The present invention generally relates to nanoalloy materials. More particularly, the present invention relates to bimetallic silver-copper alloy nanoinks with room-temperature sintering properties.
Printable inks and functional inks can provide specific properties, such as electrical conductivity, to a substrate. Ink can be printable and not necessarily functional, and an ink which contains a material that provides a specific functionality may not necessarily be printable. Further, ink may be deposited or coated onto a substrate, such as paper, plastic, metal, or semiconductor material, and glass or plastic substrates.
Various nanomaterials can now be formulated into ink forms. Inks contain various filler materials, and by removing a small weight percentage of filler materials, this enables a small concentration of nanomaterials to be formulated within an ink. The incorporation of nanomaterials can bring a variety of properties to the ink itself, as well as affecting the physical manner in which the nanoink can be printed or deposited on a substrate. There is a growing demand for the production and manufacturing of nanoinks or nanopastes for a wide range of applications including medicine, environmental monitoring, sensors, catalysis, and electronics.
One of the fastest growing areas of nanoink applications is in printed electronics for sensors and solar cells. The technology development in these areas depends on scalable synthesis of various metal nanoparticles (NPs) with controllable sizes, compositions and sintering properties. In addition to a high surface area to volume ratio, the surface atoms of NPs experience a different chemical reactivity than the bulk counterparts, reflecting transitions from metallic to atomic properties, and leading to intriguing mechanical, magnetic, electrical, and biological properties. NPs synthesized with noble metals, such as gold, silver, and platinum, exhibit multifunctionality and tunable surface functionalization. Coinage metals such as gold, silver, and copper have a distinct localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR), which have attracted interest in developing advanced sensors and electronics.
Silver has been at the forefront of nanoscale research in recent years because of its high electrical conductivity and enhanced surface plasmon resonance. In accordance with other noble metals, silver ink or paste is known for its stability, conductivity, and facile synthesis. One of the major drawbacks of the use of silver, however, is the high and volatile cost. Silver is much more expensive than other transition metals such as nickel and copper. The price of silver also fluctuates at a much more drastic monthly level compared to copper, making it more susceptible to market swings. While copper has advantages over silver and other noble metals in terms of cost, it faces serious challenges in stability.
In atmospheric conditions, copper has a high propensity to oxidize, making it more difficult to synthesize copper-based nanoparticles under ambient conditions. Certain actions can be taken to prevent rapid oxidation of copper, such as the addition of stabilizers or running synthesis under nitrogen and argon. These measures, however, can be costly and time-consuming, making the overall synthesis process for copper nanoparticles (CuNPs) less favorable than that of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) despite the cost benefit. Therefore, there has been interest in alloying cooper and silver in NPs to address the issues of the high cost of silver and copper oxidation.
Alloying can change the properties from that of the monometallic NP forms. Bimetallic nanoalloys feature a random combination of the metals in alloy structures, whereas the core-shell structure develops an outer coating of one metal on the other. A key challenge to the synthesis of silver-copper alloy NPs is the ability to control size, composition, phase structure, and oxidation resistance.
Despite significant progress in the synthesis of bimetallic silver-copper NPs, the ability to control the bimetallic nanoclusters (NCs) and NPs remains a challenge. Often, the presence of NCs make it difficult to separate NCs from NPs. The process of Ostwald Ripening can occur, in which larger particles grow at the expense of smaller particles. On the other hand, the process of Reverse Ostwald Ripening occurs when smaller particles break away from the NCs, which can lead to a bimodal distribution of NCs/NPs.
Different methods such as wet-chemical and physical methods have been demonstrated for the synthesis, but most of the methods require organic solvents and high temperature. The nanoparticles synthesized in aqueous solution or low temperatures often suffer from instability due to the propensity of aggregations. For applications of the NPs as nanoinks or nanopastes for printed conductive devices, most silver-based nanoparticles require relatively high temperatures (>70° C.) to sinter, which is problematic for devices involving temperature-sensitive substrates such as paper substrates. There has been little success in increasing the ability of near-room temperature sintering for silver-based nanoinks or nanopastes.
There has been some success in demonstrating that silver NPs and nanowires (NWs) exhibit room temperature sintering properties in the presence of electrolytic halide. For example, AgCu core-shell NPs synthesized in organic conditions were sintered at room temperature utilizing a reducing agent like hydrazine. In other extant methods, the room-temperature sintering involved galvanic displacement and subsequent electrolytic conditions.
