The present disclosure is directed to an improvement in a circuit breaker locator and tester. More specifically, the circuit breaker locator and tester has an improved ability to manage the strain of high current and heat generated during the testing process.
Circuit breaker locator and testers have been available for a number of years, and are valuable tools for use by those installing and evaluating electrical systems. Two examples are set forth in U.S. Pat. No. 7,713,428 “PORTABLE CIRCUIT INTERRUPTER SHUTOFF TESTING DEVICE AND METHOD”, and U.S. Pat. No. 7,199,587 “PORTABLE CIRCUIT INTERRUPTER TESTER AND METHOD”, the subject matter of which is incorporated herein by reference. In use, a circuit breaker locator/tester creates a brief surge of current that passes through various components and which generates heat within the device. This heat is then naturally dissipated over a period of time. However, if the circuit breaker locator/tester is used multiple times within a short time period, heat will not sufficiently dissipate, creating a cumulative heat build-up and potential problems. More specifically, this heat build-up can be destructive to the parts of the device and can possibly effect accuracy/efficiency of operation. Somewhat akin to tension in the Earth's crust going unnoticed but at some subsequent time being released in an undersea earthquake and only be expressed by an inevitable, disastrous and quite noticeable tsunami some distance way.
In one example, a switching element, e.g. a thyristor such as a power silicon controlled rectifier (SCR) which is often used in a portable circuit breaker locator/tester and can switch less current as its temperature increases. Stated differently, the SCR's current carrying capability is inversely related to temperature as shown in
Also, the locating/testing device will typically include a power resistor which is used for various purposes during the testing cycle. This power resistor also has a wattage rating, which essentially indicates how much heat it can withstand before it is destroyed or degraded. Naturally, it is very desirable to keep the operating conditions within acceptable ranges for this resistor, to avoid damage and maintain proper operation.
It is well recognized that a power resistor tends to burn up and create an open circuit, similarly to a fuse, when subjected to failure conditions (i.e. subjected to excess power levels and/or overheating). Conversely, when an SCR is used as a switch and it is subjected to excessive power and/or heat, it will burn up and create a short or closed circuit. Obviously, this can be dangerous and possibly life threatening.
A relatively unique situation with the circuit breaker locator/tester device is that it is creating heat within a very short period of time. For example, heat can be generated in a fraction of a single cycle of 120 VAC. Further, within the locator/tester device heat propagates from the heat generating points relatively slowly. Thus repeated usage can create accumulated heat before it is apparent to a user. For instance, if one is using an SCR for the switching element, the actual switching is occurring within a part which has a significant plastic shell. Consequently, it takes a length of time for the heat to emanate from the center to the surface of the SCR (i.e. to the outer surface of the plastic shell). Likewise, if a power resistor is being used for determining the current of the test cycle, it takes a length of time for the heat to emanate from the resistance wire through whatever coating or insulation is on the resistor before it will reach the resistor's surface.
This device is also unique in that it is carrying what would usually be considered to be tremendous amounts of current. For instance, it may carry 600 amps which may appear to exceed the ratings of the parts which carry the current. However, because the device's test cycle time is a fraction of a second (e.g. one half cycle of a standard 120 VAC 60 Hz power signal), it is only actually carrying 1/120th of that 600 amperes or the equivalent of 5 amps. The components of the device are selected to be able to carry such brief surges in current, but at the same time their current carrying capacity is inversely proportional to their temperature.
In addition to the SCR and power resistor, the other parts of the circuit breaker locator/tester device can operate improperly if subjected to excessive amounts of heat. Thus, the heat generated during testing can adversely affect many components.
Also, as heat is dissipated through the case of the device, it is less comfortable for a user to hold. Clearly, this is undesirable as it may lead to user injury.
Thus it would be beneficial to have a method for limiting the amount of heat generated to within a comfortable, safe operating area (SOA).
The desire is to disable the circuit breaker locator/tester device when a certain amount of heat has been generated, and then to enable the device again when it has cooled to within a safe operating temperature. Also it is desirable, although not necessary, to give the user some indication when the device is ready to use, or has paused to cool, so they won't think the device is simply out of order.
