labeled AAAT (top strand) and CCCG (bottom strand). Again, it should be noted that the bottom strand, upon sequencing, yields the reverse complement of the sequence initially present in the bottom strand of the adapter. Likewise, for sequences ligated to the other adapters, the molecular identifiers can be paired together by virtue of their paired tags. A computer program can then use a table of the known tag sequences from the adapters to assemble them into reads arising from complementary strands of single DNA molecules. Table 2 shows how the resultant sequence reads would be labeled based upon the specific non-complementary identifier sequences shown in the above example.
These are only specific examples of particular embodiments. It will be apparent to one skilled in the art that SMI tags can be any arbitrary length, that SMI's can be completely random, or that consist entirely of pre-defined sequences. When an SMI sequence is in both strands of a double-stranded molecule, the two SMI sequences can be fully complementary (as described in the first instance mentioned example above), partially non-complementary, or entirely non-complementary. In some embodiments no exogenous molecular identifier tag is needed at all. In some cases, the randomly sheared ends of DNA molecules as unique identifiers can be used, so long as some sort of asymmetry (comprising an SDE) is present that allows one to distinguish products as arising from the two independent strands of a given single molecule of double-stranded DNA.
In any herein-disclosed aspect or embodiment of the present invention (and not limited to the currently-described embodiment), in both single-stranded and double-stranded SMIs, the set of SMI tags can be designed with an edit distance between distinct tags such that an error in synthesizing, amplifying, or sequencing the SMI sequence will not result in conversion of one SMI sequence to another (see, e.g., Shiroguchi et al, Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, 109(4):1347-1352). Incorporating an edit distance between SMI sequences allows SMI errors to be identified and removed, for example by using Hamming distance, Hamming codes, or another method of error correction that is known in the art. All SMIs from a set can be the same length; alternatively mixtures of SMIs of two or more different lengths can be employed within a set of SMIs. Using mixtures of SMI lengths can be advantageous for adapter designs that use an SMI sequence and additionally have one or more fixed bases at a site within or flanking the SMI, as utilizing more than one length of SMI within a set will cause the invariant base(s) to not all occur at the same read position during sequencing (see, e.g., Hummelen R et al, PLoS One, 5(8):e12078 (2010)). This approach can circumvent problems that may arise on sequencer platforms that may encounter sub-optimal performance (e.g., difficulty with cluster identification) in situations where invariant bases are present at a specific read position.
It will also be apparent to one skilled in the art that sequences that introduce asymmetry can be introduced anywhere within a sequencing adapter, including, for example, as an internal “bubble” sequence as shown above, before or after an SMI sequence, or within a single-stranded “tail” sequence in adapter designs that possess such a sequence. These sequences, as well as any associated SMI sequences, can be read directly as part of a sequencing read, or alternatively can be determined from an independent sequencing reaction (for example, in an index read). These sequences can moreover be used in conjunction with Y-shaped adapters, “loop” adapters, or any other adapter design known in the art.
Indeed, adaptors having different relative orientations of SMI sequences, SDE sequences, and primer binding sites are envisioned and included in the present invention.
The adaptor designs shown in
Additionally the two strands of the adapter can be connected to form a closed “loop”, which may be desirable in some applications to prevent degradation or undesired ligation. See e.g.,
In any herein-disclosed aspect or embodiment of the present invention (and not limited to the currently-described embodiment) for adapter designs that use a double-stranded SMI sequence, whether it is complementary, partially non-complementary, or fully non-complementary, a specific advantage of synthesizing the adapter as a linear molecule that is annealed into a “loop” form is that the “top” and “bottom” strand SMI sequences will be present at a 1:1 ratio within the molecule itself. This approach may be advantageous relative to annealing individual “top” and “bottom” oligonucleotide pairs to form double stranded SMIs, as in such an approach, if the concentration of oligonucleotide used for the “top” and “bottom” strands is not in a perfect 1:1 ratio, excess molecules of one adapter strand or the other may be present, and may be problematic to downstream steps (e.g., the additional single-stranded oligonucleotides may cause inappropriate priming during PCR amplification, or may anneal with other single-stranded oligonucleotides that might be present which could create adapter molecules wherein the two SMI strands are not appropriately paired).
It may in some instances be desirable to prevent replication of the full loop sequence itself, in which a modified sequence position can optionally be included as a replication block. This can be a base that can be enzymatically removed (e.g., uracil, which can be removed by uracil DNA glycosylase), or for example, a region which partially or fully inhibits DNA replication (e.g., an abasic site).
