Patent Grant
7604747
This application is a 371 of PCT/GB04/05184 filed Dec. 10, 2004
This invention has to do with chromatography apparatus and methods. It is particularly concerned with systems and methods for gaining access to components of the column e.g. for maintenance, notably the column end cell structures.
The present discussion relates to apparatus and methods useful in industrial-scale chromatography, e.g. large-scale preparative purification of fine chemicals and pharmaceuticals, including biological products. It is not concerned with laboratory-scale apparatus. Conventionally an industrial-scale chromatography column has a cylindrical axially-vertical column tube with top and bottom end cells, each of which provides a strong backing plate with a fluid inlet/outlet and support for a layer of mesh, sinter or other fluid-permeable retaining material which lets process liquid flow into and out of the chromatography space while retaining the bed of particulate chromatography medium. To provide adjustability and control of bed height and bed compression, at least the top end cell is usually made in the form of a piston slidable in the column tube interior. The bottom end cell may also be a piston but more usually is a fixed plate bolted against a bottom end flange of the column tube. Typically this bottom plate acts as a support for the column as a whole, being itself supported on legs or some other stand arrangement leaving clearance for outlet pipework projecting beneath the bottom end cell.
Various mechanisms are known for controlling the position of the piston end cell. The structure supporting the piston must move into the column interior behind the piston, and so must be smaller than the column diameter. Usually metal spacer posts are fixed to the back of the end plate and extend up axially—to a distance corresponding roughly to the length of adjustment anticipated—to a lifting ring which is connected in turn down to an external drive and support mechanism able to move the end cell piston, via the spacer posts, relative to the fixed mounting. For example a set of lifting rods may extend up axially outside the column from the fixed mounting to the lifting ring. The lifting rods include (or are connected to) an axial drive, usually a mechanical threaded drive which may be hand-operated, to move the lifting ring up and down and thereby control the position of the end cell piston in the column. Because the piston is large, close-fitting and acts on a bed of fluid or particulate medium which may be packed, it is crucial that the rate of raising or lowering the piston be carefully equalised around the column and this requires care and time.
In the prior art, U.S. Pat. No. 5,681,474 describes a chromatography column in which the top end cell plunger is carried by three rods connected to hydraulic drive cylinders, operated from a central control to preserve alignment of the top cell as it is forced down onto the media bed, especially to achieve flow packing.
WO 00/00259 describes a column in which the top end cell can be fully retracted from the column tube by means of a set of threaded rods driven in rotation.
Columns marketed by Chromaflow in the mid 90's also featured hydraulic drives to move and if necessary withdraw upper and lower end cell plungers relative to the column tube.
From time to time in certain kinds of columns and processes it may be desirable or necessary to get access to the column interior for purposes other than filling or emptying particulate medium, especially since columns are now available which can do the latter through valved ports. In particular, column maintenance may require access to the inner parts of the end cells e.g. to remove their permeable retaining layers (mesh or sinter) and/or their seals, for cleaning, replacement or repair. For such access, the end cell must be withdrawn and separated from the column tube, either entirely or at least with enough clearance to carry out the operation in question, e.g. removal/insertion of a permeable layer element or seal. Typically access to the lower permeable element is by unbolting a lower column tube flange from the bottom end cell plate, and lifting the column tube up away from the plate sufficiently to unfasten and remove the permeable element sideways. Access to the permeable element of the top (piston) end cell is by lifting the piston right out of the column tube using the mechanism provided, sufficiently far for the permeable element to be moved in or out sideways.
The column elements being heavy, these operations normally have to be done with the aid of cranes, powered drives or by manual mechanisms with substantial mechanical advantage. For the same reason, alignment structures are used to keep the column and its end cells axially aligned as they are separated from each other as described. This avoids potential serious damage to precision components. The alignment and lifting structures cause significant obstructions around the tube, and need to be carefully laid out to provide sufficient clearance at some part of the circumference for insertion/removal of the permeable retaining elements if this is to be an operational requirement.
