Embodiments of the inventive subject matter relate to fire suppression and, more particularly, to fire suppression in large battery systems.
Grid energy production is rapidly evolving from the use of central power stations to the use of power sources that are more distributed in nature. The development of distributed renewable energy sources (e.g., wind and solar power generation) has created a basic problem relating to the fact that these renewable resources are only available when there is sun or wind. To have a stable grid, there must be a balance where the generation must substantially equal the load. When there is excess generation, the renewable generation must be curtailed, which results in less than maximum generation.
To maximize these renewable generation resources, an energy store, such as a large battery, may be used to store excess generation when load cannot consume all the generation. When the sun and wind fade, the energy stored in the battery can supplement the renewable generation or supply the load when no sun or wind is available. The battery in such a system may be large and include densely packed cells, which by its nature can present a fire hazard.
Installation of these battery systems into buildings or large containers (e.g., shipping containers) can increase the risk of fire and increase difficulties in extinguishing the fire. Difficulty in deploying the extinguishing agent close to the fire can delay controlling the fire which results in greater property damage. There is an additional concern that a re-ignition of the damaged battery pack can occur hours after the initial event.
Numerous battery fires that have been reported and many can be traced to some type of abuse. In some cases, manufacturing defects can weaken the ability of the battery and contribute to the inability to withstand abuse. Examples of abuse include overheating, shock, overcharge and external short circuit. When responding to a battery fire, first responders can be exposed to electrical shock from the remaining intact cells.
When these battery systems are installed into buildings or large containers, it is generally desirable to minimize the footprint in these deployments. The battery modules 120 are typically placed on individual shelves 110 in a battery rack 100 as shown in
These risks have led to extensive efforts to address the threat of thermal runaway in Li-ion battery systems. Proposed responses include the use of copious amounts of water to address this threat.
Some embodiments of the inventive subject matter provide an apparatus including a pipe configured to extend adjacent at least one rack having a plurality of vertically stacked battery shelves and at least one plurality of ports fluidically coupled to the pipe, respective ones of the ports configured to direct an extinguishing agent from the pipe towards respective ones of the shelves. The ports may include respective nozzles longitudinally spaced along the pipe. In some embodiments, the pipe may be a vertically-oriented pipe disposed adjacent a side or a corner of the at least one rack.
In some embodiments, the ports may be selectively controllable. For example, the ports may be individually heat-activated. In some embodiments, for example, the apparatus may include respective sprinkler heads coupled to the pipe, each of the sprinkler heads including a nozzle, a member configured to obstruct the nozzle in a first position and to expose the nozzle in a second position, and an actuator configured to move the member from the first position to the second position responsive to heat. The member may include a pivoting arm, the actuator may include a heat-sensitive member that holds the pivoting arm such that the pivoting arm obstructs the nozzle when the heat sensitive member is intact, and the heat-sensitive member may be configured to deform responsive to heat to release the pivoting arm and expose the nozzle.
In further embodiments, the apparatus may further include a monitor circuit configured to detect a pressure drop in the pipe.
In some embodiments, an apparatus includes a rack including a plurality of vertically-stacked battery shelves and a vertically extending pipe disposed adjacent the rack. The apparatus further includes a plurality of ports fluidically coupled to the pipe and spaced apart along a length of the pipe, respective ones of the ports configured to direct an extinguishing agent from the pipe towards respective ones of the shelves.
Still further embodiments provide methods including positioning a pipe adjacent at least one rack having a plurality of vertically stacked battery shelves and directing an extinguishing agent from respective ones of ports fluidically coupled to the pipe towards respective ones of the shelves.
Specific exemplary embodiments of the inventive subject matter will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings. This inventive subject matter may, however, be embodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodiments set forth herein; rather, these embodiments are provided so that this disclosure will be thorough and complete, and will fully convey the scope of the inventive subject matter to those skilled in the art. In the drawings, like numbers refer to like items. It will be understood that when an item is referred to as being “connected” or “coupled” to another item, it can be directly connected or coupled to the other item or intervening items may be present. As used herein the term “and/or” includes any and all combinations of one or more of the associated listed items.
The terminology used herein is for the purpose of describing particular embodiments only and is not intended to be limiting of the inventive subject matter. As used herein, the singular forms “a”, “an” and “the” are intended to include the plural forms as well, unless expressly stated otherwise. It will be further understood that the terms “includes,” “comprises,” “including” and/or “comprising,” when used in this specification, specify the presence of stated features, integers, steps, operations, items, and/or components, but do not preclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, operations, items, components, and/or groups thereof.
Unless otherwise defined, all terms (including technical and scientific terms) used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this inventive subject matter belongs. It will be further understood that terms, such as those defined in commonly used dictionaries, should be interpreted as having a meaning that is consistent with their meaning in the context of the specification and the relevant art and will not be interpreted in an idealized or overly formal sense unless expressly so defined herein.
