Patent Grant
8416833
1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to an arc discharge method, an arc discharge apparatus, and a fused silica crucible manufacturing apparatus, and more particularly, to a technique suitable for preventing electrode oscillation during arc discharge when vitreous silica powder is heated and melted for vitrification.
Priority is claimed on Japanese Patent Application No. 2008-242874, filed on Sep. 22, 2008, the content of which is incorporated herein by reference.
2. Description of the Related Art
A fused silica crucible used for pulling single-crystal silicon is generally manufactured by an arc melting method. This method is a method of manufacturing a fused silica crucible by accumulating vitreous silica powder on an inner surface of a mold made of carbon, providing carbon electrodes above the vitreous silica-deposited layer, and heating the vitreous silica-deposited layer by the arc discharge for vitrification.
Japanese Patent No. 03647688 discloses a technique related to arc melting in a manufacturing process of a fused silica crucible by arc melting, and JP-A-2002-68841 discloses a technique related to electrodes used for arc discharge.
In addition, recently, due to demand for higher efficiency of device operation, the diameter of a manufactured wafer has increased to over 300 mm, and for this, there is a requirement for a fused silica crucible capable of pulling single crystals with a large diameter. In addition, due to demand for a reduction in size of a device or the like, there is a strong demand for improvements in crucible properties such as an internal state of a fused silica crucible, which may directly affect the properties of single crystals under pulling.
However, when a fused silica crucible with a large diameter of 30 to 40 inches is manufactured, the amount of power needed for melting the vitreous silica powder increases, and accordingly oscillation of an electrode which occurs during the start of arc discharge cannot be ignored.
As described above, when electrode oscillation occurs during the start of arc discharge, current that flows through an arc is changed due to the oscillation, and the electrode is further oscillated due to the current change. This results in further increases in the amplitude of the generated electrode oscillation. As a result, there is a problem in that the generated arc becomes unstable, and the effect of this on the state of the melted vitreous silica powder cannot be ignored. In addition, there was a problem in that when electrode oscillation increases, small pieces generated from the electrode fall off due to the oscillation, and the properties of the fused silica crucible deteriorate. In addition, there was a problem in that when the amplitude of electrode oscillation increases, there is a possibility that the electrode may break.
In order prevent the oscillation of the electrode, increasing of the strength of the electrode, such as changing the material of the electrode to a material with higher strength, or increasing the diameter of the electrode, have been considered. However, in the manufacturing process of a fused silica crucible, an arc discharge electrode itself is consumed, and the composition thereof is released into a vitreous silica powder melting atmosphere. Therefore, due to effects on the crucible properties, those other than a carbon electrode cannot be used. In addition, in the case where the electrode diameter is increased, power density is decreased, and arc output becomes unstable. This may have an adverse effect on the crucible properties.
In addition, those effects due to electrode oscillation occur at first due to an increase in output of the arc melting caused by the increase in the crucible diameter.
The invention is designed to solve the above-mentioned problems. Objects of the invention are:
(1) to prevent the generation of electrode oscillation,
(2) to achieve arc stabilization,
(3) to prevent the deterioration of crucible properties and achieve an improvement thereof, and
(4) to provide a method and an apparatus which are applicable for large-output arc melting.
According to a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided an arc discharge method including the steps of heating and melting a non-conductive object by arc discharge using a plurality of carbon electrodes in an output range of 300 to 12,000 kVA; and setting a ratio of the distance between a contact position at which the carbon electrodes come in contact with each other and a front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode during the start of the arc discharge to be in the range of 0 to 0.9.
According to the arc discharge method of the present invention, the ratio of the distance between the contact position at which the carbon electrodes come in contact with each other and the front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode during the start of the arc discharge is set to be in the range of 0 to 0.9, so that the amplitude of electrode oscillation that occurs during the arc discharge is prevented from being greater than 0.15 times the electrode diameter. Therefore, even when electrode oscillation occurs, it does not expand but converges and settles down, so that it is possible to generate a stable arc.
According to the present invention, it is preferable that the power density of the carbon electrode be set to be in the range of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2.
