Patent Application
20240255459
The present invention relates to a system, apparatus and method for monitoring properties of an insulated metal structure, such as plant equipment and/or pipe work. In particular, the present invention relates to a system, apparatus and method for monitoring the external properties of and environment surrounding plant equipment and/or pipe work. One aspect of the invention relates to a system, apparatus and method for monitoring properties of insulation and/or voids which surrounds plant equipment and/or pipe work. One aspect of the invention relates to a system, apparatus and method for predicting and evaluating the risk of the occurrence of corrosion under insulation. One aspect of the invention relates to a system, apparatus and method for monitoring and/or mitigating the risk of corrosion under insulation by optimising insulation design, facility arrangements and/or maintenance programmes.
In industry, corrosion under insulation (CUI) is a problem that occurs in almost every industrial plant having insulated metal surfaces, including pipes, vessels and tanks. The corrosive environment which these surfaces are exposed to is often varying and unknown. Insulation encases such parts, often as well as a layer of weatherproof cladding or casing. The insulation and the cladding or casing can be known to act like a water trap for water which finds itself in this environment. Amongst other problems the corrosion can lead to a reduction in wall thickness and ultimately to leaks in the system.
To monitor the condition of these surfaces, manual inspection is carried out, which typically involves opening the cladding and the insulation surrounding them. This is a resource intensive and demanding process. It can also be difficult to conduct a manual inspection where the layout of a facility includes hard to access areas. At the time of scheduling and/or conducting these inspections, the status under the cladding/insulation is unknown, and the inspection might not be required at all, or it might be long overdue.
In some cases, severe corrosion (if undetected) can lead to equipment failure or leaks, having potentially hazardous consequences such as a leak of high temperature fluid, toxic gases, high pressure gas or fluid and the risk of ignition or explosion.
If corrosion does occur, industrial plants must bear high costs for the replacement of equipment and extended downtime during this process. Logs of past corrosion occurrences, assumed risk and cost (such as the cost of accessing the location in question and of replacing the equipment involved proactively) typically determine the frequency of manual visual inspection.
There is generally a need for a method and apparatus which addresses one or more of the problems identified above.
It is amongst the aims and objects of the invention to provide a system, apparatus and method for monitoring the environment in an insulating material surrounding plant equipment and/or pipe work which obviates or mitigates one or more drawbacks or disadvantages of the prior art.
In particular, one aim of an aspect of the invention is to provide a system, apparatus and method which can be used to predict the likelihood and occurrence of corrosion under insulation on plant equipment and/or pipe work.
In particular, one aim of an aspect of the invention is to provide a system, apparatus and method which can be used to determine water ingress locations in an insulating material surrounding plant equipment and/or pipework.
It is amongst the aims and objects of the invention to provide a system, apparatus and method for optimising insulation design to mitigate the occurrence of corrosion under insulation on plant equipment and/or pipe work.
It is amongst the aims and objects of the invention to provide a system, apparatus and method which can be used to determine the exposure time of plant equipment, pipework and/or insulating material to wet and/or humid conditions.
Throughout this specification, the term water is used to mean water in any form, and includes references to vapour/humidity and free/liquid water. The term humidity is used to mean the concentration of water vapour in the air, and may refer to absolute humidity, which is the ratio of the mass of water vapour present in a given volume of air, and/or relative humidity, which is the ratio of absolute humidity to the saturated humidity level at the same temperature. The term free water and/or moisture is used to mean water in a liquid state. Although the term free water is used, the sensor may be operable to detect the presence of any fluid.
According to a first aspect of the invention there is provided a sensor system for detecting the presence of water in an insulating material surrounding plant equipment and/or pipe work, the sensor system comprising:
The corrosion condition may be a condition within and/or under the insulating material which is a contributor to the risk of corrosion. Other factors which may be contributors to the risk of corrosion may include, but are not limited to: temperature; the presence of chlorides; material type; coating types and ages; design factors (including plant equipment and/or pipe work topography and geometry); insulation types, conditions and ages; cladding design, types and ages; and ambient conditions. The corrosion condition may be a condition within and/or under the insulating material which relates to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material.
The at least one reference sensor may be located externally to the insulating material in the vicinity of the plurality of sensors
There may be a communications link between the plurality of sensors and the processor. The communications link may be a wireless communications link. As a result, each of the plurality of sensors may be operable to wirelessly transmit the sensor outputs to the processor.
There may be a communications link between the at least one reference sensor and the processor. The communications link may be a wireless communications link. As a result, the at least one reference sensor may be operable to wirelessly transmit the sensor outputs to the processor.
The processor may be a remote data processing and/or storage unit. The processor may comprise one or more computers. There may be flexibility as to where the computers are located, for example the computers may not need to be located locally to one another. This gives system operators the ability to select an optimum processor location or locations based on a number of factors including, but not limited to, the location of key personnel, the location of adequately powered processing means, the cost and availability of processing means in key locations and/or the strength and availability of communications links. The processor may be located remotely to the sensor system. The processor may be located locally to the sensor system.
A sensor of the plurality of sensors may comprise at least two sensing means located on an elongate body (a probe). One of the at least two sensing means may comprise the at least one reference sensor. For example, a first sensing means may be provided on a sensor probe at a position which, in use, is close to an outer surface of the insulating material. A second sensing means may be provided on the sensor probe at a position which, in use, is embedded in the insulating material at a greater depth than the first sensing means. As a result, the first sensing means may be more sensitive to ambient changes than the second sensing means and may be used to provide the reference sensor output.
According to a second aspect of the invention there is provided a sensor system for detecting the presence of water in an insulating material surrounding plant equipment and/or pipe work, the sensor system comprising:
Embodiments of the second aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first aspect of the invention, or its embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a third aspect of the invention there is provided a method of evaluating a corrosion condition of plant equipment and/or pipe work surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
The processor may be local to the plurality of sensors or may be remotely located. Within the scope of the invention, inputting data to the processor, and/or determining one or corrosion conditions may be performed in a remote location from the plurality of sensors, including in another international jurisdiction.
