Automated microbiological testing apparatus and method therefor

Abstract
A diagnostic microbiological testing system and method for microorganism identification (ID) and antimicrobial susceptibility determinations (AST). The system includes multiple-well test panels capable of performing ID and AST testing on the same test panel. Each test panel is inoculated with reagents, broth-suspended organisms, and placed into the instrument system. The instrument system includes a rotating carousel for incubation and indexing, multiple light sources each emitting different wavelength light, precision calorimetric and fluorometric detection, barcode test panel tracking and a control processor for making determinations based on measured test data. One light source includes a plurality of LEDs arranged in a linear array. Each of the LEDs' junction currents are controllable to produce a predetermined illumination profile.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to the field of microbiological testing.




Many conventional systems exist for performing tests on microbiological samples related to patient diagnosis and therapy. The microorganism samples may come from a variety of sources, including infected wounds, genital infections, cerebro-spinal fluids, blood and abscesses. From those microorganism samples an inoculum is prepared in accordance with established procedures which produce a bacterial or cellular suspension of a predetermined concentration. Further processing of the suspension may depend on the testing method employed.




These systems are used, for example, for identification of which microorganisms are present in a patient's sample. Typically, in such systems, reagents are placed into cupules, or test wells, of identification trays, which in the presence of an actively growing culture of microorganisms change color. Based on the color change, or lack thereof, the microorganism can be identified by the use of reference tables.




Other systems have been developed for susceptibility testing of microorganisms. These systems are used to determine the susceptibility of a microorganism in a sample to various therapeutics, such as antibiotics. Based on these test results, physicians can then, for example, prescribe an antimicrobial product which will be successful in killing or inhibiting the microorganism. In particular, qualitative susceptibility testing produces an indication of whether a microorganism is resistant or sensitive to a particular antibiotic, but does not provide an indication on the degree of sensitivity or resistance of the microorganism. On the other hand, quantitative susceptibility testing, provides an indication of the concentration of the antimicrobial agent needed to inhibit growth of the microorganism. The term minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) is used to refer to the minimum concentration of the antimicrobial agent that is required to inhibit the growth of the microorganism.




The systems have certain drawbacks. For example, when performing identification and susceptibility testing, the test trays are incubated at a controlled temperature for an extended period of time. At predetermined time intervals, the wells of the test trays are individually examined for an indication of color change or other test criteria. This can be a long and tedious process if done manually by a technician. In addition, the incubation times for identification and susceptibility test trays may differ, or the optimal time to read a test result from the test tray may not be known in advance. Thus, a technician would need to read and record results for a specimen at several different times, sometimes long apart, which may cause assignment or correlation errors.




Automated systems are desirable in performing these tests to minimize the technician handling time, as well as to minimize the possibility of human error. In addition, automated systems that obtain results rapidly and accurately are preferred.




In this regard, a microbiological testing apparatus for the automatic incubation and reading of microbiological test trays is known. The test trays of this apparatus have a plurality of wells which contain the samples or agents to be tested. The trays are first placed in an incubator for a predetermined amount of time. The test trays are then moved to an inspection station. A light source is disposed above the tray and a pair of video cameras are disposed below the tray at the inspection station. Each video camera takes a video image of an entire tray. The video image signal of the entire tray is sent to an image processor to be analyzed.




The image processor requires uniform lighting over the inspection station. Consequently, the processor records the background light level of each pixel within an area of interest corresponding to each well of the tray to account for variability in the light source. The image processor processes the video image of the tray and determines the number of pixels, for a particular well, whose intensity exceeds a predetermined threshold for that area of interest. If the number of pixels exceeds a predetermined number, a positive result is assigned to that well. The image processor analyzes the binary partial results from the wells to determine the possible identity of the microorganisms. The binary partial results are compared to prerecorded patterns of results for each type of test tray to identify the sample in question.




A microbiological testing apparatus for detecting the presence of a fluorescence emitting reaction resulting from the interaction of a reacting agent and a sample for detection, susceptibility, and identification testing, is also known. In this apparatus, multiple trays having a plurality of test chambers are contained within a carousel. This carousel is rotated to move one of the trays close to a detection area. A positioning mechanism radially then moves that tray out of the carousel and into the detection area. A high-energy light source is disposed proximately to the thus positioned tray. The light source provides narrow-band light sufficient to produce an emission fluorescence from the reaction within test chambers, which in turn is detected by a video mechanism disposed opposite to the light source and behind the positioned tray. The video mechanism produces an image based on the emission wavelength.




Another test system is known for identifying bacteria using signals based on the intensity of monochromatic light reflected from specimens placed in a culture plate having a plurality of cells. A rotary disk containing six interference filters is interposed between a lamp and a group of optical fibers. The light from the lamp passes through a particular interference filter to produce monochromatic light of a certain wavelength. The filtered monochromatic light is guided by the optical fibers to be incident on respective cells of the culture plate. The disk is rotated so that the six different wavelength monochromatic lights are caused to be incident on the cells sequentially. The light reflected from the specimens is guided by additional optical fibers to corresponding phototransistors. A signal is derived for each specimen based on the intensity of the reflected monochromatic light. These signals are then analyzed to determine the identity of the specimen by calculating the difference, or ratio, between the signals and comparing that result with a reference value.




However, the above-described apparatuses fail to address all the requirements of a fully automated microbiological testing system. In particular, they are not capable of simultaneously performing both colorimetric- and fluorometric-type testing on multiple-well test panels that is needed to obtain more accurate test results. Further, these apparatuses are generally not designed to continuously gather test data from a plurality of multiple-well test panels in a quick and reliable manner. Moreover, the automated processing of these systems is limited.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides a system that overcomes the above-described problems. In particular, the present invention provides an automated microbiological testing system that tests a plurality of multiple-well test panels, for identification and susceptibility, with a minimal amount of human intervention during the testing process. In addition, this system performs both colorimetric- and fluorometric-type testing. Moreover, this system quickly analyzes the gathered test data to produce accurate identification and/or susceptibility testing results.




