Circuit interrupter with improved trip bar assembly accomodating internal space constraints

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6208228
  • Patent Number
    6,208,228
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, February 16, 2000
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 27, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A circuit interrupter including a housing, separable main contacts within the housing, and an operating mechanism within the housing and interconnected with the contacts. A trip mechanism is disposed within the housing and includes a rotatable trip bar assembly that, when selectively rotated, generates a tripping operation. The trip bar assembly includes an attaching structure which interconnects with an accessory trip member. The accessory trip member causes the trip bar assembly to rotate and generate a tripping operation when the accessory trip member is moved in a first direction. The accessory trip member is configured to enable flexing of the accessory trip member in a second direction opposite of the first direction.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates to circuit interrupters generally and, more specifically, to those kinds of circuit interrupters having a trip bar assembly that rotates during a tripping operation.




2. Description of the Prior Art




Molded case circuit breakers and interrupters are well known in the art as exemplified by U.S. Pat. No. 4,503,408 issued Mar. 5, 1985, to Mrenna et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 5,910,760 issued Jun. 8, 1999 to Malingowski et al., each of which is assigned to the assignee of the present application and incorporated herein by reference.




A continuing industry objective with respect to many types of circuit interrupters is to be able to reduce the size and/or footprint of the interrupter housing while at the same time providing the same or improved performance capabilities. A major advantage of creating such a “smaller package” is that it provides increased flexibility in installation. However, a consequence of this objective is that the internal space constraints of such interrupters have become much more limiting, posing certain design obstacles that need to be overcome.




Circuit interrupters include trip mechanisms that can be activated in a variety of manners so as to set in motion a tripping operation to open the contacts of the interrupter. These trip mechanisms often employ a rotatable trip bar assembly that, when selectively rotated, releases a portion of the operating mechanism to thereby generate a tripping operation.




Such circuit interrupters advantageously provide for automatic circuit interruption that causes the trip bar assembly to rotate when an overcurrent condition is sensed. This automatic interruption may be thermally, magnetically, or otherwise based. In addition, such circuit interrupters often enable a tripping operation to be manually initiated by implementation of a push-to-trip member which, when pressed, contacts and rotates the trip bar assembly.




Circuit interrupters may also advantageously have accessory devices, such as an undervoltage release (UVR) or a shunt trip, connected thereto. Such accessory devices can likewise initiate a tripping operation, and typically do so by contacting and rotating an accessory trip lever on the trip bar assembly that then causes the trip bar assembly to rotate. However, because of the required positioning and size of such an accessory trip lever, the lever sweeps through a relatively large range of motion within the circuit interrupter whenever any type of tripping operation occurs. Therefore, it is difficult to employ such an accessory trip lever within a circuit interrupter having the aforementioned internal space constraints. Internal components of such a circuit interrupter may obstruct the rotational movement of the accessory trip lever and undesirably prevent the trip bar assembly from sufficiently rotating in certain circumstances.




One problem associated with accessory trip lever obstruction is encountered when a bimetal is used to implement a thermal tripping operation. The bimetal reacts to current flowing therethrough, with the temperature of the bimetal being proportional to the current magnitude. As current magnitude increases, the heat buildup in the bimetal has a tendency to cause a bottom portion thereof to deflect (bend). When non-overcurrent conditions exist, this deflection is minimal. However, above a predetermined current level, the temperature of the bimetal will exceed a threshold temperature whereby the deflection causes the bottom portion to make contact with a thermal trip member of the trip bar assembly. This contact forces the trip bar assembly to rotate and generate a tripping operation.




Under certain circumstances, such as a short circuit condition or the presence of excessively high currents, the bimetal can quickly heat up to a higher temperature, causing the bimetal to deflect faster and to a greater extent than normal under overcurrent conditions. This enhanced deflection has a tendency to cause greater rotation of the trip bar assembly than what is necessary in order to generate a tripping operation, the movement of which can be hindered by the aforementioned obstruction of an accessory trip lever. Unfortunately, by preventing the trip bar assembly from continuing to rotate in this situation, an obstruction can prevent the bimetal from fully and properly deflecting, thereby undesirably causing the bimetal to “take a set.” Such an event can destroy the calibration of the bimetal and prevent it from being properly calibrated thereafter.




