Bi-directional low maintenance vane pump

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6503064
  • Patent Number
    6,503,064
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, July 15, 1999
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 7, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
A long-life, low maintenance, bi-directional vane-type water pump has a high degree of symmetry and operates with equal efficiency in either direction. The axial position of the drive shaft is controlled to permit improved lubrication by the pumping fluid of component parts on which the drive shaft is journaled.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates generally to a fluid pressure energy translating device of the vane type that is suitable for applications such as pumping water in space applications and employs water as the lubricating fluid.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The design of a vane pump for pumping fresh water in space applications presents a serious challenge to the designer because of requirements of light weight and infrequent maintenance. Also, when pumping water it is desirable for the pump to be self-lubricating, i.e., to use the pumped fluid itself as a lubricant. The poor lubricity and low viscosity of water compared with lubricating oils contributes to the challenge. The low viscosity dictates that all design clearances must be an order of magnitude less than for oil lubricated devices. In addition, the potential contamination of scarce water in a space vehicle requires that no oils or greases be used. A high pumping efficiency is clearly advantageous, since a given pumping rate is achievable with the minimum expenditure of power.




Generally, vane devices comprise a circular rotor disposed within a non circular cam ring, so that the gap between the rotor and the cam ring varies according to the angular position within the ring. Vanes are disposed in openings around the periphery of the rotor, and when in motion, make sliding contact with the inside of the cam ring. The vanes are free to move back and forth in the openings, being urged into continuous contact with the cam ring by centrifugal force, springs or hydraulic pressure. As the vanes move around the cam ring, they displace fluid into zones of increasing volume, causing more fluid to enter from an inlet port, or into zones of decreasing volume, from which fluid is discharged through an outlet port.




Various examples of vane pumps have been disclosed previously. While various examples of pumps perform satisfactorily for their intended purposes, certain limitations prevent them from performing satisfactorily as water pumps in space environments. In particular, space applications demand that pump weight be minimized and that the pump provide efficient trouble-free operation for extremely long periods with minimal maintenance.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The invention disclosed herein describes a bi-directional, self-lubricating vane-type water pump. The pump comprises a rotor with a plurality of radial slots, each of which accommodates a vane. The rotor and vanes are driven by a drive shaft to revolve within a non-circular cam ring, displacing fluid and causing it to enter through an inlet port, or to be discharged through an outlet port, the ports being present in port plates. In this invention, the port plates and the cam ring are disposed in a highly symmetrical fashion, which promotes efficiency and furthermore provides equally efficient operation of the pump in either direction. Within narrow prescribed limits, the drive shaft of the pump is free to float back and forth along its axis. This axial movement may be controlled through a shim washer placed at the end the drive shaft. This provides optimum efficiency, permitting sufficient clearance between components to avoid binding and allow the pumping fluid, for example water, to lubricate where required, but nevertheless preventing excessive play. The fluid flows in the pump are subject to minimal constriction, which also contributes to efficient operation. Additionally, wear resistant and friction resistant materials may be employed for specific component parts, so as to obviate the need for conventional bearings. The pump requires very little maintenance, and is suitable for installation in remote locations such as space.




Accordingly, it is an object of this invention to provide an improved pump for fluids of low viscosity which has an extremely long operating lifetime with minimal maintenance and is suitable for space applications.




It is further an object of this invention to provide an improved pump for fluids of low viscosity which has a simple design, such that fluid flows are minimally constricted, providing optimal efficiency.




It is further an object of this invention to provide an improved bi-directional pump for fluids of low viscosity which has a high internal symmetry, allowing effectively equal efficiency in either direction.




It is further an object of this invention to provide a pump requiring minimal maintenance via the elimination of dynamic seals.




Finally, it is an object of this invention to provide an improved pump for fluids of low viscosity which is self lubricating.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an exploded, perspective view of a pump according to various preferred embodiments of this invention.





FIG. 2

is a partial cross-sectional view of the pump of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a cross-section of a coupling between the pump and a motor.





FIG. 4

is a partial perspective, exploded view of an impeller assembly comprising a cam ring, a rotor and vanes.





FIG. 5

is a schematic view of an impeller assembly of the pump.





FIG. 6

is an end view of the impeller assembly of FIGS.