The method may comprise analysing the properties of the insulating system to determine whether one or more of the plurality of sensors is located in a substantially dry portion of the insulating material. The method may comprise identifying whether one or more of the plurality of sensors has an output which has a close correlation with/tends to follow the output of the at least one reference sensor.
The method may comprise analysing the properties of the insulating system to determine whether one or more of the plurality of sensors is located in a substantially wet portion of the insulating material. The method may comprise identifying whether one or more of the plurality of sensors has an output which is not closely correlated to/which deviates from the output of the at least one reference sensor.
The method may comprise analysing the properties of the insulating system to determine whether the system is not airtight. The method may comprise identifying whether one or more of the plurality of sensors has an output which has a close correlation with/tends to follow the output of the at least one reference sensor.
The method may comprise analysing the properties of the insulating system to determine whether the system is airtight. The method may comprise identifying whether one or more of the plurality of sensors has an output which is not closely correlated to/which deviates from the output of the at least one reference sensor.
The method may comprise analysing the properties of the insulating system to determine the general location of a water ingress point. The method may comprise identifying whether one or more of the plurality of sensors, at a point or points in time, has an output which is not closely correlated to/which deviates from the output of the at least one reference sensor, which may be following an increase in the readings from the plurality of sensors and the at least one reference sensor.
Embodiments of the third aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first or second aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a fourth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of evaluating a corrosion risk of a metal structure surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
The evaluation of the corrosion risk may relate to the environment for corrosion surrounding the metal structure, including in and/or under the insulating material.
The sensor system may further comprise a processor which may receive the sensor outputs from the plurality of sensors. The sensor system may further comprise at least one reference sensor operable to provide a reference sensor output indicative of the presence of water in an ambient environment in the vicinity of the plurality of sensors. The processor may receive the reference sensor output. The processor may correlate the sensor outputs from the plurality of sensors and the reference sensor output to provide a correlation data output for use in evaluating a corrosion condition. The output data from the sensor system may be received via the processor. The output data from the sensor system may be the corrosion condition, which may be a condition within and/or under the insulating material which is a contributor to the risk of corrosion. The corrosion condition may relate to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material.
The presence of water in the insulating material is a contributor to the risk of corrosion. Other factors which may be contributors to the risk of corrosion may form inputs to the model. The model may comprise one or more additional inputs selected from the group comprising: temperature; the presence of chlorides; material type; coating types and ages; design factors (including plant equipment and/or pipe work topography and geometry); insulation types, conditions and ages; cladding design, types and ages; and ambient conditions.
The method may comprise determining the probability and/or the likelihood of failure of the metal structure due to corrosion under insulation.
The sensor outputs may be real-time, continuous sensor outputs which may be inputted into the model.
Embodiments of the fourth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to third aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a fifth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of evaluating a corrosion risk of a metal structure surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
The evaluation of the corrosion risk may relate to the environment for corrosion surrounding the metal structure, including in and/or under the insulating material.
The sensor system may further comprise a processor which may receive the sensor outputs from the at least one sensor. The sensor system may further comprise at least one reference sensor operable to provide a reference sensor output indicative of the presence of water in an ambient environment in the vicinity of the at least one sensor. The processor may receive the reference sensor output. The processor may correlate the sensor outputs from the at least one sensor and the reference sensor output to provide a correlation data output for use in evaluating a corrosion condition. The output data from the sensor system may be received via the processor. The output data from the sensor system may be the corrosion condition, which may be a condition within and/or under the insulating material which is a contributor to the risk of corrosion. The corrosion condition may relate to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material.
The corrosion risk may relate to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material. The method may comprise determining the probability and/or the likelihood of failure of the metal structure due to corrosion under insulation.
The output data from the sensor system may provide information relating to water wetting of the metal structure as an input to the model. Additional information relating to the water wetting of the metal structure may also be input into the model. For example, where the insulation is surrounded by a cladding, the design of the cladding, including the location of any drain holes, is a factor which can be accounted for. Other properties of the cladding, such as its material, age and condition may also be considered.
The presence of water in the insulating material is a contributor to the risk of corrosion. Other factors which may contribute to the risk of corrosion may be input into the model. The model may comprise additional inputs which may comprise information and/or data relating to one or more factors selected from the group comprising: material, coating and design. The material input may include factors such as the material from which the structure is formed and/or associated temperatures. The coating input may include factors relating to coatings applied to the surface of the metal structure (i.e. paint or a corrosion resistant paint) such as the material from which a coating of the metal structure is formed and the age of the coating. The design input may include factors such as metal structure wall thicknesses, metal structure dimensions (for example, pipe diameters where the metal structure is a pipe) and non-destructive testing (NDT) results.
The method may comprise quantifying the sensor outputs into a value which may relate to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material. Where there are additional inputs into the model, the method may comprise quantifying the additional inputs into values which may relate to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material. The method may comprising combining the values relating to the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material from the model inputs to provide an overall value for the likelihood of the occurrence and/or presence of corrosion under the insulating material and/or the probability of failure of the metal structure due to corrosion under insulation.
Embodiments of the fifth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to fourth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a sixth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of evaluating a corrosion risk of a metal structure surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
Embodiments of the sixth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to fifth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a seventh aspect of the invention, there is provided a sensor for detecting humidity and/or free water, the sensor comprising:
Throughout this specification, the term water is used to mean water in any form, and includes references to vapour/humidity and free/liquid water. The term humidity is used to mean the concentration of water vapour in the air, and may refer to absolute humidity, which is the ratio of the mass of water vapour present in a given volume of air, and/or relative humidity, which is the ratio of absolute humidity to the saturated humidity level at the same temperature. The term free water and/or moisture is used to mean water in a liquid state. Although the term free water is used, the sensor may be operable to detect the presence of any fluid.
The sensor may comprise a body.
