The present invention generally relates to gas chromatography, and more particularly to valve based modulation for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography.
Multi-dimensional gas chromatography is an advanced field where multiple gas-phase separations are performed in series on a single sample. A modulator is used to periodically collect and inject effluent from each separation column into a subsequent separation column. Typically, the modulator is actuated according to a constant schedule. It is necessary to tune the separation of each subsequent stage, such that an entire separation is completed within each cycle of the modulator. This sequence allows for independent determination of the retention time of each component on each dimension of the separation. Absent a modulation device, determination of the retention characteristics of each dimension is not easily isolated and may be superimposed. It is common practice in the art to use two stages, sometimes with multiple parallel separations in each dimension. The use of two stages is typically referred to as comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (abbreviated herein as GCXGC, GC-GC, or 2DGC).
The term comprehensive is applied to methods where the entire injected sample is analyzed in the system. Although, in some cases, systems that analyze less than 100% of the sample are still considered comprehensive, for example, if the modulation frequency is high-enough that a reasonable time resolution of the first dimension separation is still achieved, as described in United States Patent Application Publication No. 20020148353 A1 of Seeley. GCXGC methods that rely on two parallel columns in the second dimension have been referred to as GCX2GC. However, these methods are clearly a sub-class of GCXGC, and therefore the term GCXGC will be predominately used herein.
The modulator in a GCXGC instrument is highly recommended. Only by capturing the effluent from the first dimension column and reintroducing it as an injection to the second dimension column(s), can the retention times of both columns be known simultaneously, while still producing a two-dimensional separation.
The modulation frequency is the frequency at which the collected sample is injected into the second dimension column. Typically, this is on the order of 1 cycle per 1-10 seconds (e.g., 0.10-1.0 Hz). In common practice, the modulation frequency is determined by the time scale of the second dimension separation (e.g., typically 1-10 seconds). Based on this value, the time scale of the first dimension separation is then designed, such that each eluting peak will be modulated into several or more injections to the second dimension. However, with most modulators the flow from the first and second dimension columns are related, and therefore independently optimizing the flow conditions of the first and second dimensions is difficult. A modulator that isolates the first and second dimension column flow rates provides a significant advantage in allowing independent flow optimization for both separations. The isolation of flows also allows for much faster separations, as many high speed GC configurations require much faster flow rates than are typically used for first dimension separations.
Generally, the first dimension separation is intentionally designed to produce wider eluting bands (and e.g., longer separation times) in order to be compatible with slower modulation frequencies and longer second dimension separations.
An advantage of GCXGC is the order of magnitude improvement in peak capacity over single-dimension separations. Single dimension systems with multiple columns offer similar avenues of selectivity. However, they do not offer the peak capacity of GCXGC. Another advantage to GCXGC, with certain modulators, is improved signal to noise ratios and therefore lower system levels of detection, but this may be heavily dependent on the type of modulator and the nature of the second dimension separation.
Modulators for GCXGC can be grouped into two categories, thermal modulators and valve modulators, wherein thermal modulators function through temperature cycling of a segment of column, bare tubing, or adsorbent/absorbent filled tubing. The sample is captured and periodically thermally desorbed into the second stage (e.g., the modulator is repeatedly heated and cooled). The main advantage with thermal modulators is a significant increase in analyte concentration (and e.g., proportional decrease in system limits of detection) via the preconcentration provided by the trapping of sample in the “cold” regions of the modulator. However, typical thermal modulators require that the carrier gas flow from the first dimension also be used for the second dimension, which can make it difficult to optimize flow conditions for both separation stages. Another advantage to thermal modulators is that, due to rapid heating cycles, they are capable of generating very sharp injection pulses that permit faster and higher resolution separations in the second dimension. The resolution of the second dimension is the major contributor to the total peak capacity of the whole GCXGC system. A potential disadvantage to thermal modulators is the vapor pressure range limitation of most thermal cycling systems. For example, for virtually all types of adsorbent materials or trapping temperatures some vapors will be too volatile to adsorb/absorb and some will be too low in volatility to be easily desorbed, for a given temperature range.