In particular, one aspect of the present invention is directed to a diagnostic microbiological testing apparatus that has a carousel assembly on which is mounted a plurality of test panels. Each test panel has a plurality of wells, each of which is inoculated with a test inoculum fluid for producing a reaction. A plurality of light sources direct light of a predetermined range of wavelengths toward the wells of the test panels to cause the wells to emit or absorb light based on the reaction of the test inoculum fluid. A light detection unit, which may include a linear CCD, is disposed opposite to the light sources with at least one test panel being positioned between the light sources and the light detection unit. The light detection unit detects the light emitted from, or absorbed by, the wells of the test panels as the carousel assembly continuously rotates each of the test panels between the light sources and the light detection unit to permit light emitted from, or absorbed by, the wells of the test panels to be detected by the light detection unit. A controller receives a plurality of signals generated by the light detection unit, which correspond, respectively, to the light, which can be fluorescent or non-fluorescent, detected from each well. The controller then determines a test result for each well based on the received signals.




In another aspect of the present invention, an incubation chamber for a diagnostic microbiological testing apparatus is provided. This chamber includes a carousel assembly on which is mounted a plurality of test panels, each test panel having a plurality of wells for receiving a test inoculum fluid for producing a reaction. An enclosure surrounding the carousel assembly prevents intrusion of ambient light into the incubation chamber. The enclosure has a door for providing access to carousel assembly. A drive system continuously rotates the carousel assembly to directly position the test panels for testing by the diagnostic microbiological testing apparatus. A heating unit heats the incubation chamber and a temperature controller controls the heating unit to maintain the temperature within a predetermined temperature range.




In yet another aspect of the present invention, methods of operating, and computer mediums which include instructions for controlling, a diagnostic microbiological testing apparatus are provided. For example, one method includes the steps of (a) rotating a carousel of the testing apparatus to position a test panel mounted thereon between a light source and a light detection unit of the testing apparatus, (b) directing light from the light source toward the test panels, (c) detecting with the light detection unit the light transmitted or emitted from, or absorbed by, each of the wells of the test panels due to the test reaction, (d) generating with the light detection unit a signal corresponding to the light detected from each of the wells, and (e) determining a test result for each of the wells based on the generated signal.




In yet another aspect of the present invention, an apparatus is provided including a light source capable of producing a composite light signal having light elements of variable intensity, and a controller adapted to control the light source using an illumination profile. The apparatus may also include a light detection unit, and an optics system capable of directing the composite light signal toward the light detection unit. The illumination profile may be used to correct optical inefficiency in the optics system or changes in the illumination output of the light source.




In yet another aspect of the present invention, a light source including a plurality of LEDs arranged in a linear array is provided. The junction current of each LED is controllable to produce a predetermined illumination profile.




In yet another aspect of the present invention, a light source including a plurality of LEDs arranged in a linear array having two ends, each end having a group of LEDs of the plurality of LEDs. The group of LEDs is geometrically compressed to produce a greater intensity of light. The LEDs may include red, green and blue LEDs arranged in a predetermined order in the linear array.




In one further aspect of the present invention, an optics system is provided for a microbiological testing apparatus.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




These and other aspects, features and advantages of the present invention can best be understood by reference to the detailed description of the preferred embodiments set forth below taken with the drawings in which:





FIG. 1

is a front perspective view of the test apparatus of the present invention with the enclosure door closed.





FIG. 2

is a front perspective view of the test apparatus of the present invention with the enclosure door open.





FIG. 3A

is a perspective view of an ID/AST test panel of the present invention.





FIG. 3B

is a top view of an ID/AST test panel of the present invention.





FIG. 3C

is a bottom view of an ID/AST test panel of the present invention.





FIG. 4

is a schematic top view of the internal components of the apparatus of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 5

is a schematic perspective view of the carousel assembly of the present invention.





FIG. 6

is a perspective view of the panel carrier of the present invention.





FIG. 7

is a schematic perspective view of the measurement system tower of the present invention.





FIG. 8

is a schematic perspective view of the CCD detection module of the present invention.





FIG. 9

shows one embodiment in which solid-state LEDs and dichroic color separation filters are used.





FIGS. 10A and 10B

are respectively front and side views of another embodiment in which surface mount LEDs and color separation filters are used.





FIG. 11

is a schematic view of the configuration of the light source assemblies of the present invention.





FIG. 12A

shows a graph of an illumination output from a light source module.





FIG. 12B

shows graph of a illumination profile used to drive the light source module of the present invention.





FIG. 12C

shows a graph of an illumination output from the light source module of the present invention resulting from the illumination profile of FIG.


12


B.





FIG. 13

shows a circuit for controlling a light source module of the present invention.





FIG. 14

shows one embodiment of a light source module of the present invention.





FIG. 15

is a schematic perspective view of a portion of the panel carrier and test apparatus of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




The present invention provides a system and method for performing highly reliable microorganism identification (ID) and antimicrobial susceptibility determinations (AST). The present invention determines identification and susceptibility based on readings from wells


31


contained in ID/AST panels


30


(see FIGS.


3


A and


3


B). For example, in one embodiment, the wells


31


contain different reagent substrates and/or different antimicrobic dilutions which change optical character sometime after being inoculated with the organism. The detection method described below measures changes in absorption, scattering, and/or fluorescence. It may also measure luminescence. These changes are processed to determine the identification and susceptibility of the microorganism.




The present invention allows a technician, for example, after having inoculated the wells


31


of the ID/AST panel


30


with an unknown microorganism, to place that panel into an instrument


20


(shown in

FIG. 1

) where it is incubated at a set temperature, periodically interrogated for changes and analyzed for microorganism identification and antimicrobic susceptibility. The apparatus


20


holds a plurality of ID/AST panels


30


and provides positivity analysis results to the technician, as described below.




As shown in

FIGS. 3A-3C

, the ID/AST panels


30


are disposable devices which are inoculated with reagents needed for both ID and AST testing. The testing is performed on reactions generated by the samples and reagents placed in individual wells


31


on each ID/AST panel


30


. The wells


31


are arranged on the ID/AST panels


30


as a two-dimensional array having rows and columns.




The instrument


20


is self-contained and sufficiently autonomous to test the ID/AST panels


30


and supply the appropriate test results. The instrument


20


stores, incubates and reads the ID/AST panels


30


. The instrument


20


has a door


21


shown closed in FIG.


1


and open in

FIG. 2

to allow for access to the interior of the instrument


20


.




In one embodiment, as also shown in

FIG. 1

, a personal computer (PC) workstation


40


is communicatively connected to the instrument


20


. The PC workstation complements the instrument's


20


microbiology information system reporting and data management features., which are discussed below. The PC workstation


40


provides tools to improve empiric therapy decision and identify therapy intervention instances. The PC workstation


40


also incorporates reporting tools to assist infection control and epidemiology.




