The current application relates to carrier-effect based switching cells and in particular to phase compensation of carrier-effect based switching cells.
Carrier-effect based switching cells can be used in photonic switches that are suitable for different applications. The individual switching cells of a photonic switch may use an interferometer structure, such as a Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) structure that includes a PIN, or PN structure, in one or both arms of the interferometer structure. Carrier-based switching cells can provide a compact and low power switch that provides sufficiently fast switching speeds for use in metro networks and data center applications. Although carrier-effect based switching cells may provide fast switching times, they can suffer from reduced extinction ratios. Switch matrices may include numerous optical taps to provide feedback signals used in controlling the switching cells to provide the desired, or required routing of optical signals. Incorporation of optical taps may be expensive in terms of optical power and available space.
In accordance with the present disclosure there is provided a carrier-effect switching cell comprising: an interferometer structure comprising a first arm and a second arm optically coupled between an input coupler and an output coupler; a carrier-effect region in the first arm; a first temperature sensor within close proximity to the carrier-effect region in the first arm; a second temperature sensor in close proximity to the second arm; and a phase compensator within the first arm or the second arm and capable of inducing a phase shift in an optical signal based on an electrical compensation signal determined based on a temperature difference between the first temperature sensor and the second temperature sensor.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the first temperature sensor is located within the carrier-effect region of the first arm.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the carrier-effect region comprises a carrier-injection region.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the carrier-injection comprises a PIN junction.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the phase compensator comprises a thermo-optic phase shifter.
In a further embodiment, the carrier-effect switching cell further comprises a second carrier-effect region within the second arm, wherein the second temperature sensor is located within close proximity to the second carrier-effect region.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the first temperature sensor comprises a first temperature sensing diode and the second temperature sensor comprises a second temperature sensing diode.
In a further embodiment, the carrier-effect switching cell further temperature compensation functionality capable of providing the electrical compensation signal to the phase compensator.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the temperature compensation functionality is further capable of supplying a constant current to each of the first and second temperature sensing diodes.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, the temperature compensation functionality is further capable of providing the electrical compensation signal with a temperature compensating power, Ptc, of: Ptc=kΔT; where: k is a settable gain factor; and ΔT is a temperature difference determined from the first temperature sensing diode and the second temperature sensing diode.
In a further embodiment of the carrier-effect switching cell, k is capable of being set during a calibration phase.
In a further embodiment, the carrier-effect switching cell further comprises temperature compensation functionality capable of providing the electrical compensation signal having a temperature compensating power, Ptc, of: Ptc=kΔT; where: k is a settable gain factor; and ΔT is a temperature difference determined from the first temperature sensor and the second temperature sensor.
In accordance with the present disclosure there is provided a photonic switch comprising: a plurality of optically coupled carrier-effect switching cells, each of the switching cells comprising: an interferometer structure comprising a first arm and a second arm optically coupled between an input coupler and an output coupler; a carrier-effect region in the first arm; a first temperature sensor within close proximity to the carrier-effect region in the first arm; a second temperature sensor in close proximity to the second arm; and a phase compensator within the first arm or the second arm and capable of inducing a phase shift in an optical signal based on an electrical compensation signal determined based on a temperature difference between the first temperature sensor and the second temperature sensor; routing functionality capable of providing routing signals to each of the plurality of switching cells for establishing optical paths through the plurality of switching cells; and temperature compensation functionality capable of providing electrical compensation signals to the phase compensators of each of the plurality of switching cells.
In accordance with the present disclosure there is provided a method of calibrating a plurality of temperature compensated switching cells of a switch, the method comprising: selecting one of the switching cells to calibrate; setting optical paths through the switch to optically couple an input of the selected switching cell to an input signal of the switch and an output of the selected switching cell to an optical tap of the switch; varying a gain factor k of the selected switching cell and monitoring an optical signal at the optical tap, the gain factor k applied to a temperature difference signal of the selected switching cell to generate a temperature compensation signal for the selected switching cell; setting the gain factor k for the selected switching cell to the varied gain factor k providing the highest signal at the optical tap; and calibrating a next switching cell.
In a further embodiment, the method further comprises varying an amplitude of current driving pulses of the selected switching cell while monitoring the output signal at the optical tap; setting an amplitude of the current driving pulses of the selected switching cell to a value providing the highest or the lowest optical signal.
In a further embodiment, the method further comprises enabling temperature compensation functionality of the selected switching cell.
