The invention, in its several forms, relates generally to techniques for such things as facilitating the containment and recovery of a lighter-than-water substance, such as crude oil, emanating into a body of water from a source down from the surface of the body of water, such as from a leaking oil well at the bottom of a sea or ocean.
Off-shore oil drilling is widely practiced but is subject to concerns about harm to marine life and shoreline beaches, flora, fauna and habitations in the event of oil leakage which can be quite serious ecologically and economically as shown by the 2010 experience in the Gulf of Mexico, as one example.
Drilling techniques have been developed to an extent that allows successful drilling and oil recovery at very deep locations, such as a mile or more from the wellhead to the surface. The oil rig provides for travel of the oil through a pipe or conduit. There is also technology, such as the use of blow-out preventers, for preventing or limiting release of oil into the sea water in the event there is a failure in the structure at the wellhead. However, devices such as blow-out preventers are also subject to mechanical failure and the entire operation of an off-shore drilling rig or platform is subject to some risk of human operator errors that can result in serious leakage.
Such problems can occur in wells at any depth but can be aggravated in very deep water because the distance from the surface and the greater water pressure at such depths prevents or severely limits human and, also, robotic accessibility to the wellhead site. Likewise, those circumstances, combined with the pressure or force of oil discharged from the wellhead, make it difficult to cap or seal the well by massive closed structures or materials lowered from the surface intended to block the escape of any oil.
In addition to escaping oil, there can be massive volumes of gas escaping from the wellhead that is immediately subjected to the high pressure of the deep water plus the very cold temperature prevalent at great depths. These can cause gas, or other substances in the crude oil, to condense or freeze and interfere with passage of the oil through a conduit to the surface even after a closed structure is placed over the wellhead. Consequently, it can be necessary to additionally provide a way to improve recovery of the gases, as well as oil, from the leak site.
Prior efforts to devise leak containment systems have taken account of the well known fact that oil, and gas, from a leak site is normally less dense than sea water and will rise through the water toward the surface. However, it is not believed that prior systems are sufficiently practical in terms of one or more of their characteristics including material costs, the facility with which the necessary apparatus can be put in place, and the ease of confinement and recoverability of the rising oil and gas. The deficiencies of such known prior systems appear particularly to hinder their application in instances of leakages from sites that are quite deep, such as in excess of a mile.
The ultimate recourse is often to drill an auxiliary relief well through the sea floor to the underlying oil deposit to try to relieve pressure from the leaking well. That is a partial remedy, at best, that is quite costly and can take a long time to do.
Any strategies employed to stop or control serious leakage still tend to leave a major risk of harm from the already escaped oil, and that oil is difficult to clean up or recover economically.
Consequently, new techniques for dealing with undersea oil leaks are highly desirable in order to make existing off-shore oil wells less risky and to have better assurance of safety for drilling to occur at additional sites.
Various forms of the invention are presented with several examples that take advantage of the difference in density between oil that escapes into sea water and the sea water itself and which are readily adaptable to leak sites of any depth, including those more than a mile below the surface.
Techniques are presented that can make the depth of the leak relatively insignificant. Deep water distances, pressures and temperatures are not a serious impediment to the practice of these techniques, which also show considerable opportunity for rapid deployment at modest cost.
Briefly, and by way of example, an inventive apparatus can include one or more canopies with certain related structures to be described. For this example, a “canopy” is an open-sided enclosure such as a sheet of material that is at least substantially impervious to both oil and water (at least when no substantial pressure differential exists on opposite sides of the sheet, which is the case most expected). A canopy can, by way of further example, be like or similar to the material and configuration of a hot air balloon, without its ancillary basket, heater, and gas fill.
