The present disclosure generally relates to the field of microwave filters. More specifically, the embodiments of the present disclosure relate to coaxial filter having at least one elongated resonator.
A microwave filter is an electromagnetic device that can be tuned to pass energy within bands of frequencies (i.e. the passband) encompassing resonant frequencies of the filter, while substantially suppressing unwanted frequencies (i.e. stopband).
Dielectric resonators, waveguide cavity resonators, and coaxial resonators are examples of types of microwave filters. Coaxial resonator filters use coaxial resonators which offer moderate quality factor, compact size and light weight. Coaxial resonator filters are attractive to many telecommunication applications.
U.S. Pat. No. 8,085,118 to Yu et al. discloses an inline microwave bandpass filter where cross coupling between non-adjacent resonators is realized by changing the orientation of selected resonators. The microwave bandpass filter includes a cavity and three or more resonators arranged in a row (or inline) in the cavity. At least one resonator has a different spatial orientation from, at least one other resonator. For example, one or more of the resonators may be rotated 90 or 180 degrees with respect to one of the other resonators. This arrangement of resonators facilitates sequential coupling between pairs of adjacent resonators and cross coupling between at least one pair of non-adjacent resonators without the use of additional cross coupling structures such as dedicated coupling probes or extra cavities. One or more plates may be introduced between adjacent resonators to independently control the sequential and cross coupling.
In order to meet rejection requirements for communication systems, transmission zeros (TZs) on one or both sides of the passband are frequently requirements in microwave bandpass filter design. Transmission zeros are often realized by couplings between non-adjacent resonators, often referred to as cross couplings. The feedback of electromagnetic signal using either iris or probe causes cancellation effect to form the TZs. Folded structures are often used to realize couplings between non-adjacent resonators. However, folded structures may not be always suitable where there are structural constraints that require input and output connectors on opposite sides of the two end resonators.
The present disclosure provides in one aspect a microwave filter having a housing defining an inner cavity. A first resonator is positioned in a first portion of the inner cavity. A second resonator is positioned in a second portion of the inner cavity. A third resonator is positioned in a third portion of the inner cavity. The first resonator and the third resonator are cross-coupled. The second resonator is elongated and is coupled to the first resonator and the third resonator. The resulting microwave filter has a frequency response having a transmission zero in the lower stopband. A high-pass filter is realized without the use of a cross-coupling probe.
The present disclosure provides in another aspect a microwave filter having five resonators. A first resonator is positioned in a first portion of the inner cavity. A second resonator is positioned in a second portion of the inner cavity. A third resonator is positioned in a third portion of the inner cavity. A fourth resonator is positioned in a fourth portion of the inner cavity. A fifth resonator is positioned in a fifth portion of the inner cavity. The first resonator and the third resonator are cross-coupled. The second resonator is coupled to the first resonator and the third resonator. The third resonator is further cross-coupled to the fifth resonator. The fourth resonator is elongated and is coupled to the third resonator and the fifth resonator. The resulting microwave filter has a frequency response having a transmission zero in the lower stopband and a transmission zero in the upper stopband. A band-pass filter is realized without the use of a cross-coupling probe.
The present disclosure provides in yet another aspect a housing defining an inner cavity. A first input port is provided in the housing for radiating a first resonant mode into the cavity. A second input port is provided in the housing for radiating a second resonant mode into the cavity. The second resonant mode is orthogonal to the first mode. A resonator is positioned in the inner cavity. The resonator has a resonator body, a first member, a second member, a third member, and a fourth member. The first and second members extend laterally from the resonator body and opposite each other. The third and fourth members extend laterally from the resonator body, opposite each other and in a direction orthogonal to a direction of extension of the first and second member. Both the first resonant mode and the second resonant mode resonate within the cavity having the resonators.
A detailed description of various exemplary embodiments is provided herein below with reference to the following drawings, by way of example only, and in which:
It will be appreciated that numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the exemplary embodiments described herein. However, it will be understood by those of ordinary skill in the art that the embodiments described herein may be practiced without these specific details. In other instances, well-known methods, procedures and components have not been described in detail so as not to obscure the embodiments described herein. Furthermore, this description is not to be considered as limiting the scope of the embodiments described herein in any ways, but rather as merely describing the implementation of the various embodiments described herein.
