The invention relates to a NMR-based biological detector and detection method that involve NMR detection of magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects using a microcoil.
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is widely used for the real-time identification of chemical compounds in solids, liquids, and gases because it can easily detect and characterize all components of mixtures without requiring separations. Unfortunately, standard high-resolution NMR spectroscopy is not useful for directly detecting dilute biological objects, such as tumor cells, bacteria, bacterial toxins, or viruses, in fluid samples. The weak signals from the analytes in the dilute species are lost against the much stronger background water signal. Even if the dynamic range challenge is met by suppressing the bulk water signal or concentrating the dilute species, the rapid transverse relaxation characteristics of macromolecular, viral, or cellular samples renders their direct detection by NMR difficult.
Recent developments involving superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) have, however, supplied the basis for new applications of NMR with high sensitivity and specificity for the detection and quantitation of dilute biological materials in fluids, such as cancer cells in blood or urine samples, or bacterial contaminants in food products or drinking water.
SPIONs are enjoying significant uses as biological contrast agents for NMR imaging in human clinical medicine. Furthermore, these nanoparticles can be coupled with biologically specific recognition ligands to target epitopes involved in diseases, like cancer. The her-2 protein, for example, is over-produced in many breast cancers and has been the subject of successful NMR imaging experiments where cells displaying this protein have been specifically imaged by means of SPIONs labeled with anti-her-2 antibodies. The image contrast effects due to SPIONs, which are typically embedded in larger beads, rely on the enhancement of the relaxation rates of water molecules sur-rounding the beads. The magnetic field gradient from a single, micron-sized magnetic bead has been shown to influence the relaxation time T*2 of the surrounding water within a voxel approximately 100 μm on a side (a volume of 1 nL), which is about 1000 times larger than that of a single cell. Thus, for a small biological object bound to a magnetic bead in water, the change in the NMR signal caused by the presence of the object is greatly amplified by the effect of the magnetic bead on the surrounding water.
In recent years, significant advances in the development and fabrication of microcoils (size<1 mm) for NMR have continued. Both planar surface microcoils and solenoidal microcoils have been developed. To enhance sensitivity for tiny samples, much of the work with microcoils has utilized the high fields produced by strong superconducting magnets.
The invention provides in an illustrative embodiment an NMR-based biological detector and detection method that involve detection of one or more magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects in a fluid, such as water, contained in a fluid-receiving conduit using a microcoil and a magnetic field generator, such as one or more low field permanent magnets or electromagnets, to establish a relatively low magnetic field with energization of the microcoil at a frequency that permits detection by NMR of one or more biological objects present in the fluid.
In an illustrative embodiment of the present invention, the microcoil has an inner diameter of about 50 to about 550 microns, preferably about 75 to about 125 microns, and even more preferably about 100 microns. The microcoil can comprise a solenoid-shaped or a flat, planar shaped microcoil. The solenoid-shaped microcoil preferably comprises a metallic wire microcoil wound on a tubular microconduit to reduce cost of the detector. The fluid in the tubular conduit is disposed in a magnetic field of about 0.5 to about 1.5 T established by one or more permanent magnets or electromagnets. The microcoil on the conduit can be mounted on a ceramic chip substrate to provide a compact assembly. A microfluidic chip also can be used to this end.
The NMR-based detector can provide capability of performing routine relaxation time measurements and low-field spectroscopy for the detection of dilute concentrations of magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects in fluids. Such biological objects include, but are not limited to, cancer cells in blood or urine samples, bacterial contaminants in food products or drinking water, and biological warfare agents in aqueous media.
The present invention is advantageous in a preferred embodiment in providing a microcoil together with one or more compact permanent magnets with benefits of reduced cost, maintenance, and space requirements of the NMR-based detector as well as portability thereof.
Other advantages of the invention will become apparent from the following detailed description taken with the following drawings.
