Coating ablating apparatus with coating removal detection

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 11819939
  • Patent Number
    11,819,939
  • Date Filed
    Friday, June 18, 2021
    2 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 21, 2023
    5 months ago
Abstract
A laser-based coating removal apparatus to remove a coating from a surface without damaging the surface. The apparatus comprises a laser source to provide a laser light, a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface thereby removing the coating from the target region, and a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface. The detection element is able to prevent the surface from being damaged by limiting or eliminating the laser light directed onto the target region after all the coating has been removed. The detection element is able to detect the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and/or chemical properties produced by the separation of the coating from the surface.
Description
FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The invention relates to ablating a coating using a laser. In particular, the invention relates to a coating ablating apparatus for detecting the removal of a coating from a surface using a laser to prevent surface damage.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Laser-based coating removal systems use pulses of light from high power lasers to ablate or vaporize the paint or other coating from a surface. Each pulse removes the coating from a small region, typically 0.1 to 100 square mm. The laser is pointed to a different area after each pulse, where the removal process is repeated until the entire surface is cleaned. An advantage of lasers for coating removal is that each laser pulse removes a predictable portion of the thickness of the coating, in the small region impacted by the pulse. This opens the possibility of selective stripping where, for example, the topcoat could be removed but not the primer.


A problem with laser de-coating systems is the possibility of damaging the surface if the stripping process is continued after all the coating is removed. A particular source of the possible damage is the result of overheating the surface due to the absorption of the excess laser light by the surface after the coating has been removed. Previous techniques to overcome this problem have relied on measuring the color of the surface at each point within the laser scan field prior to firing the laser at that point. However, these techniques do not work well if the distance and the angle from the laser optics to the substrate vary widely as is the case in many handheld laser de-coating systems on non-flat surfaces.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Embodiments of the present invention are directed to a laser-based coating removal apparatus to remove a coating from a surface without damaging the surface. The apparatus comprises a laser source to provide a laser light, a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface thereby removing the coating from the target region, and a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface. The detection element is able to prevent the surface from being damaged by limiting or eliminating the laser light directed onto the target region after all the coating has been removed. The detection element is able to detect the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and/or chemical properties produced by the separation of the coating from the surface.


In one aspect the present application relates to a laser-based coating removal apparatus to remove a coating from a surface. The apparatus comprises a laser source to provide a laser light, a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface and a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface. In some embodiments, the detection element detects the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting one or more coating properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties. In some embodiments, the routing element transmits a signal related the one or more coating properties to the detection element such that the detection element is able to detect if the coating is separating from the target region. In some embodiments, the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the surface is adjusted based on whether the detection element detects that the coating is separating from the target region. In some embodiments, if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region for a period, a controller coupled to the detection element decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected low rate. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the length of the period based on one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the level of the low rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, if the detection element detects the coating separating from the target region while the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region is equal to the low rate, the controller increases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected high rate. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the level of the high rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the one or more characteristics of the target region comprise a temperature of the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate is equal to continuous projection of the laser light onto the target region and the low rate is equal to none of the laser light being projected onto the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate and the low rate are proportional to each other such that if one of the high or low rate is adjusted, the other rate is also adjusted in proportion. In some embodiments, the detection element divides the target region into a plurality of detection areas and if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region in one or more of the detection areas for the period, the controller decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to the preselected low rate.


A second aspect of the present application is directed to a laser-based coating removal system. The system comprises a surface having a coating and a laser-based removal apparatus comprising a laser source to provide a laser light, a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface and a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface. In some embodiments, the detection element detects the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting one or more coating properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties. In some embodiments, the routing element transmits a signal related the one or more coating properties to the detection element such that the detection element is able to detect if the coating is separating from the target region. In some embodiments, the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the surface is adjusted based on whether the detection element detects that the coating is separating from the target region. In some embodiments, if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region for a period, a controller coupled to the detection element decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected low rate. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the length of the period based on one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the level of the low rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, if the detection element detects the coating separating from the target region while the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region is equal to the low rate, the controller increases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected high rate. In some embodiments, the controller is able to adjust the level of the high rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the one or more characteristics of the target region comprise a temperature of the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate is equal to continuous projection of the laser light onto the target region and the low rate is equal to none of the laser light being projected onto the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate and the low rate are proportional to each other such that if one of the high or low rate is adjusted, the other rate is also adjusted in proportion. In some embodiments, the detection element divides the target region into a plurality of detection areas and if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region in one or more of the detection areas for the period, the controller decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to the preselected low rate.


Another aspect of the present application is directed to a laser-based method of removing a coating from a surface. The method comprises activating a laser source to provide a laser light, directing the laser light onto a target region of the surface with a routing element and detecting if the coating is separating from the target region of the surface with a detection element. In some embodiments, the detection element detects the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting one or more coating properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties. The method further comprises transmitting a signal related the one or more coating properties with the routing element to the detection element such that the detection element is able to detect if the coating is separating from the target region. The method further comprises adjusting the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the surface based on whether the detection element detects that the coating is separating from the target region. The method further comprises decreasing the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected low rate if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region for a period. The method further comprises adjusting the length of the period based on one or more characteristics of the target region. The method further comprises adjusting the level of the low rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. The method further comprises increasing the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to a preselected high rate if the detection element detects the coating separating from the target region while the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region is equal to the low rate. The method further comprises adjusting the level of the high rate based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the one or more characteristics of the target region comprise a temperature of the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate is equal to continuous projection of the laser light onto the target region and the low rate is equal to none of the laser light being projected onto the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate and the low rate are proportional to each other such that if one of the high or low rate is adjusted, the other rate is also adjusted in proportion. The method further comprises decreasing the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to the preselected low rate if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region in one or more of a plurality of detection areas for the period, wherein the detection areas each comprise a portion of the target region. The method further comprises adjusting the size of the detection areas based on the characteristics of the surface.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1A illustrates an exemplary block diagram of the coating removal system having a common detection path according to some embodiments.