Referring now to
Typically, each of the first resonator 110, second resonator 120 and third resonator 130 has a cylindrical body defined by a circular cross-section, as shown. Alternatively, the first resonator 110, second resonator 120 or third resonator 130 can have a cross section wherein the cross-sectional width is substantially equal to the cross-section length, such as a square cross-section. Accordingly, for each individual resonator, the electric field propagating to and from that resonator is oriented in the same direction and in phase over the surface of the resonator. Each of the first resonator 110, second resonator 120 and third resonator 130 can be fixed to the housing floor.
The first portion 112 of the inner cavity 104 is in fluid communication with the second portion 122 of the inner cavity 104, thereby allowing the first resonator 110 to be electromagnetically coupled to the second resonator 120. The first resonator 110 and the second resonator 120 are adjacent resonators. The coupling between the first resonator 110 and the second resonator 120 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The second portion 122 of the inner cavity 104 is in fluid communication with the third portion 132 of the inner cavity 104, thereby allowing the second resonator 120 to be electromagnetically coupled to the third resonator 130. The second resonator 120 and the third resonator 130 are adjacent resonators. The coupling between the second resonator 120 and the third resonator 130 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The first portion 112 of the inner cavity 104 is further in fluid communication with the third portion 132 of the inner cavity 104 via an iris 140. The first resonator 110 and the third resonator 130 are non-adjacent resonators. The first resonator 110 is electromagnetically cross-coupled to the third resonator 130 via the iris 140. The coupling between the first resonator 110 and the third resonator 130 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
Signals propagating through the inner cavity 104 from an input 150 to an output 152 can propagate over two paths. Over the first path, signals propagate from the first resonator 110 to the second resonator 120 to the third resonator 130 (herein referred to as R1-R2-R3). Over the second path, signals propagate from the first resonator 110 to the third resonator 130 (herein referred to as R1-R3).
Referring now to
Referring now to
Continuing with reference to
While the addition of the cross-coupling probe 160 allows a transmission zero to be located in the lower stopband of the microwave filter 100, the cross-coupling probe 160 introduces certain disadvantages. For example, the cross-coupling probe 160 can generate unwanted resonances that degrade filter performance. For example, the unwanted resonances degrade near-band and wide-band transmission characteristics. Fabrication of the cross-coupling probe can also be difficult, in particular, at high frequencies (such as microwave frequencies). Furthermore, because the cross-coupling probe must be placed inside the filter, accessing the probe to tune the filter requires more parts of the filter to be moved. This further causes the tuning process to be more sensitive and difficult. Accordingly, the process for tuning a microwave filter 100 having a cross-coupling probe 160 becomes more difficult and more expensive.
Referring now to
Referring now to
Other techniques used to realize transmission zeros include extracted pole technique and non-resonating nodes technique. However both techniques require additional resonating or non-resonating structures, which lead to further size and mass increase.
Referring now to
A first resonator 710 is positioned in a first portion 712 of the inner cavity 704. A second resonator 720 is positioned in a second portion 722 of the inner cavity 704. A third resonator 730 is positioned in a third portion 732 of the inner cavity 704. Each of the first resonator 710, the second resonator 720 and the third resonator 730 can be fixed to the housing floor 708.
The first resonator 710 has a cylindrical body defined by a circular cross-section. The third resonator 730 also has a cylindrical body defined by a circular-cross-section. Alternatively, the first resonator 710 and the third resonator 730 can each have a cross section wherein the cross-sectional width is substantially equal to the cross-sectional length, such as a square cross-section.
The second resonator 720 is elongated. As shown, in
Referring now to
Referring back to
The second portion 722 of the inner cavity 704 is in fluid communication with the third portion 732 of the inner cavity 704, thereby allowing the elongated second resonator 720 to be electromagnetically coupled to the third resonator 730. The elongated second resonator 720 and the third resonator 730 are adjacent resonators. For example, the third resonator 730 can be predominantly electromagnetically coupled to the second end 738 of the elongated second resonator 720. The electromagnetic coupling between the elongated second resonator 720 and the third resonator 730 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The first portion 712 of the inner cavity 704 is further in fluid communication with the third portion 732 of the inner cavity 704. For example, the fluid communication is provided by an iris 740 as shown in
According to various exemplary embodiments, first resonator 710, second resonator 720 and third resonator 730 are positioned within the housing 702 to define a geometric shape. For example, the three resonators can be arranged to define a triangular shape. The housing 702 can have inner walls 742 (
According to various exemplary embodiments, the microwave coaxial filter 700 has an input port 750 and an output port 752, as shown in
Signals propagating through the inner cavity 704 from the first resonator 710 to the third resonator 730 can propagate over two paths. Over the first path, signals propagate from the first resonator 710 to the elongated second resonator 720 to the third resonator 730 (R1-R2-R3). Over the second path, signals propagate from the first resonator 710 to the third resonator 730 (R1-R3).
