The disclosed embodiments are generally directed to motor systems, such as actuators.
Actuators are one of the key components in a broad range of industries and applications, such as robotics, automobiles, and mechanical systems. Electric motors and power electronics have shown significant technological progress, yet some basic drawbacks have still not been solved.
According to one embodiment, a motor system includes a first motor having a first gear ratio, a second motor having a second gear ratio lower than the first gear ratio, and a drive shaft, the first and second motors being connected to an output load via the drive shaft. The motor system is arranged to electrically and/or mechanically disconnect the first motor when a speed of the first motor is greater than or equal to a threshold speed.
According to another embodiment, an electric motor system includes a first motor having a first gear ratio and driven via a first drive amplifier, a second motor having a second gear ratio lower than the first gear ratio, the second motor being driven via a second drive amplifier, and a drive shaft, wherein the first and second motors are connected to an output load via the drive shaft. The motor system is arranged to measure an output shaft velocity and electrically disconnect the first motor when an output speed is greater than or equal to a threshold speed.
According to another embodiment, a method of operating a motor system having a first motor with a high gear ratio, a second motor with a low gear ratio, and a drive shaft, the first and second motors being connected to an output load via the drive shaft is disclosed. The method includes electrically and/or mechanically disconnecting the first motor when a speed of the first motor is greater than or equal to a threshold speed.
It should be appreciated that the foregoing concepts, and additional concepts discussed below, may be arranged in any suitable combination, as the present disclosure is not limited in this respect.
The foregoing and other aspects, embodiments, and features of the present teachings can be more fully understood from the following description in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
The accompanying drawings are not intended to be drawn to scale. In the drawings, each identical or nearly identical component that is illustrated in various figures is represented by a like numeral. For purposes of clarity, not every component may be labeled in every drawing. In the drawings:
In general, an electric motor produces its highest output power when spinning at 50% of its maximum speed while generating 50% of its maximum torque. The output power goes down and efficiency becomes low when generating a high torque at a zero or almost zero speed. In addition, output power and efficiency may become low when spinning at a high speed with zero or almost zero torque. As will be appreciated, there are many applications where electric motors are required to operate at a low speed with a high torque load or at a high speed with a low torque load. The inventors have recognized that in such applications, electric motors are used inefficiently and are producing limited output power.
Legged robots are one such example of this inefficiency. As shown in
Another example of inefficiency is an all-electric excavator (see
In case of electric cars, still another example, efficiency becomes low under two extreme speed conditions, extremely low speed and high speed, unless a gearshift is involved. Wheel motors, in particular, have no physical space for placing a gearshift mechanism. In consequence it is difficult to cover a wide speed range efficiently.
As shown in
Dual-motor actuators with two geared motors having different gear ratios have been studied to overcome the low efficiency problem experienced by a single motor with a single, fixed gearing. In such applications, the two motors may be connected to a common load and are mechanically “switched” between two different speed ranges. For example, planetary gearing has been used to connect two actuators to add the velocities of the two motors. At high speed both motors contribute to generate a high-speed rotation, while at low-speed and high-torque operation, a mechanical brake is used to clamp the motor with a low gear ratio so that a large torque load does not act on the high-speed low-torque motor. In this arrangement, relative gear ratios of over 40 have been achieved with the use of a planetary gear and a brake. Another approach to dual-motor actuator design is to add two output torques from both motors. At low speeds both motors connected to the same output shaft contribute to the common load together. Specifically, the motor with a high gear ratio, called a torque booster, contributes more to generating a high torque. At high speeds, the torque booster cannot catch up with the high-speed motor. Instead, the torque booster impedes the high-speed operation. To prevent the torque booster from impeding the high-speed operation, a one-way clutch may be inserted between the torque booster and the common load, so that the torque may be transmitted only from the torque booster towards the load, and not the other way around.
