Indirect measurements (such as the Brazilian tensile measurements) are often used to estimate the mechanical properties of downhole materials such a cementitious or core plug specimens. Typically such tests are performed at ambient conditions. Due to the nature of the measurements and specimen geometry it may be impractical to estimate mechanical properties such as the tensile strength or other mechanical properties of a material under conditions experienced in situ. However, with continued advancements of well bore stress simulators, it is becoming more beneficial to have this information. What is needed is an apparatus and method to measure the mechanical properties of downhole materials to give insight into how a material might fail when subjected to confining pressures and temperatures similar to what would be experienced in situ in the wellbore.
As part of the present invention, we recognized that existing mechanical testing apparatuses and methods may inadequately simulate the in situ subterranean temperature and pressure condition experienced by downhole materials, including cementitious or resin materials used to form the well bore annulus or used as a fracturing fluid, or, the material of underground formations. In contrast, the approach of the present disclosure facilitates the measurement of mechanical properties such as tensile and compression strength under a range of precisely controlled temperatures and pressures that simulate in the subterranean environment of the wellbore and surrounding rock formation. In particular, apparatus embodiments of the disclosure facilitate testing a specimen of the downhole material under temperature-controlled elevated pressure-confining conditions simulative of a subterranean environment. Consequently, the approach of the present disclosure provides a simple and economical way to more precisely assess a mechanical failure envelop of downhole materials as a function of temperature and pressure. In turn, this information allows one to better predict the stability of a cement wellbore casing or to better perform hydraulic fracturing operations by better understanding the stress conditions under which the downhole material mechanically fail, e.g., as part of a fracturing operation.
In the drawings and descriptions to follow, like parts are typically marked throughout the specification and drawings with the same reference numerals, respectively. The drawn figures are not necessarily to scale. Certain features of this disclosure may be shown exaggerated in scale or in somewhat schematic form and some details of conventional elements may not be shown in the interest of clarity and conciseness. Specific embodiments are described in detail and are shown in the drawings, with the understanding that they serve as examples and that they do not limit the disclosure to only the illustrated embodiments.
Moreover, it is fully recognized that the different teachings of the embodiments discussed, infra, may be employed separately or in any suitable combination to produce desired results.
Unless otherwise specified, any use of any form of the terms such as “press,” “connect,” “engage,” “couple,” “attach,” or any other term describing an interaction between elements is not meant to limit the interaction to direct interaction between the elements but include indirect interaction between the elements described, as well. In the following discussion and in the claims, the terms “including” and “comprising” are used in an open-ended fashion, and thus should be interpreted to mean “including, but not limited to.” Further, any references to “first,” “second,” etc. do not specify a preferred order of method or importance, unless otherwise specifically stated but are intended to designate separate elements. The various characteristics mentioned above, as well as other features and characteristics described in more detail below, will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art with the aid of this disclosure upon reading the following detailed description of the embodiments, and by referring to the accompanying drawings.
One skilled in the pertinent art would understand how fracturing fluid, pumped into the wellbore 102 at a high rate to increase the pressure in the wellbore 102, could be used as part of the system 100 to create or increase fractures 112 in the formation intervals 108, 110. For instance, the fracturing fluid, including a cement composition or a hydrated gel, and/or resins (e.g., epoxy or other polymer resins) or composites thereof, can be pumped alone or as a mixture with proppants (e.g., sand or other proppants) or rock formation material into the fractures 112 to prop the fractures in the formation open, to thereby, effectively increase the formation's porosity.
One embodiment of the disclosure is an apparatus for measuring mechanical properties of a downhole material.