Along the first signal path R1-R2-R3, the elongated second resonator 720 couples to the first resonator 710 and the third resonator 730. The coupling between the first and the second resonators 710 and 720 as well as the second and the third resonators 720 and 730 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive. Along the signal path R1-R3, the coupling between the first and the third resonators can be modeled dominantly inductive.
Referring now to
The location of the transmission zero 904 can be further adjusted by varying the length of the elongated second resonator 720. For example, increasing the length of the elongated second resonator 720 causes the transmission zero 904 to shift towards a lower frequency. Advantageously, since the microwave filter 700 with the elongated second resonator 720 is free of any cross-coupling probe for cross-coupling any one of the resonators, tuning the microwave filter 700 can be achieved more easily and at lower cost. Furthermore, performance of the microwave filter 700 is significantly improved due to the absence of a cross-coupling probe.
Referring now to
Referring now to
Referring now to
According to various exemplary embodiments, the elongated second resonator 720 can have other suitable shapes that cause the electric field at the first end 736 to be out-of-phase with the electric field of the second end 738. The elongated second resonator 720 can be S-shaped. Such a shape provides a trade-off between increasing the width and the length of the housing 702 while maintaining the end-to-end length of the elongated second resonator 720. Alternatively, at least one of the first end 736 or second end 738, or both, is larger than a portion of the elongated second resonator 720 joining the two ends. For example, the elongated third resonator 730 can be dumbbell-shaped. Various alternate shapes of the elongated second resonator 720 allows for decreasing the length of 762 of the resonator 720.
Referring now to
A first resonator 1210 is positioned in a first portion 1212 of the inner cavity 1204. A second resonator 1220 is positioned in a second portion 1222 of the inner cavity 1204. A third resonator 1230 is positioned in a third portion 1232 of the inner cavity 1204. Each of the first resonator 1210, second resonator 1220 and third resonator 1230 can be fixed to the housing floor.
The first resonator 1210, the second resonator 1220 and the third resonator 1230 each has a cylindrical body defined by a circular cross-section. Alternatively, the first resonator 1210, the second resonator 1220 and the third resonator 1230 can have a cross section wherein the cross-sectional width is substantially equal to the cross-section length, such as a square cross-section.
The first portion 1212 of the inner cavity 1204 is in fluid communication with the second portion 1222, thereby allowing the first resonator 1210 to be electromagnetically coupled to the second resonator 1220. The first resonator 1210 and the second resonator 1220 are adjacent resonators. The electromagnetic coupling between first resonator 1210 and the second resonator 1220 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The second portion 1222 of the inner cavity 1204 is in fluid communication with the third portion 1232, thereby allowing the second resonator 1220 to be electromagnetically coupled to the third resonator 1230. The second resonator 1220 and the third resonator 1230 are adjacent resonators. The electromagnetic coupling between second resonator 1220 and the third resonator 1230 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The first portion 1212 of the inner cavity 1204 is further in fluid communication with the third portion 1232 of the inner cavity 1204. For example, an iris 1234 allows the first portion 1212 to communicate with the third portion 1232. The first resonator 1210 and the third resonator 1230 are non-adjacent resonators. The coupling between the first resonator 1210 and third resonator 1230 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
According to various exemplary embodiments, first resonator 1210, second resonator 1220 and third resonator 1230 are positioned within the housing 1202 to define a geometric shape. For example, the three resonators can be arranged to define a triangular shape. The housing 1202 can have first inner walls 1236 positioned within the geometric shape defined by the positions of the resonators 1210, 1220, and 1230. The first inner walls 1236 provide a separation between the resonators and with the housing 1202. The inner walls 1236 and the housing 1202 together define the first portion 1212, second portion 1222, and third portion 1232 of the cavity 1204. The first inner walls 1236 can further define with the housing 1202 channels of the inner cavity 1204 providing fluid communication between the first resonator 1210, second resonator 1220, and the third resonator 1230.