What is therefore needed in this technology is a scalable synthesis of silver-copper (AgCu) alloy NPs and nanoinks with room-temperature sintering capability. The nanoinks/pastes prepared from the AgCu NPs with controllable composition should be stable and easily sinterable on paper or other substrates at ambient temperatures without any subsequent chemical treatments. Such technology would be advantageous in fabricating conductive traces or devices for applications in sensors, solar cells and wearable electronics. It is thus to address the above problems with the prior art and provide this new technology that the present invention is primarily directed.
Briefly described, the present invention provides a scalable wet-chemical synthesis route for AgCu alloy NPs with controllable bimetallic compositions and room-temperature sintering capability. The bimetallic alloy nanoinks presented herein are stable in controlled ink formulations and sinterable under room temperatures. In addition to composition dependence, the dependence of the sintering can also be based on the humidity above the printed nanoink films. The nanoparticles are formulated as inks/pastes for printable applications with a high degree of conductivity. The present bimetallic alloy nanoinks, depending on the composition, display a relatively high degree of stability and scalability. The AgCu alloy nanoparticles of the present invention can be formulated into conductive inks and pastes, and the room temperature sintering capabilities has application in a wide range of technologies, such as in printable electronics and wearable sensors.
In one embodiment, the invention provides a bimetallic, sinterable AgCu alloy composition including AgCu nanoparticles in a molecular structure in a range between Ag10Cu90 and Ag95Cu5, wherein the AgCu nanoparticles further in a size range between 4.5 nm to 11.5 nm, and ethylene glycol, such that the AgCu nanoparticles comprise, at least, 25% by weight of the composition. The composition can further include deionized water and ethanol and be further comprised of 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 30% by weight of ethylene glycol, 30% by weight of deionized water, and 10% by weight of ethanol. In this embodiment, the composition can comprise a nanoink. The AgCu nanoparticles are optimally in a molecular structure of Ag23Cu77.
The composition can further include hydroxyethyl cellulose and be further comprised of 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 50% of a solution of 5% aqueous hydroxyethyl cellulose, and 20% weight of ethylene glycol. In such embodiment, the composition comprises a nanopaste.
In one embodiment, the invention provides a method of making a bimetallic, sinterable AgCu alloy composition, including the steps of providing a container under a constant flow of nitrogen, purging deionized water in the container with nitrogen for a predetermined duration, adding copper (II) nitrate trihydrate to the deionized water, adding sodium citrate to the container, adding silver nitrate to the container, adding sodium borohydride to the container, washing the solution in the container with a capping agent, centrifuging the solution, decanting the solution, and resuspending the remaining powder after the decanting in deionized water. The decanting results in the powder comprising AgCu nanoparticles in a molecular structure in a range between Ag10Cu90 and Ag95Cu5, wherein the AgCu nanoparticles further in a size range between 4.5 nm to 11.5 nm.
The method can include adding ethylene glycol with the AgCu nanoparticles in deionized water such that the AgCu nanoparticles comprise, at least, 25% by weight of the solution. Alternately, the method can include adding copper (II) nitrate trihydrate to the deionized water is adding copper (II) nitrate trihydrate at (Cu(NO3)2·3H2O, 99%), adding silver nitrate to the container is adding silver nitrate at (AgNO3, 99.998%), adding sodium borohydride to the container is adding sodium borohydride powder at (NaBH4, ≥98%), and washing the solution in the container with a capping agent is washing the solution with trisodium citrate dihydrate at (Na3C6H5Na3O7·2H2O, ≥99.0).
Further, the method creates a nanoink by further mixing a solution by adding 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 30% by weight of ethylene glycol, 30% by weight of deionized water, and 10% by weight of ethanol, and ultrasonicating the solution in an ice bath for at least 3 cycles of 15 minutes each. Alternately, the method can include creating a nanopaste by creating a composition by adding 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 50% of a solution of 5% aqueous hydroxyethyl cellulose, and 20% weight of ethylene glycol, and ultrasonicating the composition for 1 hour-15 minute cycles in an ice water bath.
In one embodiment, the method is purging 40 mL of deionized water at 18.2 MΩ with nitrogen for 10 minutes under stirring at 700 RPM, adding 0.100 ml of Cu(NO3)2 at 1 M to the deionized water, adding 0.100 mL of silver nitrate at 1 M, adding sodium borohydride powder at a concentration of NaBH4, ≥98% at 0.25 M, and washing the solution in the container with 0.100 mL of trisodium citrate dihydrate at 0.88 M. The resuspending of the remaining powder after the decanting in deionized water a powder comprised of AgCu nanoparticles results in a solution of the AgCu nanoparticles of about 7.1 nm in diameter, and which contains about 1014 AgCu nanoparticles/mL.