Therefore, it would be advantageous if a way existed by which an accessory device tripping operation could be conveniently and effectively implemented within a circuit interrupter having internal space constraints. In particular, it would be advantageous if a way existed by which to accommodate for an aforementioned obstruction of an accessory trip lever while, at the same time, enabling the trip bar assembly to continue to rotate during a tripping operation.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides a circuit interrupter that meets all of the above-identified needs.




In accordance with the present invention, a circuit interrupter is provided which includes a housing, separable main contacts within the housing, and an operating mechanism within the housing and interconnected with the separable main contacts. A trip mechanism is disposed within the housing and includes a rotatable trip bar assembly that, when selectively rotated, generates a tripping operation causing the operating mechanism to open the contacts. The trip bar assembly includes an attaching structure which interconnects with an accessory trip member. The accessory trip member causes the trip bar assembly to rotate and generate a tripping operation when the accessory trip member is moved in a first direction. The accessory trip member is configured to enable flexing of the accessory trip member in a second direction opposite of said first direction.




This and other objects and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from a reading of the following description of the preferred embodiment taken in connection with the attached drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an orthogonal view of a molded case circuit interrupter embodying the present invention.





FIG. 2

is an exploded view of the base, primary cover, and secondary cover of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a side elevational view of an internal portion of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 4

is an orthogonal view of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 5

is another orthogonal view of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of

FIG. 1

showing how the accessory trip levers are inserted.





FIG. 6A

is an orthogonal view of the attaching structures of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 6B

is another orthogonal view of the attaching structures of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 7A

is an orthogonal view of an accessory trip lever of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 7B

is an orthogonal view of the lower lever portion of an accessory trip lever.





FIG. 7C

is an orthogonal view of the upper lever portion of an accessory trip lever.





FIG. 8

is an orthogonal view of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of

FIG. 1

depicting the insertion of an accessory trip lever.





FIG. 9

is an orthogonal view depicting the locking in of an inserted accessory trip lever.





FIG. 10A

is an orthogonal side view of the trip bar assembly of the circuit interrupter of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 10B

is another orthogonal side view of the trip bar assembly with an accessory trip lever bent to the right.





FIG. 10C

is another orthogonal side view of the trip bar assembly with an accessory trip lever bent to the left.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




Referring now to the drawings and

FIGS. 1 and 2

in particular, shown is a molded case circuit interrupter or breaker


10


. A detailed description of the general structure and operation of circuit beaker


10


can be found in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/386,126, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference. Briefly, circuit breaker


10


includes a base


12


mechanically interconnected with a primary cover


14


. Disposed on top of primary cover


14


is an auxiliary or secondary cover


16


. When removed, secondary cover


16


renders some internal portions of the circuit breaker available for maintenance and the like without requiring disassembly of the entire circuit breaker. Base


12


includes internal phase walls


20


,


21


, and


22


. Holes or openings


23


A are provided in primary cover


14


for accepting screws or other attaching devices that enter corresponding holes or openings


23


B in base


12


for fastening primary cover


14


to base


12


. Holes or openings


24


A are provided in secondary cover


16


for accepting screws or other attaching devices that enter corresponding holes or openings


24


B in primary cover


14


for fastening secondary cover


16


to primary cover


14


. Holes


25


, which feed through secondary cover


16


, primary cover


14


, and into base


12


(one side showing holes


25


), are provided for access to electrical terminal areas of circuit breaker


10


. Holes


26


A, which feed through secondary cover


16


, correspond to holes


26


that feed through primary cover


14


and base


12


, and are provided for attaching the entire circuit breaker assembly onto a wall, or into a DIN rail back panel or a load center, or the like. Surfaces


29


and


30


of secondary cover


16


are for placement of labels onto circuit breaker


10


. Primary cover


14


includes cavities


31


,


32


, and


33


for placement of internal accessories of circuit breaker


10


. Secondary cover


16


includes a secondary cover handle opening


36


. Primary cover


14


includes a primary cover handle opening


38


. A handle


40


(

FIG. 1

) protrudes through openings


36


and


38


and is used in a conventional manner to manually open and close the contacts of circuit breaker