It will be appreciated that the first resonator 1210 located in the first portion 1212 of the inner cavity 1204, the second resonator 1220 located in the second portion 1222 of the inner cavity 1204 and the third resonator 1230 located in the third portion 1232 of the inner cavity 1204 share the same characteristics as the resonators of the low-pass microwave coaxial filter 100 (
A fourth resonator 1240 is positioned in a fourth portion 1242 of the inner cavity 1204. A fifth resonator 1250 is positioned in a fifth portion 1252 of the inner cavity 1204. Each of the fourth resonator 1240 and fifth resonator 1250 can be fixed to the housing floor.
The fifth resonator 1250 has a cylindrical body defined by a circular cross-section. Alternatively, the fifth resonator 1250 can have a cross section wherein the cross-sectional width is substantially equal to the cross-section length, such as a square cross-section.
The fourth resonator 1240 is elongated. The cross section of the fourth resonator 1240 in a plane parallel to the housing floor 1208 is elongated in a lengthwise direction, such that the elongated fourth resonator 1240 has a length that is substantially greater than its width. For example, the fourth resonator 1240 can have an oval cross-section as shown in
In addition, and for example, the ratio of the length of the fourth resonator 1240 to the width of the fourth resonator 1240 is between 2 to 5. When electromagnetic signals are propagating within the inner cavity 1204, the fourth resonator 1240 is elongated in a direction parallel to the orientation of the magnetic field. The elongated fourth resonator 1240 can have the characteristics of the elongated second resonator 720 described herein with reference to
The third portion 1232 of the inner cavity 1204 is in fluid communication with the fourth portion 1242 of the inner cavity 1204, thereby allowing the third resonator 1230 to be electromagnetically coupled to the fourth resonator 1240. The third resonator 1230 and the elongated fourth resonator 1240 are adjacent resonators. For example, the third resonator 1230 can be predominantly electromagnetically coupled to a first end 1246 of the elongated fourth resonator 1240. The electromagnetic coupling between the third resonator 1230 and the elongated fourth resonator 1240 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The fourth portion 1242 of the inner cavity 1204 is in fluid communication with the fifth portion 1252 of the inner cavity 1204, thereby allowing the elongated fourth resonator 1240 to be electromagnetically coupled to the fifth resonator 1250. The elongated fourth resonator 1240 and the fifth resonator 1250 are adjacent resonators. For example, the fifth resonator 1250 can be predominantly electromagnetically coupled to the second end 1248 of the elongated fourth resonator 1240. The electromagnetic coupling between the elongated fourth resonator 1240 and the fifth resonator 1250 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
The third portion 1232 of the inner cavity 1204 is further in fluid communication with the fifth portion 1252 of the inner cavity 1204. For example, the fluid communication is provided by an iris 1260. The third resonator 1230 and the fifth resonator 1250 are non-adjacent resonators. The third resonator 1230 is electromagnetically cross-coupled to the fifth resonator 1250, for example, via the iris 1260. The third resonator 1230 is electromagnetically cross-coupled to the fifth resonator 1250. Notably, the cross-coupling is free of a cross-coupling probe. The coupling between the third resonator 1230 and the fifth resonator 1250 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive. According to various exemplary embodiments, third resonator 1230, fourth resonator 1240 and fifth resonator 1250 are positioned within the housing 1202 to define a geometric shape. For example, these three resonators can be arranged to define a triangular shape. The housing 1202 can have second inner walls 1261 positioned within the geometric shape defined by the positions of the resonators 1230, 1240 and 1250. The second inner walls 1261 provide a separation between the resonators and with the housing 1202. The inner walls 1261 and the housing 1202 together define the first portion 1212, second portion 1222 and third portion 1232 of the cavity 1204 as shown in
According to various exemplary embodiments, the bandpass microwave coaxial filter 1200 has input port 1262 and an output port 1264. The input port 1262 can form an electromagnetic connection with the first resonator 1210 such that signals provided at input port 1262 initially resonate at the first resonator 1210. The output port 1264 forms an electromagnetic connection with the fifth resonator 1250 such that signals resonating at the fifth resonator 1250 are outputted via the output port 1264. It will be understood that input port 1262 and output port 1264 have been denoted as input and output respectively for ease of notation only, and that the use of the ports as either an input or an output is interchangeable. For example, input port 1262 and output port 1264 can be connected to coaxial cables or connectors 1266 and 1268.