With continuing reference to
In some embodiments, as illustrated in
The term sealed specimen chamber 218 as used herein means that there is substantially no exchange of the hydraulic fluid 230 located in the confining chamber 226 with the pore space fluid 236 located in the specimen chamber 218. One skilled in the pertinent art would understand how to select a composition (e.g., rubber, plastic or other flexible material) of the confining sleeve 218 to have sufficient flexibility to be wrapped around the fixture portions 214 and 216 and sufficient elastic strength to maintain a barrier to prevent exchange between the hydraulic fluid 230 and the pore space fluid 236 while the stress is being applied. Additionally, having a pressure differential between the confining chamber 226 and the specimen chamber 218 (e.g., Ppore<Pconf) may desirably help maintain the barrier. Based upon the present disclosure one skilled in the pertinent art would understand that the selection of the pressure differential to maintain would be a balance depending upon on the elastic strength of the sleeve material and the desire to simulate the downhole environment as accurately as possible.
As illustrated in
Maintaining an elevated pore pressure at equal to, or near but less than, the confining pressure may facilitate better modeling of the underground environment of the specimen to correspond more closely to the in situ environment experiences by a downhole cement or rock formation material. For instance, cement and rock materials are porous media and have permeability with respect to fluids present in the downhole environment. Pumping pore space fluid 236 into the specimen chamber 218 and maintaining the pore pressure at or slightly less than the confining pressure facilitates more realistic modeling of such a downhole environment, during the application of the stress. In some testing embodiments, the pore space fluid 236 can be, or include, a formation fluid, a completion fluid or other fluids such as brine, water or gases such as air or methane or other fluids intended to model the down hole environment. For example, in some testing embodiments, the pore pressure can be maintained at a pressure value that is equal to or within less than about 100 psi or about 300 psi of the confining pressure. For example, in some embodiments, the pore pressure can maintained at a pressure value equal to or within less about 1%, or about 2%, or about 10%, of the confining pressure. However, in other testing embodiments, the pore space fluid 236 can be allowed to drain out of the specimen chamber 218 such that the pore pressure can equal about atmospheric pressure.
Consider, as an example, a hydraulic fracturing system 100 such as depicted in
As further illustrated in
As further illustrated in
One skilled in the pertinent art would understand how the stress applied to the specimen could be a compressive or tensile stress depending upon the directions of forces (e.g., F,
As further illustrated in
As further illustrated in
For instance, as part of applying the stress, the force application fixtures 206, 208 can apply opposing compressive forces, that is, each of the compressive forces applied from the force application fixtures 206, 208 are configured to move in opposing directions (F,
As further illustrated in
As further illustrated in
As further illustrated in
In some embodiments of the apparatus 200, the stress can be applied as a combination or sequence of compressive or tensile stresses from stresses applied through both the force application fixtures 206, 208 via crushing pressure and via the actuator 264, or, the stress can be applied by only one of these mechanisms.
As further illustrated in
Some embodiments of the specimen 210 of the downhole material can include one of: a cementitious or resin materials for use to form a wellbore downhole annulus, cementitious material for use as a fracturing material, resins (e.g., epoxies) or composites of resins and proponent for use fracturing material materials, or, a core plug of a downhole rock formation.
In some embodiments, the hydraulic fluid can include hydraulic oil and the pore space fluid includes one of: formation fluid, completion fluid, brine, water of gas. In some such embodiments the second hydraulic fluid 258 can have the same or a different composition as the hydraulic fluid 230.
Another embodiment of the disclosure is a system for measuring mechanical properties of a rock formation.
The apparatus 200 of the system 300 can include any of the components configured as discussed in the context of
In some embodiments of the apparatus 200 of the system 300, the first and second fixtures 202, 204 can include fixture chambers 250, 252 with the force application fixtures 206, 208 located therein and the fixture chambers 250, 252 connected to third channels 254, 256 configured to add or remove a second hydraulic fluid 258 to and from the fixture chambers 250, 252 and configured to hold the second hydraulic fluid 258 therein to apply a crushing pressure to the force application fixtures 206, 208, as discussed in the context of
The one or more sensor devices 310, 312, 313, 314, of the system 300 can be configured to measure displacement while the stress is applied the specimen 210 to facilitate quantifying the stress required to cause mechanical failure of the specimen 210.