1


and


2


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




Referring to

FIGS. 1 and 2

, pump


10


comprises a generally cylindrical housing


12


and an electric motor


40


. A drive shaft


14


includes a first thrust plate


16


integral to its structure, and has a first end


42


and a second end


44


. The first end


42


is in connection with the electric motor


40


. The assembly also includes a spacer


36


and a wave spring


38


, a first port plate


18


, a rotor


20


, a cam ring


22


, vanes


24


including drive pins


26


, a second port plate


28


, a second thrust plate


30


, a screw


32


and a shim washer


34


. In the following description, any references pertaining to an axis will be understood to refer to an axis of rotation


46


of the drive shaft shown in

FIG. 2

, which axis is shared with the electric motor


40


and the housing


12


.




The housing


12


has two ports, a first port


48


axially positioned at the distal end of the housing


12


, and a second port


50


disposed orthogonally to the axis


46


of the housing


12


. A feature of the pump of this invention is that it functions with comparable, and preferably equal, efficiency when pumping in either direction. Thus, when the pump is operating in one direction, port


48


serves as an inlet port and port


50


serves as an outlet port. When the pump is operating in the opposite direction, port


50


serves as an inlet port and port


48


serves as an outlet port. In the following description, for purposes of convenience, port


48


may be referred to as an inlet port and port


50


may be referred to as an outlet port, but it is understood that the inlet and outlet functions of the two ports are interchanged when the pump operating direction is reversed.




The end of the housing opposite the inlet port


48


has a circular opening


51


, and this end of the housing is adapted for connection to the electric motor


40


. For example, in the illustrated embodiment, flange


52


of motor


40


includes holes


53


, and housing


12


includes corresponding threaded holes


55


in the surface surrounding opening


51


, whereby the flange


52


is attached to the housing


12


by bolts


54


. As seen in

FIG. 2

, a portion of the electric motor


40


that extends from flange


52


is received into the interior of housing


12


through opening


51


, and this extending portion may be provided with a circumferential groove


56


for insertion of a seal, such as an O-ring, to provide an effective seal between the motor


40


and the housing


12


.




A detailed view of a magnetic coupling between motor


40


and the drive shaft of pump


10


is shown in

FIG. 3. A

cylindrical, axially aligned permanent drive magnet


58


in the motor


40


is magnetically coupled with a cylindrical mating driven magnet


60


, which is mounted concentrically on end


42


of the drive shaft of pump


10


, for example, magnet


60


may be affixed to end


42


with an adhesive. Thus, driven magnet


60


is disposed radially inward from, and axially aligned to, the drive magnet


58


. Interposed between the drive magnet


58


and the driven magnet


60


is a cup-shaped fluid barrier


61


formed from a thin sheet of nonmagnetic corrosion resistant steel which permits magnetic forces to be transmitted between the magnets. This fluid barrier being integral to the motor housing, it completely seals the motor from the pump to prevent any liquid from passing into the motor. Magnet


60


is free to rotate when driven by magnet


58


, neither magnet having contact with fluid barrier


61


.




The first port plate


18


includes an axial opening


63


to rotatably accept the drive shaft


14


, the second end


44


of which is inserted therein such that the first port plate


18


and the first thrust plate


16


are in close proximity. In the assembled pump, the spacer


36


is located between the motor


40


and the first port plate


18


, the spacer having a large enough internal diameter to accommodate the first thrust plate


16


without interference. The wave spring


38


is interposed between the spacer


36


and the motor


40


in order to accommodate any slack in the assembly.




Referring to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, an impeller assembly


64


comprises the rotor


20


, the cam ring


22


and the vanes


24


. The cam ring


22


has an outer cylindrical surface


66


in stationary contact with the inside surface of the housing


12


, and an inner noncylindrical camming surface


69


that defines central opening


68


. Specifically, the opening has an elliptical shape defined by a major diameter


70


and a different minor diameter


72


, the two diameters offset from each other by 90°. The opening


68


is symmetrically disposed about, or concentric with, the axis


46


. As seen in

FIG. 2

, the outer perimeter of the cam ring


22


may be provided with a circumferential groove


57


for insertion of a seal, such as an O-ring, to provide an effective seal between the cam ring


22


and the housing


12


.