Additionally, the PC Workstation


40


incorporates a relational database (not shown) on a hard drive. Finalized AST and ID test results are retained in the database for a minimum of 52 weeks. Statistically summarized data is retained for a greater time period. Patient and specimen information may be gathered through an electronic interface with the instrument


20


(not shown) or manually entered into the PC workstation


40


.




The instrument


20


includes a carousel


50


, as shown in FIG.


2


. The carousel


50


includes an assembly


51


comprised of rings and ribs bolted to a drive ring


52


to form a cylindrical cage as shown in FIG.


5


. The carousel


50


is mounted vertically in an instrument enclosure


60


(shown in FIG.


1


). The instrument enclosure


60


defines the carousel compartment


61


and an electronics compartment


62


(shown in FIG.


4


). The carousel compartment


61


is insulated to provide a substantially uniform temperature incubation environment, and is light-tight under normal operation to prevent ambient light from entering.




Panel carriers


53


(shown in

FIG. 6

) are mounted in the assembly


51


which form four horizontal tiers with each tier having twenty-six panel positions. A total of one-hundred and four panel positions are provided. of course, these numbers of tiers and panel positions are merely an example and may be changed to suit the requirements of any specified application as will be appreciated by one skilled in the art. The panel carriers


53


are used to mount the ID/AST panels


30


as well as other types of panels discussed below. The panel carriers


53


are designed such that improperly seated panels will not be retained by the panel carriers


53


. When the ID/AST panels


30


are mounted in the four tiers of assembly


51


, they are arranged to form substantially circular rows and vertical columns of wells


31


. Within each tier, panel positions are numbered zero through twenty-five. Panel position zero is reserved for a normalization panel and is not accessible by an operator during normal operation of the instrument


20


.




As shown in

FIG. 15

, indicator LEDs


54


are used to indicate which ID/AST panels


30


should be removed (i.e., when testing is complete), and which panel positions are available for new, untested ID/AST panels


30


. The indicator LEDs


54


may be located in front of or behind each panel carrier


53


. For example, as shown in

FIG. 15

, the indicator LED


54


is mounted in a printed circuit board


57


behind the panel carrier


53


, which is positioned against a carousel rib


58


. A light guide


59


may also be used to focus the light from the indicator LEDs


54


through a convex indicator surface.




The indicator LED


54


may be a three-color LED wherein different colors are used to indicate status/testing information. For example, red may indicate that a test is in progress; green may indicate that testing is complete; and yellow may indicate that a panel position is available for a new, untested ID/AST panel


30


.




The carousel


50


also includes a drive system


56


. The drive system


56


is mounted within the instrument enclosure


60


and exterior to the cylindrical cage formed by the assembly


51


, as shown in FIG.


4


. The drive system


56


drives the assembly


51


, via the drive ring


52


, at a predetermined and controllable angular velocity. One complete rotation of the carousel


50


is used to acquire and accumulate test data from only light frequency from each ID/AST panel


30


mounted within the assembly


51


(i.e., one data accumulation cycle).




A precision stepper motor is preferably used to provide accurate rotational control of the assembly


51


. Of course, other types of motors can used which include servo-motors, synchronous motors and DC motors, for example.




An oil-treated felt pad is disposed against the drive ring


52


to ensure it remains properly lubricated. A poly-alpha-olefin oil, or similar oil, may be used to minimize oil spray and migration. In a preferred embodiment, a lubrication free bearing system can be used.




A home position flag magnet is affixed to the inner surface of the drive ring


52


corresponding to position zero of the assembly


51


. As the assembly


51


rotates, a signal is generated by a Hall-effect sensor


55


mounted within the carousel


50


each time the home position flag magnet passes. This signal is used by the instrument


20


to keep track of the panel position as the assembly


51


is rotated. of course, other types of sensors may be used for this purpose. For example, infrared and optical sensors may be used instead.




The temperature within the carousel compartment


61


is tightly controlled by means of an incubation heater, blower, and associated ductwork (none of which are shown) which distribute and recirculate the incubation air. The incubation heater includes one or more sensors


63


(shown in

FIG. 11

) to monitor the temperature within the carousel compartment


61


.




The incubation heater includes two heating elements wired in a three lead arrangement (not shown). An auto-resetting thermal circuit breaker is provided in the third, common lead to protect against heater over-temperature conditions. Should the carousel compartment


61


temperature rise above a first predetermined set point, power to the heat is interrupted. Power is reapplied when the temperature falls below a second predetermined set-point. The power supplied to the heater is controlled by a control processor


70


.




Preferably, the carousel compartment


61


is continuously maintained at a temperature of 35° C. with the first and second predetermined set points being set at 39° C. and 33°C., respectively. However, as will be appreciated by one skilled in the art, other temperature settings may be used to achieve the particular testing requirements.




In one embodiment, four barcode scanners (not shown) are mounted on a scanner tower (not shown) located within the carousel compartment


61


, either within or exterior to the circumference of the assembly


51


. One barcode scanner is provided for each tier of the assembly


51


. The barcode scanners are capable of reading barcoded labels (not shown) affixed to each ID/AST panel


30


as the panels are rotated via the assembly


51


. The barcode scanners are supported in proper relation to the ID/AST panels


30


mounted on the assembly


51


and are held at a proper scanning distance by the scanner tower.




The information read by the barcode scanners is used by the instrument


20


to correlate specific panel sequence numbers to test data gathered from the panels. Preferably, the barcode scanners are capable of reading Code-128 Numeric information. However, other known conventional barcode formats may be used instead to label the ID/AST panels


30


.




In another embodiment, a barcode reader (not shown) is installed behind the instrument front panel


71


. The barcode reader is used to scan barcode labels affixed to either side of the ID/AST panels


30


before the ID/AST panels


30


are mounted in the carousel compartment


61


. This allows, for example, the operator to affix supplemental barcoded information on each ID/AST panel


30


. The supplemental barcoded information could be, for example, a hospital-applied assession label. In this embodiment, the barcoded labels can be scanned, and the particular ID/AST panel


30


can then turned over to scan the supplemental barcoded information, this then links the ID/AST panel


30


to the supplemental barcoded information. Conventional barcode formats are supported by the barcode reader.




