In the field of heat exchange, a clamping system that securely fastens to one or more tubes in a heat exchanger to prevent damaging movement of the tubes within the tube bundle and to improve the performance of the vibration limiting attachments in minimizing damage to the tubes.
Tube bundles are typically used in shell-and-tube heat exchangers where the tubes, often a tube bundle, contain fluid flow of one temperature and surrounding fluid flow outside of the tubes (also referred to as the “shell side”) is at another temperature, which then enables heating or cooling of the different fluid flows due to contact with the external tube surfaces.
Fluid flow patterns around the tubes often gives rise to flow-induced vibrations of an organized or random oscillatory nature. Such vibration is known to damage the tubes so that solutions that minimize tube vibration are sought after.
Fastening rows of tubes together can be accomplished by mechanically connecting two or more rows of tubes. In one example, one or more stakes are inserted between columns formed by rows of tubes in a tube bundle often press against the external tube walls and the interference between the stake and the tube walls creates frictional-surface contact between the stake and the tubes. Preferably, the thickness of the stake is slightly greater than the lane width so that the tubes are slightly warped as well thereby increasing stiffness of the tubes that will also add to vibration mitigation. These columns are sometimes referred to as “lanes” because they extend from top to bottom of a tube set, from left to right in a tube bundle, or at any angle in-between in a tube bundle. The frictional-surface contact between the stake and the tubes provides additional tube support and thereby diminishes tube vibration.
A stake may have one or more protrusions that are intended to engage the surface of a tube and hold the stake and the tube in place. Alternatively, a stake may be softer than the tube so that it compresses against the tubes to hold it in place against the tubes. Finally, a stake may have periodic curved “saddles” that rest against each tube in the lane in a more stable engagement that resists movement of both the stake and the tubes.
A clamping system secures to at least one tube in a tube bundle of a heat exchanger in order to reduce vibration damage. The clamping system includes a first clamping component having a J-shape, a second clamping component having an L-shape, and a means for resisting movement of the clamping components.
The first clamping component with a J-shape covers a first arc around a tube in the tube bundle greater than 10 degrees of the tube. The straight part of the J-shape defines a first aperture. The curved part of the J-shape may be configured to define first fingers made flexible by one or more first cuts defined within the lower curved part of the J-shape.
The second clamping component with an L-shape covers a second arc opposite the first arc greater than 10 degrees of the tube. The vertical-leg segment of the L-shape fits against the straight part of the J-shape and defines a second aperture that aligns with the first aperture. The second arc of the L-shape may be configured to define second fingers made flexible by one or more second cuts within the horizontal-leg segment of the L-shape.
The first arc around the tube plus the second arc around the tube is equal to at least 100 degrees.
The means for resisting movement may include a stake defining a third aperture; a nut; and a bolt. The bolt is configured to fit through the first aperture, the second aperture and the third aperture when the first aperture, the second aperture and the third aperture are placed in alignment.
The means for resisting movement may include a stake and a self-tapping screw to pierce the stake to secure the first clamping component and a second clamping component to the stake.
The means for resisting movement may include at least two stakes fitting in different lanes of the tube bundle and two clamp sets that are joined together with at least three nuts and a long bolt.
The means for resisting movement may include a stake configured with an elongated channel and having a planar side and an open side with two extensions. The stake defines a third aperture. This means for resisting movement includes a bolt that fits through aligned apertures and a nut that is threadably attachable to the bolt.
The clamping system may include a flexible washer having a thickness within a range of 0.2 to 3 millimeters, and configured to occupy a position between the second clamping component and the first clamping component.
Heat exchangers have tube bundles that are vulnerable to vibration damage as fluids flow within the tubes and external to the tubes in the tube bundle. The external flow is considered to be the greater contributor to vibration damage. When the tube side has a liquid, the tube resists vibration a little more than if it is gas owing to increased dampening from the denser liquid flow. The U-bend region of a tube bundle is often the most vulnerable position involving stake retention problems.
Typically, for newly manufactured bundles, metal bars are used in initial fabrication. The metal bars have a series of half-holes at two edges to partially engage with the walls of the tubes; then these bars are welded together. This approach is not considered practical for an existing bundle. However, this design is used currently during new bundle fabrication as a vibration mitigation step, or simply for structural reasons even when vibration damage is highly unlikely or for both reasons.
