Bulk ultrasonic degreasing, cleaning, and drying method

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6279584
  • Patent Number
    6,279,584
  • Date Filed
    Friday, September 29, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, August 28, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A system and method for removing a coating from an elongated metal part or a bundle of such parts is described. The disclosed system includes a soaking vessel that contains a solution suitable for degreasing the metal part and softening the coating thereon. An ultrasonic cleaning vessel containing an aqueous cleaning solution cleans the coating off of the metal part by ultrasonic agitation. The system further includes at least one rinsing vessel for rinsing the cleaning solution of the cleaned part, and a drying vessel for rapidly and thoroughly drying the part after it has been rinsed. In the disclosed process, the elongated metal part, or a bundle of such parts, is/are soaked in a solution that is maintained at an elevated temperature for a time sufficient to soften the coating. The elongated metal part is then subjected to ultrasonic agitation in an aqueous cleaning solution bath at an elevated temperature for a time sufficient to loosen and dislodge the coating from the elongated metal part. The elongated metal part is then rinsed to remove any residue and rapidly dried.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to an ultrasonic cleaning apparatus and in particular to such an apparatus and a method of using same for the bulk cleaning of a chlorinated drawing compound from an elongated metallic object such as tubing or wire, with only a minimal amount of non-aqueous cleaning agent.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Certain elongated steel parts, such as small diameter tubes, are cold worked to precision tolerances by a process known as drawing. The drawing process involves pulling the elongated part through a die or series of drawings dies wherein its diameter is reduced to a desired dimension. In order to facilitate the drawing process, the parts are coated with a lubricant to prevent binding and wear in the drawing die. Because many drawing lubricants do not adhere well to the metal surface of the parts to be drawn, it is sometimes necessary to apply a coating to the surface of the steel part which acts as a carrier for the drawing lubricant. One such coating is chlorinated rubber and another is chlorinated paraffin. Such compounds are applied to the metal parts in solution form using an aromatic hydrocarbon solvent such as toluene. The chlorinated rubber or chlorinated paraffin coatings adhere tenaciously to the surface of the metal parts and must be removed after the drawing process is completed.




Hitherto, a chlorinated solvent such as trichloroethylene (TCE) was used to remove the chlorinated rubber and chlorinated paraffin coatings from the elongated metal parts. Chlorinated solvents such as TCE are highly toxic are very difficult to dispose of in an environmentally safe manner. Consequently, it has become highly desirable to have an environmentally safe and easy to use method for cleaning chlorinated rubber or chlorinated paraffin coatings from elongated metal parts after they have been drawn to a desired size. Moreover, since such parts are usually handled in bundles, any such process should be capable of performing such cleaning on a substantial number of pieces in bundles.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In accordance with one aspect of this invention, there is provided a system for removing a coating from an elongated metal part or a bundle of such parts. The system according to this aspect of the invention includes a soaking vessel that contains a solution suitable for degreasing and softening the coating on the metal part. The system also includes an ultrasonic cleaning vessel containing an aqueous cleaning solution for effectively cleaning the coating off of the metal part by ultrasonic agitation. The system further includes at least one rinsing vessel for rinsing the cleaning solution of the cleaned part, and a drying vessel for rapidly and thoroughly drying the part after it has been rinsed.




In accordance with another aspect of this invention, there is provided a method for removing a coating from the surface of an elongated metal part. In the process according to this invention, the elongated metal part, or a bundle of such parts are first soaked in a solution that is maintained at an elevated temperature for a time sufficient to soften the coating. The elongated metal part is then immersed in an aqueous cleaning solution bath at an elevated temperature. The cleaning solution bath is agitated, preferably by ultrasonic vibration, for a time sufficient to loosen and dislodge the coating from the elongated metal part. The elongated metal part is then rinsed to remove any residue and rapidly dried.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The following detailed description of a preferred embodiment of the present invention will be better understood when read in conjunction with the appended drawings, wherein:





FIG. 1

is a schematic diagram of a first stage of a bulk degreasing and ultrasonic cleaning system including a presoak tank and an ultrasonic cleaning tank in accordance with the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a schematic diagram of a second stage of the system of