According to the arc discharge method of the present invention, the power density of the carbon electrode is set to be in the range of 40 to 900 to 1,700 kVA/cm2, so that it is possible to allow the Lorentz force that is a cause of an increase in electrode oscillation to be in an acceptable range so as to prevent an increase in oscillation, and it is possible to allow the generated electrode oscillation to converge.
According to second aspect of the present invention, there is provided an arc discharge apparatus for heating and melting a non-conductive object by arc discharge using a plurality of carbon electrodes in an output range of 300 to 12,000 kVA, including: the carbon electrodes which are arranged such that the ratio of the distance between a contact position at which the carbon electrodes come in contact with each other and a front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode is in the range of 0.001 to 0.9.
According to the arc discharge apparatus of the present invention, the carbon electrodes are arranged such that the ratio of the distance between the contact position at which the carbon electrodes come in contact with each other and the front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode is in the range of 0 to 0.9, so that in the high-output arc discharge apparatus used as a heat source in a manufacturing process of a fused silica crucible of 24 inches or greater, the amplitude of electrode oscillation generated during the arc discharge is prevented from being greater than 0.15 times the electrode diameter. Therefore, even when electrode oscillation occurs, it does not expand but converges, and an expansion in electrode oscillation that may affect the quality of the fused silica crucible can be prevented. Consequently, it is possible to generate a stable arc and enhance the quality of the manufactured fused silica crucible.
When the output range is smaller than the above-mentioned range, there is a possibility that an arc does not continues, which is not preferable. When the output range is greater than the above-mentioned range, excessive costs are required, which is also not preferable. In addition, when the ratio of the distance between the contact position and the front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode is not in the above-mentioned range, electrode oscillation cannot be prevented, which is not preferable. In addition, in the case where an angle between the electrode axial lines is not in a preferable range due to the electrode shapes when the electrodes come in contact with each other at the front ends, the ratio of the distance between the contact position and the front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode may be in the range of 0.001 to 0.9. In addition, in the above-mentioned range, when the distance between the contact position and the electrode front end is less than or equal to 50 mm and greater than or equal to 0 mm, and more preferably less than or equal to 20 mm and greater than or equal to 0 mm, a proper arc can be generated.
Here, an effect of electrode oscillation described above on the manufactured fused silica crucible is not recognized when existing crucibles with a small diameter of up to about 22 inches were manufactured. However, as a result of detailed inspection, the inventors found that there may be a case where electrode oscillation causes spots in an inner surface state as a crucible property which were not conventionally deemed to be a problem. Therefore, by preventing electrode oscillation, it is possible to enhance the properties of the inner surface of the manufactured fused silica crucible.
In addition, according to the present invention, it is preferable that the power density of the carbon electrode be set to be in the range of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2.
According to the present invention, the power density of the carbon electrode is set to be in the range of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2, so that it is possible to control the Lorentz force that is a cause of the increase in electrode oscillation to be in the range of the acceptable range so as to prevent an increase in oscillation. Therefore, it is possible to allow the generated electrode oscillation to converge. Here, when the power density is smaller than the range, an arc is not continued, which is not preferable. When the power density is greater than the range, the amplitude of electrode oscillation is greater than 0.15 times the electrode diameter, electrode oscillation is strengthened, and the arc discharge stops, which is not preferable.
In addition, the carbon electrode may have a contact portion including the contact position at the front end, and the shape of the contact portion may be a cone shape of which the diameter decreases toward the front end, a truncated cone shape, or a curve shape in which curvature breakpoints do not exist in a cross-sectional outline along the axial line of the carbon electrode.
According to the present invention, the carbon electrode may have a contact portion including the contact position at the front end, and the shape of the contact portion may be a cone shape of which the diameter decreases toward the front end, a truncated cone shape, or a curve shape in which curvature breakpoints do not exist in a cross-sectional outline along the axial line of the carbon electrode. Specifically, the carbon electrode is configured in a columnar bar shape so as to allow the front end thereof to have the contact portion of which the diameter decreases toward the front end, and the contact portion has a shape without concave portions such that it comes in contact with another electrode at only a single point. That is, the shape of the contact portion is set such that a portion having a re-approach position with another electrode is only one point, one line, or one surface so as not to allow the carbon electrodes to come in contact with each other at two or more points in this contact portion. In addition, the carbon electrode may have a shape in which the diameter decreases basis to the front end along the entire length.