The invention also provides a method of making a printed circuit with an AgCu alloy composition on paper substrates, by preparing a bimetallic, sinterable AgCu alloy composition comprised of AgCu nanoparticles in a molecular structure in a range between Ag10Cu90 and Ag95Cu5, wherein the AgCu nanoparticles further in a size range between 4.5 nm to 11.5 nm, mixing the AgCu alloy composition with, at least, ethylene glycol, wherein the AgCu nanoparticles comprise, at least, 25% by weight of the composition, depositing the mixture on a paper substrate, and sintering the deposited mixture at an ambient temperature.
In one embodiment, the composition used is comprised of 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 30% by weight of ethylene glycol, 30% by weight of deionized water, and 10% by weight of ethanol, and depositing the mixture is printing a nanoink on a paper substrate. In a further embodiment, the composition is further comprised of hydroxyethyl cellulose, 30% by weight of AgCu nanoparticles, 50% of a solution of 5% aqueous hydroxyethyl cellulose, and 20% weight of ethylene glycol, and depositing the mixture is layering a nanopaste on a paper substrate.
In one embodiment, depositing the mixture on the paper substrate is done at thickness between 10 μm to 48 μm. Furthermore, the sintering can be water vapor induced sintering.
The present invention therefore gives an industrial advantage by providing a printable AgCu alloy that is sinterable under ambient temperature. The present invention has industrial applicability in a wide range of technologies, such as in printable electronics, flexible circuit substrates, and wearable sensors. Other advantages of the present invention will be apparent to one of skill in the art after review of the following Specification, Drawings and Claims.
With reference to the figures in which like numerals represent like elements throughout the several views, the invention is composition and method of creating and using a bimetallic, AgCu alloy composition including AgCu nanoparticles, which is sinterable at ambient temperatures, such as room temperature (59° to 77° F./15° to 25° C.). In demonstrating the present invention, metal precursors to produce AgCu NPs were all purchased from Millipore-Sigma. Silver nitrate (AgNO3, 99.998%), Copper (II) nitrate trihydrate (Cu(NO3)2·3H2O, 99%), Trisodium citrate dihydrate (Na3C6H5Na3O7·2H2O, ≥99.0%) was used as the capping agent to prevent aggregation. The reducing agent of sodium borohydride powder (NaBH4, ≥98%) was also required for each synthesis. Hydroxyethyl-cellulose was used as an additive to increase viscosity in nanopaste formulations. Each of the chemical precursors were purchased new and handled with care to avoid contamination.
Bimetallic AgCu nanoparticles (NPs) were synthesized at ambient temperatures using a wet-chemical reduction method by controlling the feeding ratios of the metal precursors. To carry out this synthesis under nitrogen, which prevents copper oxidation and nanoparticle aggregation, a Schlenk line was set up for the entirety of precursor additions. This line carried a constant flow of nitrogen through the whole system and continued for 1 hour after all precursors were added. In a round bottom flask, 40 mL deionized water (DI) at 18.2 MΩ was purged with nitrogen for 10 minutes under stirring at 700 RPM. After purging, 0.100 mL Cu(NO3)2 (1 M) was added to the water via micropipette. Next, a capping agent, 0.100 mL sodium citrate (0.88 M) was added.
The purpose of adding this capping agent directly after the copper was to help increase colloidal stability and decrease aggregation during synthesis. The next step required 0.100 mL AgNO3 (1 M). Lastly, 0.800 mL of reducing agent, NaBH4 (0.25 M), was added slowly in excess to the flask. The formation of the bimetallic NPs was evidenced by the color changes where the solution transitioned from light blue after addition of metal precursors and capping agent to dark brown upon addition of the reducing agent (
Nanoinks were formulated by mixing a solution with 30% by weight NPs, 30% by weight, ethylene glycol, 30% by weight DI water, and 10% by weight ethanol. The mixture was ultrasonicated in an ice bath for 3 cycles of 15 minutes. The mixture was then stored at 5° C. for later use. Nanopastes were formulated with 30% by weight NPs, 50% by weight of 5% hydroxyethyl cellulose(aq), and 20% by weight ethylene glycol. The mixture was then ultrasonicated for the 1-hour-15 minute cycles in an ice water bath, which was stored at 5° C. for later use.
