The present invention relates to ablation catheters, and in particular to ablation catheters with optical monitoring of tissue.
For certain types of minimally invasive medical procedures, real time information regarding the condition of the treatment site within the body is unavailable. This lack of information inhibits the clinician when employing catheter to perform a procedure. An example of such procedures is tumor and disease treatment in the liver and prostate. Yet another example of such a procedure is surgical ablation used to treat atrial fibrillation. This condition in the heart causes abnormal electrical signals, known as cardiac arrhythmias, to be generated in the endocardial tissue resulting in irregular beating of the heart.
The most frequent cause of cardiac arrhythmias is an abnormal routing of electricity through the cardiac tissue. In general, most arrhythmias are treated by ablating suspected centers of this electrical misfiring, thereby causing these centers to become inactive. Successful treatment, then, depends on the location of the ablation within the heart as well as the lesion itself. For example, when treating atrial fibrillation, an ablation catheter is maneuvered into the right or left atrium where it is used to create ablation lesions in the heart. These lesions are intended to stop the irregular beating of the heart by creating non-conductive barriers between regions of the atria that halt passage through the heart of the abnormal electrical activity.
The lesion should be created such that electrical conductivity is halted in the localized region (transmurality), but care should be taken to prevent ablating adjacent tissues. Furthermore, the ablation process can also cause undesirable charring of the tissue and localized coagulation, and can evaporate water in the blood and tissue leading to steam pops.
Currently, lesions are evaluated following the ablation procedure, by positioning a mapping catheter in the heart where it is used to measure the electrical activity within the atria. This permits the physician to evaluate the newly formed lesions and determine whether they will function to halt conductivity. It if is determined that the lesions were not adequately formed, then additional lesions can be created to further form a line of block against passage of abnormal currents. Clearly, post ablation evaluation is undesirable since correction requires additional medical procedures. Thus, it would be more desirable to evaluate the lesion as it is being formed in the tissue.
A known method for evaluating lesions as they are formed is to measure electrical impedance. Biochemical differences between ablated and normal tissue can result in changes in electrical impedance between the tissue types. Although impedance is routinely monitored during electrophysiologic therapy, it is not directly related to lesion formation. Measuring impedance merely provides data as to the location of the tissue lesion but does not give qualitative data to evaluate the effectiveness of the lesion.
Another approach is to measure the electrical conductance between two points of tissue. This process, known as lesion pacing, can also determine the effectiveness of lesion therapy. This technique, however, measures the success or lack thereof from each lesion, and yields no real-time information about the lesion formation.
Thus, there is a need for a catheter capable of measuring lesion formation in real-time, if not monitoring tissue in general. Because a catheter may assume various orientation angles at the ablation site, there is a further need for a catheter that is capable of such measuring and detecting whether the catheter is parallel, perpendicular or at an angle to the tissue. Moreover, where such measuring and detecting are accomplished through optical spectroscopy, there is a need for a catheter that can provide separate optical paths for light illuminating the tissue and for light recaptured from the tissue.
The present invention is directed to a catheter that enables real-time light measurements, for example, without limitation, diffuse reflectance, fluorescence, etc., from biological materials, such as tissue (including blood), while performing RF ablation. The catheter tip design isolates illumination and collection paths such that light exits the catheter tip and travels through the tissue of interest (e.g., cardiac tissue or blood) before returning to the catheter tip. Such a design advantageously avoids specular reflection and saturation of the optical detector, and ensures diffusion of the illumination light within the medium of interest.
The light recaptured by the catheter from the tissue conveys tissue parameters that can be evaluated using spectroscopic methods. These parameters include, without limitation, lesion formation, depth of penetration of lesion, and cross-sectional area of lesion, formation of char during ablation, recognition of char during ablation, recognition of char from non-charred tissue, formation of coagulum around the ablation site, differentiation of coagulated from non-coagulated blood, differentiation of ablated from healthy tissue, tissue proximity, evaluation of tissue health, status, and disease state, and recognition of steam formation in the tissue for prevention of steam pop.
