Apparatus for dry lubrication of a thin slitting blade

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 9789622
  • Patent Number
    9,789,622
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, November 6, 2014
    10 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, October 17, 2017
    7 years ago
Abstract
A block of a solid lubricant material, such as PTFE, is biased continuously or intermittently against the cutting edge of a rotary slitting blade for corrugated paperboard. The solid lubricant block prevents the build up of starch adhesive and biasing movement compensates for wear of the block and wear of the cutting blade edge.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to an apparatus for slitting a moveable web of corrugated paperboard and, more particularly, to a lubricator system that uses Teflon or other suitable lubricant pucks or blocks that are physically pinched or loaded onto a slitting blade to assist in sharpening of said blade and to prevent build-up of starch or similar adhesive associated with the production of the corrugated paperboard.


A slitter/scorer is used on the dry end of a corrugator to slit and score the corrugated web emerging from the double backer so as to create multiple independent “outs” that can be routed to the upper or lower level of a cutoff knife. The knife then cuts these “outs” to designated lengths to create the independent sheets that are then stacked. The slitting tool used to slit the web is a thin blade of approximately 1-2 mm in thickness that rotates at high speed with the corrugated web supported below the blade by a rotating solid anvil as described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,090,281, the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference herein.


The web that is slit is formed in and emerges from an upstream double backer with a green bond of the starch adhesive on the lower liner that has a propensity to adhere to the thin slitting blade. A standard approach to prevent starch from building up on the thin blade involves wiping a lubricating fluid onto the blade using a wick lubricator pad. A pressurized oil feed is used to wet the wick. The wick is replaced at frequent intervals to insure a fresh surface free of starch accumulation.


There are several problems with this conventional approach to thin blade lubrication. First, there is potential for over lubrication and wetting of the wicks that can result in dripping of lubricant onto the top of the board, particularly at corrugator stop. Also, to the extent that the wick wipes the lubricant on the blade, this same lubricant can contaminate the edges of the corrugated board.


To address this issue and to make this problem acceptable to corrugated manufacturers who are manufacturing board for food-grade applications, a food-grade acceptable lubricant is necessary. This is expensive and not universally acceptable. Also, the food-grade lubricant works less well than, for example, a WD-40 type lubricant. Another problem is associated with the pumps and valves and lubricant lines that have to be routed to the slit blades resulting in a complicated and maintenance-intensive system. Lubricant must be stirred to prevent coagulation. Valves become stuck. Lubrication pads need to be changed on at least a daily basis and this is expensive and labor intensive.


A recently introduced solution to the lubrication problem involves use of a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) block as an anvil. This concept is described in U.S. Patent Application Publication US2006/0075864 A1 with publication date Apr. 13, 2006. The thin slitting blade plunges into the anvil and the PTFE block then lubricates the blade as it rotates in the PTFE support. As the blade wears away the PTFE, the blocks can be laterally shifted to create a new PTFE wear block.


This solution to lubrication creates a problem on long runs between order changes where the PTFE wears. Without an order change, it is not possible to shift the block to solve the wear issue. Also, the constant lateral feeding of PTFE blocks into the machine is labor intensive and is not routinely done by plant operating personnel. As the thin blade is plunged into the PTFE block, it works effectively, but as it wears, the effectiveness of the lubrication rapidly decreases.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is directed to a method and apparatus for lubricating the thin blade with a dry lubricant that is self compensating with wear of the lubricating means.


One object of this invention is to provide a slitting device that is particularly suited to slitting of corrugated paperboard without deformation of the edges of the board as a consequence of build-up of starch adhesive on the slitting blade.


Another object of the invention is to allow continuous operation of the slitting process without requirement to interrupt the process flow so as to maintain effective operation of the slitter.


Another object of the invention is to maintain even, effective slitting performance throughout the useful wear life of the thin blade lubricating means.