FIG. 1B illustrates an exemplary block diagram of the coating removal system having a separate detection path according to some embodiments.



FIG. 2A illustrates a more detailed diagram of an exemplary block diagram of the coating removal system having a common detection path according to some embodiments.



FIG. 2B illustrates a more detailed diagram of an exemplary block diagram of the coating removal system having a separate detection path according to some embodiments.



FIG. 3 illustrates a flow chart of a method of removing a coating from a surface according to some embodiments.





Embodiments of the coating removal device are described relative to the several views of the drawings. Where appropriate and only where identical elements are disclosed and shown in more than one drawing, the same reference numeral will be used to represent such identical elements.


DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PRESENT INVENTION

Embodiments of the present invention are directed to a laser-based coating removal apparatus to remove a coating from a surface without damaging the surface. The apparatus comprises a laser source to provide a laser light, a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface thereby removing the coating from the target region, and a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface. The detection element is able to prevent the surface from being damaged by limiting or eliminating the laser light directed onto the target region after all the coating has been removed. The detection element is able to detect the separation of the coating from the target region by detecting incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and/or chemical properties produced by the separation of the coating from the surface.


Reference will now be made in detail to implementations of the laser-based coating removal apparatus as illustrated in the accompanying drawings. The same reference indicators will be used through the drawings and the following detailed description to refer to the same or like parts. In the interest of clarity, not all of the routine features of the implementations described herein are shown and described. It will also be appreciated that in the development of any such actual implementation, numerous implementation-specific decisions be made to achieve the developer's specific goals, such as compliance with application and business related constraints, and that these specific goals will vary from one implementation to another and from one developer to another. Moreover, it will be appreciated that such a development effort might be complex and time-consuming, but would nevertheless be a routine undertaking of engineering for those of ordinary skill in the art having the benefit of this disclosure.



FIG. 1A illustrates an exemplary block diagram of a coating removal system 100 using a common path according to some embodiments. The coating removal system 100 comprises a laser source 102, a routing element 104, a detection element 106 and a controller 108 for removing a coating 98 from a surface 99. In some embodiments, the system 100 comprises one or more additional laser sources 102, routing elements 104, detection elements 106 and/or controllers 108. The laser source 102 is able to comprise one or more lasers. Alternatively, the laser source 102 is able to comprise other components capable of outputting laser light 97 (see FIGS. 2A and 2B) as are well known in the art. The laser source 102 is coupled to routing element 104 such that laser light 97 output by the laser source 102 is received by the routing element 104 such that the routing element 104 is able to manipulate and direct/route the laser light 97 onto the desired portion of the surface 99 having the coating 98 to be removed. Specifically, the routing element 104 is optically coupled to the surface 99/coating 98 such that the routing element 106 is able to direct the laser light 97 received from the laser source 102 onto the surface 99 to effectuate the removal of the coating 98 from the surface 99.


As shown in FIG. 1A, the routing element 104 is also coupled to the input of the detection element 106 such that one or more of the properties of the surface 99 and/or the coating 98 (as the coating 98 is being removed from the surface 99), are able to be transmitted to the detection element 106 by the routing element 104. In other words, both the laser source 102 and the detection element 106 are able to use a common path through the routing element 104 to access the surface 99 and/or coating 98. For example, components of the routing element 104 used for routing the laser light 97 to the surface 99 are able to be used to receive incandescent light from the coating 98 caused by the removal of the coating 98 from the surface 99 and transmit that received incandescent light (or a signal 96 corresponding to the incandescent light (see FIG. 2A)) to the detection element 106. Alternatively, signals 96 corresponding to other properties of the surface 99 and/or coating 98 are able to be transmitted to the detection element 106 by the routing element 104 such as acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and other detectable chemical properties of the surface 99/coating 98 as are well known in the art. The detection element 106 is able to receive the one or more signals of properties 96 corresponding to the surface 99 and/or coating 98 from the routing element 104 and determine if the coating 98 is currently separating from the surface 99. Specifically, the detection element 106 is able to determine if the coating 98 is currently separating from the surface 99 by determining if the detected properties exceed a preselected threshold indicating that separation is currently occurring in the detected area of the surface 99.


The controller 108 is coupled to the detection element 106 and the laser source 102 such that the controller 108 is able to control the operation of the laser source 102 based on the output received from the detection element 106. Specifically, the controller 108 is able to adjust the rate and/or intensity at which the laser light 97 is output by the laser source 102 based on whether the output of the detection element 106 indicates that the coating 98 is currently being removed or if the removal of the coating 98 is no longer being detected. As a result, during the process of removing the coating 98 from the surface 99, the system 100 is able to determine when the coating 98 is no longer being removed from the surface 99 (e.g. all the coating 98 has been removed) and lower or raise the rate and/or intensity of the laser light 97 output onto the surface 99 accordingly in order to efficiently remove the coating 98 while preventing the surface 99 from being damaged from the laser light 97. The controller 108 is able to comprise various designs of one or more electronic devices well known in the art which are not discussed herein for the sake of brevity. In some embodiments, one or more of the components of the coating removal system 100 are incorporated into a single coating removal apparatus. Alternatively, the components of the coating removal system 100 are able to comprise multiple devices.



