The present invention relates to door locks, and more particularly to an assembly and method for preventing a battery fire originating in an electronic door lock.
Electronic door locks, as opposed to pure mechanical locks, need a power source to operate the locking and control mechanism. In battery operated electronic door locks, power is obtained from a set of batteries installed in the lock. The most commonly used batteries in electronic door locks are alkaline batteries. The service life (the time after which the batteries need to be replaced) depends on the usage of the lock, but is typically two to three years for normal usage doors. More recently, attempts have been made to increase battery life by incorporating other types of battery technology including lithium battery technology. However, practical application of lithium battery technology in electronic door locks has failed due in part to the technology's adverse affect on the integrity and specifications of fire rated doors. Lithium batteries adversely affect the integrity and specifications of fire rated doors because the batteries can experience severe outgassing of flammable gases and violently deflagrate when exposed to elevated temperatures achievable during a building fire. The violent deflagration of lithium batteries has the undesirable effect that it can cause the fire on one side of the fire rated door to propagate to the other side and hence compromise the intended function of a fire door. A circuit board commonly utilized in electronic door locks is commonly one of the first components to catch fire and act as a potential ignition source for constituents outgassed from the venting of lithium batteries.
An assembly for preventing a fire resulting from the outgassing of a lithium battery in an electronic door lock includes a lithium battery, a circuit board, and a thermal insulation. The lithium battery and circuit board are housed within the electronic door lock. The thermal insulation is arranged between a door interfacing side of the electronic door lock and either or both of the circuit board and lithium battery.
Another thermal management technique for preventing fire resulting from the outgassing of a lithium battery in an electronic door lock is achieved by using a battery cover that is selectively movable away from the circuit board or ignition source in response to temperature rise to ensure the lithium battery does not reach a critical temperature that may cause outgassing in close proximity to the ignition source.
The shaft block 21 movably extends from the mortise 16 into and through the inner lock cover 20. The outer handle 22 connects to the shaft 23 which rotatably extends through the door to connect to the inner handle 25. The reader 24 projects from the outer side of the door 14 and is adapted to receive a coded medium such as a magnetic card, proximity card, or memory key. The inner lock cover 20 houses portions of the inner handle or knob 25, the plate 26, and the printed circuit board 12.
The plate 26 and printed circuit board 12 extend along the exterior of the door 14 beneath the inner lock cover 20. Side surfaces (not shown) of the inner lock cover 20 abut the interior interfacing surface of the door 14 to form an enclosed unit.
The inner lock cover 20 interconnects with the printed circuit board cover 28 adjacent the printed circuit board 12. In one embodiment, the printed circuit board cover 28 is removable or movable to expose the printed circuit board 12 to ambient air external to the door lock 10. The thermal insulation 32 is disposed adjacent the shaft block 21 and abuts both the plate 26 and the printed circuit board 12. The battery 30 is disposed adjacent printed circuit board 12 within the enclosed unit formed by the inner lock cover 20 or the printed circuit board cover 28, and is electrically connected to the reader 24 and printed circuit board 12.
Lithium battery 30 is a primary (non-rechargeable) battery and can be one or more of cylindrical or coin type batteries. The cylindrical batteries can be of the AA or AAA type or any other suitable format. Lithium battery 30 is preferably chosen to have a very long shelf life and very low self discharge so that lifetimes in excess of 10 years can be achieved with the electronic lock of the present invention. Examples of suitable long-life lithium primary batteries are based on the lithium iron disulfide battery chemistry with commercially available batteries being Energizer EA91 or L91 and EA92 or L92. The capacity of L91 under constant power of 50 milliwatts (mW) at 21 degrees Celsius is 4500 mAh (milliAmperehours) and 3000 mAh under a constant current of 25 mA (milliAmpere). Other lithium primary batteries and brands that offer similar performance characteristics as those of the aforementioned lithium iron disulfide battery would be suitable alternative options. Examples of other lithium primary batteries are lithium manganese dioxide, lithium thionyl chloride, lithium sulfur dioxide, lithium carbon monofluoride, lithium copper oxide, lithium oxyphosphate, and lithium/silver vanadium oxide.
