Patent Application
20100049371
The present invention relates to an aggregated management system and particularly, but not exclusively, to an aggregated management system for a commodity, such as electricity or gas.
Currently, most electricity in the UK is generated by large nuclear, coal and gas power stations. Electricity supply and demand must remain in balance at all times, and the Transmission System Operator, currently National Grid, is charged with this responsibility by the gas and electricity regulator, OFGEM. National Grid passes a large fraction of this responsibility on to individual licensed electricity generators and suppliers via the balancing mechanism (“BM”).
Licensed generators and suppliers are permitted to trade with each other and with third parties in order to balance supply and demand within their own portfolios, up to a time known as “gate closure”, currently one to one and a half hours ahead of real time, when all trades are frozen and any residual balancing required is undertaken by National Grid. The BM is a means of allowing National Grid access to medium to large power stations for this residual balancing.
System frequency is a continuously changing variable that is determined and controlled by the balance between system demand and total generation. If demand is greater than generation, the frequency falls, while if generation is greater than demand, the frequency rises. National Grid has a statutory obligation to maintain system frequency within 1% of 50 Hz.
National Grid must therefore ensure that sufficient generation and/or demand is held in automatic readiness to manage all credible frequency change contingencies. The second-by-second system frequency control is managed through the automatic actions of generators and suppliers. Minute-by-minute balancing is managed using “bid/offer acceptances” within the BM by National Grid. Additionally, National Grid ‘calls-off’ other balancing services including Standing Reserve, Fast Reserve and other services for balancing over various timescales.
Predicted variations and peaks in demand, and problems at large power stations, are managed mainly using the flexibility of coal power stations, with additional contribution from oil, hydro, pumped storage and the lower efficiency gas power stations. In general, and with the exception of hydro, the more flexibly a power station operates, the less efficiently it generates, and the more polluting emissions it produces.
Electricity is freely traded in the UK via various mechanisms including power exchanges, for example, APX, forward and futures markets, through brokers and bilaterally. These mechanisms offer various different ways of trading electricity at the wholesale level. For example, they enable electricity to be traded on the spot markets for imminent periods (but prior to gate closure), or on the forward market for future periods. They also enable electricity to be traded for specific half hours or for much longer durations. It is through these mechanisms that generators sell their output to suppliers, who then sell the electricity to consumers. Traders can also buy and sell electricity at the wholesale level.
Commercial incentives exist to encourage market participants to balance electricity through the above trading mechanisms. In the event that supply and demand do not match, National Grid, as the system operator, buys or sells electricity and ‘calls off’ reserve services to ensure that the system is balanced in real time.
National Grid also purchases frequency response services which reward large-scale consumers who agree to provide a limited form of frequency response. Two of these (Frequency Response by Demand Management, FRDM, and Firm Frequency Response, FFR), involve the placing of certain large loads behind frequency-sensitive relays which isolate the load when the frequency falls below a pre-set level, often 49.7 Hz.
Schemes such as this are largely limited to large scale consumers and do not take into account the real time needs of any processes that the large scale consumers are running. Therefore only consumers able to make long term forward commitments to National Grid which will not be overridden by the short term needs of their own processes can provide these services.
According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided an aggregated management system for managing a commodity comprising:
In the context of the present invention, “commodity” refers to a product produced for exchange.
Preferably, the commodity resources are located physically remote from the resource aggregator, resource controller and interface.
Preferably, each of the plurality of commodity resources comprises an outstation.
Preferably, the outstation comprises the availability calculation means
Alternatively, the availability calculations means is located centrally and the outstation supplies live data to the availability calculation means.
Preferably, the availability calculation means monitors availability of the resource by means of a state machine, providing two binary levels of availability.
Alternatively or further preferably, the availability calculation means monitors availability by algorithm calculations, the algorithm calculations providing more than two levels of availability.
Preferably, the system further comprises an aggregated demand forecaster, wherein data from the commodity resources is used to predict resource usage and is then combined to provide an aggregated demand forecast for the at least one aggregated resource.
