Arc fault circuit breaker

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6232857
  • Patent Number
    6,232,857
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, September 16, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 15, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
An arc fault circuit breaker (10) conducting an electric current to a protected load is presented. The circuit breaker (10) has a first (mechanical) compartment (24) and a second (electrical) compartment (62). A bimetal resistor (50) is disposed within the first compartment (24) and conducts the current therethrough. The bimetal resistor (50) has a stud (56) extending into the second compartment (62). A single sense line (60) is electrically connected to the bimetal resistor (50) and routed into the second compartment (62). The sense line (60) and said stud (56) conduct a voltage signal indicative of arcing of the current. A circuit board (84) is disposed within the second compartment (62) and is connected to the sense line (60) and stud (56) within the second compartment (62) to process the voltage signal. The circuit board (84) has a first conductive path (104) electrically connected to the stud (56), and a second conductive path (106) electrically connected to the sense line (60). The first and second conductive paths (104,106) run substantially parallel and proximate to each other such that electromagnetic interference of the voltage signal is substantially reduced.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates generally to a circuit breaker. More specifically the present invention relates to an arc fault circuit breaker, wherein voltage is sensed across a bimetallic element and processed by current sensing components to detect the existence of an arc fault.




Arc fault circuit breakers typically comprise a pair of separable contacts that open (trip) upon sensing an arcing current from line to ground, and/or from line to neutral. Arc fault circuit breakers typically use a differential transformer to measure arcing from line to ground. Detecting arcing from line to neutral is accomplished by detecting rapid changes in load current by measuring voltage drop across a relatively constant resistance, usually a bimetallic element (bimetal). Additionally, during over current conditions (i.e., above rated current) the bimetal heats up and flexes a predetermined distance to engage a primary tripping mechanism and trip the circuit breaker.




Components of arc fault circuit breakers are generally assembled into separate compartments as defined by their function. More specifically, mechanical components (e.g., load current carrying and switching components) of each pole are assembled into mechanical compartments, while the current sensing components are assembled into an electronics compartment. In order to connect the compartments, the load current of each pole must be routed from the mechanical compartments into the electronics compartment, through appropriate current sensing devices, and back into the mechanical compartments. Additionally, conductors or sensing lines (e.g., wires connected to the bimetal), must also be routed from the mechanical compartment into the electronics compartment.




The bimetal has a dual function. First, it engages the circuit breaker's primary tripping mechanism to trip the circuit breaker during over current conditions (e.g., above its rated current of 10, 15 or 20 amps). Second, it also detects multiple, instantaneous, high-current arcing (e.g., 70 to 500 amps or more) from line to neutral.




For the first function, the bimetal is constructed of a pair of dissimilar metallic strips having different coefficients of expansion. When the bimetal conducts current, the dissimilar metallic strips heat up and expand at different rates, causing the bimetal to flex proportionally to the current conducting through it. The bimetal is calibrated to flex a predetermined distance during over current conditions to engage and activate the tripping mechanism. This, however, requires a relatively large amount of space within an already cramped mechanical compartment to accommodate the free movement of the bimetal. This problem is exacerbated by having too many connections attached to the bimetal which must also be allowed to move freely as the bimetal flexes. Additionally, making too many connections to the bimetal during assembly may bend the bimetal enough to throw it out of calibration. Therefore it is desirable to keep to a minimum, the number of connections to the bimetal.




The second function utilizes the relatively constant resistance of the bimetal. The voltage drop across the bimetal, is sensed by sensing lines and processed by circuitry (e.g., a printed circuit board) located in the electronics compartment to detect the arcing. When voltage drops indicative of arcing are detected, the circuitry generates a trip signal to activate the tripping mechanism and trip the circuit breaker. However, voltage drops indicating an arc fault are small and rapid, and can be imitated by electromagnetic interference (EMI) in the sensing lines. If the sensing lines are not properly protected, EMI may cause the sensing circuitry to trip the circuit breaker without the occurrence of arcing (false trip).




In order to reduce the effects of EMI on prior art circuit breakers a pair of sensing lines (e.g., wires) are first connected to the printed circuit board at assembly. The lines are then twisted together to offset the effects of EMI before they are routed through appropriate openings into the mechanical compartment, where they are connected across the bimetal. However, the twisting process is labor intensive and problematically adds to the cost of assembly.