Ultraviolet-Visible Spectroscopy (UV-Vis) was utilized to identify the SPR for various compositions of AgCu NPs. An Agilent 8543 UV-Vis spectrometer with a range of 200-1100 nm and both tungsten and deuterium lamps were used for analysis. A blank of DI water in a disposable cuvette was run before any sample measurements, and a base scan of 150.00 μL of synthesized solution sample was typically analyzed for each solution. Pure silver samples were analyzed with less than 125.00 μL, and Ag23Cu77 samples were analyzed with 250.00 μL.
Inductively Coupled Plasma-Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES) was used to determine the elemental composition of the AgCu NPs. The samples were prepared with concentrated nitric acid and left to decompose the solutions for 1 hour. After the decomposition, the remaining nitric acid was boiled off. The metallic components left in solution after burning all the acid were mixed with DI water and left to cool for another 1 hour. Then, 10 mL of the metal-water mixture was pipetted and analyzed with the ICP-OES instrument.
Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) was used to capture images of the NP surfaces for identifications of NP size, shape, and structure. A JEOL JEM-ARM200F instrument was used and operated at 200 kV. X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) was performed with a Phillips X'pert PW 3040 MPD x-ray diffractometer that was used to collect XRD data for various compositions of AgCu NPs. The NPs were cleaned and stripped of capping agent, then concentrated and dispensed onto quartz crystal.
Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) was also performed with a sample diluted 1:2 with DI water. DLS measurements were recorded using a Zetasizer Ultra (Malvern Panalytical Ltd, UK), fitted with a 10 mW 632.8 nm laser, with measurements performed using a Side Scatter with a 90° scattering angle. Zeta Potential measurements were made with samples diluted 1:2 with DI water. All measurements were recorded using a Zetasizer Ultra (Malvern Panalytical Ltd, UK), fitted with a 10 mW 632.8 nm laser, with measurements performed using a Side Scatter with a 90° scattering angle. Electrical Resistance Measurements of resistances were conducted using a BK Precision 393 Digital Multimeter with an IR USB connection for two-probe measurements. Sheet resistance was measured using a four-probe Digital Multimeter (Suzhou Jingge Electronic M-3).
AgCu NPs were synthesized via chemical reduction in aqueous solutions. Briefly, Cu(NO3)2 was added first to solution, and then capped with the sodium citrate, which produced a coordination complex. The formation of this coordination complex caused a color change from clear to blue. The capping agent also acted as a weak reducing agent to the Cu2+, which reduced the surface energy of the Cu2+ ions and prevented aggregation. The AgNO3 was added directly after the capping agent, where it bound to the capped Cu-ligand complex. No color change was observed at this step. The chemical reducing agent, NaBH4, was then added in excess to the solution. This method produced a solution of the AgCu NPs with excellent suspension, showing no indication of aggregation.
The bimetallic composition of the AgCu NPs is controlled by the feeding ratio of the metal precursors in terms of the moles of AgNO3 and Cu(NO3)2 in the solution. The NP compositions were determined by ICP-OES. The molar feed percentages of Ag and Cu in the solution were compared to the Ag and Cu composition in the NPs that was determined by ICP.
As shown by the plot of Ag % in the NPs vs. Ag % in the solution in
Overall, the experimentally-determined composition established a 1:1 relationship between the NP and feeding compositions, demonstrating that the synthesis itself can be well controlled by the feeding molar ratios of the two metal precursors. Since the NPs were thoroughly washed, by which any presence of monometallic Cu NPs would not have survived due to the propensity of oxidation of Cu back to Cu2+ ions, the observed 1:1 relationship in
To determine the nanoparticle morphology, size and surface properties, TEM, DLS and zeta potential measurements were performed for the NPs synthesized with a series of compositions.
Considering that the as-synthesized bimetallic NPs are very stable in the solution (no indication of aggregation/precipitation for months for NPs with Ag 50%), the different degree of aggregation for the bimetallic NPs revealed by TEM is believed to reflect that the difference of sintering on the TEM grid at the ambient condition between the bimetallic NPs and the pure silver NPs. It is evident that the bimetallic NPs exhibit a greater tendency of aggregation under room temperature on the surface of carbon film of the TEM grid. The increases in particle size for the bimetallic NPs reflect a surface-mediated Ostwald Ripening process, where the larger AgCu nanoparticles were formed at the expense of smaller particles on the surface of carbon film substrate. Apparently, the surface-mediated Ostwald Ripening process is greatly favored as the Cu % is increased in the NPs. This finding is reminiscent of the surface-mediated Ostwald Ripening of AuCu NPs at room temperature. The significance of this finding is that AgCu NPs serve as a new class of room temperature sinterable nanoparticles for the development of printable nano-inks or nano-pastes. The intriguing RT-sinterable properties are further characterized by the following DLS and zeta potential analysis.