A typical solution in older tube bundles has been to use a stake wedged in between columns of tubes and perhaps held in place with protrusions from the stake. The use of a stake wedged in a lane of tubing in a tube bundle is known to mitigate tube damage due to vibrations that are inherent in using tube bundles carrying a fluid. However, the stakes are known to loosen or shift before, during and after use to cause damage.
The typical solution of using a stake has been known to fail. Aside from vibration causing the stake to be displaced from its installed position, damage can occur when a stake is dislodged during bundle installation, operation, cleaning, or other handling and movement of the heat exchanger. If the stake becomes displaced or dislodged and then gets stuck in a nozzle, or even in other equipment downstream, it can be difficult to remove and could result in equipment damage.
The solution is an improved clamping system with or without a stake within the tube bundle that can increase vibration-dampening performance. When used without a stake, the clamping system physically locks adjacent tubes together to prevent vibration damage.
When used with a stake, the clamping system can prevent displacement, pivoting or shifting of the stake. The combination of a clamping system and stake can thereby minimize damage to the heat exchanger, the tubes that make up the heat exchanger and the downstream equipment.
When used with a stake configured with a channel, the J-shape clamp component can be configured to fit within the channel and thereby provide an additional physical impediment to pivoting of the stake.
This clamping system is particularly suitable for stabilizing tubes in the U-bend regions of U-tube bundles because when combined with a stake in this area, it provides a mechanical connection between the stake and the tube bundle that physically resists movement of the stake.
Detailed vibration analysis indicates that the clamping system in combination with a stake can potentially eliminate or at the very least drastically reduce tube damage, heat exchanger damage and downstream equipment damage.
The clamping system provides a positive mechanical engagement of the clamps with two or more tubes, increasing overall stiffness of tubes in the tube bundle. Multiple clamps can be used throughout the tube bundle to improve vibration resistance.
Since the clamps can be physically attached to a stake, the clamping system provides a mechanical connection that secures the tubes to the stake. Thus, the clamping system ensures positional integrity of the stake within the tube bundle and better resists damage from highly dynamic conditions created during operation of the heat exchanger as well as during bundle installation, cleaning, or other handling and movement.
With or without a stake, a positive mechanical engagement ensures reduced tube vibration.
A significant advantage of the disclosed clamping system is that the first clamping component and the second clamping component can be manufactured by an extrusion process.
The drawings illustrate preferred embodiments of the clamping system for a tube in a tube bundle according to the disclosure. The reference numbers in the drawings are used consistently throughout. New reference numbers in
In the following description, reference is made to the accompanying drawings, which form a part hereof and which illustrate several embodiments of the present invention. The drawings and the preferred embodiments of the clamping system for a tube in a tube bundle. The drawings are presented with the understanding that the present invention is susceptible of embodiments in many different forms and, therefore, other embodiments may be utilized and structural, and operational changes may be made, without departing from the scope of the present invention.
The use herein of a numerical “first” or “second” modifier for a component is not intended to designate a position order or a numerical valuation, but rather is intended only to provide a different name to distinguish or identify a similar but different component for purposes of assisting with the explanation of the invention. Also, the designations horizontal and vertical are intended to describe the component in one particular orientation as perhaps illustrated in the figures, but these designations are not intended to require that orientation nor to exclude rotation of the component so that the component is no longer horizontal or vertical. In this sense, the designations horizontal and vertical are intended to describe the components in order to distinguish them over similar components described herein.
Preferably, and as can be envisioned from
In some embodiments there may be two or more first fingers (115) and no second fingers (125), or two or more second fingers (125) and no first fingers (115), or two or more first fingers (115) and second fingers (125) may be present.
For example, in one exemplary embodiment, the lower curved part (111) of the J-shape (113) is further configured to define first fingers (115) made flexible by at least two of the first cuts (116) defined within the lower curved part (111) of the J-shape (113).
In a second exemplary embodiment, the horizontal-leg segment (122) of the L-shape (123) is further configured to define second fingers (125) made flexible by at least two of the second cuts (126) defined within the horizontal-leg segment (122) of the L-shape (123).
And in a third exemplary embodiment, both the lower curved part (111) of the J-shape (113) and the horizontal-leg segment (122) of the L-shape (123) are configured with one and more cuts to define fingers.