In another embodiment, a hand-held scanning barcode wand


72


, as shown in

FIG. 1

, is operatively connected to the instrument


20


. The barcode wand


72


may be used in the same manner as the barcode reader (e.g., to scan operator generated accession linkage, or to scan barcodes too large to be affixed to the ID/AST panels


30


). Conventional barcode formats are supported by the barcode wand


72


.




A panel position sensor for each tier is also mounted on the scanner tower. Panel position flags, integrated with the panel carriers


53


, are read by the panel position sensors. Upon scanning the leading edge of the panel flag position flags, the panel position sensors generate a signal used to provide test data acquisition timing for each ID/AST panel


30


.




As shown in

FIG. 4

, a plurality of light source assemblies are mounted within the carousel compartment


61


and exterior to the circumference of the assembly


51


. In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the light source assemblies comprise a visible light source assembly


80


and an Ultra-Violet (UV) light source assembly


81


(shown in FIG.


11


).




The visible light source assembly


80


includes four visible light source modules and a supporting tower. The supporting tower aligns one visible light source modules with each tier of the assembly


51


. At any given time, one column of wells from the ID/AST panels


30


can be illuminated by the visible light source modules.




In one embodiment, each visible light source module includes three parallel vertical columns of sixteen light-emitting diodes (LEDs) each. The first column consists of red LEDs, the second green LEDs and the third blue LEDs. A holographic diffuser plate


82


is located in close proximity to the ID/AST panels


30


mounted in the assembly


51


. The holographic diffuser plate


82


diffuse the illumination energy from each column of LEDs (when energized). Each column of LEDs is mounted in the visible light source modules to maintain a fixed distance from the diffuser plate


82


. Cylindrical lenses may be used to focus the illumination energy from each column of LEDs onto the vertical well columns of the ID/AST panels


30


. The illumination axis for each column of LEDs is made coincident for the red, green and blue illumination. Thus, each well column sees a uniform stripe of either red, green or, blue illumination, depending upon which column of LEDs is energized.




Each visible light source module may also be fitted with a partially reflecting beamsplitter. The beamsplitter would cause a portion of the illumination energy from the LEDs to be incident on a source monitor photodiode


84


. The signal from the source monitor photodiode


84


is then used to correct the light intensity of each of the LED columns as necessary. For example, the signal from the source monitor photodiode


84


may be used to compensate for fluctuations in illumination output during LED warm-up at start time, via an illumination profile discussed below. This allows the instrument


20


to begin testing more quickly because the testing would not have to wait for the LEDs to warm-up (i.e., to reach a steady-state illumination output).




The visible light source modules are spaced vertically and positioned properly with respect to the ID/AST panels


30


mounted in each tier of the assembly


51


by the supporting tower. The supporting tower can also include mounts for the beamsplitters, the holographic diffuser plates


82


and the cylindrical lenses.




In another embodiment, shown in FIG.


9


. other arrangements are possible for the visible light source used in the present invention.

FIG. 9

shows an overhead view of a tri-spectrum arrangement (e.g., red, green and blue) using three LEDs (


215


,


216


,


217


). A bank of more or less than three LEDs can be used at any single Z-axis location. Groups of the LED banks can be stacked as deep as needed in the Z-axis direction so as to cover the entire length of the ID/AST panels


30


.




Light from the LED


216


is reflected 90° by a first surface mirror


218


along the illumination axis. Some of this light passes through the dichroic filters


220


and


219


, diverging to a holographic diffuser


221


in the X direction. Some of the light is rejected by each filter and continues through in the Y direction. The holographic diffuser


221


acts to homogenize the light in a defined manner. The filtered, homogenized light passes through a cylindrical lens


222


which concentrates it into a homogenous light stripe of a prescribed width at the ID/AST panel


30


.




A portion of the light focused at the ID/AST panel


30


is redirected 90° by a planar glass optical flat


223


into a light pipe


224


that concentrates it to a source monitor


225


. A signal generated by the source monitor


225


is used to correct the light intensity from each of the groups of the LED banks as necessary.




Similarly, some of the light from the LED


217


is reflected 90° by the dichroic filter


219


and this filtered energy is optically processed in the manner described above. Again, some light from the LED


215


is reflected 90° by dichroic filter


220


and this filtered energy is optically processed by the remaining components in the optical train as described above.




In another embodiment, a solid-state visible light source assembly is shown in

FIG. 10A. A

plurality of surface mount LEDs


300


(SMLEDs) are placed in an array which coincides with a column of wells


31


of the ID/AST panels


30


. The SMLEDs are arranged in a repeated pattern in the array. For example, the first SMLED can be red, the second a green SMLED and the third a blue SMLED. This pattern is then repeated the length of the array. As many banks of SMLEDs as needed can be arranged to properly illuminate the area desired.




In this embodiment, the illumination axis of the array of SMLEDs is arranged in the same line with the wells


31


. Consequently, the SMLEDs


300


are energized based on their respective spectral content (i.e., red, green or blue illumination). As before, this light is further conditioned to homogenize and concentrate it onto the target using a holographic diffuser


301


and a focusing lens


302


, as shown in FIG.


10


B. As described above, a beamsplitter and source monitor are also used in this embodiment.




Because the illumination intensity tends to fall off at the ends, each column of LEDs, the holographic diffuser plate


82


, and cylindrical lenses can be made physically longer than the active area of the ID/AST panels


30


. In order to compensate for the light fall-off at the ID/AST panel


30


extremes caused by the optical inefficiencies, the intensity of illumination near the ends of each LED column is boosted to improve uniformity. One way this may be accomplished is by driving the LEDs near the ends of each column with higher currents, which increases the intensity of the light at those ends.




The junction current used to drive the LED or SMLEDs, discussed above, can be controlled using a computer program stored in the control processor


70


, as shown in FIG.


13


. Illumination profiles can be used to dynamically drive the LEDs to compensate for optical inefficiency. As shown in

FIG. 12A

, when the LEDs of one column are all driven with the same drive current, the illumination output from the LEDs at the ends (i.e., top and bottom) of the columns, as measured by an optical detection system


100


, is less than the illumination output from the LEDs near the center of the column.

FIG. 12B

shows an illumination profile in which the LEDs at the ends of the column are driven with a higher current. This produces a greater illumination output from the LEDs at the ends of the column as compared to the LEDs near the center of the column.

FIG. 12C

shows the resulting illumination output, as measured by the optical detection system


100


, of the LED column when driven by the illumination profile of FIG.


12


B.




