In sports training, it is desirable to measure performance indications of an athlete, such as the power produced and the total energy expended. As athlete training continues to become more and more sophisticated, some training is conducted indoors under controlled conditions, where typically large or stationary equipment is used. However many athletes and trainers prefer to monitor performance in real time under actual conditions. In rowing, some products measure rowing stroke cadence, power output and energy expended by direct or indirect measurements of the forces that the rower is applying to drive a vessel forward. Examples include mechanical strain gauges installed in an oarlock to measure the applied forces and, when combined with a measurement of the vessel speed, calculates power and energy. Such equipment is complex to install and expensive. Additionally, the same apparatus and equipment that can determine the power provided by a human may also be applied to powered vessels, for example power boats and sail boats.
The disclosure of the present invention describes a novel approach to the determination of the amount of power produced and energy expended by a person or persons in propelling a water-going vessel, for example by rowing, sculling, or paddling or by a non-human power source such as an engine/propeller or sail. The term “vessel” will be used throughout the instant disclosure, and refers to at least a rowing shell, paddle boat, dragon boat, row boat, canoe, kayak, power boat, sail boat and other human-powered and non-human powered water craft. The present invention determines the forces that oppose the motion of the vessel, any forces that aid in the motion of the vessel (such as a tail wind or water current), and determines the net resistive forces which must be overcome by the rowing motion. According to Newton's Third Law, the sum of these forces is equal and opposite to the force applied by the rower. These opposing forces comprise water skin drag, aerodynamic drag, and inertia.
To determine the various forces which oppose movement of the vessel, the present invention provides a suite of sensors for obtaining data, the sensors mounted within a case on a vessel, facing the direction of motion. An accelerometer provides data related to changes in velocity. One or more differential pressure sensors provide data on the aerodynamic pressure applied against the front, back, or sides of the vessel and its occupants, thereby to calculate the net opposing or aiding aerodynamic force. Barometric pressure and air temperature values are used to estimate air density. Due to the relatively slow speed of a vessel, and given that wind may sometimes push forward from the rear of the vessel rather than pushing back from the front, some embodiments include a second set of sensors facing directly away from the first set of sensors.
A sensor for measuring the velocity of the vessel through the water provides a value for calculating the drag due to water skin resistance, water form resistance, and other sources of energy loss in water such as wake formation that are functions of speed relative to the water surface. One example of a device for measuring vessel speed through the water is a hull-mounted impeller, for example an impeller available from Nielson-Kellerman, 21 Creek Circle, Boothwyn, Pa., 19061. Sensors based upon other technologies may be used, for example Doppler radar, digital imaging, sonar, and GPS.
In some embodiments the calculations to derive forces from acceleration and wind pressure information are improved by input from the user or through calibration procedures. For example, the acceleration data is combined with the known or assumed total weight of the vessel and occupants to determine the force due to acceleration (vessel+occupant acceleration). Aerodynamic forces are calculated from aerodynamic pressure measurements combined with aerodynamic drag and area terms, which in some embodiments are improved by measurements from a coast-down procedure. Drag forces may be estimated, assumed, entered by a user, or measured by a coast-down calibration or other calibration procedures.
Since water skin drag and aerodynamic drag act on the vessel simultaneously, in some embodiments the magnitude of the two factors is determined using a calibration procedure denominated a “blow back procedure”. In this procedure, the vessel and occupants are allowed to be blown backwards by the wind until they reach a steady-state velocity relative to the water. By measuring the water speed and air speed, together with a previous measurement or estimate of the vessel's water skin drag as determined by a coast down procedure, the aerodynamic drag coefficient can be calculated. After completion of the blow back calibration, another coast down calibration is performed, using the measured value of aerodynamic drag, thereby to determine a refined value of water skin drag. With this refined value of water skin drag, another blow back calibration is performed, iteratively, until the values of water skin drag and aerodynamic drag stabilize. The coast-down procedure can then be done again with the refined value of aerodynamic drag iteratively improving the measurements of the drag coefficients with each additional calibration cycle.