FIG. 1

including rinse tanks and a dryer;





FIG. 3

is a front elevational view of an support structure for a set of ultrasonic transducers used in system according to the present invention;





FIG. 4

is top plan view of a retaining bracket for suspending the support structure shown in

FIG. 3

inside the ultrasonic cleaning tank shown in

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 5

is a side elevational view, in partial section showing further details of the retaining bracket of

FIG. 4

;





FIG. 6

is a detail view of a transducer support used for mounting the ultrasonic transducers on the support pipe of

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 7

is a side elevational view of a pivotable support and housing for a blower and an intake filter, and





FIG. 8

is a bottom plan view of the housing shown in FIG.


7


.











DESCRIPTION OF A PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




The bulk degreasing and cleaning apparatus according to the present invention, and the associated process of operating same, utilizes a unique combination of components and steps, respectively, including ultrasonic energy, to provide enhanced cleaning of small diameter tubes in bulk form with a minimum amount of non-aqueous solvent. The system and method of the present invention includes processing the parts in two cleaning solutions followed by a rough rinse in hot deionized water, a final rinse in hot deionized water, and a forced air dry.




Referring now to

FIGS. 1 and 2

, there shown schematically a system in accordance with the present invention. A presoak tank


10


contains a semi-aqueous solution of a degreaser and softener which is maintained at an elevated temperature. A preferred degreaser/softener is terpene solution. The parts are immersed in the semi-aqueous solution for a time sufficient to loosen surface soils and to soften any coating on the tubes that contains chlorinated rubber and/or chlorinated paraffin. The presoak tank


10


has a heating loop


124


for heating and maintaining the degreasing/softening solution at the elevated temperature, preferably about 150-200° F. The heating loop


124


includes a plurality of boilers


130


, a feed line


126


, a return line


128


, and a condensate collection tank


146


.




The boilers


130


heat water into steam which travels through feed line


126


to the presoak tank


10


. A shut-off valve


132


, solenoid valve


134


, regulator valve


136


, temperature control valve


138


, and check valve


142


are provided to control and regulate the supply of steam to the presoak tank. The regulator


136


regulates the steam pressure from about 70 psi to about 30 psi. The temperature control valve


138


is provided in the feed line


126


for automatically controlling the flow of steam into the presoak tank and thereby to control the temperature of the degreaser/softener solution. A temperature bulb


140


is disposed inside the presoak tank


10


to sense the temperature of the degreasing/softening solution and is operatively connected to the temperature control valve


138


. When the temperature bulb


140


senses that the temperature of the degreasing/softening solution is above the desired temperature, it sends a signal to the control valve


138


to close, thereby prohibiting steam from entering the presoak tank


10


. When temperature bulb


140


senses that the temperature of the degreasing/softening solution is below the desired temperature, it sends an appropriate signal to the temperature control valve


138


to open, thereby allow steam to pass enter the presoak tank


10


. The heat from the steam in the feed line


126


extending in the presoak tank


10


passes to the degreasing/softening solution, thereby raising its temperature. As the heat from the steam is transferred to the degreasing/softening solution the steam condenses into water. The condensation passes through a check valve


144


, travels through the return line


128


, and is collected in a condensate collection tank


146


. The condensate in tank


146


is pumped back into the boilers


130


by a series of pumps


148


.




Identical heating loop arrangements are provided at the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


, the rough rinse tank


16


, and the final rinse tank


18


to heat the fluids used in those devices during operation of the system.




The presoak tank


10


has an overflow recirculation filtering system


11


for removing the loosened soil from the degreasing/softening solution. The overflow recirculation filtering system


11


includes an overflow tank


42


, a pump


50


, and a fine filter


54


. As the presoak tank


10


is filled with degreasing/softening solution, a catch basin


46


at the top of the presoak tank


10


will fill and begin to overflow. The overflowing degreasing/softening solution passes through a coarse filter


58


located in the overflow tank


42


. The coarse filter


58


removes the larger pieces of loosened soil from the degreasing/softening solution. The pump


50


draws the degreasing/softening solution and unfiltered loosened soil out of the overflow tank


42


and pumps it through the fine filter


54


where the remaining pieces of loosened soil are filtered out of the solution. A level switch


62


is located inside the overflow tank


42


for sensing the level of the solution in the overflow tank


42


. When the level switch


62


senses that the level of the solution is too low, it operates to turn off pump


50


to prevent cavitation and possible destruction of the pump


50


. After the degreasing/softening solution and loosened soil is passed through the fine filter


54


, the filtered solution is injected back into the presoak tank


10


.