FIG. 1B illustrates an exemplary block diagram of the coating removal system 100′ having a separate detection path according to some alternative embodiments. The system 100′ shown in FIG. 1B is substantially similar to the system 100 except for the differences described herein. Specifically, the detection element 106 of the system 100′ is coupled directly to the surface 99 and/or the coating 98 forming a separate detection path instead of coupling through the routing element 104. The manner in which the detecting element 106 is coupled to the surface 99/coating 98 depends on the one or more types of surface 99/coating 98 properties used to determine if the coating 98 is currently being removed. For example, if the incandescence produced by the removed coating 98 is to be detected, the detecting element 106 is optically coupled to the surface 99/coating 98. Alternatively, other manners of coupling or combination of manners of coupling are able to be used as are well known in the art in order to detect one or more of incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and other detectable chemical properties of the surface 99/coating 98. As a result, the detection element 104 is able to directly monitor and receive signals 96 (see FIG. 2B) from the surface 99 and/or coating 98 as the system 100′ is operating and output to the controller 108 whether the removal of the coating 98 is currently detected. Alternatively, the detection element 106 is able to be coupled to both the routing element 104 and the surface 99/coating 98 such that the detection element 106 is able to receive signals 96 corresponding to the properties of the coating 98 and/or surface 99 as the coating 98 is removed from the surface 99 from the surface 99/coating 98 directly, via the routing element 104 or both.



FIG. 2A illustrates a more detailed diagram of a coating removal system 100 using a common path according to some embodiments. As shown in FIG. 2A, the routing element 104 comprises a beam splitter 202, focusing optics 204 and scanning optics 206. The focusing optics 204 receive and focus light passing through the beam splitter 202 from the light source 102 to the scanning optics 206 which align and focus the laser light 97 onto the coating/surface 98, 99. The scanning optics 206 also receive signals 96 (e.g. incandescent light from gaseous removed coating 98) that are routed from the scanning optics 206 to the beam splitter 202 (via the focusing optics 204). The beam splitter 202 receives the signals 96 and routes the signals 96 to the detection element 106. As a result, the routing element 104 is able to utilize the common path to simultaneously route the laser light 97 onto the surface/coating 98, 99 and receives/transmits signals 96 (e.g. detected coating 98 gaseous incandescence upon removal) related to one or more properties of the removal of the coating 98 from the surface 99 to the detection element 106 for determining the state of the coating removal process. It is understood that the routing element 104 is able to comprise less or more components for routing the laser light 97 and/or transmitting the surface/coating signals 96 to the detection element 106 as are well known in the art. For example, in some embodiments, the routing element 104 is able to comprise audio, electrical and/or chemical detection and transmission elements enabling the routing element 104 to use the common path to simultaneously route, in addition to light, audio, electrical, chemical and/or other types of signals 96 related to the properties of the removal of the coating 98 from the surface 99 to the detection element 106.


As also shown in FIG. 2A, the detection element 106 comprises an input interface 208, a signal detector 210 and a comparator 212. In some embodiments, the input interface 208 comprises an input lens for receiving a light signal 96. Alternatively, the input interface 208 is able to comprise one or more other components for receiving audio, visual, electrical, chemical and other types of signals 96 as are well known in the art. In some embodiments, the signal detector 210 is a photosensitive device such as a photodiode for receiving a light signal. Alternatively, the signal detector 210 is able to be other detecting devices such as a microphone or other types of detectors able to detect one or more of incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and other detectable chemical properties of the surface 99/coating 98. For example, in order to detect an acoustic signature of the separating coating 98, the signal detector 210 is able to comprise a microphone for converting the received audio signal to a desired corresponding signal and a filter to separate sounds generated from the separated coating 98 from other noise. In some embodiments, the comparator 212 comprises an amplifier for comparing the signal 96 to a threshold voltage. Alternatively, the comparator 212 is able to comprise other components for comparing a received signal 96 to a reference as are well known in the art.


In operation, the input interface 208 receives the signals 96 from the routing element 104 and transmits the signals 96 to the signal detector 210. The signal detector 210 converts the received signal 96 to a desired corresponding signal and transmits the corresponding signal to the comparator 212 which determines if the received corresponding signal indicates that the coating 98 is currently being removed from the surface 99. In some embodiments, the comparator 212 makes this determination by determining if a voltage of the corresponding signal exceeds a predetermined threshold voltage. Alternatively, the comparator 212 is able to make the determination based on voltage and/or one or more other properties of the corresponding signal as are well known in the art. As a result, the detection element 106 is able to output a detection signal to the controller 108 indicating whether the coating 98 is currently being detected as being currently removed from the surface 99. It is understood that the detection element 106 is able to comprise less or more components for determining if the surface/coating signals 96 indicate that the coating 98 is currently being removed from the surface 99 as are well known in the art. For example, the input interface 208 is able to be omitted and the signal 96 is able to be received directly by the signal detector 210.


As described above in relation to FIG. 1A, the controller 108 adjusts the rate and/or intensity at which the laser light 97 is output by the laser source 102 based on whether the coating 98 is currently being removed or if the removal of the coating 98 is no longer being detected. In some embodiments, the controller 108 increases the intensity and/or rate/frequency at which the light 97 is output from a predetermined low level to a predetermined high level when the removal of the coating 98 is detected. For example, the controller 108 is able to increase the rate and/or intensity from 0 or 1% of the normal rate/intensity to 100% of the normal rate/intensity upon detecting the removal of the coating 98. Alternatively, the low and high levels are able to be other percentages of the normal rate/intensity or preselected rate/intensity values. Alternatively, the rate and/or intensity is able to be adjusted gradually/incrementally by the controller 108. In some embodiments where both rate and intensity values are adjusted, the rate value and frequency value are able to be adjusted to different levels dependently or independently.


Similarly, in some embodiments, the controller 108 decreases the intensity and/or rate at which the light 97 is output from the predetermined high level to the predetermined low level when the removal of the coating 98 is not detected for a period. In some embodiments, the period is 50 milliseconds. Alternatively, other periods are contemplated. In some embodiments, the period, predetermined high level and/or predetermined low level are able to be adjusted based on the characteristics of the surface 99. For example, if the rate of change of the surface temperature is low, the surface temperature is low and/or the surface is able to endure high temperatures before becoming damaged, the period and/or low level is able to be increased to reflect the resistance to damage of the surface 99. As a result, during the process of removing the coating 98 from the surface 99, the system 100 is able to determine when the coating 98 is no longer being removed from the surface 99 (e.g. all the coating 98 has been removed) and lower the rate and/or intensity of the laser light 97 output onto the surface 99 in order to prevent the surface 99 from being damaged from the laser light 97.