Yet another object is to eliminate the problem of dripping of wet lubricant on the corrugated board by use of a dry lubricating means. It is also an object of this invention to simplify the process of blade lubrication by elimination of lubricating lines, pumps, filters, stirring systems, and valves associated with prior art wet lubricating systems.


These and other objects and advantages are achieved by use of continuously loaded wear pucks of PTFE, or other lubricating material, onto each side of the thin blade used for slitting of the corrugated paperboard web. In this embodiment, the pucks are loaded against the blade edge with continuous adjustment using springs, air cylinders, or other load biasing means well known to those skilled in the art. There is a puck for each side of the thin blade. Each puck may have its own loading system. The pucks are retained or captured within a fixed lubricator housing that is carried on the tool head that carries the slitting blade. The loading system is mounted to the outside of the housing and in one embodiment, attaches via a loading plunger or rod through a suitable opening in the lubricator housing. The lubricator pucks may float within the housing so that they can achieve the correct contact surface with the sharpened cutting edge of the thin slitting blade. In one embodiment of the invention, there are lubrication housings on each side of the blade offset from one another. This allows the lubricator pucks to travel laterally beyond the tip of the blade on the outer edge as the blade wears.


In another embodiment of the invention, a single puck is radially loaded against the rotating thin blade with the natural spring force of the puck material loading the bifurcated sides of the puck against the opposing edges of the thin blade.


One particularly appealing feature of the puck lubrication apparatus is that lubricant can be applied at a position around the periphery of the blade other than the point of contact of the thin blade with the corrugated board. This makes it possible to use effective board support means such as the slotted anvil of U.S. Pat. No. 6,837,135.


Since the lubricator pucks are continuously loaded against the thin blade, the puck maintains contact with the blade as it wears in the lubrication transfer process. The pucks may also be free floating to the point that they adapt to the blade as the blade wears during the blade sharpening process. It is particularly advantageous that the loading, of the lubrication puck against the blade occurs continuously during rotation of the blade with no interruption of the slitting process required to adjust the puck.


In another embodiment of the invention, the loading means can be retracted by physical means or automatically to avoid continuous lubrication of the blade while it turns but is not in use as a selected tool in the slitting process, or when intermittent lubrication is acceptable.


Yet another problem associated with the PTFE block is the requirement to adjust the relative position of the blade being lubricated by the block. As the blade wears and the radius decreases, the blade must be frequently discretely adjusted to maintain an effective position of the blade in the block.


In yet another embodiment of the invention, a pair of PTFE rods are positioned in an “X” type configuration and continuously biased in a radial direction against the blade to be lubricated. The rods pivot about their base and are biased to create a force on each rod that acts normal to the end of the rod forcing the rod into contact with the blade edge. This results in a variable loading of the rods onto the blade as a function of how deeply the blade is biased into the throat of the crossed rods.


There may be several formats of lubrication pucks other than PTFE that could provide the necessary starch release protection on the slitting blades and any suitable solid puck lubricant used would be within the scope of the invention.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1 is a side elevation view of a conventional web slitting apparatus on which is mounted a blade lubricator of the subject invention in its presently preferred embodiment;



FIG. 2 is an enlarged perspective detail of the web slitting apparatus of FIG. 1 showing the preferred embodiment of the prevent invention in greater detail;



FIG. 3 is an exploded view of the components of the invention shown in FIG. 2;



FIG. 4 is a side elevation detail of the blade lubricator shown in FIGS. 1-3 in its initial operative position;



FIG. 5 is a sectional view taken on line 5-5 of FIG. 4;



FIG. 6 is a side elevation detail similar to FIG. 4 showing a position of the blade lubricator as the contact lubricator is cut away in use;



FIG. 7 is a sectional view taken on line 7-7 of FIG. 6;



FIG. 8 is a sectional view similar to FIG. 7 showing an addition to the FIG. 7 embodiment;