In other embodiments, the coast-downs are performed both into a head wind and then with a tail wind providing data that again can separate the action of the aerodynamic resistance from the water skin resistance. Using this method, both the skin drag coefficient and the aerodynamic drag coefficient are calculated simultaneously by fitting the combined data to the appropriately reduced equation of motion. Since the fitting is done on data where (1) water drag and air drag both slow the vessel and (2) wind aids the vessel motion and only water drag slows it down, the method provides an improved method for accurately calculating the water skin drag coefficient and the aerodynamic drag coefficient and separating the contribution of each to the resistance of vessel motion.
In another embodiment, a vessel whose drag coefficient is to be measured is attached to another vessel and is towed through the water at a steady rate typical of the subject vessel. A strain gauge or other force measuring device is used to determine the total force required to pull the subject vessel forward at the desired speed. Once this force is determined it is a straightforward process to calculate the hull drag of the target vessel.
In one embodiment these procedures are used in the same manner to determine the various parameters regarding a power boat, thereby enabling the same apparatus and methods to be used in determining the power delivered by the engine without monitoring the engine itself. Similarly, applying the same apparatus and methods to a sail boat determines the power provided by the sail to the boat.
The sensors described by the instant disclosure are used by a microcomputer, which in turn calculates certain performance and status information. The results are presented to the user, and/or may be recorded for later analysis.
Table 1 provides some Acronyms, and Abbreviations as may be used in the detailed description.
The present invention is described as implemented on a water vessel, such as a rowing shell, but it may be practiced on any water-going vessel. The term “vessel” as used throughout this disclosure may include the human(s) that is using the vessel device. For example, the drag coefficient of a vessel would include the effect of the person(s) propelling or riding in the vessel.
The present invention comprises sensors to measure vessel speed relative to a body of water, acceleration, air temperature, absolute and differential ambient air pressure facing one or more directions, an MCU to control system operation and to collect and process sensor data, an optional display of user information or instructions, switches to accept user control inputs, and electrical DC power for circuit and sensor operation. In another embodiment a GPS sensor is used to determine vessel position and speed of the vessel with respect to the land.
This disclosure describes an embodiment of the present invention wherein all of the described modules are employed. This description should not be considered limiting, in that the invention encompasses subset embodiments wherein some features, accuracy, or both may be diminished for cost or other reasons. For example, some embodiments do not include a second set of sensors. Others will be obvious to one skilled in the relevant art. All such embodiments are practice of the present invention.
Connections between the functional blocks comprising one embodiment of the invention are shown in
There are many MCUs in the industry that are suitable for practicing the invention. Alternatives may include more or fewer on-chip functions. MCU 200 described herein is for illustrative purposes. One skilled in the art will understand that some functions and features ascribed to the MCU 200 may be implemented with a different system partitioning of on or off chip, such as an external ADC, external MUX, and external temperature sensor. The embodiment described herein is representative of a certain complement of features and functions. The present invention includes alternative embodiments that incorporate more or fewer end-user features.
User switches SW1 through SW6 202 provide for command input and system reset by the user. Switch SW1, diode D1, resistor R11, and capacitor C6 provide a reset network. Application of battery voltage to terminal VCC or closure of switch SW1 asserts line RST*, forcing the MCU 200 to reset and restart. The values of resistor R11 and capacitor C6 are selected to achieve the desired duration of reset pulse width in accordance with the specification of a selected MCU. A typical keypad input arrangement for user interface is connected to port 2. The MCU 200 periodically reads port 2 terminal logic states to execute a system function associated with a depressed switch. If available, input interrupt circuits in the MCU 200 may detect changes in the switch states and alert the processor.
In some embodiments power consumption is minimized by selectively powering various portions of the system only when needed. In the example shown the differential pressure module 700 is powered in response to signal nDIFFPWR, the absolute pressure module 600 is powered in response to signal nABSPWR, and the accelerometer module 300 is powered in response to signal nACCELPWR, and the water speed 900 sensor is powered in response to signal IMPPWR.
The MCU 200 asserts signal DIFFEN to enable differential pressure module 700 differential amplifier 702 and releases signal DIFFEN to place differential amplifier 702 in low-power mode. Lines DIFFPHI and DIFFPLO are connected to the ADC MUX of the MCU 200.
The absolute pressure module 600 provides absolute pressure measurements for air density and altitude calculations. The MCU 200 asserts signal ABSEN to enable absolute pressure module 600 differential amplifier 602 and releases ABSEN to place differential amplifier 602 in low power mode. Lines ABSPHI and ABSPHLO are connected to the ADC MUX of the MCU 200.