The inventors have recognized that such dual-motor designs may be applicable only to cases where the direction of rotation is never reversed. In other words, these designs only work for one-way motion. In contrast, a dual wheel motor developed for electric cars, for example, uses two electric motors with diverse gear ratios, where the high gear ratio motor is connected to its load through a unidirectional clutch. The unidirectional clutch allows the system to disengage the high-gear ratio motor when spinning at high speeds. However, it works only for one-directional operation. The unidirectional clutch mechanism would not work when the car is moving backward.
In view of the above, the inventors have recognized that in many robotic and mechatronic applications, a single geared motor with a fixed gear ratio is unable to cover the two extreme load conditions. The inventors have also recognized the benefits of having a dual motor actuator with two electric motors having different gear ratios and disconnecting the motor with the higher rear ratio such that the motor does not act as a generator consuming energy.
For example, in some embodiments of the present disclosure, the dual motor may include a motor with a higher gear ratio that produces a high torque and a motor with a lower gear ratio that is able to turn on quickly. In some embodiments, as speed increases, the motor with the higher rear ratio cannot spin very fast and may generate a reverse current, thereby consuming mechanical power as a generator. The inventors have recognized the benefit of disconnecting the torque booster when the torque booster reaches a threshold speed such that the torque booster does not act as a generator. For example, the torque booster may be disconnected when the speed of the torque booster is greater than or equal to a threshold speed. In some embodiments, the torque booster may be electrically disconnected such that the torque booster is isolated from whatever is powering it. For example, the torque booster may be electrically disconnected from a drive amplifier. In such embodiments, switching between a low speed/high torque and a high speed/low torque operation may be performed via only electric switches. As will be appreciated, in such embodiments, the motors may remain physically connected to one another even though they are electrically disconnected.
In other embodiments, the torque booster also may be mechanically disconnected such as via a clutch (e.g., a centripetal clutch) or a brake. As with the above, the torque booster may be mechanically disconnected from whatever is powering it and/or from the lower gear ratio motor, also referred to as the speed motor, when the torque booster reaches (e.g., is greater than or equal to) the threshold speed such that the torque booster does not act as a generator consuming mechanical power.
Accordingly, embodiments disclosed herein include an electric motor actuator system having two motors, a first motor having a high gear ratio and a second motor having a low gear ratio. The system may include at least one gearing and driving electronics. In some embodiments, the first and second motors may be connected to the same output load through a drive shaft. For example, in some embodiments, the motors may be directly geared together. In some embodiments, the motors may be connected via a gear (e.g., a spur gear), a stiff belt, or another suitable arrangement. The first and second motors may be driven with independent drive amplifiers, although the motors may be driven via the same drive amplifier in some embodiments.
In some embodiments, the velocities (e.g., speeds) of the first and second motors may be bound together, such as with low stiffness binding. For example, the velocities of the first and second motors, and the output, may be proportional to one another. In some embodiments, the speeds of the first and second motors may be determined by the gear ratio of the gearing of the torque booster, denoted by N(>1). For example, the torque booster may rotate N times faster than the speed rotor. In such embodiments, both motors may possess proportional speeds and add their output torques.
In some embodiments, the dual motor system may include an additional external gearing (see gearing 119 in
In some embodiments, the motor system is arranged to measure an output shaft velocity and to disconnect the first motor when an output speed is high. For example, in some embodiments, at high speeds, the first motor (e.g., the torque booster) generates a high back emf, which may exceed the voltage that its respective drive amplifier may generate. In such an example, at such high speeds, the drive amplifier cannot provide a high voltage and, as such, the torque booster may become a generator that consumes the mechanical power. Thus, in some embodiments, the torque booster may be electrically disconnected when the output speed is high, while in other embodiments, the first motor may be mechanically disconnected when the output speed is high. For example, in some embodiments, the torque booster may be disconnected at the speed where the torque booster is contributing no torque but has reached a high voltage limit (e.g., a cutoff speed). The inventors have appreciated that disconnection of the motor while current is flowing may cause an arc, which could potentially damage electronics. Accordingly, in some embodiments, the current to the torque motor may be diminished before disconnection of the torque booster.