If one canopy is used, it can be arranged with a main cable to, and through, its top center (in a liquid tight fitting) to a location within a volume enclosed laterally by the canopy with some peripheral canopy locations connected by tie cables to the main cable with weights at some of the same or different locations of the canopy periphery for gravity descent of the canopy through the water. A canopy does not need to fit around its whole periphery securely against the sea floor; it is open enough to permit easy entrance and exit of liquids, in both directions, between the canopy and the sea floor, or through openings near the bottom of the canopy. Some additional lateral rigid structure can be included, if desired, as part of the weight structure to make sure the canopy stays in a substantially fully open orientation. A weighted ring around the bottom of the canopy, with openings for fluid exchange, can avoid any need for a lateral structure. A cross-section diameter of about 25 feet to 50 feet is a convenient size for the open side of the canopy for some applications where that size is sufficient to cover a wellhead, including features at the wellhead such as a blowout preventer.
Various other forms and arrangements of canopies will be described in the text below.
To practice a method in accordance with an example of the invention, with a single canopy apparatus, steps are performed that include lowering the main cable of the apparatus into the sea over the leak so that the weighted canopy vertically covers the wellhead and the peripheral weight at the canopy edge holds it in place against the sea bottom while openings at the periphery of the canopy allow sea water under the canopy to be displaced by oil from the leak, because the oil (as well as any gas) will rise in the water due to the differential density.
If the single canopy were allowed to fill completely with oil, subsequent oil from the leak would again escape; the canopy is not, in this example, intended to totally enclose it. To avoid this, a step is performed of drawing oil out of the top inner portion of the canopy while it is so placed. This oil can be withdrawn, for example through one or more flexible conduits that descend with the main cable to the top of the canopy.
In this way, as soon as the invention is used, which can be done quite rapidly, two functions are performed: one is that the oil from the leak is contained to minimize any escaping into the sea water and, two, the oil can instead be readily recovered and used without extensive cleanup operations.
In some examples, a multi-canopy apparatus is used and can provide greater convenience for leaks at greater depths and larger leaks with oil quantities greater than those conveniently removed by a conduit from a single canopy. Here, a first canopy can be as described above and one or more additional similar canopies, each with some peripheral weights and openings for fluid interchange, are attached at their centers in series on the main cable above the first canopy. Each successive canopy can, for example, be the same size or successively larger in cross-section than the one below it. The number of canopies applied in a multi-canopy system is readily varied to extend from a deep leak to the surface with means for upward, confined, transfer of the leaking fluids between canopies to the surface.
A method of operating with a multi-canopy apparatus can include allowing any oil that exceeds the capacity of any conduit from the first canopy to rise from the first canopy into the second canopy and successively up the entire series of canopies which can be up to sea level. Oil in the final canopy can be readily withdrawn. In addition, oil from the flexible conduit from the first canopy or from any additional conduits from other intermediate canopies can result in more complete recovery of the leaking oil. For a leak from a depth of one mile approximately 25 to 50 canopies in series might be used, each about 25 to 50 feet across at the bottom and having a vertical dimension of about 100 to 200 feet. However, there is a wide choice of sizes and shapes of canopies that can perform the functions of containing and recovering the oil.
Various embodiments of the invention are shown by way of example. A common aspect of them is that advantage is taken of the lighter density of leaked oil (or gas), or at least a substantial amount of what may leak, compared to the density of sea water and they are readily adaptable for use at leaks of any depth. The use of such innovations has the potential of avoiding a great deal of expense and damage.
Further explanations and examples of various aspects of the invention are presented below.
Referring to
The wellhead 22 is typically attached to the drill pipe 20 by a blowout preventer (BOP) 11 for the purpose of preventing oil from gushing out into the water 12 if there is damage to the drill pipe 20 or other equipment of the rig 15.
