Circuit breaker latch mechanism with decreased trip time

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6218919
  • Patent Number
    6,218,919
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, March 15, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, April 17, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A decreased mechanical trip time latching system for use in a molded case circuit breaker assembly. The latching system comprising a quick release primary latch having a first primary latching surface and a second primary latching surface. Where the second primary latching surface engages a first secondary latching surface located on an interactive secondary latch, to prevent the rotation of the quick release primary latch. The first primary latching surface engages a cradle latching surface, located on a cradle, to prevent the rotation of the cradle. Assembled to the interactive secondary latch is a trip bar. Activation of the trip bar rotates the secondary latch so that the first secondary latching surface moves out of contact with the second primary latching surface just prior to the interactive secondary latch making physical contact with the quick release primary latch. The quick release primary latch then rotates moving the first primary latching surface out of contact with the cradle latching surface thereby releasing the cradle. The cradle rotates and the operating system is activated to terminate current flow.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to circuit breaker assemblies having an improved latching system that substantially decreases mechanical trip time. The improved latching system can be utilized, but not limited to circuit breaker assemblies rated for residential and lower current industrial applications and for high ampere-rated circuit breaker assemblies.




Conventional circuit breaker assemblies utilize a thermal-magnetic trip unit to automatically sense overcurrent circuit conditions and to subsequently interrupt circuit current accordingly. It is the practice of the circuit protection industry to mount a magnet portion of the magnetic trip unit around a bimetal trip unit and to arrange an armature as part of the circuit breaker latching system. It is well appreciated in the electric circuit protection field that the latching surfaces within the circuit breakers latching system must be carefully machined and lubricated in order to ensure repeated latching and unlatching between the surfaces over long periods of continuous use.




The special machining that is required includes a time consuming polishing process or a special machining or shaving operation on the latch systems latch surfaces. The smooth low friction surfaces are required to minimize the amount of tripping force that must be applied to overcome the bias of the operating spring and the static friction on the contracting latch surfaces. The trip force is the amount of force that must be applied to the trip bar to overcome the latch spring bias and latch surface friction




In operation, a magnetic trip unit comprising an armature and a magnet is actuated upon the occurrence of an overcurrent condition. The actuation causes the armature, which is biased away from the magnet by a spring, to be rapidly driven towards the magnet so that a trip bar is activated. The thermal trip unit comprising a bimetal element senses overcurrent conditions by responding to the temperature rise on the bimetal element. When an overcurrent condition occurs over a period of time, the bimetal flexes and activates the trip bar.




Once activated, the trip bar sets in motion the activation and disengagement of a latching system comprising a primary latch, secondary latch, and a cradle. The trip bar, secured to the secondary latch, drives the secondary latch clockwise about a fixed point so that the secondary latch is moved out of contact with the primary latch. The primary latch in turn is positioned to prevent the rotation of the cradle. When the primary latch is released from the secondary latch, the cradle acts on the primary latch urging it to rotate clockwise about a fixed point. Once the primary latch is moved out of contact with the cradle, the cradle is released allowing it to rotate counterclockwise about a fixed point. As the cradle pivots the upper and lower links collapse under the biasing of an operating spring to draw a moveable contact arm containing a moveable contact to the open position. In the open position the moveable contact and a fixed contact are separated thereby terminating the circuit.




The primary latch and the secondary latch have a plurality of latching surfaces. The latching surfaces are defined as the surface of the latch that makes physical contact with any adjoining surface. The first latching surface of the secondary latch is positioned against the second latching surface of the primary latch. A first latching surface of the primary latch is positioned against the latching surface of the cradle. As previously described when the trip bar is actuated, it drives the secondary latch so that the secondary latch rotates about its pivot causing the first latching surface of the secondary latch to break contact with the second latching surface of the primary latch. Once this occurs, the first latching surface of the primary latch has a force bearing on it by the cradle at the cradle latching surface. If this force is great enough to overcome any resistant forces existing between the latching surfaces, the primary latch will rotate about its pivot point so that the first latching surface of the primary latch breaks contact with the latching surface of the cradle. Once released, the cradle rotates counterclockwise and set in motion a chain of events that trips the breaker.