In some embodiments, switching between the low-speed/high torque and the high-speed/low-torque modes may be achieved via only electric switches. For example, in some embodiments, the torque booster may be disconnected from its drive amplifier via one or more relays, couplers, and/or additional switching semiconductors at high speeds. In one such example, the relay may shut out the torque booster when its speed exceeds a certain threshold. As will be appreciated, once the torque booster is disconnected, no current may flow and thus, no power is taken, although the back emf voltage may still be high. In some embodiments, the power amplifier may include a H-bridge bi-polar amplifier. In some embodiments, the H-bridge bi-polar amplifier includes four switching semiconductors with additional diodes inserted between motor terminals and the individual switching semiconductors. As will be appreciated, other suitable numbers of semiconductors may be used in other embodiments.
In some embodiments, a control strategy for coordinating the two motors with an optimal power efficiency is provided, and the time-optimal control of the dual-motor hybrid dynamics may be addressed in the context of the “fall-catching” of the robotic assist system. For example, in some embodiments, the torque booster may be effective for rapid acceleration at a low speed, but is “disconnected” for further increasing the speed. This may be treated as a time-optimal control of the dual motor system.
In some embodiments, the speed of the first and second motors may be determined by the gear ratio of the first gearing 105 (e.g., first and second gears 106, 108), denoted by N (>1). In such embodiments, both motors may possess proportional speeds with their output torques being added together. In some embodiments, the gear ratio of the second gearing 119 is selected to appropriately match the system load, while the gear ratio of the first gearing 105 (e.g., gears 106, 108) determines how diverse speed ranges of operation may be covered with the two motors. In some embodiments, the torque booster rotates N times faster than the high-speed rotor.
In some embodiments, the gearing of the torque booster of the dual-motor actuator may possess two angular velocities, which may correspond to the velocities of the shafts of the first and second motors (e.g., the booster shaft and the output shaft). In some embodiments, to reduce the inertial load in the high-speed, low torque mode, a lightweight gearing may be used for the torque booster. In some embodiments, this may include plastic gears.
In some embodiments, the dynamics for the dual-motor system may arise from combining two instances of DC motor dynamics, with the dynamics of a gearbox used to combine them. In some embodiments, the inertia and friction contributions of the torque booster motor may be magnified by gear reduction. For example, inertia and viscous damping friction may both be magnified by N2, and Coulomb friction may be magnified by N. In some embodiments, the magnification of these loads by the gear reduction may be a primary physical constraint preventing use of an arbitrary high gear ratio N.
As will be appreciated, although gearings are shown for connecting the first and second motors, in other embodiments, the system may have other suitable arrangements. For example, in some embodiments, a stiff belt may be used to connect the first motor (e.g., the torque booster) to the drive shaft.
As shown in
In some embodiments, the controller may control the two motors to provide a control input with two internal degrees of freedom. In some embodiments, the first degree of freedom may be used to control actuator output, such as velocity, torque, and/or impedance. In some embodiments, at a given operation velocity, any torque (e.g., within speed-dependent limits) may be easily commanded. In some embodiments, a torque command may be achieved through current control, given the proportionality of lossless output torque and motor current. In some embodiments, the speed-dependent torque limits may be those provided by the voltage limits of the overall system's battery or power supply.
In some embodiments, the second degree of freedom may be used to balance motor contribution, such as power efficiency maximization and/or voltage limit enforcement. The dual-motor actuator also may control an external degree of freedom, as it only has a single output shaft. In some embodiments, one of the internal degrees of freedom may be dedicated to providing the specified torque to the external degree of freedom, while the other internal degree of freedom may be used to adjust how the tow motors share the torque. In this regard, under a torque-sharing policy, this degree of freedom may be used to maximize power efficiency at each operating point.
With respect to power efficiency, in some embodiments, the motors may be both voltage limited, which may impose limits on both the ability to maintain an optimal current ratio and on the overall torque. In this regard, the torque booster motor may reach its voltage limit well before the direct-drive (e.g., high speed) motor.