In an alternative prior art embodiment, a pair of shielded wires (e.g., coaxial cables) are used as sensing lines to reduce the effects of EMI. However, shielded wires are expensive and still require connecting two wires across the bimetal in the cramped mechanical compartment, which can result in disturbing the sensitive calibration of the bimetal.




BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In an exemplary embodiment of the invention, an arc fault circuit breaker conducting an electric current to a protected load comprises a pair of separable contacts for interrupting the current to the protected load. A first housing of the circuit breaker has a first compartment enclosing the pair of separable contacts. A second housing of the circuit breaker has a second compartment and a first opening. The second housing is assembled to the first housing to enclose the first compartment. A bimetallic element is disposed within the first compartment and conducts the current therethrough. A stud extends from the bimetallic element into the second compartment through the first opening. A conductor electrically connects to the bimetallic element and is routed into the second compartment through the first opening. The conductor and the stud conduct a voltage signal indicative of the current. A circuit board is disposed within the second compartment, and electrically connects to the conductor and the stud within the second compartment, wherein the circuit board processes the signal.




In alternative exemplary embodiment of the invention, the circuit breaker comprises a first conductive path disposed on the circuit board. The first conductive path electrically connects to the stud for conducting the voltage signal. A second conductive path disposed on the circuit board electrically connects to the conductor for conducting the voltage signal. The first and second conductive paths run substantially parallel and proximate to each other for a predetermined distance.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




Referring now to the drawings wherein like elements are numbered alike in the several Figures:





FIG. 1

is a perspective view of a circuit breaker in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is an exploded view of the mechanical compartment of the circuit breaker of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

is an exploded view of the electronics compartment of the circuit breaker of

FIG. 1

; and





FIG. 4

is schematic view of the printed circuit board of the circuit breaker of

FIG. 3

in an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Referring to

FIGS. 1

,


2


, and


3


, an exemplary embodiment of a fully assembled, single pole, arc fault circuit breaker is shown generally at


10


. Circuit breaker


10


comprises a first housing


12


, a second housing


14


, and a cover


16


that are assembled securely together with a plurality of permanent fasteners (not shown). First housing


12


defines a mechanical compartment


24


, having load current carrying and switching components


26


disposed therein (see FIG.


2


). Second housing


14


defines an electronics compartment


62


, having current sensing components


72


and neutral current carrying components


74


disposed therein (see FIG.


3


). A load current from a source (not shown) connects to line connection


38


(see FIG.


2


), and conducts along the current carrying and switching components


26


to load lug


18


for customer connection to a load (not shown). A neutral current from the load connects to neutral lug


20


(see FIG.


3


), and conducts along the neutral current carrying components


74


to neutral return wire


22


for customer connection to the source. Arc faults are sensed and processed by sensing components


72


.




Referring to

FIG. 2

, the mechanical compartment


24


is shown in detail. First housing


12


is generally rectangular in shape, and formed of electrical insulative material (i.e., plastic). First housing


12


comprises first insulative tab


28


, first rim


30


, and first side wall


32


. First tab


28


protrudes forwardly from the front of first housing


12


adjacent load lug


18


to provide an insulative barrier. First rim


30


extends around the periphery of first side wall


32


. A first rectangular slot


34


is located in rim


30


at the top and rear of first housing


12


and sized to receive pole handle


36


. First side wall


32


and first rim


30


define the mechanical compartment


24


which includes the load current carrying and switching components


26


. The load current carrying and switching components


26


within the mechanical compartment


24


are electrically connected (e.g., welded, bolted, or crimped) to form a load current path. The load current path begins at line connection


38


where the load current enters the mechanical compartment


24


. Line connection


38


includes a lower tab


40


to connect to a source line (not shown), and a fixed contact


42


which extends downwardly from the upper end of line connection


38


. Blade


44


is pivotally engaged to the first housing


12


and pivotally attached to insulated pole handle


36


. A lower end of blade


44


includes a flat contact point


46


which is forcibly biased against contact point


42


to provide electrical continuity for the load current. Pole handle


36


is pivotally attached to first housing


12


and extends outwardly from mechanical compartment


24


into the electronics compartment


62


(see FIG.