Valve modulators can act to divert flow between multiple flow paths to achieve pulses of effluent entering the first column, for example, as described in United States Patent Application Publication No. 20020148353 A1 of Seeley. Commonly, vents are used at one or more connections, which is a potential source of sample loss (and therefore a non-comprehensive GCXGC separation), and dilution is often a side-effect of the flow manipulation process. Often, a two-position three-way valve or a sampling valve is used to collect the sample and reintroduce it into the second dimension column. Common examples of these valves are rotary valves with sampling loops or sampling grooves on the rotor, face-sealing valves with rotary or sliding plates, and diaphragm valves with sample grooves or external sampling loops.
Valve modulators have the advantage of avoiding the engineering issues of repetitive modulator heating and cooling, and therefore are more durable, easier to manufacture, and usually capable of much faster modulation frequencies. Valve modulators also have the advantage of not being limited to specific analyte vapor pressure ranges, as is the case with thermal modulators. In some cases, an additional advantage arises in the isolation of carrier gas flows, which results in easier flow optimization. However, the significant disadvantage to valve modulators is that little or no increase in sample concentration is achieved and the injection pulses are therefore generally wider than for thermal modulators.
Therefore, there is a need for a method and apparatus (which also may be referred to herein as a “system”) that addresses the above and other problems. The above and other needs and problems are addressed by the exemplary embodiments of the present invention, which provide a method and apparatus, including a valve based modulation technique for two-dimensional gas chromatography (e.g., GCXGC, GC-GC, or 2DGC) and which has several advantages. In combination with dual high-pressure detectors, significant improvements in system performance are possible. A traditional first dimension GC separation is performed and the effluent exits into a sampling valve. The valve is designed such that it has two positions, both of which allow for collection of an effluent sample and injection of a previously collected sample. The valve is cycled between the two positions, such that collected samples are introduced into each of two secondary columns in an alternating fashion. Advantageously, this allows for a two-fold increase in the modulation frequency, without a reduction in the separation time of either of the second stage separations (or conversely, a 2-fold increase in separation time in the second dimension with no reduction in modulation frequency). In addition, the valve provides flow isolation between all three columns, allowing for true optimization of all columns' flow rates. By pressurizing each of the second stage separations (e.g., via a restrictor or any suitable back-pressure regulator on each of the respective outlets of the detectors), the sample can be compressed during the introduction to each of the second stages, resulting in a significant increase in analyte concentration, which will significantly improve limits of detection. A reduced modulator injection band width has significant implications for the second dimension separation. For example, faster and/or higher resolution separations become possible and total peak capacity is increased. Compression ratios of 100:1 or more are easily achievable.
Accordingly, in exemplary aspects of the present invention there is provided an apparatus for two-dimensional gas chromatography, comprising: a valve including first and second positions, and first, second, third, and fourth flow paths, wherein the valve, while in the first position, is configured to: collect a first gas sample from a first dimension gas chromatography column via the first flow path, provide a connection between a first pressure source and a first, second dimension gas chromatography column via the second flow path, provide a connection between a second pressure source and a second, second dimension gas chromatography column via the third flow path, and maintain the fourth flow path in a disconnected state; and the valve, while in the second position, is configured to: introduce the first collected gas sample in the first flow path to the second, second dimension gas chromatography column via the first flow path, with aid of the second pressure source, collect a second gas sample from the first dimension gas chromatography column via the second flow path, provide a connection between the first pressure source and the first, second dimension gas chromatography column via the fourth flow path, and maintain the third flow path in a disconnected state. The valve may be a sliding-plate type valve, or a rotary type valve.
The apparatus for two-dimensional gas chromatography may be further described wherein a time to collect the first gas sample before moving the valve to the second position is equal to or less than a volume of the first gas sample divided by a volumetric flow rate of an outlet of the first dimension gas chromatography column. In addition, the time spent by the valve in the second position may be equal to the time to collect the first gas sample. A separation time may be employed on both the first and second, second dimension gas chromatography columns, which may be less than a total time spent in the first and second valve positions, and which may be equal to twice a reciprocal of a modulation frequency.