In an alternative embodiment, a mixer


66


is provided in the overflow tank


42


for mixing a powder form of the degreaser/softener with water to form a liquid degreasing/softening solution. No mixer is required for the preferred degreaser/softener, terpene solution, because it can be purchased as a liquid.




The presoak tank


10


has an unfiltered recirculation system


70


for maintaining the homogeneity of the degreasing/softening solution and the uniformity of its temperature. A valve


80


at the bottom


74


of the presoak tank


10


is opened to drain the degreasing/softening solution from the presoak tank


10


. A recirculation pump


82


draws the solution from the bottom


74


of the presoak tank


10


and injects the solution back into the presoak tank


10


. The constant recirculation of the solution keeps the solution homogeneous and at a uniform temperature.




The ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


contains a heated sodium hydroxide based solution and is equipped with submersible ultrasonic transducers


14




a


-


14




f


which provide agitation of the sodium hydroxide based solution to assist in cleaning the parts. The ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


has an overflow recirculation filtering system


15


for removing particles of loosened soil and coating from the sodium hydroxide based solution. The overflow recirculation filter system


15


includes an overflow tank


44


, a pump


52


, and a fine filter


56


. As the cleaning tank


12


is filled with the cleaning solution, a catch basin


48


at the top of the cleaning tank


12


will fill and begin to overflow. The overflowing cleaning solution passes through a coarse filter


60


located in the overflow tank


44


. The coarse filter


60


removes the larger pieces of loosened soil and coating particles from the cleaning solution. The pump


52


draws the cleaning solution and unfiltered soil and coating particles out of the overflow tank


44


and pumps it through the fine filter


56


where the remaining pieces of loosened soil and coating are filtered out. A level switch


64


is located inside the overflow tank


44


for sensing the level of the solution in the overflow tank


44


. When the level switch


64


senses that the level of the cleaning solution is too low, it operates to turn off pump


52


to prevent cavitation and possible destruction of the pump. After the cleaning solution and loosened soil and coating particles are passed through the fine filter


56


, the filtered solution is injected back into the cleaning tank


12


.




A mixer


68


is provided in the overflow tank


44


to mix a powder with water to form the cleaning solution. The preferred sodium hydroxide based cleaning solution comes in a powder form that must be mixed with water to form a liquid cleaning solution.




The ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


has an unfiltered recirculation system


72


for maintaining the homogeneity of the sodium hydroxide based cleaning solution and the uniformity of its temperature. A valve


82


at the bottom


76


of the cleaning tank


12


is opened to drain the cleaning solution from the cleaning tank


12


. A recirculation pump


84


draws the solution from the bottom


76


of the cleaning tank


10


and injects the solution back into the cleaning tank


12


. The constant recirculation of the cleaning solution keeps the solution homogeneous and at a uniform temperature.




The application of ultrasonics for cleaning small diameter tubes in lengths of up to


30


feet or more, in bulk bundles is not standard. The problem is how to expose the interior and exterior surfaces along the entire length of the parts to the ultrasonic energy. The approach that is used in the present invention is full tank insonification. The transducers generate a homogeneous sound field encircling the transducer which creates a sufficient vibration density throughout the entire tank.




Referring now to

FIG. 3

, submersible transducers


14




a


,


14




b


,


14




c


,


14




d


,


14




e


, and


14




f


are mounted on a support pipe


88


that is removably installed inside the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


. That arrangement facilitates installation, handling, and maintenance of the transducers. The ultrasonic transducers


14




a


-


14




f


are disposed lengthwise, end-to-end in the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


on alternate sides of the support pipe


88


. Thus, transducers


14




a


,


14




c


, and


14




e


are aligned on one side of pipe


88


and transducers


14




b


,


14




d


, and


14




f


are aligned on the opposite side of the bar. Transducer supports


91


are provided for mounting the transducers


14




a


-


14




f


on the support pipe


88


.