The invention provides an NMR-based biological detector and detection method for detection of one or more magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects in a fluid, such as water. The fluid can be contained in a closed or open microconduit, such as a capillary tube or open-sided microchannel on or in a substrate (microfluidic chip), or other fluid sample holder. The fluid can be introduced to the conduit by injection using a fluid sample syringe for example, by capillary action using a capillary tube as the conduit, under pressure by a micropump for example, and/or any other technique and can be static in the conduit or can flow through the conduit during practice of the invention. The NMR-based detector includes a microcoil and a magnetic field generator, such as one or more low field permanent magnets or electromagnets, to establish a magnetic field of about 0.5 to about 1.5 T (Tesla) with energization of the microcoil at a frequency that permits detection by NMR of one or more labeled biological objects present in the fluid in the conduit. The NMR-based detector can provide capability of performing routine relaxation time measurements and low-field spectroscopy for the detection of dilute concentrations of magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects in biological fluids such as blood, saliva, and serum as well as aqueous fluids such as drinking water and aqueous industrial waste or effluent streams or spills. Such biological objects include, but are not limited to, cancer cells in blood or urine samples, bacterial contaminants in food products or drinking water, and biological warfare agents in aqueous media.
Referring to
The permanent magnets 12 can comprise cylindrical shaped commercially available SmCo, NdFeB or other low field permanent magnets that provide a magnetic field in the range of about 0.5 to about 1.5 T. For example, suitable SmCo and NdFeB permanent magnets are available from Neomax, Osaka, Japan. For purposes of illustration and not limitation, such permanent magnets can have a diameter of 2 inches and length of 2 inches and provide a gap of 0.05 inch width in which the conduit 10 is disposed. The permanent magnets can have any shape in practice of the invention. One or more permanent magnets, or a single C-shaped or similar shaped permanent magnet having integral opposite polarity ends at a gap can be used in practice of the invention.
Use of one or more low field compact permanent magnets with the microcoil 20 to be described below provides benefits of reduced cost, maintenance, and space requirements for the NMR-based detector as well as imparts portability to the detector.
However, the present invention also can be practiced using one or more electromagnets to provide a low magnetic field of about 0.5 to 1.5 T in lieu of the one or more permanent magnets described above. An electromagnet that can be used can comprise a high quality solenoid, or an iron-core magnet with polished pole faces.
Referring to
The solenoid-shaped microcoil 20 illustrated in
As described below in the Example, the conduit 10, the permanent magnets 12 (or one or more electromagnets if used), and the microcoil 20 can be disposed or mounted on a ceramic chip substrate C (see
The invention envisions detecting dilute concentrations of one or more specific magnetic nanoparticle-labeled biological objects in the fluid by performing routine relaxation time measurements and low-field spectroscopy. For example, for purposes of illustration and not limitation, such biological objects include, but are not limited to, cancer cells in blood or urine fluid samples, bacterial contaminants in fluid food products or drinking water, biological contaminants in waste water or spills, and biological warfare agents in aqueous fluid media.
The biological objects of the fluid are labeled using specific biological ligands (e.g. antibodies), which are carried on super-paramagnetic or other magnetic nanoparticles detectable by NMR. The nanoparticles can include, but are not limited to, superpara-magnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs), or nanoparticles made out of cobalt, manganese, nickel, or other small paramagnetic materials. The surfaces of the nanoparticles typically are partially or fully covered or encapsulated by the specific biological ligand (e.g. antibody) to this end, although other particle surface chemistry may be employed in practice of the invention to provide desired NMR-detectable bioconjugations with the biological objects to be detected.
The recognition of the biological objects by the magnetic-labeled ligands (e.g. antibodies) results in a perturbation of the magnetic relaxation times (T1, T2, T2*) and properties of the fluid (water) molecules in the NMR fluid sample to amplify the recognition event to an extent to permit NMR detection of dilute concentrations of the labeled biological objects. The magnetic perturbations emanating from the presence of super-paramagnetic nanoparticles are so strong that only a few, possibly one, biological object may be needed to provide a detectable change in the NMR signal. The recognition of the biological objects by the magnetic-labeled ligands (e.g. antibodies) may or may not result in nano-self-assembly of the labeled biological objects. That is, the present invention does not require that self-assembly of the labeled biological objects occur.