Conventionally both the cradle and the primary latch are fabricated from a stamping operation followed by a shaving operation to flatten and smooth the latching surface of the cradle and the latching surfaces on the primary latch to maintain a low trip force between the cradle and the primary latch. To aid in the release of the latches there is a primary latching force provided by the operating spring. During use there is often a degradation of the latching surfaces due to wear and contaminates on the various latching surfaces. Even when the latching surfaces are prepared in an effort to minimize friction and the various springs provide a biasing force it is unpredictable if and when the latching system will be fully activated. If significant contaminates or excessive wear exists on the various latching surfaces, the latching system will not activate and result in a stalled situation between the cradle and the primary latch. In particular, once the primary latch is released by the secondary latch, the cradle through the latching surface of the cradle and supplied by provides a force on the primary latch at the first latching surface. This force must be great enough to overcome the friction forces acting between the first latching surface of the primary latch and the latching surface of the cradle. If contaminants or other sources cause the friction between these latching surfaces to become too large the first latching surface of the primary latch will not rotate and release the cradle so that the system is in a stalled situation.




Conventional circuit breakers have a size limitation imposed upon them in order to fit into panel boards of residential, office and light industrial applications. While the outer dimensions of the circuit breaker are fixed, short circuit current magnitudes available from electrical utilities have increased, requiring circuit breaker designers to seek new and improved operating and trip mechanisms which limit the energy let-through. To do this, one must minimize the current and/or the time from the onset of overload to arc extinction. One way to accomplish this is to provide an extremely fast acting circuit breaker capable of early contact separation upon detection of an overload.




SUMMARY OF THE PRESENT INVENTION




It is therefore desirable to provide a molded case circuit breaker capable of exceedingly fast tripping action effective in limiting to acceptable levels let-through energy incident with a high fault current interruption. This is accomplished by utilizing an improved latching system employed to immediately release the primary latch once the secondary latch is disengaged by the actuation of the trip bar. Once the primary latch is set free it subsequently releases the cradle so that the breaker mechanism is tripped by the movement of the link system comprising an upper link, a lower link and the operating spring thereby allowing the moveable contact and the fixed contact to separate thereby terminating the circuit. This immediate release of the primary latch, upon the secondary latch disengagement, achieves contact separation in significantly shorter time than when reliance for the release of the cradle is solely dependent upon the cradle forces and minimal friction between the cradle surface and the primary latch surface.




The improved latching system comprises the primary latch, the secondary latch and the trip bar. The improved latching system is designed to function so that upon activation of the trip bar and the disengagement of the secondary latch, the primary latch, being in direct physical contact with the trip bar/secondary latch configuration is immediately released. The primary latch and the secondary latch are shaped and positioned so that once the trip bar is activated, an extension on the secondary latch acts directly on an extension on the primary latch. Therefore the secondary latch drives the primary latch clockwise about its pivot point to positively release the cradle. The timing is such that as soon as the secondary latch clears the primary latch the primary latch is also freed. The timing of the release of the cradle is immediately after the release of the primary latch from the secondary latch.




Because the trip bar/secondary latch configuration is in direct physical contact with the primary latch the mechanical trip time is decreased thereby limiting the energy let-through to an acceptable value. Additionally, the release of the cradle is no longer only dependent on the cradle forces and the finishing of the latching surfaces to reduce friction to effectuate tripping of the breaker.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




Referring now to the drawings wherein like elements are numbered alike in the several Figures:





FIG. 1

is a side view of a single contact arm molded case circuit breaker shown with the contacts closed according to the prior art;





FIG. 2

is a side view of a trip bar according to the prior art;





FIG. 3

is a side view of the secondary latch according to the prior art;





FIG. 4

is a side view of the trip bar assembled to the secondary latch according to the prior art;





FIG. 5

is a side view of a single contact arm molded case circuit breaker with an improved latching system according to the present invention;