In accordance with the present invention, the catheter has a catheter body and a tip section adapted for ablating tissue, the tip section providing separate optical paths for light illuminating the tissue and light recaptured from the tissue. In one embodiment, a tip electrode has a shell defining a hollow cavity, where the shell has in its wall illumination openings to pass light onto the tissue and collection openings to recapture light from the tissue in the hollow cavity. The optical path for light illuminating the tissue includes passage through an optically diffuse material in the tip section and through the illumination openings. The optical path for light recaptured from the tissue includes passage through the collection openings and collection in the hollow cavity. An opaque coating lining the hollow cavity separates the optically diffuse material and the hollow cavity and therefore the two optical paths from each other. Moreover, the catheter may be adapted with irrigation for flushing the collection openings with fluid, such as saline or other biocompatible fluid. Fiber optic cable(s) extend into the tip section to illuminate the optically diffuse material. Other fiber optic cable(s) extend into the tip section to receive the light recaptured in the hollow cavity.
In a more detailed embodiment, a catheter adapted to ablate tissue has a catheter body and a tip electrode adapted for ablating tissue. The tip electrode has an exterior shell, an inner layer of diffuse material and a hollow cavity, wherein the inner layer is configured to transmit light outside the tip electrode to a tissue via illumination openings in the shell wall, and the hollow cavity is configured to receive light from the tissue via collection openings in the shell wall and the inner layer. An inner surface of the inner layer has an opaque coating to isolate light injected into the inner layer from light collected in the hollow cavity. At least one optical waveguide extends between the catheter body and the tip electrode to inject light into the inner layer to provide the tip electrode with light to illuminate the tissue. To that end, the inner layer of diffuse material may have projections that extend into the illumination openings in the shell wall to facilitate transmission of the light to outside the tip electrode. At least another optical waveguide extends between the catheter body and the tip electrode to collect the light from the tissue recaptured in the hollow cavity.
As an omnidirectional illuminator and collector, the tip electrode has a distal portion defining a first section that is generally perpendicular to a longitudinal axis of the tip electrode, a second section that is at an angle between about 30 and 60 degrees with the longitudinal axis, and a third section that is generally parallel with the longitudinal axis. The illumination openings are configured in the second section and in the third section but may also be present in the first section. The collection openings are configured in the first and third sections but may also be present in the second section. The catheter may have a deflectable intermediate section between the catheter body and the tip electrode. It may also carry a temperature sensor and a location sensor in the tip section.
The present invention is also directed to a method of making an ablation tip electrode that also functions as an omnidirectional illuminator and collector. The method includes providing a shell having a wall that defines an open proximal end and a generally dome shape distal end, configuring illumination openings through the shell wall, filling the shell with a moldable or injectable diffuse material, configuring a hollow cavity at the distal end of the shell, and configuring collection openings through the shell wall and the moldable diffuse material and into the hollow cavity. The method includes providing an optical barrier between the moldable plastic material and the hollow cavity, inserting a fiber optic cable into the moldable diffuse material to provide light to the tip electrode, and inserting a fiber optic cable into the hollow cavity to receive recaptured light in the hollow cavity.
The method further includes providing a plug to seal the hollow cavity, and configuring the plug with passages for the fiber optic cables. The portions of the fiber optic cables in the passages may be fixedly secured within the passages by glue, adhesive or the like, to stabilize the fiber optic cables and reduce the risk of breakage or detachment.
The present catheter and method are designed to use light in conjunction with irrigation and the technology of RF ablation. Advantageously, the light used to monitor and assess the tissue (or a lesion formed in the tissue) is generally not affected by the portion of the electromagnetic radiation used for ablation. Moreover, the bandwidth used for monitoring and assessing also transmits through blood with minimal attenuations. The fiber optics are used and disposed in the catheter in a manner that avoids contact with tissue, which can increase the operative lifetime of the catheter and minimize damages caused by abrasion to the fiber optics. Furthermore, the alignment plug in the tip electrode secures the fiber optic cables with minimal bend or strain but increased angular coverage, which can minimize fiber optics breakage during assembly and use, as well as reduce nonlinear optical effects caused by orientation of the fiber optics. In addition, the use of fiber optics to emit and receive light is a generally temperature neutral process that adds little if any measurable heat to surrounding blood or tissue.