The following EXAMPLE is offered to further illustrate the invention without limiting the invention in any way:
This Example involves an NMR-based detector having a 550 μm inner diameter, solenoidal microcoil deposited and micromachined on a capillary tube. Superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) are shown to measurably change the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation properties of nearby protons in aqueous solution.
Microcoils were fabricated onto quartz tubes each having a length of 2.5 cm and a 550 μm outer diameter and 400 μm inner diameter using the procedure depicted in
Thirty keV Ga ions emitted from a liquid metal ion source were used to remove (micromachine) the Au/Cr layer in order to define the coil and the neighboring cuffs 20c. The ion beam was focused to approximately 0.5 μm width using a dual-lens Magnum ion column from FEI Co., Hillsboro, Oreg., and steered across areas outlined by the operator until all the metal was removed from targeted regions (step 4). Rates of metal removal were on the order of 10 μm3/s when using a 20 nA Ga beam. Minimal heat and force accompany FIB bombardment. The secondary electron intensity was monitored during ion bombardment to ensure complete removal of metal and slight penetration into the quartz.
An example microcoil is shown in
The finished metallic coil used in this Example (
The microcoil/capillary tube were packaged on a ceramic chip substrate C comprising DuPont™ Green Tape™ Low Temperature Co-Fired Ceramic (LTCC) material available from DuPont Microcircuit Materials, Research Triangle Park, N.C. The chip substrate had dimensions of 20 mm by 60 mm. The chip substrate had been previously plated with alloyed gold (Au—Pt) co-firable material (DuPont 5739) solder leads 11a as shown in
‘H NMR measurements, at a resonant frequency of 44.2 MHz, were performed using a MRTechnology console (Tsukuba City, 300-2642 Japan), and a 1.04 T (Tesla) NEOMAX permanent magnet assembly comprising a NdFeB permanent magnet assembly providing a 2 inch gap. The microcoil on the chip substrate was inserted in the gap between the magnet pole faces with the chip substrate supported in the gap by plastic spacers for the NMR measurement. A smaller 1 Tesla permanent magnet suitable for use in a portable microcoil NMR device can be fabricated.
The transmitter pulses were output directly from the console, without a conventional radiofrequency power amplifier, because only 0.25 mW of power was required to produce a B1 field of 0.3 G (vide infra). Ethanol (100%) was purchased from AAPER (Shelbyville, Ky.). Spin-lattice 1H T1 values were obtained, using a standard inversion-recovery sequence, from a Gd-DTPA-containing water sample (Gd-DTPA is gadolinium-diethylene-triamine-pentaacetate), from a sample of magnetic beads in water, and from a sample of de-ionized water.
Magnetic beads (Dynabeads; MyOne Streptavidin) were purchased from Dynal Inc. Each magnetic bead consists of thousands of 8-nm diameter superparamagnetic iron oxide particles, uniformly dispersed in a polystyrene matrix, and coated with a thin layer of polymer and a monolayer of streptavidin which served as a bonding agent onto which biotinylated antibodies could be attached. The beads are 26% Fe by weight (about 10% Fe by volume) with an average diameter of 1.05±0.10 μm. The stock solution has a stated bead concentration of between 7×103 and 1.2×104 beads per nL (equivalent to about 2.6 mg Fe/ml). NMR samples were prepared by diluting the same batch of stock solution with de-ionized water by factors of 10, 100, and 1000 to produce nominal concentrations of 1000, 100, and 10 beads per nL introduced to the detector tube by supply syringe. The relaxation time T*2 was determined by collecting a single free-induction decay (FID) and fitting the resulting spectrum with a Lorentzian, unless noted otherwise. The relative shift of the NMR frequency of water caused by the magnetic-labeled beads was determined by measuring the resonance frequency of each solution in a 5 mm NMR tube in a conventional coil relative to a separate tube of deionized water. To avoid errors due to field drift of the permanent magnet, each frequency shift measurement was performed by switching several times between the bead solution and a deionized water sample during a period when the frequency drift was confirmed to be less than 1 Hz/min.