The means for detecting the presence of free water may comprise at least two electrodes spaced apart from one another on the body portion, and may comprise a means for determining the capacitance value between the at least two electrodes. A dielectric property of a material between the least two electrodes may be indicative of its water content, such that the capacitance value between the two electrodes may represent the presence of free water in the material. A change in capacitance value between the at least two electrodes may be affected when the water content of the material changes.
The humidity sensing means may be provided in the body of the sensor. The body of the sensor may comprise an air channel. The air channel may be located at least between the humidity sensing means and an exterior surface or surfaces of the body, such that the humidity sensing means may be in fluid communication with an exterior environment surrounding the body of the sensor via the air channel.
The sensor may be used for detecting the presence of humidity and/or free water in and/or surrounding an insulating material, The material between the least two electrodes may be an insulating material.
The humidity sensing means may comprise any suitable humidity sensing means. The humidity sensing means may comprise a humidity sensor chip. The humidity sensing means may comprise a capacitive sensing element. The humidity sensing means may further comprise a temperature sensing means. The humidity sensing means may comprise a resistive sensing element. The humidity sensing means may comprise a thermal conductivity sensing element.
Embodiments of the seventh aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to sixth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to an eighth aspect of the invention, there is provided a sensor system for monitoring the presence of humidity and/or free water in an insulating material, the sensor system comprising:
Each of the plurality of sensors may be operable to wirelessly transmit their outputs to a processor. The processor may be a remote data processing and/or storage unit. The processor may be a computer.
Embodiments of the eighth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to seventh aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a ninth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of assessing the source of water in an insulating material, the method comprising:
The method may comprise obtaining location data from each of the sensors of the plurality of sensors, corresponding to the location of each sensor on the insulating material. The method may comprise manual input of location data corresponding to the location of each sensor on the insulating material.
The method may comprise detecting the occurrence of peak sensor outputs. The method may comprise determining the location of the sensor or sensors providing the peak outputs.
The method may comprise detecting the occurrence of a pattern or patterns in the outputs obtained from multiple sensors of the plurality of sensors. The method may comprise determining the location of the sensor or sensors providing patterns in the outputs.
Each sensor of the plurality of sensors may be operable to provide a sensor output indicative of the presence of free water and/or humidity.
The method may comprise monitoring and/or recording the sensor outputs obtained from each sensor of the plurality of sensors over a set period of time.
The pattern or patterns in the sensor outputs may provide an indication of water propagation from a distant ingress point or points. The pattern may be a pattern of decaying or decreasing sensor outputs obtained from neighbouring sensors.
The insulating material may be provided on and/or around plant equipment and/or pipe work.
Factors relating to the layout of the insulating material may be accounted for in the method. Factors relating to the layout of the plant equipment and/or pipe work may be accounted for in the method. The method may comprise manually assessing locations of the plant equipment and/or pipe work layout that are deemed to be more susceptible to humidity and/or free water exposure, for example, a lowermost section in a vertical or substantially vertical arrangement may be assessed as being more susceptible to exposure by virtue of the possibility of water moving under the influence of gravity and pooling in this area. Another example of a location which may be deemed to be more susceptible to exposure may be at the base of a vertical U-bend in a pipe work system.
Embodiments of the ninth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to eighth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a tenth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of determining the location of insulation barriers in an insulation system, the method comprising:
Installation of an insulating barrier may, as a consequence, minimise the resources spent on replacing wet or damaged insulation.
Embodiments of the tenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to ninth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to an eleventh aspect of the invention there is provided a sensor system for detecting the presence of water at a plurality of depth locations within an insulating material, the sensor system comprising:
The term water is used to mean water in any form, and includes references to vapour/humidity and free water. The sensor output may be a reading relating to humidity and/or may be a reading relating to free water.
The system may comprise additional sensing means. The system may comprise a sensing means corresponding to each depth location of the plurality of depth locations. For example, the system may comprise a third sensing means, may comprise a fourth sensing means and may comprise a fifth sensing means.
The plurality of depth locations may comprise additional depth locations. For example, the plurality of depth locations may comprise a third depth location, may comprise a fourth depth location and may comprise a fifth depth location.
The depth of the insulating material may correspond to its thickness in a direction between the insulated surface and the outer surface of the insulating material (or materials).
The plurality of depth locations may correspond to a plurality of radial locations in the insulating material. This may be the case where the insulating material encases circular, tubular, cylindrical and/or spherical plant equipment and/or pipe work and, as a consequence, may have a generally cylindrical cross-section.
The at least one sensor may be capable of detecting the presence of humidity and/or free water in an insulating material.
The sensor system may comprise a single sensor. The second sensing means may be located on the elongate body of the at least one sensor. The first sensing means and the second sensing means may be positioned at different locations on the elongate body of the at least one sensor. The at least one sensor may therefore be operable to detect the presence of water at more than one position along the length of the elongate body.
The sensor system may comprise multiple sensors. The multiple sensors may comprise elongate bodies of differing lengths. The second sensing means may be provided on an elongate body of a second sensor. The first sensing means and the second sensing means may be positioned at different locations on the elongate bodies of the first sensor and the second sensor, respectively.
The sensing means may comprise a capacitive sensing means. The sensing means may comprise at least two electrodes spaced apart from one another on the body portion, and may comprise a means for determining the capacitance value between the at least two electrodes. A dielectric property of a material between the least two electrodes may be indicative of its water content, such that the capacitance value between the two electrodes may represent the presence of free water in the material. A change in capacitance value between the at least two electrodes may be affected when the water content of the material changes. The sensing means may comprise a resistive sensing element. The sensing means may comprise a thermal conductivity sensing element.
Embodiments of the eleventh aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to tenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a twelfth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of detecting the presence of water at a plurality of depth locations within an insulating material, the method comprising:
The location of each of the sensing means on the elongate body or bodies of the at least one sensor may be known.
The method may comprise determining, based on the location of each of the sensing means on the elongate body or bodies of the one or more sensors, the depth location of the sensing means in the insulating material.
The method may comprise linking the sensor outputs from each sensing means to the determined location of the sensing means.