3


).




Blade


44


is electrically connected to a bottom end of bimetal element (bimetal)


50


via braided wire


48


. A top end of bimetal


50


is, in turn, electrically connected to L-shaped strap


52


. L-shaped strap


52


comprises a vertical strap body


54


and a horizontal stud extension


56


. Horizontal stud


56


is substantially perpendicular to vertical strap body


54


, and extends outwardly from mechanical compartment


24


into electronics compartment


62


as shown in FIG.


3


. Load terminal


58


also extends outwardly from the mechanical compartment


24


into electronics compartment


62


. Load terminal


58


is, in turn, electrically connected to the load lug


18


. The load current path conducts the load current from the line connection


38


, through contacts


42


and


46


, through blade


44


, braid


48


, bimetal


50


, and L-shaped strap


52


. At this point, the load current path passes out of the mechanical compartment


24


through horizontal strap extension


56


. The load current path returns to the mechanical compartment


24


through load terminal


58


and out through the load lug


18


to the load. When an arc fault is detected, the pole handle


36


pivots clockwise under the force of a tripping mechanism (not shown), causing blade


44


to pivot and separate contact points


42


and


46


, thereby opening the load current path.




Bimetal


50


has a dual function. It engages and activates the primary tripping mechanism (not shown) for tripping the circuit breaker


10


during over current conditions (e.g., above the circuit breaker's rated current of 10 amps 15 amps or 20 amps). By utilizing the different expansion rates of its bimetal construction, the bimetal is calibrated to flex a predetermined distance at the circuit breaker's rated current. Once the rated current is exceeded, any additional flexing of the bimetal will engage and activate the tripping mechanism of the circuit breaker. Additionally, bimetal


50


provides relatively constant resistance in series with the current path. Therefore, the voltage drop across the bimetal is indicative of the current in the current path. Arcing from line to neutral results in rapid current changes (e.g., 70 to 500 amps peak) in the current path, which can be sensed as rapidly changing voltage across the bimetal.




Detecting arc faults from line to neutral is accomplished by sensing the rapidly changing voltage across the bimetal


50


. The voltage sensed is by electrically connecting (e.g., welding) a single wire (sense line or conductor)


60


from the bottom end of bimetal


50


to the current sensing components


72


in the electronics compartment


62


. Additionally, the top end of bimetal


50


is connected to the current sensing components


72


through the horizontal stud extension


56


to provide a return path for the voltage signal. Advantageously, by utilizing stud extension


56


, the number of sensing lines welded to the bimetal is reduced to a single line


60


, as opposed to a pair of lines in prior art circuit breakers. This significantly reduces the number of connections made to the bimetal during assembly and, consequently, the risk of bending the bimetal and disturbing its sensitive calibration. Also, by reducing the number of connections to the bimetal, the problem of having to accommodate the free movement of the connections as the bimetal flexes is correspondingly reduced.




Referring to

FIG. 3

, the electronics compartment


62


is shown in detail. Second housing


14


is generally rectangular in shape and formed of electrical insulative material, i.e., plastic. Second housing


14


comprises second insulative tab


64


, second rim


66


, and second side wall


68


. Second tab


64


protrudes forwardly from the front of second housing


14


adjacent neutral lug


20


to provide an insulative barrier. Second rim


66


extends around the periphery of second side wall


68


. A second rectangular slot


70


is located in rim


66


and cooperates with slot


34


to receive and secure pole handle


36


when housings


12


and


14


are assembled together. Second side wall


68


and second rim


66


define the electronics compartment


62


which includes the current sensing components


72


and the neutral current carrying components


74


. The second housing


14


is assembled securely against first housing


12


with a plurality of permanent fasteners (not shown). When secured against first housing


12


, second housing


14


encloses mechanical compartment


24


and insulates and secures load lug


18


between tabs


28


and


64


.




Second side wall


68


of second housing


14


includes rectangular through holes


76


and


78


and circular through hole


80


to provide openings in the second housing


14


to permit the load terminal


58


, horizontal stud


56


and wire


60


respectively, to extend through to the electronics compartment


62


. The load current path is completed by electrically connecting stud


56


and load terminal


58


to the respective ends of the wire connector


82


.