A rotor


20


is placed with the cam ring


22


, the rotor having a circular perimeter


76


and an outer cylindrical surface


78


. Rotor


20


is symmetrically disposed about the axis


46


, such that rotor


20


is concentric with respect to the cam ring


22


. The diameter of the rotor outer surface


78


approximates the minor diameter


72


of the cam inner surface. Accordingly, the insertion of the outer cylindrical surface


78


of the rotor within the elliptical camming surface of the cam ring


22


provides two diametrically opposed gaps


80


therebetween, the gaps arranged symmetrically with respect to one another about diameter


72


.




As best seen in

FIG. 4

, outer surface


78


of the rotor


20


has a plurality of spaced radial slots


82


formed therein to accept vanes


24


. The rotor


20


also has a central axial opening


84


and a plurality of smaller openings


86


around the periphery of the axial opening


84


, these recesses being aligned with the axis


46


and sized to accommodate the drive pins


26


. Disposed around a circumferential zone of the drive shaft are recesses


88


which correspond and align with the smaller openings


86


in the rotor


20


so that the drive pins


26


may be inserted into the openings


86


and recesses


88


to engage the drive shaft


14


with the rotor


20


.




Inserted into the slots


82


are the vanes


24


. Each of the vanes


24


is generally rectangularly shaped with a base and an arcuate outer end surface


90


. Vanes


24


are free to translate within slots


82


, such that when the rotor


20


revolves during the operation of the pump


10


, centrifugal force maintains surfaces


90


of the vanes in sliding contact with the inner surface


69


of the cam ring


22


. In other words, the cam ring remains stationary, and as the rotor rotates, the vanes are free to translate radially according to their position relative to the cam ring. It is noted that it is unnecessary for the vanes to be spring-biased according to the illustrated embodiment.




The impeller assembly


64


is positioned between the first port plate


18


and the second port plate


28


, with the cam ring


22


remaining stationary with respect the port plates, and the rotor


20


rotating with respect to the port plates


18


and


28


. The axial location of second port plate


28


is defined by a step


91


in the interior wall of the housing. As will be described further, the port plates


18


and


28


, which are essentially identical in their geometry, differ in their orientation within the pump assembly.




The second thrust plate


30


, which is mounted within the housing


12


at the same end of the housing as the inlet port


48


, has an annular region


92


, an extension


94


and an opening


96


sized to receive the second end


44


of the drive shaft


14


. The opening


96


penetrates the entire thickness of the annular region


92


and into the extension


94


, terminating at a cap


98


. The cap


98


has an axial hole


100


sized to pass the screw


32


, by which the second thrust plate


30


is fixedly bolted into a corresponding threaded hole


102


in the second end


44


of the drive shaft


14


. A shim washer


34


is situated between the distal end


44


of the drive shaft and the inner shoulder of cap


98


of the second thrust plate. The second thrust plate


30


is in close proximity with the second port plate


28


.




Referring further to the port plates


18


and


28


, port plate


18


has two diametrically opposed reniform ports


104


through which fluid can pass, and port plate


28


similarly has two diametrically opposed reniform ports


105


. Port plate


18


also has two diametrically opposed reniform recesses


106


, and port plate


28


includes two similar recesses


107


, which act as fluid reservoirs. The recesses


106


are staggered from the ports


104


by 90°, and the recesses


107


are staggered from the ports


105


by 90°. The ports


104


,


105


and recesses


106


,


107


are symmetrically positioned about the axis


46


in a circular band so that they straddle the gap


80


between the rotor


20


and the cam ring


22


. Each such port


104


,


105


and recess


106


,


107


extends around an arc of about 45°. In addition to the reniform recesses


106


,


107


, each of the port plates


18


and


28


also has, facing the rotor, a circular recess


108


close to but not abutting the central opening. Besides their role in providing fluid channels and reservoirs, the port plates


18


and


28


also function as journal bearings for the drive shaft


14


; the drive shaft is inserted directly in, and journaled by, the port plates requiring no anti-friction bearings. The thrust plates


16


and


30


are sufficiently smaller in diameter than the port plates


18


and


28


, so that the thrust plates do not cover the ports


104


,


105


.