The outputs obtained from the sensor system may be used to construct a profile of water readings throughout the depth of the insulating material. The outputs obtained from the sensor system may be used to produce a model or a plot representing water readings throughout the depth of the insulating material.
The sensor system may comprise a plurality of sensors spatially distributed over an insulating material. The outputs obtained from the sensor system may be used to produce a model or a plot representing how water readings throughout the depth of the insulating material change at different, spatially distributed locations of the insulating material.
The insulating material may be located on or around plant equipment and/or pipe work.
Embodiments of the twelfth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to eleventh aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a thirteenth aspect of the invention there is provided a sensor mounting apparatus, the apparatus comprising:
At least one aperture may be provided in the body. The at least one aperture may be provided in the at least one outer wall of the body and may be in fluid communication with the cavity of the body. The at least one aperture may be configured to provide the channel through which the at least part of a sensor and the insulating material are in fluid communication, in use.
When installed, the body of the sensor mounting apparatus may not extend throughout the entire thickness of the insulation and may only partially penetrate the thickness of the insulation.
The sensor mounting apparatus may be configured to removably mount at least part of a sensor within an insulating material comprising a plurality of layers. The body of the sensor mounting apparatus may be configured to be installed in the insulating material, such that it penetrates at least two layers of the insulating material. The at least one outer wall may be configured to form a seal between the at least two layers of the insulating material.
Embodiments of the thirteenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to twelfth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a fourteenth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of mounting a sensor in an insulating material, the method comprising:
Embodiments of the fourteenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to thirteenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a fifteenth aspect of the invention there is provided a sensor for detecting the presence of water in an insulating material comprising a plurality of layers, the sensor comprising:
When installed, the body of the sensor mounting apparatus may not extend throughout the entire thickness of the at least two layers of insulating material and may only partially penetrate the thickness of the insulation.
A part of the elongate body may be operable to expand and form a seal. Multiple parts of the elongate body may be operable to expand and form a seal. Alternatively, the entire elongate body may be operable to expand and form a seal.
The elongate body may comprise an expandable material. The elongate body may be surrounded, or partially surrounded by an expandable material. The expandable material may be a foam. The expandable material may be triggered to expand when exposed to water and/or when exposed to air and/or when exposed to a certain temperature.
The elongate body may comprise a compressible material. The elongate body may be surrounded, or partially surrounded by a compressible material. The compressible material may be compressed in an initial condition and may be triggered to expand when the compressive force is removed. The compressible material may be a foam.
Embodiments of the fifteenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to fourteenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a sixteenth aspect of the invention there is provided a method of installing a sensor in an insulating material comprising a plurality of layers, the method comprising:
Embodiments of the sixteenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to fifteenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to a seventeenth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of producing a corrosion model of a metal structure surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
The metal structure may be a pipe or piece of plant equipment.
The initial corrosion model may comprise theoretical data inputs. The theoretical data may include data obtained from calculations relating to the insulating environments and/or the geometry or topology of structure which it surrounds. This data might also include information, data and/or values obtained from literature.
The corrosion inspection data may be obtained by conducting a visual inspection of the structure.
The method may comprise repeating steps (b) and (c). The steps may be repeated at a later time or times.
The method may comprise:
The method may comprise repeating steps (d) and (e). The steps may be repeated at a later time or times.
Embodiments of the seventeenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to sixteenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
According to an eighteenth aspect of the invention, there is provided a metal structure surrounded by an insulating material, the method comprising:
Embodiments of the eighteenth aspect of the invention may include one or more features according to the first to seventeenth aspects of the invention, or their embodiments, or vice versa.
There will now be described, by way of example only, various embodiments of the invention with reference to the drawings, of which:
Referring firstly to
The pipe 12 carries a flowing medium (not shown) within its flow bore 14. The pipe 12 is surrounded by a layer of insulation 16, which is in turn surrounded by a layer of weatherproof protective cladding 18. In this example, air voids 20 and 22 are also present between the outer surface of the pipe and the inner surface of the insulation, and between the outer surface of the insulation and the inner surface of the cladding, respectively. It will be appreciated that air voids may not be present in alternative pipeline arrangements, or that the presence of air voids may not be continuous over the length of a pipe. Air voids may be present in some areas whilst being absent in others, and may develop or disappear over the course of time. In addition, although a weatherproof cladding 18 is shown, it will be appreciated that this may be omitted in some systems.
The system 10 includes a number of sensors 24a, 24b, 24c, 24d. 24e, 24f . . . 24n distributed over the length of the pipe 12. The pipe 12 is an existing pipe to which the sensor system has been retrofit. To install the sensors, holes (not shown) were made in the cladding 18 at the intended location of each sensor 24a-n. Each sensor has a rod-shaped probe (not shown) which has been inserted through holes in the cladding and embedded into the insulation 16 surrounding the pipe 12. In
The sensors 24a-n which make up the system can detect and measure the presence of free water, humidity or both. The sensors may also be operable to obtain temperature measurements, and/or separate temperature sensors might be provided within the system. These parameters are all linked to the occurrence of CUI, and can be used to build up a predictive model of when and where corrosion will occur in the system. For example, high humidity readings might pinpoint a problem area at which CUI is likely to occur. These factors can also indicate the presence of leaks from pipes, such as steam tracing tubes surrounding the pipe, and can be monitored for the purpose of leak identification.
The system 10 also includes one or more reference (or ambient) sensors 9. The reference sensor 9 is used to take readings from the environment surrounding the monitored component (in this case, pipe 12) which can be factored into the data collected from the sensors 24a-n and any data processing or calculation that is performed using the sensor data.
A purpose of the reference sensor 9 is to monitor ambient humidity. The reference sensor 9 could, for example, pick up daily fluctuations in humidity and/or fluctuations depending on weather conditions experienced. The ambient environment surrounding a pipe can influence the data obtained by the pipe sensors 24a-n and use of the reference sensor 9 to obtain real-Lime data relating to the ambient conditions can help to compensate for these fluctuations. In some cases, there can be a delay between changes in the ambient environment (for example, due to a change in weather) and the data picked up by the pipe sensors 24a-24n.