For instance, in some embodiments, the sensors devices 310, 312, 313 can be or include linear variable differential transformer sensors configured to measure axial, lateral or circumferential displacements (e.g., in vertical direction 315 or horizontal direction 317, respectively, as shown in
For instance, in some embodiments, increasing amounts of the stress can be applied as a uniaxial compressive or tensile load (e.g., in direction 315 or 317) until breaking, buckling, deflection, displacement or other irreversible deformation of the specimen 210 occurs, as measured by the sensor devices 310, 312, 313.
For instance, in some embodiments, an axial displacement sensor 310 can include end pins 320 configured to be coupled to one or both of the first and second fixtures 202, 204 and connect to arms 322 of the axial displacement sensor 310, the arms 322 configured to record axial displacements (e.g., cantilevered arms configured measure changes in the distance between the first and second fixtures 202, 204) as the stress is applied to the specimen. In other embodiments, the sensor 310 can include arms 323 (e.g., a spring-loaded sensor arm) located in the fixture chambers 250, 252 and coupled to one or both of force application fixtures 206, 208 to record axial displacements (e.g., changes in the distance between the force application fixtures 206, 208) as the stress is applied to the specimen.
For instance, in some embodiments, a lateral displacement sensor 312 can similarly include arms 324 coupled to the outside surface of the confining sleeve 212 and configured to measure the lateral displacement of the specimen (e.g., changes in the distance between arms 324 located on opposite sides of the specimen) as the stress is applied to the specimen.
In some embodiments, a circumferential extensometer sensor 314 can include one or more strings or coils 325 wrapped around the circumference of the sleeve 212 and configured to measure changes in circumference (e.g., circumferential elongation) as the stress is applied to the specimen.
In still other embodiments, additionally or alternatively, the displacement of the force application fixtures 206, 208 can be determined by volume displacement measurements. That is, the volume of second hydraulic fluid 258 pumped into the fixture chambers 250, 252, to increase the crush pressure (Pcrsh) as part of applying the stress to the specimen, can be measured. By knowing the volume of hydraulic fluid pumped by the third pump 260 and knowing the volume of the chambers 250, 252, the axial displacement of the force application fixtures 206, 208 can be calculated (e.g., via the control module 330). Such volume displacement measurements have the advantage of not requiring sensors to measure linear or circumferential displacements. In some such embodiments, the third pump 260 can be configured to measure the volume pump, and as such, also serves as a volume displacement sensor 314. In other such embodiments, a separate volume sensor 314 (e.g., a flow meter coupled to one or both of the channels 254256 configured to deliver the second hydraulic fluid 258) can be used to measure the volume of second hydraulic fluid 258 pumped into the fixture chambers 250, 252.
One skilled in the pertinent art would understand how axial, lateral, circumferential or volume displacements associated with the stress-induced failure of the specimen 210 could be recorded by the sensor devices 310, 312, 3.13, 314 in the form of voltages or other electrical signals, which are then transmitted (e.g., via wirelessly via RF transmissions or via wired data transmission lines) to a control module 330 (e.g., a computer or, application specific integrated circuit ASIC) configured for date recording and processing.
Embodiments of the system 300 can further include environmental sensors 332, 334 configured to measure the temperature and pressure conditions inside of the any one or all of the specimen chamber 218, the confining chamber 226, or fixture chambers 250, 252 and/or inside the respective channels 232, 234, 254, 256 connected to these chambers.
For instance, environmental sensors 332 configured as temperature gages can be located in or facing any of these chambers 218, 226, 250, 252 and/or in or facing the channels 232, 234, 254, 256 connected to these chambers to measure the temperature of the hydraulic fluid 230, pore space fluid 236 or second hydraulic fluid 258 inside of the respective chamber or channel that these fluids are located in. Such temperature data can be transmitted (e.g., wirelessly or via wired data transmission lines) to the control module 330 for data processing. Based upon such data, the control module 330 can send instructions (e.g., wirelessly or via wired data transmission lines) to the heating element 244 to increase or decrease applied heating as appropriate to maintain the specimen 210 at a desired target temperature during the application of the stress as part of the stress testing.