Alternatively or additionally, a restriction endonuclease site may be introduced (marked at position “T” in
It is should be readily apparent that different arrangements of base asymmetry between the two adapter strands equally serve as a strand-defining element. A bubble can be formed in an adapter strand when there is insertion of one nucleotide or more than one nucleotide relative to the otherwise complementary strand is shown in the adapter of
The adapter designs shown in
In this design, P and P′, respectively, represent a primer site and its complement and αi and αii represent two degenerate or semi-degenerate sequences which are non-complementary for all or a portion of their length. The synthesis of this form of adapter is most readily accomplished by individually synthesizing and hybridizing pairs of oligonucleotides with different degenerate or semi-degenerate sequences prior to pooling two or more of these together to form a diverse pool. Because the oligonucleotides are individually synthesized and annealed, the relationship between a given αi and αii sequence will be known and recorded in a database that can be searched for corresponding partner SMI sequences during post-sequencing analysis.
Following adaptor ligation to a double-stranded DNA fragment, the structure shown in
After PCR amplification, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand is shown in
Because the primer site sequence is the same at both ends of the molecule (in this example), two different types of sequence reads will be obtained from single-ended sequencing reads of the PCR product of each strand and depending on which single-strand happens to be sequenced. The single-ended sequencing read from the “top” strand PCR product is shown in
During analysis reads can then be grouped by specific SMI sequences and their corresponding non-complementary partner based on a relationship known from a database produced at the time of and in conjunction with SMI adaptor library synthesis. As shown in
Another way strand asymmetry can be introduced into a Duplex Sequencing adaptor is by a nucleotide or nucleotide analog which initially forms a paired strand DNA, but then results in a mismatch following a further biochemical step. One example of this is a DNA polymerase mis-incorporation. The mis-incorporation can occur during amplification, either inherently, or after conversion to a mismatched region via a chemical or enzymatic step.
For some applications, this form of SDE may be preferable to the “bubble type” sequences, disclosed above, since they avoid problems that may arise from free single-stranded regions, e.g., mis-annealing to other DNA oligonucleotides and exonuclease/endonuclease degradation.
Many non-standard nucleotides known in the art can serve this purpose. Non-limiting examples of such modified nucleotides include tetrahydrofuran; 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A); 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-G); deoxyinosine, 5′-nitroindole; 5-Hydroxymethyl-2′-deoxycytidine; iso-cytosine; 5′-methyl-isocytosine; and iso-guanosine, and others known in the art.
An 8-oxo-G-containing Duplex Sequencing adapter is shown in
Following adaptor ligation to a double-stranded DNA fragment, the structure shown in
Treatment of double-stranded DNA of
During PCR or other forms of DNA amplification, under certain conditions with particular polymerases, adenine will be preferentially inserted opposite the abasic when the strand is copied. With subsequent rounds of copying this adenine will be paired to a thymine, ultimately leading to replacement of the original 8-oxo-G site with a T. Moreover, treatment with a glycosylase is not mandatory. Under appropriate reaction conditions, polymerases can insert A opposite 8-oxo-G without the shown abasic intermediate (Sikorsky J A et al Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2007). In either case, after PCR amplification, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
Because the primer site sequence is the same at both ends of the molecule in this (non-limiting) example, two different types of sequence reads will be obtained from single-ended sequencing reads of the PCR product of each strand depending on which single-strand happens to be sequenced. Those PCR products derived from the “top” strand PCR product will be as shown in
During analysis, sequencing reads can be grouped by those containing a particular SMI, in this case α or β. See,
It will also be apparent to one skilled in the art that a modified nucleotide or another analog, as described above, may be placed anywhere within a sequencing adapter, so long as the sequence obtained from the modified nucleotide or the other analog can be recovered at the time of DNA sequencing.
It will be apparent to one skilled in the art that many other nucleotide analogs can be utilized to fulfill the same purpose. Other examples include tetrahydrofuran and 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2′-deoxyadenosine (8-oxo-A). Any nucleotide modification which can inherently result in mis-incorporation of a different nucleotide by a DNA polymerase or which can be converted into a mis-coding lesion or a mismatched base by an enzymatic or chemical step or spontaneously with time can be used in adapters of this embodiment.
Moreover, a non-nucleotide molecule can be incorporated to asymmetrically label the two strands. For example, biotin can be incorporated into one of the two adapter strands, which would facilitate separate analysis of the two strands by utilizing streptavidin to physically separate biotin-containing strands from strands which lack biotin. This embodiment is disclosed in detail below.