Embodiments are described herein with references to the appended drawings, in which:
Carrier-effect based optical switches provide high speed switching of optical signals. Switching cells based on the carrier-effect, which may be either carrier injection or depletion, comprise a PIN, or PN, junction in at least one of a pair of arms of an interferometer structure, such as a Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) structure. Driving at least one PIN or PN junction can induce a relative phase shift between optical signals carried by the two arms. The relative phase shift may be used to provide switching of an optical signal between outputs. For example, if no relative phase shift is provided, the optical signal may be output at a first output of the switching cell. If a relative phase shift of π degrees is provided, the optical signal may be output at a second output of the switching cell. In another example, no relative phase may result in the optical signal being evenly split between the two outputs, and a relative phase shift of either sign may switch the optical signal to be output at the first or the second output. Although a particular phase shift, such as π degrees, may result in complete switching of the optical signal to the second output, phase shift errors may result in a reduction of the intensity of the optical signal at the output. Accordingly, phase shift errors can reduce the extinction ratio, or contrast ratio, of the switching cell, and so an optical switch built from the switching cells. The phase errors may include contributions from constant phase shift errors that may be a result of the fabrication process as well as dynamic phase shift errors that arise from the operation of the switching cell. The constant phase shift errors may be compensated for by applying a constant bias phase shift. The dynamic phase shift errors may be more complex to account for due to their dynamic nature. One possible approach is to use optical taps to monitor the outputs of each individual switching cell to provide feedback information that can be used to compensate for the dynamic phase shift errors. The optical taps may also be used in compensating the constant phase shift errors. However, placing optical taps at each output of each individual switching cell may consume valuable real estate on a photonic chip and may also reduce the optical efficiency of the switching cells since each optical tap consumes optical power. As described further herein, the dynamic phase shift error, or at least one source of the dynamic phase shift error, may be compensated for based on a temperature difference between the two arms of a switching cell.
A temperature sensing diode may be incorporated into the waveguide of each arm and used to provide a voltage signal indicative of the temperature difference between the two arms. The voltage difference signal may be used to control a phase shift compensator that induces a compensating dynamic phase shift to counteract the phase shift error induced by the temperature difference between the two arms. As described further herein, switches built using temperature-compensated switching cells may provide improved contrast ratios, as compared to un-compensated switching cells, without requiring optical taps be placed at all outputs of the individual switching cells.
Under ideal operation, a carrier-effect based optical switch generates a relative phase shift from current flowing at a carrier injection or depletion region. However, in practical devices, driving the carrier injection or depletion region generates a temperature difference between the two arms, resulting in an undesirable phase shift error. Reducing a distance between the two arms may help reduce the temperature difference between the two arms; however, it does not eliminate the temperature difference. Using current fabrication processes, a minimum gap between arms is approximately 12 μm, which can result in a temperature difference when driving the PN junction of approximately 0.9° C. Such a temperature difference between arms may provide significant optical crosstalk unless it is compensated for.
A carrier-effect based switching cell may be fabricated with a diode associated with each arm of the switching cell. The diodes may be used as temperature sensing diodes in order to provide feedback information used to compensate for the phase shift errors resulting from temperature difference across the two arms.
The individual switching cells 108 are provided by carrier-effect based switching cells. Each of the switching cell comprises a pair of arms within an interferometer structure with a carrier injection, or depletion region located within at least one of the arms. Driving the carrier-effect region induces a relative phase shift between optical signals in the pair of arms, which causes the optical signal to be output to one of two outputs of the individual switching cell. The routing functionality 110 may determine the appropriate driving signals in order to establish the desired optical paths through the individual switching cells 108. However, driving the switching cells to induce a phase shift will also generate a temperature difference between the two arms, which causes a temperature dependent phase shift between optical signals in the two arms of switching cells. As described further below, temperature sensors in each arm of the individual switching cells can detect the temperature difference and temperature compensation functionality 112 can use the determined temperature differences of the individual switching cells 108 to control phase compensators within each of the switching cells in order to compensate for a phase error induced by the temperature difference.
The switch 100, and more particularly the switch matrix 102, is depicted as having a small number of optical taps, which are represented schematically as small black boxes, 114a-114n (referred to collectively as optical taps 114). With each individual switching cell 108 being temperature-compensated, optical taps are not required at each output of each individual switching cell 108. As described further below, the optical taps 114 may be used during a calibration phase in order to calibrate the temperature dependent phase compensation for each of the switching cells 108. Although depicted as being present on the switch outputs 106, that is the outputs of the final stage of switching cells, depending upon the architecture of the switch matrix 102, as well as the calibration technique used, additional optical taps may be used on some of the outputs of the switching cells 108.