By way of illustration, a system and method working in line with known principles (see U.S. Pat. No. 6,736,974) are described with reference to
First, the basic elements of the apparatus are described with reference to
The top cell 6 likewise has a rigid flat backing plate 62 and an inner contoured cell plate 63 for supporting an end mesh (not shown), but unlike the bottom end cell is configured as a piston slidable inside the column tube. It is supported from above through a circumferentially-distributed array of vertical (axial) spacer rods 66 whose bottom ends are screwed rigidly into the cell's backing plate 62, while their top ends screwed up into the inner periphery of an annular adjuster flange 7. The adjuster flange 7, sometimes called a lifting ring, is spaced coaxially above the top column tube flange 11 and has the same OD but a smaller ID, so that it overhangs the column interior for securement to the spacer rods 66 that hold the piston 6.
Fluid communication through the top end cell 6 is through another central access valve 65, similar to that in the bottom plate 5. Among other functions, these access valves enable particulate medium to be packed into and unpacked from the bed space of the column as a slurry, without opening the column.
Three vertical guide rods 71 have their top ends fixedly threaded into the adjuster flange 7 at spaced locations (see views (b)). Each of these guide rods 71 descends with clearance through a set of aligned guide holes through the upper and lower column tube flanges 11,12 and the periphery of the column base 5.
Hydraulic drive cylinders 8 are mounted vertically on the underside of the outer base plate 52, and their driven rods 81 extend up through further sets of aligned holes in the base 5, upper and lower column tube flanges 11,12 and adjuster flange 7. Each lifting rod 81 is threaded near its top and has a pair of locating nuts 82 to either side of the adjuster flange 7 for fixing the flange to the rod 81 at a selected position. In this example there are three drive cylinders 8.
Further connecting structure is provided by a set of three vertical tie bars 73. These are short threaded rods received in openings through the adjuster flange 7 and top column tube flange 11, with respective pairs of locking nuts 74,75 to fix the location of each of these engagements.
Operation of the drive cylinders 8 directly raises or lowers the adjuster flange 7, to a height determined by the location of the drive rod locknuts 82. The top end cell piston 6, being rigidly connected to the adjuster flange 7 through the spacer rods 66, is raised or lowered correspondingly. If the tie rods 73 are locked by their locating nuts 74,75 to both the adjuster flange 7 and column tube flange 11, the drive rods 81 will lift the column tube 1 as well provided that it has first been released from the base 5 by releasing the studs 57.
The following description of maintenance steps can now be followed.
To remove or gain access to the lower mesh or seals, the hydraulic cylinders are fully retracted to set the piston 6 to its lowermost position. The studs 57 holding the column tube 1 to the base 5 are removed. The tie rods 73 are locked to the upper column tube flange 11. Refer to
Next, the known mode of removal of the upper mesh is described with reference to
The described procedure and apparatus provide access to the two end cells without requiring overhead lifting equipment. Industrial columns can be very large and heavy; typically the column diameter is 500 mm or more. The illustrated column has a 1400 mm diameter and would be very difficult to manoeuvre without a powered lift.
The described apparatus and procedure have however the drawback that access to the upper mesh is difficult; it has to be removed at quite a distance above the ground. For such a large and delicate component this is a significant issue.
We also note the system described in WO 03/076923, which gets access to the top end cell piston by connecting the piston centrally to an overhead yoke. Once the piston has been lifted to the top of the column tube, this yoke can be released at one side and swung up and over to bring the piston (inverted) down beside the column. This gives lower access in the final position, but the swinging over of the piston would be a risky matter with a large column, so that this proposal is limited to smaller columns.
Aspects of our new proposals are new apparatus and techniques for improving access to the piston end cell in operations of this kind.