According to various exemplary embodiments, the first resonator 1210, the third resonator 1230 and the fifth resonator 1250 can be substantially aligned to define an axis. Input port 1262 and output port 1264 can be further aligned with the axis. Accordingly, input port 1262 and output port 1264 are opposing. Moreover, the microwave filter 1200 can have a generally linearly elongated shape.
Signals propagating through the inner cavity 1204 from the first resonator 1210 to the third resonator 1230 can propagate over two paths. Over the first path, signals propagate from the first resonator 1210 to the second resonator 1220 to the third resonator 1230 (R1-R2-R3). Over the second path, signals propagate from the first resonator 1210 to the third resonator 1230 (R1-R3).
Along the first signal path R1-R2-R3, the second resonator 1220 couples to the first resonator 1210 and the third resonator 1230. The coupling between the first and the second resonators 1210 and 1220 as well as the coupling between the second and the third resonators 1220 and 1230 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
After having reached the third resonator 1230, signals can further propagate from the first resonator 1230 to the fifth resonator 1250 and output 1264 over two paths. Over the first path, signals propagate from the third resonator 1230 to the fourth resonator 1240 to the fifth resonator 1250 (herein referred to as R3-R4-R5). Over the second path, signals propagate from the third resonator 1230 to the fifth resonator 1250 (herein referred to as R3-R5).
Along the first signal path R3-R4-R5, the elongated fourth resonator 1240 couples to the third resonator 1230 and the fifth resonator 1250. These couplings between the third and the fourth resonators 1230 and 1240 as well as the coupling between the fourth and the fifth resonators 1240 and 1250 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive. For the second signal path R3-R5, the coupling between the third and the fifth resonators 1230 and 1250 can be modeled as being dominantly inductive.
Referring now to
Continuing with reference to
The location of the transmission zero 1308 in the lower stopband can be further adjusted by varying the length of the elongated fourth resonator 1240. Advantageously, since the microwave filter 1200 with elongated fourth resonator 1240 is free of a cross-coupling probe for at least one of the cross-coupling of two resonators, tuning of the microwave filter 1200 can be achieved. For example, tuning can be achieved using tuning screws that can be accessed from outside of the filter housing 1202. This tuning approach can be achieved more easily and at lower cost. Furthermore, performance of the microwave filter 1200 is significantly improved due to the absence of a cross-coupling probe. According to some exemplary embodiments, the entire bandpass microwave filter 1200 can be implemented without use of a cross-coupling probe.
It will be appreciated that the microwave filter 1200 is formed by cascading a low-pass microwave filter 100 with the microwave filter 700 having an elongated resonator 720, wherein the third resonator 1230 is shared in the cascaded arrangement. According to various exemplary embodiments, any number of low-pass microwave filters 100 can be cascaded with any number of microwave filters 700 having the elongated resonator 730 in order to form a microwave filter assembly with a desired number of transmission zeros in the lower stopband and a desired number of transmission zeros in the upper stopband. A low-pass microwave filter 100 can be introduced in order to form a transmission zero in the upper stopband. A microwave filter 700 having an elongated resonator 730 can be introduced in order to form a transmission zero in the lower stopband. It will be appreciated that a microwave filter assembly formed by cascading one or more low-pass microwave filters 100 described herein and one or more high-pass microwave filters 700 having an elongated third resonator 730 described herein can be implemented to be free of cross-coupling probes for cross-coupling two resonators of the microwave filter assembly.
Referring now to
Reference is now made to
Returning to
Returning to
Returning to
The location of the transmission zeros in the stopband can be adjusted using one or more of tuning screws, decoupling walls, adjustments of the resonators or other mechanisms according to techniques known in the art. The location of the transmission zeros located in the lower stop band can be further adjusted by varying the length of the elongated fourth resonator 1240 of the first microwave filter 1200 and/or the length of the elongated fourth resonator 1240′ of the second microwave filter 1200′.