While the illumination profile of

FIG. 12B

shows a complementary profile used to produce a uniform illumination output, a variety of illumination profiles can be used. These profiles may be selected based different criteria, such as, the type of test panel used, the type of test to be performed, or feedback signals. For example, a proportional feedback control loop using signals from the source monitor photodiode


84


can correct for light intensity changes during testing, during LED warm-up, or for long term degradation of the LED junction current. Other types of feedback correction systems may be based on temperature changes within the instrument


20


or on signals from a normalizer panel, discussed below.




Another way of compensating for the intensity fall-off at the ends of the column is to geometrically compress the spacing of LEDs or SMLEDs at the ends of each column, i.e., a stacked LED configuration at the ends. As shown in

FIG. 15

, LEDs


90


at the ends of the linear array are geometrically compressed. This type of configuration compensates for degradation of optical efficiency at the ends of the columns. When the LEDs are placed closer together, the intensity of the illumination increases. Preferably, the LEDs should be compressed to produce an intensity inverse to the fall-off. For example, an optical coupling roll-off of 90% at the column ends (relative to the column center) may be compensated by decreasing the LED center-to-center distance at the column ends by a factor of ten.




Returning to

FIG. 11

, the UV Light Source assembly


81


includes two tubular UV cold-cathode lamps. Hot-cathode lamps may also be used. Suitable lamps may be obtained from Voltarc (VTI, Waterbury, CT 06705). The radiation passes through excitation filters


85


. The excitation filters


85


eliminate unwanted spectral components present in the output of the lamps.




As shown in

FIG. 11

, the lamps are disposed on either side of the primary illumination axis so that one column of vertically-aligned ID/AST panels


30


are illuminated simultaneously. There is no need to align the UV light sources along the primary illumination axis. Adjustment of the illumination intensity is performed by altering the high-frequency power applied to the lamp and its series inductance. This is controlled by the control processor


70


. only one lamp is illuminated at a time. The other lamp is held in reserve.




In this embodiment, the fluorescence reaction is stimulated via a direct transmission mode of the light through the wells


31


. However, a reflective mode may also be used which would require repositioning of the UV light sources.




A UV source monitor photodiode


86


for each lamp is positioned to intercept a small portion of the radiation leaving the lamp. The resulting signal is used to monitor the lamp's intensity. This signal also allows the control processor


70


to detect a decrease in the lamp's intensity so that the other reserve lamp can be activated if necessary.




The active lamp is operated at full power only when UV excitation measurements are being taken. Otherwise, the lamp is dimmed to low power to conserve lamp life, or turned off, to prevent optical interference with readings using the visible excitation light sources discussed above. In addition, an emission filter


83


(shown in

FIG. 11

) is used eliminate any unwanted spectral components that may be introduced by the lamps. For example, the emission filter


83


filters out the UV light wavelengths of the lamp. The lamp current is raised to operating level for test data acquisition by means of a signal line controlled by the control processor


70


(i.e., switching the lamp from low- to high-intensity operation).




A UV source power supply


92


powers the active lamp. As discussed above, adjustment of the lamp's intensity is accomplished by varying the frequency of high voltage excitation applied to the lamp and its series inductance. An increase in frequency causes a decrease in lamp current as the inductive reactance increases, which in turn causes a decrease in lamp intensity.




The UV source power supply


92


also includes high voltage reed relays (not shown) to transfer power from the active lamp to the reserve lamp as directed by the control processor


70


. As discussed above, lamp transfer occurs when the source monitor photodiode detects a significant decrease in the intensity of the active lamp.




In operation, the visible light source assembly


80


and the UV light source assembly


81


are sequentially energized. After one complete rotation of the carousel


50


(i.e., one data accumulation cycle), another type of wavelength illumination is energized. For example, in one arrangement, each column of LEDs (i.e., red, green and blue) contained in the visible light source modules are energized sequentially, then the UV light source module is switched to full power, each light source being active for one complete of carousel


50


rotation. This enables the instrument


20


to gather test data from each ID/AST panel


30


based on different types of wavelength light. In a preferred embodiment, the sequence is UV warm up, UV reading, followed by red, green and blue readings.




As shown in

FIGS. 4

, the optical measurement system


100


is disposed approximately within the center of the assembly


51


such that it is aligned to the visible light transmitted through each well


31


of the ID/AST panels


30


during excitation with red, green or blue illumination from the visible light source modules. Visible fluorescent radiation is similarly detected from the wells


31


excited by the UV light. As discussed above, the emission filter


83


eliminates unwanted spectral components that may be present in the output signal before detection by the optical measurement system


100


. In another embodiment, near-Infrared (IR) light can be used to perform the optical test scans.




As will be appreciated by one skilled in the art, a variety of means may be used to measure changes in optical characteristics. For example, photodiodes or an array of photosensors may be used.




In a preferred embodiment, a plurality of CCD detector modules


101


and lens assemblies


105


(shown in

FIGS. 7 and 8

) are provided, one for each assembly


51


tier. The CCD detector modules


101


and lens assemblies


105


are supported on a measurement system tower


103


. The measurement tower


103


supports the lens assemblies


105


and the CCD detector modules


101


so that they are oriented in alignment with the optical axis of one well column of the ID/AST panels


30


.




The lens assemblies


105


include objective lens


102


. The light from of each panel well column is focused onto the CCD arrays


104


by the objective lens


102


.




Each CCD detector module


101


includes a CCD array


104


. A 2048-pixel linear CCD array, for example, may be used. The CCD arrays


104


detect and measure the intensity of light transmitted through each well


31


when illuminated by the red, green and blue LEDs. Visible fluorescent light is similarly detected by the CCD array


104


under UV light excitation. Alternatively, the UV light excitation can be positioned such that the CCD arrays


104


detect the reflected, or absorbed, visible fluorescent light from the wells


31


.




The CCD arrays


104


are positioned relative to each tier to provide ample illumination over-scan of all the locations of the wells


31


in any column of the ID/AST panels


30


. The only light detectable by the CCD arrays


104


is the monochromatic light passing through, or the visible fluorescence emissions from the wells


31


. Thus, the CCD arrays


104


detect and measure the light intensity of the wells but not of any other object illuminated by the light source assemblies. Y-axis column information, which represents one vertical slice of information, is scanned electronically by the CCD arrays


104


. Multiple slices of information are required to detect and measure the light intensity from one column of wells. X-axis information is accumulated with the rotation of the assembly


51


(i.e., the ID/AST panels


30


are rotated so that the next vertical slice of information can be scanned).