The preceding examples of non-Y-shaped adapters show symmetric ligation of the same type of adaptor to both ends of DNA molecules. Currently, most sequencing platforms require that adapted DNA molecules have different primer sites on either end, for example, to allow cluster amplification on either surfaces or beads. For sequencing platforms that do not routinely use Y-shaped adapters to create these different primer sites (for example Ion Torrent™ (Thermo® Inc), SOLiD (Applied Biosystems® Inc.), and 454 (Roche® Inc.)) a mixture of two different adapters are ligated and then molecules containing one of each primer site are selected;
most commonly through a bead-based emulsion PCR process.
Illustrated below is one simple approach for generating asymmetric primer sites using non-Y-shaped Duplex Sequencing adapters.
For this, a mixture of one Duplex Adapter and one standard adapter is produced in which each adapter contains a different PCR primer site. The Duplex Adapter may be any design described herein above or below or as known in the art.
An exemplary Duplex Adapter is shown in
Following ligation of this adapter mix to a DNA library, three different types of products are produced, as shown in
After PCR amplification, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
Sequencing from primer site P will yield the following sequences that derive from the “top” and “bottom” strands. These can be distinguished by virtue of carrying either an SDE X or Y label. See,
It is readily apparent that any other form of non-Y-shaped Duplex Adaptor described herein or as known in the art could serve the same purpose as that used in this embodiment. For example, instead of one Duplex Adapter and one standard adapter, it is possible to use two Duplex Adapters carrying different primer sites. After ligation and PCR, the amplified product could be split and one portion sequenced with primer P and the other sequenced with primer 0. This would enable Duplex Sequencing both ends of each adapted molecule. Because reads from different primer sites are not actually paired-end, they cannot readily be related together for any particular molecule. However, for applications where DNA to be sequenced is of very limited quantity, additional sequence information obtained from Duplex Sequencing of both ends of molecules may still be advantageous.
Paired-end sequencing, such as that carried out on Illumina® instruments, generally requires that a sequencing platform be able to sequence one strand from a primer site on one end of an adapter DNA molecule and then generates the reverse complement strand prior to sequencing the other end of the molecule from a different primer site. A technical challenge of this includes the process of complementary strand generation, which is a reason why not all platforms are easily compatible with this paired end sequencing.
However, the ability to sequence two different portions of an adapted DNA molecule can be accomplished, to a limited extent, without the need to generate a complementary strand. This may be accomplished by using a second primer site contained within a second adapter attached at the opposite end of the DNA molecule relative to the first adapter such that that sequencing read progresses away from the DNA molecule and the first adapter, thereby producing a sequencing read of the second adapter itself. In some situations such ability might be desirable. For example, because the SMI and SDE sequences required for Duplex Sequencing consume a portion of the inherently limited read-length that can be achieved, being able to move these elements to the opposite adapter to be read during a second shorter read could be helpful when maximum read length is required. A similar benefit could be realized by relocating the index barcode sequences often used for sample multiplexing.
To enable this process, two different adapters may be used. The first, as shown in
The other adapter sequence, as shown in
In the example shown in
Following ligation of this adapter mix to a DNA library, three different products are produced. Those with two of the same adapter types on opposite ends can be ignored because only the product with one of each adapter (containing both primer sites P and O, as shown in
After PCR amplification the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
Shown below are the orientations of annealed sequencing primers P1 and P2 and regions that can be sequenced by each. These reads would most conveniently be sequenced with one before the other. This would be accomplished by introducing one sequencing primer and undergoing a first sequencing read; then, introducing the second after the first sequencing read is completed. If “read #2” (as shown in
The arrangement for the sequencing template strand derived from the “top” strand is as shown in
The sequencing reads from the “top” strand-derived template will be as shown in
It is readily apparent that the sequencing read pairs from the different original strand molecules are distinguishable by virtue of carrying either an SDE X label or SDE Y label.
The potential advantages stemming from use of the above-disclosed form of double reading extends beyond simply conserving read length. In the original description of tag-based Duplex Sequencing with Y-shaped adapters, one SMI sequence was appended to each end of the adapted DNA molecule. This design has a practical advantage in certain situations for efficiently generating a sufficiently large population of diverse SMI-containing adapters to ensure every DNA molecule can be uniquely labeled.
As an illustration, if a fully degenerate four-nucleotide SMI sequence is introduced into the original Y-shaped adapter design and ligated to a DNA fragment library (as shown in
For some embodiments of Duplex Sequencing, the oligonucleotide synthesis method of SMI adapter production is preferable and a sufficiently diverse SMI-containing adapter population might not be practically achievable with only a single SMI on one end of a molecule, such as disclosed above.
The above-described method of double reading on non-paired end compatible platforms could be used to overcome this limitation by allowing an SMI sequence to be included in both adapters for sequencing in two steps of the same reaction. This is illustrated below.