The carbon electrodes are provided, and they come in contact with each other at only the contact portions of the front end. Specifically, the carbon electrodes may be disposed such that the ridge lines from the front ends form a polygonal cone according to the number of the electrodes toward an apex. In addition, the diameter of the contact portion of the electrode front end decreases toward the front end in order to make the arc discharge easier and prevent electrode oscillation. Accordingly, it is possible to prevent the discharge at the side surface of the electrode where electrode oscillation is more likely to occur, and the discharge is performed only from the contact portion which does not have the concave portions at the electrode front end portion, so that it is possible to simultaneously realize the generation of a stable arc flame and the prevention of electrode oscillation.
According to the present invention, it is preferable that a ratio of the diameter of the carbon electrode to a length consumed per unit during arc discharge be in the range of 0.02 to 0.6.
According to the present invention, the ratio (length consumed per unit minutes/electrode diameter) of the diameter of the carbon electrode to the length consumed per unit during arc discharge is in the range of 0.02 to 0.6, so that it is possible to generate an arc flame that can supply an amount of heat needed for arc melting to a non-conductive object (vitreous silica powder), and simultaneously, realize an advantage in preventing electrode oscillation.
According to another aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus for manufacturing a fused silica crucible by molding raw powder into a mold for crucible forming, and heating and melting the compact thereof by arc discharge, including: the mold for charging and molding the raw powder; and the arc discharge apparatus according to any one of the above-mentioned aspects.
According to third aspect of the present invention, there is provided a manufacturing method of a fused silica crucible, comprising: a forming step by forming a vitreous silica powder into a crucible mold; and a discharging step by heating and melting a fused silica crucible by arc discharge using a plurality of carbon electrodes in an output range of 300 to 12,000 kVA for manufacturing the fused silica glass crucible, wherein the discharging step includes an arc discharge stating step of setting a ratio of the distance between a contact position at which the carbon electrodes come in contact with each other and a front end to the diameter of the carbon electrode during the start of the arc discharge to be in the range of 0.001 to 0.9 and an arc discharge maintaining step of increasing the distance between the carbon electrodes after the arc discharge starting step.
The inventors have considered, as explained below, a mechanism where electrode oscillation is generated to such an extent that there is deterioration of the arc melting state.
In the case where minute oscillation occurs in the carbon electrode during the arc discharge, due to the change in electrode positions caused by the oscillation, there is a change in the supplied current. In addition, due to the generated minute current oscillation, the Lorentz force is exerted on the electrode, and the amplitude of electrode oscillation increases. When the amplitude of electrode oscillation increases, the current oscillation further increases. By such promotive effects, there is a possibility that electrode oscillation continuously increases so as to eventually cause electrode breakage.
However, the inventors found that in the case where the amplitude of the oscillation generated in the carbon electrode during arc discharge is suppressed to be less than or equal to 0.15 times the electrode diameter, due to the interaction between electrode oscillation and the change in current caused by electrode oscillation, the increase in the electrode oscillation is prevented, and the oscillation can be converged. It is though that in the above-mentioned amplitude range, even when electrode oscillation occurs, an increase in Lorentz force caused by the change in current and electrode oscillation is prevented, and the increase in electrode oscillation can be prevented.
On the contrary, in the case where the amplitude of the oscillation generated in the carbon electrode during the arc discharge is greater than 0.15 times the electrode diameter, there is a possibility that electrode oscillation continuously increases to eventually cause electrode breakage. Therefore, in order to control the acceptable limit of the Lorentz force when oscillation is generated so as to allow the amplitude of electrode oscillation to be in the above-mentioned range, the following conditions were set.