Current sensing components


72


comprise circuit board


84


, which is electrically connected to solenoid


86


, current sensing transformer


90


, and optional current sensing transformer


92


. Printed circuit board


84


is connected across the bimetal


50


by connecting, e.g., welding, square post


94


of printed circuit board


84


to wire connector


82


proximate the electrical connection between wire connector


82


and stud


56


. Additionally, wire


60


from the bottom end of bimetal


50


is connected (e.g., welded) to stake


96


on printed circuit board


84


. When an arc fault occurs from line to neutral, voltage across bimetal


50


changes rapidly. These rapid voltage changes are sensed by wire


60


and stud


56


, which are connected across bimetal


50


. Upon receiving the signals from wire


60


and stud


56


, circuit board


84


amplifies and processes the voltage signal, and provides a trip signal to a solenoid


86


to trip the arc fault circuit breaker


10


.




As more particularly discussed hereinafter, conductive paths (traces)


104


,


105


and


106


on circuit board


84


(as shown in

FIG. 4

) receive the voltage signal to be processed by circuit board


84


. Traces


104


and


106


are run substantially parallel and proximate to each other. This significantly reduces the effects of EMI on the voltage signals from bimetal


50


, and prevents false trips. Unlike prior art circuit breakers, circuit board


84


advantageously eliminates the requirement to use expensive twisted or shielded (e.g., coaxial) wires to reduce EMI.




Solenoid


86


comprises trip rod


88


for engaging the trip mechanism (not shown) to pivot the pole handle


36


in response to the trip signal, and provides the means to trip the circuit breaker


10


under arc fault conditions. That is, when an arc fault is sensed, circuit board


84


generates a trip signal to actuate solenoid


86


, which extends the trip rod


88


to activate the trip mechanism which pivots pole handle


36


. The pole handle


36


pivots, which in turn pivots blade


44


to separate contacts


42


and


46


and thereby opens the load current path.




The neutral current carrying components


74


within the electronics compartment


62


are electrically connected (e.g., welded, bolted, or crimped) to form a neutral current path for the neutral current. The neutral current path begins at neutral lug


20


where the neutral current enters the electronics compartment


62


. Neutral lug


20


secures the neutral lead connected to the load (not shown) against neutral terminal


98


to provide electrical continuity thereto. Neutral terminal


98


is electrically connected to neutral return wire


22


via copper braid


100


. Insulated sleeve


102


surrounds a portion of copper braid


100


and provides electrical insulation between copper braid


100


and sense line


60


. Copper braid


100


is routed through the center of sensing transformer


90


such that the flow of the neutral current through the center of transformer


90


is in the opposite direction of the flow of the load current through lead


82


.




Both the copper braid


100


of the neutral current path, and wire connector


82


of the load current path are routed through the current sensing transformer


90


to sense fault currents from line to ground as is well known. This is accomplished by routing the flow of the neutral current through the sensing transformer


90


in the opposite direction to the flow of the load current. The total current flow through sensing transformer


90


thus cancels unless an external ground fault current is caused by arcing from line to ground. The resulting differential current, sensed by sensing transformer


90


, is indicative of the ground fault current and is processed by circuit board


84


. Arcing from line to ground is thereby detected.




Optional oscillating current transformer


92


is used for ground fault applications where a method is needed to detect improper wiring by the customer (e.g., the neutral current path is wired backwards). Copper braid


100


of the neutral current path is routed through the optional oscillating current transformer


92


. The resulting signal, injected by oscillating current transformer


92


and sensed by current sensing transformer


90


, is indicative of the neutral current resulting from improper wiring, and is processed by circuit board


84


.




Referring to

FIGS. 3 and 4

, a detailed schematic of the conductive paths (traces)


104


,


105


and


106


on circuit board


84


are shown in FIG.


4


. Wire


60


from the bottom end of bimetal


50


is connected to stake


96


. The voltage signal from the bimetal


50


travels through the stake


96


onto circuit board


84


. Once on the circuit board


84


, the signal travels along the conductive path formed by traces


105


and


106


. Trace


105


(shown as a dotted line) is located on the opposite side of board


84


relative to trace


106


, and connects stake


96


to trace


106


at through-hole


107


. Trace


105


is located on the opposite side of board


84


to avoid contact with other components (not shown). Substantially parallel and proximate to trace


106


is trace


104


, which provides the return path for the voltage signal back through square post


94


. Stud


56


is welded directly to square post


94


and acts as a grounding conductor to carry the voltage signal back to the top end of bimetal


50


through L shaped strap


52


(shown in FIG.