10


and to reset circuit breaker


10


when it is in a tripped state. Handle


40


may also provide an indication of the status of circuit breaker


10


whereby the position of handle


40


corresponds with a legend (not shown) on secondary cover


16


near handle opening


36


which clearly indicates whether circuit breaker


10


is ON (contacts closed), OFF (contacts open), or TRIPPED (contacts open due to, for example, an overcurrent condition). Secondary cover


16


and primary cover


14


include rectangular openings


42


and


44


, respectively, through which protrudes a top portion


46


(

FIG. 1

) of a button for a push-to-trip actuator. Also shown are load conductor openings


48


in base


12


that shield and protect load terminals


50


. Although circuit breaker


10


is depicted as a four phase circuit breaker, the present invention is not limited to four-phase operation.




Referring now to

FIG. 3

, a longitudinal section of a side elevation, partially broken away and partially in phantom, of circuit breaker


10


is shown having a load terminal


50


and a line terminal


52


. There is shown a plasma arc acceleration chamber


54


comprising a slot motor assembly


56


and an arc extinguisher assembly


58


. Also shown is a contact assembly


60


, an operating mechanism


62


, and a trip mechanism


64


including a rotatable trip bar assembly


122


. Although not viewable in

FIG. 3

, each phase of circuit breaker


10


has its own load terminal


50


, line terminal


52


, plasma arc acceleration chamber


54


, slot motor assembly


56


, arc extinguisher assembly


58


, and contact assembly


60


. Reference is often made herein to only one such group of components and their constituents for the sake of simplicity.




Each contact assembly


60


is shown as comprising a movable contact arm


78


supporting thereon a movable contact


80


, and a stationary contact arm


82


supporting thereon a stationary contact


84


. Each stationary contact arm


82


is electrically connected to a line terminal


52


and, although not shown, each movable contact arm


78


is electrically connected to a load terminal


50


. Also shown is a crossbar assembly


86


which traverses the width of circuit breaker


10


and is rotatably disposed on an internal portion of base


12


(not shown). Actuation of operating mechanism


62


causes crossbar assembly


86


and movable contact arms


78


to rotate into or out of a disposition which places movable contacts


80


into or out of a disposition of electrical continuity with fixed contacts


84


.




Operating mechanism


62


comprises a handle arm or handle assembly


92


(connected to handle


40


), a configured plate or cradle


94


, an upper toggle link


96


, an interlinked lower toggle link


98


, and an upper toggle link pivot pin


100


which interlinks upper toggle link


96


with cradle


94


. Lower toggle link


98


is pivotally interconnected with upper toggle link


96


by way of an intermediate toggle link pivot pin


102


, and with crossbar assembly


86


at a pivot pin


90


. Provided is a cradle pivot pin


104


which is laterally and rotatably disposed between parallel, spaced apart operating mechanism support members or sideplates


106


. Cradle


94


is free to rotate (within limits) via cradle pivot pin


104


. A main stop bar


112


is laterally disposed between sideplates


106


, and provides a limit to the counter-clockwise movement of cradle


94


.




In

FIG. 3

, operating mechanism


62


is shown for the ON disposition of circuit breaker


10


. In this disposition, contacts


80


and


84


are closed (in contact with each other) whereby electrical current may flow from load terminals


50


to line terminals


52


.




Operating mechanism


62


will assume the TRIPPED disposition of circuit breaker


10


in certain circumstances. The TRIPPED disposition is related to an opening of circuit breaker


10


caused by a manual tripping operation, an accessory tripping operation (as described below), or the thermally or magnetically induced reaction of trip mechanism


64


to the magnitude of the current flowing between load conductors


50


and line conductors


52


. A detailed description of the manual tripping operation and the automatic operation of trip mechanism


64


can be found in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/386,126. Whatever the nature of a tripping operation, it is initiated by a force causing trip bar assembly


122


to rotate clockwise (overcoming a spring force biasing assembly


122


in the opposite direction) and away from an intermediate latch


114


. This unlocking of latch


114


releases cradle


94


(which had been held in place at a lower portion


116


of a latch cutout region


118


) and enables it to be rotated counter-clockwise under the influence of tension springs (not shown) interacting between the top of handle assembly


92


and the intermediate toggle link pivot pin


102


. The resulting collapse of the toggle arrangement causes pivot pin


90


to be rotated clockwise and upwardly to thus cause crossbar assembly


86


to similarly rotate. This rotation of crossbar assembly


86


causes a clockwise motion of movable contact arms


78


, resulting in a separation of contacts


80


and


84


.