In some embodiments, the booster motor may be at its voltage limit. In such embodiments, the booster voltage may be saturated. In some embodiments, this mode may be referred to as a saturation mode. In some embodiments, the maximum speed achievable while in the saturation mode may be less than the no-load speed of the direct-drive motor alone. In some embodiments, to achieve certain speeds, it may be necessary for the voltage limit on the booster motor to be relaxed. In some embodiments, this may be achieved via electrically disconnecting the booster motor. In some embodiments, this mode may be referred to as a disconnection mode.
In some embodiments, as shown in
As will be appreciated, although the relays are shown as being positioned between the torque motor and the respective drive amplifier, in other embodiments, one or more relays may be positioned in another suitable portion of the circuit.
Another example of the dual-motor actuator is shown in
In some embodiments, the system may include two direct current (DC) motors. As will be appreciated, although a brushed DC is shown and described in the example shown in at least
As will be appreciated, although an encoder is shown for measuring speed, it will be appreciated that in other embodiments, other suitable arrangements for sensing speed, transmitting the information, to a controller, and then switching to electrically disconnect the booster motor.
In some embodiments, the motor system does not include any additional actuators than those shown in the figures. For example, the system includes only the first and second motors (e.g., torque booster and speed motor). As will be appreciated, systems may be designed with additional actuators included.
In some embodiments, an algorithm may be designed to control the system. In some embodiments, the algorithm includes a first sharing paradigm arranged to control a ratio between the torque motor current and the speed motor current such that it is appropriate for the desired speed range. In some embodiments, the first paradigm may ensure that zero current is flowing through the torque booster once the threshold speed, also referred to as a disconnection speed, has been reached. In some embodiments, it also may ensure that the torque motor is participating significantly at low speeds.
The algorithm also may include a second sharing paradigm, to maximize power efficiency while respecting the voltage limits of the motors. In some embodiments, boundaries of optimization are selected, and limits to voltages of both motors may be supplied. In some embodiments, application of boundaries may create a torque-speed envelope, within which the actuator can operate. In some embodiments, the algorithm also may enforce that the motors do not oppose in current.
In some embodiments, the algorithm design includes implementing robot-level control, with speed-dependent torque limits. In some embodiments, a standard feedback control may be used, but with output torque limited by a threshold which varies with speed.
According to other embodiments herein, the torque booster may be mechanically disconnected during use. In some embodiments, as shown in
In some embodiments, the mechanical disconnection also may include a gearbox design (see, e.g.,
While the present teachings have been described in conjunction with various embodiments and examples, it is not intended that the present teachings be limited to such embodiments or examples. On the contrary, the present teachings encompass various alternatives, modifications, and equivalents, as will be appreciated by those of skill in the art. Accordingly, the foregoing description and drawings are by way of example only.
Various aspects of the present invention may be used alone, in combination, or in a variety of arrangements not specifically discussed in the embodiments described in the foregoing and is therefore not limited in its application to the details and arrangement of components set forth in the foregoing description or illustrated in the drawings. For example, aspects described in one embodiment may be combined in any manner with aspects described in other embodiments.
Also, the invention may be embodied as a method, of which an example has been provided. The acts performed as part of the method may be ordered in any suitable way. Accordingly, embodiments may be constructed in which acts are performed in an order different than illustrated, which may include performing some acts simultaneously, even though shown as sequential acts in illustrative embodiments.
Use of ordinal terms such as “first,” “second,” “third,” etc., in the claims to modify a claim element does not by itself connote any priority, precedence, or order of one claim element over another or the temporal order in which acts of a method are performed, but are used merely as labels to distinguish one claim element having a certain name from another element having a same name (but for use of the ordinal term) to distinguish the claim elements.
Also, the phraseology and terminology used herein is for the purpose of description and should not be regarded as limiting. The use of “including,” “comprising,” or “having,” “containing,” “involving,” and variations thereof herein, is meant to encompass the items listed thereafter and equivalents thereof as well as additional items.
This application claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 119(e) to U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 62/925,434, filed Oct. 24, 2019, the contents of which are incorporated herein in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62925434 | Oct 2019 | US |