FIG. 2B illustrates a more detailed diagram of a coating removal system 100′ with a separate detection path according to some embodiments. The system 100′ shown in FIG. 2B is substantially similar to the system 100 shown in FIG. 2A except for the differences described herein. Specifically, the input interface 208 of the detection element 106 of the system 100′ is coupled directly to the surface 99 and/or the coating 98 forming a separate detection path instead of coupling through the routing element 104. As described above in relation to FIG. 1B, the manner in which the input interface 208 is coupled to the surface 99/coating 98 depends on the one or more types of surface 99/coating 98 properties used to determine if the coating 98 is currently being removed. For example, if the incandescence produced by the removed coating 98 is to be detected, the input interface 208 is able to comprise a lens that is optically coupled to the surface 99/coating 98. Alternatively, other manners of coupling or combination of manners of coupling are able to be used as are well known in the art in order to detect one or more of incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and other detectable chemical properties of the surface 99/coating 98. As a result, the detection element 104 is able to directly monitor and receive signals 96 from the surface 99 and/or coating 98 as the system 100′ is operating and output the detection signal to the controller 108 indicating whether the removal of the coating 98 is currently detected. In some embodiments, the input interface 208 is able to be coupled to both the routing element 104 and the surface 99/coating 98 such that the detection element 106 is able to receive signals 96 corresponding to the properties of the coating 98 and/or surface 99 as the coating 98 is removed from the surface 99 from the surface 99/coating 98 directly, via the routing element 104 or both. In some embodiments, the input interface 208 is able to be omitted and instead the signal detector 210 is able to be coupled directly to the surface 99/coating 98, via the routing element 104 or both.


In some embodiments, the detection element 104 is able to define a plurality of detection areas, which are a fraction of a target area of the surface 99/coating 98 contacted by the laser light 97 during the removal process, in order to guard against the situation where one are of the target surface is being damaged even though coating removal is still being detected in another part of the target area. Specifically, using the smaller detection areas, the detection element 104 to able to individually detect whether coating removal is absent in one or more of the detection areas and lower the laser rate and/or intensity even though coating removal is still being detected in another detection area (i.e. another part of the target area). Thus, by refining the size/number of detection areas defined within the target area, the system 100, 100′ is able to minimize the chance that current coating removal at one end of the target area is able to occur while another end of the target area is being damaged. In some embodiments, the system 100, 100′ is also able to reduce the risk of damage by enabling a user to selectively choose the one or more types of properties of the surface 99/coating 98 the system 100, 100′ should detect in order to determine if the coating 98 is currently being removed. For example, a user is able to select one or a combination of light, audio and chemical properties to detect based on what is determined as the most accurate indicator for a particular surface 99/coating 98. Thus, the system 100, 100′ is able to be customized for each job in order to most effectively reduce the risk of surface damage.



FIG. 3 illustrates a flow chart of a method of removing a coating from a surface according to some embodiments. The controller 108 activates the laser source 102 and begins firing the laser light 97 at the low rate and/or intensity onto the target region of the surface at the step 302. Alternatively, the controller 108 is able to cause the laser source 102 to begin firing at the high rate and/or intensity as described in step 306 below. The detection element 106 detects if the coating 98 is currently separating from the target region of the surface 99, wherein the system 100, 100′ returns to step 302 (firing at the low rate/intensity) if removal is not detected and advances to step 306 if removal is detected at the step 304. In some embodiments, the detection element 106 detects the separation of the coating 98 from the target region by detecting one or more coating properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties. In some embodiments, a signal 96 related to the one or more coating properties is transmitted by the routing element 104 to the detection element 106 such that the detection element 106 is able to detect if the coating 98 is separating from the target region. The controller 108 increases the rate and/or intensity at which the laser light 97 is directed onto the target region to a preselected high rate at the step 306. In some embodiments, the level of the preselected high rate is adjusted based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the one or more characteristics of the target region comprise a temperature of the target region. The detection element 106 detects if the coating 98 is currently separating from the target region of the surface 99, wherein the system 100, 100′ returns to step 306 (firing at the high rate/intensity) if removal is detected and advances to step 310 if removal is not detected at the step 308. The controller 108 determines if the detection element 106 has not detected the coating 98 separating from the target region for a predefined period, wherein if the period has not elapsed the system 100, 100′ returns to step 306 (firing at the high rate/intensity) and if the period has elapsed the system 100, 100′ returns to step 302 (firing at the low rate/intensity) at the step 310.


In some embodiments, the length of the period is adjusted automatically by the controller 108 or by a user based on one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the level of the low rate is adjusted automatically by the controller 108 or by a user based on the one or more characteristics of the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate is equal to continuous projection of the laser light 97 onto the target region and the low rate is equal to none of the laser light 97 being projected onto the target region. In some embodiments, the high rate and the low rate are proportional to each other such that if one of the high or low rate is adjusted, the other rate is also adjusted in proportion. In some embodiments, one or more detection areas are defined and the rate at which the laser light 97 is directed onto the target region is decreased to the preselected low rate if the detection element 106 does not detect the coating 98 separating from the target region in one or more of the detection areas for the period. In some embodiments, the detection areas each comprise a portion of the target region. In some embodiments, the size of the detection areas are adjusted automatically by the system 100, 100′ or by a user based on the characteristics of the surface 99 and/or the coating 98. Accordingly, the coating removal system 100, 100′ is able to minimize the risk of damage to the surface 99 by dynamically detecting if the coating 98 is no longer being removed from the surface 99 such that the surface 99 is being directly subjected to damaging laser light 97.