The 93 nH inductance of the 550-μm outer diameter microcoil described above could reach resonance at 44.2 MHz with a variable capacitor of reasonable size. However, since use of much smaller microcoils at coil outer diameters nearer the 50 μm outer diameter are envisioned, described below are tuning circuits for tuning such smaller microcoils to resonance at the 44.2 MHz resonant frequency or less to detect water with a spectral resolution of 2.5 Hz in a 1.04 Tesla permanent magnet.
Such a tuning circuit involves an auxiliary tank circuit with conventional scale capacitors and to connect the microcoil to it. The key parameter of the microcoil described above that guided the design of this tuning circuit was its very high coil resistance. Optimization of a tuned circuit's SNR (where SNR is the signal to noise ratio) is a compromise between maximizing coil efficiency, in terms of the magnetic field produced per unit current in the sample coil, while minimizing the resistive noise. The dominant noise source for the very thin, ribbon-wire shaped microcoils used in this Example was its large coil resistance. Therefore, the introduction of the additional inductor did not degrade performance, because this extra inductance did not contribute to the resistive losses.
Two tuning circuits were constructed for use in the Example as shown in
The two circuits exhibited nearly identical SNR performance. All subsequent measurements were performed with the first circuit (
The nutation performance of the microcoil probe is shown in
The free-induction decay (FID) and spectrum of deionized water in the microcoil are shown in
0 The standard values are shown in square brackets
To test the ability of the microcoil to measure spin-lattice relaxation times, three different water samples were used; the first sample was doped with Gd-DTPA to shorten the T1 to around 70 ms, the second sample consisted of pure de-ionized water, and the third sample contained magnetic beads (at a concentration of 1000 beads/nL) in de-ionized water. In all cases, a single scan was acquired at each recovery time. The results (
In
The solid symbols in
Because magnetic field gradients can cause motion of the magnetic beads with respect to the fluid, it was not clear a priori that the concentration of beads delivered to the microcoil would be the same as the concentration in the supply syringe. Indeed, the measured T*2 of bead solutions in the microcoil was observed to decrease over time if the bead solution was allowed to sit motionless in the coil over several minutes, suggesting that the spatial distribution of the beads was changing, due to clustering, settling, or migration out of the coil. Thus, in order to validate the microcoil results, the T*2 of the same bead solutions (1000, 100, and 10 beads/nL) and deionized water in capped 5 mm NMR tubes using a conventional probe in the same magnet. Each measurement was performed within 20-30 s after shaking the tube to homogenize the bead solution, and the tube was immediately extracted afterwards to visually confirm that the beads had not settled during the measurement. (Shimming was performed on the deionized water, and a sample holder was used to position the other 5 mm tubes identically, to avoid the need to re-shim. Repeatedly placing the same sample in the probe using this holder gave linewidths that were reproducible to ±5 Hz.) Migration of the beads was similarly observed in the 5 mm tubes (both visually and as an increase in T*2 over time) if the samples were allowed to sit in the magnet for longer time periods. The ΔR*2 values measured for the bead solutions in 5 mm tubes (open symbols in
Thus, in summary, the nutation performance of the microcoil was sufficiently good so that the effects of magnetic beads on the relaxation characteristics of the surrounding water could be accurately measured. The solution of magnetic beads (Dynabeads MyOne Streptavidin) in deionized water at a concentration of 1000 beads per nL lowered the T1 from 1.0 to 0.64 s and the T*2 from 110 to 0.91 ms. Lower concentrations (100 and 10 beads/nL) also resulted in measurable reductions in T*2, indicating that low-field, microcoil NMR detection using permanent magnets can be used as a high-sensitivity, miniaturizable detection mechanism for very low concentrations of magnetic beads in biological fluids.