In addition, in the case where arc melting is performed on a non-conductive object as in the manufacturing process of the fused silica crucible, unlike a case where arc melting is performed on a conductive material such as iron, a discharge has to be started between the electrodes. Accordingly, it is necessary to allow the electrode front ends to converge, so that the discharge direction crosses the axial line of the electrode. Therefore, electrode oscillation is more likely to occur. In addition, unlike a situation in which simply an object needs to be melted as in the manufacturing process of the fused silica crucible, it is necessary to more precisely perform the temperature state management in the vicinity of the surface of a vitreous silica powder compact that is to be melted. Therefore, more accurately controlling the position state or the like of the electrode is required.
According to the present invention, the power density device an amount of power supplied per unit area in an electrode cross-section perpendicular to an electrode center axis in an electrode. Specifically, it is represented as a ratio of power supplied to an electrode to a cross-sectional area of the electrode perpendicular to the electrode center axis at a position of an axial length of about 15 to 25 mm, preferably about 20 mm from the electrode front end, that is, the amount of the power supplied (kVA)/the electrode cross-sectional area (cm2). Specifically, the above-mentioned range may be set by setting the electrode diameter at the position of 20 mm to be in the range of φ20 to 40 mm, preferably in the range of φ25 to 35 mm, and more preferably φ30 mm.
In addition, electrode oscillation has the highest possibility of occurring during the start of an arc discharge, and an effect at the time of starting arc melting, that is, at the time of starting an increase in temperature at which the non-conductive object (vitreous silica powder) is highly influenced, is suppressed, so that it is possible to perform proper arc melting.
Here, the length of the carbon electrode per unit during arc discharge is different according to the size of the manufactured object. When a fused silica crucible of 32 inches is manufactured, a length of about 120 mm over 60 minutes, that is, a length of about 2 mm per minute is consumed.
In addition, when the arc discharge method and the arc discharge apparatus according to the present invention is applied to manufacture the fused silica crucible, they can be applied to any method including a manufacturing method of adding vitreous silica powder during arc discharge, that is, so-called thermal spraying and a manufacturing method in which vitreous silica powder is not added during arc discharge, that is, a so-called rotational molding.
In addition, the present invention can be applied to anywhere, such as, to a method of supplying arc power supply such as AC two-phase, three-phase, and DC, or regardless of the number of the electrodes, if it is possible.
According to the present invention, the generation of an arc flame as a heat source for melting a non-conductive object (vitreous silica powder) can be stabilized by preventing instability of an arc caused by electrode oscillation. Therefore, it is possible to provide the arc discharge method and the arc discharge apparatus capable of manufacturing a fused silica crucible which does not deteriorate the properties of a pulled semiconductor single-crystal which has good properties.
Here, the crucible properties that can be enhanced are factors that have effects on the properties of a semiconductor single-crystal pulled from the fused silica crucible, such as, the vitrification state on the inner surface of the crucible, the bubble distribution and bubble size in a thickness direction, the OH group content, impurity distributions, unevenness of the surface, and non-uniform distribution states in a crucible height direction.
Hereinafter, an arc discharge method and an arc discharge apparatus according to an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In the description, the arc discharge apparatus 1 according to this embodiment is used as a heat source in a manufacturing process of a fused silica crucible of 24 inches or greater. However, as long as it is an apparatus for performing arc melting on a non-conductive member, it is not limited by the crucible diameter, apparatus outputs, and the purpose as a heat source, and is also not limited by this configuration.
The arc discharge apparatus 1 in this embodiment includes, as illustrated in
The arc discharge apparatus 1 is a high-output apparatus for heating and melting a non-conductive object (vitreous silica powder) by arc discharge using the plural carbon electrodes 13, 13, and 13 in an output range of 300 to 12,000 kVA.
The carbon electrodes 13, 13, and 13 are electrode bars with the same shape so as to perform, for example, AC three-phase (R-phase, S-phase, and T-phase) arc discharge, and as illustrated in
The carbon electrodes 13 have a substantially columnar bar shape, and as illustrated in
An angle θ2 between the peripheral surface 13e and the axial line 13L of the carbon electrode 13 is set such that when the carbon electrodes 13 come in contact, the contact position 13b is in the range of the contact portion 13c, and preferably, θ1>2×θ2. However, for example, even in the case where θ1=2×θ2, and the contact position 13b is in the vicinity of the border between the truncated cone and the uniform diameter portion, a range in which the contact position 13b is in the range of the contact portion 13c is not excluded.
