The disclosure relates to methods for at least one of blood pressure and arterial compliance estimation from arterial segments.
The pulse wave, generated by left ventricular ejection, propagates at a velocity that has been identified as an important marker of atherosclerosis and cardiovascular risk. Increased pulse wave velocity (PWV) indicates an increased risk of stroke and coronary heart disease. This velocity is considered a surrogate marker for arterial compliance, is highly reproducible, and is widely used to assess the elastic properties of the arterial tree. Research shows that measurement of pulse wave velocity as an indirect estimate of aortic compliance could allow for early identification of patients at risk for cardiovascular disease. The ability to identify these patients would lead to better risk stratification and earlier, more cost-effective preventative therapy. Several studies have shown the influence of blood pressure and left ventricular ejection time (LVET) on pulse wave velocity.
Over the past decades, there has been ongoing research for better theoretical prediction of PWV. The clinical relationship between PWV and arterial stiffness is often based on classic linear models or the combination of the linear models, and measured results with an incorporated correction factor. Whereas linear models predict PWV as a function of only geometric and physical properties of the fluid and the wall, there is strong empirical evidence that PWV is also correlated to pressure and ejection time.
There exist no models that accurately describe PWV and flow accounting for the nonlinearities in an arterial segment. A model that would enable solution of the inverse problem of determination of blood pressure and aortic compliance for a PWV measure has yet to be developed.
In accordance with one aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for determining material characteristics for an artery, the method including providing at least three values for each of blood pressure, internal radius, and external radius of an arterial segment or segments of a subject; applying a base model of fluid-structure interaction incorporating conservation of mass and momentum for the fluid, and non-linear elasticity of the structure; and running a mathematical optimization on the base model to provide a calibrated model to determine material characteristics of the arterial segment or segments.
In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for determining at least one of a blood pressure and an arterial compliance parameter of a subject, the method including providing a value for pulse wave velocity within an arterial segment or segments of a subject; providing a value for flow velocity within the arterial segment or segments of the subject; providing a value for blood density of the subject; providing the material characteristics of an artery; and applying a calibrated model of fluid-structure interaction incorporating conservation of mass and momentum for the fluid, and non-linear elasticity of the structure, to calculate at least one of blood pressure and an arterial compliance parameter of the subject using the provided values.
These and other aspects of the present disclosure will become apparent upon a review of the following detailed description and the claims appended thereto.
A fully nonlinear model of pressure and flow propagation in arterial segments is disclosed that enables determination of blood pressure and arterial compliance based on measures of pulse wave velocity and flow velocity following a calibration. The approach allows for determination of systolic and diastolic blood pressure. The approach allows for determination of a systolic and diastolic aortic compliance.
A noninvasive method for monitoring the blood pressure and arterial compliance of a patient based on measurements of a flow velocity and a pulse wave velocity is described. An embodiment uses a photoplethysmograph and includes a method to monitor the dynamic behavior of the arterial blood flow, coupled with a hemodynamic mathematical model of the arterial blood flow motion in a fully nonlinear vessel. A derived mathematical model creates the patient specific dependence of a blood pressure versus PWV and blood flow velocity, which allows continuous monitoring of arterial blood pressure. The calibrated mathematical model presents an arterial compliance and a distensibility as a clinical marker of arterial stiffness. The disclosure is applicable for fully nonlinear elastic vessels that are commonly found in the major arteries, as well as smaller vessels that operate closer to the linear elastic regime.
The disclosure includes a fully nonlinear basic model for blood pressure wave propagation in compliant arteries. A nonlinear traveling wave model was used to investigate mechanisms underlying the effects of pressure, ejection time, ejection volume, geometric, and physical properties on PWV. A patient calibration procedure was developed that involves measurement of blood pressure and arterial dimensions (internal and external radii). An embodiment includes blood pressure prediction using the model, per patient calibration, and the measurement of flow velocity and pressure wave velocity. An embodiment includes arterial compliance determination using the model, per patient calibration, and the measurement of flow velocity and pressure wave velocity.
A basic mathematical fluid-structure interaction model for pulse wave velocity (PWV) propagation incorporates the dynamics of incompressible flow in a compliant vessel. This one dimensional model simulating blood flow in arteries effectively describes pulsatile flow in terms of averages across the section flow parameters. Although it is not able to provide the details of flow separation, recirculation, or shear stress analysis, it accurately represents the overall and average pulsatile flow characteristics, particularly PWV.