Considering their spatial relationship with the impeller assembly


64


, the port plates


18


and


28


are disposed so that the recesses


106


,


107


are on the faces of the port plates that abut the rotor. Further, the port plates are radially displaced from each other by 90° with respect to their ports


104


,


105


, and the ports


104


and


105


are radially equidistant from the major and minor diameters


70


and


72


of the cam ring


22


by 45°.




The cam ring


22


and port plates


18


and


28


have corresponding alignment holes


110


and are secured in place with an alignment pin


112


which is inserted in the alignment holes


110


and bolted into a threaded hole in the step


91


of the housing.




The second thrust plate


30


has a plurality of radial recesses


114


extending from its outer edge to meet with a circular recess


116


around the opening


96


, the recesses being in the surface which abuts the second port plate


28


. The first thrust plate


16


has like radial recesses meeting with a circular recess


118


where the first thrust plate meets the drive shaft


14


, the recess


118


being shown in FIG.


2


. The recesses of the first thrust plate


16


abut the first port plate


18


.




A primary function of shim washer


34


is to control the amount of axial play in the entire assembly of components about the drive shaft


14


. In effect, shim washer


34


determines the distance by which the thrust plates


16


and


30


are separated; the drive shaft


14


is allowed to float axially back and forth by a small but fixed distance, which allows for a film of fluid to be interposed between proximate faces of the port plates


18


and


28


and the thrust plates


16


and


30


. The fluid film acts as a lubricant, which avoids the need to introduce a separate lubricating liquid which potentially may be a source of contamination. Generally, for a given lubricating action, generally, a fluid of low viscosity must be present as a thinner film than a fluid of higher viscosity. In other words, the lubricity of a fluid film tends to degrade more rapidly with increasing film thickness if the fluid has a lower viscosity. Therefore, by controlling axial play, the thickness of the fluid film may be controlled to provide a desired range of lubricity, thereby contributing to the efficiency of the pump.




The operation of the pump is dependent on the relationship of the port plates


18


and


28


to the impeller assembly


64


. In the context of this invention, the term fluid will normally but not exclusively refer to a liquid, since a liquid would better fulfill the potential efficiency of the invention. Referring to

FIG. 5

, there is shown schematically the cam ring


22


, the rotor


20


positioned within the cam ring, and the vanes


24


. It will be seen that gaps


80


are present between inner surface


69


of the cam ring


22


and the outer surface


78


of the rotor, these gaps varying in width about the circumference of the rotor. As the rotor


20


rotates, each of the vanes


24


tends to be displaced outwardly from its respective slots


82


by centrifugal force, so that the outer surfaces


90


of the vanes slidingly contact the inner surface


74


of the cam ring


22


.





FIG. 5

shows in outline the position of the ports


104


,


105


in the first and second port plates


18


and


28


, respectively. Although the rotor


20


may equally well be driven in either direction, the explanation which follows will assume that the rotation is counter-clockwise as viewed in FIG.


5


. It will be seen that the ports


104


,


105


of the first port plate


18


and the second port plate


28


are staggered by 90° when viewed along the axis


46


.




Considering first in

FIG. 5

the vane


24


in position


120


, as the rotor rotates counter-clockwise, fluid is pushed ahead of this vane. Because of the widening gap between the rotor


20


and the cam ring


22


, each given quantity of fluid is impelled into a larger volume than it previously occupied. Since the fluid does not expand to fill such additional volume, the additional volume is filled with incoming liquid, which enters through port


105


in the second port plate


28


from an inlet chamber


121


. Considering now the vane in position


122


, the volume is still increasing ahead of this vane as the rotor rotates counterclockwise, and the rotation of the vane in this position continues to cause the admission of fluid into gap


80


. Position


124


is essentially a dwell point, where the available volume is at a maximum and therefore there is neither an increase nor decrease of fluid. Thus, the portion between positions


120


and


124


is a fluid inlet region. By contrast, from position


124


through


126


and up to position


128


, there is a region of decreasing volume, from which an incompressible fluid is necessarily expelled through port


105


in the second port plate


28


into an outlet chamber


129


. The position


128


has minimum available volume; just as with the region of maximum volume, the available volume neither increases nor decreases, whereby position


128


is essentially another dwell point. Thus, the portion between positions


124


and


128


is a fluid discharge region.