FIG. 9 is a side elevation of a web slitting apparatus showing an alternate embodiment of the invention that is repositioned with respect to the slitting blade;



FIG. 10 is a sectional detail taken on line 10-10 of FIG. 9;



FIG. 11 is a sectional detail similar to FIG. 10 showing another embodiment thereof;



FIG. 12 is a sectional detail of yet another embodiment of the invention;



FIGS. 13A and 13B are sectional details showing wear patterns developed in alternate embodiments of the invention; and



FIG. 14 is a side elevation of a web slitting apparatus showing an alternate embodiment of the invention.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

Referring initially to FIG. 1, a web slitting apparatus 10, suited particularly for slitting a moving corrugated paperboard web 11, includes an upper tool head 12 carrying a rotary slitting blade 13. A lower counterhead 14 is mounted below the web and carries a web-supporting anvil roll assembly 15. The upper tool head 12 is supported for lateral movement in the cross machine direction on a pair of linear bearing ways 17 that are attached to the underside of an upper box beam 16. Similarly, the lower counterhead 14 is supported for lateral movement in the cross machine direction on a lower linear way 20 mounted on the upper face of a lower box beam 21. Upper tool head 12 is moved along the upper linear ways 17 to position the slitting blade 13 by an upper servomotor 22 driving a pinion 23 that engages a linear rack 24 attached to the upper box beam 16 and extending parallel to the linear ways 17.


In a similar manner, lateral positioning of the anvil roll assembly 15 on the lower counterhead 14 utilizes a lower servomotor 25 driving a pinion 26 that engages a lower linear rack 27 attached to the lower box beam 21 and extending parallel to the lower linear way 20.


In a typical slitting, apparatus 10, multiple pairs of upper and lower tool heads 12 and 14, respectively, are positioned along their respective box beams 16 and 21. Each of the upper tool heads 12 carries a rotatable drive assembly 28 including a center drive hub 30 with a hexagonal throughbore that receives a hexagonal shaft 31. The drive assembly 28 is operable to drive the slitting blades 13 and to permit their positioning in the cross machine direction on the hexagonal shaft 31 utilizing suitable microprocessor control. The upper tool head 12 typically carries a blade sharpener 33 for each slitting tool head for on-the-fly sharpening.


In accordance with the present invention, the tool head 12 also carries a contact blade lubricator 34 that improves upon and replaces the wet lubricator pads of the prior art as discussed above. One embodiment is shown in FIGS. 9 and 10. The blade lubricator 34 includes a housing 35 mounted in a stationary position on the upper tool head 12. Within the housing, there are mounted a pair of solid lubricant pucks 36, preferably made of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). The pucks 36 are mounted within the housing 35 on opposite sides of the slitting blade 13. Each puck is seated within the housing 35 in a puck holder 37 secured within the housing, but allowing limited movement of the pucks to engage both faces of the blade edge.


Referring particularly to FIG. 10, the lubricator housing 35 preferably comprises a box-like structure having an open interior substantially closed on five sides, but having an open operating face 38. The end walls 40 of the housing 35 are provided with slots 41 which, together with the operating face 38, accommodate entry of the slitting blade 13. Each of the puck holders 37 is secured in the housing 35 by gluing or other attachment means. The puck holders 37 have an L-shaped cross section including a short leg 42 that, together with the open interior of the housing 35, nest the pucks 36 for limited movement toward the blade 13 with a puck positioned on and in bearing contact with each side of the blade edge. The pucks are mounted such that they are spaced circumferentially with respect to the circular blade edge.


Each puck 36 is biased laterally (perpendicular to the slitting blade 13) by a spring plunger 43 or other biasing device. The spring plunger 43 maintains the puck in intimate contact with the cutting blade edge and edge faces as the puck wears and as the blade diameter is reduced as a result of on-the-fly sharpening by the blade sharpener 33. Each spring plunger 43, which is of conventional construction, is mounted in a casing 44 attached to a side face of the housing 35. Within the casing 44 there is located a plunger head that bears directly on the puck 36 under the biasing influence of a spring 46. Multiple spring plungers may be used with each puck.