For this, two types of adapters are needed, each bearing a different amplification primer site. At least one must contain an SDE and, in examples, both will contain a degenerate or semi-degenerate SMI sequence. As shown in
It will be obvious to one experienced in the art that the relative arrangements of the SMI and SDE features of the two adapters can be interchanged to achieve the same outcome. The SDE shown above in the latter adapter could be placed in the former instead. Any form of SDE or SMI described previously could be substituted with equivalent effect for those used in this example.
Following ligation of this adapter mix to a DNA library, the product successfully bound to one of each adapter type will as shown in
After PCR amplification, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
As described in the previous embodiment, the orientation of sequencing primer sites P1 and P2 and regions sequenced by each for the “top” strand are as shown in
The reads from the “top” strand-derived template will be as shown in
Again, the products of the two strands are readily distinguishable by virtue of their differing X and Y SDE labels. For Duplex Sequencing analysis, the sequences of SMI α and SMI β can be combined into a single identifying tag sequence.
Several currently-available sequencing platforms require different primer sites on the opposite ends of DNA molecules to allow cluster amplification and sequencing. This can be accomplished with Y or bubble-shaped adapters with asymmetric primer binding sites or through the two adapter ligation method illustrated in the immediately previous three embodiments. Y-shaped adapters have been most commonly used on paired end sequencing-compatible platforms, such as those manufactured by Illumina®; however, they could be used on other platforms.
One general advantage of Y or “bubble-shaped” adapters for library preparation is that, theoretically, every double-adapted DNA molecules will be capable of being sequenced. However, with methods that use two different adaptors, only half of molecules produced will be capable of being sequenced they have one of each adaptor type whereas the other half of molecules produced will have two copies of the same adapter. In certain situations, e.g., where input DNA is limiting, a higher conversion of Y-shaped adapters may be desirable.
However, as illustrated in first embodiment described above (the originally-described Duplex Sequencing method), without the ability to do paired end-reads or complete read-throughs, originally-described Y-shaped Duplex Adapters do not readily allow Duplex Sequencing with single ended-reads.
However, use of a sequencing primer site in the complementary “stem” sequence of the Y-shaped adaptors allows single-ended reads for Duplex Sequencing, but only if an asymmetry is introduced by at least one SDE elsewhere in the adaptor sequence. A brief illustration follows.
In
Following adapter ligation to a DNA fragment the structure shown in
After PCR amplification using primers complementary to sites A and B, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
After sequencing from primer site C, two different types of sequencing reads will be obtained from single-ended reads of the PCR product of each strand depending on which single-stranded half happens to be sequenced. The sequencing reads from the “top” strand PCR product are as shown in
During analysis, sequencing reads can be grouped by specific SMI sequences and their corresponding non-complementary partner based on a relationship known from a database produced at the time of and in conjunction with SMI adaptor library synthesis. In this, as shown in
Duplex sequence analysis can therefore be carried out. The analysis is analogous to that described above in the embodiment entitled “Introduction of strand-defining asymmetry using a non-complementary SMI sequence”.
An alternate design, as exemplified in
In some situations, it is preferable not to be required to perform additional enzymatic steps after adapter ligation prior to PCR. An adapter design, as exemplified in
Another variation on the concept of unpaired SMIs in Y-shaped or loop-shaped adapters, includes these unpaired SMIs located in the free single-stranded tail regions between PCR primer sites and a complementary stem. One advantage of this design is that it allows the SMIs to be completely sequenced as part of “dual-indexing” reads, such as are available on select Illumina® sequencing systems (Kircher et al (2012) Nucleic Acid Res. Vol. 40, No. 1, e3). Not having SMIs included in the main sequencing read would maximize read-length of a DNA insert for applications where long reads are particularly desirable. An example follows.
Following adapter ligation to a DNA fragment the structure shown in
After PCR amplification using primers complementary to sites A and B, the double-stranded product derived from the “top” strand will be as shown in
On the Illumina® platform, as an example, when using paired-end sequencing with dual-indexing, after completing one sequencing read and one indexing read, the complementary strand may be generated and the corresponding sequencing and index read of the other strand may be carried out.
However, it should be noted that neither paired end sequencing nor dual indexing as techniques allows Duplex Sequencing by itself. While both single-strands of a given PCR product are effectively sequenced together, each PCR product derives from only one of the two strands of an original DNA duplex, and thus, sequencing both strands of a PCR product does not equate to sequencing both strands of an original DNA duplex.