The length L1 of the contact portion 13c is set to L2<L1 for a distance L2 from the front end 13a to the contact position 13b, and set such that a ratio L2/R is in the range of 0 to 0.001 to 0.9 for the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13.
Of course, those are dependent on the angle θ1 between the axial lines 13L of the carbon electrodes 13 and the angle θ2 between the peripheral surface 13e and the axial line 13L of the carbon electrode 13, so that those ranges are set to satisfy the above-mentioned conditions.
In addition, in this embodiment, the contact position 13b is set to be on the border between the front end surface 13d and the peripheral surface 13e, and the distance L2 from the front end 13a to the contact position 13b set to zero. However, in
The contact portion 13c of the carbon electrode 13, as illustrated in
The carbon electrode 13 is set such that a ratio of the diameter R of the uniform diameter portion thereof to a length consumed per unit during arc discharge is in the range of 0.02 to 0.6.
Although the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13 is determined depending on the conditions such as the output of the arc discharge, the amount of raw powder to be melted which is defined by the diameter (size) of the fused silica crucible, and melting temperature, the time needed to maintain arc discharge, and the required electrode strength, and in addition to this, in terms of electrode oscillation prevention, the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13 is further restricted.
Specifically, when a fused silica crucible of 32 inches is manufactured, a length of about 120 mm is consumed over 60 minutes, that is, a length of 2 mm is consumed per minute. The diameter R of the carbon electrode 13 in this case is 20 to 30 to 100 to 120 mm.
The carbon electrode 13 is formed of high-purity carbon particles with a particle size of less than or equal to 0.3 mm, preferably less than or equal 0.1 mm, and more preferably less than equal to 0.05 mm. When the density thereof is in the range of 1.30 to 1.80 g/cm3, or in the range of 1.30 to 1.70 g/cm3, the density difference between the carbon electrodes disposed at the corresponding phases can be less than or equal to 0.2 g/cm3. Due to the high uniformity as described above, a generated arc becomes stable, and local deficiency of the carbon electrode 13 can be prevented.
The arc discharge apparatus 1 in this embodiment is set such that the power density of the carbon electrode 13 is in the range of 40 to 900 to 1,700 kVA/cm2 when arc discharge is performed in the manufacturing process of the fused silica crucible. Specifically, a power of 300 to 500 to 2000 to 6000 to 10000 to 12,000 kVA is supplied to the carbon electrode 13 with the set diameter R described above.
The electrode position setting device 20 includes, as illustrated in
In addition, in the figure, the supporting unit 21 and the like are illustrated only for the left carbon electrode 13, however, other electrodes are supported by the same configuration, and the heights of the carbon electrodes 13 can be individually controlled.
Hereinafter, an arc generation method according to this embodiment will be described.
The arc discharge method according to this embodiment includes, as illustrated in
In the step S1 of setting an electrode initial position shown in
Next, in the step S2 of starting the power supply shown in
In the step S3 of increasing an electrode distance shown in
In the step S4 of adjusting an electrode distance shown in
In addition, from time t3 shown in
At the same time as in the step S4 of adjusting an electrode distance, in the step S5 of setting an electrode height illustrated in
In the step S6 of terminating the power supply shown in
In addition, in each of the steps, the pressure in the vicinity of the vitreous silica powder compact 11 may be controlled by the pressure-reducing device connected to the air passages 12.
