Communication from “fixed” Earth stations such as ground stations or ship-borne stations to rocket-propelled objects such as missiles is now common. The “Earth” station may even be an aircraft in this context. The communication is often in a military scenario in which the missile is defensive, and is commanded and or guided toward its target by signals transmitted from the Earth station. In one common scenario, a ship or ground station includes a radar or other sensing system which tracks both the target and the missile, and updates the information available to the missile guidance to improve the likelihood of hitting the target.
The quality of the communication link between the Earth station and the missile in a “link budget” which is determined by analysis that captures all of the hardware and environmental gains and losses of the communication path. Among the elements which can be incorporated into the link budget analysis during the boost phase or portion of the missile flight is rocket plasma plume radio-frequency (RF) attenuation, thought to be attributable to free electrons arising from alkali metal impurities found in the rocket propellant.
The radio-frequency (RF) link budget loss attributable to the plume is calculated by a complex and expensive modeling procedure. The calculation yields plume attenuation for an engine under various flight conditions, such as altitude, Mach number, and aspect angle.
Improved methods are desired for determining link attenuation budgets in complex situations.
A method according to an aspect of the disclosure is for adjusting the track or path of a boosting missile in order to maintain the quality or attenuation of a communication link between the missile and a communication device in the presence of at least one other boosting missile. The method comprises the step of precalculating a communication link budget including an attenuation factor, where the communication link budget attenuation factor includes a table of the attenuation characteristics of a communication path extending to a single missile which, when operating, generates a plasma plume. A first missile is provided, with the first missile including a motor or engine which, when operating, generates a plasma plume, and which also includes an antenna for transducing signals with a communication device. The first missile is initialized and launched. The number of additional boosting missiles traveling along paths lying in or immediately adjacent to the line of sight between the communication device and the first missile is determined. The quality or attenuation factor of the link budget in the presence of the additional boosting missiles is determined. If (a) the link budget quality falls below a predetermined standard and (b) the loss is deemed to be attributable to the plumes of the additional boosting missiles, the track of a missile is adjusted to improve the quality. In a particular mode of this method, the step of determining the quality of the link budget in the presence of said additional boosting missile or missiles includes the step of calculating
where:
A1 is the predetermined value of plume attenuation for the missile with which communication takes place;
h1 is the altitude associated with the missile with which communication takes place;
ATOTAL is the total attenuation for multiple plumes 1 through N, which plumes may be at different altitudes, and for h≦70 km;
havg is the average altitude of all plumes (km); and
Req is the equivalent nozzle plane exit radius based on the total nozzle exit plane area associated with all the missile plumes
Req=(R12+R22+R32+R42+ . . . +RN2)1/2
According to another aspect of the disclosure, a method is provided for commanding an attitude change of a boosting missile to tend to maintain good communication link quality. The method includes the step of precalculating attenuation of a link between the boosting missile and a ground station in the presence and in the absence of multiple missile plumes. If the actual link attenuation is less than the precalculated attenuation in the absence of multiple missile plumes, no attitude change is commanded. If the actual link attenuation exceeds the precalculated value, the actual link attenuation is compared with the calculated attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes. If the calculated multiple plume RF attenuation is less than the actual link attenuation, the attenuation is deemed to be caused by some factor other than multiple plume attenuation, and produces a flag for commanding a change in attitude of the boosting missile. In a particular mode of this method, the step of determining the quality of said link budget in the presence of said additional boosting missile or missiles includes the step of calculating
where:
A1 is the predetermined value of plume attenuation for the missile with which communication takes place;
h1 is the altitude associated with the missile with which communication takes place;
ATOTAL is the total attenuation for multiple plumes 1 through N, which plumes may be at different altitudes, and for h≦70 km;
havg is the average altitude of all plumes (km); and
Req is the equivalent nozzle plane exit radius based on the total nozzle exit plane area associated with all the missile plumes
Req=(R12+R22+R32+R42+ . . . +RN2)1/2
A method according to another aspect of the disclosure is for adjusting the track or path of a boosting missile to maintain the quality of a communication link between the missile and a communication device in the presence of at least one other boosting missile. The method comprises the steps of precalculating a communication link budget including an attenuation factor, where the communication link budget attenuation factor includes a table of the attenuation characteristics of a communication path extending to a single missile which, when operating, generates a plasma plume. A first missile is provided, the first missile including a motor which, when operating, generates a plasma plume, and which also includes an antenna for transducing signals with a communication device. The first missile is initialized and launched. The characteristics of the environment of the first missile are determined, including the number of additional boosting missile or missiles traveling along paths lying adjacent to the line of sight extending between the communication device and the first missile, and also including information relating to the exit plane areas of the boosting missiles. The quality of the link budget is determined in the presence of the additional boosting missile or missiles as a function of the exit plane areas of the missiles.
