The present invention belongs to the technical field of reliability analysis of electric drive systems, in particular to a compilation method for a reliability test load spectrum of a high-speed bearing of an electric drive system.
As an effective way of sustainable development of automobiles, electrification has been strongly supported by strategic planning and industrial policies in different countries.
The electric drive system is a core component of vehicle electrification.
Higher requirements have been proposed for stability, reliability and durability of high-speed bearings of electric drive systems because of characteristics of a new energy vehicle drive motor, such as a wider speed regulation range, a large starting torque, high power density and high efficiency.
At present, there are rare reliability test methods and technical evaluation specifications for high-speed bearings of electric drive systems. For the reliability assessment of a single part or component, screening and evaluation methods of a highly accelerated life and a highly accelerated stress under simple working conditions and continuous loading are often adopted, but it is difficult to effectively cover the variable amplitude load history of high-speed bearings under multiple working conditions during actual use by users.
Therefore, it is an urgent necessity to propose a method to construct a reliability test load spectrum correlated to actual failure modes of a high-speed bearing based on a load time history of an electric drive system in a whole life cycle, so as to effectively verify a reliability level of the high-speed bearing and provide technical support for positive high-performance development of the bearing.
The purpose of the present invention is to provide a compilation method for a reliability test load spectrum of a high-speed bearing of an electric drive system, which correlates with actual failure modes of the high-speed bearing, covers damage targets of the bearings in a whole life cycle, and constructs the reliability test load spectrum of the high-speed bearing under variable amplitude loading and multiple working conditions. The present invention can effectively verify a reliability level of the high-speed bearing and provide technical support for high-quality development of the high-speed bearing in the electric drive system.
To achieve the above purpose, the present invention provides the following solution: The present invention provides a compilation method for a reliability test load spectrum of a high-speed bearing of an electric drive system, which comprises the following steps:
step 1: according to a load spectrum of a whole life cycle of an electric drive system, correlating a leading failure load of a high-speed bearing, and analyzing joint distribution characteristics of multi-dimensional loads of a rotation speed and a torque;
step 2: constructing a high-speed bearing balance equation under the joint loads;
step 3: calculating a high-speed bearing life and bearing damage and conducting damage analysis;
step 4: determining a reliability test load level and a time proportion relation of each typical load level;
step 5: determining a damage target of the whole life cycle of the bearing; and
step 6: compiling a reliability test load spectrum of the high-speed bearing.
Preferably, a multi-dimensional load joint counting method is used to count action frequencies under different rotation speeds and different torque levels in the load spectrum of the electric drive system in the whole life cycle, and the number of turns of the high-speed bearing under the different load levels is obtained.
Preferably, a Newton-Raphson iterative method is used to calculate different contact loads of the high-speed bearings, comprising the following sub-steps:
step 2-1: constructing the balance equation of the high-speed bearing under a radial load; and
step 2-2: constructing the balance equation of the high-speed bearing under the radial load and an axial load.
Preferably, a specific method of constructing the balance equation of the high-speed bearing under the radial load comprises the following steps:
Under high-speed bearing centrifugal force, Qi, is a contact load between a steel ball and a bearing inner ring, Qe is the contact load between the steel ball and a bearing outer ring, so that centrifugal force Fe of a bearing ball is:
Q
ej
−Q
ij
=Fe (1)
Where j is the number of the bearing ball;
F
e=½mDmωm2 (2)
In equation (2), m is the mass of the steel ball; Dm is an average diameter of the high-speed bearing; ωm is a revolution angular velocity of the bearing ball;
In equation (3), δr is a relative radial displacement between inner and outer rolling paths of the high-speed bearing; Pd is a radial internal clearance of the high-speed bearing; δmax is a total elastic deformation at the contact position between a rolling body and the inner and outer rings of a radial load action line; and ε is a load distribution parameter of the high-speed bearing, where ε is calculated as follows:
A contact load Qij of the inner ring of the high-speed bearing is:
Where Qmax is a maximum contact load between a roller of the high-speed bearing and the rolling path; and Kn is a contact stiffness coefficient between the roller and the rolling path of the high-speed bearing;
Q
rj
=Q
iψcos ψj (7)
In equation (7), Qiψ, is a contact load at different position angles ψj;
According to the mechanical balance equation of the bearing, the radial contact load of the high-speed bearing is obtained. The mechanical balance equation of the high-speed bearing is:
In equation (8), Kn is a contact stiffness coefficient between the roller and the rolling path of the high-speed bearing.