As shown in
As with the letter “J”, the J-shape (113) of the first clamping component (110) includes a lower curved part (111) and a straight part (112). In a preferred embodiment shown in
The first arc (210) is preferably defined to be within an arc segment greater than 90 degrees of the tube (130), measured from a horizontal axis to the left in
Referring to
The straight part (112) of the J-shape (113) preferably defines a first aperture (114) through the first clamping component (110). There may be more than one first aperture (114) in applications where more than one bolt (310) and nut (311) is used.
The second clamping component (120) is configured with an L-shape (123). The “L-shape” description is a creative term because that generally describes the shape of the second clamping component (120) when in a vertical orientation and viewed from the left side. As can be seen in
The second clamping component (120) includes a horizontal-leg segment (122) and a vertical-leg segment (121). The horizontal-leg segment (122) of the L-shape (123) has a downward-curved section (221) that is configured to occupy a second arc (220) on an arc segment of the tube (130). The second arc (220) is generally opposite to the first arc (210) of the J-shape (113).
In the example shown in
As shown in
For most embodiments, the minimum arc coverage of the tube (130) by the combination of the first arc (210) and the second arc (220), is determined by an equation: the first arc (210) plus the second arc (220) is equal to or greater than 100 degrees. Theoretically, this minimum arc coverage is about 100 degrees because functionality involving a positive grip of the clamps to the tube (130) is retained with 90 degrees, or 10 degrees less than the 100 degrees specified for most embodiments. Thus, in theory, the minimum of the first arc (210) around the tube (130) plus the second arc (220) around the tube (130) is in a range of 90 to 100 degrees. This minimum arc coverage limitation preferably applies when a single tube is between the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120). When two tubes are involved, such as the two tubes in
Alternatively, when the second arc (220) for the L-shape (123) of the second clamping component (120) exceeds 90 degrees, the tightening process creates a relative movement between the two curved portions of the clamping components where the tube (130) mostly tightens toward the straight part (112) of the J-shape. The lower curved part (111) of the J-shape (113) prevents the clamping system from being ejected out of the tube bundle (320).
In an alternative preferred embodiment shown in
While shown in
Referring to
As shown in
The clamping system further includes a means for resisting movement of the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120) once the second clamping component (120) is placed against the first clamping component (110) with the tube between the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120). These means for resisting movement are next explained in more detail.
In a first preferred embodiment, the means for resisting movement is a stake (330) that defines a third aperture (610). The third aperture (610) is configured to align with the first aperture (114) and the second aperture (124) when the second clamping component (120) is placed against the first clamping component (110) with the tube (130) between the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120). This first preferred embodiment further includes a nut (311) and a bolt (310). The bolt (310) is configured to fit through the first aperture (114), the second aperture (124) and the third aperture (610) when the first aperture (114), the second aperture (124) and the third aperture (610) are placed in alignment. While the stake (330) and the second stake (430) may possess a unique configuration, as shown in the figures, it should be recognized that these stakes are exemplary of preferred stakes. Other stake designs are known. Any stake well known in the field may be used in lieu of the stake (330) and the second stake (430), shown in the figures.
The preferred stake is the stake (330) with an elongated channel (510), shown in
Preferably, the stake (330) is wide enough so that a planar side (710) and the extensions (705) push against adjacent tubes in each row of the heat exchanger below the row having the two clamping components. When so configured, the stake (330) directly contacts and engages with each row below the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120), also referred to herein as two clamping components, so as to inhibit tube vibration in the rows of tubes below these two clamping components. The flat part (605) of the stake near the top is one configuration to simplify attachment of the two clamping components to the stake (330). It is noted that the first tube on the right side of the stake (330) in
An alternative preferred embodiment of an alternative stake (530) is shown in
The means for resisting movement may alternatively be a stake (330) and a self-tapping screw (315). The self-tapping screw (315) is configured to fit within the first aperture (114) and the second aperture (124) and pierce the stake (330) to secure the first clamping component (110) and a second clamping component (120) to the stake (330). Reference herein to the stake (330) is intended to include reference to the alternative stake (530) and to any other stake design that may be used when the context so permits. This embodiment with a self-tapping screw (315) is one where welding may be advisable as a backup means for resisting movement to ensure the self-tapping screw (315) does not loosen up and to have added security the clamping system will not move once installed.