Temperature sensors, such as temperature sensing diodes 224a, 224b (referred to collectively as temperature sensors 224), or other devices, are integrated into the arms 218 of the optical switching cell 208. The temperature sensors 224 may be located in close proximity to the optical waveguides in order to detect the temperature in each arm. Further, the temperature sensors 224 may be monolithically integrated into the carrier injection region or regions 222 of the arms 218. The integrated temperature sensors 224 do not consume optical power, and as such the temperature sensors 224 may be used to provide dynamic real-time compensation to phase errors without incurring additional losses of optical power. The temperature sensors 224 are located as close to the waveguide as possible, or practical.
A temperature sensing diode may comprise a diode such as a PN junction or Schottky junction diode or diode-connected MOSFET. As conventionally understood, when a forward-bias voltage is applied to such a diode, a forward current passes through the diode according to the well-known diode equation. Conversely, if a forward current is passed through the diode, then a voltage is induced across the diode according to the inverse of the diode equation. The diode equation has a strong temperature dependency, and therefore the induced voltage at a given current depends strongly on the temperature of the diode.
The temperature sensors 224 are connected to temperature compensation functionality 214. If the temperature sensors 224 are provided by two identical, or nearly identical, temperature sensing diodes and are forward biased with a constant current, depicted as being provided by temperature independent current sources 226a, 226b, then a voltage difference 228, depicted as ΔVt, will be proportional to a temperature difference between the two diodes. With the temperature sensors 224 located in close proximity to the arms 218, the temperature difference between the temperature sensors 224 will correspond to the temperature difference between the arms 218. A compensating circuit 230 receives the voltage difference 228 ΔVt and determines an amount of power to supply to a phase compensator 234 in order to compensate for the temperature-dependent phase error. The power, Ptc, may be determined by the compensating circuit 230 according to:
P
tv
=kΔV
t (1)
The phase compensator 234 is depicted as being provided by a thermo-optic phase shifter. The thermo-optic phase shifter may be provided by a heating element located adjacent to at least one of the arms 218. The heating element may be provided by a heating resistor made from, for example, titanium nitride, a doped silicon region, or other possible alternatives. The power output by the heating element as a function of heater driving voltage may be temperature dependent, however the dependence would be small and would not need to be accounted for. The thermo optic phase shifter of the phase compensator 234 induces a phase shift that is proportional to the power Ptc. As indicated above, the power Ptc is proportional to the voltage difference ΔVt 228 between the two temperature sensors 224, which in turn is proportional to the temperature difference between the two arms 218 of the optical switching cell 208. The compensating circuit 230 may determine the current Itc or voltage Vtc to supply to the heating element in order to induce a phase shift to compensate for temperature induced phase shift errors according to the following equations, which are mutually consistent:
As described above, a temperature compensated switching cell, such as the optical switching cell 200, can provide thermal compensation to compensate for self-heating effects of integrated carrier injection, or depletion, optical switching cells. The thermal compensation may use diode based temperature measurements, made using integrated temperature sensing diodes located in each MZI arm as close as possible to the waveguide of the arm. Temperature compensation functionality can convert temperature differences at the temperature sensing diodes to a voltage difference that may be provided to an operational amplifier, or op amp 230. The output of the op amp 230 feeds an integrated heater within at least one of the MZI arms that compensates for the self-induced temperature difference and hence, counteracts the thermo-optic phase shift within the carrier injection section. The output of the op amp 230 corresponds to the voltage difference 228 from the temperature sensors 224. The op amp 230 may apply a gain factor k 232 to the voltage difference 228 from the temperature sensors 224 to generate the output. The feedback works by directly measuring the temperature difference between MZI arms and applying heater electrical power proportional to the measured temperature difference.
Although depicted as having carrier injection regions associated with each of the waveguides 318, a carrier injection region may be associated with only one of the waveguides 318. Alternatively, carrier injections regions may be associated with each of the waveguides 318 and only one of the carrier regions may be driven instead of both. That is, the temperature compensated switching cell may be a single-drive or dual drive switching cell.
Doping regions of optical switching cells have been described above. The concentrations, and dimensions of the doping regions described above are intended to be illustrative of varying the doping regions to provide a monolithically integrated temperature sensing diode. The specific concentrations and dimensions of the doping regions may vary depending upon the fabrication process. Each temperature sensor may be a simple diode with linear relation Vd=f(T) for a constant diode current Id, where:
In the above equation:
K is the Boltzmann constant;
T is an absolute temperature of the diode;
q is the electron charge;
Is is the reverse bias saturation current; and
n is a fabrication constant that is usually between 1 and 2.