The microwave coaxial filters described according to various exemplary embodiments provide a savings in space over an equivalent waveguide filter. Referring now to
According to various exemplary embodiments, the filter function can be slightly pre-distorted in order to improve the shape of the return loss and obtain a better equivalent Quality Factor. For example, the filter function can be pre-distorted by having 10 to 15 dB return loss. The pre-distortion of the filter function provides improved in-band flatness without having to increase the size of the filter.
Various exemplary embodiments of microwave coaxial filters described herein can be implemented to achieve a Quality Factor of approximately 3000. Accordingly, the microwave coaxial filters having at least one elongated resonator can be suitable for use as Ka-band filters. For example, the microwave coaxial filters having at least one elongated resonator can be suitable where only wideband filters are required. Advantageously, in being free of cross-coupling probes for at least one of the cross-coupling of two resonators, the microwave coaxial filters having at least one elongated resonator can be manufactured at a lower cost and with more easily.
Referring now to
A first input 1710 is provided in a first subwall 1712 (
The electromagnetic energy radiated into the inner cavity 1704 via the first input 1710 can resonate as a first resonant mode in the inner cavity 1704. The electromagnetic energy radiated into the inner cavity 1704 via the second input 1714 can resonate as a second resonant mode that is orthogonal to the first resonant mode. Accordingly, the first resonant mode and the second resonant mode can resonate simultaneously within the inner cavity 1704 without substantially interfering with one another.
A dual-mode resonator 1720 is positioned in the inner cavity 1704. For example, the resonator 1720 can be attached to the housing floor 1708. The dual mode resonator 1720 has a body portion 1722 (
The first member 1724 and second member 1726 extend laterally from the central body 1722 opposite from each other. The directions of the extension of the first and second members 1724 and 1726 define a first axis 1732, designated as an X-axis.
Third member 1730 and fourth member 1728 each extend laterally from the central body 1722 opposite from each other. The directions of the extension of the third and fourth members 1730 and 1728 define a second axis 1734, designated as a Y-axis, that is orthogonal to the first axis 1732. As shown in
The first and second resonant modes can simultaneously resonate within the dual-mode resonator 1720. For example, the first axis 1732 of the dual-mode resonator 1720 can be aligned with the input port 1710 and the second axis 1734 with the second input port 1714.
It will be appreciated that the dual-mode resonator 1720 acts as two elongated resonators being positioned orthogonally within the inner cavity 1704. Advantageously, the two resonant modes can be generated individually. Furthermore, the coupling between the two resonant modes can be optimized individually. Moreover, the space required to implement the dual-mode resonator 1720 is substantially less than the space that would be required by using two separate elongated resonators. For example, the space required by the dual-mode resonator 1720 can be half of that required by two separate resonators.
According to various exemplary embodiments, a coupling element 1736 can be provided in the housing wall 1702 to couple the first resonant mode of the dual-mode resonator 1720 with the second resonant mode of the dual-mode resonator 1720. For example, the coupling element 1736 can be a coupling screw. The coupling element 1736 is oriented at a non-zero angle relative to axes 1732 and 1734. For example, the coupler is oriented at a 45 degree angle in relation to axis 1732 defined by the first and second members 1724 and 1726 and to axis 1734 defined by the third and fourth members 1728 and 1730.
While the above description provides examples of the embodiments, it will be appreciated that some features and/or functions of the described embodiments are susceptible to modification without departing from the spirit and principles of operation of the described embodiments. Accordingly, what has been described above has been intended to be illustrative of the invention and non-limiting and it will be understood by persons skilled in the art that other variants and modifications may be made without departing from the scope of the invention as defined in the claims appended hereto.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4623857 | Nishikawa | Nov 1986 | A |
5936490 | Hershtig | Aug 1999 | A |
8085118 | Yu et al. | Dec 2011 | B2 |
20070139142 | Li et al. | Jun 2007 | A1 |
20080252399 | Wiehler | Oct 2008 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2640210 | Mar 1978 | DE |
102006061141 | Jun 2008 | DE |
1320144 | Jun 2003 | EP |
Entry |
---|
European Search Report for European Application 14166086.0 dated Jan. 30, 2015. |
European Partial Search Report for EP Application No. 14166086.0, dated Sep. 1, 2014. |
European Examination Report for EP Application No. 14166086.0 dated Dec. 18, 2015. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20140347147 A1 | Nov 2014 | US |