A failure or breakage causing a serious leak giving rise to a need for a remedy, as the following invention embodiments provide, might occur anywhere in the system, either at, above or below the BOP 11 or the wellhead 22. In this illustration a failure or breakage has occurred at a point 23 of the drill apparatus that allows oil 24 to escape from its intended passageway in equipment 20 into the water 12. Once there, it rises because it is lighter than the water 12 and is subject to currents and tidal forces to drift over the water surface and form an oil layer (or oil slick) 26 that can extend over a very large area. The invention (not shown in
A canopy 30 is shown that is similar in shape to an umbrella, or it could be thought of as similar to a hot air balloon turned upside down so its narrowest part is at the top, and with a section of the former top removed. It can be generally round with a generally circular perimeter at the bottom of the canopy. As will be seen, the particular shape of the canopy is not limited to that shown. For example, it need not be so hemispherical, it could have a more tapered configuration (like that of a hot air balloon as mentioned above). It is also not necessarily round, and its vertical dimension can be significantly greater compared to its horizontal dimension than that shown here.
The canopy 30 can be of any material that is capable of preventing fluids (i.e., oil or water) from passing through it. Hot air balloon type material is just one example. A flexible and collapsible material may be chosen for convenience in transport and storage but a rigid canopy can also be suitable. The example illustration of
Some elements of and with the example canopy 30 are a weight 32, either unitary (such as a thick metal cable) or in multiple elements, at the bottom edge or periphery of the canopy. Here the element 32 is shown as a strip or ring, such as of steel cable fastened to and extending more or less continuously along the edge of the canopy 30. Additional weights (not shown) may be attached to opposing points of the cable 32, outside the canopy 30, in this example. Many different forms of weights could be provided with, or instead of, the cable 32.
Another aspect is that there are openings 34 occurring at various locations at the bottom of the canopy 30. The openings 34 are to allow water to pass relatively freely from the inside to the outside of the canopy 30. The size, shape and exact location of the openings can be quite variable as will be apparent from the ensuing description of the operation of the apparatus.
The cable 36 is for lowering the canopy 30 into the water over the wellhead (such as location 22 of
The cable 36 can be affixed to the canopy 30 at a joint 36a, here just illustrated as a small point. Often this would be a fluid tight joint; the tightness of the joint 36a is less important if the cable 36 has one or more additional canopies above the one shown. Alternatively, or additionally, the cable 36 may be affixed to the weight 32 by means of tie cables 35 that extend from the main cable at the joint 36a to points on the cable 32. All the mechanical elements described may take a variety of forms to perform their indicated functions.
The canopy 30 with the conduit 38 is an example primarily for, but not restricted to, an arrangement with a single canopy 30 on a cable 36. Where present in a single canopy arrangement the conduit 38 may have a fluid tight joint 38a with the canopy 30 so oil can be safely transferred to the platform above and then transferred elsewhere as desired.
While a single canopy 30 as shown in
In a multiple canopy arrangement, oil could be withdrawn to the surface from any, but not necessarily all, of the canopies. It is usually the case for at least the uppermost canopy of a series of multiple canopies to have a conduit for recovery of substantially all of the leakage fluid. That conduit can be joined to the uppermost canopy at or near the sea surface so it can be selected for attachment, or replaced if needed, to have a size for adequate capacity. Reference to “a conduit” herein is, of course, not meant to restrict an embodiment of the apparatus to only a single conduit from a particular canopy; multiple conduits may be applied as needed or desired.
Oil from the wellhead 122 rises within the bottom canopy 130a and displaces water (represented by arrows W1) that passes out through openings 134 like or similar to openings 34 of
In the example of
The first canopy 130a is provided with one or more openings at its top for upward flow of oil that is not withdrawn, by suction, through the conduit 138 which has an open end in the canopy 130a. The openings and the oil flow through them are represented by the arrows P1 indicating oil (petroleum) flowing from the inner volume of the first canopy 130a into the second canopy 130b. (The conduit 138 and openings for oil flow P1 (either one or both together) are examples of elements of what is sometimes referred to herein as an “exit arrangement” for removal of fluid from a canopy.)
The second canopy 130b can be (but need not be) similar in size, shape, and overall features as the first canopy 130a. The second canopy 130b is physically attached to the first canopy 130a. For example, a cable 132 or some other weight element on the lower edge of the second canopy 130b can be secured, such as by loops (not shown), to the outside of the upper part of the first canopy 130a. A similar relation and attachment may be present between each successive pair of canopies.