Sensitivity of the CCD detection modules


101


is governed by the integration time selected for each CCD array


104


. As understood by one skilled in the art, light is composed of individual photons. Each photon has an extremely small amount of energy associated therewith. The amount of time necessary to charge the pixels is called the integration time. Varying amounts of photons emitted from, or absorbed by, the individual wells


31


are incident on individual pixels within each CCD array


104


and charge the pixels to different levels proportional to the incident light.




The integration time for the CCD arrays


104


in the present invention is variable. This gives the present invention the flexibility of having ID/AST panels


30


that contain substrates with a variety of optical properties (i.e., transparent or optically dense). From information gathered from the barcode label, the integration time is set to control the gain for each ID/AST panel


30


. The integration time for the next ID/AST panel


30


is set before it is illuminated by the light sources. In one embodiment, a default integration time is selected to be approximately 4.0 milliseconds. Other integration times may be selected by the control processor


70


as needed during testing of the ID/AST panels


30


.




Data processing of the accumulated pixel information is accomplished by four detector microcontrollers (and supporting circuitry)


106


, one for each CCD detector module


101


. Each detector microcontroller


106


receives and processes data from the associated CCD arrays


104


. This data is collected from each well


31


when illuminated by the red, green and blue LEDs and excited by the UV light during the rotation of the ID/AST panel


30


via the assembly


51


.




In operation, the detector microcontrollers


106


use the panel flag signal generated by the panel position sensors to initiate panel data acquisition via the CCD arrays


104


. As mentioned above, the panel flag signal is generated as the panel position flags pass the panel position sensors during rotation of the assembly


51


. This signal is used as a timing start point for test data gathering.




The carousel


50


rotates continuously while the detector microcontrollers


106


receive test data gathered by the CCD arrays


104


. In a this embodiment, the CCD arrays


104


measure more than one variable in parallel (absorption, turbidity and/or fluorescence) from essentially the same spatial location. The measurements are taken by the CCD linear arrays as the ID/AST panels


30


“fly by.” All the detector microcontrollers


106


simultaneously receive the test data from the CCD arrays


104


as a well column of the ID/AST panels


30


is illuminated by the light from the visible light source assembly


80


, or excited by the UV light source assembly


81


.




A registration mark (not shown) on each of the ID/AST panels


30


is located by performing an algorithmic search on the series of linear array data scans. Knowing how many steps the step motor of the drive system


56


have occurred between the timing start point and the registration mark, in addition to the first CCD array


104


pixel where the registration mark starts, gives the information needed to locate precisely any well


31


on the scanned ID/AST panel


30


.




There are two light source normalization processes that occur during the test data acquisition process. The first reduces the effects of spatial inhomogeneities from well to well. The second normalization process involves monitoring the instantaneous source intensity simultaneous with the CCD array


104


test data acquisition.




A normalizer panel serves as a reference panel for instrumental correction of the optical measurement system


100


. Each tier of the assembly


51


contains one normalizer panel which resides in position location zero on each tier. The normalizer panel contains a matrix of absorbers in ID/AST panel-well format. The normalizer panel is constructed such that it has a nominal geometry equivalent to the ID/AST panels


30


. The readings from the normalizer panel do not change overtime and transmits the same light intensity when illuminated uniformly. By measuring each normalizer panel well's output, a correction factor for each well is created to eliminate any nonuniformities in well to well source intensity, to correct individual well signals for losses occurring in the optical system, and to compensate for the reduction in LED output over time. Test data collected from each ID/AST panel


30


in a tier of the assembly


51


is corrected (normalized) for any changes in the optical system since the normalizer panel for that tier was last read.




In one embodiment, a selectably energized monochromatic light source provides linear illumination for a column of uniform wells of the normalizer panel. The profile of illumination intensity along the column is piecewise adjusted to provide uniform detector response for all the wells in the column of the normalizer panel. The columns of all the ID/AST panels


30


are then illuminated with this profile. The normalizer optical response of each well in the ID/AST panel


30


is thereby measured with uniform sensitivity for all the well locations within each column.




As mentioned above, the signal from the source monitor photodiode


84


is used to determine any changes in visible light source assembly's


81


light intensity as the carousel assembly


51


rotates. While the normalizer panel is used to monitor relative spatial variations of intensity, the source monitor photodiode


84


enables the present invention to monitor quasi-absolute intensity as it fluctuates throughout a single rotation of the carousel assembly


51


or varies over a long period of time. The source monitor photodiode


84


is monitored simultaneously with each CCD array acquisition. The detector microcontroller


106


has two correction factors to apply to each set of test data gathered so that any differences between test data scans are due only to the optical properties of the reagents in the wells


31


.




Each detector microcontroller


106


also receives data from a CCD dark current scan. Dark current correction is applied to the data on a per-pixel basis.




In an alternative embodiment, a fluorescent visible light source and a filter wheel (not shown) can be used instead of the visible light sources discussed above. The filter wheel contains a plurality of spectral filters. In this embodiment, for example, absorption and turbidity measurements are acquired in three consecutive rotations of the assembly


51


, while fluorescence measurements are acquired during a fourth rotation. Upon completing the first rotation for normalization and registration mark locations (this is done for each of the panels per tier), the filter wheel indexes to it's first spectral filter. Upon reaching the normalizer panel, the filter wheel indexes the second spectral filter. Test data acquisition, normalization and the computation process, as described above, are repeated for each spectral filter within the filter wheel. After colorimetric measurements are performed, the visible fluorescent source is turned off. The filter wheel indexes an emission filter and fluorescence measurements are taken in a similar manner.




In order to reduce the post-processing burden, all pixel information not associated with ID/AST panel wells are eliminated. For example, the analog signal from the CCD array


104


can be digitized and the detector microcontroller


106


can then process the digitized signal accordingly. The test data for each well


31


(i.e., the light intensity information) is then averaged. The averaging is performed based on a per-pixel value received from the CCD array


104


for each well


31


. The averaging produces a single integer numerical value for each well


31


. One numerical value is produced for each data accumulation cycle (i.e., red, green and blue illumination and UV light excitation). This information is then sent via a multi-drop serial data transmission protocol to the control processor


70


.




In one embodiment, spatially averaging of an analog signal from the CCD arrays


104


is performed by the detection microcontroller


106


so as to eliminate unwanted optical and electrical artifacts from sample column data. The spatial averaging is performed using partial analog decommutation of the pixel intensity of the analog signal.




