The present disclosure relates generally to ducted fan propulsion for aircraft.
Propellers driven by reciprocating (piston) engines are widely used in general aviation to economically propel aircraft, particularly those flown by individual private pilots. Costs for economical 2-4 passenger aircraft may begin at $100-300,000. Two or more radial blades shaped as airfoils may rotate about a hub axis, with the chord of each blade twisted out of the plane of rotation by a blade twist angle in order to set a positive angle of attack (AOA) with respect to the relative airflow. The angle of the relative airflow may be approximately calculated by vector summing the axial velocity (arising from aircraft motion) and the blade velocity at any given point along the span of the blade. In order to maintain a positive AOA that is less than a stall angle, the blade twist angle may need to become progressively smaller in moving from the inboard region of the blade to the outboard region because blade velocity is greater at the tip. Unfortunately, high drag may occur as the relative airflow at the tip approaches Mach 1, reducing efficiency, and may limit prop-driven aircraft to low subsonic speeds of less than approximately 350 miles per hour (mph), or approximately Mach 0.5. Prop-driven aircraft may also be limited to flight ceilings of less than approximately 30,000 feet. The propulsion efficiency of a propulsion system may be defined as the thrust divided by the weight of the engine and propeller (or fan), often quoted as a ratio.
Basic turbofan engines typically have several times the thrust per unit weight (propulsion efficiency) as piston engines driving propellers, and so may be used to achieve aircraft speeds of 300-1200 mph where the thrust required to overcome aircraft drag may be higher than at low subsonic speeds, according to approximately the velocity squared. A turbofan may comprise a jet turbine and a propulsion fan, producing both reactive thrust and fan thrust. The fan itself, also sometimes called a rotor, may be constructed of a hub with a plurality of fan blades attached at its rim surface. A duct circumscribing the fan blades may mitigate tip turbulence and improve efficiency over propellers. Aircraft employing ducted turbofans may reach flight ceilings of approximately 50,000 to 60,000 feet. However, the multi-stage compressors and multi-stage turbines often contained within a basic turbofan may experience high heat and stresses, requiring superalloys or exotic metals, making turbofans expensive to build. Additionally, although basic turbofans may generate large amounts of thrust for a military aircraft, a turbofan may consume approximately three times as much fuel as a piston engine, which may make turbofan aircraft relatively expensive to fly. For example, a turbine may consume approximately one pound of fuel per horsepower per hour, whereas a piston engine may consume approximately ⅓rd pound per horsepower per hour. Additionally, the lower weight afforded by the turbofan's high propulsion efficiency may be partially cancelled out by the additional fuel that must be carried.
High bypass turbofans may derive most of their thrust from the ducted fan and little from the turbine exhaust, thereby reducing noise and making them ideal for commercial airliners and business aircraft operating at speeds of approximately 300-600 mph. Costs for a 4-6 passenger very light jet with a cruising speed of approximately 450 mph and a cruising altitude of approximately 40,000 feet may be at least approximately $3 million. Unfortunately, the long fan blades commonly used may have a low hub-to-tip ratio (HTR) producing a relative airflow that is subsonic at a root and supersonic at the tip of the blade. For example, a typical fan having a low HTR of 0.3 may, by reciprocal, create a differential in blade speed between the root and the tip, requiring a progressive blade twist to maintain a positive, non-stalling AOA. Additionally, a transonic zone occurring at the intersection of the subsonic and supersonic regions may generate shock wave turbulence that may require additional blade shaping to recover efficiency or may require additional power to overcome additional drag. The blade may be swept progressively backward to keep the leading edge behind a forward shock wave. Blade thickening may be necessary to stabilize a long blade against mechanical flutter, but may add weight and cause shock waves that reduce performance. In summary, thickening, sweeping, twisting, and otherwise shaping a blade in order to compensate for deficiencies in transonic, low HTR fans may require a complex manufacturing process not well suited to an economical high subsonic propulsion system.