Thus, it is clear that the coating removal system described herein has numerous advantages. Specifically, the coating removal system is able to efficiently remove coatings on a surface without damaging the surface by detecting when all the coating has been removed. Further, this damage prevention is able to effectively operate even if the distance and the angle from the laser optics to the substrate vary widely as is the case in many handheld laser de-coating systems on non-flat surfaces. Moreover, the damage prevention aspect is able to be dynamically adjusted based on the characteristics of the surface and/or the properties of the coating and its separation from the surface. As a result, the coating removal system is able to save energy and cost while still ensuring that no damage is caused to the surface by the system.


The present invention has been described in terms of specific embodiments incorporating details to facilitate the understanding of the principles of construction and operation of the invention. Such reference herein to specific embodiments and details thereof is not intended to limit the scope of the claims appended hereto. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that modifications may be made in the embodiment chosen for illustration without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.

Claims
  • 1. A laser-based coating removal apparatus to remove a coating from a surface, the apparatus comprising: a. a laser source to provide a laser light for removing the coating from a target region of the surface;b. a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface;c. a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface by inputting a signal received from the surface at the target region; andd. a controller configured to adjust a current firing rate of the laser light based on the signal received from the surface at the target region, wherein if the detection element detects that the coating has separated from the surface in the target region for a period, the controller coupled to the detection element decreases an amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light from a non-zero preselected high value to a non-zero preselected low value and wherein the controller is able to adjust a length of the period based on one or more characteristics of the surface in the target region.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the signal comprises data indicating one or more properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties.
  • 3. The apparatus of claim 2 wherein the routing element receives the signal from the surface and transmits the signal to the detection element such that the detection element is able to detect if the coating has separated from the surface.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein an amount of energy per second directed onto the surface by the laser light is adjusted from a first non-zero amount to a second non-zero amount different than the first non-zero amount based on whether the detection element detects that the coating has separated from the surface in the target region.
  • 5. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region for the period, the controller coupled to the detection element decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to the non-zero preselected low value.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 5 wherein the controller is able to adjust the length of the period based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 6 wherein the controller is able to adjust the level of the non-zero preselected low value based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 7 wherein if the detection element detects the coating has not yet separated from the surface in the target region for a duration while the amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light is equal to the non-zero preselected low value, the controller increases the amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light to the non-zero preselected high value.
  • 9. The apparatus of claim 8 wherein the controller is able to adjust the level of the non-zero preselected high value based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 10. The apparatus of claim 9 wherein the one or more properties of the surface in the target region comprise a temperature of the surface in the target region.
  • 11. The apparatus of claim 10 wherein the non-zero preselected high value is equal to a maximum amount of energy per second produced when the laser light has a maximum intensity and frequency and the non-zero preselected low value is equal to a minimum amount of energy per second produced when the laser light has a non-zero minimum intensity and frequency.
  • 12. The apparatus of claim 11 wherein the non-zero preselected high value and the non-zero preselected low value are proportional to each other such that if the non-zero preselected high or value rate is adjusted, the non-zero preselected low value is adjusted in proportion to the non-zero preselected high value and if the non-zero preselected low value is adjusted, the non-zero preselected high value is adjusted in proportion to the non-zero preselected low value.
  • 13. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein the detection element divides the target region into a plurality of detection areas.
  • 14. A laser-based coating removal system comprising: a. a surface having a coating; andb. a laser-based removal apparatus comprising: i. a laser source to provide a laser light for removing the coating from a target region of the surface;ii. a routing element coupled to the laser source and configured to direct the laser light onto a target region of the surface;iii. a detection element to detect the coating as the coating separates from the target region of the surface by inputting a signal received from the surface at the target region; andiv. a controller configured to adjust a current firing rate of the laser light based on the signal received from the surface at the target region, wherein if the detection element detects that the coating has separated from the surface in the target region for a period, the controller coupled to the detection element decreases an amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light from a non-zero preselected high value to a non-zero preselected low value and wherein the controller is able to adjust a length of the period based on one or more characteristics of the surface in the target region.
  • 15. The system of claim 14 wherein the signal comprises data indicating one or more properties selected from the group consisting of the incandescence, acoustic signature, motion, fluorescence and chemical properties.
  • 16. The system of claim 15 wherein the routing element receives the signal from the surface and transmits the signal to the detection element such that the detection element is able to detect if the coating has separated from the surface.
  • 17. The system of claim 14 wherein an amount of energy per second directed onto the surface by the laser light is adjusted from a first non-zero amount to a second non-zero amount different than the first non-zero amount based on whether the detection element detects that the coating has separated from the surface in the target region.
  • 18. The system of claim 14 wherein if the detection element does not detect the coating separating from the target region for the period, the controller coupled to the detection element decreases the rate at which the laser light is directed onto the target region to the non-zero preselected low value.
  • 19. The system of claim 18 wherein the controller is able to adjust the length of the period based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 20. The system of claim 19 wherein the controller is able to adjust the level of the non-zero preselected low value based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 21. The system of claim 20 wherein if the detection element detects the coating has not yet separated from the surface in the target region for a duration while the amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light is equal to the non-zero preselected low value, the controller increases the amount of energy per second directed onto the target region by the laser light to the non-zero preselected high value.
  • 22. The system of claim 21 wherein the controller is able to adjust the level of the non-zero preselected high value based on the one or more properties of the surface in the target region.
  • 23. The system of claim 22 wherein the one or more properties of the surface in the target region comprise a temperature of the surface in the target region.
  • 24. The system of claim 23 wherein the non-zero preselected high value is equal to a maximum amount of energy per second produced when the laser light has a maximum intensity and frequency and the non-zero preselected low value is equal to a minimum amount of energy per second produced when the laser light has a non-zero minimum intensity and frequency.
  • 25. The system of claim 24 wherein the non-zero preselected high value and the non-zero preselected low value are proportional to each other such that if the non-zero preselected high or value rate is adjusted, the non-zero preselected low value is adjusted in proportion to the non-zero preselected high value and if the non-zero preselected low value is adjusted, the non-zero preselected high value is adjusted in proportion to the non-zero preselected low value.
  • 26. The system of claim 25 wherein the detection element divides the target region into a plurality of detection areas.
RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a divisional of co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/123,210, filed on Sep. 6, 2018, and entitled “A COATING ABLATING APPARATUS WITH COATING REMOVAL DETECTION” which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/177,431, filed on Jul. 6, 2011, and entitled “A COATING ABLATING APPARATUS WITH COATING REMOVAL DETECTION” which claims priority of U.S. provisional application Ser. No. 61/362,976, filed Jul. 9, 2010, and entitled “Non-Color Sensing for Laser Decocting.” The U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/123,210, filed on Sep. 6, 2018, and entitled “A COATING ABLATING APPARATUS WITH COATING REMOVAL DETECTION”, U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/177,431, filed on Jul. 6, 2011, and entitled “A COATING ABLATING APPARATUS WITH COATING REMOVAL DETECTION” and the provisional application Ser. No. 61/362,976, filed Jul. 9, 2010, and entitled “Non-Color Sensing for Laser Decoating which are all incorporated herein by reference.