For instance, environmental sensors 334 configured as pressure gages can be located in or facing the environment of any of these chambers 218, 226, 250, 252 and/or in or facing the environment of any of the channels 232, 234, 254, 256 connected to these chambers to measure the pressure of the first hydraulic fluid 230, the pore space fluid 236 or the second hydraulic fluid 258 inside of the respective chambers or channels that these fluids are located in. Such pressure data can be transmitted (e.g., wirelessly or via wired data transmission lines) to the control module 330 for data processing. Based upon such data, the control module 330 can send instructions to the first or second pump 240, 242 (e.g., wirelessly or via wired data transmission lines) to increase or decrease pressure as appropriate to maintain the specimen 210 at a desired target pressure (e.g., Pconf and Ppore) during the application of the stress as part of the stress testing of a specimen 210. Based upon such data, the control module 330 can send instructions to the third pump 260 (e.g., wirelessly or via wired data transmission lines) to increase the crushing pressure (PCrsh) at a desired target rate as part of the stress testing of a specimen 210.
In some embodiments of the system 300, the control module 330 can be configured (e.g., programed) to calculate a tensile strength or a compression strength for the specimen 210, and combine these value with analogous values obtained from multiple measurements made on other specimens of the downhole material, the measurements conducted at different combinations of elevated temperature and/or pressure conditions simulative of the in situ down hole environment. The control module 330 can be configured to display the combined values as a 3-dimensional a mechanical failure envelop (e.g., a plot of the tensile strength or compression strength versus the temperature of the first hydraulic fluid 230 or pore space fluid 236 and versus the confining pressure (Pconf) or pore pressure (Ppore).
In some embodiments, any one or more of the sensors 310, 312332, 334 can be integrated into and be part of the apparatus 200.
Another embodiment of the disclosure is a method of measuring mechanical properties of a downhole material.
With continuing reference to
The order of steps 410, 415 and 420 could be carried out in various different sequences. For example, as part of step 410, of the specimen 210 can be placed on one force application fixtures (e.g., one of fixture 206, 208 coupled to one of fixtures 202, 204). Then as part of step 415, the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the one fixture (e.g., one of portions 214, 216). Then as a continuation of steps 410 and 415 the other fixture (the other one of fixture 206, 208 coupled to the other of fixtures 202, 204), can be placed adjacent to the specimen 210 and the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the other fixture (e.g., the other one of portions 214, 216). For example, as part of step 415, the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the one fixture (e.g., one of portions 214, 216) and then as part of step 410 the specimen 210 can be placed on the one force application fixture. Then as a continuation of steps 410 and 415, the other fixture can be placed adjacent to the specimen 210 and the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the other fixture. For example, as part of step 420, one of the force application fixtures (e.g., one of fixture 206, 208 coupled to one of fixtures 202, 204) can be placed inside the confining chamber 226, the specimen 210 can be placed on the one force application fixture and then the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the one fixture while the fixture in the chamber 226. Then as part of step 410 the other one fixture (the other one of fixture 206, 208 coupled to the other one of fixtures 202, 204) can placed adjacent to the specimen after the specimen is in the chamber 226 and then as part of step 415 the confining sleeve 212 can be wrapped around the portion of the other fixture after the other fixture is placed in the chamber. Based on the present disclosure, one skilled in the pertinent art would appreciate how still different sequences of such steps could implied as part of the method 400.