These and other features and advantages of the present invention will be better understood by reference to the following detailed description when considered in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein:
a is an exploded side elevational view of an embodiment of a tip electrode and a plug.
b is a cross sectional view of an embodiment of an assembled tip electrode with a plug and an internal fixture member.
c is a perspective view of an embodiment of an internal fixture member.
As shown in
With additional reference to
Extending through the single lumen 18 of the catheter body 12 are components, for example, lead wire 40 and thermocouple wires 41, 45 protected by a sheath 52, fiber optic cables 43, a first irrigation tube segment 88, a compression coil 56 through which a puller wire 42 extends, and an electromagnetic sensor cable 74. A single lumen catheter body can be preferred over a multi-lumen body because it has been found that the single lumen body permits better tip control when rotating the catheter. The single lumen permits the various components such as the lead wire, thermocouple wires, infusion tube, and the puller wire surrounded by the compression coil to float freely within the catheter body. If such wires, tube and cables were restricted within multiple lumens, they tend to build up energy when the handle is rotated, resulting in the catheter body having a tendency to rotate back if, for example, the handle is released, or if bent around a curve, to flip over, either of which are undesirable performance characteristics.
The outer diameter of the catheter body 12 is not critical, but is preferably no more than about 8 french, more preferably 7 french. Likewise the thickness of the outer wall 22 is not critical, but is thin enough so that the central lumen 18 can accommodate the aforementioned components. The inner surface of the outer wall 22 may be lined with a stiffening tube 20, which can be made of any suitable material, such as polyimide or nylon. The stiffening tube 20, along with the braided outer wall 22, provides improved torsional stability while at the same time minimizing the wall thickness of the catheter, thus maximizing the diameter of the central lumen 18. The outer diameter of the stiffening tube 20 is about the same as or slightly smaller than the inner diameter of the outer wall 22. Polyimide tubing may be preferred for the stiffening tube 20 because it may be very thin walled while still providing very good stiffness. This maximizes the diameter of the central lumen 18 without sacrificing strength and stiffness.
The catheter may have an outer wall 22 with an outer diameter of from about 0.090 inch to about 0.104 inch and an inner diameter of from about 0.061 inch to about 0.075 inch and a polyimide stiffening tube 20 having an outer diameter of from about 0.060 inch to about 0.074 inch and a wall thickness of about 0.001-0.005 inch.
Referring also to
Referring to
If desired, a spacer can be located within the catheter body between the distal end of the stiffening tube and the proximal end of the tip section. The spacer provides a transition in flexibility at the junction of the catheter body and intermediate section, which allows this junction to bend smoothly without folding or kinking. A catheter having such a spacer is described in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/924,616, entitled “Steerable Direct Myocardial Revascularization Catheter”, the entire disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.
Extending from the distal end of the intermediate section 14 is the tip section 36 that includes a tip electrode 37 and a plastic housing 21 as shown in
The tip electrode 37 has an open proximal end that is in communication with a generally hollow distal portion or cavity 49, and is of a three-piece construction. The tip electrode comprises an outer shell 38 (
With reference to
With reference to
The inner layer 39 is also configured to minimize obstruction to the optical collecting function of the tip electrode. To that end, the collection openings 87 of the shell wall extend through the inner layer 39 so there is communication between outside the tip electrode and the hollow cavity 49. Moreover, the inner surface 91 can provide a rim region 93 that circumscribes a generally conical/parabolic distal portion 92 of the hollow cavity 49 which optimizes diffusion of light injected into the inner layer 39 and optimizes the amount of light received in the hollow cavity 49 from outside the tip electrode 37.
The hollow cavity 49 is physically and optically separated from the inner layer 39 by a an opaque barrier. In the disclosed embodiment, the hollow cavity 49 is defined by inner surface 91 of the inner layer 39 which is coated with a layer of opaque material 103, for example, gold, to keep light in the inner layer 39 from entering the hollow cavity 49 (and vice versa).