The inventors have appreciated that the use of one or more reference sensors to obtain reference data can lead to effective processing of the sensor system readings. Reference sensor(s) and their importance to the system are described in more detail with reference to
The sensors 24a-n are operable to wirelessly transmit readings taken from the insulation and/or the air voids surrounding the pipe 12 to a computer 26, where the data can be stored, analysed and/or further processed. Readings are transmitted to the computer 26 in real time. For example, readings are sent to the computer at selected rate, such as once per hour. The selected rate may be based on a monitoring rate that is deemed suitable for CUI prediction purposes.
Although a computer is shown in this example, it will be appreciated that any other type of remote processing and/or storage means may be used. The wireless link between the sensor system and the computer can be via any suitable communications protocol such as the internet or a wireless or mobile communications protocol.
The sensors 24a-n can be placed at any position along the pipe and at any point, or points, around its circumference. Initial sensor placement might, for example, be determined based on the layout of the facility, with a higher concentration of sensors being provided in areas which are thought to present a higher risk of CUI. This determination could be based on the layout of the facility, taking into account areas of the pipeline which are at a greater risk to water ingress or which deal with a high temperature medium flowing through the pipe. The orientation of a pipe might also factor into this determination, as the base of a vertically oriented section—such as the bend indicated generally by the arrow A in
The location of each of the sensors 24a-n with respect to the pipe is known to the processing means, either by manually inputting location data corresponding to each sensor 24a-n when establishing the system or by equipping each sensor 24a-n with a location tag or identifier (for example, using GPS) which can be determined by the processing means.
By monitoring the readings obtained from the sensors and the reference sensor (or sensors) a picture can be built up of the environment in and under the insulation surrounding the pipe. In particular, this data can be used to determine whether an environment in which CUI is likely to occur exists, or whether this is likely to exist in the future.
Following its collection, the data can be analysed manually by operators and/or automatically by the computer. For example, the data may be fed into a model which provides an overall profile of water readings along the length of the pipe and, in some cases, throughout the depth of the insulation (i.e. in the case of a pipe, radially outward from the pipe). A digital twin—a digital replica of a physical asset—could be constructed of the pipe, to provide a real-time indication of the insulating environment, and a real-time estimation of CUI.
The sensor system readings can also be inputted into a risk-based inspection (RBI) programme for a plant, which the plant operator can use to categorise the risk of certain areas in a plant and to plan repair, maintenance and inspection strategies accordingly. This can save time and money by avoiding carrying out inspections in low risk areas, or by reducing their frequency. Ultimately, this can allow users to make decisions based on an optimisation of cost versus risk. Prompts and alarms can be programmed to alert a user if readings from the sensor system exceed or drop below pre-determined values. Therefore, not only is the sensor system suitable for monitoring the environment for predicting CUI, it is also able to pick up on unexpected changes, such as changes in the temperature or humidity and/or the amount of free water in the insulation environment, which might have occurred as a result of holes in the cladding and/or the insulation, leaks from the pipe or from surrounding steam trace tubes or other pipes, or other general damage to the facility.
The data recorded by the system can be used to determine a number of factors, including: how to optimise the design of the insulation to reduce the occurrence of CUI; when and where to conduct a physical inspection of the system; where to locate additional sensors (i.e. CUI critical areas or safety critical zones, such as high pressure or explosive gas carrying zones) and where to reduce the number of sensors placed (i.e. low risk CUI areas).
This type of system is suitable for installation in a “greenfleid” (or new) plant or asset or in a “brownfield” (or existing) plant or asset.
Referring now to
The sensor 124 is shown installed in an insulating material 116 surrounding a pipe or piece of plant equipment. The sensor 124 comprises a rod-shaped probe, shown generally at 130 which extends through a pre-made hole in the cladding 118 (not shown) and penetrates the insulation 116, in use. The sensor also comprises an upper or external body part 128 which is configured to engage the outer surface of the cladding 118. The external part 128 can be used to mount the sensor, or hold the sensor in place, using any suitable means. For example, its underside may be adhered or screwed to the outer surface of the cladding 118 or insulation 116. Alternatively, the probe 130 itself or a section thereof (such as an upper section) might be provided with an external self-tapping screw thread to hold it into place in the insulation.
The external body part 128 can be adapted to house sensor parts and electronics. In
The sensor 124 is capable of detecting both free water and humidity. Throughout this specification, the term humidity is used to mean relative humidity. That is, the ratio of absolute humidity (the ratio of the mass of water vapour present in a given volume of air) to the saturated humidity level at the same temperature. The term free water is used to mean water in a liquid state. To measure and detect both of these properties, the sensor 124 utilises a combination of free water and humidity sensing technologies.
It is beneficial to distinguish between the presence of free water and humidity at a known location, rather than simply detecting the presence of water (which could be either humidity/vapour or water in its liquid form), for a number of reasons. For example, the presence of free water is likely to indicate a more aggressive atmosphere in terms of the likelihood of CUI occurring. Free water and humidity may also migrate through the insulation environment surrounding a pipe or other equipment at different rates, and in different manners depending on the facility layouts. CUI predictions can therefore be enhanced in this knowledge. However, it will be appreciated that sensors which determine humidity alone or free water alone, or which detect each of these properties in an alternative manner can also be used in the sensor system. In some operating environments, the external environment surrounding a pipe or piece of plant equipment can be of high relative humidity. In such scenarios, a humidity reading from the sensors might not actually indicate the presence of humidity in or surrounding the insulation, but rather that the sensor readings are influenced by the ambient environment (in other words, the sensor system can provide a false positive). However, the detection of free water in such cases provides a certain indication that water is present in the system and an environment for the occurrence of CUI might exist. As described above, in any of the systems and arrangements described herein, including in systems such as this, reference measurements may be taken of the external environment surrounding the monitored component (such as ambient temperature and relative humidity) and factored into corrosion estimations and predictions.