In order to address the above-outlined issues related to heating, the systems and method described herein provide a dual approach to heat management. Generally speaking, a temperature sensor is included within the device which monitors temperature at a predetermined location or area. This information is then provided to a controller which can decide whether the device should be shut down or paused for a period of time, or should continue to be operational. In addition, the controller circuit is capable of monitoring the frequency of operation, and using this information to control operation in a manner which will minimize heating effects. The monitoring of operation is carried out in a number of ways, including modeling based upon a parallel charge capacitor, or maintenance of a counter which tracks the operation time of the device. Based upon this information, a subsequent timing or delay sequence can be implemented, which will limit operation and avoid undesirable conditions.
As shown in
To deal with heat related issues, a temperature sensor circuit 1500 is also included, which is a simple potential divider circuit comprising a thermistor 1501 and a resistor 1502, which supplies micro-controller 134 with a voltage 1503 indicative of sensed temperature. For example, thermistor 1501 could be a 10 kΩ thermistor and resistor 1502 could be a resistor of 10 kΩ. In this configuration, the output voltage 1503 at a given baseline temperature will be half the supply voltage. When the resistance of thermistor 1501 changes due to changes in temperature, the fraction of the supply voltage across the thermistor also changes producing an output voltage 1503 that is proportional to the fraction of the total series resistance between the output terminals. Thermistor 1501 may be in physical contact with the power resistor through an electrically insulating but thermally transmissive medium, or not in direct contact but positioned to receive heat generated nearby.
As will be appreciated, there are many variations of temperature sensing circuits, thus circuit 1500 is simply one example. Likewise there are various types of temperature sensors available for use, such as Negative Temperature Coefficient (NTC) thermistors or semiconductor-based temperature sensors, each of which has their own advantages and circuit designs. It is further contemplated that any of these devices can be used to carry out the principles of the disclosed embodiments.
Temperature sensor circuit 1500 is used to detect the ambient temperature at a particular location within the device. Clearly, this information can be used to help determine if the device is operating within or outside of the safe operating area (SOA). That said, heat can build up in the load resistor during repeated uses which will not be immediately apparent or detectable by the temperature sensor. Unfortunately some span of time is typically required for the thermistor to become measurably heated and give an indication of the heat that is on its way. Additionally, once heat reaches the load resistor's surface and spreads throughout the locator/tester device, it can be destructive to the device's parts. Likewise there can be variations in the length of time required to dissipate the heat generated within the device. For instance, heat dissipation can vary depending on whether the device is in open air or in one's pocket.
While a temperature sensor, such as a thermistor, can be used to indicate when the device has cooled enough to be used again, it may not always respond fast enough to prevent a buildup of heat. As suggested above, if the device is triggered many times in quick succession heat buildup will occur, but will not be immediately detectable. Thus, it is desirable to have a supplemental approach to temperature sensing, and to provide real-time temperature monitoring.
Some embodiments include load resistor 120 (e.g., resistor/fuse R19), which acts as a high-current load (e.g., 0.15 ohms, 50 watts). In some embodiments, this resistor 120 acts as a fuse that opens if a high current is seen for too long a period, such as a failure of SCR 110 that shorts it, or a failure of controller circuit 130 that turns the SCR 110 on for too long a period of time.
Again, tester 100 includes one or more controllers 130 that stop conduction of the respective trip-testing function at a predetermined point in time that is related to the specified trip time of the circuit interrupter being tested. As will be further discussed below, operational options (such as the number of cycles per test or responses to thermistor input) will be controlled through programming the micro-controller 134.
For example, for testing an instantaneous-trip function of a circuit interrupter that specifies that it is to trip within 1/20 of a second (3 full cycles of 60 Hz AC), the switching element 110 conducts for a half cycle in some embodiments (in other embodiments, two, three, four, five, or six half cycles of conduction are used). In some embodiments, non-consecutive half cycles are used.
For the above embodiments, resistor 120 is about 0.15 ohms, which limits the short-circuit current to about (110 volts to 120 volts)/0.15 ohms, which equals about 733 to 800 amperes. Some embodiments will omit the current-limiting resistor 120, and instead will count on the internal resistance of the electronic switch 110 (or will incorporate a resistance into switch 110) along with the resistance of the wiring to limit the current during the half cycle(s) of switch 110 being activated.
If one is using other means, such as a counter, to anticipate over-heating from repeated uses, the counter records each cycle and starts a timer with the first cycle 1330. After a predetermined number of cycles have occurred within a given time period 1350 the device would pause 1360. Optionally a pause or delay between cycles 1325 will typically allow heat to emanate as shown with dashed line 1327. This allows the heat to emanate and reach the temperature sensor as in step 1335. If the maximum number of cycles within the given time period has not been reached 1355, then the device is ready to be used again 1315. Such a counter can work in isolation or in combination with a temperature sensor. If there is no temperature sensor then one can simply use empirical testing to define a pause of sufficient length to allow the device to stay within the SOA.
