This invention pertains to rare earth-iron-boron permanent magnets. More specifically, this invention pertains to cerium-iron-boron permanent magnets.
Melt-spun neodymium-iron-boron magnets were invented and commercialized by General Motors researchers in the early 1980s. The hard magnetic properties stem from the anisotropic crystal structure of the Nd2Fe14B compound, when melt quenched into a nanocrystalline microstructure together with a small amount of Nd-rich grain boundary phase. At that time the magnetic properties of melt-spun Ce—Fe—B were briefly explored, specifically at the same composition yielding optimum Nd—Fe—B material. However, owing to the superior magnetic properties of Nd—Fe—B, work was then directed to the neodymium-containing compositions. Rare earth-iron-boron magnets based on the ternary phase Nd2Fe14B remain today the best permanent magnets with energy products that can exceed 50 MGOe.
Renewed interest in Ce—Fe—B magnet materials has been stimulated by recent developments in rare earth supply and price. Nd is expensive, and furthermore Nd—Fe—B magnets are often modified with other rare earth additives such as Pr, Dy, Tb, or mixtures thereof, that enhance the magnetic properties. However, Pr, Dy, and Tb are also expensive, plus Dy and Tb constitute only a very small portion (˜2%) of a typical rare earth containing ore. Recently concerns have arisen about the future cost and availability of rare earths, particularly Nd, Pr, Dy, and Tb.
Samarium-cobalt permanent magnets have high energy product, but samarium is very expensive, and cobalt is more expensive than iron.
Ferrite magnets are inexpensive, but have limited magnetic properties.
Permanent magnets are used in electric motors, especially traction motors, and generators. Consequently there is an arising need for an alternative R—Fe—B magnet material based on the less expensive, more available rare earth Ce, while still retaining acceptable permanent magnet qualities.
Early studies of melt-spun Ce—Fe—B ribbon materials produced annealed permanent magnet compositions with remanence values, Br, of only 3.4 kG, and coercivity values of Hci=2.5 kOe. In accordance with practices of this invention, magnetic properties of compositions of the Ce—Fe—B system have been improved to achieve Br of about 5.3 kG and Hci of up to 7.1 kOe (but not necessarily both values in a specific Ce—Fe—B composition). Many melt-spun and annealed Ce—Fe—B compositions have been produced in selected molar proportions yielding permanent magnets with coercivity values (Hci, in kOe) and remanence values (Br, in kG) where the sums of the numerical values of Hci and Br are equal to 8 or greater. And in many rapidly-solidified and annealed compositions the sums of the Hci and Br values exceed 9.
In many instances the data presented in this specification are refined with respect to the data presented in the above-identified provisional application. Also, the compositions of the magnetic materials are presented in this specification as CeaFebBc, where a, b, and c are molar values totaling 100. This format is preferred for easy recognition. Compositional formulas were presented in the provisional application in a slightly different format, but the formulas in the provisional specification are readily converted to the compositional format used in this specification.
In our provisional application, it was disclosed that compositions of CeaFebBc, where a, b, and c are mole fractions totaling 1 and having values 0.10<a<0.33, 0.44<b<0.82, and 0<c<0.44, were prepared having permanent magnet properties that are higher than previously obtained with Ce—Fe—B compositions. As the data has been refined, it has been determined that CeaFebBc compositions are preferred where 13.0≦a≦26.8, 70.0≦b≦81.5, 3.2≦c≦12.0, and the values of a, b, and c total 100. Further, such compositions are selected so that they may be processed to produce coercivity and remanence values as specified above in this specification. Magnetic data for representative preferred Ce—Fe—B permanent magnet compositions are found in Tables I and II of this specification.
These materials are initially prepared as a melt, protected under a non-oxidizing atmosphere. In one practice of the invention the melt is quenched or otherwise rapidly solidified (e.g., by melt spinning) to form particles of soft magnet precursor materials. Particles of the soft magnet material are then annealed to form permanent magnet powder, which may be bonded or sintered into permanent magnet shapes and magnetized for many applications. The annealing temperature typically varies among individual cerium-iron-boron compositions, and a preferred annealing temperature for best permanent magnet properties may be found for each three-component composition.
Melt spun and carefully annealed Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 has been produced with an intrinsic coercivity, Hci of 6.18 kOe and remanence, Br of 4.92 kG. Similarly, Ce14.3Fe78.6B7.1 has been produced with coercivity, Hci of 5.43 kOe and remanence, Br of 5.33 kG. Other rapidly solidified and annealed Ce—Fe—B compositions that have good permanent magnet properties include Ce15.4Fe76.9B7.7, Ce17.9Fe77.9B4.2, Ce22.8Fe71.1B6.1, Ce14.4Fe74.9B10.7, Ce18.2Fe72.7B9.1, Ce21.1Fe73.7B5.3, Ce13.3Fe80.0B6.7, Ce18.5Fe70.0B11.5, and Ce23.1Fe73.5B3.4. Magnetic properties for these compositions are summarized in Table I presented below in this specification. It is seen that the highest values of both Hci and Br are not found simultaneously in any single Ce—Fe—B composition.