Conservation of mass and momentum results in the following system of one dimensional equations
where t is time, z is the axial coordinate shown in
For an impermeable thin walled membrane, neglecting inertia forces, the vessel pressure-strain relationship is maintained by equilibrium condition as a function p=p(η), based on relevant constitutive relations where 11 is the circumferential strain (ratio of wall deflection to zero stress arterial radius (R)). Noting that A=πR2(1+η)2, and assuming that transmural pressure is a smooth function of a wall normal deflection (derivative pη=∂p/∂η exists at any point), the total system of equations can be presented in the following non-conservative form
We find the eigenvalues of H(U) to be real and distinct. PWV is associated with the forward running wave velocity, i.e., the largest eigenvalue, hence it is identified as
The partial derivative pii indicates sensitivity of pressure with respect to the wall normal deflection, and has a clear interpretation as tangent (incremental) moduli in finite strain deformation. In the general case, equation (5) is supplemented by appropriate constituent equations for a hyperelastic anisotropic arterial wall, accounting for finite deformation.
It is assumed that arterial wall is hyperelastic, incompressible, anisotropic, and undergoing finite deformation. After a few original loading cycles (preconditioning) the arterial behavior follows some repeatable, hysteresis free pattern with a typical exponential stiffening effect regarded as pseudo elastic. The strain energy density function W for the pseudo elastic constitutive relation may be presented in the form
W=½c(eQ−1) (6)
where c is a material coefficient, and Q is the quadratic function of the Green-Lagrange strain components. For the finite inflation and extension of a thin walled cylindrical artery the following strain energy function is used
Q=a
11
E
θ
2+2a12EθEz+a22Ez2 (7)
where c, a11, a12, a22 are material constants. The Cauchy stress components in circumferential and axial directions are:
With the geometry of the reference state determined, we define R, Z, H—as an internal radius, axial coordinate and a wall thickness in a stress free configuration, r,z,h—internal radius, axial coordinate and a wall thickness in a physiologically loaded configuration. The corresponding principal stretch ratios are
λθ=r/R,λz=dz/dZ,λr=h/H (9)
Assuming isochoric deformation incorporate the incompressibility condition as
λzλθλr=1 (10)
The Green-Lagrangian strain components relate to the principal stretch ratios of Eq. 12 by
E
i=½(λi2−1), (i=θ, z, r) (11)
For the membrane thin walled cylindrical artery undergoing finite inflation and axial deformation, the load-stress relations follow from the static conditions
where F is the axial pretension force and f is the axial pre-stress per unit of cross section area of a load free vessel. A substitution back into equation (8) yields the desired relations:
The solution of equations (13), (11), (7) results in a load-strain relations, which with account of the identity
converts into the p=p(η) function, required by (5) to predict a wave front speed of propagation, i.e., PWV.
Arterial stiffness, or its reciprocals, arterial compliance and distensibility, may provide indication of vascular changes that predispose to the development of major vascular disease. In an isolated arterial segment filled with a moving fluid, compliance is defined as a change of a volume V for a given change of a pressure, and distensibilty as a compliance divided by initial volume. As functions of pressure the local (tangent) compliance C and distensibility D are defined as
Equations (14) determine arterial wall properties as local functions of transmural pressure.
We present equations (14) in the following equivalent form
The classical results are generalized for the case of a hyperelastic arterial wall with account of finite deformation and flow velocity. To proceed, determine pη from Equation (5) and substitute in Equation (15), arriving at the following relations
Arterial constants can be defined based on the developed mathematical model. The Cauchy stress components based on Fung's energy are presented in equations (6), (7), and (8). Neglecting longitudinal stress (σ=0) in equation (8), we obtain
where the ratio
is a counterpart of a Poisson coefficient in a linear isotropic elasticity.
It follows from Equations (7), (17) that a circumferential stress is a function of a circumferential strain and two material constants, a and c
The governing equation specifies an equilibrium condition
where p is the transmural pressure, ri is the internal radius, ro is the outer radius, and h is the wall thickness. Let us define rm as the mid radius of a loaded vessel, and Rm as the mid radius for a stress free vessel. Measuring ri and ro corresponding to the pressure p leaves us with three unknowns (a, c, Rm) which need to be determined as a part of a calibration procedure. The calibration provides a calibrated model which can be individualized for each subject.