The apparatus may further comprise an injector coupled to an inlet of the first dimension gas chromatography column for injecting a gas to be analyzed into the first dimension gas chromatography column. Such apparatus may further comprise a first restrictor coupled to the valve for restricting the gas injected into the first dimension gas chromatography column by the injector to increase a compression ratio in the first dimension gas chromatography column.
The apparatus for two-dimensional gas chromatography may also comprise a first detector coupled to an outlet of the first, second dimension gas chromatography column for performing gas chromatography detection in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column. Such apparatus may further comprise a second restrictor coupled to the first detector for restricting gas in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column to increase a compression ratio in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column. It should be noted however, that the first detector may comprise a thermal conductivity detector (TCD).
The apparatus for two-dimensional gas chromatography may also comprise a second detector coupled to an outlet of the second, second dimension gas chromatography column for performing gas chromatography detection in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column. Such apparatus may further comprise a third restrictor coupled to the second detector for restricting gas in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column to increase a compression ratio in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column. It should be noted however, that the second detector may comprise a thermal conductivity detector (TCD).
In another aspect of the present invention there is provided a method for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography conducted with a valve having first and second positions, and first, second, third, and fourth flow paths, the method comprising: putting the valve in the first position, and: collecting a first gas sample from a first dimension gas chromatography column via the first flow path, providing a connection between a first pressure source and a first, second dimension gas chromatography column via the second flow path, providing a connection between a second pressure source and a second, second dimension gas chromatography column via the third flow path, and maintaining the fourth flow path in a disconnected state; putting the valve in the second position, and: introducing the first collected gas sample in the first flow path to the second, second dimension gas chromatography column via the first flow path, with aid of the second pressure source, collecting a second gas sample from the first dimension gas chromatography column via the second flow path, providing a connection between the first pressure source and the first, second dimension gas chromatography column via the fourth flow path, and maintaining the third flow path in a disconnected state. Furthermore, the valve may be a sliding-plate type valve, or a rotary type valve.
The method for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography may be further described wherein setting a time to collect the first gas sample before moving the valve to the second position may be equal to or less than a volume of the first gas sample divided by a volumetric flow rate of an outlet of the first dimension gas chromatography column. In addition, setting a time spent by the valve in the second position may be equal to the time to collect the first gas sample. Setting a separation time may be employed on both the first and second, second dimension gas chromatography columns to less than a total time spent in the first and second valve positions, and equal to twice a reciprocal of a modulation frequency.
The method may further comprise the step of injecting a gas to be analyzed into the first dimension gas chromatography column via an injector coupled to an inlet of the first dimension gas chromatography column. Such method may include restricting the gas injected into the first dimension gas chromatography column by the injector to increase a compression ratio in the first dimension gas chromatography column via a first restrictor coupled to the valve.
The method for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography may further comprise the step of performing gas chromatography detection in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column via a first detector coupled to an outlet of the first, second dimension gas chromatography column. Such method may include restricting gas in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column to increase a compression ratio in the first, second dimension gas chromatography column via a second restrictor coupled to the first detector. The first detector may be a thermal conductivity detector (TCD).
The method may further comprise the step of performing gas chromatography detection in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column via a second detector coupled to an outlet of the second, second dimension gas chromatography column. Such method may include restricting gas in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column to increase a compression ratio in the second, second dimension gas chromatography column via a third restrictor coupled to the second detector. The second detector may comprise a thermal conductivity detector (TCD).
In a further aspect of the present invention there is provided an apparatus for gas chromatography, comprising: a valve including first and second positions, and first, second, third, and fourth flow paths, wherein the valve, while in the first position, is configured to: collect a first sample from a sample source via the first flow path, provide a connection between a first pressure source and a first gas chromatography column via the second flow path, provide a connection between a second pressure source and a second gas chromatography column via the third flow path, and maintain the fourth flow path in a disconnected state; and the valve, while in the second position, is configured to: introduce the first collected sample in the first flow path to the second gas chromatography column via the first flow path, with aid of the second pressure source, collect a second sample from the sample source via the second flow path, provide a connection between the first pressure source and the first gas chromatography column via the fourth flow path, and maintain the third flow path in a disconnected state. The first and second samples may be in a gas phase, or in a liquid phase. However, where the first and second samples are in a liquid phase, the apparatus may comprise a chamber provided between the sample source and the valve, wherein the chamber is configured to convert the first and second samples in the liquid phase to a gas phase.