In accordance with the invention, the tip electrode 37 has multiple sections relative to its longitudinal axis 99, as shown in
Each section can have any number of illumination and/or collection openings as desired or appropriate. In the illustrated embodiment, the distal section 100 has a collection opening 87 at the distal end of the tip electrode along its longitudinal axis 99. The mid-section 102 has three illumination openings 89 that are equi-angular from each other at about 120 degrees about the axis. The proximal section 104 has six more collection openings 87 that are equi-angular from each other at about 60 degrees about the axis. Three alternating of these six collection openings 87 are generally in radial alignment with the three recesses 94 in the rim section 93 and the other three alternating are generally in radial alignment with the illumination openings 89 in the mid-section 102. Also in the proximal section 104 proximal the collection openings 87 are another six illumination openings 89 that are equi-angular from each other at about 60 degrees about the axis. These illumination openings 89 are offset from the six collection openings 87 in the proximal section 104.
Formed of the same or comparable material as the shell 38, the plug 44 has a generally elongated cylindrical configuration having a predetermined length and a generally circular cross-section. A distal portion of the plug 44 is press fitted into the open proximal end of the tip electrode 37 to seal the hollow cavity 49, while a proximal portion of the plug 44 extends proximally from the tip electrode 37 for attachment to the housing 21. The distal portion of the plug 44 may also be slip fitted and sealed with solder. As shown in
In accordance with a feature of the present invention, the catheter 10 is adapted to facilitate optically-based real-time assessment of ablation tissue characteristics, including without limitation, lesion formation, depth of penetration of the lesion, cross-sectional area of the lesion, formation of char during ablation, recognition of char during ablation, differentiation of char from non-charred tissue, formation of coagulum around the ablation site, differentiation of coagulated from non-coagulated blood, differentiation of ablated from healthy tissue, tissue proximity, and recognition of steam formation in the tissue for prevention of steam pop. These assessments are accomplished by measuring the light intensity at one or more wavelengths that is recaptured at the catheter resulting from the light radiated from the catheter tip onto ablated tissue. In that regard, the catheter has fiber optic cables 43 extending into the tip electrode 37 to transmit light to the tip electrode and to collect light recaptured from the tissue.
The fiber optic cables 43 are protectively housed in the catheter from the control handle 16 to the tip section 36. As shown in
In the disclosed embodiment, there are three cables 43E and one cable 43R. The cables 43E function as a light emitters by transmitting light to the tip electrode 37 from a remote light source. The cable 43R functions as a light receiver by collecting light from the hollow cavity 49 in the tip electrode 37. It is understood by one of ordinary skill in the art that optical waveguides and fiber optic cables in general serve to transmit optical energy from one end to the other, although these are not exclusive.
The emitting fiber optic cables 43E have their distal ends received and fixed in the recesses 94 of the inner layer 39. As such, light from the cables is injected into the inner layer 39 which diffuses the light throughout the inner layer 39, including the projections 95 which in turn transmit light out the openings 89 of the tip electrode 37 and onto tissue of interest 111, as shown in
As lesion 113 forms in the tissue 111 from ablation carried out by tip electrode 37 of the catheter 10 (or by another catheter), its characteristics are altered as understood by one of ordinary skill in the art. In particular, as the lesion is radiated by light, the light is scattered and/or reflected back toward the tip electrode 37, where such light having interacted or otherwise having been affected by the lesion bears qualitative and quantitative information about the lesion 113 as it is recaptured by the hollow cavity 49 via the collection openings 87 of the tip electrode.
Within the hollow cavity 49, the opaque coating 103 lining the inner surface 91 of the inner layer 39 prevents the light from entering the inner layer 39. With its distal end inserted into the hollow cavity, the receiving fiber optic cable 43R collects the recaptured light which bears the qualitative and quantitative information and is transmitted to an optical processing system, as described below in further detail. The conical distal portion 92 of the hollow cavity 49 helps direct light entering the hollow cavity from the distal end of the tip electrode and optimizes the collection of light by the fiber optic cable 43R.
In accordance with the present invention, the tip electrode 37 provides separate optical paths for the light that illuminates tissue and the light recaptured from the tissue. The optical path from the tip electrode to the tissue begins with light that is injected into the inner layer 39 which is diffusely scattered throughout the layer 39 into multiple angles and directions and into the projections 95 that extend into the illumination openings 89 of the tip electrode 37. Exiting the tip electrode 37 from the illumination openings 89, the light is incidental on the tissue of interest, interacts with the tissue and is reflected or scattered back to the tip electrode from the tissue. The separate optical path from the tissue back to the tip electrode begins with entry through the collection openings 87 and then collection in the hollow cavity 49. The optical barrier in the form of the opaque coating 103 between the inner layer 39 and the hollow cavity 49 helps avoid saturation of the fiber optic cable 43R, and to ensure diffusion of the illumination light within the tissue.