Preferably, the aggregated demand forecaster re-forecasts demand when a resource is altered from its predicted usage.
Alternatively or further preferably, the aggregated demand forecaster re-forecasts demand dependent on third party information which affects a resource.
Preferably, the resource controller selectively operates the resources and receives data from the resources by means of a virtual private network to the relevant resource outstation.
Preferably, the commodity is an energy commodity transferable via a network interconnecting a multiplicity of said commodity resources.
Preferably, the commodity is electricity.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is an electricity generator.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is an electricity load.
Preferably, the electricity load is a variable speed drive (VSD) according to the fourth aspect of the present invention.
Preferably, the electricity load is an energy store and is enabled, when required by the resource controller, to act as an electricity generator through release of the stored energy.
Preferably, the energy store is a battery charging system.
Preferably, the electricity load has one or more alternative power sources other than the electricity commodity and is enabled to load the, or at least one of the, alternative power sources when required by the resource controller, thereby reducing electricity load to the electricity commodity.
Preferably, one or more of the alternative power sources is a battery.
Preferably, the electricity load is a portable electronic device having a communication means, the resource controller enabled to communicate with the portable electronic device to control loading of the electricity commodity.
Alternatively, the commodity may be gas.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is a gas compressor, which keeps mains gas pressure constant.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is a gas load (consumer of gas).
According to a second aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of managing and aggregating a commodity comprising the steps of:
Preferably, each resource's availability is calculated by means of a state machine, providing two binary levels of availability.
Alternatively or further preferably, each resources availability is calculated by algorithm calculations, the algorithm calculations providing more than two levels of availability.
Preferably, the method further comprises the step of forecasting aggregated demand, wherein availability data from the commodity resources is used to predict resource usage and is then combined to provide an aggregated demand forecast for the at least one aggregated resource.
Preferably, the method further comprises the step of re-forecasting aggregated demand when a resource is altered from its predicted usage.
Alternatively or further preferably, the step of re-forecasting aggregated demand is also performed dependent on third party information which affects a resource.
Preferably, the commodity is an energy commodity transferable via a network interconnecting a multiplicity of said commodity resources.
Preferably, the commodity is electricity.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is an electricity generator.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is an electricity load.
Preferably, the electricity load is a variable speed drive (VSD) according to the fourth aspect of the present invention.
Preferably, the electricity load is an energy store and enabling, when required by the resource controller, the energy store to act as an electricity generator through release of stored energy.
Preferably, the energy store is a battery charging system.
Preferably, the electricity load has one or more alternative power sources other than the electricity commodity and loading the, or at least one of the, alternative power sources, when required by the resource controller, thereby reducing electricity load to the electricity commodity.
Preferably, one or more of the alternative power sources is a battery.
Preferably, the electricity load is a portable electronic device having a communication means, the resource controller communicating with the portable electronic device to control loading of the electricity commodity.
Alternatively, the commodity may be gas.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is a gas compressor, which keeps mains gas pressure constant.
Preferably, at least one of the plurality of commodity resources is a gas load (consumer of gas).
According to a third aspect of the present invention there is provided an aggregated load management system for managing a commodity comprising:
According to a fourth aspect of the present invention there is provided a variable speed drive comprising a frequency compensation means and an availability calculation means, wherein the frequency compensation means varies the speed of the drive dependent on the frequency of the electricity supply and the availability of the drive as calculated by the availability calculation means.
Preferably, the frequency compensation means responds to a reduction in the frequency of the electricity supply by reducing the speed of the variable speed drive, if the availability calculation means confirms availability.
Preferably, the frequency compensation means reduces the speed of the variable speed drive to a greater extent than the reduction in the frequency of the electricity supply, providing an enhanced balancing effect.
Preferably, the frequency compensation means responds to an increase in the frequency of the electricity supply by increasing the speed of the variable speed drive, if the availability calculation means confirms availability.
Preferably, the frequency compensation means increases the speed of the variable speed drive to a greater extent than the increase in the frequency of the electricity supply, providing an enhanced balancing effect.