A further drawback of a ducted fan and turbine combination optimized for propulsion efficiency is that the fan itself may not be optimized. To demonstrate this, fan efficiency may be defined as thrust divided by drive power, often quoted as pounds per horsepower. Due to the high propulsion efficiency of turbofans, the horsepower used to drive the fan is easily increased by making the turbine bigger and adding fuel which, when combined with a refinement in the fan, may result in more turbofan thrust, but less fan efficiency. For example, a longer blade may create more thrust, and additional drag that is overcome with a bigger turbine, resulting in a fan having less thrust per unit of drive horsepower but producing a turbofan with higher thrust to weight (propulsion efficiency). In conclusion, because the fans being used in high subsonic flight may be optimized in conjunction with a turbine, the fans themselves may not be efficient enough to propel a 2-4 seat aircraft at high subsonic speeds using a more economical reciprocating engine. This may be one reason why piston-driven ducted fans may not yet be efficient enough to reliably achieve high subsonic flight.
Another penalty of prior fan technology may be the use of multi-piece rotors that are heavier and may require that preformed fan blades be welded, bolted, or otherwise attached to a preformed hub, adding weigh and cost. For example, the complexly-shaped blades used in conventional fans may have a low HTR and may be therefore too heavy to be adhesively retained by a compositely formed hub. In addition, the materials of which the fan blade is fabricated may comprise exotic materials such as titanium and which may be too expensive or difficult to co-form with a hub. Also, conventional blades may be formed of heavy materials such as titanium, having a specific gravity of 4.5 grams per cubic centimeter (g/cc), or such as steel having a specific gravity of 7.8 g/cc, creating a higher centrifugal pull on a hub than a lighter material such as aluminum having a specific gravity of only 2.7 g/cc. Additionally, long blades are more susceptible to damage, such as by the ingestion of birds, necessitating an even thicker, heavier blade that precludes adhesion in a one-piece rotor. The result of a multi-piece assembly may be a higher parts count, complex manufacturing tooling, and a greater weight not supportive of economical high subsonic flight. What's needed is a rotor design that reduces the centrifugal pull of preformed fan blades on a composite hub having modest adhesive strength.
Another problem in fan art are the flow regimes that may arise from boundary layer conditions near the rim surface of the hub, and which may migrate to outboard regions of the blade, reducing lift and increasing drag. A flow regime may be a region of air having a localized pattern of movement distinct from air movement in adjacent regions. A flow regime may be a laminar flow over an airfoil, a vortex coming off of a wing tip, a boundary layer attached to a hard surface, a turbulent regime of air, such as on the suction side of a wing in stall, or a mix of these individual flow regimes. Boundary layers may be regions of shearing between the molecules of air attached to a hard surface and the air that is further away, giving rise to various flow regimes having turbulence, vortices, or other movement patterns. In contrast, the working portion of the fan blade may generate propulsion and an associated low pressure zone due to a laminar flow across the suction and pressure sides of the blade. Because inboard flow regimes near the rim surface may have differing airflow and higher pressures than the laminar flow generating propulsion, they may migrate outboard along the blade and substantially reduce propulsion.
Conventional turbofan designs may utilize various methods to compensate for inboard flow regimes in the fan, such as rounding the root of the blade so it does not attempt to generate lift, or using long blades to place the working portion of the blade further away from the rim surface, thereby forfeiting fan efficiency. However, while sacrificing efficiency may be acceptable in a design allowing higher fuel consumption and higher manufacturing cost, it may not be acceptable in a solution requiring economy. Particular inboard flow regimes that reduce fan efficiency may include those arising from the boundary layers associated with the rim surface, the air inlet adjacent to the rim surface, and the wing-body corner line between the hub and the root of the blade.
Another problem in the art may be the lack of a lightweight, composite rotor of simple manufacture. An integrally bladed composite rotor like that disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 7,491,032 may form blades at each blade location during circumferential winding of a hub with a continuous filament, creating a lightweight one piece assembly. Unfortunately, the disclosure requires cornering of the filaments from a circumferential to a radial path to form each blade, then back again to a circumferential path, which may require a complex manufacture and tension control. Also, blade shaping options may be fewer in such an integrated rotor formation since any sweep, twist, thickness, and taper that is required needs to be integrated into one winding process, which may restrict the features and parameter ranges can be implemented. Additionally, the disclosure of an integrally bladed rotor may not allow for the insertion of a simple preformed blade into a hub being wound.