In another practice of the invention, the molten alloy is quenched at a predetermined quench rate, such as at a predetermined melt-spinning quench wheel speed, to directly produce CeaFebBc permanent magnet material. In this direct quench method the material usually does not require an anneal to produce its permanent magnet properties. For example, direct quenched Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 has been produced with an intrinsic coercivity, Hci of 5.32 kOe and remanence, Br of 5.19 kG. The direct quench particles may, for example, be ball milled to a desired particle size and resin bonded or hot compacted into a magnet body of desired shape.
Other objects and advantages of the invention will be apparent from a description of illustrative embodiments which follows in this specification.
While the intrinsic magnetic properties of Ce2Fe14B (saturation magnetization 4πMs=11.7 kG and anisotropy field Ha=26 kOe at 295K, Curie temperature Tc=424K) are inferior to those of Nd2Fe14B (4πMs=16 kG, Ha=73 kOe, Tc=585K), they are nevertheless sufficient to offer the potential for producing Ce—Fe—B magnets having hard magnet characteristics intermediate between those of ferrites and Nd—Fe—B.
Since the Ce—Fe—B phase diagram is distinct from that of Nd—Fe—B in several respects, featuring in particular the compound CeFe2 having no Nd analog under normal conditions, it was anticipated that the Ce—Fe—B composition yielding the most favorable hard magnet properties via rapid solidification might well differ from the optimum composition for Nd—Fe—B. Accordingly, a range of compositions was explored that is indicated by the squares in the section of the Ce—Fe—B phase diagram near the Fe vertex shown in
Ingots of Ce—Fe—B of various compositions were made by induction melting the elements. Ribbons of Ce—Fe—B were melt-spun by induction melting pieces of ingot in a quartz crucible under an argon inert gas atmosphere and ejecting the molten alloy through a 0.6 mm diameter orifice onto the circumferential surface of a chromium-plated copper wheel (25 cm diameter) spinning at a wheel surface speed, vs, of 35 m/s. The molten stream is rapidly solidified as it hits the spinning quench wheel and ribbon fragments are thrown from the wheel and collected while still in the protective argon atmosphere. This wheel speed, vs, corresponds to a quench rate large enough to yield “overquenched” as-spun ribbon fragments that are mostly amorphous or nanocrystalline. A portion of the collected ribbon product was ground to a coarse powder in a SPEX 8000 High Energy Ball Mill (HEBM) by milling for 2 minutes in an argon atmosphere. X-ray diffraction (XRD) of the as-quenched powder showed a superposition of peaks from nanocrystalline material together with very broad peaks of an amorphous powder diffraction pattern.
Powdered ribbons were heat treated using a Perkin-Elmer, System 7 thermogravimetric analyzer (TGA). The ribbons were heated at 100° C./min under flowing argon to a target temperature, held at temperature for 5 min, and then cooled at 100° C./min back to room temperature. No significant weight changes occurred during heat treatment. The target temperature was varied between 450° C. and 800° C. to determine the temperature, Ta, at which the remanence Br, intrinsic coercivity Hci and energy product (BHmax) are maximized. Requiring only that the quench rate (i.e., vs to a first approximation) exceed a minimum value to produce largely amorphous material, this procedure is an alternative to identifying the best vs for each composition; it was originally established many years ago for melt-spun Nd—Fe—B. Identifying a best vs for molten CeaFebBc alloys is demonstrated below in this specification.
Magnetic properties of the heat treated ribbons were measured on a PAR model 155 vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM). Crushed powder was loaded into a KEL-F sample holder, and then fully magnetized by a pulsed magnetic field. Demagnetization curves were measured to a maximum reverse field of 18.9 kOe.
The variation in magnetic properties with composition is summarized in the following Table I.
It is also evident from Table I that the maximum values of the three magnetic properties do not occur for a unique composition: among the formulations we prepared, Br and (BH)max are largest for Ce14.3Fe78.6B7.1 (composition B), while Hci peaks for the substantially Ce-richer composition Ce22.8Fe71.1B6.1 (E). To organize the results in a way that emphasizes remanence and coercivity equally, certainly justifiable from a technological perspective, we use their sum as a convenient and practical, although arbitrary, figure of merit. The entries in Table I are given in order of decreasing (Br+Hci), and the squares in
By means of time-temperature observations of thermal arrest during the cooling of several melted ingots (A, D, G, O, T in Table I) roughly spanning our composition region, we determined that the Ce—Fe—B liquidus is in the narrow 1041° C.-1056° C. interval (substantially smaller than the ˜90° C. excursion of melting points for the same Ce/Fe ratio range in the Ce—Fe phase diagram, illustrating one profound effect of boron). Since the melt temperature in almost all of our spins (A-F, H-K, M-P, R in Table I) was 1300° C., the difference between it and the liquidus was essentially independent of stoichiometry, hence it can be inferred that composition rather than quenching regimen is the primary factor controlling the magnetics.