According to a fifth aspect of the present invention there is provided an electronic device comprising:
Preferably, one or more of the alternative power sources is a battery.
Preferably, the device is one of the following: a portable computer; or a personal digital assistant.
According to a sixth aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of controlling the power consumption of an electronic device having a mains electricity power supply means, one or more alternative power supply means, communication means and processing means comprising:
Preferably, one or more of the alternative power sources is a battery.
Preferably, the device is one of the following: a portable computer; or a personal digital assistant.
According to a seventh aspect of the present invention there is provided a computer program product directly loadable into the internal memory of a digital computer comprising software code portions for performing the sixth aspect of the invention.
The invention will now be described, by way of example, with reference to the figures of the drawings in which:
a, 2b and 2c show respectively availability data of three groups of aggregated loads, call data for those groups and forecast consumption for those groups;
a, 4b and 4c show respectively availability data of three groups of aggregated loads after a call has been made, call data for those groups and forecast consumption for those groups; and
Referring to
The generators 12 are typically standby diesel generators, which can only generate electricity which is usually too small to be considered for contributing to the balancing required for the electricity network. Other types of electricity generators can also be used, such as hydro plants and combined heat and power plants. Where additional power is required to help the electricity system, these generators can be brought online as an aggregated generator of electricity.
The loads 14 can be any processes or equipment, such as water pumping, refrigeration, air conditioning, product movement, stock preparation and any other process. These types of loads are usually not constantly running and many include a control system which attempts to keep a certain variable within pre-defined parameters. As such, if the loads are able to be reduced or switched, then the load on the electricity system can be reduced.
Each generator 12 and load 14 comprises an outstation (not shown). The outstation provides monitoring and control of the resource at the remote location and comprises an availability calculation means. So, for example, where a load 14 is a refrigeration unit, the outstation can monitor whether the refrigeration unit is on and the temperature the refrigeration unit is controlling. From this it can determine when the refrigeration unit is likely to be available as a load on the system. A forecast of availability, taking into consideration the variation of the temperature the refrigeration unit is controlling, can then be calculated. It is important to note that although the forecast of availability may be a binary on/off value, it may also have a number of other levels or be an analogue value. So, it may be possible to provide limited load or generation to the aggregator depending on the circumstances of the resource.
The outstations are able to communicate with a server 16. The communication can take place by any suitable means, such as direct connection via Ethernet cables, an internet connection, which could be over a virtual private network (VPN) protocol or any other suitable means. Preferably, the outstations are equipped with dial-up modems and “always on” internet connections, such as ADSL lines. The outstations are enabled to attempt communication by a number of means should the most preferred connection not be available. It is also preferred that the outstation communicates with the server 16 over a VPN to provide a high level of security.
The server 16 comprises a resource controller 18, a resource forecaster 20, a resource aggregator 22 and an interface 24.
The resource controller 18 is enabled, via the communication channel with the outstation, to selectively operate the generators 12 and loads 14 dependent on instructions received via the interface 24.
The resource forecaster 20 receives availability information from each outstation and calculates when the generator 12 or load 14 can be utilised by the system 10. It is also possible for each outstation to comprise a resource forecaster such that future availability is calculated at the resource. In either case, the resource forecaster accesses a set of calculations which are unique to each resource in order to calculate both the resource availability and the forecast consumption (if a load) or production (if a generator or similar) of the resource. The resource forecaster uses process information such as analogue and digital information read at each resource by the relevant outstation in each calculation. Each calculation is repeated on a regular cycle, or when triggered by an external event.
The resource aggregator 22 combines the availability information from the resource forecaster 20, or from each resource forecaster from each outstation, into an aggregated availability of generators and an aggregated availability of loads. As such, the individual availabilities of each generator and each load are combined to present an aggregated generator and an aggregated load. In some instances, it may be desirable to combine certain resources dependent on either their type, ownership or other classification. For example, all the refrigeration units for a particular supermarket company, across all the company's stores, could be aggregated as a single aggregated load.