The MCU 200 asserts signal ACCELEN to enable acceleration module amplifier U2A 302 and releases ACCELEN to place amplifier U2A 302 in low power mode. Signal ACCELBIAS, under the control of the MCU 200 as described later, controls the bias to amplifier U2A 302. Line ACCEL from accelerometer module 300 is connected to the ADC MUX of the MCU 200.
Line IMPELLER provides contact closure pulse signals responsive to an impeller 900 (in this example) rotation sensor to a digital input of the MCU 200. The MCU 200 measures the time between pulses to calculate vessel speed relative to the water. The speed of the vessel through the water is used for power calculations:
Power=(Vessel speed through the water)*(sum of opposing forces).
In another embodiment, ground speed calculations are used by the MCU 200 to provide information to the occupants regarding the progress of the vessel towards a stationary, earth-bound target. In some embodiments position data is provide by a module, such as a GPS satellite module (not shown).
The output of U1 304 varies ratiometrically with the supply voltage. Zero acceleration provides an output of approximately half of the supply voltage, with some offset due to production variations. The resistor divider formed by R3 and R5 (
Amplifier U2A 302 has a differential gain of about 5.8. The amplifier output terminal is connected to the ADC through the MUX of the MCU 200. The ADC input range also varies ratiometrically with supply voltage, therefore the resolution of acceleration by the system expressed in units of g per bit is constant, regardless of supply voltage.
Amplifier U2A 302 gain is selected to optimize the sensitivity of the circuit while allowing an acceptable range of minimum and maximum acceleration values. Since production variations of the range of output values in a given MEMS accelerometer can be significant, R4 and the ACCELBIAS signal are provided to modify the inverting amplifier U2A 302 terminal bias to accommodate accelerometer zero bias offsets. ACCELBIAS is driven by a tri-state output terminal of the MCU 200 and thus the output terminal may float or be driven to VCC or ground. When ACCELBIAS is floating, R4 will have no effect and the offset will be AVCC/2 as determined by R3 and R5. When ACCELBIAS is driven to ground, R4 will act in parallel with R5, providing a bias voltage of ( 5/12)*AVCC. Similarly, if ACCELBIAS is driven high, then the bias voltage will change to ( 7/12)*AVCC. This accommodates the full range of possible offsets specified for the accelerometer component used in the example shown.
One embodiment of the present invention includes an absolute pressure module 600 to provide barometric pressure (Ps).
Absolute pressure sensor U6 608 generates an approximately zero volt differential between sensor U6 output terminals +V and −V at zero pressure (complete vacuum), and a positive differential voltage for nonzero atmospheric pressures. As ambient pressure decreases in response to atmospheric changes, the differential output voltage from sensor U6 608 decreases. If the pressure rises, the differential voltage increases. The sensor U6 608 component selected must take into account the maximum and minimum pressure readings possible, functions of the maximum and minimum design attitude for the system. The barometric pressure is provided to pressure sensor U6 608 by air tight passages between the sensor and a hole in an enclosure, the hole oriented so as to be orthogonal to the direction of travel of the vessel. Alternatively, the static port of a pitot tube may be connected to pressure sensor U6 608 by an air tight passage.
The differential voltage across sensor U6 608 terminals +V and −V is applied to the high impedance inputs of differential amplifier 602, comprised of two operational amplifiers USA and U5B and resistors R16, R18, and R19. The difference of the output signals of operational amplifiers U5A and USB is approximately proportional to the difference of the inputs, with a gain of about 201 for the resistor values shown. The average of the two differential output voltages from differential amplifier 602 will be the same as the average of the inputs, equal to the common mode bias voltage of the sensor, typically near AVCC/2. Differential amplification causes one output to go up and the other to go down by equal amounts. If the differential input is zero, i.e., the two inputs are the same, the two outputs will also be the same. When pressure is applied the inputs will spread out, one going higher and one going lower from the common mode or average voltage of the two. As an example, given inputs of 1.501 and 1.499 (2 mV differential), with a gain of 201 the outputs would be 1.701 (1.5+201*001) and 1.299V. The output differential are 1.701-1.299=402 mV or 201 times the 2 mV input differential. The common mode voltage or average voltage of the two outputs are (1.701+1.299)/2=1.500V, same as the input.