US Referenced Citations (263)
Number Name Date Kind
3624553 Van-Tran Nov 1971 A
3626141 Daly Dec 1971 A
3657707 McFarland et al. Apr 1972 A
3771880 Bennett Nov 1973 A
3843865 Nath Oct 1974 A
3941973 Luck, Jr. et al. Mar 1976 A
4052523 Rhodes Oct 1977 A
4114018 Von Allmen Sep 1978 A
4136779 Bieringer Jan 1979 A
4148057 Jesse Apr 1979 A
4207874 Choy Jun 1980 A
4328068 Curtis May 1982 A
4398790 Righini et al. Aug 1983 A
4421201 Nelsen Dec 1983 A
4449043 Husbands May 1984 A
4504727 Melcher Mar 1985 A
4521070 Scottini et al. Jun 1985 A
4539244 Beggs Sep 1985 A
4543477 Doi et al. Sep 1985 A
4564736 Jones et al. Jan 1986 A
4566937 Pitts Jan 1986 A
4584455 Tomizawa Apr 1986 A
4588885 Lovoi May 1986 A
4600619 Chee Jul 1986 A
4644948 Lang Feb 1987 A
4654532 Hirshfield May 1987 A
4665377 Harpaintner May 1987 A
4671848 Miller et al. Jun 1987 A
4676586 Jones et al. Jun 1987 A
4687918 Hughes et al. Aug 1987 A
4695698 Mayor et al. Sep 1987 A
4707073 Kocher Nov 1987 A
4725485 Hirokawa Feb 1988 A
4729621 Edelman Mar 1988 A
4737004 Amitay et al. Apr 1988 A
4737628 Lovoi Apr 1988 A
4749840 Piwczyk Jun 1988 A
4756756 Woodroffe Jul 1988 A
4762385 Fuse Aug 1988 A
4799755 Jones Jan 1989 A
4807954 Oyamada et al. Feb 1989 A
4818049 Assenheim et al. Apr 1989 A
4818062 Schifres et al. Apr 1989 A
4821943 Gaudin et al. Apr 1989 A
4833029 DuPont May 1989 A
4842360 Caro et al. Jun 1989 A
4844574 Chande Jul 1989 A
4844947 Kanser et al. Jul 1989 A
4859075 Sutter, Jr. et al. Aug 1989 A
4876444 Field Oct 1989 A
4880959 Baum et al. Nov 1989 A
4900891 Vega et al. Feb 1990 A
4920994 Nachbar May 1990 A
4921751 Wakahara May 1990 A
4928695 Goldman et al. May 1990 A
4931616 Usui et al. Jun 1990 A
4960988 Simms Oct 1990 A
4986664 Lovoi Jan 1991 A
4994567 Crisp et al. Feb 1991 A
4994639 Dickinson Feb 1991 A
5006268 Griffaton Apr 1991 A
5014207 Lawton May 1991 A
5040479 Thrash Aug 1991 A
5068750 Cook et al. Nov 1991 A
RE33777 Woodroffe Dec 1991 E
5081350 Iwasaki et al. Jan 1992 A
5107445 Jensen et al. Apr 1992 A
5113802 Le Blanc May 1992 A
5151134 Boquillion et al. Sep 1992 A
5194723 Cates Mar 1993 A
5204517 Cates Apr 1993 A
5210944 Monson et al. May 1993 A
5216808 Martus et al. Jun 1993 A
5229593 Cato Jul 1993 A
5240533 Bottger Aug 1993 A
5245682 Ortiz et al. Sep 1993 A
5281798 Hamm Jan 1994 A
5291570 Filgas et al. Mar 1994 A
5293023 Haruta et al. Mar 1994 A
5328517 Cates et al. Jul 1994 A
5333218 Ortiz et al. Jul 1994 A
5355063 Boone et al. Oct 1994 A
5364390 Taboada et al. Nov 1994 A
5371582 Toba et al. Dec 1994 A
5373140 Nagy et al. Dec 1994 A
5386112 Dixon Jan 1995 A
5387455 Horsch Feb 1995 A
5395362 Sacharoff et al. Mar 1995 A
5446256 Cartry Aug 1995 A
5451765 Gerber Sep 1995 A
5526167 Peng Jun 1996 A
5531857 Engelsberg et al. Jul 1996 A
5548113 Goldberg Aug 1996 A
5558666 Dewey et al. Sep 1996 A
5562840 Swain Oct 1996 A
5571335 Lloyd Nov 1996 A
5581346 Sopori Dec 1996 A
5589089 Usegi Dec 1996 A
5592879 Waizmann Jan 1997 A
5593808 Ellis Jan 1997 A
5610753 Kessler et al. Mar 1997 A
5613509 Kolb Mar 1997 A
5622540 Stevens Apr 1997 A
5637245 Shelton Jun 1997 A
5643476 Garmine et al. Jul 1997 A
5656186 Mourou et al. Aug 1997 A
5662762 Ranalli Sep 1997 A
5720894 Neev Feb 1998 A
5767479 Kanaoka Jun 1998 A
5780806 Ferguson et al. Jul 1998 A
5782253 Cates Jul 1998 A
5784162 Cabib et al. Jul 1998 A
5789755 Bender Aug 1998 A
5790046 Blossfeld Aug 1998 A
5805275 Taylor Sep 1998 A
5845646 Lemelson Dec 1998 A
5864114 Fukuda Jan 1999 A
5889253 Kanaoka Mar 1999 A
5954712 Goodman Sep 1999 A
5954974 Broer Sep 1999 A
5986234 Matthews Nov 1999 A
6040549 Kanaoka Mar 2000 A
6040553 Ross Mar 2000 A
6067306 Sandstrom May 2000 A
6165170 Wynne et al. Dec 2000 A
6210773 Moore Apr 2001 B1
6215094 Dausinger Apr 2001 B1
6285002 Ngoi Sep 2001 B1
6288362 Thomas et al. Sep 2001 B1
6313435 Shoemaker Nov 2001 B1
6323457 Jung Nov 2001 B1
6347976 Lawton Feb 2002 B1