Another example of a composite rotor is the composite turbine described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,354,804. The hub disclosed in '804 may be formed of carbon cloth and reinforcing carbon filaments, and the blade may be formed of chopped carbon fibers with radial reinforcing, all fabricated at the same time. Unfortunately, complex shaping of blade and hub are combined into one process that may be expensive and a difficult one in which to control tolerances. In another disclosure, a composite flywheel disclosed by U.S. Pat. No. 4,187,738 uses continuous filaments coated with a binding agent to layer concentric toroids, each layer being individually cured before adding the next layer. However, layering and then curing successive toroids of composite material may require a long manufacturing process. Additionally, the process disclosed in '738 may require that the filaments be highly prestressed in order to resist the large centrifugal forces present in a flywheel rotating at speeds in excess of 35,000 rpm. Unfortunately, prestressing may be an expensive and unnecessary manufacturing constraint for a lower-speed fan hub. For example, a fan comprised of low-stress filament may be adequately strong for speeds of less than approximately 14,000 revolutions per minute (rpm). Additionally, rotor speeds of less than 14,000 rpm may allow grease bearings to be used instead of complicated oil lubrication. In summary, the prior art may lack a method for manufacturing a lightweight composite rotor of modest centrifugal strength using preformed blades and using simple manufacturing techniques.
As can be seen, there exists a need in the art for a more efficient and lightweight ducted fan, preferably driven by a reciprocating engine, and optimized for high subsonic flight. Furthermore, there exists a need in the art for an all-supersonic rotor that eliminates transonic turbulence and simplifies blade shaping. Additionally, there exists a need in the art for methods to manage inboard flow regimes that reduce fan efficiency. Also, there exists a need in the art for a composite hub comprised of low-stress filaments into which thin, preformed blades may be adhesively retained, forming a one-piece rotor. Finally, there exists a need in the art for a composite rotor formed of non-exotic materials and that can be fabricated using simple processes and without expensive machining or tooling.
The above-noted needs associated with supersonic fans are specifically addressed and alleviated by the present disclosure that, in an embodiment, provides a supersonic fan that may comprise a hub having a rim surface and rotating. At least two fan blades may extend radially from the rim surface of a hub. Each fan blade may have an inboard leading edge of an inboard length rotating at an airspeed of at least approximately Mach 1 and swept at an inboard sweep angle with respect to a radial of the hub. A duct may circumscribe the fan blades. A low-pressure zone along each fan blade may generate propulsion. An inboard flow regime forming near the rim surface may migrate along the fan blades toward the duct and contaminate the low-pressure zone, thereby reducing propulsion. An outboard leading edge may have an outboard length that is greater than the inboard length and which is swept at an outboard sweep angle. The outboard leading edge may extend approximately radially from the inboard leading edge and form an apex therebetween. The inboard and outboard sweep angles may each be at least approximately 30 degrees and in opposite directions. An inboard vortex may form near to and as a result of the apex and trail circumferentially across the fan blades. The inboard vortex may be positioned to substantially confine the inboard flow regime to be inboard of the apex, thereby preserving the low-pressure zone and increasing propulsion for the supersonic fan.
Also disclosed is a supersonic fan that may comprise a hub having a hub volume defined by an inner circumferential surface, two adjoining parallel side surfaces perpendicular to the inner circumferential surface, and a rim surface. The rim surface may have a rim width and a rim radius defining a plane of rotation. At least one continuous filament may wind spirally, substantially within the plane of rotation, and may be surrounded by a cured binder having a binder volume. The continuous filament may have a filament inner end terminating near the inner circumferential surface and a filament outer end terminating near the rim radius. The continuous filament may array laterally between the two side surfaces and layer radially out to the rim surface, forming a hub. A ratio of the binder volume to the hub volume may range from approximately 20 percent to approximately 65 percent. At least two fan blades may each have at least one mounting finger substantially parallel to the plane of rotation and buried beneath the rim surface. Each fan blade may have a working portion extending above the rim surface to a tip radius. The mounting finger may have a finger thickness, where a ratio of the finger thickness to the rim width may be less than approximately 25 percent of a ratio of the binder volume to the hub volume. The cured binder may bind the fan blades to the hub, forming the supersonic fan in one piece. A ratio of the rim radius to the tip radius may be at least approximately 0.65, creating a substantially uniform speed along the outboard leading edge. The continuous filament may substantially provide the tensile strength resisting the centrifugal and circumferential forces within the hub.