As shown in

FIG. 4

, the control processor


70


is mounted in the electronic compartment


62


of the instrument enclosure


60


. The control processor


70


includes the instrument front panel


71


, a keyboard


72


, a computer readable medium drive


73


(e.g., floppy disk or CD-ROM drive), and a loudspeaker/audible alarm. The control processor


70


also includes an I/O interface board, a CPU, memory, an Ethernet interface circuitry, display driver circuitry (none of which are shown). The control processor


70


can also be provided with a mouse.




In operation, the control processor


70


performs the following functions by executing instructions stored in a computer readable medium. The control processor


70


senses the home flag magnet on the drive ring


52


via the hall-effect sensor


55


. This is done in order to properly index the ID/AST panels


30


which are mounted on the assembly


51


while being rotated. High-level commands are sent to the detector microcontrollers


106


to initiate or stop testing of the ID/AST panels


30


. The intensity of the UV light source assembly


81


is controlled based on the signal from the UV source monitor photodiode


86


. The control processor


70


illuminates the status indicator LEDs


54


on the panel carriers


53


. The indicator LEDs


54


, as discussed above, identify which ID/AST panels


30


have been tested and can be removed from the assembly


51


. The incubation temperature is also controlled by the control processor


70


via signal/control lines operatively connected to the incubation heater.




The control processor


70


also receives the data generated from the barcode scanners, the barcode reader and the barcode wand


72


. As discussed above, the data from the barcode scanners is used to correlate the test data gathered to a particular ID/AST panel


30


. Each data accumulation cycle (i.e., one rotation of the assembly


51


), the control processor


70


expects to receive data related to the barcode labels of each ID/AST panels


30


in assembly


51


and test data for each ID/AST panel


30


. If either is received, the control processor


70


determines that an ID/AST panel


30


is logically present in that panel location. However, if both types of data are not received, the control processor


70


discards the data for that accumulation cycle.




Upon the completion of one data accumulation cycle, the control processor


70


receives serially the data from the detector microcontrollers


106


. This data is stored in the memory. The control processor


70


then interprets the data from the ID wells


31


(i.e., from the wells associated with the ID portion of the ID/AST panels


30


as discussed below) to produce an organism identification. The control processor


70


also interprets the data from AST wells


31


to produce either MIC results or, via National Committee for Laboratory Standard (NCCLS) guidelines, produces an Susceptible, Intermediate, or Resistant (SIR) result which refers to breakpoint for AST categories. The final results for the ID/AST panels


30


are stored memory and may be downloaded to a floppy disk, for example, to conserve storage space within the memory.




Other functions performed by the control processor


70


include communicating with externally connected network devices (e.g., a local area network (LAN) and the like), providing a printer port, performing start-up and diagnostic-self tests to ensure that the instrument


20


is operating properly, and generating appropriate alarm signals. The control processor


70


also provides the operator with a graphical-user interface (not shown) via the instrument front panel


71


, and accepts user commands and input via the keyboard


72


.




Returning to

FIGS. 3A-3C

, the ID/AST panels


30


are supplied in a combination format. Each ID/AST panel


30


has reagent well positions capable of performing ID and AST testing on the same panel. As discussed above, the ID/AST panels


30


include the wells


31


and the barcode labels. The wells


31


are segregated into an ID section


33


and an AST section


34


. The ID section


33


of the ID/AST panel


30


consists of fifty-one wells


31


. The AST section


34


of the ID/AST panel


30


consists of eight-five wells


31


. For example, the wells


31


of the AST section


34


may contain dried antibiotics therein.




The ID/AST panels


30


also includes a base


35


, a chassis


36


, a lid


37


, and a cellulose acetate pad


38


. Each ID/AST panel


30


also includes a panel label (not shown) which includes information to identify the complete manufacturing history of the particular ID/AST panel


30


.




The barcode label provides information related to the ID/AST panel type and also has a unique sequence number for identification purposes. The barcode label can be provided in Code 128, numeric format or any other suitable barcode format.




Each ID/AST panel


30


is inoculated with an broth-suspended organism before being placed into the instrument


20


. In practice, the microorganism is a processed and resuspended dilution of microbiological growth from primary culture in either an ID inoculum fluid or an AST inoculum fluid which is then poured into the test panel. The ID/AST panels


30


are inclined with the inoculation ports


39


at the top for filling. Separate inocula are added manually to the ID and AST ports


39


. Each well


31


in the ID section


33


is inoculated with the ID inoculum fluid as the inoculum flows down the panel toward the pad


38


. Each well


31


in the AST section


34


is inoculated with the AST inoculum fluid. The inocula flow down the ID/AST panel


30


in a serpentine fashion, filling the wells


31


as the liquid front progresses toward the pad


38


. Each well


31


is vented, permitting liquid to fill the well


31


. Each well


31


has a sharp, circular rim to separate a consistent quantity of liquid from the excess and to isolate each well


31


from liquid in adjacent wells


31


. The pad


38


absorbs excess liquid.




The ID/AST panels


30


are inoculated with the inoculum fluids at a panel inoculation station (not shown). Each station holds two tubes of inoculum fluid (i.e., the ID inoculum fluid and the AST inoculum fluid) and supports one ID/AST panel


30


. Gravity drives the inoculum fluids through the ID/AST panels


30


.




The ID inoculum fluid and AST inoculum fluid comprise the reagent subsystem which includes all reagents required to process isolated bacterial colonies into prepared inocula for addition to the ID section


33


and the AST section


34


of the ID/AST panels


30


.




The ID inoculum fluid is used for organism identification. A variety of ID inoculum fluids can be used, although a saline solution is preferred. A detergent may be added to enhance ID/AST panel


30


filling in the panel inoculation station. Preferably, the inoculum density for ID panel inoculation is at least 1×10


5


cfu/ml. A variety of identification reagents may be used which include Phenol Red and Iodo-Nitro-Tetrazolium (INT). A variety of substrates may also be used which include 4-Methyl Umbelliferrone (4-MU) derivatives, Methyl-Amino-Coumarin (4-AMC) derivatives, para-Nitrophenol derivatives, and Esculin.




The AST inoculum fluid used for AST determination is a modified formulation of Mueller-Hinton broth. Preferably, the inoculum density for AST panel inoculation is at least 1×10


5


cfu/ml. Different inoculum densities may be used for other embodiments of the present invention such as “rapid” AST test results.