Note that agglomeration of nanoparticles could increase the particle size, which is partially responsible for sintering via interparticle coalescence or interparticle necking at room temperature. However, a simple agglomeration process could involve a reversible aggregative process which does not lead to interparticle coalescence or interparticle necking. As shown by the DLS data, the increase of hydrodynamic diameters reflects mostly such a simple agglomeration.
The AgCu NPs of different compositions were further characterized by x-ray diffraction to determine the phase structures and the grain sizes of the NPs.
Further in
Based on the XRD data, the lattice parameters of the AgCu NPs of different compositions were obtained (graph 42) showing that the lattice parameter increases with composition of Ag in the NPs. This trend is consistent with that from Vegard's Law:
where LPAg and LPCu are the lattice parameters of pure metals and x is fraction of the components. Subtle differences are evident between the experimental and theoretical values. The good agreement with Vegard's Law in terms of the fcc alloy's lattice parameter versus. The bimetallic composition is evidence of the presence of Cu in the as-synthesized AgCu NPs. This result also suggests the presence of additional lattice strain for the NPs with a higher Cu %, which likely reflects the nanoscale effect on the lattice strain.
The average grain size was determined through the Scherrer equation:
where τ is the mean particle grain size, K is the shape factor, λ is the x-ray wavelength, β is the line broadening at FWHM, and e is the Bragg angle. The average grain size shows a clear trend of increase with the Ag % composition in the NPs (Graph 44). This further supports the tendency of sintering for the bimetallic NPs. The average grain size on average was slightly different than the particle size determined through TEM, reflecting the difference in NP aggregation of the NP samples.
Silver and copper nanoparticles in solutions exhibit strong localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) bands due to oscillations of surface conduction electron under the electromagnetic field. These oscillations coincide with specific wavelengths of incident light, which can be identified through UV-Vis. The SPR for Ag NPs occurs at a wavelength of 386 nm, while Cu nanoparticles have an expected wavelength of 548 nm. The characterization of the LSPR bands provides information for assessing the composition change and stability of NPs.
Graph 50 shows a representative set of UV-Vis spectra for AgCu NPs with different compositions. First, the intensity LSPR band is shown to decrease with Cu % in the NPs (Graph 50). Second, the LSPR band is shown to display a subtle red shift to longer wavelength, along with the broadening of the band to the longer wavelength (Graph 52). The red shift also depends on other factors, including a change in the refractive index, particle size, or aggregation. The peak shift reflects a combination of the particle size, size distribution and metal composition of the AgCu NPs. While there is no apparent redshift of the peak position toward the copper LSPR band with the increase of Cu %, there is a peak broadening at the longer wavelength range, indicative of the incorporation of copper in the NPs. DLS data showed an increase in size as the Cu % in the NPs is increased, likely reflecting the increase in aggregation.
It is evident that increasing the composition of Ag in the bimetallic NPs produced a stronger and sharper absorbance peak at the Ag SPR. This is consistent with the fact that Ag has the strongest SPR band among the coinage metals. As Cu % is increased, the band width widened, and the absorbance decreased. The linear trend of SPR band with the composition (Graph 52) supports the bimetallic properties of the AgCu NPs with controllable bimetallic compositions. Simulation of the LSPR bands of pure AgNPs and pure CuNPs were also performed using Mie theory for comparison with the experimental UV-Vis. The simulated LSPR bands for AgNPs and CuNPs occur at 386 nm and Cu at 548 nm, respectively. The LSPR band for pure AgNPs shows a sharp and well-defined peak while CuNPs had a much broader SPR.
The stability of AgCu NPs in solutions was also characterized by monitoring the change of SPR band. Graph 54(C) compares the SPR of the 1× Ag86Cu14 NPs in solutions between the inert and ambient conditions. The solutions were prepared under nitrogen conditions of a Schlenk line to prevent any Cu oxidation and subsequent CuO formation. In comparison, the NPs in ambient atmosphere conditions showed a subtle red shift in the width and SPR position. There are two possibilities for the shift. One possibility is the oxidation of the Cu in the NPs due to exposure to O2. However, there is little change in the peak intensity which does not seem to support oxidation. It is likely that the NPs under air caused a certain degree of aggregation due to propensity of the surface Cu to undergo partial oxidation and desorption of the capping ligands. This possibility is supported by the observation of aggregation for the NPs synthesized under ambient conditions, which showed a higher degree of aggregation.