RC low pass filters 604 and 606 remove high frequency noise from the outputs of differential amplifier 602. The filtered differential signals are connected with MCU 200 on lines ABSPHI and ABSPHLO. In some embodiments, low pass filters 604 and 606 are not used (that is, ABSPHI and ABSPLO are the unfiltered output of differential amplifier 602). In either case, digital signal processing firmware within the MCU 200 may also perform signal filtering.
In the example embodiment shown the differential voltage (ABSPHI−ABSPHLO) changes ratiometrically with battery supply voltage. Since the ADC input range also varies ratiometrically with battery supply voltage, the ADC count output will be approximately the same for a given pressure regardless of the supply voltage. In one embodiment the battery supply is regulated and the ADC is provided a reference voltage source.
MCU 200 calculates the absolute pressure by digitally sampling the signals on lines ABSPHI and ABSPLO and subtracting the two numerical values received from the ADC. The resulting difference is then scaled and corrected to take into account offsets and variations in circuit gain and sensor sensitivity as determined during calibrations.
The circuit for differential pressure module 700 is nearly identical to absolute pressure module 600. Differential amplifier 702 has a gain of 1820. Sensor U8 708 is connected with two pressure ports versus sensor U6 608, which is connected with one pressure port.
The following describes the operation and use of the differential pressure ports. For embodiments including an optional second set of sensors at the rear of the vessel, the operation is identical. Polling of the two differential pressure signals may be used to determine which set of sensors are to be used. The MCU 200 has been programmed to use one or the other sets of sensors, but not both at the same time. Differential pressure is used to measure the dynamic air pressure against the front of the vessel. Sensors measure the difference between two pressure input ports. The pressure input ports are holes in the system encasement which are connected with the pressure sensors by air tight passages. A first pressure input port faces the direction of travel and the air pressure (Pt) is connected to one side of pressure sensor U8 708 via an air tight passage. A second pressure input port is located on the side of the system encasement such that it receives static or atmospheric pressure (Ps). The atmospheric pressure is connected to a second side of pressure sensor U8 708 and to pressure sensor U6 608 by air tight passages. In some embodiments Pt and Ps are provide to the pressure sensor(s) by air tight passages connected to a pitot tube. Pressure sensor U8 708 senses the difference between the two pressure values, the difference being defined as “dynamic pressure” (Q), and is due to the movement of the vessel through the air. The total force against the vessel is related to the dynamic pressure, the drag coefficient, and the frontal area. That portion of total power required to move the vessel through the air is calculated based upon this force and the vessel speed.
In the embodiment shown sensor U8 708 includes two pressure input ports, sensing the differential pressure directly. In another embodiment a first sensor senses Ps and a second sensor senses Pt. The output signal of each sensor is connected to the ADC MUX. The ADC converts each of the two output signals separately and provides the digital result to the MCU 200. The MCU 200 calculates the dynamic pressure by subtracting Ps from Pt. Other configurations of differential pressure measurement are known to those skilled in the art.
According to Bernoulli's equation the dynamic pressure is
Since the density of the air is known or can be estimated, the relative wind speed can be calculated from the dynamic pressure. Rearranging terms, we find the wind speed as:
Since the pressure system has no knowledge of ground speed, this represents wind speed relative to the vessel.
In one embodiment differential pressure module 700 is designed for operation over a pressure range of +/−10 kPa for good resolution of low pressure signals. The gain and sensitivity of differential pressure module 700 optimize the measurement range and measurement resolution over the expected range of vessel operating speeds. Using the configuration and values indicated in
The MCU 200 digitally samples the signals provided by lines DIFFPHI and DIFFPLO and subtracts the two numerical values returned by the ADC conversions. The difference is scaled and corrected to take into account offsets and variations in circuit gain and sensor sensitivity as may be determined by calibrations.