FIG. 6

is a side view of a second embodiment of a single contact arm molded case circuit breaker with an improved latching system according to the present invention;





FIG. 7

is a side view of the improved latching system according to the present invention;





FIG. 8

is a perspective view of a self actuating primary latch according to the present invention; and





FIG. 9

is a side view of a secondary latch according to the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION





FIG. 1

shows a conventional circuit breaker assembly of the prior art, which is generally indicated at


10


. It is to be appreciated that this invention deals with one, two, three, or four-pole circuit breakers formed with one or multiple adjacent compartments for housing multiple pole units, a common operating mechanism is provided to simultaneously actuate the interrupter of each pole. For ease of illustration the Figures will show only one pole.

FIG. 1

shows a circuit breaker used for lower circuit interruption applications. Although not shown, the invention can also be used in many different types of circuit breaker assemblies. When activated, the invention operates in the same manner regardless of which circuit breaker assembly in which it is mounted. Therefore, when describing the prior art,

FIG. 1

will be referenced however it is to be appreciated that the improved latching system


92


can be utilized in any type circuit breaker assembly.




The circuit breaker assembly


10


includes an insulative housing


12


shown with one side of the circuit breaker removed. At one end of the housing


12


exists a line strap


14


and a line terminal screw


16


. Permanently affixed to the line strap


14


is a fixed contact


18


. When the circuit breaker assembly


10


is in an on mode the fixed contact


18


makes electrical contact with a moveable contact


20


which is permanently affixed to a first end


22


of a moveable operating arm


24


. At the opposite end of the housing


12


exists a load lug


26


that connects with a bimetal


28


by means of a load strap


30


. A braided conductor


32


electrically connects the bimetal


28


to the moveable operating arm


24


.




The moveable operating arm


24


is pivotally connected at a second end


34


intermediate to a pivot


35


and pivotally connected by a pivot


37


at a distance from the second end


34


to a first end


36


of a lower link


38


. A second end


40


of the lower link


38


is pivotally connected to a first end


42


of an upper link


44


, which in turn is pivotally connected at a second end


46


to a cradle


48


. The cradle


48


is used to mechanically interact with a latching system


68


and a trip unit assembly


50


with the moveable operating arm


24


. An on-off handle


52


operatively connects with the moveable operating arm


24


by means of a handle yoke


54


, a mechanism spring


56


and the upper and lower links


44


,


38


. The handle yoke


54


connects the mechanism spring


56


with the upper and lower links


44


,


38


through an operating springs support pin


58


.




Useful in detecting short circuit conditions is a magnetic trip unit


60


comprising an armature


62


and a magnet


64


. When the circuit breaker assembly


10


is subjected to short circuit conditions, a magnetic attraction is immediately generated between the armature


62


and the magnet


64


. Subsequently, the armature


62


is drawn in the direction of the magnet


64


which strikes a trip bar


66


thereby setting into motion the activation of a latching system


68


. Additionally, useful in detecting overcurrent conditions is a thermal trip unit


70


that reacts to temperature rise on the bimetal element


28


causing the bimetal


28


to flex and strike the trip bar


66


which in turn activates the latching system


68


.




The latching system


68


comprises a primary latch


72


, a secondary latch


74


and the trip bar


66


. When the circuit breaker assembly


10


is in the “ON” mode, the fixed and moveable contacts


18


,


20


are closed so that electrical continuity is retained throughout the assembly


10


allowing the current to flow.