Also disclosed is a method for providing a supersonic fan, which may include the step of pultruding at least one continuous filament through a bath of uncured binder, thereby forming a coated filament. The method may further include the step of winding the coated filament spirally into a hub shaped substantially as a disk with a rim surface, a rim width, and a rim radius defining a plane of rotation. The method may further include the step of embedding at least 2 fan blades into the rim surface where the fan blades each have a working portion and at least one mounting finger. The mounting finger may have a finger thickness and be substantially parallel to and adhere between adjacent windings of the coated filament. The mounting finger may displace a part of the uncured binder, where the finger thickness may be less than approximately 15 percent of the rim width. The working portion may be located opposite the mounting finger and extend above the rim radius to a tip radius, wherein the working portion generates propulsion. The method may further include the step of curing the hub. The method may further include the step of circumscribing the fan blades with a duct. The method may further include the step of dividing the working portion into an inboard length and an outboard length, the inboard length corresponding to an inboard leading edge rotating at an airspeed of at least approximately Mach 1. An inboard flow regime forming near the rim surface may migrate outboard over the working portion, thereby reducing propulsion. The method may further include the step of sweeping an outboard leading edge backward from an apex formed between the inboard leading edge and the outboard leading edge, the outboard leading edge corresponding to the outboard length. The outboard leading edge may be swept at an outboard sweep angle with respect to a radial of the hub, and the inboard leading edge may be swept forward at an inboard sweep angle. The outboard length may be greater than the inboard length. The difference between the outboard sweep angle and the inboard sweep angle may be at least approximately 60 degrees. The method may further include the step of confining the inboard flow regime to remain substantially inboard of the apex, wherein an inboard vortex generating near to and as a result of the apex and trailing circumferentially across the rotating fan blades substantially prevents the migration of the inboard flow regime and thereby increases propulsion for the supersonic fan. The method may further include the step of limiting a ratio of the rim radius to the tip radius to be at least approximately 0.65, creating a substantially uniform speed across the outboard leading edge and producing the supersonic fan in one piece rotating in the plane of rotation and circumscribed by the duct.
The features, functions and advantages that have been discussed can be achieved independently in various embodiments of the present disclosure or may be combined in yet other embodiments, further details of which can be seen with reference to the following description and drawings below.
These and other features of the present disclosure will become more apparent upon reference to the drawings wherein like numbers refer to like parts throughout and wherein:
Referring now to the drawings wherein the showings are for purposes of illustrating various aspects of the present disclosure, shown in
Referring to
Continuing with
Referring to
Blade suction side 35 and blade pressure side 34 may form the two sides of an airfoil generating propulsion as a result of a substantially laminar flow with a positive, non-stalling AOA. The laminar flow may also generate a low pressure zone (not shown) proximate to blade suction side 35 and facilitating propulsion. Inboard leading edge 22 and outboard leading edge 25 may be sharpened or thinned to minimize the drag due to supersonic shock formation. For example, the leading edges may be thinned to approximately 0.004 inches. Additionally, the trailing edges (not shown) may be thinned to approximately 0.004 inches to minimize drag.
Continuing with
Referring to
Referring now to
Continuing with
Referring to
Continuing with
Continuing, rim width 15 may span the distance between the two side surfaces 16 of hub 11 and, in an embodiment, may approximately match the width of fan blade 21 rotated to blade twist angle 36. The design AOA may be varied through the related effects of fan rotation speed, axial air speed, and a convergence-divergence nozzle (not shown). In an embodiment, the design value for AOA may range from approximately 20 degrees to less than approximately 0 degrees.
In summary,
Referring to
In another embodiment not shown, air inlet slat 51 may be adjustable, closing or opening automatically in response to air pressure, or controlled manually. Slat 51 may be segmented into sections that can move independently of each other in response to yaw and other aircraft orientations that create variations in airflow along the circumference of duct 18. For example, slat 51 may divided into two 180 degree contiguous sections mounted to duct 18 and operated with differing degrees of closure or opening. It is to be noted that the term “slot” may be sometimes used in the literature in place of the word “slat”, and both terms may refer to an airfoil-shaped member positioned in front of a forward edge.
Continuing with
Additionally, stator blades 60 may be positioned aft of the fan blades in order to remove the swirl caused by the rotating fan, and may be affixed to inner duct surface 19. Stator blades 60 may straighten and redirect the axial flow, increasing the thrust substantially. Combining an improved supersonic fan 10 with air inlet slat 51, CD nozzle 52 and stator blades 60, and integrating aircraft enhancements such as reduced weight, reduced drag, and carrying less fuel may enable an economical 2-4 passenger aircraft flying at high subsonic speeds to be driven by a fuel-economical, diesel or gasoline reciprocating engine having a high horsepower to weight ratio.