Either state (either the temperature sensor anticipating overheating 1345 or the counter reaching a predetermined number of cycles 1350), can cause the device to pause 1360. An optional indicator, such as an LED, can communicate to let the user know the device is paused 1365. The counter resets after a given time period 1370 and the temperature sensor cools 1375 giving the device time to achieve a safe operating temperature. When such a state has been achieved 1380 the optional pause indicator 1365 is turned off and device is re-enabled so it is ready to be used again 1315.
The idea is not simply to respond to overheating but to be able to anticipate a possible future overheated state and to accommodate cooling the device preemptively so it can operate within its safe operating area. Additionally, the temperature sensor circuit 1500 (as shown in
When the circuit breaker locator/tester device 100 is used, it attempts to trip a breaker by creating a brief current surge. If the breaker does not trip then the current surges for the entire period that the tester is on. If the breaker trips faster than the duration of the tester's programmed on-time, then less total current actually flows. Using a temperature sensor circuit 1500 with a delay can track such current via the heat created.
Since heat buildup in the tester is proportional to the total current that flows there is an advantage to measuring the actual current flow. This can be done various ways such as via measuring the on-time or by charging and discharging a resistor-capacitor network 153 having a charge capacitor 150 and a discharge resistor 152 (as shown in
Likewise, even if one is tracking current or number of cycles, if the temperature sensor circuit 1500 senses an overheating situation it can independently pause the device 100. This could occur, for instance, if the device 100 were in a hot environment. So the device can have one temperature setting for pausing and a different temperature setting for being re-enabled.
One can also have a default pause or delay before and/or after a test cycle to allow the heat generated to reach the temperature sensor 1501 and to allow the device to cool. The combination of a delay and a temperature sensor 1501 can then control when the device 100 is allowed to be used again. This combination of a delay and a temperature sensor can operate with or without an associated counter or other ways of tracking usage.
If one empirically determines the amount of heat generated and the amount of time it takes for the heat to reach the temperature sensor 1501, one can incorporate a delay of that amount of time between uses. For instance, if it takes 5 seconds for the heat to reach and heat up the sensor, then there could be a delay of 5 seconds between uses. Typically such an amount of time is between 1 and 10 seconds. Such a delay could come after the device is connected to the circuit of the circuit breaker but before it is possible to trigger the test cycle of the device or the delay could come after triggering or some combination of delays before and after the test cycle.
The foregoing is presented simply as one example of a way to perform the desired improved functions to the circuit breaker locator/tester 100. Those skilled in the art will understand there are other ways to accomplish such things as monitor temperature, track cumulative on-time, count number of times the device is cycled and allow pausing and re-enabling of a device and other functions mentioned in this disclosure. This may also include carrying out certain steps in a different order, or concurrently.
In another embodiment, the heat build-up in the power resistor 120 and SCR 110 is modeled by means of a stored charge on a modeling capacitor 150 as shown in sub-section 153 in
In this embodiment, the capacitor 150 charges a little bit every time the device is activated, and the capacitor will discharge at a controlled rate through a resistor 152. The rate of discharge of the capacitor 150 models the cooling down of the power resistor. The charge will persist through power-downs, so it fills the function of a non-volatile memory and timer when the microcontroller is not running.
Operational options (such as the number of half cycles of virtual short-circuit) is controlled through programming the microcontroller. Optionally, there can be an on-board option selection switch to select the number of on cycles.
The foregoing is presented simply as one example of a way to perform the desired functions of temperature management. Those skilled in the art will understand there are other ways to monitor temperature, track cumulative on time or current and allow pausing and reenabling of a device.
Either state, either the temperature sensor overheating 1425 or the capacitor reaching the charged state 1435, can cause the device to pause 1437. An optional indicator, such as an LED, can communicate to let the user know the device is paused 1445. The capacitor discharges 1450 and the temperature sensor cools 1455 giving the device time to achieve a safe operating temperature 1460. When such a state has been achieved the optional pause indicator can turn off (not shown) and the ready to use indicator can be activated 1410. Now the user can use the tester again 1405.