An interface 16 provides access to the aggregated resources managed by the system 10. In this example, Licensed Electricity Suppliers 26 and National Grid 28 are able to view aggregated resources on their computer terminals by accessing the interface 16.
The system 10 provides an end-to-end control tool for matching electricity supply and demand in real time. At one end are the relatively small number of electricity traders working for Licensed Electricity Suppliers 26, responsible for forward purchasing sufficient electricity for the consumption they expect their customers to use, or National Grid's own operational control staff. At the other end are the large number of industrial and commercial customers of various sizes who need electricity to power their normal business activities, or owners of electricity generators or electricity storage equipment which may be too small to access by the means employed for large power stations. The system 10 allows high speed, aggregated load management (switching off electricity consuming equipment for short periods) or generation during periods of high stress on the electricity system.
Load management means short term reduction or cessation of electricity consumption by some process or equipment in order to reduce the burden on the overall electricity system during a period of system stress. The processes or equipment whose consumption is being curtailed will be suitable parts of the normal business activities of industrial and commercial electricity consumers, such as water pumping, refrigeration, air conditioning, product movement, stock preparation and any other process. The value to Licensed Electricity Suppliers is the ability to opt out of buying short term high priced electricity when the market is short (i.e. under stress), or indeed to create a surplus of premium electricity to sell during such a period. The value to National Grid is the ability to access load management for reserve purposes at lower cost than other reserve options. Furthermore, the system 10 allows the creation of a virtual large volume resource from a large number of relatively small resources.
One resource, which would be particularly beneficial to the balancing of the electricity system is a variable speed drive (VSD), also known as a variable frequency drive. In many motors or drives, the frequency of the electricity supply directly affects the speed at which they operate. But with a VSD, the speed of the drive is independent of the frequency of the electricity input. A VSD with a frequency sensitive mode which reacts to the frequency of the electricity supply provides additional supply balancing.
That is, when the frequency of the electricity supply falls relative to nominal frequency, the frequency of the drive (and hence the rotation rate of the motor) would be set to fall to a greater or lesser extent, thus reducing the load on the national electricity system and thereby tending to correct the frequency excursion. If the frequency of the electricity supply rises, the VSD would respond in the opposite manner.
The ability of a drive to respond to frequency would be continuously adjusted on the basis of the need of that VSD to carry out its function at its “nominal” rate at that time. For example, sewage pumps operating with a relatively full well would exhibit little or no response to a fall in frequency, but when the well was close to empty, the response would be greater. Air conditioning fans would likewise exhibit more response when the controlled variable (say temperature) was well within normal operational limits, and less when the variable was close to limits. The response could be skewed to reflect the different-sided limits, e.g., while the sewage pumps were unable to respond to a fall in frequency, they may be able to respond to a rise, and vice versa.
An outstation attached to a VSD could monitor the available frequency response and report on it, or to set particular loads into frequency sensitive mode when required by the resource controller. These are optional additions. However, the ability of the frequency-sensitive process to automatically “opt out” of frequency sensitive operation would be a significant factor in its acceptability by operators of VSDs.
Variable speed electricity generators, such as wind turbines using doubly fed induction generators or inverter drives, could also provide frequency sensitive operation controlled by the system 10.
Referring now to
Three groups depicted in different colours (Group 1—dark grey, Group 2—light grey and Group 3—white) represent aggregated load which is available to electricity traders in this example.
A trader or operator makes a call by selecting which groups of loads should be shut down during a particular time period, which, in this example, are broken down in to half-hour slots. In this case, the trader or operator selects Groups 1 and 3 for one hour, approximately 90 minutes ahead of the time (current time shown at the left most point of the x-axis). The system then shows the new forecast consumption (
In response to the trader or operator actions, the system 10 will both issue and control the loads 14 via the resource controller 18, where the loads 14 are part of groups 1 and 3, and at the same time update the forecast consumption and availability via the resource forecaster 20.
The present invention benefits both traders (or operators) and consumers by reducing both the cost of production of electricity and the price of electricity to the consumer.