As noted above, conventional solutions to fire suppression in large battery systems include using copious amounts of water or other extinguishing agents to suppress the fire. However, conventional approaches can be less effective than desired because they do not distribute extinguishing agent effectively to the fire. For example, if an extinguishing agent is only deployed at the top of a battery rack, battery modules above the fire can block the extinguishing agent from the reaching the fire directly.
The amount of extinguishing agent can be significantly reduced and be more effective if it can be delivered early and at or near the origin of the fire which in turn reduces the extent of the damage to property. Risk can be mitigated by an intelligent set of safety systems that detect and direct the extinguishing agent near to the fire origin to cool it and provide a thermal barrier to adjacent battery modules that will prevent cascading failures.
The effective extinguishing agent should be able to knock down the flame and cool the fuel so it will not ignite the remaining fuel. Tests have shown that water is one of the best agents due to its ability to cool. However, a challenging aspect of a battery fire can be the densely-packed nature of the heat source and the associated inability to direct extinguishing agent on or near the fire.
Some embodiments of the inventive subject matter can provide workable solutions to the above-mentioned challenges by delivering the extinguishing agent closer to the source of the fire and providing a thermal curtain that can prevent batteries adjacent a first from reaching a temperature where they can become involved in the fire.
Using battery rack structures according to some embodiments of the inventive subject matter, extinguishing agent can be delivered closer to a fire in an individual battery module located in the battery rack. Some embodiments can reduce or eliminate the need to provide an extinguishing agent delivery pipes or spray nozzles within the battery rack assembly. Battery racks according to some embodiments may be placed under a standard fire sprinkler head and when sprinkler is activated, the water will be collected near the top of the rack and distributed to each battery tray within the battery rack.
The EADP 200 includes a hollow column having respective ports 210 in its walls. Although the EADP 200 is illustrated as a cylindrical, it will be appreciated that an EADP may take other form factors, such as a pipe, column, conduit or similar structure with a polygonal (e.g., triangular, rectangular, hexagonal, etc.), elliptical or other cross section. The vertically spaced ports 210 may provide extinguishing agent more effectively to the individual battery shelves of a rack, and may provide a flat spray that both cools the battery on fire and also creates a thermal shield (i.e., a wall of extinguishing agent) that can reduce heating of a battery sitting on the shelf above the fire. The ports may for example, be machined into a wall of the EADP 200 or may be nozzles configured to be installed in threaded openings in the EADP 200.
A lip on the underside of the battery tray can deflect the extinguishing agent back onto the fire and help contain the extinguishing agent in the fire area. An EADP, such as the EADP 200, may operate such that no extinguishing agent is in the pipe until the fire event is detected, upon which a valve is opened to fill the pipe and force extinguishing agent through the ports of the EADP. When this occurs, extinguishing agent is directed through all ports of the EADP and provided to all batteries, whether or not they are actively involved in the fire event. This can be cost-effective deployment but can result in substantial unnecessary damage and an unduly expensive cleanup, since all the batteries are exposed to extinguishing agent.
Some embodiments may employ a single EADP that has extinguishing agent delivery ports that face multiple battery racks. For example,
As shown
It will be appreciated that, although the above-described embodiments utilize a vertical EADP, further embodiments may employ other arrangements. For example, instead of one or more vertical EADPs, some embodiments may use respectively horizontally oriented pipes, conduits, etc., that are located at respective shelf levels of multiple adjacent battery racks.
The previous examples show systems that deliver extinguishing agent to all battery modules in a rack or group of racks. According to further embodiments, fire suppression systems and methods may selectively provide extinguishing agent to locations where it is needed. For example, heat-controlled valves can be used at each of the extinguishing agent delivery ports to deliver extinguishing agent only when a sensor mechanism is activated. For example, some embodiments may use a heat sensitive glass capsule similar to those found in conventional fire sprinkler heads to activate an EADP port. Such a configuration can provide a more controlled delivery of extinguishing agent that can be more effective in extinguishing and preventing cascading failures that involve additional battery modules and create collateral damage.
Some embodiments may use similar techniques with dry extinguishing agents. In such cases, after a fire is detected, only the battery pack areas that have experienced excessive heat would deliver the extinguishing agent to the battery minimizing the extent of collateral damage. Alternately, the EADP can be pressurized with a gas and monitored. In the event that there is a loss of pressure in the EADP, an alarm could be sounded, and an operator manually commands to deliver the extinguishing agent through the EADP. Such a system can be used to detect a fire since the capsule would only break if there was excessive heat in that location. For example, a resulting pressure loss could be detected and, responsive to detecting the pressure loss, automatic delivery of the extinguishing agent through the EADP could be initiated. In some embodiments, a pressure drop in the EADP pipe could be monitored, with the magnitude of the drop being used to indicate whether a significant thermal event is occurring.