Connections between the functional blocks comprising another embodiment of the invention are shown in
Lines nROMPWR, NROMEN, SIMO, and UCLK connect MCU 1000 to a nonvolatile storage system 1700, such as that shown in
Lines RX1, TX1, and nINVALID232 connect from MCU 1000 to an RS232 serial port 1800 of
In one embodiment lines TDO/TDI, TDI_TCLK, TMS, TCK, and nRST/NMI connect MCU 1000 in
In one embodiment, both outputs of a dual-axis accelerometer are provided by acceleration module 1100, as shown in
A signal on line ACCELEN from MCU 1000 to the enable input terminal EN of voltage regulator U22 1104 in
Dual 4:1 differential analog multiplexer U20 1106 decodes address signals SIGINV and SIGSEL to determine whether the x-axis or y-axis accelerometer signal from U3 1102 is connected as a differential signal to the inputs of differential amplifier 1102. The outputs of differential amplifier 1102, signals ACCEL1 and ACCEL2, are provided to an input port of the MUX to the internal ADC in MCU 1000. U20 1106 also functions as a commutating switch to swap input signals to differential amplifier 1102 for the purpose of nulling amplifier offset errors. To null amplifier offset errors, MCU 1000 first measures the difference between differential signals ACCEL1 and ACCEL2 while driven by either the x-axis or y-axis signal as selected by SIGINV and SIGSEL. SIGSINV and SIGSEL are then changed to swap the high side of the accelerometer differential signal pair with the low side. MCU 1000 again computes the difference between ACCEL1 and ACCEL2 and sums this value with the first difference computed for ACCEL1 and ACCEL2. The offset error present in the first difference is the same magnitude as the offset error in the second difference, but opposite in sign, so when the two differences are summed the offset errors cancel. The sum of the two differences is twice the value of the difference between ACCEL1 and ACCEL2 for an ideal amplifier with no offset error. This procedure is performed independently for the x-axis signal and the y-axis signal.
Signal ACCFILTEN in
Pressure sensor connections are shown in
U23 1510 also functions as a commutating switch to swap input signals to differential amplifier 1502 for the purpose of nulling amplifier offset errors. MCU 1000 controls the swapping of inverting and noninverting inputs to amplifier 1502 and calculates the resulting differences between PRESS1 and PRESS2, similar to the method previously described for nulling amplifier errors in differential amplifier 1102.
Absolute and differential pressure sensors may have different sensitivities and therefore different amplifier gain requirements. 2:1 analog multiplexer U24 in
MCU 1000 turns power to amplifier 1500 on and off by controlling line nAMPPWR. Asserting a signal on line nAMPPWR turns on power to multiplexers U23 1510 and U24 1512 and operational amplifiers U21C 1514 and U21D 1516.
In one embodiment some sensor circuits are calibrated to improve the overall accuracy of the systems. Gain and offset values for pressure, acceleration, and temperature sensors are determined by a calibration method comprising exposing the system to two or more controlled pressures, accelerations, and temperatures respectively. For pressure and acceleration the no-pressure (vacuum) and no-acceleration (at rest) conditions are determined by calculations extending the calibration data to find the “zero offset” values. The results of calibrations are ADC readings which are stored in memory. One may optionally calibrate to more conditions and determine a calibration curve throughout the operating range of a sensor. A lower cost system with less accuracy may use one point for calibration or no calibration but rather component datasheet and design values.
Other information is needed by the system. For example, the user may enter the weight of the vessel plus himself and any other occupants, the oars, and all other equipment. In some embodiments the system is updated for such factors as ambient pressure, altitude, or temperature by user entry.
In some embodiments we estimate an average water skin friction and a scale factor relating frontal area and drag coefficient to dynamic pressure. These values are improved upon in one embodiment by a “coast-down calibration” procedure. The vessel is accelerated until it attains a certain minimum (high) speed for example, 8 mph, then all rowing, paddling or other power input is stopped, letting the vessel coast down to a predetermined maximum (low) speed, for example, 2 mph, while the occupants maintain their typical positions, holding the oar(s) or paddle(s) out of the water. During the coast-down period the system records readings to be used by a curve fitting technique. The curve fitting step is done to determine dynamic wind and water skin resistance forces. The aerodynamic factor is the overall constant relating Q to drag force. The aerodynamic factor is found by the product:
Aerodynamic drag=(drag coefficient)*(frontal area),
though neither is known separately. The water skin resistance is the product of a constant and the square of the water speed of the vessel.
