Payne et al., “Proliposomes: A Novel Solution to an Old Problem”, Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, vol. 75, No. 4, Apr. 1986, pp. 325-329. |
Payne et al., “Characterization of Proliposomes”, Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, vol. 75, No. 4, Apr. 1986, pp. 330-333. |
Fukushima “Improved Oily Foundation Composition”, Patent Abstracts of Japan, vol. 4, No. 73 (C-12)[552], May 1980, No. 55-38332(A). |
French Search Report of FR 91 11985. |
Decison of the Opposition Division (French & English text), EPO, dated Jan. 21, 2000, relating to Appln. No. 92402.3 (European Patent No. 0534823), which claims benefit of F 91 11985, which is the priority document for the present U.S. application. |
Ingredient disclosure statement for Cover Girl Luminesse Lipsticks dated Nov. 4, 1986 (English text). |
“Happi”, Jan. 1998, p. 53. |
Two articles from Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 1986. |
A copy of Proctor & Gamble Company's Request of the Board of Appeal of the EPO to over turn the Opposition Division's Decision concerning grant of European Patent No. 0534823 (undated, English text). |
Affidavit of David Walling executed May 31, 2000, 3 pages including attached Figures A (1 page), B (1 page, color) and C (2 pages, color). |
L'Oreal Response to Appeal of Proctor & Gamble Company Appeal concerning grant of European Patent No. 0534823 (French & English text) dated Feb. 9, 2001 including Figures T1-T7. |
Declaration of Pascal Arnaud (French and English text) (Declaration 1 executed Feb. 8, 2001). |
Declaration of Jean-Thierry Simonnett (French and English text) (Declaration 2 executed Feb. 8, 2001 and containing 7 pages of figures). |
U.S. Patent Appln. Ser. No. 08/115,093 filed Sep. 7, 1993, El-Nokaly et al. |
U.S. Patent Appln. Ser. No. 08/066,351 filed May 21, 1993, El-Nokaly et al. |
U.S. Patent Appln. Ser. No. 07/947,692 filed Sep. 21, 1992, El-Nokaly et al. |
Copy of Communication under Rule 51(4) EPC dated Mar. 26, 1996, with regard to EP Application No. 93921577.8-2114; The Proctor & Gamble Company. |
Opposition paper dated Oct. 8, 1997, with regard to European Appln. No. 0660696 (English text). |
Opposition paper dated Oct. 8, 1997, of L'Oreal with regard to European Application No. 660696 (French & English text). |
English translation of JP 55-38332 (i.e., (26) and document D12 listed in (40 below). |
Communication from the EPO, EPO Form 2318 11.92 dated Nov. 13, 1997 with regard to Opposition of Application No. 93921577.8-2114 (European Patent No. 0660696). |
Copy of EPO Form 2911 10.93 dated Mar. 31, 1998 with regard opposition of Application No. 93921577.8-2114 (European Patent No. 0660696). |
Copy of Statutory Declaration of Magda El-Nokaly executed May 18, 1998 and submitted in connection with Opposition of European Patent No. 0 660 696. |
Observations in Support of Patent in Suit, submitted in opposition of European Patent No. 0660696 (undated but signed by Maura O'Connell). |
Letter of May 22, 1998, to the European Patent Office signed by Maura O'Connell in Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696. |
Copy of Statutory Declaration document M12.06.98 executed May 18, 1998, by Magda El-Nokaly filed in Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696. |
Letter dated Jun. 8, 1998, executed by Maura O'Connell to the European Patent Office with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696. |
Letter of Oct. 6, 1998, executed by Catherine Lhoste with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 660696 (French & English text). |
Copy of letter dated Feb. 3, 1999, executed by Catherine Lhoste with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 660696 (French text). |
Copy of letter dated Nov. 5, 1999, executed by Odile Bredeville to European Patent Office with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 660696 (French & English text). |
Copy of letter dated Dec. 2, 1999, executed by Odile Bredeville to European Patent Office with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 660696 (French & English text). |
Copy of Brief Communication from European Patent Office regarding Summons to Attend the Oral Proceedings with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696 dated Nov. 8, 1999. |
Copy of Summons to Attend the Oral Proceedings dated May 4, 1999, from the European Patent Office with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696. |
“The Lipid Handbook”, Chapman & Hall, second edition (1994) p. 443-446 (document D2 listed in (40)). |
Lutton, E.S., J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc., 42 (1966) p. 1068-1070 (document D3 listed in (40)). |
Product sheet for Hostaphat KO 300 N (document D5 from (40) French text). |
Declaration from M. Simonnet and phase contrast images dated Sep. 26, 1997. |
Cosmetic Research Int. 3 (1991) p. 37. |
“Handbook of surfactantas”, Chapman and Hall (1991) p. 33-34. |
“Cosmetics & Toiletries”, vol. 106 (1991) p. 69-72. |