From the above, two forward-biased diodes with identical size will have a voltage VD difference proportional to the temperature difference between the diodes according to:
As described above, VD may be provided to circuitry that converts the directly measured VD into an output voltage or current, that is power, that is proportional to VD. The output power feeds a resistive heater element of a thermo-optic phase shifter providing the dynamic temperature-dependent phase error compensation. The electrical power relation between the carrier injection section and the thermo-optic section may be described by
P
tc
=kΔT
Where k is defined by the carrier injection phase shifter cross-section and the thermo-optic phase shifter cross section. It is possible to calculate k, however it can be accurately obtained and validated through a calibration procedure.
The diodes may be integrated in a standard CMOS photonic fabrication process using a foundry platform with P-doped and N-doped regions. The temperature compensation functionality that provides the phase compensating power based on the temperature difference determined from temperature sensing diodes may be implemented on CMOS technology. The electrical chip and photonic chip may be monolithically integrated, or electrically connected using flip-chip bonding or bonding wires. The temperature compensation functionality may be provided by a programmable gain amplifier or an ADC-based digital feedback.
The temperature compensated optical switching cell described above can provide real-time phase compensation for temperature dependent phase errors. The temperature difference that needs to be compensated for may be determined using monolithically integrated temperature sensing diodes. Although the performance of the temperature sensing diodes may change as the diodes age, it may not be necessary to calibrate for aging effect. The diodes are lateral bipolar silicon diodes, and may be manufactured in a high quality silicon bipolar production line, which will reduce an amount of aging. Further, any aging that may occur will likely be equal in the two diodes since the diodes are very close to each other on the same die. It is necessary to calibrate k where P=kΔT. P is the electrical power that drives the thermo-optic heater to compensate for optical phase shifts due to ΔT, where ΔT is the measured temperature difference between the carrier injection arms. The process for calibrating an individual temperature compensated switching cell is to disable the temperature-based phase compensation and drive the switching cell with short current pulses through the carrier injection drive current. The length of each pulse may be for example approximately 100 ns and is selected to be long compared to the carrier injection characteristic time, which is in the order of a few ns, and short compared to the thermal compensator's time, which is in the order of a few μs. The amplitude of the short current pulse train is varied in order to maximize an output signal. Using the drive current that provided the maximum output signal, the temperature based phase compensation is enabled and the value of k varied to maximize the output.
The method 600 may be performed by functionality implemented in a controller, such as the temperature compensation functionality. The method 600 begins with selecting a switching cell in a switch matrix, such as switch matrix 102, to calibrate (602). Once the switching cell to calibrate is selected, light paths are established (604) through other switching cells, from an input of the switch matrix to the selected switching cell, and from an output of the selected switching cell when the switching cell is in a state associated with the largest temperature difference, for example the cross state to an optical tap in the switch matrix, such as one of the optical taps 114. The temperature compensation is disabled (606), and the drive current is varied with short pulses in order to determine the drive current that maximizes the output of the optical signal detected by the optical tap (608). Once the drive current is determined that maximizes the optical output, the drive current is set to the determined maximizing drive current (610) and the temperature compensation for the selected switching cell may be enabled (612). With the temperature compensation enabled and the switching cell driven by the static drive current determined to maximize the optical output, the value of a gain factor k, which is applied to the difference signal from the temperature sensors. is adjusted in order to maximize the output of the optical signal detected by the optical tap and the maximum value of k is set in the selected switching cell (614). With the individual switching cell calibrated, calibration proceeds to a next switching cell (616).
The method 600 assumes that the drive current of the switching cells has not been set and as such calibrates the initial drive current with the temperature compensation disabled (606-612). However, it is possible to calibrate the temperature compensation of the individual switching cells without having to calibrate the drive current at the same time. For example, the drive current of the switching cells may be calibrated and the temperature compensation can be calibrated separately.
The present disclosure provided, for the purposes of explanation, numerous specific embodiments, implementations, examples and details in order to provide a thorough understanding of the invention. It is apparent, however, that the embodiments may be practiced without all of the specific details or with an equivalent arrangement. In other instances, some well-known structures and devices are shown in block diagram form, or omitted, in order to avoid unnecessarily obscuring the embodiments of the invention. The description should in no way be limited to the illustrative implementations, drawings, and techniques illustrated, including the exemplary designs and implementations illustrated and described herein, but may be modified within the scope of the appended claims along with their full scope of equivalents.
While several embodiments have been provided in the present disclosure, it should be understood that the disclosed systems and components might be embodied in many other specific forms without departing from the spirit or scope of the present disclosure. The present examples are to be considered as illustrative and not restrictive, and the intention is not to be limited to the details given herein. For example, the various elements or components may be combined or integrated in another system or certain features may be omitted, or not implemented.