As the pucks are worn away by contact with the slitting blade and the slitting blade itself is worn by operation of the blade sharpener 33, the pucks assume a cross sectional shape shown in FIG. 13A in which the radially outer portion 47 of the puck remains essentially unworn and retains its full thickness, but thins in the radially inward direction. Thus, the pucks 36 must be separated or spaced circumferentially with respect to the blade so that the unworn radially outward portions 47 of the pucks do not interfere with one another as the pucks are worn away. FIG. 11 is a view similar to FIG. 10 in which the biasing arrangement utilizes an air cylinder 48 to bias each puck into contact with the slitting blade edge. Otherwise, this embodiment is the same as that shown in FIG. 2.


In FIG. 12, there is shown a further embodiment of the blade lubricator of the present invention. In this arrangement, a pair of circumferentially spaced solid lubricant pucks 50 are biased into contact with the outer blade edge by a pair of spring plungers 51 which may be the same as or similar to the spring plunger 43 described above. The plungers may include a retractable feature as is well known with these devices. The pucks 50 are nested in a liquid lubricant-retaining wick 52. Each of the wicks 52 has a stepped construction such that a puck 50 is seated in the thinner portion of the wick which, together with an identical but reversed puck and wick for the other side of the blade, are inserted and held in the housing 49 through an open end face 53. Each side of the housing 49 carries a spring plunger 51 which is operatively biased through the side wall of the housing against the thinner stepped portion of the wick 52. The bias force, in turn, presses the pucks 50 against the side faces of the slitting blade edge. This construction provides an advantage in applications where the starch adhesive used in the manufacture of the web 11 utilizes a particularly aggressive formulation that might tend to build up unacceptably if only solid lubricant pucks are used.


In another example as shown in FIG. 14, the pucks 36 are held by first and second lubricator holders 80, 82 proximate respective first and second opposing sides of the slitting blade 13. The separate first and second lubricator holders 80, 82 hold the first and second pucks 36 on each side of the blade 13 in contact with the first and second blade faces, respectively. Additionally, the first and second lubricator holders 80, 82 are circumferentially offset from one another with respect to the slitting blade 13. As described herein above, this allows the lubricator pucks 36 to travel laterally beyond the tip of the blade on the outer edge as the blade wears. The first and second biasing mechanisms are supported by the first and second lubricator holders 80, 82, respectively (see FIGS. 10-12).


The presently preferred embodiment of the invention is shown in FIGS. 2-8. In this embodiment, a lubricator housing 54 holds a rectangular block of solid lubricant 55 and the block and housing together are biased radially into contact with the circular edge 56 of the slitting blade 13. The lubricator housing 54 is a rectangular box-like enclosure, substantially closed on all sides, except for an open end face 57 through which the rectangular lubricant block 55 is inserted. Conveniently, the housing may comprise two mirror halves bolted together as shown. The housing 54 is supported on the blade head 58 with a pivotal attachment 60 permitting pivotal movement of the housing 54 and lubricant block 55 between a non-contact inoperative position (shown in phantom in FIG. 6) and an operative position with the block 55 biased into contact with the blade edge (shown in FIG. 4). The pivotal attachment 60 includes a pivot shaft that extends between and interconnects an inner side wall 62 of the housing 54 and the blade head 58. In one example, the pivot shaft 61 extends from the blade head 58 and through an aperture 94 in a corner of the housing 54 that is distal the blade 13. The pivot shaft 61 carries a biasing mechanism, which in one example comprises a torsion spring 63, the ends of which operatively interconnect the housing inner side wall 62 with the blade head 58. For example, a first end 90 of the torsion spring 63 is seated on the blade head 58 and a second end 92 of the torsion spring 63 is seated on the housing 54. (See FIGS. 2, 3, 5, and 7.) The force of the torsion spring 63 biases the housing 54 and lubricant block 55 against the edge of the slitting blade 13.