An embodiment of the calibration includes the use of published values for a population or segment of a population. Referenced values for material constants c, a11, a12, a22 can be used to calculate the material constant a based on equation (20). The material constant c is used directly. A reference value for the mid radius in the stress free state (Rm) is used along with a reference value for the arterial wall thickness (h) and associated mid radius (rm) for the loaded wall. The material parameters (a, c, Rm) along with the product of wall thickness and mid radius for the loaded wall (hrm) can then be used to determine at least one of blood pressure and arterial compliance, e.g., distensibility, of a subject by measuring PWV and flow velocity.
Another embodiment of the calibration is disclosed as follows and described in
σθ=σθ(a, c, Rm) (22)
Now using a mathematical optimization, e.g., a least square (LS) minimization technique identifies (a, c,Rm)
The following nonlinear calibration method describes one approach that may be completed to determine arterial constants.
Step 1: Obtain k measurements, k≧3, for blood pressure-pk, internal radius-rik; outer radius-rok, calculate mean radii rmk=0.5(rik+rok) and wall thicknesses hk=rok−rik. example, tonometry could be used to measure a continuous blood pressure to create the array of blood pressures, and Doppler speckle ultrasound could be used to measure artery radii to create the corresponding array of rik, rok.
Step 2: Run a least square minimization as in equation (23) to identify the three constants (two material constants a, c and the mean radius Rm, in a load free condition). Substituting σθ in equation (23) with equation (18) results in
where
LS is a function of measured parameters pk, rik, rmk, hk and unknown properties (a,c,Rm), determined from the minimization procedure. Since we have 3 unknowns, at least 3 sets of pressure and associated outer and inner radii are required.
In an embodiment, a calibrated model can be used to determine at least one of blood pressure and arterial compliance, e.g., distensibility, of a subject by measuring PWV and flow velocity.
With the three material properties (a,c,Rm) and the constant product (hrm) a blood pressure may be estimated based on the equilibrium equation (21) rearranged to
where the stretch ratio (λθ) can be defined in terms of η
The circumferential strain (Eθ) can be defined in terms of η
E
θ=(λθ2−1)/2=η(η+2)/2 (27)
Wall thickness follows from incompressibility conditions
hrm=hkrmk (28)
where from
Internal Radius
r
i
=r
m−0.5h=λθRm−0.5h=(η+1)Rm−0.5h (30)
These formulations provide a relationship between pressure (p), circumferential strain (η), two arterial material parameters (a and c) and two arterial geometric parameters (Rm and the constant product hkrmk).
Equation (5) for PWV in arterial tissues can be re-arranged
p
η(1+η)=2ρ*PWVf2 (31)
where a flow corrected PWV (PWVf) has been introduced (PWVf=PWV-u).
This relation can be used in combination with equation (16) to define distensibility D in terms of the pη
D=
2/p
In an embodiment, a lookup table can be created for convenience to enable determination of a blood pressure and distensibility based on the 4 arterial parameters (can be subject specific) and measurement of PWV and flow velocity. A blood density ρ is either measured or a value is assumed based on age and gender. As illustrated in an embodiment shown in
Set η=0.
Using equation (26) calculate circumferential stretch ratio λθ.
Using equation (27) calculate circumferential strain Eθ.
Using equation (29) and any hkrmk product from the calibration, calculate wall thickness h.
Using equation (30) calculate the internal radius ri.
Using equation (25) calculate pressure p.
While η<0.5, η=η+0.005, go back to calculation of the circumferential stretch ratio or else continue.
Calculate the array for pn using the slope of the (p,η) curve.
Using equation (31) and the array of values for η and pn calculate a 1D array for pη(1+η).
Using equation (31) and the array of pη, calculate D for each value of η.
An example resultant array is shown in
A method for monitoring a blood pressure of a subject is disclosed. The model is calibrated for the subject (or population) by a non-linear calibration. For example, a non-linear calibration as illustrated in
Determination of PWV includes measurement of the transit time of the pulse wave between two points, and a measure or estimate of the distance traveled. The PWV is the distance travelled divided by the time difference. This can be done by extracting the foot (
In some embodiments, the wave will propagate across multiple arterial segments between the proximal and distal points of pressure measurement. This measurement can be used in at least two ways. In the first form, average properties of the vessel segments, radius, and modulus will be considered so that the result corresponds to bulk average of the segment. In the second, the properties of individual arterial segments are determined. First, use the model to determine the relative transit time through each sequential arterial segment based on geometrical properties of each segment and assuming a similar pressure within all segments. Then using a solution method, such as minimization of a least squares or another method, solve for the PWV within each segment by recognizing that the total transit time (measured) is the sum of the transit time through each segment.