Once a given vane


24


passes position


128


it begins to repeat the pumping cycle in a fashion equivalent to position


120


; similarly, positions


130


,


132


and


134


are equivalent to positions


122


,


124


and


126


, respectively. In other words, for every revolution of the rotor, a given vane


24


goes through two pumping cycles. Therefore, there are two diametrically opposed inlet regions and two diametrically opposed discharge regions, the inlet and outlet regions being radially positioned at 90° from one another. The profile of the cam ring opening


68


is defined as a high power polynomial curve, which is selected to reduce both the acceleration and change in acceleration to zero at dwell points. This greatly reduces impact forces and therefore minimizes wear on the cam ring and vanes.




For the described counterclockwise rotation of the rotor,

FIG. 5

shows the ports


104


of the first port plate


18


are lined up with the inlet regions, and the ports


105


of the second port plate


28


lined up with the discharge regions. The ports are sized and shaped to be most compatible with the flow rates at the regions of optimum inlet and discharge, providing the minimum possible constriction to flow and minimizing frictional energy losses. The use of radially opposed port plates results in a balance of forces on the rotor and thus promotes efficiency in operating the pump.




The housing, the drive shaft and the thrust plates are preferably made from stainless steel. Preferably, the drive shaft and the thrust plate are coated with a wear- and corrosion resistant coating, such as tungsten carbide. The vanes and cam ring are preferably made from tungsten carbide or other ceramic material, with tungsten carbide most preferred for the vanes because its high density provides greater centrifugal force than other ceramic materials, thus maintaining better contact with the cam ring. The rotor and the port plates are preferably made from a ceramic material exhibiting good wear resistance and corrosion resistance. The hardness and dimensional stability of an alumina ceramic renders it ideal for hydrodynamic journal bearings. The rotating drive shaft runs directly in the port plate journals; the inclusion of a wear resistant coating such as tungsten carbide on the drive shaft precludes the need for antifriction bearings. Additionally, the drive shaft and its thrust plate bear on the outboard faces of the port plates; such a coating serves to provide a hydrodynamic thrust bearing. Accordingly, the need to include antifriction bearings is eliminated, especially for applications of a water pump of relatively low pressure (i.e., no greater than 100 psi). Overall, the stability of the preferred materials provides resistance to the degradation of pump efficiency over long periods of time, thus reducing maintenance of the pump which is important for applications where the pump is installed in a remote location, such as in space.




It is clear that the pump


10


of this invention has a high degree of symmetry. In particular, if the revolution of the rotor


20


is reversed, the fluid flow patterns in the vicinity of the rotor


20


and port plates


18


and


28


are identical except in their direction. Such a reversal merely converts an inlet region to an outlet region and an outlet region to an inlet region, thus reversing the roles of the ports


104


,


150


in the port plates


18


and


28


, the inlet and outlet chambers


121


and


129


, and the inlet and outlet ports


48


and


50


in the housing


12


. The aforementioned symmetry mandates that the efficiency of the pump is independent of the direction in which it is operated. An exception to this symmetry is in the positioning of the inlet port


48


and outlet port


50


of the housing


12


. Since the openings at these ports are much larger than the fluid clearances at other points in the system, they provide little resistance to flow by comparison, and will therefore have only a negligible effect on pump efficiency.




The arrangement of the various reniform recesses


106


and circular recesses in port plates


18


and


28


, and of the radial recesses


114


in the thrust plates


16


and


30


, is such that a film of the fluid being pumped is formed at the interfaces between the stationary port plates


18


and


28


, and the rotating rotor


20


or thrust plates


16


and


30


. This film acts as a lubricant which avoids the need to introduce a separate lubricating liquid which could be a source of contamination.




In summary, the combination of high internal symmetry, minimal constriction of fluid flow, control of play and inter-surface clearances, and low- corrosion, low-wear materials provides a long-life self-lubricating pump of high efficiency which operates equally well in either direction. Further, the ceramic material used for some components allows them to have a reduced weight by comparison with metal, which is important in space applications.