In the instance of an external fire 34, (a fire in a fire zone exterior to the door 14—for example, the hallway in most hospitality situations) heat from the fire will most effectively pass through the door 14 via heat transfer process 36, wherein heat transfer process 36 is comprised of conduction, convection and/or radiation processes. For example, a fire zone temperature of about 650° C. on the exterior side of the door 14 in some cases can result in temperatures on the interior side of the door 14 exceeding about 370° C. due to transfer of heat through the door 14. A temperature of about 370° C. can be high enough to ignite components of the electronic door lock 10. More specifically, at temperatures of about 370° C. certain electrical components of the printed circuit board 12 or other components of the electronic door lock 10 can ignite. As will be discussed subsequently, “hot surfaces” (i.e., components that can ignite flammable battery constituents at lower temperatures) such as parts of the electronic door lock 10 or door 14 can act as ignition sources for flammable battery constituents outgassed from the lithium battery 30. The printed circuit board 12 is one such problematic potential ignition source. In the presence of an ignition source such as the printed circuit board 12, the outgassed battery constituents (especially flammable gases and fumes) can violently ignite thereby propagating a flame into the door 14 and into the space exterior to the door 14 (a guest room in the example of the hospitality situation given above) from the external fire 34.
With regard to the lithium battery 30 at elevated temperatures, when the temperature experienced by the battery 30 is in the range of about 110° C. to 200° C., the battery 30 experiences an initial outgassing and some constituents of the lithium battery 30 are outgassed away from the battery 30. These constituents include a mixture of flammable gases and less flammable gasses and fumes. When the lithium battery 30 experiences temperatures of about 400° C. the lithium battery 30 experiences a second large outgassing of battery constituents including flammable gases and less flammable gases and fumes and this outgassing is accompanied by fire or deflagration. Semi-quantitatively, this second outgassing is generally of a much larger magnitude than the first, and thus, has a greater chance of violently igniting in the presence of an ignition source to propagate a flame into the door 14, electronic door lock 10, and space interior to the door 14 from the external fire 34 in the original fire zone.
To reduce the likelihood of the initiation and propagation of a flame and prevent a fire resulting from the outgassing of the lithium battery 30, the door lock 10 can be configured with thermal insulation 32 between both the printed circuit board 12 and lithium battery 30 and the door 14 interfacing portion of the electronic door lock 10. The thermal insulation 32 decreases the rate of heat transfer process 36 through the door interfacing portion of the electronic door lock 10 to the lithium battery 30 and the printed circuit board 12 during the external fire 34. The thermal insulation 32 reduces the rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 within the electronic door lock 10 relative to the rate of temperature rise of a portion of the electronic door lock 10 that interfaces with the door 14 during the fire 34. The reduced rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 reduces the risk of initiation and propagation of a flame and allows the door 14 to meet fire ratings such as UL10C. The reduced rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 also provides more time prior to the first outgassing of the lithium battery 30 (and more time prior to when the printed circuit board 12 reaches a temperature sufficient for the printed circuit board materials to ignite) in which the fire 34 can be fought and contained without a flame occurring from ignition of the outgassed lithium battery 30 constituents. By utilizing the thermal insulation 32, the maximum temperature experienced by both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 during a fire 34 is substantially reduced. The temperature reduction with thermal insulation 32 relative to the door lock without the thermal insulation is of the order of 200° C. With proper selection and design of the key characteristics of thermal insulation 32, the key characteristics being its thermal conductivity (in units of W/m·K or Btu·in/h·ft2·° F.) and its thickness, the reduction in the maximum temperature of the lithium battery 30 remains below the temperature threshold that causes the second large outgassing of battery constituents including flammable decomposition gas products arising from the charring or pyrolysis of the organic-based separator sheet. Thus, the potential for a flame occurring as a result of the second outgassing of the lithium battery 30 is reduced. Furthermore, the potential for deflagration of the other lithium battery 30 flammable materials, e.g., separator sheet in its initial state or charred/pyrolyzed state, the lithium metal foil, the electrode substrate metal foils, and the battery can metal foil, is substantially reduced or eliminated altogether.
More particularly, the thermal insulation 32 can be a high temperature ceramic sheet with a thickness of less than about 10 mm, preferably less than 7 mm, and most preferably less than 5 mm. In one embodiment, the sheet is comprised of alumina-silica fibrous material, which can withstand temperatures that exceed 1100° C., and has a thermal conductivity of <1 W/m·K (or 7 Btu·in/h·ft2·° F.) or most preferably <0.5 W/m·K (or 3.5 Btu·in/h·ft2·° F.). The heat flow rate is the amount of heat that flows per unit of time per unit area across the (ceramic) sheet of unit thickness if the difference in temperature between opposite faces of the sheet is 1 degree of temperature. An example of one such ceramic sheet is model number APA-3 manufactured by ZIRCAR Ceramics, Inc. of Florida, N.Y. Specifically, the APA-3 ceramic sheet is composed of 96 Al2O3, 4 SiO2, by weight percent with a binder composed of alumina. Other examples of materials that are suitable for the thermal insulation 12 sheet are: alumina-silica continuous or discontinuous fibers, alumina continuous or discontinuous fibers, zirconia fibers continuous or discontinuous fibers, silica continuous or discontinuous fibers, zirconia reticulated ceramics, alumina reticulated ceramics, particulate silica aerogels, particulate alumina aerogels, particulate zirconia aerogels, or high-porosity silica aerogel sheet. Other materials that could function as thermal insulation are evacuated metal foil structures of suitable design that ensure substantially reduced heat transfer rates by conduction, convection and/or radiation. These alternative materials options for the thermal insulation 12 should have a value of effective thermal conductivity, i.e., thermal conductivity that accounts for the transfer of heat by any combination of conduction, convection and radiation and is expressed as conductivity, less than 1 W/m·K, and most preferably less than 0.5 W/m·K.