It may not be cost effective to assemble a large and packed battery system on site. Rather, it may be desirable to build the system in subassemblies and then transport the subassemblies to the site, such that the factory-built subassemblies can be interconnected with a simplified interconnection system. This fabrication approach can reduce or eliminate the need for skilled labor during the interconnection of the subassemblies at the site.
Embodiments of the inventive concepts can be integrated into these factory-built modules, along with other features that may be required at the site, such as seismic anchors, site connections for the EADP, wireways, plenums, etc. These features can be accessed without undue disassembly of the factory-built subassemblies, such as removal of one or more battery trays to access/secure subassembly in seismic zones that might be required in conventional construction.
As illustrated in
Such subassemblies can be positioned using, for example, lifting eyes 930 at the top of the assembly 900. Multiple subassemblies may be placed side-by-side to form a battery system. At the end of a row of such subassemblies, a combiner box or similar structure may be placed to provide a common point of connection for the battery racks and a point of connection to the site electrical infrastructure. Installation of the subassemblies may define wireways that facilitate wiring and access to the combiner box. The integrated EADP 960 in the submodules can also reduce the number of on-site extinguishing agent connections required. For example, each subassembly may have a flexible connection to allow adjacent subassemblies to be connected to one another (e.g., in a daisy chain manner) and/or to site-based extinguishing agent infrastructure, such as standpipes. For example, in applications in which multiple battery rack subassemblies are integrally housed in an enclosure such as a shipping container, firefighters may connect a firehose to a connection outside of the shipping container (not shown) that is connected to the main extinguishing agent input port 965 of the factory-built subassemblies 900 to provide an immediate and desirable distribution of extinguishing agent to the battery racks inside via the EADP(s) 960 in the housing and connected extinguishing agent tubes 970. This can relieve the firefighters of the challenge of manually creating the desired flow pattern, reduce delays in extinguishing the fire and reduce dangers to the firefighters associated with opening the housing and/or attempting to disassemble the battery racks to gain access to the burning portions of the assembly. Similar modularized interconnections can be used for fire sensing or control within the subassemblies.
Such modular subassemblies can provide effective solutions for provision of extinguishing agent at the origin of a fire and can also reduce collateral damage from the extinguishing agent. Further embodiments provide integrated subassemblies for constructing complete battery systems that can reduce installation costs and the need for skilled labor on site.
According to additional embodiments, an EADP along the lines described above with reference to
Fire suppression systems for battery racks according to further embodiments will now be discussed with reference to
Although this structure can distribute extinguishing agent to all batteries in the rack, the time to get extinguishing agent to the lower batteries may be significantly delayed. To enhance the delivery of extinguishing agent to the lower batteries, the shelf 1120 can further include bypass (e.g., overflow) paths that allow excess extinguishing agent to fall to the shelf (or shelves) below when the overlying shelf contains a certain level of extinguishing agent. This can accelerate the distribution of extinguishing agent among the trays in the battery rack. Referring to
In some embodiments, the overflow holes can be selectively plugged to provide a desired overflow path. For example, referring to
The top of the battery rack 1100 is configured to collect extinguishing agent that falls on the top of the battery rack 1100 and to direct it to the first battery shelf 1120-1 through one or more holes in the top of the battery rack.
Battery racks according to some embodiments allow extinguishing agent to be distributed to multiple tray-like shelves in the battery rack. Such structures can form extinguishing agent barriers of a desired depth at each shelf and disperse a controlled amount of extinguishing agent through the drain holes in each shelf, which in turn falls to the battery below. The thermal barriers can reduce the likelihood that heat from a fire in a given battery pack will excessively raise the temperature of nearby battery modules. The discharge of extinguishing agent from the drain holes can help reduce the temperature of the battery that is on fire and help extinguish the fire. A battery cabinet without such features might prevent extinguishing agent from reaching the origin of a fire located deep in the battery rack.
The size and number of the drain holes can be estimated using volume flow of liquids from a container equation:
The liquid volume flow can be calculated
V=Cd A(2g h)1/2
where
V=volume flow (m3/s)
A=area of aperture-flow outlet (m2)
Cd=discharge coefficient
g=acceleration of gravity (9.81 m/s2)
h=height of fluid above aperture (m)
where
Cd=Cc Cv
Cv=velocity coefficient (water 0.97)
Cc=contraction coefficient (sharp edge aperture 0.62, well rounded aperture 0.97)
For example, height of fluid above the aperture is selected to be 0.00635 m (0.25 inch). The aperture has a sharp-edged hole. This would make Cd equal to 0.62×0.97 or 0.60 for water. The target liquid volume flow is 6.309×10−5 m3/s (1 gal./minute), thus yielding an aperture area of 0.002972 m2 (0.46066 in2). It is generally desirable to distribute the aperture area over a large number of small holes to disperse the extinguishing fluid over battery module located below the shallow tray. Choosing a 0.003175 m (0.125 inch) diameter aperture for the drain hole can yield approximately 38 in a shelf. This pattern of holes can be evenly or selectively distributed to maximize cooling effect on a battery below. The shape, size, number, location and style of the apertures can be selected to provide a desired volume flow and pattern of extinguishing fluid on a battery fire located below the shelf. If extinguishing agent volume flow entering the top of the battery rack is sufficient, the height of extinguishing agent in each shelf can be maintained at the desired height and extinguishing agent delivered to the battery modules below each shelf.