The upper end wall 64 and lower end wall 65 of the housing 54 are provided, respectively, with end wall slots 66 and 67 that extend from the open end face 57 toward the rear housing end face 68. Both slots 66 and 67 provide clearance for the slitting blade 13 as it penetrates the lubricant block biased into engagement therewith. The lower end wall slot 67 is just wide enough to provide the necessary blade clearance. The upper end wall slot 66 is somewhat wider and provides a clear view of slitting blade penetration into the lubricant block such that the useful life of the block can be visually monitored. In the embodiment shown, total blade penetration into the lubricant block may be about 1 inch (25 mm), but the size of the housing 54 and lubricant block 55 may be varied widely to provide a much greater blade penetration. The rate of blade penetration into the block 55 and the effective wear life of the block may be varied considerably depending on the bias force and the hardness of the PTFE block. For example, in one embodiment of the invention, the blade may penetrate the block at a rate of 0.0001 inch (0.0025 mm) per minute. At this rate, and assuming a maximum penetration of 1 inch (25 mm), the block would last up to 165 hours before replacement would be necessary. As may be seen in FIGS. 6 and 7, the slitting blade 13 penetrates the block 55 in a generally diagonal path as best seen in FIG. 6. From this position, the housing and slit block may be pivoted to the inoperative position and the block reversed in the housing 54.


In certain applications, it is possible that, as the slitting blade penetrates the lubricant block, the separated halves 71 of the slit block, only one of which is shown in FIG. 13B, may become more flexible and not provide adequate bearing contact with the opposite blade faces near the blade edge. In this case, it may be desirable to provide a supplemental lateral blade force to bias the lubricant block halves toward one another. As shown in FIG. 8, this can be most easily accomplished by using a biasing mechanism, such as, for example, a retractable spring plunger 70 that may be the same as the spring plunger 43 described above. The spring plunger 70 is coupled to, and in one example, mounted in the outer side wall 59 near the open end face 57 and the upper end wall slot 66 such that, when the spring is released, the head of the spring plunger 70 will bear against the side of the lubricant block and squeeze the two slit block halves 71 more tightly together. Although an oppositely disposed spring plunger 70 could also be used, a single plunger 70 is believed to be adequate. In the example shown, in FIG. 8, the spring plunger 70 is a biasing mechanism that is coupled to the inner side wall 62 of the housing 54 and that bears against a first side 96 of the lubricant block 55. Another spring plunger 70 may be provided in the outer side wall 59 and bear against a second, opposite side 98 of the lubricant block 55.



FIG. 6 shows the lubricant housing and lubricant block assembly pivoted to its inoperative position away from the slitting blade. The edges of the housing inner side wall 62 and outer side wall 59, defining the open end face 57 of the housing 54 are provided with semicircular recesses 72 to facilitate grasping the lubricant block 55 for insertion into or removal from the housing 54.