According to this embodiment, in the step S1 of setting an electrode initial position, the carbon electrodes 13, 13, and 13 come in contact with each other, and by setting the range of the distance L2 between the contact position 13b and the front end 13a to be the above-mentioned range as the ratio to the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13, power distribution is started in the step S2 of starting the power supply. Then, the amplitude of electrode oscillation that occurs, when the distances between the carbon electrodes 13 are set in the step S3 of increasing an electrode distance and the step S4 of adjusting an electrode distance, is prevented from being greater than 0.15 times the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13, so that as illustrated in
In addition, when the amplitude of electrode oscillation is controlled to be not greater than 0.15 times the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13, electrode oscillation can converge within 12 seconds from the time t1 shown in
When the amplitude of electrode oscillation is controlled to be not greater than 0.10 times the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13, electrode oscillation can converge within 8 seconds from the time t1 shown in
When the amplitude of electrode oscillation is controlled to be not greater than 0.05 times the diameter R of the carbon electrode 13, electrode oscillation can converge within 4 seconds from the time t1 shown in
According to this embodiment, in the step S3 of increasing an electrode distance, the step S4 of adjusting an electrode distance, and the step S5 of setting an electrode height, the control of the power supplied by the power supply device is controlled to allow the power density in each carbon electrode 13 to be in the range of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2. Therefore, it is possible to allow the Lorentz force that is a cause of an increase in electrode oscillation to be in an acceptable range for preventing the increase in oscillation, and it is possible to allow electrode oscillation generated in the carbon electrode 13 to converge.
In this embodiment, the shape of the contact portion 13c of the carbon electrode 13 is set such that it comes in contact with another carbon electrode 13 at only a single point, that is, a portion having a re-approach position with another electrode is only one point. Therefore, the generation of discharge at a side of the carbon electrode 13 where electrode oscillation is more likely to occur can be prevented, so that the discharge is performed only at the front end of the contact portion 13c. Accordingly, it is possible to simultaneously realize the generation of a stable arc flame and the prevention of electrode oscillation.
According to this embodiment, the carbon electrode 13 is set such that the ratio of the diameter R of the uniform diameter portion thereof to a length consumed per unit during arc discharge is in the range of 0.02 to 0.6. Accordingly, conditions, such as the output of the arc discharge, the amount of raw powder to be melted which is defined by the diameter (size) of the fused silica crucible, the melting temperature, the time needed to maintain arc discharge, and the required electrode strength are simultaneously satisfied. Therefore, it is possible to generate an arc flame that can supply an amount of heat needed to melt the vitreous silica powder compact 11 for arc melting, and simultaneously, realize an advantage in preventing electrode oscillation.
In addition, in this embodiment, the contact portion 13c has a truncated cone shape; however, the following configuration can be employed.
The carbon electrode according to the present invention is set such that as illustrated in
Here, as illustrated in
Hereinafter, Examples of the present invention will be described.
As the carbon electrode 13 described above, carbon electrodes with the following dimensions were prepared, and arc discharge was performed under the following conditions to manufacture a fused silica crucible. Here, under the condition set as follows, the results of the carbon electrodes 13 with power densities of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2 were compared.
Crucible diameter: 32 inches
Output: 3,000 kVA
Processing time: 30 minutes
Electrode shape: front end truncated cone
θ1: 16°
θ2: 7°
Carbon electrode diameter R: 70 mm
Contact portion length L1: 50 mm
Contact position L2: 10 mm from the electrode front end
Power density of carbon electrodes: 30, 50, 800, 1200, 1800, and 2000 kVA/cm2.
As a result, in the case of a power density of 30 kVA/cm2 in the carbon electrode, an arc was not normally generated. However, in the case of a power density of 50 kVA/cm2, an arc was normally generated.
In addition, in the cases of power densities of 800 and 1200 kVA/cm2 in the carbon electrodes, electrode oscillation was not greater than 0.15 times the carbon electrode diameter R, and as schematically illustrated in
From the above results, it could be seen that the generated electrode oscillation converged by setting the power density of the carbon electrode 13 to be in the range of 40 to 1,700 kVA/cm2.
Next, Experimental Examples for changing the electrode front end contact position L2 will be described.
An arc discharge was performed under the following conditions by changing the distance L2 from the electrode front end to the electrode contact position to manufacture a fused silica crucible, and the amplitude of electrode oscillation and electrode breakage were inspected.