A second set (420) of the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120) may be added to any of the embodiment described herein, as shown in
The means for resisting movement may alternatively be a stake (330) in combination with a self-tapping screw (315), shown in
As shown in
For a triangular tube bundle (421) where one row of tubes is above or below the adjacent tube row,
This means for resisting movement next comprises a second set (420) of the first clamping component and the second clamping component, the second set (420) installed on one of the tubes in the two other nearby tube rows. This means for resisting movement is further limited to the configuration wherein both sets of first clamping components and second clamping components are joined together with at least three nuts on the long bolt (410). As intended by the transitional phrase “comprises,” additional nuts may be added to back up these three nuts and provide greater security against any nut (311) loosening up. This configuration is shown in
It is intended that the means for resisting movement may alternatively include clamping components that are either directly welded together, welded to a member like the bolt (310), the long bolt (410), the stake (330), or welded in addition to the use of one or more nuts with one or more bolts. The welding process optionally replaces the need for threaded attachments using one or more nuts with a bolt, or increases safety by adding another physical engagement that resists movement. Thus, one means for resisting movement comprises a stake (330) inserted between two adjacent tube rows; and a weld (230) joining the first clamping component (110) and the second clamping component (120) to the stake.
In this example, the clamping components are fabricated by welding curved rods or tubular ends to a flat plate. First tubular ends (140A) and (140B) for the J-shape and second tubular ends (129A) and (129B) for the L-shape are shown in
In the alternative embodiment shown in
In other embodiments, the first clamping component (110) with the J-shape (113) shown in
Referring to
The two curved parts and the two vertical parts, i.e., the straight part (112) of the first clamping component (110) and the vertical-leg segment (121) of the second clamping component (120), are preferably precision-made using die sets with tight tolerances or by an extrusion process with adequate tolerances. When all pieces are manually assembled and pushed to their respective tightened positions, the presence of this flexible washer (512), or the presence of the gap if the washer is not present, is the means with which reactive forces are created between five members: The first clamping component (110), the second clamping component (120), the tube (130), the nut (311), and the bolt (310).
For this embodiment, the first arc (210) is preferably defined to be greater than 30 degrees of the first tube (161). If the first clamping component (110) with the extended J-shape has a thickness of about ¼″, which is the typical thickness for an inline arrangement of tubes, then this 30-degree angle is practical. For the staggered arrangement of tubes, the thickness is typically only about ⅛″ and, therefore, would probably not be sufficiently sturdy. So, for the staggered arrangement, the angle would preferably be greater than 90 degrees of the first tube. As with the other preferred embodiments, the straight part (112) of the first clamping component (110) with an extended J-shape defines a first aperture (114) through the first clamping component (110). Preferably, the second arc (220) of the second clamping component (120) with the L-shape (123) is greater than about 10 degrees of the second tube (171).
The first clamping component (110) of the
The above-described embodiments including the drawings are examples of the invention and merely provide illustrations of the clamping system for a tube in a tube bundle. Other embodiments will be obvious to those skilled in the art. Thus, the scope of the invention is determined by the appended claims and their legal equivalents rather than by the examples given.
The invention has application to the heat exchanger industry.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3232569 | Deardorf | Feb 1966 | A |
3544049 | Ribble | Dec 1970 | A |
4088184 | Cavallaro | May 1978 | A |
4648442 | Williams | Mar 1987 | A |
4789028 | Gowda et al. | Dec 1988 | A |
4848452 | McDonald | Jul 1989 | A |
5515911 | Boula et al. | May 1996 | A |
7032655 | Wanni et al. | Apr 2006 | B2 |
7073575 | Wanni et al. | Jul 2006 | B2 |
7128130 | Wanni et al. | Oct 2006 | B2 |
7219718 | Wanni et al. | May 2007 | B2 |
7267164 | Wanni et al. | Sep 2007 | B2 |
7343964 | Rudy et al. | Mar 2008 | B2 |
7699093 | Wanni et al. | Apr 2010 | B2 |
7793708 | Wanni et al. | Sep 2010 | B2 |
9488419 | Wanni | Nov 2016 | B2 |
9958217 | Oakes | May 2018 | B1 |
10077677 | Prestel | Sep 2018 | B2 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20210123694 A1 | Apr 2021 | US |