A cradle latching surface


76


exists at the end of the cradle


48


located opposite the cradle


48


connection with the upper link


44


. When the circuit breaker assembly


10


is in the “ON” mode the latching system


68


is set. Setting the latching system


68


includes positioning the cradle latch surface


76


under a first primary latching surface


78


so that the first primary latching surface


78


prevents the cradle


48


from rotating counterclockwise about its pivot point. A second primary latching surface


80


is positioned against a first secondary latching surface


82


so that the secondary latch


74


is in the path of the primary latch


72


preventing the primary latch


72


from rotating clockwise about its pivot point. Referring to

FIGS. 2-4

,

FIG. 2

showing the trip bar


66


,

FIG. 3

showing the secondary latch


74


and

FIG. 4

showing the trip bar


66


assembled in the secondary latch


74


. The trip bar


66


comprises a projection


84


, a leg


86


and a crosspiece


87


wherein the trip bar crosspiece


87


fits in a slot


89


on the secondary latch


74


. A secondary latch pivot pin


88


allows the trip bar projection


84


and the trip bar leg


86


to rotate clockwise upon contact with the bimetal


28


or the armature


62


. The secondary latch further comprises a leg


91


which snappingly engages a lip


93


on the trip bar


66


so that when activated, the two rotate together.




In operation, when the magnetic trip unit


60


is subjected to tripping conditions. A magnetic attraction is immediately generated between the armature


62


and the magnet


64


drawing the armature


62


in the direction of the magnet


64


thereby striking the projection


84


of the trip bar


66


. When dealing with lower level overload conditions, the bimetal


28


flexes and strikes the leg


86


of the trip bar


66


. Once the projection


84


or leg


86


of the trip bar


66


is contacted the trip bar


66


rotates clockwise. When this occurs the secondary latch


74


is also rotated clockwise so that the secondary latching surface


82


is moved from the path of the primary latch


72


. Acting under tension from the mechanical spring


56


biasing the cradle


48


to rotate in a counterclockwise direction about its pivot point, the biasing force pulls at the cradle


48


so that the cradle latching surface


76


pushes up on the first primary latching surface


78


. When the force exerted by the cradle


48


acting on the primary latch


72


overcomes the friction force between the two latching surfaces, it drives the primary latch


72


in a clockwise direction thereby freeing the cradle latching surface


76


. Once the cradle latching surface


76


is freed, the cradle


48


rotates counterclockwise thereby collapsing the upper link


44


and the lower link


38


so that the moveable operating arm


24


can move to the open position. This separates the moveable contact


20


and the fixed contact


18


so that the current flow is terminated.




In order to improve the circuit breaker assembly mechanical trip time and eliminate a potential latch and cradle stall condition an improved latching system


92


in accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail. Referring to

FIGS. 5 and 6

,

FIG. 5

showing the exemplary embodiment of the present invention and

FIG. 6

showing a second embodiment of the present invention, when like components are used reference numbers remain the same. Conventional trip systems as described above depend on the cradle forces alone to apply the appropriate forces required to rotate the primary latch


72


thereby releasing the cradle latching surface


76


from contact with the first primary latching surface


78


. In these conventional systems, the mechanical trip time is slow and results in excess energy let-through. The improved latching system


92


depicted in

FIGS. 5 and 6

limits energy let-through to acceptable levels by decreasing the mechanical trip time.




As shown in

FIG. 7

, the improved latching system


92


comprises a quick release primary latch


94


, an interactive secondary latch


96


and the trip bar


66


. Although the interactive secondary latch


96


and the trip bar


66


are described as two separate elements, the secondary latch


96


and the trip bar


66


, could have their features combined into one interactive secondary latch/trip bar element


140


.

FIG. 8

details the quick release primary latch


94


and

FIG. 9

shows the interactive secondary latch


96


. The quick release primary latch


94


comprising a top cross bar


100


having a primary latch extension


102


extending generally perpendicular to the top cross bar


100


at approximately the midpoint of the top cross bar


100


. The primary latch extension


102


being of sufficient length so that a bottom surface


104


of the extension


102


becomes a first primary latching surface


106


capable of interfacing with the cradle latch surface


76


to prevent the cradle


48


from counterclockwise rotation.




Referring to

FIG. 8

, extending at an angle from the top cross bar


100


in the same direction as the primary latch extension


102


on either side of the primary latch extension


102


are two primary legs


108


. Extending generally perpendicular to the two primary legs


108


away from the primary latch extension


102


are two primary arms


110


. The two primary arms


110


each having a generally oblong opening


112


through which a primary latch pivot pin


114


passes. At a distal end


116


of at least one of the primary arms


110


, a cam element


124


extends. The formation of the cam element


124


as shown in

FIG. 8

is illustrative and is not meant to be limiting.