The sensor probe 130 comprises a substantially tubular body defining an internal air channel, shown generally at 132. The air channel 132 provides an unobstructed path between a humidity sensor chip 134 housed in the external body part 128 of the sensor 124 and the insulating material 116, when the sensor 124 is installed. The humidity sensor chip 134 is exposed to the atmosphere inside the insulation 116 via the air channel 133.
A humidity sensor chip 134 comprises a capacitive sensing element comprising two capacitor electrodes (not shown) with a hygroscopic dielectric material positioned between them (not shown). The dielectric constant of the hygroscopic dielectric material varies when it is subjected to a change in humidity, which in turns changes the capacitance value between the two electrodes. The humidity sensor chip 134 also comprises a temperature sensing means. Combining the humidity and temperature readings—both obtained by the humidity sensor chip 134 via its exposure to the insulation 116 atmosphere via the air channel 132—allows the relative humidity to be determined by the chip 134. Although the humidity sensor chip is described in this example as comprising a capacitive sensing element, it will be appreciated that any known and suitable means of detecting humidity may be used. For example, the humidity sensor chip may employ resistive and/or thermal conductivity sensing methods.
The presence of free water is also determined by the sensor 124 using a capacitive sensing technique. To this end, a pair of electrodes 136 are provided on the sensor probe 130. The electrodes 136 are shaped as annular discs surrounding the air channel 132.
In the case of free water detection, the insulating material 116 itself-either dry or soaked in water-surrounding the electrodes 136 of sensor 124 forms the dielectric material. As the dielectric constant of water is proportionally much greater than the dielectric constant of air, the presence of free water in the insulating material is recognizable by the sensor 124. In alternative embodiments of the invention, the electrodes 136, and/or additional sensing elements provided on the probe, are also capable of detecting changes in humidity. In such embodiments, the humidity sensor chip 134 may not be provided.
To avoid direct current flow from one electrode 136 to the other 136 through the free water (if present), the surfaces of the electrodes 136 are insulated from one another using, for example, an epoxy coating or similar. This also protects the electrodes 136 from galvanic corrosion. In the sensor 124, a non-metallic insulating material 138 forms the body of the probe 130 and thus separates the two electrodes 136 from one another. In addition, the probe 130, including the insulating material 138 and the electrodes 136, is coated with an insulating protective layer 140 (such as an epoxy coating, or similar).
By determining the degree of correlation between the pipe or equipment sensors and a reference sensor (or sensors), valuable information can be gleaned from the data which is useful in the determination of free water and/or high moisture presence in an insulation system. In general, the inventors have found that a section of insulation which tends to be dry during normal operation of the pipe or equipment changes in line with the ambient environment more so than a typically wet section of insulation. As such, the inventors have identified that sensors from a section of insulation which feedback high humidity readings with a low correlation to the reference (ambient) data provide a strong indication that the section in question is the subject of free water and/or high moisture in the insulation system. This indicates a higher CUI risk.
An alternative use for reference sensor data is to evaluate the extent to which an insulation system is airtight. Although not common or easily achieved, in some systems the goal is to achieve a fully airtight system to prevent the ingress of external humidity, moisture and any free running water into the insulating environment. To achieve an airtight system, the weatherproof cladding must be carefully reviewed to ensure that all seals, joints, holes and gaps are adequately closed.
The pipe or equipment sensors can detect sudden changes in humidity: for example, due to a sudden water ingress event. Reference sensors can similarly pick up on sudden changes in humidity: for example, due to sudden heavy rainfall. By correlating the data obtained from the pipe or equipment sensors with the reference sensor data, changes within the insulating environment can be linked to ambient changes or can be identified as being a local phenomenon, occurring only within the insulation system and not linked to the ambient environment.
The readings obtained from reference sensors can also be used to cancel out ambient fluctuations—such as ambient daytime and night-time fluctuations—picked up by the pipe or equipment sensors, which could otherwise obscure important readings or anomalies in the data. Statistical filtering methods, algorithms and machine learning can be employed to carry out this function.
A horizontal section of pipeline which is open to the environment 285 follows the vertical section 283. Due to its exposure to the outside environment, direct water ingress in the insulating environment also occurs in this section of pipeline. This is followed by a covered section of pipeline 287 which lies underneath the roof 288. As such, this section of pipeline is protected from the external environment and the possibility of direct ingress. However, water is still present in this section as a result of propagation from ingress in the environmentally open section.
In
Proportionally high readings from the sensors installed on the sections of pipeline adjacent the deluge system 281 and open to the environment 285 indicate that direct water ingress is occurring at these locations, thus verifying the expectations during the step of sensor placement based on facility layout. Respective decaying patterns in the readings between the deluge system 281 and the area open to the environment 285 (with the exception of the bend 284) and the area open to the environment 285 and the covered area 287 indicate that water present in these areas is a result of propagation.
The sensor system can also be used to measure the impact of an operation on the pipe and, in particular, on the environment for CUI surrounding the pipe. For example, if the pipe is in the vicinity of a deluge testing site—such as that in
By combining the readings from multiple sensors in a sensor system an overall picture and/or a model of the insulating environment of an entire system can be built up. This information can be used to establish information regarding the system, and in particular regarding flaws in the insulation system leading to the presence of water in the insulating environment. From analysing the readings obtained from a sensor system, it can be determined whether the presence of water is a result of direct water ingress, and where this occurs, or whether it is a result of propagation of water from one or more distant ingress points.
Information obtained from the system can therefore be used to optimise the design of insulation and to mitigate the occurrence of CUI, as the optimisation of insulation design can be based on various factors such as the location of water ingress points. CUI risk and the general configuration of the facility. Optimisation of insulation design covers all aspects of the insulation arrangement such as selection of the type of insulation, material from which the insulation is formed, number of layers in the insulation arrangement, whether to insulate a specific area or to leave it exposed and where to locate of drainage points (if any) in the system. To reduce the overall risk of corrosion, zonal barriers can be installed which isolate sections of pipe or equipment insulation from one another. The zonal barriers are configured to stop the transport of water and humidity in the insulation and/or in the void or voids between the outer surface of the pipe and the inner surface of the insulation.