Referring now to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, shown is trip bar assembly


122


of trip mechanism


64


of the exemplary embodiment. Assembly


122


includes a trip bar or shaft


140


to which is connected thermal trip bars or paddles


142


, magnetic trip bars or paddles


144


, and accessory trip levers


148


A and


148


B. Trip bar assembly


122


also includes an intermediate latch interface


150


that locks with intermediate latch


114


(

FIG. 3

) when trip bar assembly


122


has not rotated clockwise during a tripping operation.




Circuit breaker


10


includes the ability to provide accessory tripping operations which can cause trip bar assembly


122


to rotate in the clockwise direction and thereby release cradle


94


. Referring now briefly again to

FIG. 2

, primary cover


14


includes cavities


32


and


33


into which may be inserted internal accessories for circuit breaker


10


. Examples of such conventional internal accessories include an undervoltage release (UVR), and a shunt trip. Each of cavities


32


and


33


includes a rightward opening (not shown) that provides access into base


12


and which faces trip mechanism


64


. In particular, the opening within cavity


32


provides actuating access to accessory trip lever


148


A, and the opening within cavity


33


provides actuating access to accessory trip lever


148


B (see FIG.


4


). When an appropriate accessory device, located in cavity


33


for example, operates in a conventional manner whereby it determines that a tripping operation of circuit breaker


10


should be initiated, a plunger or the like comes out of the device and protrudes through the rightward opening in cavity


33


and makes contact with a contact surface


160


of accessory trip lever


148


B. This contact causes trip lever


148


B to move to the right, thereby causing a clockwise (when viewed in

FIG. 3

) rotation of trip bar assembly


122


which leads to the TRIPPED disposition.




Internal components of circuit breaker


10


, such as portions of primary cover


14


, may obstruct the rotational movement of the top of an accessory trip lever


148


during clockwise rotation of trip bar assembly


122


during any type of tripping operation (push-to-trip, thermal, magnetic, etc.). This is especially true in a circuit breaker having internal space constraints. Such an obstruction can prevent lever


148


from continuing to rotate in the clockwise direction. In a manner described below, circuit breaker


10


of the present invention ensures that trip bar assembly


122


can continue to sufficiently rotate in the clockwise direction during a tripping operation notwithstanding such obstruction of an accessory trip lever


148


.




Referring again to

FIGS. 4 and 5

, trip bar assembly


122


includes integrally molded attaching devices or structures


166


that connect accessory trip levers


148


A and


148


B to trip bar assembly


122


. Referring now also to

FIGS. 6A and 6B

, each of the attaching structures


166


of the exemplary embodiment includes an open-ended cavity


168


defined by a front wall


170


, sidewalls


172


and


174


, and a backwall


176


. For purposes described below, front wall


170


includes a groove


178


positioned within cavity


168


and extending from the top of wall


170


to a point above the bottom thereof (see FIG.


8


). The tops of sidewalls


172


and


174


each define a shoulder


180


and


182


, respectively, for purposes described below. The above-described configuration of attaching structure


166


can be advantageously molded into trip bar assembly


122


without complicated molding processes such as bypass molding or side pull molding.