Claims
  • 1. A dry lubrication system for a web slitting machine including an annular rotary slitting blade for slitting into a running corrugated paperboard web, the dry lubrication system comprising: a first puck and a second puck of plastic lubricant held proximate a cutting edge of the slitting blade, the first puck contacting a first blade face of the slitting blade at a first blade face location and the second puck contacting a second, opposite blade face of the slitting blade at a second blade face location that is not immediately opposite the first blade face location, such that the first and second pucks are situated diagonally across the slitting blade from each other; anda first biasing mechanism that applies an external load to the first puck and thereby biases the first puck into continuous, generally uniform contact with the first blade face;wherein biasing of the first puck compensates for wear of the first puck due to contact with the first blade face and for wear of the blade cutting edge due to sharpening and continually advances the first puck in a lateral direction, perpendicular to the first blade face, to maintain the continuous, generally uniform contact as the first puck is worn away by the slitting blade.
  • 2. The dry lubrication system of claim 1, further comprising a second biasing mechanism applying an external load to the second puck and biasing the second puck into continuous, generally uniform contact with the second blade face.
  • 3. The dry lubrication system of claim 2, wherein the first and second pucks are biased independently of one another into contact with the first and second blade faces, respectively.
  • 4. The dry lubrication system of claim 2, wherein the first and second pucks are biased generally perpendicularly with respect to the first and second blade faces, respectively.
  • 5. The dry lubrication system of claim 2, further comprising a lubricator housing supported by the web slitting machine and having an open operating face for insertion of the blade cutting edge therein, wherein the first and second pucks are held within the lubricator housing.
  • 6. The dry lubrication system of claim 5, wherein the lubricator housing comprises first and second opposing side faces joined by first and second opposing end walls, the first and second opposing end walls each having a slot there through to accommodate the blade cutting edge when the blade cutting edge is inserted into the lubricator housing via the open operating face.
  • 7. The dry lubrication system of claim 6, further comprising first and second puck holders in the lubricator housing for holding the first and second pucks, respectively, and that nest the first and second pucks for limited movement toward the first and second blade faces, respectively.
  • 8. The dry lubrication system of claim 7, wherein the first and second puck holders are seated in diagonally opposite open spaces in the lubricator housing, each puck holder having a short leg that contacts a respective one of the first and second pucks and holds the respective puck in a corner formed by one of the first and second side faces and one of the first and second end walls of the lubricator housing, and a long leg that contacts an opposing other of the first and second end walls to brace the short leg of the respective puck holder in place against the respective puck.
  • 9. The dry lubrication system of claim 6, wherein the first biasing mechanism is supported by the first side face of the lubricator housing and the second biasing mechanism is supported by the opposing second side face of the lubricator housing.
  • 10. The dry lubrication system of claim 2, further comprising first and second lubricator holders on opposite sides of the slitting blade that hold the first and second pucks in contact with the first and second blade faces, respectively.
  • 11. The dry lubrication system of claim 10, wherein the first and second lubricator holders are circumferentially offset from one another with respect to the slitting blade.
  • 12. The dry lubrication system of claim 11, wherein the first and second biasing mechanisms are supported by the first and second lubricator holders, respectively.
  • 13. A dry lubrication system for a web slitting machine including an annular rotary slitting blade for slitting into a running corrugated paperboard web, the dry lubrication system comprising: a lubricant holder box supported by the web slitting machine and having first and second opposing side faces connected by first and second opposing end walls, and an open operating face for insertion of a cutting edge of the slitting blade therein;first and second lubricant pucks held within the holder box, the first puck positioned proximate the first end wall of the holder box and contacting a first blade face of the slitting blade at a first blade face location and the second puck positioned proximate the second end wall of the holder box and contacting a second, opposite blade face of the slitting blade at a second blade face location that is not immediately opposite the first blade face location, such that the first and second pucks are situated diagonally across the slitting blade from each other; andfirst and second biasing mechanisms that apply external loads to the first and second pucks, respectively, so as to continuously advance the first and second pucks in a lateral direction, perpendicular to the first and second blade faces, against and into continuous contact with the first and second blade faces, respectively, as the first and second pucks are worn away by the slitting blade.
  • 14. The dry lubrication system of claim 13, further comprising first and second liquid lubricant-retaining wicks held within the holder box, wherein the first and second pucks are nested between the first and second wicks and the first and second blade faces, respectively.
  • 15. The dry lubrication system of claim 14, wherein each of the first and second wicks has a stepped construction including a thinner portion adapted to seat the respective first or second puck therein and a thicker portion that contacts a respective one of the first and second blade faces.
  • 16. The dry lubrication system of claim 15, wherein the first and second biasing mechanisms provide first and second biasing forces through the first and second opposing side faces of the holder box against the thinner portions of the respective first and second wicks, which first and second biasing forces in turn press the first and second pucks against the respective first and second blade faces.
  • 17. The dry lubrication system of claim 13, wherein the first and second biasing mechanisms comprise spring-actuated mechanisms.
  • 18. The dry lubrication system of claim 13, wherein the first and second biasing mechanisms comprise pneumatically-actuated mechanisms.
  • 19. The dry lubrication system of claim 13, wherein positioning of the first puck proximate the first end wall of the holder box and of the second puck proximate the opposing second end wall of the holder box causes the first and second pucks to be circumferentially offset from one another with respect to the slitting blade.
  • 20. The dry lubrication system of claim 13, wherein the first and second pucks comprise blocks of PTFE.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED PATENT APPLICATIONS