The trip bar


66


, as shown in

FIG. 7

, comprises the trip bar projection


84


and the trip bar leg


86


. When the trip bar


66


is assembled to the interactive secondary latch


96


, the trip bar


66


can freely rotate. Shown in

FIG. 9

, the interactive secondary latch


96


further comprises a step


130


and a leg


132


. Wherein the leg


132


securely snaps into the lip


93


on the trip bar


66


such that when the trip bar


66


is activated by movement of the armature


62


or the bimetal


28


, the interactive secondary latch


96


pivots clockwise with the trip bar


66


. The step


130


is designed to make physical contact with the cam element


124


upon the release of the interactive secondary latch


96


.




As shown in

FIG. 5

, the improved latching system


92


is set in the manner previously described, a second primary latching surface


134


is positioned against a first secondary latching surface


136


so that the quick release primary latch


94


is prevented from rotating clockwise about its pivot point. When the trip bar


66


is activated, it drives the interactive secondary latch


96


clockwise so that the second primary latching surface


134


and the first secondary latching surface


136


are moved out of contact with each other thereby releasing the quick release primary latch


94


. At this point in a conventional system, the activated latching system


68


would depend on the cradle forces to drive the primary latch


72


clockwise so that the first primary latching surface


78


moves thereby releasing the cradle latching surface


76


.




In the improved latching system


92


, instantaneously upon the interactive secondary latch


96


clearing the quick release primary latch


94


, the step


130


makes physical contact with the cam element


124


. This results in the immediate rotation of the quick release primary latch


94


thereby moving the first primary latching surface


106


out of contact with the cradle latching surface


76


. Once the cradle latching surface


76


is freed, the cradle


48


rotates counterclockwise thereby collapsing the upper link


44


and the lower link


38


so that the moveable operating arm


24


can move to the open position. This separates the moveable contact


20


and the fixed contact


18


so that the current flow is terminated.




The cam element


124


, located on the quick release primary latch


94


, and the step


130


, located on the interactive secondary latch


96


, are designed so that the moment the first secondary latching surface


136


clears the second primary latching surface


134


, the step


130


makes physical contact with the, cam element


124


.




As shown in

FIG. 6

a second embodiment of the present invention relies on a linkage mechanism


138


positioned between and physically connecting the trip bar


66


and the quick release primary latch


94


. The linkage mechanism


138


is utilized to drive the quick release primary latch


94


clockwise about its pivot point as the trip bar


66


is activated. This insures positive tripping and the elimination of any possibility of a stalled situation.




It will be understood that a person skilled in the art may make modifications to the preferred embodiment shown herein within the scope and intent of the claims. While the present invention has been described as carried out in a specific embodiment thereof, it is not intended to be limited thereby but is intended to cover the invention broadly within the scope and spirit of the claims.