In another aspect of the invention there is provided a method for gas chromatography conducted with a valve having first and second positions, and first, second, third, and fourth flow paths, the method comprising the steps of: putting the valve in the first position, and: collecting a first sample from a sample source via the first flow path, providing a connection between a first pressure source and a first gas chromatography column via the second flow path, providing a connection between a second pressure source and a second gas chromatography column via the third flow path, and maintaining the fourth flow path in a disconnected state; putting the valve in the second position, and: introducing the first collected sample in the first flow path to the second gas chromatography column via the first flow path, with aid of the second pressure source, collecting a second sample from the sample source via the second flow path, providing a connection between the first pressure source and the first gas chromatography column via the fourth flow path, and maintaining the third flow path in a disconnected state. The first and second samples may be in a gas phase, or in a liquid phase. However, where the first and second samples are in a liquid phase, the method may further comprise converting the first and second samples in the liquid phase to a gas phase via a chamber provided between the sample source and the valve.
Still other aspects, features, and advantages of the present invention are readily apparent from the entire description thereof, including the figures, which illustrates a number of exemplary embodiments and implementations. The present invention is also capable of other and different embodiments, and its several details can be modified in various respects, all without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Accordingly, the drawings and descriptions are to be regarded as illustrative in nature, and not as restrictive.
The embodiments of the present invention are illustrated by way of example, and not by way of limitation, in the figures of the accompanying drawings and in which like reference numerals refer to similar elements and in which:
Various embodiments and aspects of the invention will now be described in detail with reference to the accompanying figures. The terminology and phraseology used herein is solely used for descriptive purposes and should not be construed as limiting in scope. Language such as “including,” “comprising,” “having,” “containing,” or “involving,” and variations thereof, is intended to be broad and encompass the subject matter listed thereafter, equivalents, and additional subject matter not recited.
Referring now to the drawings, wherein like reference numerals designate identical or corresponding parts throughout the several views, and more particularly to
Each of the
In each case, as shown in
The term modulation frequency can create some ambiguity, as the frequency of the actuation of the valves 118, 218 and 318 is twice that of the frequency of injection into each second stage column (i.e., second dimension column). In the context of the present invention, the modulation frequency refers to the actuation frequency, or twice the injection frequency into each of the second dimension columns 114 and 116, although the injection to GC2a (column 114) is offset from the injection to GC2b (column 116) by one actuation.
In position 1, as shown in
By restricting the detector 104 and 106 outlets via the respective restrictors 120 and 122, the inlet pressure of the second dimension columns 114 and 116 (GC2a and GC2b, respectively) can be elevated substantially. When the valve 118, 218 or 318 is actuated, the sample volume is compressed, which elevates analyte concentrations and reduces the injection band width proportionally. This generates significantly larger detector 104 and 106 signal-to-noise ratios (e.g., decreasing system limits of detection) for the same analyte sample. Compression ratios of 100:1 are easily achieved. In an exemplary embodiment, the detectors 104 and 106 are configured so as to be (1) capable of operating at this elevated pressure, and (2) have an outlet flow that can reasonably be restricted (e.g., a flame ionization detector with excessive exhaust gases would not be ideal). For example, a thermal conductivity detector (TCD), and the like, can be employed for the detectors 104 and 106. Advantageously, the TCD response time can be enhanced, because of the decreased mean free path of the carrier gas, as a result of the pressure elevation. However, in further exemplary embodiments, any other suitable detector can be employed, as will be appreciated by those skilled in the relevant art(s).
A compression ratio of 100:1 is large compared to the “preconcentration” factors typically observed with thermal modulators. Similar values could be obtained with very slow modulation frequencies with thermal modulators, but the cost of a decreased modulation frequency would be a substantially longer experiment time and/or decreased first-dimension time resolution. With the exemplary embodiments, however, signal-to-noise ratio enhancement is possible, while still maintaining or even increasing the modulation frequency (e.g., minimizing the time scale of the second dimension separation).