A method according to yet another aspect of the disclosure is for determining if the attitude of a boosting missile should be modified in order to improve the quality of a communication link extending between the boosting missile and a stationary communication device. The method comprises the step of precalculating a missile link budget including attenuation attributable to the engine plume of the boosting missile with which communication is desired. The missile with which communication is desired is launched. The quality of the link is determined as good or bad. If the quality of the link is bad, the actual link attenuation to the boosting missile is determined under the existing conditions, and the actual link attenuation is compared to the precalculated value to determine if the actual link attenuation is greater than or less than the precalculated value. If the actual link attenuation is less than the precalculated value, a signal is generated indicating that the boosting missile attitude need not be changed. The link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is calculated. If the actual link attenuation is greater than the precalculated value, the actual link attenuation is compared with the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes, and if the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is less than the actual link attenuation, a signal is generated indicating that the boosting missile attitude need not be changed. If the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is greater than the actual link attenuation, a signal is generated indicating that the boosting missile attitude needs to be changed.
The possibility exists that a military scenario will involve attack by a plurality of hostile vehicles or missiles, or that multiple defensive missiles will be used to engage the hostile missile(s). In such a scenario, there is the possibility that the communication link associated with one of the missiles with which communication is desired will pass through the plasma plume of another missile. If this happens, even for a short period of time, the quality of the communication link might be severely compromised. Such compromise might occur at an inopportune time, such that the disruption of communication could lead to failure of the defensive missile to properly engage the hostile target.
According to an aspect of the disclosure, a pre-calculated single-plume RF signal attenuation, which may be generated in the prior-art manner, is used as an input to a multiple-plume attenuation estimation algorithm. The link budget is compared with the results of the multiple-plume attenuation estimate, and if it appears that the multiple-plume attenuation is significant, the track of at least one of the missiles is modified to reduce the multiple-plume attenuation. While ordinarily the track will be modified of the missile with which communications are desired, it is also possible to modify the track of one or more of the missiles causing the second or multiple plume(s).
In general, the plume RF signal attenuation A is a function
A=f(R,h,θ,ε) (1)
where:
R is the nozzle exit plane radius associated with plume size;
h is plume altitude (A increases as h in endo-atmosphere);
Θ is aspect angle; and
ε is plume electron density (varies with location in the plume).
According to an aspect of the disclosure, plume attenuation is calculated or estimated for a multiple-plume scenario such as that of
As suggested by the placement of the various missiles 181, 182, 183, and 184 in
Plume attenuation increases with altitude up to a maximum of about 70 kilometers (km) at constant aspect angle. In a scenario including multiple plumes, it would be difficult to determine the individual values of the aspect angle, the electron densities of each plume (other than the missile with which communications are desired) at the aspect angle in question. Even if determined, the values affecting the attenuation change from moment to moment, rendering direct calculation difficult.
One might expect that the total RF attenuation attributable to multiple plumes would be, if calculated, the sum of all the individual plume RF attenuations along the line-of-sight or communication path. Performing a calculation for multiple plumes from missiles having the same size nozzles and at the same altitude yields a value for the total plume attenuation that is less than the sum of the calculated plume attenuation values.
It has been discovered that the total plume RF attenuation in the case of multiple plumes is a function of the total nozzle exit plane area, which is to say that it is proportional to R2. The attenuation ATOTAL attributable to the passage of RF through multiple plumes is calculated, according to an aspect of the disclosure, as
where:
A1 is the predetermined value of plume attenuation for the missile with which communication takes place (181 of
h1 is the altitude associated with the missile with which communication takes place;
ATOTAL is the total attenuation for multiple plumes 1 through N, which plumes may be at different altitudes, and for h≦70 km;
havg is the average altitude of all plumes (km); and
Req is the equivalent nozzle plane exit radius based on the total nozzle exit plane area associated with all the missile plumes
Req=(R12+R22+R32+R42+ . . . +RN2)1/2 (3)
Note that havg will always be less than or equal to h1.
From block 622 of
Block 626 represents a comparison of actual plume RF attenuation with the modeled plume attenuation to determine the source of, or reason for, any excess plume attenuation not attributable to hardware causes or to range or jamming. The current plume attenuation of missile 181 is generated in block 626 from current information supplied from the radar system and stored in block 640. This information may include the altitude and attitude of missile 181, the number of other missiles, and their plume radii. Block 642 represents the precalculated single-plume RF attenuation for the current conditions, as generated in block 614. Block 626 represents the calculation of the actual attenuation by subtracting all other effects from the link budget. These other effects include missile attitude and the number of supernumerary or additional missiles, their plume radii, range and jamming. Block 626 compares the pre-calculated plume RF attenuation for missile 1 (18 of
Block 628 of
The SP flag from block 628 (if any), the SP flag from block 626 (if any), and the RJ flag from block 614 are coupled onto return logic path 650 and applied to a block 632. Block 632 sums the values of the RJ and SP flags. If the sum of the RJ and SP flags is found to be greater than zero, this is taken as an indication that the link attenuation can be improved by changing the attitude or heading of the trajectory of missile 181. The sum signal is applied to a block 660 to initiate transmission of a “change attitude” command to missile 181 if the sum is greater than zero. Control logic continues along return path 650 back to block 618 to define a recurrent loop where the process starts again to check the quality of the link.