While the invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation of material to the teachings of the invention without departing from the scope of the invention. Therefore, it is intended that the invention not be limited to the particular embodiments disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out this invention, but that the invention will include all embodiments falling within the scope and spirit of the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. A self-lubricating, bi-directional vane pump comprising:a pump housing including a first port and a second port; a reversible motor connected to a drive shaft such that the drive shaft is reversibly rotatable about its axis; a stationary cam ring mounted in the pump housing, the cam ring having inner elliptical camming surface; a rotor concentrically disposed within the cam ring and connected to the drive shaft to rotate therewith, the rotor having an outer cylindrical surface with radial slots therein, wherein the cam ring and the rotor are each concentrically aligned with the drive shaft axis, and the rotor is disposed in the cam ring such that two diametrically opposed, symmetrical gaps are present between the rotor outer surface and the cam ring camming surface; a plurality of vanes slidingly disposed in the radial slots of the rotor, such that during operation of the pump, the vanes slide outwardly in the radial slots and maintain contact with the cam ring camming surface; first and second port plates disposed in the housing on each side of the rotor and cam ring, wherein each of said port plates comprises: two diametrically opposed ports, two diametrically opposed recesses formed in surfaces adjacent the rotor and cam ring, and a central opening on which the drive draft is journaled directly; wherein said first and second port plates are arranged with respect to the cam ring such that the two diametrically opposed recesses of the first port plate are aligned with the two diametrically opposed ports of the second port plate, the two diametrically opposed recesses of the second port plate are aligned with the two diametrically opposed ports of the first port plate, and the two diametrically opposed ports of the first port plate are offset by 90° from the two diametrically opposed ports of the second port plate, the port plates being in fluid connection with the pump housing first and second ports, such that one of the pump housing ports functions as an inlet port when the pump is operated in a first direction, and the other of the pump housing ports functions as an outlet port when the pump is operated in a second direction, the pump operating with comparable efficiency in both directions; and wherein axial position of the drive shaft is controlled to permit a pumping fluid to lubricate component parts on which the drive shaft is journaled; the pump further comprising a first thrust plate adjacent the first port plate, and a second thrust plate adjacent the second port plate, the first and second thrust plates being centrally attached to the drive shaft to rotate therewith and having diameter sized to avoid obstructing the ports in the first and second port plates, respectively.
  • 2. The pump of claim 1, wherein the first thrust place is integrally formed with the drive shaft.
  • 3. The pump of claim 1, wherein a surface of the first thrust plate adjacent the first port plate includes a plurality of radially disposed recesses connected to a circular recess surrounding its juncture with the drive shaft, and a surface of the second thrust plate adjacent the second port plate includes a plurality of radially disposed recesses connected to a circular recess around its juncture with the drive shaft.
  • 4. The pump of claim 1, wherein a shim is interposed between an end of the drive shaft and an inner shoulder of the second thrust plate, said shim controlling axial movement of the drive shaft.
  • 5. The pump of claim 4, wherein axial movement of the drive shaft is controlled to permit formation of a lubricating film of pumping fluid between surfaces of the port plates and adjacent surfaces of the port plates.
  • 6. The pump of claim 5 wherein the pumping fluid has low viscosity.
US Referenced Citations (26)
Number Name Date Kind
2809593 Klessig et al. Oct 1957 A
3204565 Kirkpatrick Sep 1965 A
3279387 McGill Oct 1966 A
3829924 Bright et al. Aug 1974 A
4035115 Hansen Jul 1977 A
4204810 Vogel May 1980 A
4376620 Colston Mar 1983 A
4384828 Rembold et al. May 1983 A
4484868 Shibuya et al. Nov 1984 A
4516918 Drutchas et al. May 1985 A
4566869 Pandeya et al. Jan 1986 A
4578948 Hutson et al. Apr 1986 A
4656099 Sievers Apr 1987 A
4770612 Tuebler Sep 1988 A
4902209 Olson Feb 1990 A
5064362 Hansen Nov 1991 A
5083909 Kunsemiller et al. Jan 1992 A
5154593 Konishi et al. Oct 1992 A
5183392 Hansen Feb 1993 A
5407327 Felhmann Apr 1995 A
5496159 Devore Mar 1996 A
5513960 Uemoto May 1996 A
5556270 Komine et al. Sep 1996 A
5654107 Tanaka et al. Aug 1997 A
5658137 Makela Aug 1997 A
5672054 Cooper et al. Sep 1997 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
59168291 Sep 1984 JP
59180088 Oct 1984 JP