1


). Preferably, traces


104


and


106


are proximate to each other by a distance ranging from 0.8 mm to 1 mm, and run substantially parallel to each other to their points of termination. By placing traces


104


and


106


substantially parallel and proximate to each other, the effective coupling area (antenna) of traces


104


and


106


is minimized and, therefore, the possibility of EMI coupling is substantially reduced. Additionally, stud


56


further reduces the possibility of EMI coupling by eliminating a wire that would act as an antenna for the input signal. This significantly reduces the possibility of generating false trip signals due to EMI coupling. Advantageously, this eliminates the need to use expensive shielded wire, e.g., coaxial cable, or time consuming twisted pair wire to connect printed circuit board


84


to bimetal


50


. Therefore, the time and cost of assembly is significantly reduced from that of the prior art.




While the exemplary embodiment of the conductive paths on the circuit board


84


are shown as traces, one skilled in the art would recognize that the invention can apply to other conductive paths as well, e.g., embedded wires. While the exemplary embodiment of arc fault circuit breaker


10


is shown as a single pole circuit breaker, one skilled in the art would recognize that the invention can apply to multi-pole circuit breakers as well (e.g., two or three pole).




While the invention has been described with reference to a preferred embodiment, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation or material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiment disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention, but that the invention will include all embodiments failings within the scope of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An arc fault circuit breaker conducting an electrical current to a protected load, said circuit breaker comprising:a pair of separable contacts for interrupting said current to said protected load; a first housing having a first compartment enclosing said pair of separable contacts; a second housing having a second compartment and having at least one opening, communicating between said first compartment and said second compartment, said second housing assembled to said first housing to enclose said first compartment; a bimetallic element having a resistance thereby generating a voltage signal indicative of the current, said bimetallic element disposed within said first compartment and conducting said current therethrough; a stud extending from said bimetallic element into said second compartment through said at least one opening; a conductor electrically connected to said bimetallic element and routed into said second compartment through said at least one opening, said conductor and said stud conducting said voltage signal indicative of said current; and a circuit board having a circuit thereon disposed within said second compartment, said circuit board electrically connected to said conductor and said stud, wherein said circuit board processes said voltage signal to determine if a fault or over current condition exists.
  • 2. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 1 wherein said circuit board comprises:first conductive path disposed on said circuit board, said first conductive path electrically connected to said stud for conducting said voltage signal; and a second conductive path disposed on said circuit board, said second conductive path electrically connected to said conductor for conducting said voltage signal; wherein said first and second conductive paths run substantially parallel and proximate to each other for a predetermined distance.
  • 3. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 1 wherein said bimetallic element is calibrated to flex a predetermined distance when a predetermined current threshold is reached.
  • 4. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 1 wherein said circuit board processes said voltage signal to detect arcing of said current, said circuit board generating a trip signal to trip said circuit breaker when said arcing is detected.
  • 5. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 1 wherein said conductor comprises a wire.
  • 6. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 1 wherein said at least one opening comprises a first opening having said stud extend therethrough, and a second opening having said conductor routed therethrough.
  • 7. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 2 wherein said first and second conductive paths are traces disposed on said circuit board.