Crucible diameter: 32 inches
Output: 3,000 kVA
Processing time: 30 minutes
Electrode shape: front end truncated cone
θ1: 16°
θ2: 7°
Carbon electrode diameter R: 70 mm
Contact portion length L1: 50 mm
Power density of carbon electrode: 800 kVA/cm2.
The results are shown in Table 1.
From the results, it could be seen that as shown in Experimental Examples 1 to 3, when the ratio of the distance between the contact position and the front end to the carbon electrode diameter was in the range of 0 to 0.9, electrode breakage did not occur, and simultaneously, the state of the manufactured fused silica crucible was preferable.
In addition, in Tables 1 and 2, “Fail” refers to problems caused by the are discharge state and device states where the crucible had properties not to be used for pulling single-crystal, such as a state where the melting process could not be performed until the thickness or the outer diameter of the crucible reached desired values, and a state where even when the shape had desirable dimensions, arc melting was insufficient and the bubble content was not reduced to a sufficient level at portions configured as non-air bubble layers in the vicinity of the inner surface of the crucible. “Pass” refers to a state where a crucible that can satisfy desired standards in all crucible properties such as the shape and the inner surface state.
Next, Experimental Examples 4-6 prepared by changing the electrode front end shape will be described.
The electrode front end shape was configured as the shapes illustrated in
Discharge direction: discharge in a downward direction (electrode axial line direction) from the electrode front end surface 13a
Amplitude of electrode/Diameter of electrode: smaller than 0.15
Arc break/Electrode fall: None
In addition, as Comparative Examples with the change in front end shape, an electrode of which the diameter increases toward the electrode front end, a columnar electrode, an electrode with unevenness at a cylindrical portion were used and arc discharge was performed thereon under the same conditions. Ratios between the electrode amplitude and the electrode diameter in this case were obtained. The result is also described.
Discharge direction: side surface discharge (discharge at peripheral surface 13e) due to an unequal electric field
Amplitude of electrode/Diameter of electrode: greater than 0.15
Arc break/Electrode fall: Yes
From the results, it could be seen that with the shape illustrated in
Next, Experimental Examples 8-10 prepared by changing the ratio between the electrode diameter and the length consumed per unit during arc discharge will be described.
The ratio between the electrode diameter and the length consumed per unit during arc discharge was changed from 1.8 to 87.5, and under the same conditions as those in Experimental Examples 1-3 prepared by changing L2, arc discharge was performed with L2 being 10 mm from the electrode front end. In this state, the ratio between the electrode amplitude and the electrode diameter was obtained. The result is described along with discharge states.
From the result, it could be seen that as shown in Experimental Examples 8 to 10, it is preferable that the ratio LL/R of the electrode diameter R to the length LL consumed per unit during arc discharge be in the range of 0.02 to 0.6.
While preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described and illustrated above, it should be understood that these are exemplary of the present invention and are not to be considered as limiting. Additions, omissions, substitutions, and other modifications can be made without departing from the spirit or scope of the present invention. Accordingly, the present invention is not to be considered as being limited by the foregoing description, and is only limited by the scope of the appended claims.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| P2008-242874 | Sep 2008 | JP | national |
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4759787 | Winterburn | Jul 1988 | A |
| 4874417 | Winterburn | Oct 1989 | A |
| 6363098 | Hagihara et al. | Mar 2002 | B1 |
| 7350378 | Leist et al. | Apr 2008 | B2 |
| 20030210731 | Fukui et al. | Nov 2003 | A1 |
| 20050120945 | Hansen | Jun 2005 | A1 |
| 20070102133 | Kemmochi et al. | May 2007 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 2000-264776 | Sep 2000 | JP |
| 2002-068841 | Mar 2002 | JP |
| 3647688 | Feb 2005 | JP |
| 8602919 | May 1986 | WO |
| 9809481 | Mar 1998 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| English language Abstract of JP 2001-089171, Apr. 3, 2001 (corresponding to JP 3647688). |
| Extended European Search Report dated Nov. 24, 2009 that issued with respect to patent family member European Patent Application No. 09170981.6. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20100071417 A1 | Mar 2010 | US |