This application is a divisional of U.S. application Ser. No. 12/854,492, filed Aug. 11, 2010, which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/232,961, filed Aug. 11, 2009, and both of which are hereby incorporated by reference.

US Referenced Citations (59)
Number Name Date Kind
2134018 Alderman Oct 1938 A
2741281 Braun Apr 1956 A
2796933 De Gelleke Gerrit Jun 1957 A
2895553 De Gelleke Gerrit Jul 1959 A
3452734 Cleland Jul 1969 A
3460418 Boothe, Jr. Aug 1969 A
3540334 McLauchlan Nov 1970 A
3563285 Thrasher Feb 1971 A
3570343 Wolnosky Mar 1971 A
3593763 Neild Jul 1971 A
3623520 Neild Nov 1971 A
3674065 Fairfield, Jr. Jul 1972 A
4028973 Bogdanski Jun 1977 A
4079617 Whiting Mar 1978 A
4323145 Allen Apr 1982 A
4635513 McGeehee Jan 1987 A
4813319 Weyand, Jr. Mar 1989 A
4817477 Emery Apr 1989 A
4848200 McGehee Jul 1989 A
4873759 Burch Oct 1989 A
4877174 Bruhn Oct 1989 A
4896793 Briggs et al. Jan 1990 A
4951537 Bennett Aug 1990 A
4983145 Hirai et al. Jan 1991 A
5054582 Aracil Oct 1991 A
5090281 Paulson Feb 1992 A
5159866 Dunham Nov 1992 A
5165314 Paulson et al. Nov 1992 A
5197366 Paulson Mar 1993 A
5339665 Yoshikawa Aug 1994 A
5393174 Wawrzyniak Feb 1995 A
5406869 Prochnow Apr 1995 A
5435217 Kato Jul 1995 A
RE35086 Paulson et al. Nov 1995 E
5494368 Matthews Feb 1996 A
5616406 Nakamaru et al. Apr 1997 A
5667347 Matthews Sep 1997 A
5839335 Tilley Nov 1998 A
5925299 Dierckes et al. Jul 1999 A
5971342 Sakai et al. Oct 1999 A
6092452 Adami Jul 2000 A
6128990 Drew Oct 2000 A
6165117 Adami Dec 2000 A
6415697 Brash Jul 2002 B1
6431037 Dai et al. Aug 2002 B1
6804983 Mori Oct 2004 B2
6826993 Michalski Dec 2004 B2
6837135 Michalski Jan 2005 B2
7299727 Gravely et al. Nov 2007 B2
7325473 Belfiglio Feb 2008 B2
8375765 Schaltegger Feb 2013 B2
8931378 Paulson Jan 2015 B2
20050183559 Rue Aug 2005 A1
20060075864 Adami Apr 2006 A1
20060107810 Chiu et al. May 2006 A1
20080105096 Gravely et al. May 2008 A1
20080236354 Esposito Oct 2008 A1
20090178528 Adami Jul 2009 A1
20110036220 Paulson et al. Feb 2011 A1
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20150059545 A1 Mar 2015 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
61232961 Aug 2009 US
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 12854492 Aug 2010 US
Child 14534943 US