These are AST test results obtained within sixteen hours of ID/AST panel


30


inoculation.




A variety of AST indicators may be used. The preferred indicator for AST determinations in the present invention is alamarBlue™, a redox-buffered oxidation-reduction indicator. The indicator is added to the AST inoculum fluid and mixed just prior to addition of the microorganism sample to be tested by the instrument


20


.




As mentioned above, the control processor


70


interprets the data from the wells


31


for the purpose of detection, identification and susceptibility testing. The control processor uses three variable threshold levels to interpret this data: an absolute, a dynamic and relative threshold. When using the absolute threshold, a positivity assessment made by determining if the normalized well


31


reading is above (positive) or below (negative) a given predetermined value. When using the dynamic threshold, a reagent reaction determination is calculated using first- and second-differences or other mathematical manipulations of detection data related to the rate-of-change of signal increase as a function of time by determining when certain parameters of the calculated first- and/or second-differences have been exceeded. When using the relative threshold, a reagent reaction determination is made by setting a threshold a predetermined percentage above the starting signal level of the well


31


in question.




In operation, the ID/AST panels


30


are mounted and incubated in the carousel


50


of the instrument


20


. As the visible light source assembly


80


and the UV light source assembly


81


are energized sequentially, one reading is taken corresponding to the red, green, blue and fluorescent wavelengths of light. Based on the rotation speed of the carousel


50


, light intensity readings are taken at predetermined intervals by the optical measurement system


100


.




For example, when the carousel


50


is driven by the drive system


56


at an angular velocity of 2.0 revolutions per minute (RPM), one rotation of the carousel


50


requires 30 seconds. Thus, to accumulate data for red, green, blue and UV wavelengths, two minutes are required. Accordingly, in this example, a complete set of data can be taken by the present invention every two minutes, Since it is possible to vary the angular velocity, different angular velocity may be used for different tests. For example, it may be desirable to accumulate UV data at 1.0 RPM (while other test data is accumulated at 2.0 RPM). In this case, a complete data set would require two and a half minutes to complete.




In the present invention, AST end-point results based on the well


31


readings can be obtained after 18-24 hours of incubation. In an alterative embodiment, AST results can be obtained within 16 hours of panel inoculation.




With regard to identification accuracy, the control processor


70


includes an ID taxa database that includes greater than


126


species for gram-negative organisms, and


103


species for gram-positive organisms. The control processor


70


also includes an AST taxa database equivalent to the ID taxa database for both gram-positive and -negatives. For the purposes of AST testing, the present invention also includes a database with all human and veterinary antimicrobics currently known.




While the present invention has been described above in terms of specific embodiments, it is to be understood that the invention is not intended to be confined or limited to the embodiments disclosed herein. On the contrary, the present invention is intended to cover various methods, structures and modifications thereof included within the spirit and scope of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A microbiological testing apparatus comprising:a light source capable of producing a composite light signal having light elements of variable intensity; and a controller adapted to control said light source using an illumination profile.
  • 2. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 1, further comprising:a light detection unit; and an optics system capable of directing the composite light signal toward said light detection unit.
  • 3. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the illumination profile corrects optical inefficiency in said optics system.
  • 4. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 1, wherein said light source comprises a plurality of LEDs being arranged as a linear array.
  • 5. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 1, further comprising a sensor electrically connected to said controller, wherein said sensor monitors the composite light signal, and said controller controls said light source in response to a signal from said sensor.
  • 6. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 1, further comprising feedback means for providing feedback to said controller, wherein said controller compensates for undesired changes in the composite light signal by selecting one of a plurality of illumination profiles.
  • 7. A microbiological testing apparatus, comprising:a light source having a plurality of LEDs being arranged in a linear array, wherein a junction current of each LED is capable of producing a predetermined illumination profile.
  • 8. A microbiological testing apparatus, comprising:a light source having a plurality of LEDs, the LEDs being arranged in a linear array having two ends, each end having a group of LEDs of said plurality of LEDs, each said group of LEDs being geometrically compressed.
  • 9. A microbiological testing apparatus according to claim 8, wherein the LEDs comprise red, green and blue LEDs arranged in a predetermined order in the linear array.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a division of Application No. 09/083,130, filed on May 22, 1998, which issued as U.S. Pat. No. 6,096,272 on Aug. 1, 2000, and which claims the benefit of, and incorporates by reference the entirety of, U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/047,481, filed May 23, 1997.

US Referenced Citations (27)
Number Name Date Kind
3932131 Rolfe-Fontana Jan 1976 A
4116775 Charles et al. Sep 1978 A
4118280 Charles et al. Oct 1978 A
RE31150 Ginsberg et al. Feb 1983 E
4406547 Aihara Sep 1983 A
4427294 Nardo Jan 1984 A
4456380 Kondo et al. Jun 1984 A
4536369 Sakurada et al. Aug 1985 A
4687638 Benajam Aug 1987 A
4724215 Farber et al. Feb 1988 A
4814667 Tanaka Mar 1989 A
4856073 Farber et al. Aug 1989 A
4896963 Kato Jan 1990 A
5003611 Miyake et al. Mar 1991 A
5079144 Carr et al. Jan 1992 A
5089395 Snyder et al. Feb 1992 A
5164796 Di Guiseppi et al. Nov 1992 A
5206151 Robertson Apr 1993 A
5290701 Wilkins Mar 1994 A
5320808 Holen et al. Jun 1994 A
5340747 Eden Aug 1994 A
5366873 Eden et al. Nov 1994 A
5501959 Lancaster et al. Mar 1996 A
5686300 Berndt Nov 1997 A
5817475 Gibbs et al. Oct 1998 A
5853666 Seaton et al. Dec 1998 A
5858769 DiGuiseppi et al. Jan 1999 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (14)
Number Date Country
0181228 May 1986 EP
0258565 Mar 1988 EP
0319309 Jun 1989 EP
0353592 Feb 1990 EP
0353592 Feb 1990 EP
0516274 Dec 1992 EP
0576291 Dec 1993 EP
0711995 May 1996 EP
0301699 Feb 1998 EP
0841557 May 1998 EP
WO 8806062 Aug 1988 WO
WO 931818 Sep 1993 WO
WO 9504263 Feb 1995 WO
WO 9605488 Feb 1996 WO
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/047481 May 1997 US