6383177 Balle-Peterson et al. May 2002 B1
6384370 Tsunemi et al. May 2002 B1
6414263 Uchida Jul 2002 B1
6437285 Thomas et al. Aug 2002 B1
6494960 Macdonald et al. Dec 2002 B1
6537720 Foley Mar 2003 B1
6608438 Topelberg Aug 2003 B2
6635844 Yu Oct 2003 B2
6664499 Brink et al. Dec 2003 B1
6693255 Freiwald Feb 2004 B2
6864478 Schroder Mar 2005 B2
6924457 Koyoma et al. Aug 2005 B2
6927917 Kiruma Aug 2005 B2
7009141 Wool et al. Mar 2006 B1
7055781 Behrens Jun 2006 B2
7062177 Grivna Jun 2006 B1
7170030 Haight Jan 2007 B2
7265033 Shigematsu et al. Sep 2007 B2
7337810 Orr Mar 2008 B2
7381383 Yokoyama Jun 2008 B1
7397014 Hart et al. Jul 2008 B2
7407591 De Battisti et al. Aug 2008 B2
7408130 Sonoda et al. Aug 2008 B2
7429470 Lee et al. Sep 2008 B2
7452476 Bayer et al. Nov 2008 B2
7525065 Engler et al. Apr 2009 B2
7535565 Viertl et al. May 2009 B1
7632420 Thomas Dec 2009 B2
7633033 Thomas Dec 2009 B2
7696454 Nam Apr 2010 B2
7791188 Sung Sep 2010 B2
7800014 Thomas Sep 2010 B2
7833463 Munson, Jr. Nov 2010 B1
7867404 Deutsch Jan 2011 B2
8030594 Thomas Oct 2011 B2
8144740 Brown Mar 2012 B1
8182609 Le Claire et al. May 2012 B1
8246172 Amano Aug 2012 B2
8269135 Thomas et al. Sep 2012 B2
8304686 Sano Nov 2012 B2
8348655 Kuzusako Jan 2013 B2
8371339 Li Feb 2013 B2
8536483 Thomas Sep 2013 B2
8604380 Howerton et al. Dec 2013 B2
8610025 Thomas et al. Dec 2013 B2
8687189 Agrawal et al. Apr 2014 B2
8980639 Clark et al. Mar 2015 B2
9108387 Retz Aug 2015 B2
9370842 Thomas et al. Jun 2016 B2
9375807 Thomas et al. Jun 2016 B2
9481052 Thomas et al. Nov 2016 B2
9895771 Thomas Feb 2018 B2
10086597 Simko Oct 2018 B2
10112257 Thomas Oct 2018 B1
10493559 Straw Dec 2019 B2
20020134770 Freiwald et al. Sep 2002 A1
20020153361 Sakamoto Oct 2002 A1
20030040164 Inoue et al. Feb 2003 A1
20030062349 Suh Apr 2003 A1
20030075531 Kupisiewicz Apr 2003 A1
20030083646 Sirhan May 2003 A1
20030085209 Lu May 2003 A1
20030090200 Topelberg May 2003 A1
20030098614 Shields May 2003 A1
20030169167 Fey Sep 2003 A1
20040033311 Bayer Feb 2004 A1
20040045497 Kriews et al. Mar 2004 A1
20040057047 Knebel Mar 2004 A1
20040199151 Neuberger Oct 2004 A1
20040219286 Flanagan Nov 2004 A1
20050006345 Thomas Jan 2005 A1
20050072612 Maggio Apr 2005 A1
20050150878 Thomas Jul 2005 A1
20050173052 Mitarai Aug 2005 A1
20050211680 Li Sep 2005 A1
20050224474 Kilburn Oct 2005 A1
20050233547 Noda Oct 2005 A1
20050247683 Agarwal Nov 2005 A1
20060000488 Claar et al. Jan 2006 A1
20060027540 Bruland Feb 2006 A1
20060151433 Chang et al. Jul 2006 A1
20060153270 Matsumoto Jul 2006 A1
20060186098 Caristan Aug 2006 A1
20060273896 Kates Dec 2006 A1
20070000885 Thomas Jan 2007 A1
20070051469 Bossi Mar 2007 A1
20070051708 Talwar et al. Mar 2007 A1
20070114213 Chen May 2007 A1
20070129474 Salamone Jun 2007 A1
20070224768 Chaplick Sep 2007 A1
20080006615 Rosario Jan 2008 A1
20080134939 Arpac Jun 2008 A1
20090007933 Thomas Jan 2009 A1
20090080476 Partlo Mar 2009 A1
20090242527 Anger Oct 2009 A1
20090273782 Yoo Nov 2009 A1
20100033817 Ono Feb 2010 A1
20100044357 Thomas Feb 2010 A1
20100044359 Sawabe Feb 2010 A1
20100093112 Takagi Apr 2010 A1
20100134628 Pfitzner Jun 2010 A1
20100176101 Costin Jul 2010 A1
20100243625 Osako Sep 2010 A1
20100272961 Costin, Jr. Oct 2010 A1
20110024400 Rumsby Feb 2011 A1
20110067808 Nishio Mar 2011 A1
20110088720 Varanasi et al. Apr 2011 A1
20110115129 Straw May 2011 A1
20110163068 Utlaut Jul 2011 A1
20110168679 Qi et al. Jul 2011 A1
20110186553 Chung Aug 2011 A1
20110203468 Harada Aug 2011 A1
20110206071 Karavitis Aug 2011 A1
20110240617 Xu Oct 2011 A1
20120006806 Thomas et al. Jan 2012 A1
20120086934 Dignonnet Apr 2012 A1
20120321735 Thomas Dec 2012 A1
20130005059 Song Jan 2013 A1
20130036380 Symons Feb 2013 A1
20130136744 Bouche et al. May 2013 A1
20130199732 Niwa et al. Aug 2013 A1
20130220982 Thomas et al. Aug 2013 A1
20130270234 Thomas et al. Oct 2013 A1
20140038392 Yonehars Feb 2014 A1