Now referring also to

FIGS. 7A

,


7


B and


7


C, shown is an accessory trip lever


148


of the exemplary embodiment. Accessory trip lever


148


is comprised of a lower lever portion or accessory lower lever


190


, and an upper lever portion or accessory spring lever


192


. As best seen in

FIG. 7B

, lower lever portion


190


includes a base


196


connected to a head


198


which defines abutment surfaces


200


and


202


. Base


196


includes a protrusion


204


which, in the exemplary embodiment, is oval in shape. Also connected to base


196


are parallel legs


206


with a cutout


208


therebetween. Legs


206


have abutment regions


206


A for purposes described below. Lower lever portion


190


also includes a front surface


209


. In the exemplary embodiment, lower lever portion


190


is formed of cold-rolled steel of sufficient thickness so as to be substantially rigid.




As best seen in

FIG. 7C

, upper lever portion


192


of accessory trip lever


148


is rectangular in shape and includes a lower end region


210


through which extends an opening


212


that is sized and shaped to correspond to protrusion


204


of lower lever portion


190


. Near its top, upper lever portion


192


includes a contact surface


160


(as described above). In the exemplary embodiment, upper lever portion


192


is formed of stainless spring steel having a thickness of approximately 0.010 inches, and is semi-flexible for reasons discussed below.




Accessory trip lever


148


is assembled by inserting protrusion


204


of lower lever portion


190


into opening


212


of upper lever portion


192


in the manner shown in FIG.


7


A. In this configuration, the back surface of portion


192


contacts front surface


209


of portion


190


, with contact surface


160


positioned above head


198


of portion


190


. As shown in

FIG. 7A

, the width of base


196


of lower lever portion


190


is approximately the same as the width of upper lever portion


192


.




Each of accessory trip levers


148


A and


148


B (assembled as shown in

FIG. 7A

) insert into attaching structures


166


in order to be connected to trip bar assembly


122


. Referring now also to

FIG. 8

wherein a portion of front wall


170


of attaching structure


166


is cut away for purposes of illustration, the insertion process begins with the insertion of legs


206


into cavity


168


, and continues until abutment surfaces


200


and


202


abut shoulders


180


and


182


, respectively. During this insertion, protrusion


204


of accessory trip lever


148


is channeled into groove


178


of front wall


170


, resulting in the insertion of lower end region


210


of upper lever portion


192


within cavity


168


and the locking together of lower lever portion


190


and upper lever portion


192


.




After insertion of an accessory trip lever


148


as described above, legs


206


of lower lever portion


190


protrude through the bottom of cavity


168


, as shown in FIG.


8


. Referring now also to

FIG. 9

, legs


206


are then bent outwards and away from each other until abutment regions


206


A of legs


206


abut the bottoms of sidewalls


172


and


174


(see FIG.


6


B), thereby vertically locking accessory trip lever


148


within cavity


168


and providing a secure engagement of lever


148


with trip bar assembly


122


. In order to achieve the aforementioned separation of legs


206


, an arbor press with a V-shaped mandrel may be used.




The attachment of an accessory trip lever


148


to an attaching structure


166


enables lever


148


to cause a clockwise rotation of trip bar assembly


122


(when viewed in

FIG. 3

) when contact surface


160


is contacted by one of the above-described accessory devices during an accessory tripping operation. Referring now also to

FIGS. 10A

,


10


B, and


10


C,

FIG. 10A

shows a side view of a completely assembled trip bar assembly


122


without the application of any external forces thereon. When contact surface


160


is first contacted by an accessory device, upper lever portion


192


may slightly bend to the right at an upper bending moment


220


located along the length of portion


192


substantially at the point where it contacts the top of head


198


of lower lever position


190


, as shown in FIG.


10


B. However, the position of upper bending moment


220


makes upper lever portion


192


sufficiently rigid such that further force exerted upon contact surface


160


causes rotation of trip bar assembly


122


which, in turn, initiates a tripping operation.




In order to accommodate for an aforementioned obstruction of an accessory trip lever


148


, and yet enable trip bar assembly


122


to continue to sufficiently rotate in the clockwise direction during a tripping operation, trip lever


148


is capable of more substantial bending than that shown in FIG.


10


B. In particular, referring to

FIG. 10C

, when an obstruction occurs, upper


30


lever portion


192


bends to the left at a lower bending moment


222


located along the length of portion


192


substantially at the point where it contacts attaching structure


166


. Because bending moment


222


is positioned lower along the length of upper lever portion


192


than upper bending moment


220


(FIG.