Thus, A method for commanding an attitude change of a boosting missile (181) to tend to maintain good communication link quality includes the step (614) of precalculating attenuation of a link (12) between the boosting missile and a ground station in the presence and in the absence of multiple missile plumes (182, 183). If the actual link attenuation is less than the precalculated attenuation in the absence of multiple missile plumes (626), no attitude change is commanded (SP+RJ=0). If the actual link attenuation exceeds the precalculated value (path 653), the actual link attenuation is compared (628) with the calculated attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes (630). If the calculated multiple plume RF attenuation is less than the actual link attenuation, the attenuation is deemed to be caused by some factor other than multiple plume attenuation, and produces a flag (SP=1) for commanding a change in attitude of the boosting missile.
A method according to an aspect of the disclosure is for adjusting the track or path (22) of a boosting missile (181) in order to maintain the quality or attenuation of a communication link (12) between the missile (181) and a communication device (14) in the presence of at least one other boosting missile (182). The method comprises the step of precalculating (614) a communication link budget including an attenuation factor (A), where the communication link budget attenuation factor (A) includes a table (614) of the attenuation characteristics of a communication path (12) extending to a single missile (181) which, when operating, generates a plasma plume (161). A first missile (181) is provided, with the first missile (181) including a motor or engine which, when operating, generates a plasma plume (161), and which also includes an antenna (20) for transducing signals with a communication device (14). The first missile (181) is initialized and launched. The number of additional boosting missiles (182, 183, 184) traveling along paths lying in or immediately adjacent to the line of sight between the communication device (14) and the first missile (181) is determined (640). The quality or attenuation factor of the link budget in the presence of the additional boosting missiles (182, 183, 184) is determined (626). If (a) the link budget quality falls below a predetermined standard and (b) the loss is deemed to be attributable to the plumes (162, 163, 164) of the additional boosting missiles (182, 183, 184), the track of a missile is adjusted (632, 660, 514) to improve the quality.
A method according to another aspect of the disclosure is for adjusting the track or path of a boosting missile (181) to maintain the quality of a communication link (12) between the missile (181) and a communication device (14) in the presence of at least one other boosting missile (183). The method comprises the steps of precalculating (614) a communication link budget including an attenuation factor (A), where the communication link budget attenuation factor (A) includes a table (614) of the attenuation characteristics of a communication path (12) extending to a single missile (181) which, when operating, generates a plasma plume (161). A first missile (181) is provided, the first missile (181) including a motor or engine which, when operating, generates a plasma plume (161), and which also includes an antenna (20) for transducing signals with a communication device (14). The first missile (181) is initialized (614) and launched (616). The characteristics of the environment of the first missile (181) are determined, including the number of additional boosting missile or missiles traveling along paths lying adjacent to the line of sight extending between the communication device and the first missile (181), and also including information relating to the exit plane areas of the boosting missiles. The quality of the link budget is determined (630) in the presence of the additional boosting missile or missiles as a function of the exit plane areas of the missiles.
A method according to yet another aspect of the disclosure is for determining if the attitude of a boosting missile (181) should be modified in order to improve the quality of a communication link (12) extending between the boosting missile (181) and a stationary communication device (14). The method comprises the step of precalculating (614) a missile (181) link budget including attenuation attributable to the engine plume (161)) of the boosting missile (181) with which communication is desired. The missile (181) with which communication is desired is launched (616). The quality of the link is determined (618) as good or bad. If the quality of the link is bad, the actual link attenuation to the boosting missile is determined (619) under the existing conditions, and the actual link attenuation is compared (626) to the precalculated value to determine if the actual link attenuation is greater than or less than the precalculated value. If the actual link attenuation is less than the precalculated value, a signal (SP=0) is generated (626) indicating that the boosting missile attitude need not be changed. The link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is calculated (630). If the actual link attenuation is greater than the precalculated value, the actual link attenuation is compared (628) with the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes, and if the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is less than the actual link attenuation, a signal is generated indicating that the boosting missile attitude need not be changed. If the calculated link attenuation in the presence of multiple missile plumes is greater than the actual link attenuation, a signal is generated indicating that the boosting missile attitude needs to be changed.
This invention was made with Government Support under Contract No. N00024-03-C-6110 awarded by the Department of the Navy. The Government has certain rights in this invention.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4010467 | Slivka | Mar 1977 | A |
4148029 | Quesinberry | Apr 1979 | A |
4194204 | Alpers | Mar 1980 | A |
4204210 | Hose | May 1980 | A |
4752779 | Jones et al. | Jun 1988 | A |
4987419 | Salkeld | Jan 1991 | A |
5131602 | Linick | Jul 1992 | A |
5583508 | Pugh et al. | Dec 1996 | A |
6596976 | Lin et al. | Jul 2003 | B2 |