20140069897 Thomas Mar 2014 A1
20150013884 Yeh Jan 2015 A1
20150202858 Simko Jul 2015 A1
20160256959 Thomas et al. Sep 2016 A1
20180161936 Thomas et al. Jun 2018 A1
20180370212 Simko Dec 2018 A1
20190001435 Thomas Jan 2019 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (19)
Number Date Country
19715702 Oct 1998 DE
91646 Sep 2008 EP
2 661 371 Apr 1990 FR
2 689 423 Apr 1990 FR
2 246 099 Jan 1992 GB
2 402 230 Dec 2004 GB
2481190 Dec 2011 GB
01203090 Aug 1989 JP
02263854 Oct 1990 JP
05082276 Apr 1993 JP
05138377 Jun 1993 JP
10309516 Nov 1998 JP
2000103607 Apr 2000 JP
2001300755 Jan 2001 JP
200168829 Mar 2001 JP
361161781 Jun 2003 JP
2004039531 Oct 2004 WO
WO-2013059779 Apr 2013 WO
8301400 Apr 2019 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (22)
Entry
“Photonic Cleaning Process Moves to Heavy Industry,” Mar. 1997, p. 22, Photonics Spectra.
Freiwald et al., “Laser Ablation of Contaminants fromConcrete and Metals Surfaces,” Dec. 1994, pp. 1-53, F2 Associats, Incorporated.
Inta, “Radiant Energy Based Cleaning and Coating Removal Technology Comparison,” Aug. 8, 1994, pgs.
Barone,Philip A. “Automated Laser Paint Stripping(ALPS),” Jun. 1, 1992, pp. AD92-206-1 through AD92-206-17, Society of Manufacturing Engineers.
“The Company The Technology,” Apr. 1997, General Lasertronics Corporation.
“Lasertronics Corporate Overview,” Apr. 1997, Lasertronics Engineering Excellence.
“Lasertronics Aircraft Paint Removal,” Apr. 1997, Lasertronics Engineering Excellence.
“Lasertronics Radiation/Medical Decontamination,” Apr. 1997, Lasertronics Engineering Excellence.
“Lasertronics Graffiti Abatement,” Apr. 1997, Lasertronics Engineering Excellence.
“Lasertroniics Lead-Based Paint Removal,” Apr. 1997, Lasertronics Engineering Excellence.
Drscoll et al., “Handbook of Optics,” Dec. 1978, pp. 13-16 through 13-10, McGraw-Hill Book Company.
Liu et al., “Paint Removal Using Lasers,” Jul. 20, 1995, pp. 4409-4414, Applied Optics, vol. 34, No. 21.
Lovoi, Paul, “Laser Paint Stripping Offers Control and Flexibility,” Nov. 1994,pp. 75-80, Laser Focus World.
Bonkowski et al., “CW Laser Paint Stripping,” Aug. 1991, pp. 1-20, The Laser Institute and National Science and Engineering Research Council.
Lovoi, Paul,“Laser/Robot Paint Stripping, Laser Ablation CoatingRemoval,” Apr. 1988, International Technical Associates.
Tavernier et al., “Photoluminescence from laser assisted debonded epitaxial GaN and ZnO films”, Applied Physics Letters 74(18), pp. 2678-2680 (May 3, 1999).
Horie et al., “Interface structure modified by plasma-surface interaction and its effect on ablative hole opening process in a bilayer system of TeSeF film and a fluorocarbon subbing layer”, Journal of Applied Physics 77, 162-166 (Jan. 1995), American Institute of Physics.
Kononenko et al., “Ablation of CVD diamond with nanosecond laser pulses of UV-IR range”, Apr. 1998, Elsevier, Diamond and Related Materials, vol. 7, pp. 1623-1627.
Montelica-Heino et al., “Macro and Microchemistry of trace metals in vitrified domestic wastes by laser ablation ICP-MS and scanning electron microprobe X-Ray energy dispersive spectroscopy”, Aug. 1998, Elsevier, Talanta, pp. 407-422.
Hagans et al., “Chromate Conversion Coatings”, Dec. 1994, ASM Handbook, vol. 5, Surface Engineering, pp. 405-411.
Robertson, “Diamond-like amorphous carbon”, Dec. 2002, Elsevier, Materials Science and Engineering R, vol. 37, pp. 129-281.
Rothgeb, “Final Report on NASA portable laser coating removal systems filed demonstrations and testing,” May 1, 2008, NASA.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20210308788 A1 Oct 2021 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
61362976 Jul 2010 US
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 16123210 Sep 2018 US
Child 17351908 US
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 13177431 Jul 2011 US
Child 16123210 US