The long-term stability of the AgCu NPs was monitored by UV-Vis over a span of ˜100 days for AgCu NPs of three different compositions, as shown in Graph 54(D). Each cuvette was kept under N2 at room temperature. The NPs with a higher Ag % showed much stronger stability than the other NPs. The NPs with higher Ag % are suspendable in the solution apparently due to suppressed formation of CuO, whereas the Cu-rich particles showed a tendency of precipitation due to formation of CuO. The corresponding DLS and Zeta potential data for Ag86Cu14 and Ag55Cu45 NPs in the solutions after >100 days showed relatively little change to the particle size. The slight shift to smaller particle sizes and slightly broader distribution of zeta potential is due to subtle differences in batch-to-batch synthesis. The slightly broader distribution of zeta potentials is due to the different synthesis batches.
AgCu NPs were formulated into aqueous solution as nanoinks or pastes with a weight percentage of 25% metal NPs and printed onto paper substrates to allow sintering under two different ambient conditions: (1) ambient atmosphere (22° C., ˜18 RH %), and (2) controlled relative humidity (22° C., 1˜90 RH %). The sheet resistance (Ω/□) was measured using a 4-probe multimeter with 2.0-mm probe spacing. A commercial silver ink/paste was also tested for comparison. Table 1 shows a representative set of results for the sheet resistance values determined after drying the traces printed on the paper substrates under ambient condition (room temperature).
For the 25% by weight Ag86Cu14 and Ag55Cu45 inks, the sheet resistances are much lower than that from the 100% commercial silver ink by a factor of 110 and 8, respectively. For Ag23Cu77 nanoink, however, the sheet resistance is greater than that of the commercial silver ink by a factor of 60 and is much greater than the AgCu inks with >50% Ag by 2˜4 of orders of magnitude. The electrical conductivity strongly depends on the bimetallic composition. Using the AgCu nano paste, conductive tracers and interdigitated devices were printed on paper substrates by screen printing.
The printed AgCu alloy traces (picture 60) on the paper substrate, after the ambient sintering, were further examined to assess the device performance upon bending of the paper substrate (illustrative diagram 64).
The room-temperature sintering kinetics were also examined by monitoring the resistance of the conductive traces and the interdigitated microelectrodes (IMEs) on the paper substrate immediately following the screen printing using a stainless steel 325-micron mesh under ambient condition.
The results shown in
For the data with the lower volume of nanoink, the resistance showed a drastic decrease within 50 seconds down to between 2.00-3.50 Ω. For the run with the higher volume of nanoink, it took nearly 100 seconds for the resistance to drastically reduce to a value of 2.000. The change of the resistance (R) can be fitted with a first order rate kinetic model:
where R1 and R2 represent final and initial resistances, respectively, and k is the rate constant for the overall sintering process.
There are two competing processes in sintering. The first is the dominant exponential decay as fitted by the first order kinetic model (eqn. 3). The rate constant k clearly depends on the amount of ink applied to the substrate (0.53 and 0.55 s−1 for 0.5 μL, and 0.17 s−1 for 0.75 μL), with the larger quantity showing a smaller rate constant. The average rate constant (k) is 0.54 s−1. The average final resistance (R1) is 3.7 Ω, and average initial resistance (R2) is 1.5×107 Ω. This process is believed to reflect the aggregation NPs during the initial drying process which is accompanied by the growth of the NPs via Ostwald ripening in the surface-mediated sintering process. The second is a process involving an initial resistance increase followed by resistance decrease, which likely reflects a combination of nucleation and growth processes involved in the Ostwald ripening process. For simplicity, we approximate the reaction times by a simple Gaussian distribution in terms of times:
where C1 represents the peak height (maximum resistance) and C2 corresponds to half width of the peak at about 60% of the peak height; and to represents the peak position (the time taken to reach the maximum resistance). The fitting parameters with these two kinetic equations (eqns. 3 and 4) are shown below in Table 2.
The average peaking time (to) is 4 s, with an average half-width of the time distribution of 4.4 s. The average maximum peak resistance is 3.45×106 Ω. The values of the fitting parameters strongly depend on the volume of the nanoink dispensed on the substrates. When more ink is deposited on the substrate the kinetics follow a slower process, reflecting the dissolution of small particles via Ostwald ripening, which is reminiscent of the observation of the resistance peaking for AuCu NP sintering process. In the sintering process, there is a transition from the not-fully-continuous film (less conductive state) of the sintered domains to a continuous film with the interconnected NPs (more conductive state).