A first aspect of our proposals is a method of operating chromatography apparatus, the apparatus comprising a column tube having first and second ends, and first and second discrete end structures associated with the respective ends and defining with the column tube a column space for retaining chromatography medium in use of the apparatus, at least the first end structure comprising a piston portion fitting slidably in the column tube. In the method, the column tube is separated from the first and second end structures to provide access to those structures, e.g. for inspection, cleaning, repair, replacement or exchange or the like of parts, such as seal(s) and permeable retaining members (conveniently referred to herein using “maintenance” as a collective term). The characteristic feature in our first proposal is that access to the first end structure is provided by moving the piston thereof forwardly through the column tube to expose it at the open second end of the column tube, which is separated from the second end structure to give access.
Compared with existing methods, this has the radical advantage that the access positions for the first and second end structures can be relatively close to one another. In the preferred orientation, where the first end and second end are the top and bottom respectively, the first end structure appears below the column, greatly reducing the potential access height requirement. Separation of the second end structure from the column—necessary for access to the second end structure—is also involved in access to the first end structure, potentially simplifying the procedure e.g. compared with that described above with reference to
The second end structure (usually the bottom) may remain fixed. The column tube may then be released from the fixed second end structure and moved away from it axially to a position spaced from it. Then the piston of the second end structure is moved through the column towards the second end structure and emerges at the second column end, the tube and second end structure remaining fixed during this movement. This is most obviously practical where the first end is at the top and the column is an upright column on a stand. However different types of movement may be appropriate, e.g. to hold the column tube and lower the second end structure away from it.
Preferably a powered drive such as a hydraulic drive is used to space the column tube from the second end structure, and move the first end structure's piston through the column tube to its exposed position. Preferably the same drive performs both functions. Preferably the drive is mounted on or adjacent the second end structure.
For the piston to be moved right through the column, it needs to be supported from behind by a structure that can fit into the column tube behind it, essentially over the full length of the tube. This insertable piston support structure desirably connects the piston to an operating drive, preferably a powered drive such as a hydraulic drive, throughout its stroke including the position exposed at—and preferably projecting from—the second end, so that it can be driven controllably to and from the exposed position.
We talk here about pushing the piston through the tube; it should be understood that except where the context specifies otherwise this is a relative matter and may involve absolute movement of the tube while the piston remains fixed, or movements of both elements over different distances. The preferred combination of movements will depend to some extent on the dimensions of the components, the operating stroke available for the drive(s) used, and on whether (as preferred) the same drive(s) is/are used for the operations exposing the end structures as is/are used for adjusting the position of the mentioned piston when the column is closed for operation.
In apparatus terms, chromatography apparatus embodying the invention has a column tube, first and second end structures as described above, and means for driving relative movement between the column tube and end structures from a closed position, in which the first end structure's piston is fitted inside the tube and the second end structure closes the second end of the tube, and an open (maintenance) position in which the second end of the column tube is held spaced away from the second end structure, and the piston of the first end structure is exposed at the second end of the tube and preferably projecting beyond it. Preferably the drive arrangement supports the piston axially via a drive support behind the piston, i.e. having an insertion structure which extends along inside the column tube in the maintenance position. The drive means which carries out this function may drive the column tube and/or the piston relative to the second end structure; the drive source is preferably fixed on or fixed relative to the second end structure, and preferably adjacent that structure. Preferably the drive means is fixed directly to the second end structure, e.g. a base of the column. To drive the piston, the drive means may have a piston drive connector extending axially outside the column from the second end to the first end, and connecting past the first end with an insertable support structure for the piston as mentioned above. Preferably the drive is via axially-movable rods extending up beside the column, e.g. hydraulically-driven rods. A radial connecting structure, such as a lifting ring or adjuster flange as referred to previously, may form a part of the drive connector which connects these rods to the insertable piston support structure. The insertable structure itself may be a set of axial rods extending back from the piston, as in previous constructions, but of a length enabling the piston to emerge at the second end of the column tube.