The left-hand side of the pipeline system 380 is positioned directly beneath a routinely operated deluge sprinkler system 381. Near the deluge system 381 the pipeline system has a flaw 386 in the exterior cladding surrounding the insulation, through which water is able to enter the insulating environment when the deluge system 381 is operated. As such, the flaw 386 acts as an ingress point for water. This fault may be unknown in instances where visual inspection has not been carried out, where this section of the pipeline system is located in a difficult to reach and/or see area and/or where the flaw is small, difficult to see and/or obscured. A sensor system 324 comprising seven sensors labelled A to G is installed on the pipeline system.
Sensor A is installed on the left-hand side of the flaw 386 and its readings over time 390 are relatively unaffected by the activity of the deluge system. Sensor B is very close to the flaw 386. From the plot it can be seen that the readings 391 obtained from Sensor B experience a significant and rapid rise during the deluge activity, and a relatively slow decline thereafter. Sensors C and D are located in a vertical segment 383 of the pipeline system. Like sensor B, sensors C and D also experience a significant and rapid rise; however, the readings obtained from sensors C and D—392 and 393 respectively—also experience a rapid decline as water passes them by, under the influence of gravity. Sensor E is located at a lower bend in the pipeline at the base of the vertically oriented section, where water tends to accumulate for a longer period. This is evident from the relative humidity readings 394 obtained from sensor E which remain the highest throughout the period of time shown by the plot. Like sensor E, sensor F is in a section which is subject to water accumulation. However, water in this area is moving and the readings 395 from sensor F show that the area in which it is located does not experience as high a relative humidity as sensor E. The readings 396 from sensor G show that relative humidity begins to taper off as the pipeline system continues horizontally, allowing water to disperse.
By reviewing the outputs from the sensor system, such as the plot of
The material 1103 factor input concerns the material from which the pipe or equipment is formed and may also include information relating to the material surface or surrounding temperature and temperature fluctuations. The coating 1104 input might include information such as: the material from which the coating is formed; the age of the coating; and the temperature of the coating. For the water wetting input 1105, information relating to the insulating system and maintenance schedules may be used, including, for example, the watertightness of the insulating system, the water held by the insulating system and any drainage and evaporation effects. Design considerations such as pipe wall thicknesses and diameters and non-destructive testing (NDT) results may be used in the design input 1105. Following consideration of each of the input factors 1102, 1103, 1104 and 1105, each factor is risk assessed and assigned an associated probability of failure score ranging from very low to very high. The overall probability of failure 1102 is a function of these scores.
The probability of failure 1102 is generally a static value for the pipe, pipe section or piece of equipment in question. However, by replacing one or more of the inputs 1103, 1104, 1105, 1106 with a dynamic input, a dynamic representation of the probability of failure 1102 can be generated. The continuous, real-time outputs of a sensor system of the present invention can be used to provide the relevant water wetting 1105 information required by the function and thus, provide a dynamic input to the function.
For example, the sensor system could identify insulating environments surrounding pipes or pipe sections which are substantially dry and which therefore have a low or very low score. These sections could be omitted from a maintenance scope as CUI at these sections will be unlikely. The system can update the probability of failure 1102 function on the identification of wet areas, ingress points, free water flowing areas and the like.
Information obtained from the sensor system could also be linked to and provide an insight into the coating factor 1104 and its degradation.
Corrosion can generally be considered to be a function of multiple variables including (amongst other factors) time of exposure to water, temperature, presence of water and/or humidity and material properties. Corrosion models and predictions can be generated on the basis of this data. Without the use of a sensor system such as that according to embodiment of the invention, key variables of the corrosion function are unknown and resulting corrosion models and predictions are of limited value.
In many facilities it is known to implement a Risk Based Inspection (RBI) scheme, where manual inspection intervals for a pipe, structure or plant equipment are based on a risk assessment which considers the likelihood of failure due to corrosion versus the impact of failure due to corrosion. A pipe or plant equipment which has a high risk score in the risk assessment is typically inspected more often and more thoroughly than a low risk pipe or plant equipment. However, due to the uncertainties associated with RBI, those producing maintenance inspection programmes must be conservative when determining the inspection scope and intervals; this consequently drives up the cost of inspection planning and execution.
Monitoring the presence of water and/or temperature in an insulating environment allows for the introduction of a Data Based Inspection (DBI) scheme. DBI schemes can be used to supplement RBI schemes. In some cases, DBI schemes based on a matured corrosion model may provide corrosion estimates—for example, quantification of metal loss due to corrosion—based on data obtained from a sensor monitoring system which are considered to be accurate enough to replace RBI schemes altogether.
One method of improving and maturing a data based corrosion model is to collect inspection data—including measurements and observations—to document actual/real corrosion over a period of time and correlate this with the monitored data obtained from the sensor system during the same period of time. This building and maturing method can go through an iterative process, or learning cycle, to increase the reliability and accuracy of the corrosion model over time. Such an iterative process is well suited to be supported by Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) algorithms.
This data might also include information, data and/or values obtained from literature. The corrosion model is matured through iterative steps (n=1, 2, 3 . . . ) of corrosion estimation and prediction, by correlating inspection data against the monitored data 415 and theoretical foundations. Risk based inspection (RBIn) and data-based inspection (DBIn) 419 are therefore repeatedly carried out and compared to establish a stronger, more reliable and accurate corrosion model.
As the accuracy and reliability of the data-based corrosion model is increased throughout this iterative process, inspection and maintenance schedules can become more efficient and targeted. This is achieved by focusing inspection and maintenance resources on pipes, equipment and structures for which specific maintenance needs have been identified and confirmed, rather than depending on a purely theoretical process for identifying these needs.
The monitored data obtained from the sensor system, either alone or together with the corrosion model, can also be used to identify design weaknesses and provide valuable inputs to the maintenance program.