The tuning circuit described above is capable of tuning an arbitrarily small inductance at a frequency compatible with a permanent magnet, coupled with the 550 μm microcoil, allows spectroscopic and relaxation measurements using less than 1 mW of radiofrequency power. (This low power requirement further aids in making the NMR detector portable.) The line widths for deionized water are adequate for the detection of magnetic beads in water at a concentration of 10 beads/nL. The coil used for these proof-of-principle measurements is not optimized in size for NMR sensitivity, as discussed further below. However, the above results indicate that this approach will allow the detection of very dilute biological species, perhaps as rare as a single cell or molecule labeled with a single magnetic bead.
The challenge of achieving this detection sensitivity can be discussed quantitatively in light of the data of
Extrapolating the straight line in
A 100 μm diameter coil (1 nL) will give substantially less signal than the Example 264 nL microcoil due to the reduced sample size. Thus one must consider whether such a coil will have sufficient SNR to detect 10 beads in its 1 nL volume. In the “large” microcoil data in
While the Example microcoil described above is already capable of detecting the presence of as few as 3000 magnetic beads (nanoparticles), it can be further optimized for maximal SNR performance for operation at 44.2 MHz. The thickness of the coil “wire” is much less than a skin depth, which raises the resistance of the coil without providing any improvements in signal detection. The width of the “wire” is much more than a skin depth, so that it may be possible to increase the number of turns per unit length and gain in coil sensitivity without suffering a nullifying increase in resistance. Careful attention to the geometrical design of the smaller microcoil, should improve the SNR above the estimate of about 3.7 based on this Example. SNR performance will be enhanced by reducing the coil resistance, which is higher than expected in Example ion-milled microcoil. Improving the line width of the background fluid places a lower demand on the SNR performance. The use of susceptibility matching (either in the choice of evaporated metals or via a matching fluid) and the reduction of the filling factor (by increasing the relative wall thickness in the capillary tube) may improve the line widths in smaller coils. In addition, the permanent magnet used in the Example is not very homogeneous and only first order shims are available; a more homogeneous applied field may be required to achieve narrower lines. Optimization of the coil can also include comparisons of both the SNR and line width performance of ion-milled coils to other types of microcoils, such as copper wire-wound coils. Some compromise between line width and sensitivity may provide the best opportunity for detecting single biological objects.
The surface of a single cancer cell (about 10 μm in diameter) can bear upwards of 105 binding sites (antigens) for a particular antibody and can accommodate up to 400 one micron diameter magnetic beads (nanoparticles), assuming monolayer coverage and random close packing. Thus, sensitivity to 10 beads would already be adequate to detect single magnetically labeled cells. On the other hand, bacterial toxin molecules (e.g., botulism toxin) are much smaller and would accommodate only one or a few beads, requiring single-bead detection sensitivity. Hence, single-bead sensitivity is envisioned by practice of the present invention.
So far in the Example, the detection limits have been based on measurements of a particular type (Dynabeads) and size (1 μm) of magnetic bead (nanoparticle). Larger magnetic beads (having larger magnetic moments) are available and will permit an increase in the relaxivity of a single bead and further lower the detection limit. Assuming that a background T*2 was at least 100 ms, the ΔR*2 for a single 1.63 μm bead in a 1 nL volume to be at least 60 s−1, which should be readily detected using a 1 nL microcoil with a background water T*2 of 100 ms and a SNR of about 3. Even larger beads (e.g., 2.8 μm and 4.8 μm Dynabeads) are commercially available, and may be used, if necessary, to further enhance the ability to detect a single magnetic bead in an NMR microcoil.
Although the invention has been described hereinabove in terms of specific embodiments thereof, it is not intended to be limited thereto but rather only to the extent set forth hereafter in the appended claims.
This application claims benefits and priority of U.S. provisional application Ser. No. 60/839,006 filed Aug. 21, 2006, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60839006 | Aug 2006 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 12720499 | Mar 2010 | US |
Child | 13776580 | US | |
Parent | 11894597 | Aug 2007 | US |
Child | 12720499 | US |