The calibration method is further described by
Consider an example of applying the method of the present invention to the disclosed apparatus to determine the power expended when rowing or paddling against a rapid current. Even if the vessel makes no progress relative to land, since the water speed is used for calculating the water skin drag, the invention would show that the rower or paddler is expending energy during the workout. In some embodiments, additional energy losses are measured and taken into account for calculating the power supplied by the rower. Using Newton's Third Law, the equation of motion for a vessel on water is:
F
Toral
=F
Skin
+F
Aero
+F
Acceleration.
The forces due to other sources of water drag, such as wave or hull form resistance, are small for racing hulls and may be ignored. The portion of the drag force due to aerodynamic resistance is:
F
Aero=0.5*(CDAρVAir2),
where Cd is the coefficient of drag, A is the cross-sectional area, ρ is air density, and Vair is the velocity of the vessel relative to air. The power required to propel the vessel can be obtained by multiplying FTotal by the speed of the vessel relative to the water, Vwater. Further, the power associated with each term in the equation of motion can be calculated by multiplying by VWater.
However, beyond the power need to propel the vessel, additional power must be delivered by the rower to overcome other sources of loss beyond the sources of loss in the equation of motion. For example, if the vessel in a body of still water were pointed into a stiff headwind and the rower were only rowing fast enough to keep the vessel still and not be blow backwards by the wind, the rower supplies rowing power even though FTotal equals zero for the equation of motion. This is because the rowing propulsion process creates turbulence, and therefore heat. That is, the propulsion mechanism is lossy and in the example all of the rower power goes into that loss mechanism. With the sensors available in the present invention, part of that loss can be accounted for, specifically:
Thermodymanic Loss=FAero*(VAir−VWater)
This is a portion of the power that does not contribute to the equation of motion, but does result in thermodynamic energy loss in the system. In some embodiments of this invention, this power loss is included in the calculation of power supplied by the rower.
Firmware in the MCU processes sensor, timing, scale and calibration data to determine, record, or present certain information to the viewer.
Appendix II presents one embodiment of firmware for using the (adjusted) sensor readings, referred to in
Finally, per the “Result” section of
The pseudocode presented in the appendices is for illustration purposes. One skilled in the art would be able to develop code for any suitable MCU using any suitable programming language from the pseudocode.
One skilled in the art will recognize from the above that the present invention can be extended to any number of different combinations or subsets of sensing, computing, and storage elements. Accordingly, the present disclosure is to be taken as illustrative rather than as limiting the scope, nature, or spirit of the subject matter claimed below. Numerous modifications and variations will become apparent to those skilled in the art after studying the disclosure, including use of equivalent functional and/or structural substitutes for elements described herein, use of equivalent functional couplings for couplings described herein, and/or use of equivalent functional steps for steps described herein. Such insubstantial variations are to be considered within the scope of what is contemplated here. Moreover, if plural examples are given for specific means, or steps, and extrapolation between and/or beyond such given examples is obvious in view of the present disclosure, then the disclosure is to be deemed as effectively disclosing and thus covering at least such extrapolations.
After this disclosure is lawfully published, the owner of the present patent application has no objection to the reproduction by others of textual and graphic materials contained herein provided such reproduction is for the limited purpose of understanding the present disclosure of invention and of thereby promoting the useful arts and sciences. The owner does not however disclaim any other rights that may be lawfully associated with the disclosed materials, including but not limited to, copyrights in any computer program listings or art works or other works provided herein, and to trademark or trade dress rights that may be associated with coined terms or art works provided herein and to other otherwise-protectable subject matter included herein or otherwise derivable herefrom.
Unless expressly stated otherwise herein, ordinary terms have their corresponding ordinary meanings within the respective contexts of their presentations, and ordinary terms of art have their corresponding regular meanings.
This application is a Continuation of the commonly owned U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/615,571 filed Sep. 13, 2012 by Travis Pape et al which is incorporated by reference in its entirety. Application Ser. No. 13/615,571 is a Divisional application of commonly owned U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/715,391 filed Mar. 2, 2010, which is incorporated by reference in its entirety. Priority to both is hereby claimed to the extend allowed by law.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 12715391 | Mar 2010 | US |
Child | 13615571 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13615571 | Sep 2012 | US |
Child | 14262721 | US |