  • 8. An arc fault circuit breaker conducting an electric current to a protected load, said circuit breaker comprising:a pair of separable contacts for interrupting said current to said protected load; a first housing having a first compartment enclosing said pair of separable contacts; a second housing having a second compartment and having at least one opening, said second housing assembled to said first housing to enclose said first compartment; a bimetallic element having a resistence thereby generating a voltage signal indicative of the current, said bimetallic element disposed within said first compartment and conducting said current therethrough; and a circuit board having a circuit thereon disposed within said second compartment and electrically connected to said bimetal element via a conductor through said at least one opening, said circuit breaker including first and second conductive paths disposed on said circuit board to receive said voltage signal for processing by said circuit on said circuit board to determine if a fault or over current condition exists, wherein said first and second conductive paths run substantially parallel and proximate to each other for a predetermined distance.
  • 9. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 8 wherein said bimetallic element is calibrated to flex a predetermined distance when a predetermined current threshold is reached.
  • 10. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 8 wherein said circuit board processes said voltage signal to detect arcing of said current, said circuit board generating a trip signal to trip said circuit breaker when said arcing is detected.
  • 11. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 8 wherein said conductor comprises a wire.
  • 12. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 8 wherein said conductor comprises a pair of twisted or shielded wires.
  • 13. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 8 wherein said first and second conductive paths are traces disposed on said circuit board.
  • 14. The arc fault circuit breaker of claim 10 wherein said arcing is from line voltage to neutral voltage of said current.
US Referenced Citations (79)
Number Name Date Kind
3401363 Vyskocil et al. Sep 1968
3443258 Dunham et al. May 1969
3596218 Layton Jul 1971
3596219 Erickson Jul 1971
4081852 Coley et al. Mar 1978
4208690 McGinnis et al. Jun 1980
4345288 Kampf et al. Aug 1982
4468071 Russell, Jr. Aug 1984
4513268 Seymour et al. Apr 1985
4513342 Roche Apr 1985
4552018 Legetti et al. Nov 1985
4568899 May et al. Feb 1986
4573259 Seymour et al. Mar 1986
4589052 Dougherty May 1986
4598183 Gardner et al. Jul 1986
4641216 Morris et al. Feb 1987
4641217 Morris et al. Feb 1987
4658322 Rivera Apr 1987
4667253 Morris et al. May 1987
4672501 Bilac et al. Jun 1987
4686600 Morris et al. Aug 1987
4688134 Freeman et al. Aug 1987
4702002 Morris et al. Oct 1987
4847850 Kafka et al. Jul 1989
4878143 Kalai et al. Oct 1989
4878144 Nebon Oct 1989
4931894 Legatti Jun 1990
4936894 Larson et al. Jun 1990
5089796 Glennon et al. Feb 1992
5121282 White Jun 1992
5185684 Belhoff et al. Feb 1993
5185685 Tennles et al. Feb 1993
5185686 Hansen et al. Feb 1993
5185687 Belhoff et al. Feb 1993
5206596 Belhoff et al. Apr 1993
5208542 Tennies et al. May 1993
5223682 Pham et al. Jun 1993
5224006 MacKenzie et al. Jun 1993
5229730 Legatti et al. Jul 1993
5245498 Uchida et al. Sep 1993
5246302 Brune et al. Sep 1993
5250916 Edds et al. Oct 1993
5299730 Pasch et al. Apr 1994
5303113 Goleman et al. Apr 1994
5307230 MacKenzie Apr 1994
5358293 Boksiner et al. Oct 1994
5416463 Fleming et al. May 1995
5420740 MacKenzie et al. May 1995
5430247 Bockelman Jul 1995
5432455 Blades Jul 1995
5434509 Blades Jul 1995
5452223 Zuercher et al. Sep 1995
5453723 Fello et al. Sep 1995
5459630 MacKenzie et al. Oct 1995
5475609 Apolhaker Dec 1995
5483211 Carrodus et al. Jan 1996
5485093 Russell et al. Jan 1996
5493278 MacKenzie et al. Feb 1996
5506769 Russell et al. Apr 1996
5510946 Franklin Apr 1996
5510949 Innes Apr 1996
5512832 Russell et al. Apr 1996
5519561 Mrenna et al. May 1996
5546266 MacKenzie et al. Aug 1996
5550751 Russell Aug 1996
5561805 Zuercher et al. Oct 1996
5578931 Russell et al. Nov 1996
5583732 Seymour et al. Dec 1996
5590012 Dollar, II Dec 1996
5600526 Russell et al. Feb 1997
5614878 Patrick et al. Mar 1997
5615075 Kim Mar 1997
5628824 Rankin et al. May 1997
5659453 Russell et al. Aug 1997
5694101 Lavelle et al. Dec 1997
5706154 Seymour Jan 1998
5818671 Seymour et al. Oct 1998
5831500 Turner et al. Nov 1998
5831509 Elms et al. Nov 1998
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
2036032 Aug 1981 CA
WO 9113464 Sep 1991 WO
WO 9520235 Jul 1995 WO