Claims
  • 1. A latching system for use in a molded case circuit breaker assembly comprising;a quick release primary latch having a first primary latching surface and a second primary latching surface; a cradle having a cradle latching surface which engages the first primary latching surface preventing the rotation of the cradle; and an interactive secondary latch/trip bar having a first secondary latching surface which engages the second primary latching surface preventing the rotation of the quick release primary latch and wherein activation of the interactive secondary latch/trip bar causes it to rotate so that the first secondary latching surface moves out of contact with the second primary latching surface prior to the interactive secondary latch/trip bar making contact with the quick release primary latch rotating the quick release primary latch thereby moving the first primary latching surface out of contact with the cradle latching surface releasing the cradle.
  • 2. The latching system according to claim 1, wherein the interactive secondary latch/trip bar comprises;an interactive secondary latch having a first secondary latching surface which engages the second primary latching surface preventing the rotation of the quick release primary latch; and a trip bar that is assembled to the interactive secondary latch, wherein activation of the trip bar rotates the secondary latch so that the first secondary latching surface moves out of contact with the second primary latching surface prior to the interactive secondary latch making contact with the quick release primary latch rotating the quick release primary latch thereby moving the first primary latching surface out of contact with the cradle latching surface releasing the cradle.
  • 3. The latching system according to claim 2, wherein the interactive secondary latch further comprises a leg that securely snaps into a lip formed on the trip bar so that when the trip bar is assembled to the interactive secondary latch the two rotate together.
  • 4. The latching system according to claim 3, wherein the interactive secondary latch further comprises a step that extends in the same direction as the first secondary latching surface.
  • 5. The latching system according to claim 4, wherein the quick release primary latch further comprises at least one cam element that extends in a direction opposite the first primary latching surface.
  • 6. The latching system according to claim 5, wherein the interactive secondary latch rotates in a clockwise direction so that the first secondary latching surface moves out of contact with the second primary latching surface, the continued rotation of the interactive secondary latch drives the step to make physical contact with the cam element forcing the quick release primary latch to rotate clockwise releasing the first primary latching surface from the cradle latching surface.
  • 7. A latching system for use in a molded case circuit breaker assembly comprising;a quick release primary latch having a first primary latching surface and a second primary latching surface; an interactive secondary latch having a first secondary latching surface which engages the second primary latching surface preventing the rotation of the quick release primary latch; a cradle having a cradle latching surface which engages the first primary latching surface preventing the rotation of the cradle; a trip bar assembled to the interactive secondary latch; and a linkage mechanism attaching the trip bar and the quick release primary latch, wherein activation of the trip bar rotates the secondary latch so that the first secondary latching surface moves out of contact with the second primary latching surface as the linkage mechanism drives the quick release primary latch thereby moving the first primary latching surface out of contact with the cradle latching surface releasing the cradle.