A possible relative orientation of a sequencing primer and an indexing primer and the regions they sequence is shown in
It would also suffice to sequence both the SMI and the sequence itself in a single sequencing read rather than in two separate reads. It is apparent that many different configurations and numbers of primers can be utilized to sequence the SMI and the read sequence. In some embodiments, such as nanopore sequencing, sequencing of the SMI and/or DNA sequence might not require specific primer sites at all. Moreover, while this example describes use of PCR, this and other embodiments can be amplified by any other method known in the art, including rolling circle amplification and other approaches. See, Kircher et al (2012).
When comparing the different pattern of sequences in all four reads with regard to those derived from the “top” and “bottom” strands (as shown in
Illustrated in
In this embodiment, a circular structure is formed by attaching the two ends of a linear double-stranded molecule (comprising the elements necessary for Duplex Sequencing) with the two ends of a DNA fragment with compatible ligation sites.
In
After ligation of a double-stranded DNA fragment into the double-stranded molecule of
After generating the ligated product of
It will be readily apparent that any of the forms of SMIs and SDEs described above and below could be substituted for those shown or the order of them rearranged.
As an example of another embodiment, as shown in
Alternatively, as shown in
In this design it should be noted that it is not mandatory for the SMI sequences on opposite strands to be complementary (as shown in
As discussed above, Duplex Sequencing fundamentally relies on sequencing both strands of a DNA duplex in a way that they can be distinguished. In an originally-described embodiment of Duplex Sequencing (in WO2013142389A1), both strands could be linked together with a hairpin sequence to sequence paired strands together. WO2013142389A1, as well as in the multiple embodiments disclosed-above, describes ways in which two strands of a unique DNA duplex can be distinguished using DNA tagging. This latter approach involves labeling each DNA molecule with a unique DNA sequence (an endogenous SMI comprising the coordinates of one or both ends of a DNA fragment or an exogenous SMI comprising a degenerate or semi-degenerate sequence) and introducing strand-defining asymmetry through at least one form of an SDE (e.g., an asymmetric primer sites with paired end-reading, a “bubble” sequence, a non-complementary SMI sequence, and a non-standard nucleotide which either naturally or chemically is converted to a mismatch).
Below is disclosed another approach for carrying out Duplex Sequencing which includes asymmetric chemical labeling of the two strands in a duplex such that they can be physically separated for sequencing in independent reactions. One example of this follows.
As shown in
Other binding partner pairs known in the art may be used, preferably in the form of a small molecule, a peptide or any other uniquely bindeable moiety. This label could also be in the form of a nucleic acid sequence (e.g., DNA, RNA, or a combination thereof and a modified nucleic acid such as peptide-nucleic acids or locked nucleic acid), preferably in single-stranded form, where a substantially complementary “bait” sequence affixed to a solid substrate (e.g., a solid surface, a bead, or a similar other fixed structure) could be used to bind to, and selectively capture and isolate one strand of the adapter-ligated molecule from the other.
The second adapter does not carry a chemical tag in this non-limiting example. As shown in
After the adapters of
In addition, two other types of structures will be produced: one that has two primer site P containing adapters and another that is ligated to two primer site O containing adapters. As discussed above in the embodiment entitled “Using combinations of Duplex Sequencing adapter designs to introduce different primer sites on opposite ends of DNA molecules”, enrichment for the preferred structure over the other two types of structures can be routinely achieved with specific amplification conditions prior to sequencing, such that the other two types of structures can be ignored.
As shown in
Alternately, both strands may be labeled with different chemical tags with affinities for two different types of baits. Tags found in one sequencing reaction or index group can then be compared to corresponding tags in the other population and Duplex Sequencing analysis carried out. In this example, an SDE is still used, but it entails an asymmetrically-affixed chemical tag that can be used to physically separate the strands. Their physically-different compartmentalization allows the two strands to either be sequenced individually or undergo a subsequent differential labeling step (e.g., PCR with primers carrying different index sequences on their tails) prior to pooling and combined sequencing that can later be informatically-deconvolved.
Another embodiment of this concept would be to use labels (i.e., physical groups) with other properties that allow strand separation by means other than chemical affinity. As examples, a nucleic acid strand comprising a molecule with a strong positive charge (e.g., a physical group having a charge property) could be preferentially separated from its paired unlabeled paired strand through application of an electric field (e.g., by electrophoresis) or a nucleic acid strand comprising a molecule with a strong magnetic capacity (e.g., a physical group having a magnetic property) could be preferentially separated from its paired unlabeled paired strand through application of a magnetic field. A nucleic acid strand comprising a chemical group that is sensitive to precipitation (e.g., a physical group having an insolubility property) could be preferentially separated from is paired unlabeled paired strand when in solution under certain applied conditions, such that DNA itself is soluble, but DNA comprising the physical group is insoluble.