According to further embodiments, another configuration can be provided that facilitates directing the extinguishing agent only on battery modules that have reached elevated temperatures. The extinguishing agent distribution holes of a battery, such as the holes 1122 shown in
It may not be cost effective to assemble a large and densely-packed battery system on site. Rather, it may be desirable to build the system in subassemblies and then transport the subassemblies to the site. The subassemblies may include battery racks preassembled including battery modules in groups of two or more to reduce installation costs at the customer site. A passive fire containment system along the lines described above can be integrated into such a subassembly, allowing elimination of a need for a direct connection between the building sprinkler systems and the battery rack. Although no direct connection is required, in some embodiments, the sprinkler system at the customer site could also be connected to the rack.
It will be appreciated that, although the above-described embodiments utilize a pattern of drain holes and overflow holes, further embodiments may employ other arrangements. For example, using louvers 1824 on sides of shelves 1820-1, 1820-2, 1820-3 for capturing the extinguishing agent and discharge to the shelf below as shown in
Another configuration that can be used is one in which the sides of the battery support shelves are extended above the bottom surface of the battery pack, which allows the extinguishing agent to collect and partially or completely submerge the battery pack. This arrangement can cause the extinguishing agent to rise to a higher level before falling to the battery shelf below. The battery pack can sit on raised areas of the shelf such that the extinguishing agent can flow under the battery pack while rising to a desired level around the battery pack. Excess extinguishing agent will overflow the sides of the battery support tray to be caught by the battery support tray below. Although full immersion of the battery in extinguishing agent is optimal, it may be impractical to achieve due to features of the battery module, such as fans, power cables and signal connections. The foregoing description of arrangements for dispersing extinguishing agent within the battery rack are examples, and embodiments of the inventive concepts include other mechanical arrangements that combine with one or more of these techniques to provide for a cascading or “ladder” type fall and dispersal of extinguishing agent within a battery cabinet.
Embodiments of the inventive concepts can be integrated into factory-built modules, along with other features that may be required at the site, such as seismic anchors, wireways, plenums, etc. These features can be accessed without undue disassembly of the factory-built subassemblies, such as removal of one or more battery trays to access/secure subassembly in seismic zones that might be required in conventional construction.
As illustrated in
Multiple subassemblies may be combined to form a battery system. At the end of a row of such subassemblies, for example, a combiner box or similar structure may be placed to provide a common point of connection for the battery racks and a point of connection to the site electrical infrastructure. Installation of the subassemblies may define wireways that facilitate wiring and access to the combiner box. Passive containment systems according to some embodiments of the inventive concepts integrated in the subassemblies can reduce or eliminate the need to make on-site extinguishing agent connections as the subassembly can be placed under a standard sprinkler head(s) to receive extinguishing agent. For example, in applications in which multiple battery rack subassemblies are integrally housed in an enclosure, such as a shipping container, firefighters may connect a firehose to a main extinguishing agent input port accessible at the exterior of the housing to provide an immediate and desirable distribution of extinguishing agent to the battery racks. This can relieve the firefighters of the challenge of manually creating the desired flow pattern, which can reduce delay in extinguishing the fire and reduce danger to the firefighters associated with opening the housing and/or attempting to disassemble the battery racks to gain access to the burning portions of the assembly.
Such modular structures can provide effective solutions for provision of extinguishing agent at the origin of a fire and can also reduce collateral damage from the extinguishing agent. Further embodiments provide integrated subassemblies for constructing complete battery systems that can reduce installation costs and the need for skilled labor on site.
In this specification, there have been disclosed embodiments of the inventive subject matter and, although specific terms are employed, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purposes of limitation.
The present application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/755,049 entitled APPARATUS AND METHODS FOR FIRE CONTAINMENT OF LARGE BATTERY SYSTEMS, filed Nov. 2, 2018, and to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/801,675 entitled APPARATUS AND METHODS FOR PASSIVE FIRE CONTAINMENT OF LARGE BATTERY SYSTEMS, filed Feb. 6, 2019, the disclosure of each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62755049 | Nov 2018 | US | |
62801675 | Feb 2019 | US |