As described earlier, the variously-angled sections 100, 102 and 104 of the tip electrode 37 enables radiation and collection of lesion optical data at a variety of angles between the tip electrode and the tissue surface. Each emission and collection openings 89 and 87 in the shell 38 defines an optical cone of radiation, the combinations of which envelope the tip electrode. Accordingly, illumination and recapture of light by the fiber optic cables are possible for a most angles between the tissue and the tip electrode. In accordance with a feature of the present invention, the tip section 36 serves as a generally omni-directional optical radiator and collector. The tip electrode may assume a nearly perpendicular angle with the tissue surface (
It is understood that the fiber optic cables 43E and 43R may be any suitable optical wave guide wherein light introduced at one of the cable is guided to the other end of the cable with minimal loss. Each of the cables 43E and 43R may be a single fiber optic cable or fiber bundles. They may be single mode (also known as mono-mode or uni-mode), multi-mode (with step index or graded index) or plastic optical fiber (POF), depending on a variety of factors, including but not limited to transmission rate, bandwidth of transmission, spectral width of transmission, distance of transmission, diameter of cable, cost, optical signal distortion tolerance and signal attenuation, etc. Moreover, light delivery and collection may be accomplished with other devices, such as air-core fibers, hollow waveguides, liquid waveguides and the like.
To keep the collection openings 87 of the tip electrode 37 generally free from obstruction from blood or other bodily fluids and tissue encountered by the tip electrode 37, the tip electrode is irrigated with fluid, e.g., saline, that is fed into the hollow cavity by an irrigation tube segment 48, as shown in
In accordance with a feature of the present invention, the pump maintains the fluid at a positive pressure differential relative to outside the hollow cavity 49 so as to provide a constant unimpeded flow or seepage of fluid outwardly from the hollow cavity 49 which continuously flushes the collection openings 87 and minimizes obstruction so light can freely pass through for the aforementioned light collection purposes. In addition to the above, the irrigation adaptation of the catheter 10 may serve other typical functions such as cooling the tip electrode and/or the ablation site and increasing conduction for deeper and larger lesions.
Included in the present invention is a method for manufacturing the shell 38 and inner layer 39. The method includes providing a rod of a suitable diameter and length, constructed of a suitable material that is thermally and electrically conductive which allows for radio frequency ablation using an RF generator. Such suitable material may include, without limitation, platinum-irridium, platinum, gold alloy, or palladium alloy. To form the shell 38, the distal end of the rod is turned (lathed) to form the dome shape and the interior is drilled from the proximal end. The hollow dome shell can also be formed from a flat plate which can provide a more even and smoother reflection surface with less machining and material waste. The openings 89 are drilled in the shell 38. The openings 87 may also be drilled in the shell 38. To form the inner layer 39, a moldable plastic material compounded with optical scattering material is injected or otherwise placed into the shell 38 to fill the interior of the shell and until the moldable plastic material fills and perhaps extrudes from the openings 89 in the shell 38. After the moldable plastic material sufficiently hardens, it is drilled from the proximal end of the tip electrode to form the hollow cavity 49. Alternatively, the hollow cavity shape can be incorporated into the mold so no post drilling would be needed. Smaller drill bit(s) may be used to form the distal end 92 of the cavity 49 and/or the recesses 94 in the rim region. From the exterior of the tip electrode, collection openings 87 are drilled and/or extended through the inner layer 39 and into the hollow cavity. The coating 103 made of any suitable biocompatible material is applied to the inner surface 91 of the inner layer 39 after the formation of the hollow cavity 49 with its distal end 92, but the coating may be applied before or after the formation of the recesses 94 if the recesses are masked off. If appropriate, hardened moldable plastic material extruding from openings 89 in the shell may be milled or sanded down to be flush with the outer surface of the shell 38.