As shown in

FIG. 6

, the transducer support


91


includes a tubular sleeve


92


and wing plates


94




a


,


94




b


. The sleeves


92


are welded at selected locations on the support pipe


88


. The wing plates


94




a


,


94




b


are welded onto opposite sides of the tubular sleeve


92


. The transducers are mounted to the wing plates


94




a


,


94




b


. Electrical cables


90


for connecting the transducers to an electrical power source are connected to the tops of the transducers by any suitable connector. The cables


90


run along the length of the support pipe


88


and extend outside of the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


.




Referring now to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, a retaining bracket


98


is affixed to the upper end of the support pipe


88


and provides a means for suspending the pipe


88


on the edge of the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


. The retaining bracket


98


includes a top plate


100


, a bottom plate


103


, two side plates


102




a


,


102




b


, a vertical support plate


104


, and an angle member


106


.




The top plate


100


of the retaining bracket


98


has a planar portion


97


, a curved portion


99


, and two tab portions


101




a


,


101




b


, one located on each side of bracket


98


. The tab portions


101




a


,


101




b


are bent at a ninety degree angle relative to the planar portion


97


of bracket


98


. Tab portion


101




b


is not shown in the drawing. The top plate


100


has an extending portion


105


that is bent at an angle relative to the planar portion


97


. The two side plates


102




a


,


102




b


are generally U-shaped and are welded to the tab portions


101




a


,


101




b


, respectively. An angle member


106


that is generally V-shaped has a notch


107


formed at one end thereof and a cutout portion


109


at its other end. The angle member


106


is welded to the support pipe


88


and to the top plate


100


. The angle member


106


acts as a stiffener for the retaining bracket


98


and stabilizes the retaining bracket


98


from twisting about the support pipe


88


.




The bottom plate


103


is generally U-shaped and is welded to the side plates


102




a


,


102




b


to form a channel therebetween with the top plate


100


. The vertical support plate


104


is bolted to the planar portion


97


of the top plate


100


with bolts


150


,


152


and divides the channel into two equal portions. The long edge of the vertical plate


104


is welded to the support pipe


88


and serves to attach the retaining bracket


98


to the support pipe


88


. A portion the vertical plate


104


passes through the notch


107


of the V-shaped angle member


106


.




The assembled retaining bracket


98


rests on the edge of the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


as shown in FIG.


5


. In order to place the cables


90


in the retaining bracket


98


, bolts


150


,


152


are loosened and the top plate


100


is removed. The cables are then placed inside the retaining bracket


98


, the top plate is put back in place, and bolts


150


,


152


are tightened. The cables


90


are divided by the vertical plate


104


inside of the retaining bracket


98


. Thus, the cables for transducers


14




a


,


14




c


, and


14




e


are placed one side the channel inside the bracket


98


and the cables for transducers


14




b


,


14




d


, and


14




f


are placed on the other side of the channel inside the retaining bracket


98


. In this manner, the cables


90


are effectively protected from damage when the retaining bracket


98


is resting on the edge of the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


. A hoisting ring


96


is provided on the end of the support pipe


88


so that the support pipe


88


can be lifted out of the tank


12


with the transducers


14




a-f


and cables


90


attached.




Referring now to

FIG. 2

, the rinsing tanks


16


and


18


are provided for rinsing the parts after the ultrasonic cleaning step. The rinsing tanks


16


and


18


contain deionized water at an elevated temperature, preferably about 150-200° F. The presoak tank


10


, ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


, and rinsing tanks


16


and


18


are constructed and dimensioned to receive a bundle of elongated tubes.




A dryer


20


includes a vessel


22


that is constructed and dimensioned to receive the bundle of elongated tubes. Dryer


20


has an opening


24


at one end and a hatch


26


associated therewith for closing off the vessel


22


after a load of tubes has been placed in the vessel. A steam inlet


28


is disposed at the opposite end of vessel


22


. The steam inlet


28


is connected to a source of deionized steam, such as boiler


30


. A damper


32


is mounted over a second opening


34


in the side of vessel


22


. Damper


32


is connected to a source of air for pneumatically operating the damper to open or close. A high velocity blower


36


, including an intake filter


38


, is mounted on a pivotable support


40


. The support


40


is constructed and located such that the blower


36


can be removably positioned over the opening


24


in vessel


22


.