Either or both of the intermediate canopies 130b and 130c may also be arranged to feed oil into the conduit 138, such as by windows into the conduit at locations near the top of the respective conduits, as can also be the case with respect to the uppermost canopy 130d and the conduit 138. (Such windows, or additional openings, in canopies 130b and 130c are optional and are not shown in
It is of course the case that the conduit 138 may, at least initially, carry sea water to the surface or sea water mixed with oil. That would frequently be quite all right. In some cases there may be apparatus modifications applied so that fluid drawn out by the conduit 138 contains at least a preponderance of oil. For example, such modifications may use sensor elements to determine oil is occurring at inlets to the conduit before any pump or suction apparatus (not shown) related to the conduit 138 is activated. In addition, any openings from the canopies into the conduit 138 could be provided with covers that are openable or closeable for any reason determinable from the surface or from conditions in the water learned by monitoring equipment.
In a multi-canopy arrangement as shown in
A system is shown in
In
Conduit elements are, for simplicity, not more clearly shown in
The example of
Various modifications of the above examples will be apparent. A few particular variations will be mentioned by way of further example.
The systems as described above can be readily compacted for transport or storage and can be readily placed in a location over a wellhead, or a ruptured oil pipe, or the like, that is under water even if not right at a wellhead. This can be done quickly, especially if a drilling platform is equipped with the apparatus before it is needed.
In addition, a system can be designed for placement in the water over a wellhead upon or during initial drilling of a well, or any time thereafter, as a security measure even before any leakage occurs. Such a system can be placed over and around the initial drilling equipment and the piping placed in the drilled well. Whenever any leakage occurs, the leaked oil will be captured by the system and extracted through the conduit or conduits built into the system.
A further alternative is to have a system in place on the sea floor at a wellhead but not in an operational position until it is drawn up by a cable to form the oil capturing structure in an operational position along with conduiting to remove the oil. This would provide both non-interference with normal drilling and well extraction operations and, also, not require storage of the system on the platform.
One alternative type of system to those previously described that still utilizes the principle of displacement of water by the rise of lower density oil is one in which a series of multiple canopies are arranged in a manner similar to those of
For this alternative system, as one example, consider a series of canopies that are each in a form of something like a hemispherical umbrella (e.g., similar in shape to canopy 30 of
A system as just described can have conduiting for oil from any of the canopies, including at least the uppermost canopy. Depending on the leakage rate, it is possible the conduiting takes care of all the oil without any exiting a canopy back into the water, in which case an arrangement of successive canopies, that are open from the bottom and able to intake oil from the next lower canopy, is not necessary but serves as additional security in case the leakage changes or any blockage of a conduit occurs.
As mentioned previously, canopies of the described systems may be highly flexible which permits compacting them for convenient transport and storing. They may also be of rigid material with otherwise similar characteristics as those of a flexible material. For example, they could be of molded plastic, fiberglass, or of metal of a thickness no more than one inch. Rigid canopies, such as for the system of successive umbrella shaped canopies described above, could be stacked for storage when not in use and in some applications may be preferred to be rigid to have them extend over the desired area more readily.
While the description here is directed to applications such as deep water oil leaks, it is to be understood the invention can also be applied in other instances for capturing a material released at some distance below the surface into a fluid medium that has a greater density than the material desired to be captured.
Consequently, it can be seen from the above description of examples, as well as the following claims, that capturing and recovering a fluid, such as oil or gas leaking from an undersea wellhead, can be performed with reasonably simple apparatus that can be made and used economically and can result in avoiding or limiting damage that could otherwise result and still permits making use of the oil or gas which need not be subjected to adulteration by use of the invention.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61398269, filed Jun. 23, 2010, which is hereby incorporated by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61398269 | Jun 2010 | US |