To form the plug, a rod of the aforementioned suitable material with a suitable diameter and length is provided. The passages 108, 110, 112, 114 and 116 for the fiber optic cables are drilled. The plug is press-fitted or soldered around the periphery into the proximal opening of the tip electrode, but preferably after the fiber optic cables are inserted into the passages and received in the recesses 94 in the inner layer 39 of the tip electrode. The plug is in electrical contact with the shell 38. Glue, adhesive or the like is injected into the passages to fix the portions of the fiber optic cables extending through the passages. These fixed portions are intended to hold distal portions of the fiber optic cables stationary within the tip electrode as a measure against breakage in or detachment from the tip electrode.
A shell 38 of the tip electrode may have an actual length, i.e., from its distal end to its proximal end, between about 2.5 mm to about 8 mm. A plug 44 of the tip electrode may have an actual length, i.e., from its distal end to its proximal end, between about 1.5 mm to about 4.0 mm. The tip electrode as a combination of the shell and the plug may have an actual length, i.e., from its distal end to its proximal end, between about 3.5 mm to about 11.0 mm. Preferably the tip electrode 37 has a diameter about the same as the outer diameter of the tubing 19 of the intermediate section 14. As shown in
To energize the tip electrode 37 for RF ablation, a lead wire 40 is anchored in the plug 44. With reference to
A temperature sensing means is provided for the tip electrode 37 in the disclosed embodiment. Any conventional temperature sensing means, e.g., a thermocouple or thermistor, may be used. With reference to
Referring to
As shown in
With reference to
In the illustrated embodiment, the tip section 36 carries an electromagnetic sensor 72, and as mentioned, the electromagnetic sensor may be carried in the plastic housing 21, with its distal end anchored in the blind hole 106 in the plug 44 as shown in
As illustrated in
With reference to
The quantification apparatus 140 translates measured light intensities into an electrical signal that can be processed with a computer 142 and displayed graphically to an operator of the catheter 10. The quantification apparatus 140 may comprise a charged coupled device (CCD) for simultaneous detection and quantification of these light intensities. Alternatively, a number of different light sensors, including photodiodes, photomultipliers or complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) detectors may be used in place of the CCD converter. Information is transmitted from the quantification device 140 to the computer 142 where a graphical display or other information is generated regarding parameters of the lesion.
The preceding description has been presented with reference to presently preferred embodiments of the invention. Workers skilled in the art and technology to which this invention pertains will appreciate that alterations and changes in the described structure may be practiced without meaningfully departing from the principal, spirit and scope of this invention.
Accordingly, the foregoing description should not be read as pertaining only to the precise structures described and illustrated in the accompanying drawings, but rather should be read consistent with and as support to the following claims which are to have their fullest and fair scope.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
1791794 | Chesney | Feb 1931 | A |
4469098 | Davi | Sep 1984 | A |
4587972 | Morantte, Jr. | May 1986 | A |
4669098 | Boatwright | May 1987 | A |
4669467 | Willett et al. | Jun 1987 | A |
4672961 | Davies | Jun 1987 | A |
4736743 | Daikuzono | Apr 1988 | A |
4819632 | Davies | Apr 1989 | A |
4860743 | Abela | Aug 1989 | A |