US Referenced Citations (175)
Number Name Date Kind
D. 367265 Yamagata et al. Feb 1996
2340682 Powell Feb 1944
2719203 Gelzheiser et al. Sep 1955
2937254 Ericson May 1960
3158717 Jencks et al. Nov 1964
3162739 Klein et al. Dec 1964
3197582 Norden Jul 1965
3307002 Cooper Feb 1967
3517356 Hanafusa Jun 1970
3631369 Menocal Dec 1971
3742401 Strobel Jun 1973
3803455 Willard Apr 1974
3883781 Cotton May 1975
4129762 Bruchet Dec 1978
4144513 Shafer et al. Mar 1979
4158119 Krakik Jun 1979
4165453 Hennemann Aug 1979
4166988 Ciarcia et al. Sep 1979
4220934 Wafer et al. Sep 1980
4255732 Wafer et al. Mar 1981
4259651 Yamat Mar 1981
4263492 Maier et al. Apr 1981
4276527 Gerbert-Gaillard et al. Jun 1981
4297663 Seymour et al. Oct 1981
4301342 Castonguay et al. Nov 1981
4360852 Gilmore Nov 1982
4368444 Preuss et al. Jan 1983
4375021 Pardini et al. Feb 1983
4375022 Daussin et al. Feb 1983
4376270 Staffen Mar 1983
4383146 Bur May 1983
4392036 Troebel et al. Jul 1983
4393283 Masuda Jul 1983
4401872 Boichot-Castagne et al. Aug 1983
4409573 DiMarco et al. Oct 1983
4435690 Link et al. Mar 1984
4467297 Boichot-Castagne et al. Aug 1984
4468645 Gerbert-Gaillard et al. Aug 1984
4470027 Link et al. Sep 1984
4479143 Watanabe et al. Oct 1984
4488133 McClellan et al. Dec 1984
4492941 Nagel Jan 1985
4541032 Schwab Sep 1985
4546224 Mostosi Oct 1985
4550300 Jencks et al. Oct 1985
4550360 Dougherty Oct 1985
4562419 Preuss et al. Dec 1985
4589052 Dougherty May 1986
4595812 Tamaru et al. Jun 1986
4611187 Banfi Sep 1986
4612430 Sloan et al. Sep 1986
4616198 Pardini Oct 1986
4622444 Kandatsu et al. Nov 1986
4622530 Ciarcia et al. Nov 1986
4631625 Alexander et al. Dec 1986
4642431 Tedesco et al. Feb 1987
4644438 Puccinelli et al. Feb 1987
4649247 Preuss et al. Mar 1987
4658322 Rivera Apr 1987
4672501 Bilac et al. Jun 1987
4675481 Markowski et al. Jun 1987
4682264 Demeyer Jul 1987
4689712 Demeyer Aug 1987
4694373 Demeyer Sep 1987
4710845 Demeyer Dec 1987
4717985 Demeyer Jan 1988
4733211 Castonguay et al. Mar 1988
4733321 Lindeperg Mar 1988
4736174 Castonguay et al. Apr 1988
4764650 Bur et al. Aug 1988
4768007 Mertz et al. Aug 1988
4780786 Weynachter et al. Oct 1988
4789848 Castonguay et al. Dec 1988
4831221 Yu et al. May 1989
4870531 Danek Sep 1989
4883931 Batteux et al. Nov 1989
4884047 Baginski et al. Nov 1989
4884164 Dziura et al. Nov 1989
4900882 Bernard et al. Feb 1990
4910485 Bolongeat-Mobleu et al. Mar 1990
4914541 Tripodi et al. Apr 1990
4916420 Bartolo et al. Apr 1990
4916421 Pardini et al. Apr 1990
4926282 McGhie May 1990
4935590 Malkin et al. Jun 1990
4937706 Schueller et al. Jun 1990
4939492 Raso et al. Jul 1990
4943691 Mertz et al. Jul 1990
4943888 Jacob et al. Jul 1990
4950855 Bolonegeat-Mobleu et al. Aug 1990
4951019 Gula Aug 1990
4952897 Barnel et al. Aug 1990
4958135 Baginski et al. Sep 1990
4965543 Batteux Oct 1990
4983788 Pardini Jan 1991
5001313 Leclerq et al. Mar 1991
5004878 Seymour et al. Apr 1991
5029301 Nebon et al. Jul 1991
5030804 Abri Jul 1991
5057655 Kersusan et al. Oct 1991
5077627 Fraisse Dec 1991
5083081 Barrault et al. Jan 1992
5095183 Raphard et al. Mar 1992
5103198 Morel et al. Apr 1992
5115371 Tripodi May 1992