Yet another variation on the concept of physical separation of paired strands after an SMI is applied (either as an exogenous tag within a ligated adapter sequencer or as an endogenous SMI comprising the unique shear points of the DNA fragment) is to use dilution following thermal or chemical melting of DNA duplexes into their component single-strands. Instead of applying a purifiable chemical label to one strand to separate it from the other, the single-strands are diluted into multiple (i.e., two or more) physically-separated reaction chambers such that the probability of the two originally paired strands sharing the same container is small. For example, if the mixture were split among one hundred containers, by random chance, only about 1% of partner strands would be placed in the same container. Containers could entail a set of physical vessels, such as containers, test tubes, or wells in a microwell plate, or physically separated, non-communicating droplets, for example an aqueous-in-hydrophobic phase emulsion. Any other method may be used in which the contents of two or more spatially-distinct volumes of a fluid or a solid which contains nucleic acid molecules are prevented from substantially intermixing the nucleic acid molecules. In each container, PCR amplification could be carried out, preferably using primers carrying a different tag sequence in each. This unique tag sequence added by the different primer in every container would most conveniently be situated where it could be recorded during a sequencing index read (e.g., see
In some settings, such as in commercially available kits used for adapter ligation for the Ion Torrent™ platform, double-stranded adapters are ligated to a double-stranded target DNA molecule that is to be sequenced. However, here, only one of the two strands of the target DNA molecule is ligated to the adapter. A common embodiment of this is when the 5′ strand of the ligation domain is non-phosphorylated. A polymerase with strand displacement activity is then used to copy the sequence from the ligated strand onto the unligated strand, in a process commonly known as “nick translation”. If the adapter designs disclosed herein are used this way and without modification, in many cases the SDE would be lost during the nick-translation step; thereby, preventing Duplex Sequencing. This is exemplified below.
Shown in
After ligation of the adapter of
With standard “nick-translation” approaches, a strand-displacing polymerase is used to extend the 3′ end of the library DNA molecule and displaces the unligated strand of the adapter. This is shown in
One approach to allow use of the nick-translation method of adapter ligation and which retains the SDE is as follows.
Shown in
After ligation of each adapter of
Next, a strand-displacing polymerase is added as per the typical nick translation protocol (e.g., Bst polymerase, as used in some commercial kits, due to its strong strand-displacement activity). However, as shown in
While mismatch incorporation can be fairly efficient under certain conditions, mismatch extension and creation of a second mismatch is fairly inefficient (McCulloch and Kunkel, 2008). Thus, with appropriate conditions, nucleotide incorporation will cease after the mismatch occurs. At this time, the remaining three dNTPs can be added such that the polymerase has access to all four dNTPs. The remainder of the adapter sequence will be copied to form the structure shown in
After PCR the product arising from the original “top” strand will be as shown in
Sequencing of the “top” strand product will yield the structure shown in
Note that the sequencing products are can be distinguished from each other on the basis of the introduced mismatch.
A specific example of reducing this concept to practice with Ion Torrent™ adapters is shown below.
Ion Torrent™ adapters can use the following sequences:
The asterisk “*” represents a phosphorothioate bond.
The sequence of Adapter A could be modified as follows. NNNN indicates a degenerate or semi-degenerate SMI sequence (four nucleotides are shown, but the length of this sequence is arbitrary), and MMMM indicates the complement of the NNNN. As previously described, Duplex Sequencing can be performed without SMI sequences but an SMI is shown here as a specific example of applying the concept with double-stranded molecular tagging.
Adapters A and P1 are attached to opposite ends of a DNA molecule to be sequenced. For simplicity, only the adapter A end of the molecule is shown, and also for simplicity, the two strands are shown as X's and Y's, respectively. Any DNA sequence of any length could be used, as long as the length of the sequenced fragment is compatible with the sequencing process being used.
The “top” strand is ligated, but the “bottom” strand is not ligated, leaving a nick (shown as |)
A strand-displacing polymerase is added along with dGTP. G is incorporated at the first position encountered in the 5′-3′ direction (correct incorporation of G opposite C), as well as at the second position encountered (incorrect incorporation of G opposite A). Because extension of an incorrect base after a mismatch is inefficient, under appropriate conditions of polymerase concentration, reaction time, and buffer conditions, the polymerase stalls and further incorporation does not occur. Note that the first two nucleotides of the “bottom” adapter strand are displaced during this reaction, and are shown below the adapter-DNA construct in the schematic below. Newly incorporated bases are indicated in bold.