5041109 | Abela | Aug 1991 | A |
5061265 | Abela et al. | Oct 1991 | A |
5147348 | Leckrone et al. | Sep 1992 | A |
5151096 | Khoury | Sep 1992 | A |
5248311 | Black et al. | Sep 1993 | A |
5267996 | Fletcher | Dec 1993 | A |
5370608 | Sahota et al. | Dec 1994 | A |
5370640 | Kolff | Dec 1994 | A |
5391199 | Ben-Haim | Feb 1995 | A |
5443489 | Ben-Haim | Aug 1995 | A |
5480422 | Ben-Haim | Jan 1996 | A |
5546951 | Ben-Haim | Aug 1996 | A |
5558091 | Acker et al. | Sep 1996 | A |
5568809 | Ben-haim | Oct 1996 | A |
5630809 | Connor | May 1997 | A |
5643253 | Baxter et al. | Jul 1997 | A |
5688264 | Ren et al. | Nov 1997 | A |
5693043 | Kittrell et al. | Dec 1997 | A |
5807248 | Mills | Sep 1998 | A |
5807389 | Gardetto et al. | Sep 1998 | A |
5830209 | Savage et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
5861020 | Schwarzmaier | Jan 1999 | A |
5964757 | Ponzi | Oct 1999 | A |
5997571 | Farr et al. | Dec 1999 | A |
6016452 | Kasevich | Jan 2000 | A |
6053912 | Panescu et al. | Apr 2000 | A |
6071302 | Sinofsky et al. | Jun 2000 | A |
6106516 | Massengill | Aug 2000 | A |
6120476 | Fung et al. | Sep 2000 | A |
6143018 | Beuthan et al. | Nov 2000 | A |
6168594 | LaFontaine et al. | Jan 2001 | B1 |
6171275 | Webster, Jr. | Jan 2001 | B1 |
6171303 | Ben-Haim et al. | Jan 2001 | B1 |
6241666 | Pomeranz et al. | Jun 2001 | B1 |
6423055 | Farr et al. | Jul 2002 | B1 |
6464694 | Massengill | Oct 2002 | B1 |
6468260 | Bumbalough et al. | Oct 2002 | B1 |
6579285 | Sinofsky | Jun 2003 | B2 |
6602242 | Fung et al. | Aug 2003 | B1 |
6692486 | Jaafar et al. | Feb 2004 | B2 |
6736808 | Motamedi et al. | May 2004 | B1 |
6923805 | LaFontaine et al. | Aug 2005 | B1 |
6953457 | Farr et al. | Oct 2005 | B2 |
20010012429 | Wach et al. | Aug 2001 | A1 |
20020022834 | Simpson et al. | Feb 2002 | A1 |
20020026188 | Balbierz et al. | Feb 2002 | A1 |
20020045848 | Jaafar et al. | Apr 2002 | A1 |
20020183729 | Farr et al. | Dec 2002 | A1 |
20030004506 | Messing | Jan 2003 | A1 |
20030040657 | Yamaya | Feb 2003 | A1 |
20030125730 | Berube et al. | Jul 2003 | A1 |
20040015061 | Currier et al. | Jan 2004 | A1 |
20040015138 | Currier et al. | Jan 2004 | A1 |
20040158302 | Chornenky et al. | Aug 2004 | A1 |
20050059962 | Phan et al. | Mar 2005 | A1 |
20050065504 | Melsky et al. | Mar 2005 | A1 |
20050070894 | McClurken | Mar 2005 | A1 |
20050096643 | Brucker et al. | May 2005 | A1 |
20050143721 | Brucker et al. | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20050143722 | Brucker et al. | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20050159734 | Brucker et al. | Jul 2005 | A1 |
20050165462 | Bays et al. | Jul 2005 | A1 |
20050171520 | Farr et al. | Aug 2005 | A1 |
20050222557 | Baxter et al. | Oct 2005 | A1 |
20050267452 | Farr et al. | Dec 2005 | A1 |
20060122587 | Sharareh | Jun 2006 | A1 |
20060184165 | Webster, Jr. et al. | Aug 2006 | A1 |
20070287998 | Sharareh et al. | Dec 2007 | A1 |
20080097220 | Lieber et al. | Apr 2008 | A1 |
20080119694 | Lee | May 2008 | A1 |
20080154257 | Sharareh et al. | Jun 2008 | A1 |
20090005768 | Sharareh et al. | Jan 2009 | A1 |
20090005773 | Beeckler et al. | Jan 2009 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
0 441 040 | Aug 1991 | EP |
0 195 375 | Sep 1999 | EP |
WO 9502995 | Feb 1995 | WO |
WO 2007127228 | Nov 2007 | WO |
WO 2007146995 | Dec 2007 | WO |
Entry |
---|
European Patent Search Report of European Patent Application EP 08 25 3725 dated Apr. 22, 2009. |
U.S. Appl. No. 11/281,853, filed Nov. 17, 2005, Sharareh et al. |
International Search Report of the International Searching Authority, International Application No. PCT/US2007/071107, mailed Nov. 19, 2007, 5 pgs. |
Extended European Search Report dated Jun. 16, 2010 for EP Patent Application No. 10075155.1 (3 pages). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20090131931 A1 | May 2009 | US |