We emphasize that the Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 (A) composition yields properties superior to those of Ce13.5Fe81.9B4.7 (L), the Ce—Fe—B analog of the optimum Nd—Fe—B composition. In
XRD patterns for Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 (A) are displayed in
Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6=0.746 Ce11.8Fe82.4B5.9+0.227 Ce33.3Fe66.7+0.027 Ce12.3Fe43.9B43.95
where Ce11.8Fe82.4B5.9, Ce33.3Fe66.75 and Ce12.3Fe43.9B43.9 respectively represent the phases Ce2Fe14B, CeFe2, and Ce1.12Fe4B4 normalized to 100 atoms per phase to be consistent with the notation for the starting composition, Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 on the left side. The relatively small coefficient of Ce12.3Fe43.9B43.9 may be responsible for its lack of an x-ray signature in
A multi-component Rietveld analysis of
Ce2Fe14B is the only species present that is magnetic at room temperature, thus the remanence of an isotropic magnet comprising 88 vol % uniaxial Ce2Fe14B having 4πMs=11.7 kG can be estimated as Br˜0.88×0.5×11.7 kG=5.15 kG, in good agreement with our measured value of 4.92 kG. Analysis of the line widths affords estimates of ˜60 nm and ˜20 nm for average Ce2Fe14B and CeFe2 grain sizes, respectively. We note that Br=5.33 kG for the Ce14.3Fe78.6B7.1(B) sample in Table I implies a Ce2Fe14B volume fraction larger than that for sample A, but at the expense of coercivity. In optimized Nd—Fe—B the Nd2Fe14B volume fraction is ˜95% and the average grain size is ˜30 nm. Moreover, the only secondary component is an intergranular Nd—Fe binary alloy. The differences in overall composition and secondary phase occurrence between optimized melt-spun Ce—Fe—B and Nd—Fe—B are consequences of the contrast between the Ce—Fe—B and Nd—Fe—B phase diagrams, as discussed in paragraph [0027]. In turn, that contrast is due at least in part to the fact that the Nd ion is trivalent while the Ce ion is tetravalent when combined with Fe and B; the distinct bond character that results from the different number of valence electrons affects the stoichiometry and number of the compounds that form.
In the practices of the invention described above in this specification the melt of the selected CeaFebBc composition was over-quenched and then optimally annealed to obtain good permanent magnet properties. In another practice of the invention portions of the CeaFebBc are melt-spun using varying quench wheel speeds to determine a quench rate that directly yields a melt-spun product with permanent magnet properties. For example, a melt of the above specified Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 (A) composition was prepared in a quartz crucible and portions of the molten alloy were ejected through a 0.6 mm diameter onto the circumferential surface of the chromium-plated copper wheel (25 cm diameter). Fragments of melt-spun Ce16.7Fe77.8B5.6 composition were obtained using wheel surface speeds of 16 m/s, 19 m/s, 22 m/s, 25 m/s, and 28 m/s. The melt-spun fragments were ball milled as-is (no anneal) and their magnetic properties determined. This data is presented in the following Table II and graphically in
In the examples described above in this specification the chromium-coated copper quench wheel was relatively massive compared to the volumes of liquid cerium-iron-boron alloys being quenched. It was initially at room temperature and it did not require cooling. However, in the melt spinning and quenching of larger volumes of such molten alloys it may be necessary to provide for cooling or other temperature control of the quench wheel.
Thus, we have identified the region of the Ce—Fe—B phase diagram from which materials primarily comprised of Ce2Fe14B and having optimum hard magnet properties can be synthesized by melt spinning. As is generally the case for melt-spun magnets, the composition can be varied to improve Br and (BH)max at the sacrifice of Hci, and vice versa. Br and Hci values that are ˜50% of 4πMs (the upper limit for an isotropic uniaxial magnet) and ˜27% of Ha, respectively, have been achieved in heat treated ribbons. By these metrics the results are quite comparable to those well established for Nd—Fe—B.
Certain practices of the invention have been presented for the purpose of illustration and not for the purpose of limiting the scope of the invention.
This application claims priority based on provisional application 61/485,156, titled “Cerium Based Permanent Magnet Material,” filed May 12, 2011 and which is incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61485156 | May 2011 | US |