The thickness of the nanoink-printed trace was also controlled by controlling the amount of nanoink deposited on the paper substrate. Measured sheet resistance strongly depends on the thickness of the nanoink-printed trace, which was controlled by dispensing 0.5 μL of Ag86Cu14 (30 wt %) to produce a 1-cm trace in successive layers. The thickness of the traces ranged from 10 to 48 μm. The resistivity of the traces decreases with the thickness, indicating likely the important role of interparticle sintering in addition to surface-mediated sintering. Additional paper substrates were also tested with this nanoink, including cellulose nanofibrous substrates, standard 8G letter paper, and Whatman filter paper (#1), the sintered film on the HP paper showed the lowest resistance. However, a detailed assessment of the substrate dependence remains to be studied in future work.
Given the operation of both interparticle sintering and surface-mediated sintering in the ambient sintering process, we further monitored the sintering process under controlled relative humidity. This experiment is performed by printing a nanoink onto a screen-printed silver IME which is then sintered under ambient conditions. This device is then exposed in a chamber with a controlled humidity at room temperature and concurrent measurement of the resistance.
In contrast, with a nanoink of Ag55Cu45-HydroxyEthyl Cellulose (HEC) (30%-30% by weight) printed on screen-printed silver IME, upon drying under ambient condition, the film has a high 2-probe resistance value (7.00 MΩ) and shows a remarkable reduction of the resistance upon exposing to a controlled humidity of 40% RH at room temperature (
There can be humidity-regulated sintering of AgCu nanoinks with different formulations on IME devices, including bimetallic compositions and cellulose additives (Ag86Cu14, Ag86Cu14-HEC, Ag23Cu77, and Ag23Cu77-HEC). For Ag86Cu14, initial low resistance of the film is indicative of being fully sintered on the substrate before the water vapor treatment is introduced. Upon exposure to water vapor, there is no response in the resistance. For Ag86Cu14-HEC (30% by weight: 30% by weight), there is also no response to humidity, indicative of a film that is already sintered, which is in stark contrast to the Ag55Cu45 HEC (30% by weight: 30% by weight) conductive films. The Ag86Cu14 alloy ink with and without HEC are capable of room temperature sintering without presence of water vapor. For Ag23Cu77, there is a dramatic negative response to the increase of humidity, in sharp contrast to the Ag86Cu14 film. As the humidity increases, the resistance reduces by 4 orders of magnitude, and returns to the original high resistance upon purging with nitrogen. For Ag23Cu77 HEC (30% by weight: 30% by weight), there is also a dramatic negative response to the increase of humidity, similar to that of the Ag55Cu45 film. The un-sintered Ag23Cu77 NPs in a dry state did not undergo sintering even in the presence of water vapor. Instead, it underwent reversible changes in interparticle distances and dielectric medium properties, where HEC additive regulates the adsorption of water vapor in the film.
Based on the recent theoretical simulations on sintering of Ag and Cu NPs, nanoscale Ag and Cu NPs were shown to undergo near room temperature sintering toward bulk conductivity. The adsorption energies of Ag or Cu atom on the surface, where EAg or Cu, Ecellulous surface, and Eatom/metal surface are the total energy for the isolated Ag or Cu atom, the isolated substrate (e.g., cellulose), and the Ag or Cu atom adsorption on metal surfaces, respectively. The activation energy of diffusion (Ediff) is the barrier of the diffusion that was calculated by ΔEa=ETS−EIS, where the energies of the transition state (ETS) and the initial state (EIS) were obtained with ZPE corrections. Theoretical simulations of the sintering processes were carried out in terms of the surface-mediated Ostwald ripening using Gibbs-Thompson (GT) model coupled with modified bond additivity (MBA) model by considering the atom mobilities of the different metals on the surface:
where R is radius of nanoparticle, t is time, Etot is total energy, k is Boltzmann constant, T is temperature, γ is surface free energy, and Ω is atomic volume of bulk metal. R* represents the critical nanoparticle size at which the size neither increases or decreases. K is expressed as K=(2 sin θ)Vp Ω/a(2−3 cos θ+ (cos θ)3), where θ is the contact angle, a is an interatomic distance and Vp is the frequency of thermal vibration of atoms. The total energy (Etot) is expressed as
where ΔHsub is sublimation energy, Eadssupport is the adsorption energy of metal atom on the substrate surface, and Ediffsupport is the activation energy for the diffusion of metal atom on the substrate surface.