Measurement of flow velocity can be done using Doppler ultrasound, an inductive coil, MRI or CT scan with contrast agents. The flow velocity can be captured as a continuous wave, as a peak value, or a minimum value (including u=0). It is also possible to estimate flow velocity using related measures or with a scale factor. For example PWV can be measured using previously described techniques and flow velocity is then estimated as a percentage of PWV (for example u=0.2 PWV). Aortic flow velocity can be estimated through left ventricular ejection time (LVET), ejection volume (EV), and aortic cross-sectional area (CA) where u=EV/(LVET*CA). Left ventricular ejection time (LVET) can be measured or estimated using a number of sensors (e.g. PPG, heart sound). Using PPG for example, the measure of LVET is the length of time from the foot of the PPG wave (
Pressure can be measured using any approved technique, for example, brachial cuff, tonometry, or intra-arterial catheter. Ideally a continuous method (e.g., tonometry, intra-arterial) is used with a method of time synchronization to the flow and PWV measures (e.g. via ECG). However serial measures can also be used. Here the pressure p can be systolic, diastolic, or any intermediate pressure (e.g., mean pressure) when coupled with the appropriate flow velocity (u). For example, systolic pressure could be associated with the peak flow velocity, and diastolic pressure could be associated with the lowest (or zero) flow velocity, or an average pressure could be associated with an average flow velocity.
An optional ECG can be measured across the chest or wrists. Other locations are also possible such as ear lobes, behind the ears, buttocks, thighs, fingers, feet or toes. PPG can be measured at the chest or wrist. Other locations such as the ear lobes, fingers, forehead, buttocks, thighs, and toes also work. Video analysis methods examining changes in skin color can also be used to obtain a PPG waveform. Flow velocity can be measured at the chest or wrist. Other locations for flow velocity measure are also possible such as the neck, arm and legs.
In one embodiment, the pulse transit time is measured based on aortic valve opening determined by the J-wave of the BCG waveform, and a PPG foot measured (e.g.,
In another embodiment, the pulse transit time is measured from the carotid artery using tonometry, to the pressure pulse measured at thigh with a thigh cuff. The arterial distance is estimated from aortic root along the path of the aorta to the femoral artery at the thigh cuff measurement location. The PWV is calculated by dividing the arterial distance by the measured time difference. The foot to foot timing on the measured pressure pulses (e.g.,
A method for monitoring an arterial compliance of a subject is disclosed. The model is calibrated for the subject (or population) by a non-linear calibration. For example, a non-linear calibration as illustrated in
The systolic PWV and the peak flow velocity are used to determine a systolic distensibility, while a diastolic PWV and the minimum flow velocity are used to estimate a diastolic distensibility. Although other estimates and combinations may be used to determine the subject distensibility parameter.
In one embodiment, the pulse transit time is measured based on aortic valve opening determined by the J-wave of the BCG waveform, and a PPG foot measured (e.g.,
In another embodiment, the pulse transit time is measured from the carotid artery using tonometry, to the pressure pulse measured at thigh with a thigh cuff. The arterial distance is estimated from aortic root along the path of the aorta to the femoral artery at the thigh cuff measurement location. The PWV is calculated by dividing the arterial distance by the measured time difference. The foot to foot timing on the measured pressure pulses (e.g.,
The disclosure will be further illustrated with reference to the following specific examples. It is understood that these examples are given by way of illustration and are not meant to limit the disclosure or the claims to follow.
Paper Example, Blood Pressure and Distensibility
This paper example uses referenced values for an aorta c=120123 Pa, a11=0.320, a12=0.068, a22=0.451. The reduced constant ‘a’ is calculated based on equation 20 (a=0.31). In addition reference values were used for the mid radius for the stress free vessel Rm=0.009 m, the aortic wall thickness h=0.00211 m, and the mid radius of the loaded wall rm=0.011. A computer routine executed the functions outlined in
and the systolic distensibility is identified as
This application claims the benefit of the filing date of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/080,740, filed Nov. 17, 2014, and U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/080,738, filed Nov. 17, 2014, each of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US15/61190 | 11/17/2015 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62080740 | Nov 2014 | US | |
62080738 | Nov 2014 | US |