Now, dCTP, dATP, and dTTP are added to the reaction, such that all four nucleotides are available to the polymerase. Strand-displacement synthesis can proceed, with an intermediate product shown below for illustration purposes:
After the end of the template is reached, the original “bottom” strand of the adapter is fully displaced (not shown) and a fully synthesized “bottom” strand is present with a single base pair that is not complementary (A:G basepair, underlined)
GYYYYYY
This construct can then be used for PCR amplification and sequencing per typical Ion Torrent™ protocols. Of note, PCR amplification results in products from both the “top” and “bottom” strand, and these products can be distinguished from one another by virtue of the non-complementary base pair introduced during nick translation.
Products arising from the “top” strand will be of the following form (position of base mismatch is underlined):
Products arising from the “bottom” strand, in contrast, will be of the following form (position of base mismatch is underlined):
Note that the “bottom” strand product is the reverse-complement of the sequence initially present in the “bottom” strand of the adapter-ligated DNA (and thus, the G nucleotide, which was the base mis-insertion introduced during nick-translation, is read out during sequencing as a C nucleotide).
Now, amplification duplicates arising from each of the two strands can be compared to one another for error correction. “Top strand” products arising from a given molecule of double-stranded DNA will have tag sequence NNNNAAC. “Bottom” strand products, in contrast, will have tag sequence NNNNACC. Thus duplicates from the two strands can be resolved for purposes of error correction, as previously described (Schmitt et al, PNAS 2012).
Introducing a Mismatch after Nick Translation
An alternative approach to the above would be to complete nick translation with all four nucleotides present, and then to change a base in the template strand to a different base.
An adapter containing a primer sequence and its complement (P/P′), a U-A base pair (U=uracil), and a single-stranded SMI sequence and its complement (α/α′) is shown in
After the adapter of
Strand displacement synthesis can be performed with a polymerase (e.g., Bst polymerase) and all four dNTPs, resulting in the structure shown in
The resulting extended product now re-appears as it did in the original adapter. As shown in
A purification step can be performed to remove the polymerase and dNTPs. The uracil can then be removed from the “top” strand (of the structure shown in
Next, a non-strand-displacing polymerase is added (e.g., Sulfolobus DNA polymerase IV, which is highly error-prone and facilitates base mis-incorporation) along with a single nucleotide, e.g., dGTP but no other nucleotides. In this example, this would result in mis-incorporation of G opposite A. The resultant nick could be sealed with DNA ligase, resulting in a product with a mismatch in the adapter as shown in
As shown in
This example is illustrated with creation of a G-A mismatch but it will be apparent that any other mismatch of one or more bases, at any position in the molecule, would have the same effect
A specific example of applying this concept on the Ion Torrent™ platform is shown below.
Consider the following “Modified adapter A” with additions to the standard sequence in bold (U=uracil):
The adapter is ligated to a target DNA molecule as above, with the location of the nick shown as a “|”:
Now, a strand displacement polymerase is used in the presence of all four dNTPs to allow full strand displacement of the “bottom strand” of the adapter (newly incorporated bases are in bold, original bottom adapter strand is displaced and is not shown):
The product is purified to remove dNTPs, then uracil DNA glycosylase and an AP endonuclease are added to remove the uracil from the “top” strand, leaving a single nucleotide gap:
Next, a non-strand-displacing error-prone polymerase (e.g., Sulfolobus DNA polymerase IV) is added along with dGTP, which results in incorporation of G opposite A at the single nucleotide gap; ligase can then be added to result in an intact adapter-DNA product on the “top” strand. This results in a non-complementary base-pair (location underlined).
This product can be used for error correction with a method analogous to that described in the immediately preceding embodiment.
Introducing a Mismatch after Nick Translation
The embodiment entitled “Introducing an SDE during nick translation” showed how an asymmetric SDE can be introduced during nick-translation within an adapter sequence. The same principle could be applied to a DNA molecule library itself such that an asymmetric site (an SDE) is incorporated into library molecules, possibly even before an adapter is added. This can be achieved a variety of ways. The following is merely one example.