In
Similarly,
Advantageously, the physical distance employed for actuation with the valves 118 and 318 can be relatively small, and with no connecting flow paths (e.g., tubes or grooves 126-132 in the rotor 504 or the sliding-plate 404) that must pass over other entry or exit ports during actuation, before arriving to the final location.
Various advantages are provided by modulation scheme of the exemplary embodiments, for example, including (1) improved signal to noise ratio and injection band widths by virtue of the compression resulting from the high pressure second dimension columns; (2) increased modulation frequency by virtue of the valve design and dual second dimension columns; (3) flow isolation for all three columns and therefore independent flow optimization for all columns; (4) the capability of using different stationary phases on the two second dimension columns to enhance the selectivity of the separation; (5) improved capability for 100% sample transfer between the first and second dimensions, by virtue of the valve design and dual second dimension columns (which is usually not the case with valve modulators, for example, as described in United States Patent Application Publication No. 20020148353 A1 of Seeley); (6) the potential for integration with microfabricated components (e.g., such as valves, columns, and detectors); (7) the capability of achieving a faster and/or higher resolution GCXGC separation by taking advantage of the faster modulation frequency and sharp second dimension injections and therefore the ability to tolerate sharper first dimensional peaks; and (8) this valve modulator, unlike most previously known, does not generate dilution in the process of manipulating the flow.
Further embodiments are also possible. For example, a variety of other valve types can employed based on the teachings of the exemplary embodiments so as to provide similar flow configurations. In further exemplary embodiments, a single second dimension column can be used that is connected by a tee junction to both valve injection points. Similarly, both second dimension columns can be coated with the same stationary phase, if the additional selectivity of a third stationary phase is not necessary. More than two second dimension columns can also be employed, with a suitable valve design, and which would allow for even faster modulation frequencies. In addition, the modulation frequency can be further increased, without increasing valve actuation times or reducing second dimension separation times, by employing several valve modulators in parallel, each configured as in
In further exemplary embodiments, the exemplary sliding-plate valve configuration of
In
All or a portion of the devices and subsystems of the exemplary embodiments can be conveniently implemented by the preparation of application-specific integrated circuits or devices and/or by interconnecting an appropriate network of conventional component circuits and/or devices, as will be appreciated by those skilled in the relevant art(s). Thus, the exemplary embodiments are not limited to any specific combination of hardware circuitry and/or devices.
Although the exemplary embodiments are described in terms of sliding-plate, and rotary valve configurations, the exemplary embodiments can be employed with any other suitable valve configurations, as will be appreciated by those skilled in the relevant art(s).
While the present inventions have been described in connection with a number of exemplary embodiments, and implementations, the present inventions are not so limited, but rather cover various modifications, and equivalent arrangements, which fall within the purview of the present claims.
The present application is based on and claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/140,094, filed Dec. 23, 2008.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4016074 | Porter | Apr 1977 | A |
4962662 | Berger | Oct 1990 | A |
5049509 | Szakasits et al. | Sep 1991 | A |
5152176 | Bryselbout et al. | Oct 1992 | A |
5281256 | Sacks et al. | Jan 1994 | A |
5611846 | Overton et al. | Mar 1997 | A |
6575015 | Lechner-Fish et al. | Jun 2003 | B2 |
6776025 | Lechner-Fish | Aug 2004 | B2 |
6968729 | Karlsson et al. | Nov 2005 | B1 |
7241424 | Guan et al. | Jul 2007 | B2 |
8322189 | Wang | Dec 2012 | B2 |
20020148353 | Seeley | Oct 2002 | A1 |
20070193336 | McCurry et al. | Aug 2007 | A1 |
20080092639 | Lee | Apr 2008 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
1257461 | Dec 1971 | GB |
1291724 | Oct 1972 | GB |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20100154511 A1 | Jun 2010 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61140094 | Dec 2008 | US |