The concepts of load management, electricity system balancing and aggregation are not necessarily new as individual concepts. However, the present invention introduces a number of advantageous benefits as set out below.
Process-led load management, that is, aggregation and management of loads dependent on their availability, which is determined according to the loads current operating conditions. In addition, the future needs of the load are also calculated and taken into consideration when forecasting future availability. Electricity consumption at any site will not be curtailed when parameters measured by the outstations indicate that loads should not be curtailed, for example, air cooling equipment would not be considered available for load management when the controlled air temperature was in excess of, or was expected to exceed in the near future, a limit agreed in advance. However, during periods when the processes do possess flexibility (for example when the controlled temperature was within agreed limits) this flexibility is made available for electricity balancing. Therefore, the core business processes of electricity consumers are protected while the consumers earn revenue by providing balancing services. This enables a much wider participation of consumers in system balancing.
“Firm-by-prediction” electricity system balancing. Industry practice worldwide has tended to be for “firm” services (high commitment, high value) or “non-firm” services (no commitment, limited value). For many consumers these two forms translate as “impractical” on one hand and “not worthwhile” on the other, and load management has grown little as a system balancing tool as a result. Continuously updated load management availability makes services which would otherwise be “non-firm” potentially as valuable for system balancing as “firm” services. “Firm-by-prediction” electricity balancing services are therefore far more atteactive to National Grid and to Licensed Electricity Suppliers.
Overall, the present invention enables cheaper and less polluting electricity system balancing, reduces the need to invest in transmission infrastructure, creates more capacity to absorb renewable generation, and mitigates against high energy costs, and provides electricity consumers and owners of small generators with an additional revenue stream.
Aggregated management through the system 10 for large scale electricity system balancing saves at least 130 tonnes of carbon dioxide per gigawatt-hour of electricity consumed, plus an additional 300 tonnes of carbon dioxide for each megawatt of load management capacity made available per year, providing a significant benefit to the environment. This benefit will vary from country to country, but will be of this order in any country where fossil fuels are a significant component of electricity generation. The savings arise by reducing the need to operate the lowest efficiency fossil fuelled generators during peaks in demand, reduction in costly starts, stops and part load operation of large power stations, from better electricity system balancing and by making the electricity system more able to absorb variable renewable generation.
In addition, the application of balancing supply and demand in electricity through process-led aggregation can also be applied to the supply and demand of gas with the exception of the carbon dioxide benefit and the replacement of frequency responsive operation with pressure responsive operation. However, the supply and demand of gas managed by the present invention enhances the safety of the gas network. A loss of pressure in the national gas system can cause deaths, so the ability to curtail supply to controllable consumers is a safety benefit as it provides the gas transmission system operator with another means of ensuring that pressure in the national gas system does not fall below critical safety levels.
In fact, any energy commodity which is part of a continuous infrastructure-based supply chain can be managed using the present invention. The more time-critical the supply and demand, the greater the benefit that the present invention provides. In particular, commodities transferable via a network and, preferably, a near instantaneous network, benefit most from the present invention.
On the other hand, energy commodities which are delivered using bulk transport vehicles (small scale oil, all solid fuels, etc) might not find the present invention so useful, as there is a less time critical “balancing” requirement.
However, where a bulk energy commodity has a natural interaction with a time critical commodity, the present invention would be particularly useful. The most obvious example would be the timing of the charging of, for example, hydrogen tanks or batteries for road transport—charging of such energy stores should avoid periods of electricity system stress. It should be noted that a commercial energy storage plant could be connected to the electricity (or gas) system and absorb energy during times of surplus, giving it back during times of stress. Both of these already exist at large scale in both electricity and gas systems but they do not exist at small scales due to the lack of a process-led aggregation system, such as the present invention.
Improvements and modifications may be incorporated in the foregoing without departing from the scope of the present invention.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0614193.1 | Jul 2006 | GB | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/GB07/50347 | 6/21/2007 | WO | 00 | 9/22/2009 |