A double-stranded DNA molecule with a “top” and “bottom” strand is shown in
This asymmetric state can be converted into a sequence asymmetry by using a polymerase in the presence of only a single nucleotide that is not complementary to the first nucleotide to be copied by the polymerase. In this example dGTP is used which will lead to an T-dGTP mis-incorporation (such mis-incorporations can be made to occur with a number of DNA polymerases under appropriate reaction conditions; see McCulloch and Kunkel, Cell Research 18:148-161(2008) and the references cited therein). A partially double-stranded DNA molecule including two mismatches is shown in
Next the all four nucleotides are added to the reaction and copying continues to extend the end of the DNA molecule until the DNA molecule is double-stranded. A mismatch bubble is produced on each fragment end, forming two SDEs as shown in
Duplex Sequencing adapters can then be ligated to the DNA molecule. The exemplary adapters shown in
Ligation is carried out between the double-stranded DNA molecule of
After PCR the product derived from the “top” strand is as shown in
Sequencing using primer P will lead to the following sequences from the respective strands shown in
Note that the presence of a C vs. a T following the SMI sequence allows “top” strand reads to be distinguished from those derived from the “bottom” strand.
Similar SDE labeling could similarly be achieved with use of mutagenic nucleotide analogs to fill in the 3′ recessed end gaps or other methods.
Other shearing methods could be used and 3′ recessed ends created with an exonuclease prior to filling in in a way that creates an SDE.
In broad terms, this example illustrates that an SDE can be introduced in a way that is independent of adapters themselves. For Duplex Sequencing to occur, only some form of an SMI and an SDE in each final adapted molecule allows the sequences derived from each strand of a Duplex to be related back to each other, yet also definitively distinguished from each other. These elements come in a variety of forms, as considered above, and can be introduced before, during, or after adapter ligation.
The embodiments disclosed above illustrate improved methods for Duplex Sequencing, wherein a final molecule that is assembled comprises at least one strand-defining element (SDE) and at least one single molecule identifier (SMI) sequence; both of the SDE and SMI are attached to a double-stranded or partially double-stranded molecule of DNA that is to be sequenced. However, the SMI and SDE do not need to be included in a single adapter; they simply need to be present in the final molecule, ideally prior to or during any amplification and/or sequencing step.
For example, an SDE can be created in an adapter after ligation via an enzymatic reaction, as shown in
The following list includes non-limiting variants of such adapters:
Each of the variants disclosed herein are included in the present invention.
In each of these variants, the same general concept applies: the final molecule for Duplex Sequencing comprises the core elements of a SDE and an SMI connected to a segment of DNA that is to be sequenced. Also note that the same general concept applies to the original description of Duplex Sequencing (in WO2013142389A1), wherein Duplex Sequencing is performed with an adapter comprising two asymmetric primer binding sites (e.g., in a “Y” configuration), which serve as the SDE in this case, and an SMI sequence attached to a double-stranded DNA molecule. These components can be assembled onto a target DNA molecule in a variety of ways, so long as the requisite components are present in the final molecule, ideally prior to or during any amplification or sequencing step.
Duplex Sequencing can be performed by obtaining a “consensus” of amplified duplicates arising from each of the two individual DNA strands to obtain two single-strand consensus sequences, then comparing the resultant single-strand consensuses to obtain a Duplex consensus sequence. This approach of “averaging” the sequence of amplified duplicates of a single molecule, position-by-position, may not be desirable in some settings (e.g., if recurrent amplification errors might occur at a given position in heavily damaged DNA) and more reliable results could thus be obtained in some settings with a different data processing scheme.
Alternate approaches include the following:
In one embodiment, such an approach could be specifically enabled with the algorithm described below. It is understood that this is only a single example for the purposes of illustration, and many other algorithms could be used to form duplex consensus reads. Moreover the example is shown for a specific embodiment of Duplex Sequencing, but similar examples could be prepared appropriate for many other embodiments of Duplex Sequencing.
The following steps may be used in an embodiment disclosed herein which uses a “bubble” sequence to result in “top” strands of each duplex being labeled GCGC, and “bottom” strands being labeled TATA, with both strands sharing the same single molecule identifier (SMI) sequence.
Within the resultant “duplexes” file, consider all reads that have a matching SMI tag sequence. In some cases, there may be multiple “duplex” reads that have the same SMI tag (these may be due to, for example, multiple PCR duplicates of a single starting DNA molecule). These can be converted to a single duplex read by any of the following approaches:
It will be apparent to one skilled in the art that combinations of the above options can be used to develop duplex consensus reads, or that several other methods not described above could be used.
While the invention has been described in conjunction with the detailed description thereof, the foregoing description is intended to illustrate and not limit the scope of the invention, which is defined by the scope of the appended claims. Other aspects, advantages, and modifications are within the scope of the following claims.
This application is claims priority to and the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/264,822, filed Dec. 8, 2015 and U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/281,917, filed Jan. 22, 2016. Each of the above-mentioned applications is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62264822 | Dec 2015 | US | |
| 62281917 | Jan 2016 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 15372761 | Dec 2016 | US |
| Child | 17719147 | US |