Preferably a common drive operates both the relative movement between a piston and second end structure and the relative movement between the column tube and first end structure. For this purpose, somewhat analogous to the structure described previously in relation to
By operating the drive from one end, in practice preferably the base of the column which may be a base mounted on a stand, we can provide the advantages of the invention without relying on overhead structures or separate units. Nevertheless, the skilled person will appreciate that the advantageous exposure of the piston at the opposite end of the column tube may be achieved by other means if extra drives or attachments to other structures are tolerated, e.g. to drive the piston down from a fixed structure above, and/or to lift the column tube up or down relative to its base e.g. by a similar means, or to support the tube and drive the base downwardly. In general, use of dedicated drives for the different functions simplifies the drive connections but makes the apparatus more bulky, complicated and expensive overall, to the extent that it may be difficult to mount the various drives while retaining adequate access to the column area.
As in previous proposals, it is preferred to have one or more non-driving guide structures engaging the relatively axially moveable column components to maintain and support their axial alignment as they are driven in relative movement. For example, plural slidable guide rods passing through openings in the components may be used as described previously. Mechanisms are preferably provided for locking relative to these structures e.g. guide rods in selected positions, so that components can be held at selected spaced orientations (particularly for access) without relying on (or relying solely on) the drive for this purpose. A skilled person will appreciate that there are other ways of providing detents for holding various axial positions of the components, for safety or otherwise.
Safety stops may also be provided for limiting the extent of available axial movement between various components to prevent their exceeding the safe reach of the structure; these also may be embodied in rods or tensile elements with stop abutments engaging between the components in question. The guide rods can be used for this. In present embodiments, the guide rods need not connect to the lifting ring.
Typically these proposals are useful with columns whose column tubes are at least 500 mm in internal diameter, or preferably 800 mm or more, or 1000 mm or more. The height of the column tube is preferably at least 200 mm, more preferably at least 300 or at least 400 mm. It may be used with integrally flanged steel columns or with polymer tubes held between discrete flange plates.
Because the usual use of the system is for gaining access to the permeable elements of the first and second end structures, the disposition of axially-extending surround and drive structures needs to be determined in conjunction with the axial clearances achieved by the mechanism so that there is room to get these permeable elements in and out.
Preferably the invention is implemented in a column having one or more packing and/or unpacking valves enabling the column to be filled with or emptied of packing medium as a slurry. These may be combined valves also providing for flow of process liquids, and preferably access the column interior through the centre of each end structure, bypassing the permeable structure.
While the particular kind of drive used for moving the tube and end structures axially relative to one another is not particularly limited, and indeed these movements may be done manually if necessary, it is preferred to use a hydraulic drive with plural hydraulic drive units distributed around the column. The skilled person is well aware that where a piston end cell is moved in a column tube, it is important to preserve exactly the axial alignment of the piston in the tube. This is not straightforward where it is wide, heavy, subject to large forces and supported at more than one point. In this respect, we propose to detect the axial positions of plural circumferential drive components (acting on the piston), input the detected positions to a control processor, and use the control processor to compare the detected positions with one another and/or with a predetermined value. The control processor is programmed then to control and adjust the rates and/or pressures of supply of hydraulic fluid to the respective hydraulic drive units to keep the piston axially aligned as it moves. This proposal is new and useful in any chromatography column using multiple hydraulic drives for the end cell piston; it is itself a separate aspect of our proposals and not limited to the particular mechanisms described above as aspects of the invention.
Returning however to the maintenance proposals, it is preferred that in the maintenance position the first end structure's piston actually projects from the column tube's second end, and more preferably sufficiently far to expose a peripheral outwardly-directed seal of the piston. When retracting the piston towards the operational condition, this seal structure rides over the edge of the column tube and might be liable to damage. It may therefore be desirable to adapt the seal structure and/or column tube conformation at this point to avoid such damage. The top opening of a column tube conventionally has a guide chamfer for this purpose, but this is usually undesirable at the bottom end because uniformity at this region is critical for chromatography. Therefore it is preferred to adapt the seal structure, such as by providing a projecting annular support e.g. of engineering plastics, closely axially adjacent a sealing ring to protect it against possibly damaging deformations as it retracts into the tube.