Referring now to

FIG. 7

, the pivotable blower support


40


includes a swivel post


108


, a thrust bearing


110


, and a base


112


. An upper support flange


114


and a lower support flange


116


extend from the swivel post


108


for supporting a housing


118


for the blower


36


. An intake filter (not shown) is disposed inside the housing


118


. The thrust bearing


110


bears the load of the blower


36


, housing


118


, and intake filter and permits the blower


36


to be easily rotated into and out of position over the opening


24


of the drying vessel


22


.




The lower support flange


116


has a seal to prevent leakage of air between the blower


36


and the opening


24


in vessel


22


when the blower


36


is positioned over the vessel


22


. As shown in

FIG. 8

, the seal includes an inflexible metal seal


120


and a flexible seal


122


. The flexible seal


122


is disposed about the leading edge of the flange


116


so that when the blower


36


is moved into position over the opening


24


, the flexible seal


122


flexes as it passes over the lip or flange of the opening


24


. When the blower


36


is fully in place over the drying vessel


22


, the flexible seal


122


returns to its original shape to close off part of the gap between the drying vessel flange and the flange


116


. In addition to sealing the remainder of the gap between the drying vessel and the flange


116


, the inflexible metal seal


120


butts against the outside rim of the vessel


22


and, because of its rigidity, acts as a stop to prevent the pivotable support


40


from rotating further.




The following is a description of how the equipment is operated in accordance with the method of the present invention, with reference to

FIGS. 1 and 2

. A load is immersed and soaked in the presoak tank


10


containing the degreaser/softener solution for at least about 15 minutes. During the presoaking step, the degreaser/softener solution temperature is maintained at the elevated temperature. When the presoak time is complete, the load is transferred to the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


. The load is subjected to ultrasonic cleaning in the sodium hydroxide based solution for at least about 15 minutes. The overflow recirculation system


13


flushes the loosened soil and coating away and traps it in the filtering system


15


. During the ultrasonic cleaning step, the sodium hydroxide based solution is maintained at an elevated temperature of about 150-200° F. At the end of the ultrasonic cleaning step, the load is spray rinsed with hot deionized water as the load is withdrawn from the ultrasonic cleaning tank


12


. The load is then transferred into the rough rinse tank


16


.




The parts load is rough rinsed by soaking it in the heated deionized water for at least about 15 minutes. The temperature of the deionized rinse water is maintained at the elevated temperature and the tank is continuously overflowed during the rough rinse. After the rough rinse step, the load is transferred to the final rinse tank


18


. The load is given a final rinse by soaking in deionized water for at least about 15 minutes. During the final rinse, the deionized water is maintained at the elevated temperature and the tank is continuously overflowed.




After the final rinse, the load is transferred into the dryer


20


and hatch


26


is closed. Live deionized steam is injected into the dryer


20


and applied to the parts load directly. The steam heats the parts and when the parts reach the desired elevated temperature, preferably about 180° F., the steam is turned off. The damper


32


and the hatch


26


are opened. The blower


36


is swung into position over opening


22


and air is directed over the heated parts at high velocity. The heated parts flash the deionized rinse water to vapor and the high velocity air cools the parts and evacuates the water vapor through damper


32


. The application of the forced air in the drying tank is carried out for at least about 15 minutes, until the load is completely dry. The load is then checked to be sure that it is completely dry, particularly inside the tubes before it is processed further.




It will be recognized by those skilled in the art that changes or modifications may be made to the above-described embodiments without departing from the broad inventive concept of the invention. It should therefore be understood that this invention is not limited to the particular embodiments described herein but is intended to include all changes and modifications that are within the scope and spirit of the invention as set forth in the following claims.