Again, the basic idea is to be able to anticipate an overheated state and to accommodate cooling of the device so it can operate within its safe operating area. One could have such a setup without a temperature sensor being incorporated. In such a case one would simply trust in the capacitor/resistor or other control means to control the activation and pausing by anticipating what heating might occur during usage. Additionally, having the temperature sensor allows for controlling the device's usage in various situations, for instance, if the user puts the device into an insulated area such as a coat pocket where it cools more slowly or if it is placed where it can cool more rapidly such as in free air. So while having a means to anticipate the heating is essential, in actual practice the heat sensor may be deemed unnecessary. Likewise, if the temperature sensor can be positioned such that it can sense temperature changes relatively instantaneously, such as if it were wrapped in the resistance wire of the power resistor, then the sample capacitor/resistor may be deemed necessary. Also, it may be of use to have predetermined time delay between test cycles which could allow the emanated heat to reach the temperature sensor. This and other such variations and combinations are well known to those skilled in the art.
When the circuit breaker locator/tester is used it attempts to trip a breaker by creating a brief current surge. If the breaker does not trip then the current surges for the entire period that the tester is on. If the breaker trips faster than the duration of the tester's maximum on time, then less total current actually flows. Since heat buildup in the tester is proportional to the total current that flows there is an advantage to measuring the actual current flow. This can be done various ways such as via measuring the time on or by charging a capacitor while the test is in progress. On the other hand, a designer may find advantage in simply counting the number of on-cycles or number of test periods instead. These are just a few ways a designer can anticipate an overheating situation to pause the device so it has a chance to cool and to also allow time for the generated heat to reach a temperature sensor which can also serve to pause the device until cooled to a safe operating temperature.
Likewise, if the temperature sensor senses an overheating situation it can independently pause the device. This could occur, for instance, if the device were in a hot environment.
One could also have a default pause or delay after a test cycle to allow the heat generated to reach the temperature sensor and/or to allow the device to cool. If such a temperature sensor is incorporated then said temperature sensor can then control when the device is allowed to cycle again.
Obviously, if one is using a different way to anticipate repeated uses, such as a counter, then the device would pause after a predetermined number of cycles within a predetermined amount of time. This allows the heat to emanate and reach the temperature sensor. Such a counter can work in isolation or in combination with a temperature sensor. If there is no temperature sensor then one can simply use empirical testing to define a pause of sufficient length to allow the device to cool and stay within the SOA. A method, such as a counter, could include a power source such as a battery, so that it is not reset simply by being plugged out and back in or incorporate a type of memory which is retained in such a situation.
Alternatively, if one determines the amount of heat generated and the amount of time it takes for the heat to reach the temperature sensor, one can incorporate a delay between uses. For instance, if it takes 5 seconds for the heat to reach and heat up the sensor, then there could be a delay of 5 seconds between uses. Such a delay could come after the device is connected to the circuit of the circuit breaker before it is possible to trigger the test cycle of the device or the delay could come after triggering or some combination of part of the delay before and part of the delay after the test cycle. Likewise there could be variable delay lengths depending on the number of test cycles or length of on time or actual measurement of current passed.
A display, such as a series of lights, could show the delay time elapsing so the user will have an indication of when the device will be ready for use.
As outlined above, the circuit breaker locator/tester 100 comprises a current anticipating portion and real time temperature sensing portion which work cooperatively and independently to control pausing and enabling the device so as to keep the tester within a comfortable safe operating temperature. Variations have also been presented, such as a counter or time delays, or controlled capacitor discharge, which can also perform the job of anticipating and handling heat generation to keep the tester within a comfortable safe operating temperature.
As set forth above, the following components have been discussed and described:
Having thus described several illustrative embodiments, it is to be appreciated that various alterations, modifications, and improvements will readily occur to those skilled in the art. Such alterations, modifications, and improvements are intended to be part of this disclosure, and are intended to be within the spirit and scope of this disclosure. While some examples presented herein involve specific combinations of functions or structural elements, it should be understood that those functions and elements may be combined in other ways according to the present invention to accomplish the same or different objectives. In particular, acts, elements, and features discussed in connection with one embodiment are not intended to be excluded from similar or other roles in other embodiments. Accordingly, the foregoing description and attached drawings are by way of example only, and are not intended to be limiting.
The present application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/590,834, filed Nov. 27, 2017, which is incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62590834 | Nov 2017 | US |