“International Cosmetic Ingredient Distionary and Handbook” CTFA, seventh ed (1997) vol. 1, p. 819. |
“Cosmetics, Science and Technology”, 1992, vol. 1, p. 27 and 34. |
“CTFA Cosmetic Ingredient Dictionary”, third ed. (1982) p. 325. |
“International Cosmetic Ingredient Dictionary”, fifth ed. (1993) p. 760. |
Declaration 3 from P. Hallegot, dated Jan. 26, 1999 (French & English text). |
Copy of letter dated Feb. 3, 1999 executed by Catherine Lhoste with regard to Oppostiion of European Patent No. 660696 (French & English text). |
Copy of Declaration 1 of P. Arnaud dated Jan. 20, 1999 (French & English text). |
Copy of Declaration 2 of Jean-Thierry Simonnet dated Jan. 25, 1999 (French & English text). |
Copy of minutes in accordance with Rule 76(4) EPC dated Dec. 23, 1999 in Opposition of EP Aplication No. 93921577.8-2114. |
Copy of Description of EP 0 660 696 B1. |
Copy of Interlocutory decision in Opposition proceedings (Article 106(3) EPC) dated Dec. 23, 1999 from European Patent Office, with regard to Opposition of European Patent No. 0660696. |
Copy of Articles 106, 107, 108 from the European Patent Office. |
Copy of 1st Auxilliary Request, Claims with regard to the Opposition of European Patent 0660696. |
Copy of Notice from the European Patent Office signed by Maryse Dainese and dated Mar., 2000 regarding the Appeal in European Patent No. 0660696. |
Copy of letter dated Feb. 22, 2000, signed by Odile Bredeville regarding the Opposition of European Patent No. 660696 (French text). |
Copy of letter dated Apr. 21, 2000, signed by Odile Bredeville regarding the Opposition in European Patent No. 660696 (French & English text). |
Copy of International Search Report in EP 0524 892A, Sep. 16, 1992. |
Copy of letter of May 27, 1998 from Mrs. Lhoste to EPO regarding Patent No. 660697 (French & English text). |
EPO Communication Pursuant to Rule 57(2) dated Aug. 3, 1998 re: Opposition to EP 0660697. |
Brief Communication of EPO dated Feb. 19, 1999 re: Opposition to EP 0660697 with letter of Maura O'Connell dated Feb. 9, 1999 to EPO. |
Copy of letter dated Jun. 22, 1999 of Mrs. Lhoste to EPO re: Opposition to EP 660697 (French & English text). |
Summons to Attend Oral Proceedings Pursuant to Rule 71(1) EPC in Opposition to EP 660697 dated Jul. 27, 2000 with copy of Preparation of Oral Proceedings dated Jul. 6, 2000. |
Copy of letter to EPO dated Nov. 14, 2000 from Mrs. F. Bulle re: Opposition to EP 660697 with attached Declaration of Jean-Claude SER executed Nov. 13, 2000 and attached color Figure (French & English text). |
Copy of letter to EPO dated Nov. 17, 2000 from H.S. Griffiths re: Opposition to EP 660697. |
Brief Communication from EPO dated Nov. 13, 2000 with copy of Nov. 1, 2000 letter from H.S. Griffiths to EPO re: Opposition to EP 660697. |
Brief Communication from EPO dated Nov. 17, 2000 with attached copy of Nov. 14, 2000 letter of Maura O'Connell to EPO. |
Claims of First Auxilliary Request, Second Auxilliary Request, Third Auxilliary Request, Fourth Auxilliary Request, Replacement Main Request, Replacement Auxilliary Request, Replacement Second Auxilliary Request, and Replacement Third Auxilliary Request in Opposition to EP 660697, and copy of Decision of Jun. 21, 1994 in T0565/981—3.3.3 of Board of Appeal of the EPO. |
Brief Communication of EPO dated Apr. 19, 2001 to Mrs. F. Bulle with attached letter of Apr. 6, 2001 from Maura O'Connell to EPO re: Opposition of EP 660697. |
Decision revoking th European Patent (Article 102(1), (3) EPC)—EP 660697 dated Apr. 19, 2001. |
Appeal notice of Maura O'Connell to EPO dated Jun. 21, 2001 re: Opposition of EP 660697. |
EPO Board Appeal notice dated Jun. 29, 2001 to Mrs. F. Bulle re: Opposition of EP 660697. |
EPO Board of Appeal letter and Article 108 Communication dated Sep. 13, 2001 re: Opposition to EP 660697. |
Decision of the Technical Board of Appeal 3.3.7 of Dec. 17, 2001 re: Opposition of EP 660697. |
Cosmetics Science and Technology, 2nd Ed., vol. 1, Wiley Interscience, 1972, Chapter 12, p. 365-392, Lauffer, Chapter 12 “Lipsticks”. |
The Chemistry and Manufacture of Cosmetics, 22 Ed. vol. IV, 1975, Chapter 44, pp. 767-840, deNavarre, “Lipstick”. |
English translation of JP-A-1 1439812. |
Declaration of Jean-Thierry Simonnet executed Apr. 7, 2000 (marked “Annex D36” (French text) (English translation attached)). |
Declaration of Philippe Hallegot executed Apr. 12, 2000 (marked “Annex D37” (French text) (English translation attached). |
Declaration of Jean-Pierre Lechaire executed Apr. 13, 2000 (marked “Annex D38” (French text) (English translation attached). |
Cosmetics Science and Technology, 2nd Ed., vol. 1, Wiley Interscience, 1972, Chapter 12, p. 365-392, Lauffer, Chapter 12 “Lipsticks” (document “(9)”) in (85) above). |
Declaration of Pascal Arnaud executed Apr. 7, 2000 (marked “Annex D35” (French text) (English translation attached). |
English translation and Japanese text of JP-A-55038332 (document “(4)” in (85) above). |