The method 400 can include a step 425 of pumping a hydraulic fluid 230 into the confining chamber 226 to fill the confining chamber 230 with the hydraulic fluid 230 such that the hydraulic fluid 230 exerts a constant confining pressure (Pconf) on the confining sleeve 212 to maintain the seal of the sealed specimen chamber 218 and to maintain contact between the inner surface 220 of the confining sleeve 212 and the specimen 210. The method 400 can include a step 430 of pumping a pore space fluid 235 to fill the sealed specimen chamber 218 with the pore space fluid 235 including passing the pore space fluid 235 through one or more specimen chamber ports 238 open to the specimen chamber 218 such that the pore space fluid 235 maintains a constant pore pressure (Ppore) at the specimen chamber ports 238 that is equal to or less than the confining pressure (Pcore≤Pconf). The method 400 can include a step 435 of applying a stress (F) to the specimen 210 through the force application fixtures 206, 208, while maintaining the constant confining pressure to maintain contact between the inner surface 220 of the confining sleeve 212 and the specimen 210 and while maintaining the constant pore pressure, until mechanical failure of the specimen 210.
In some embodiments of the method 400, applying the stress (step 435) can include a step 440 of pumping a second hydraulic fluid 258 into fixture chambers 250, 252 of the first and second fixtures 202, 204. As disclosed in the context of
In some embodiments of the method 400, applying the stress (step 435) can include a step 445 of applying a tensile stress or compressive stress by a mechanical force actuator 264. As disclosed in the context of
In some embodiments of the method 400, applying the stress (step 435) can include a step 450 of applying heat from a heating element 244 of the apparatus 200 to maintain the hydraulic fluid 230 at a constant temperature while the stress is applied to the specimen 210 in accordance with steps 440 or 445.
Some embodiments of the method 400 can include, as a starting step 455, providing a specimen of a downhole material.
For instance, providing the specimen in accordance with step 455 can include providing a core plug specimen the down hole rock formation material (e.g., one of formation intervals 108 or 110). One skilled in the pertinent art would be familiar with the operation of conventional coring tools, such as rotary coring tools, to obtain such a specimen. For instance, in some embodiments, providing the core plug specimen from the rock formation can include using downhole core drilling equipment to cut a cylindrically-shaped core plug specimen from axially diagonally or laterally oriented side wall portions of a well bore and catching and storage equipment to capture and transport the core plug sample to the surface to be placed between the force application fixtures 206, 208 in accordance with step 410.
For instance, providing the specimen in accordance with step 455 can include providing a cementitious specimen (e.g., cementitious material used to form a well bore casing 104, or, cement formed in fractures 112 from cementitious fracturing fluid). One skilled in the pertinent art would be familiar with how forming such a cementitious specimen can include mixing a dry cement binder material with water and other fracturing additives or proppants to form a cement slurry in a container (e.g., a cylindrically shaped contain) and then allowed to set under conditions analogous to that used to form a cement wellbore downhole annulus or cement fracturing material. After setting, the cylindrically shaped cement specimen can be removing from the container and placed between the force application fixtures 206, 208 in accordance with step 410.
Some embodiments of the method 400 can further include, after applying the stress until the mechanical failure of the specimen 210 (step 435): pumping the hydraulic fluid 230 out of the confining chamber 226 (step 460); pumping the pore space fluid 236 out of the specimen chamber 218 (step 465); removing the confining sleeve wrapped around the portions 214, 216 of the first and second fixtures 202, 204 (step 470); and, as a finish step, removing the mechanically failed specimen 210 from between the force application fixtures 206, 208 (step 475).
Based upon the present disclosure one skilled in the pertinent art would understand how the method 400 could be repeated for a plurality of different specimens of the down hole material but with the confining pressure and core pressure adjusted to a different value and/or repeating the method steps at different temperatures in order to obtain sufficient information to produce a mechanical failure envelop to determine at what stresses under the simulated down hole environmental conditions the specimen would fail.
Those skilled in the art to which this application relates will appreciate that other and further additions, deletions, substitutions and modifications may be made to the described embodiments.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2018/036706 | 6/8/2018 | WO | 00 |