10


B), portion


192


is afforded greater flexibility when bent to the left than when bent to the right, thereby allowing trip bar assembly


122


to continue to sufficiently rotate in the clockwise direction during a tripping operation notwithstanding an obstruction.




As described above, accessory trip lever


148


of the present invention is designed to be sufficiently rigid when force is applied to it in a rightward direction (as viewed in

FIG. 10B

) and sufficiently flexible when force is applied to it in a leftward direction (as viewed in FIG.


10


C). The positioning of lower lever portion


190


relative to upper lever portion


192


, and the material used for and thickness of upper lever portion


192


, are appropriately selected in order to provide this desired functionality.




Although the preferred embodiment of the present invention has been described with a certain degree of particularity, various changes to form and detail may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as hereinafter claimed.



Claims
  • 1. A circuit interrupter comprising:a housing; separable main contacts within said housing; an operating mechanism within said housing and interconnected with said separable main contacts; and a trip mechanism within said housing and including a rotatable trip bar assembly that, when rotated, generates a tripping operation causing said operating mechanism to open said separable main contacts, said rotatable trip bar assembly including an attaching structure having a cavity into which an accessory trip member is inserted, said accessory trip member causing said rotatable trip bar assembly to rotate and generate said tripping operation when said accessory trip member is moved in a first direction, said accessory trip member including a lower portion and an upper portion positioned partially adjacent to said lower portion, said upper portion extending a greater distance away from said attaching structure than said lower portion, said lower portion including a protrusion that inserts through an opening in said upper portion, said cavity including a recess into which said protrusion then inserts when said accessory trip member is inserted into said cavity.
  • 2. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 1 wherein said lower portion is positioned to generate a first bending moment in said upper portion when said upper portion is moved in said first direction and a second bending moment in said upper portion when said upper portion is moved in a second direction opposite of said first direction.
  • 3. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 2 wherein said first bending moment is positioned further away from said attaching structure than said second bending moment.
  • 4. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 1 wherein said accessory trip member includes leg portions that are inserted into and extend past said cavity and that are bent to abut portions of said rotatable trip bar assembly and thereby prevent said accessory trip member from being removed from said cavity.
  • 5. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 4 wherein said attaching structure includes a shoulder and said accessory trip member includes a ledge that abuts said shoulder upon full insertion of said accessory trip member into said cavity.
  • 6. A circuit interrupter comprising:a housing; separable main contacts within said housing; an operating mechanism within said housing and interconnected with said separable main contacts; and a trip mechanism within said housing and including a rotatable trip bar assembly that, when rotated, generates a tripping operation causing said operating mechanism to open said separable main contacts, said rotatable trip bar assembly including an attaching structure including a cavity into which an accessory trip member is inserted, said accessory trip member causing said rotatable trip bar assembly to rotate and generate said tripping operation when said accessory trip member is moved in a first direction, said accessory trip member having leg portions that are inserted into and extend past said cavity and that are bent to abut portions of said rotatable trip bar assembly and thereby prevent said accessory trip member from being removed from said cavity.
  • 7. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 6 wherein said accessory trip member comprises a lower portion and an upper portion positioned partially adjacent to said lower portion, said upper portion extending a greater distance away from said attaching structure than said lower portion, and wherein said lower portion includes said leg portions.
  • 8. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 7 wherein said lower portion includes a protrusion and said upper portion includes an opening through which said protrusion is inserted.
  • 9. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 8 wherein said cavity includes a recess into which said protrusion inserts when said accessory trip member is inserted into said cavity.
  • 10. The circuit interrupter as defined in claim 6 wherein said attaching structure includes a shoulder and said accessory trip member includes a ledge that abuts said shoulder upon full insertion of said accessory trip member into said cavity.
US Referenced Citations (7)
Number Name Date Kind
3973230 Ciarcia et al. Aug 1976
4503408 Mrenna et al. Mar 1985
5469121 Payet-Burin Nov 1995
5479143 Payet-Burin Dec 1995
5581219 Nozawa et al. Dec 1996
5831499 Batteux et al. Nov 1998
5986225 Castonguay et al. Nov 1999