To determine a more accurate total energy we also considered the nanoparticle size effect on the sublimation energy, which is expressed as ΔHsub (R)=ΔHsub∞−2εsM/ρR, where ΔHsub (R) is the sublimation energy at a specific size, ΔHsub∞ is the sublimation energy of bulk solid metal, p is the bulk solid phase density, and M is the molar mass. εs is the specific surface energy, expressed as εs(R)=(1−2δ/R+A/R2)εs, where δ is Tolman length with a value of 0.3˜0.6, A(=2πRL) is area, and εs is the specific surface energy of bulk solid. The understanding of the findings is aided by examining how adhesion, mobility and surface free energy of the two types of atoms play a role in the sintering process.
Theoretically, the surface-mediated Ostwald Ripening (OR) based on Gibbs-Thompson model coupled with modified bond additivity (see equations and parameters in Method, including sublimation energy (ΔHsub), adsorption energy (Eads) and activation energy for diffusion (Ediff) of metal atom on the surface was shown to provide a good assessment of the sintering process. Using typical values found for bulk metals, the simulated size evolution for Ag and Cu showed no indication of sintering near room temperature.
With the literature-available bulk and nanoscale parameters for Ag and Cu, we simulated sintering kinetics.
Key parameters used for GT MBA-Model based simulation of the NP sintering on the substrate.
With the calculated size-dependent ΔHsub, and cellulose surface mediated Eads and Ediff, the surface mediated Etot was considered in the GT-MBA simulation. Etot=300.45 and 290.7 KJ/mol for bulk Ag and Cu, respectively.
Further,
Based on Young's equation for surface tensions (γ, surface free energy) vs. contact angle (θ):
the relative change of the Ag/HEC-solution interfacial surface tension upon adsorption of water in the nanoink film is estimated. Consider that the change of contact angle (θ) for the HEC-containing water layer on Ag NP would fall in between 0˜90 degrees depending on the concentration of HEC. The surface free energy of water is 7.3 μJ/cm2. The change of γ(Ag-water) of Ag under water is thus expected to fall in between 0-7.3 (γ(Ag-water)=γ(Ag)−γ(water) cos (θ)). By increasing the surface free energy accordingly for Ag (120, 122, 124, and 126, and 128 μJ/cm2) and Cu(170, 172, 174, 176 and 178 μJ/cm2), the simulations yield the results shown in graphs 102,104. The results indicate, indeed, that the sintering time decreases for the disappearance of smaller Ag and Cu NPs (graphs 90,92) and the sintering temperature decreases for the growth of larger Ag and Cu NPs (96,98). By further considering that the surface free energy of AgCu alloy can be approximated as an average of those of Ag and Cu based on a recent study, i.e., 145 μJ/cm2 from the average of 120 and 170 ρJ/cm2, the results (graphs 94,100) shows that the disappearance of smaller AgCu NPs (graph 94) and the sintering temperature decreases for the growth of larger AgCu NPs.
The surface free energy changes play an important role in the sintering process, as demonstrated by the GT-Model simulation results. It is likely that the surface free energy of the nanoparticles changes upon adsorption of the water vapor in the nanoink-printed film. The surface free energy of the metal nanoparticles is expected to increase upon adsorption of water containing HEC on the surface. Under the elevated RH % in the atmosphere, the adsorption of water would effectively dilute the concentration of HEC near the particle surface, thus leading to the increase of the surface free energy. This results in a decrease of the sintering time. The sintering temperature is shown to drastically reduce. This offers one likely reason to explain the accelerated sintering of AgCu NPs with hydroxyethyl cellulose additive in the ink formulation upon adsorption of water vapor. The hydrophilic HEC additive facilitates the adsorption of water vapor to increase the surface tension, favoring interparticle necking as a sintering mechanism.
The corresponding structures, materials, acts, and equivalents of all means or step plus function elements in the claims below, if any, are intended to include any structure, material, or act for performing the function in combination with other claimed elements as specifically claimed. The description of the present invention has been presented for purposes of illustration and description, but is not intended to be exhaustive or limited to the invention in the form disclosed. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of the invention. The embodiment was chosen and described in order to best explain the principles of one or more aspects of the invention and the practical application, and to enable others of ordinary skill in the art to understand one or more aspects of the invention for various embodiments with various modifications as are suited to the particular use contemplated.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 63/460,162, filed on Apr. 18, 2023, the entirety of which is hereby incorporated herein by this reference.
This invention was made with government support under Grant Award Numbers CHE2102482 and IIP1923323, awarded by the National Science Foundation. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63460162 | Apr 2023 | US |