Claims
  • 1. A method of removing a coating from the surface of an elongated metal part comprising the steps of:soaking the elongated metal part in a soaking solution contained in a soaking vessel, said soaking solution being maintained at an elevated temperature and for a time sufficient to soften the coating; immersing the elongated metal part in an aqueous cleaning solution bath at an elevated temperature, said aqueous cleaning solution bath being contained in a cleaning vessel; agitating the aqueous cleaning solution bath for a time sufficient to loosen the coating from the elongated metal part; rinsing the elongated metal part to remove any residue; and then drying the elongated metal part.
  • 2. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of agitating the aqueous cleaning solution bath comprises the step of applying ultrasonic waves to the aqueous cleaning solution bath.
  • 3. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of rinsing the elongated metal part comprises the steps of:spraying the elongated metal part as it is removed from the aqueous cleaning solution bath; and immersing the elongated metal part in a rinsing liquid that is heated to an elevated temperature, said rinsing liquid being contained in a rinsing vessel.
  • 4. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of rinsing the elongated metal part comprises the steps of:spraying the elongated metal part as it is removed from the aqueous cleaning solution bath; immersing the elongated metal part in a first rinsing liquid that is heated to a first elevated temperature said rinsing liquid being contained in a first rinsing vessel; and immersing the elongated metal part in a second rinsing liquid that is heated to a second elevated temperature, said rinsing liquid being contained in a second rinsing vessel.
  • 5. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of drying the elongated metal part comprises the steps of:placing the elongated metal part in a drying vessel; closing the drying vessel; heating the elongated metal part and rinsing liquid remaining thereon to an elevated temperature; opening the drying vessel; and blowing air through the drying vessel over the elongated metal at a velocity and volume sufficient to vaporize the rinsing liquid, whereby the elongated metal is simultaneously dried and cooled.
  • 6. A method as set forth in claim 5 wherein the step of heating the elongated metal part and residual rinsing liquid thereon comprises the step of injecting steam into the drying vessel.
  • 7. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of soaking the elongated metal part comprises the steps of:removing the soaking solution from the soaking vessel such that loosened soil and particles of the coating suspended in the soaking solution are also removed from the soaking vessel; removing the loosened soil and coating particles from the soaking solution to provide clean soaking solution; and injecting the clean soaking solution into the soaking vessel, whereby the soaking solution is recycled.
  • 8. A method as set forth in claim 7 wherein the step of removing the loosened soil and coating particles from the soaking solution comprises the steps of:transferring the soaking solution removed from the soaking vessel to a holding vessel; and passing the soaking solution from the holding tank through a filter.
  • 9. A method as set forth in claim 1 wherein the step of immersing the elongated metal part in the aqueous cleaning solution bath comprises the steps of:removing aqueous cleaning solution from the cleaning vessel whereby loosened soil and particles of the coating suspended in the cleaning solution are also removed from the cleaning vessel; removing the loosened soil and coating particles from the cleaning solution whereby purified cleaning solution is provided; and injecting the purified cleaning solution into the cleaning vessel, whereby the cleaning solution is recycled.
  • 10. A method as set forth in claim 9 wherein the step of removing the loosened soil and coating particles from the cleaning solution comprises the steps of:transferring the cleaning solution removed from the cleaning vessel to a holding vessel; and then passing the cleaning solution from the holding tank through a filter.
Parent Case Info

This application is a divisional application of Ser. No. 09/218,185 filed Dec. 22, 1998, and now Pat. No. 6,145,518, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.

US Referenced Citations (19)
Number Name Date Kind
2417468 Canziani et al. Mar 1947
2834359 Kearney May 1958
2854360 Pajes Sep 1958
3001769 Plassmeyer Sep 1961
3229702 Murdoch, Jr. Jan 1966
4089704 Heiss, Jr. et al. May 1978
4379724 Kashiwagi Apr 1983
4788992 Swainbank et al. Dec 1988
5067983 Uchino Nov 1991
5201958 Breunsbach et al. Apr 1993
5218980 Evans Jun 1993
5240506 Liers et al. Aug 1993
5378287 Pedziwiatr Jan 1995
5409594 Al-Jiboory et al. Apr 1995
5494063 Suzuki et al. Feb 1996
5501240 Dohku et al. Mar 1996
5503681 Inada et al. Apr 1996
5820693 Patchett et al. Oct 1998
5888312 Inada et al. Mar 1999