While the incorporation of thermal insulation 12 is one electronic lock feature for mitigating or containing fire from lithium batteries, the electronic lock can be configured with additional features that enhance the likelihood of fire mitigation or containment. One such additional fire mitigation or containment feature is to configure the electronic door lock 10 with a movable printed circuit board cover 28 which allows the printed circuit board 12 to be exposed to convection cooling from ambient air on the opposite side of the door 14 from the external fire 34. The printed circuit board cover 28 can be hingedly or otherwise attached to the remainder of the electronic door lock 10 such that at a predetermined temperature the printed circuit board cover 28 can fall open to expose the printed circuit board 12 to convection cooling. In alternative embodiments, the printed circuit board cover 28 can house the lithium battery 30 or printed circuit board 12 and can be configured to totally separate from and fall away from the remainder of the electronic door lock 10 once the predetermined temperature is reached or sensed. Thus, either the thermal insulation 32 or the movable printed circuit board cover 28 (or the combination of both in the electronic door lock 10) reduces the rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 within the electronic door lock 10 relative to the rate of temperature rise of a portion of the electronic door lock 10 that interfaces with the door 14 during the fire 34. The reduced rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 reduces the risk of propagation of a flame and allows the door 14 to meet fire ratings such as UL10C. The reduced rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 also provides more time prior to the first outgassing of the lithium battery 30 (and when the printed circuit board 12 reaches a temperature sufficient to become a potential ignition source) in which the fire 34 can be fought and contained without a flame occurring from ignition of the outgassed lithium battery 30 constituents. By utilizing the thermal insulation 32 and/or the movable printed circuit board cover 28, the maximum temperature experienced by both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 during a fire 34 can be reduced. With this reduction in the maximum temperature, the lithium battery 30 may not achieve a temperature sufficient to cause the second large outgassing of battery constituents including flammable gases from the lithium battery 30. Thus, the potential for a flame occurring as a result of the second outgassing of the lithium battery 30 is reduced.
To reduce the likelihood of the propagation of a flame and prevent a fire resulting from the outgassing of the lithium battery 30, the door lock 10 can also be configured with components (discussed subsequently) that short circuit or nearly short circuit the lithium battery 30 during a fire 34. Lithium batteries are generally equipped with built-in safety features such as 1) a thermal switch, this being a Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) Thermal Switch, and 2) a Pressure Relief Vent. The PTC thermal switch is in series with the battery's internal current path. On short circuiting or near-short circuiting, the battery temperature rises by means of the combination of I2R heating and the resistance of the PTC thermal switch. Resistance of PTC thermal switch increases very quickly, limiting the current that can flow through the lithium battery 30 and preventing the battery temperature from increasing beyond a safe limit. However, the combination of this internal I2R heat generation and the reduced rates of heat loss from the lithium battery 30 as a result of the higher temperature of the ambient battery environment due to the heat transfer process 36 driven by the external fire 34 leads to a faster internal pressure rise in the lithium battery 30, thus increasing electrolyte solvent vapor pressures and causing the relief vent to open and release solvent vapors. Venting occurs at substantially earlier times (this will be referred to as event time displacement or advanced timing of events) than the time when burning (ignition) of printed circuit board 12 components begins. By time displacing or staggering the outgassing of the lithium battery 30 from the burning of a printed circuit board 12, interaction between the outgassed battery solvent and electrolyte constituents and one potential ignition source for those constituents can be reduced, thus reducing the likelihood for generation of a flame, and thereby, increasing the capability of the electronic lock's inherent or built-in features and measures to prevent fire development.
By utilizing the components and fire prevention techniques disclosed herein, lithium technology can be successfully incorporated into electronic door locks while maintaining the integrity and specifications of the fire rated doors into which the electronic door locks are installed. With the incorporation of lithium technology in electronic door locks, the service life of the battery can be extended to over ten years, rather than the two to three year battery service life achieved with alkaline batteries. This increase in battery service life allows for a reduction in operational costs associated with replacement of door lock batteries.