5120921 DiMarco et al. Jun 1992
5132865 Mertz et al. Jul 1992
5138121 Streich et al. Aug 1992
5140115 Morris Aug 1992
5153802 Mertz et al. Oct 1992
5155315 Malkin et al. Oct 1992
5166483 Kersusan et al. Nov 1992
5172087 Castonguay et al. Dec 1992
5178504 Falchi Jan 1993
5184717 Chou et al. Feb 1993
5187339 Lissandrin Feb 1993
5198956 Dvorak Mar 1993
5200724 Gula et al. Apr 1993
5210385 Morel et al. May 1993
5239150 Bolongeat-Mobleu et al. Aug 1993
5260533 Livesey et al. Nov 1993
5262744 Arnold et al. Nov 1993
5280144 Bolongeat-Mobleu et al. Jan 1994
5281776 Morel et al. Jan 1994
5296660 Morel et al. Mar 1994
5296664 Crookston et al. Mar 1994
5298874 Morel et al. Mar 1994
5300907 Nereau et al. Apr 1994
5310971 Vial et al. May 1994
5313180 Vial et al. May 1994
5317471 Izoard et al. May 1994
5331500 Corcoles et al. Jul 1994
5334808 Bur et al. Aug 1994
5341191 Crookston et al. Aug 1994
5347096 Bolongeat-Mobleu et al. Sep 1994
5347097 Bolongeat-Mobleu et al. Sep 1994
5350892 Rozier Sep 1994
5357066 Morel et al. Oct 1994
5357068 Rozier Oct 1994
5357394 Piney Oct 1994
5361052 Ferullo et al. Nov 1994
5373130 Barrault et al. Dec 1994
5379013 Coudert Jan 1995
5424701 Castonguary et al. Jun 1995
5438176 Bonnardel et al. Aug 1995
5440088 Coudert et al. Aug 1995
5449871 Batteux et al. Sep 1995
5450048 Leger et al. Sep 1995
5451729 Onderka et al. Sep 1995
5457295 Tanibe et al. Oct 1995
5467069 Payet-Burin et al. Nov 1995
5469121 Payet-Burin Nov 1995
5475558 Barjonnet et al. Dec 1995
5477016 Baginski et al. Dec 1995
5479143 Payet-Burin Dec 1995
5483212 Lankuttis et al. Jan 1996
5485343 Santos et al. Jan 1996
5493083 Olivier Feb 1996
5504284 Lazareth et al. Apr 1996
5504290 Baginski et al. Apr 1996
5510761 Boder et al. Apr 1996
5512720 Coudert et al. Apr 1996
5515018 DiMarco et al. May 1996
5519561 Mrenna et al. May 1996
5534674 Steffens Jul 1996
5534832 Duchemin et al. Jul 1996
5534835 McColloch et al. Jul 1996
5534840 Cuingnet Jul 1996
5539168 Linzenich Jul 1996
5543595 Mader et al. Aug 1996
5552755 Fello et al. Sep 1996
5581219 Nozawa et al. Dec 1996
5604656 Derrick et al. Feb 1997
5608367 Zoller et al. Mar 1997
5784233 Bastard et al. Jul 1998
Foreign Referenced Citations (60)
Number Date Country
819 008 Dec 1974 BE
12 27 978 Mar 1966 DE
30 47 360 Jun 1982 DE
38 02 184 Aug 1989 DE
38 43 277 Jun 1990 DE
44 19 240 Jan 1995 DE
0 061 092 Sep 1982 EP
0 064 906 Nov 1982 EP
0 066 486 Dec 1982 EP
0 076 719 Apr 1983 EP
0 117 094 Aug 1984 EP
0 140 761 May 1985 EP
0 174 904 Mar 1986 EP
0 196 241 Oct 1986 EP
0 224 396 Jun 1987 EP
0 239 460 Sep 1987 EP
0 235 479 Sep 1987 EP
0 258 090 Mar 1988 EP
0 264 314 Apr 1988 EP
0 264 313 Apr 1988 EP
0 283 358 Sep 1988 EP
0 283 189 Sep 1988 EP
0 291 374 Nov 1988 EP
0 295 158 Dec 1988 EP
0 295 155 Dec 1988 EP
0 313 106 Apr 1989 EP
0 313 422 Apr 1989 EP
0 309 923 Apr 1989 EP
0 314 540 May 1989 EP
0 331 586 Sep 1989 EP
0 337 900 Oct 1989 EP
0 342 133 Nov 1989 EP
0 367 690 May 1990 EP
0 375 568 Jun 1990 EP
0 371 887 Jun 1990 EP
0 394 922 Oct 1990 EP
0 394 144 Oct 1990 EP
0 399 282 Nov 1990 EP
0 407 310 Jan 1991 EP
0 452 230 Oct 1991 EP
0 555 158 Aug 1993 EP
0 560 697 Sep 1993 EP
0 567 416 Oct 1993 EP
0 595 730 May 1994 EP
0 619 591 Oct 1994 EP
0 665 569 Aug 1995 EP
0 700 140 Mar 1996 EP
0 889 498 Jan 1999 EP
2 410 353 Jun 1979 FR
2 512 582 Mar 1983 FR
2 553 943 Apr 1985 FR
2 592 998 Jul 1987 FR
2 682 531 Apr 1993 FR
2 697 670 May 1994 FR
2 699 324 Jun 1994 FR
2 714 771 Jul 1995 FR
2 233 155 Jan 1991 GB
9200598 Jan 1992 WO
9205649 Apr 1992 WO
9400901 Jan 1994 WO