Corrosion occurs on the outer surface of a pipe or piece of equipment. Humidity readings obtained within an outer portion of a layer of insulation surrounding said pipe or equipment provide an indication, but not a precise measurement, of the environment at the surface of that pipe or equipment. There is a benefit to obtaining such readings (i.e. those from an outer portion of the insulation) as this is the location closest to where water ingress typically begins. However, to provide a fuller picture of the environment for CUI, it is desirable to obtain readings from multiple depth locations within an insulating material. Where the insulating material encases a substantially circular or tubular part—such as a pipe—the multiple depth locations correspond to radial locations in the insulating material, and a radial profile of measurements can be produced. Otherwise, the depth readings generally correspond to the thickness of an insulating material in a direction between the insulated surface and the outer surface of the insulating material (or materials).
The system comprises two sensors 624a and 624b installed adjacent to one another in an insulating material 616. The first sensor 624a has a longer probe 630a than the probe 630b of the second sensor 624b. As such, the electrode pair 636a of the first sensor 624a is positioned at an approximate depth of A in the insulating material 616 and the electrode pair 636b of the second sensor 624b is positioned at an approximate depth of B.
As described above with reference to
In an alternative embodiment of the invention, a single sensor can be used to obtain readings at different depth (or radial) positions in an insulating material.
Pairs can be formed between adjacent electrodes 736a-n, and the capacitance value between each pair of electrodes can be measured to obtain a water reading at various depth (or radial) positions. A reading obtained from the electrode pair 736a and 736b will correspond to an approximate depth of A in the insulation, a reading obtained from the electrode pair 736b and 736c will correspond to an approximate depth of B in the insulation, and so on. The processing means is told, by manual input or wireless communication protocol, the location of each electrode pair on the probe and, as such, can compute the corresponding insulation depth (or radial) position and/or proximity to the outer surface of the pipe/equipment.
In alternative combined humidity and free water embodiments of the invention, the electrode pairs, and/or additional sensing elements provided on the probe (such as additional or alternatively provided sensor chips), are also capable of detecting changes in humidity. In such embodiments, a humidity sensor chip in the external body part of the sensor may not be provided.
A microprocessor 760 is provided for multiplexer control, the processing of capacitance values and conversion to humidity values.
The foregoing embodiment concerns a sensor which capable of taking readings at different depth (or radial) positions in an insulating material. It will be appreciated that in embodiments of the invention, this type of sensor can be used to provide a reference (or ambient) reading in the same manner as the sensor 9 in the system of
In this embodiment, the outermost electrode pair is more sensitive to the ambient environment and therefore operable as the reference sensor. The other electrode pairs are embedded at a greater depth within the insulating material and therefore function as ordinary sensors, to obtain humidity readings indicative of water inside the insulating material.
In some embodiments, the innermost electrode pair (i.e. the pair closest to the surface of the pipe or plant equipment) may be selected to be the reference sensor, where the environment immediately adjacent the pipe or plant equipment surface is of interest.
Where more than one of this type of sensor is provided in a sensor system, an electrode pair of only one of the sensors may function as the reference sensor or, alternatively, an electrode pair of some or all of the sensors may function as a plurality of reference sensors.
In the foregoing description, the sensors are described as being self-installed into or on the cladding or insulation, without the use of an external mounting means. However, the sensors described can also be used with a mounting apparatus.
The mounting apparatus 870, shown in
Mounting apparatus 870 of this type can be pre-manufactured into a protective cladding or casing 818, and the sensors 824 can be installed subsequently into the mounting apparatus. Alternatively, the mounting apparats 870 can be retrofitted into an existing insulating arrangement.
In some arrangements, several types of insulating layers—such as sheets or blankets—are used to protect pipes or equipment. The sensors described with reference to
Therefore, whilst it is desirable to obtain readings from throughout several insulating layers or to generally puncture one or more layers to obtain single or multiple readings, it is also desirable to seal any resultant holes in the insulation to avoid water seeping between these layers.
The mounting apparatus described with reference to
Several alternative, un-illustrated sealing solutions have been realised by the inventors. For example, prior to installation the sensor probe (or sections thereof) is provided with an airtight cover, surrounding a layer or layers of expandable material. The cover can be removed prior to installation of the sensor to reveal the expandable material, which is triggered to slowly expand upon exposure to air or humidity, or by another factor, thereby beginning a short time window in which to install the sensor before expansion of the material completes. The sensor then seals the holes in the insulating layers following installation of the sensor therein. Another alternative sealing solution is the provision of a compressible material on the sensor probe (or sections thereof), which is initially compressed by a sleeve provided around the sensor probe (for example, a thin metal cylindrical sleeve). Removal of the sleeve prior to installation causes the compressible material to expand. Again, this begins a time window in which to install the sensor, such that it seals the layers of insulating material when installed. In both of these examples, the cover or the sleeve could be dissolvable in place, by air or humidity, following insertion of the sensor.
The invention provides a sensor system for detecting the presence of water in an insulating material surrounding plant equipment and/or pipe work and a method of evaluating a corrosion condition of plant equipment and/or pipe work surrounded by an insulating material. The sensor system comprises a plurality of sensors located in and spatially distributed over the insulating material operable to provide a sensor output indicative of the presence of water in an insulating material. The system further comprises at least one reference sensor operable to provide a reference sensor output indicative of the presence of water in an ambient environment in the vicinity of the plurality of sensors and a processor configured to receive the sensor outputs from the plurality of sensors and the reference sensor output. The processor is configured to correlate the sensor outputs from the plurality of sensors and the reference sensor output to provide a correlation data output for use in evaluating a corrosion condition.
Various modifications to the above-described embodiments may be made within the scope of the invention, and the invention extends to combinations of features other than those expressly claimed herein.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015828.3 | Oct 2020 | GB | national |
This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 17/494,289, filed Oct. 5, 2021, which claims priority to and the benefit of the filing date of Application Number GB2015828.3, filed Oct. 6, 2020, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 17494289 | Oct 2021 | US |
| Child | 18434322 | US |