The configuration of the electronic lock shown in
In the embodiment of the electronic door lock 10 illustrated in
The fastener 38 can include a screw, pin, or equivalent and can be comprised of a material that degrades/melts at elevated temperatures. For example, the fastener 38 can be comprised of a thermoplastic or wax material or a low-melting-point metallic alloy, which melts or slumps or plastically deforms or loses a solid structure at a predetermined temperature above about 200° C. The degradation of the fastener 38 within the receiving member 41 thereby allows the upper portion of the printed circuit board cover 28 to swing open away from the plate 26 and door 14 and expose the battery 30 and printed circuit board 12 to natural convection cooling by the cooler ambient air. Additional amounts of convection cooling can reach the printed circuit board 12 by disposing the lithium battery 30 inside the movable printed circuit board cover 28. As the printed circuit board cover 28 opens to the ambient air, the lithium battery 30 is removed from immediately adjacent the printed circuit board 12 thereby allowing more ambient air to reach and cool the printed circuit board 12. The swing motion of the upper portion of the printed circuit board cover 28 may be driven by gravity forces or spring force (discussed in reference to
As discussed previously, the utilization of either the thermal insulation 32 or the movable printed circuit board cover 28 (or the combination of both components in the electronic door lock 10) reduces the rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 within the electronic door lock 10 relative to the rate of temperature rise of the portion of the electronic door lock 10 that interfaces with the door 14 during the external fire 34. The reduced rate of temperature rise of both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 allows the door 14 to meet fire ratings such as UL10C. By utilizing the thermal insulation 32 and/or the movable printed circuit board cover 28, the maximum temperature experienced by both the printed circuit board 12 and the lithium battery 30 during the external fire 34 can be reduced. With this reduction in the maximum temperature the lithium battery 30 may not achieve a temperature sufficient to cause the second large outgassing of battery constituents including flammable gases from the lithium battery 30. Thus, the potential for a flame occurring as a result of the second outgassing of the lithium battery 30 is reduced.
In the embodiment of the electronic door lock 10 illustrated in
More particularly, the controller 46 receives and processes signals from the temperature sensor 44 and in response to a predetermined sensed temperature selectively actuates the motor 56 housed in the inner lock cover 20. The motor 56 turns the worm gear 58 which intermeshes with the top portion of the cam 60. The intermeshing of the worm gear 58 and cam 60 rotates the cam 60 into depressing engagement with a top portion of the lever arm 62. The engagement of the cam 60 with the top portion of the lever arm 62 overcomes the bias of the second spring 63 on a bottom portion of the lever arm 62 to rotate the lever arm 62 about a pivot point 65 of the lever arm 62. The rotation of the lever arm 62 raises the portion of the lever arm 62 disposed to the other side of the pivot point 65 from the cam 60 upward away from the inner lock cover 20. This in turn raises the notched fastener 50 (which is engaged by the lever arm 62) upward out of the spring housing 54 and out of engagement with the spring block 64.
The fastener 50 movably extends through the inner lock cover 20 and is received in the aperture 68 in the spring block 64. Thus, the fastener 50 can be selectively moved by the lever arm 62 to withdraw the fastener 50 from the aperture 68 thereby allowing the first spring 52 to move the printed circuit board cover 28 relative to the base 66. The printed circuit board cover 28, biased by the first spring 52, swings open on the pivot pin or hinge 70 to expose the printed circuit board 12 to natural convection cooling by the ambient air.
Prior to engagement of the lever arm 62 by the cam 60, the portion of the lever arm 62 disposed to the opposite side of the pivot point 65 from the cam 60 is biased downward toward the inner lock cover 20 by the second spring 63. This downward bias extends the fastener 50 through the inner lock cover 20 and into the aperture 68 of the spring block 64. When received in the aperture 68, the fastener 50 retains the spring block 64 at least partially within a cavity in the spring housing 54 against the bias of the compressed first spring 52. Thus, when received in the aperture 68 the fastener 50 secures the printed circuit board cover 28 in a generally upright position between the upper and lower portions of the inner lock cover 20.
The embodiments shown in
The temperature sensor 71 can be housed within or adjacent the inner lock cover 20 (
In regard to the electronic circuit 72 with the components shown in
The near short circuiting of the lithium battery 30 increases the temperature of the lithium battery 30 at a faster rate than would otherwise occur without the creation of the short circuit. This quicker rate of temperature rise of the lithium battery 30 allows the time period when the first outgassing of the lithium battery 30 occurs to be staggered relative to the time period when burning (ignition) of a printed circuit board 12 begins in the electronic door lock 10 during an external fire 34 (
The temperature sensor 80 can be housed within or adjacent the inner lock cover 20 (
Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US09/46621 | 6/8/2009 | WO | 00 | 11/28/2011 |