Referring to
Referring to
Continuing, mounting fingers 46 of fan blades 21 may be embedded into hub 11, exposing working portion 47 having a blade suction side 35 and a width approximately equal to rim width 15. The fan blades 21 may be aligned for the desired blade twist angle 36 (not shown) prior to curing the composite hub. A ratio of rim radius 14 to tip radius 38 may be at least approximately 0.65 so that fan blades 21 have of a low aspect ratio and are of correspondingly low weight. In an embodiment, a ratio of rim radius 14 to tip radius 38 may be approximately 0.8. Outboard leading edge 25 may intersect inboard leading edge 22 at apex 28 and thereby establish a simple blade shaping that substantially confines inboard flow regimes (not shown) to remain inboard of apex 28, thereby increasing fan efficiency. The low aspect ratio of working portion 47 may allow fan blade 21 and mounting fingers 46 to be thin relative to rim width 15, thereby minimizing the displacement of cured binder 42 and continuous filaments 41 and preserving the centrifugal strength of hub 11. In an embodiment, the finger thickness (not shown) may be less than approximately 15 percent of rim width 15. In another embodiment, a ratio of finger thickness to rim width 15 may be less than approximately 25 percent of a ratio of the binder volume 56 to the hub volume 12. Filament outer end 54 may terminate close enough to rim surface 13 so that fan blade 21 is reliably retained during rotation of hub 11 within plane of rotation 45.
Continuing with
Fan blades 21 may be pre-formed and comprised of one or more of the following materials: metal, carbon composite, molded composite, laminate composite, ceramic, plastic. Fan blade 21 may be cast, cut, stamped, extruded, molded, or otherwise formed. In an embodiment, fan blade 21 may be formed of aluminum and have a length of approximately 3 inches. Low aspect ratio fan blades 21 may be reliably bonded to a composite hub 11 formed of cured binder 42 and at least one lightly tensioned continuous filament 41. However, the heavier weight of high aspect blades may not allow reliable adhesion by a composite hub below an HTR of less than approximately 0.65. HTR (hub-to-tip ratio) may be chosen to insure that fan blade 21 is all-supersonic under all aircraft conditions, including take-off, cruise, and unusual slow-flight conditions. The CD nozzle (not shown), engine rpm, and other factors may be adjusted to maintain all-supersonic conditions.
Referring to
Continuing with
Referring now to
Continuing with
Referring to
Once all fan blades 21 have been inserted, hub 11 may be cured by the application of heat, ultraviolet light, the passage of time, chemical catalyst, or any other curing means known in the art. Following curing, blade insertion tool 67 and winding spool 64 may be removed, and axle mount 30 may be attached to hub 11 for driving the composite rotor (not shown), followed by dynamically balancing the assembly. Rough edges may be removed and bearings or other hardware may be attached. In another embodiment not shown, preformed fan blades 21 may be aligned with and inserted into hub 11 using any tooling or methods available to one skilled in the art.
Additional modifications and improvements of the present disclosure may be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art. Thus, the particular combination of parts described and illustrated herein is intended to represent only certain embodiments of the present disclosure and is not intended to serve as limitations of alternative embodiments or devices within the spirit and scope of the disclosure.
This application claims priority from U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/849,513, filed Jan. 28, 2013, entitled “ALL-SUPERSONIC DUCTED FAN FOR PROPELLING AIRCRAFT AT HIGH SUBSONIC SPEEDS”, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3030770 | Ranard et al. | Apr 1962 | A |
3675294 | Palfreyman et al. | Jul 1972 | A |
3754839 | Bodman | Aug 1973 | A |
3762835 | Carlson et al. | Oct 1973 | A |
3989406 | Bliss | Nov 1976 | A |
4012172 | Schwaar | Mar 1977 | A |
4187738 | Knight | Feb 1980 | A |
4354804 | Cruzen | Oct 1982 | A |
4726737 | Weingold | Feb 1988 | A |
5755554 | Ryall | May 1998 | A |
6071077 | Rowlands | Jun 2000 | A |
6609674 | Gabrys | Aug 2003 | B2 |
7334990 | Lawlor | Feb 2008 | B2 |
7374403 | Decker et al. | May 2008 | B2 |
7491032 | Powell | Feb 2009 | B1 |
20040042902 | Hornick et al. | Mar 2004 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
WO 2007138779 | Dec 2007 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20150098834 A1 | Apr 2015 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61849513 | Jan 2013 | US |