A system and method working in line with known principles (see U.S. Pat. No. 6,736,974) are described with reference to
Examples of aspects of the invention are now discussed with reference to the remainder of the following drawings in which:
The column components are broadly similar to those in
Continuing with reference to
The top of each of the three drive rod extensions 183 is bolted into the outer periphery of a lifting ring 107. From its inner periphery, a circumferential series of nine spacer rods 166 depends vertically, their bottom ends being screwed fixedly into the back plate 162 of the upper cell piston 106. The spacer rods 166 are slightly longer than the interior axial length of the column tube 101.
Guide rods 171 are provided to guide and limit the movement between the column tube 101 and the base 105 when these are disconnected. The top end of each guide rod 171 is fixed into the top column flange 111, unlike the previously-described system in which they had to extend up to the lifting ring 7. The bottom of each guide rod passes down through slide openings in the bottom tube flange 111 and base 5 into a housing sleeve 178 extending down beneath the base 105. The bottom of each guide rod 171 has a projecting stop portion 177 (see also
The nuts 184 are then secured to lock the column tube 101 to the drive via its upper flange 111, and the drive rods 181,183 extended to their full height. This height is limited by the abutment of the guide rod stops 177 against the underside of the base plate. The safety slides 176 are then pushed across, relieving the drive mechanism of the load. In this position, as in previous techniques, the bottom end cell is available for access.
To access the upper end cell, however, it is not necessary to re-lower the tube 101. Rather, the retaining nuts 184 securing the tube flange 111 to the drive rods 183 are released. The tube is then supported solely by the guide rods 171. The drive is then partially retracted to the position shown in
Having thus described the essential advantageous operation of the column, some particular features are now described in a little more detail and with reference to
The seal arrangement at the bottom of the column does not slide. Instead, a mesh clamping ring 157 seats in an annular recess of the base plate 153 (see also
Finally, the hydraulic supplies to the three drives 108 are controllable independently of one another. Electronic monitors (not shown) read the axial positions of the drives and compare them, by means of a control processor. The control processor (not shown) is operatively connected to the hydraulic control and adjusts the hydraulic supplies to the respective drives 108 in dependence on the monitored values, equalising the axial extensions of the three drive rods 181. The skilled person will appreciate that this system is also used when the column is closed and preparing for operation, e.g. in adjusting the compression of the bed of chromatography medium. Any suitable hydraulic fluid may be used. Gas may be used instead.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0328674.7 | Dec 2003 | GB | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/GB2004/005184 | 12/10/2004 | WO | 00 | 2/26/2007 |
| Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| WO2005/056156 | 6/23/2005 | WO | A |
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4451365 | Sättler et al. | May 1984 | A |
| 5167809 | Mann et al. | Dec 1992 | A |
| 5674455 | Marchand et al. | Oct 1997 | A |
| 5681474 | Günther et al. | Oct 1997 | A |
| 5708191 | Greenwood et al. | Jan 1998 | A |
| 5886250 | Greenwood et al. | Mar 1999 | A |
| 6082180 | Greenwood | Jul 2000 | A |
| 6082181 | Greenwood | Jul 2000 | A |
| 6117317 | Dickson et al. | Sep 2000 | A |
| 6190560 | Mann | Feb 2001 | B1 |
| 6558539 | Mann | May 2003 | B1 |
| 6736974 | Mann | May 2004 | B1 |
| 6763698 | Greenwood | Jul 2004 | B2 |
| 6877375 | Greenwood | Apr 2005 | B2 |
| 20040099604 | Hauck et al. | May 2004 | A1 |
| 20060124525 | Bellafiore | Jun 2006 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| WO 9610451 | Apr 1996 | WO |
| WO 9732207 | Sep 1997 | WO |
| WO 0000259 | Jan 2000 | WO |
| WO 0033935 | Jun 2000 | WO |
| WO 03076923 | Sep 2003 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20070138098 A1 | Jun 2007 | US |