Preferably, when the high-speed bearing bears both the radial load and the axial load simultaneously, the inner and outer rings of the high-speed bearing will generate relative displacements, including the axial displacement 8a and the radial displacement δr. The outer ring of the high-speed bearing is fixed. After the high-speed bearing is loaded, the inner ring of the high-speed bearing will generate a relative displacement relative to the outer ring of the high-speed bearing;
Db is the diameter of the high-speed bearing ball; D, is the average bearing diameter of the high-speed bearing; and ao is an initial contact angle between the high-speed bearing ball and the rolling path;
After the high-speed bearing is loaded, a circumferential radius R, where a curvature center of an inner ring rolling path groove is located is:
R
i=0.5Dm+(ri−0.5Db)cos α0 (9)
A circumferential radius Ro where the curvature center of a rolling path groove of the high-speed bearing outer ring is located is:
R
o=0.5Dm−(re−0.5Db)cos α0 (10),
At any angular position Vi, a distance r between the curvature centers of inner and outer rolling path grooves of the high-speed bearing is:
r=[(GDb sinαo+δa)2+(GDb cosαo,+δr,cosψ)2]1/2 (11),
In equation (11), r is a curvature radius of the rolling path groove of the inner and outer rings of the high-speed bearing; G=fe+fi−1, fn is a curvature radius coefficient of the rolling path groove of a high-speed bearing cover; fn=rn/Db, wherein n=i and e, which respectively represent the inner ring and outer ring of the high-speed bearing; 6a and 6r represent the relative axial displacement and the relative radial displacement of the inner and outer rings of the high-speed bearing respectively;
Dimensionless quantities are introduced:
The following equations are set:
N=sinαo+
L=cosαo+
In equations (14) and (15), N and L are dimensionless quantities. Equations (14) and (15) are substituted into Equation (11), so that:
r=GD
b(N2+L2)1/2 (16),
A total deformation δ104 obtained by the contact between the bearing ball and the inner and outer rings of the high-speed bearing at the angular position ψ is:
δψ=GDb[(N2+L2)1/2 −1] (17),
According to equation (1), the contact load Qψ, of the inner ring of the high-speed bearing is:
In equation (18), Kp is an elastic deformation constant of high-speed bearing point contact.
The contact angle αψ between the bearing ball and the high-speed bearing ring at any angular position is
According to balance conditions, the radial load and the axial load acting on the high-speed bearing are Fr and Fa respectively, so that:
Equations (20) and (21) are nonlinear equation systems of unknown numbers
Preferably, in step 3, that method for calculating the life of the high-speed bearing is as follow:
Based on standards improved by a Lundberg-Palmgren bearing life theory, the life of the high-speed bearing under different load levels is calculated.
A calculation method of high-speed bearing damage is as follows: a Palmgren-Miner linear cumulative damage rule is adopted, and a life of the rolling path of the high-speed bearing is L1 under the working condition of an equivalent dynamic load P1, and if the bearing runs for Ni turns under the working condition, equivalent damage of the high-speed bearing under the working condition P1 is: D1=N1/L1; If the high-speed bearing experiences a random road load and runs for N1,N2, . . . ,Nn turns under equivalent loads of P1, P2, . . . ,Pn, the damage caused by the random road load to the high-speed bearing is as follows:
In equation (22), n is a set of working conditions of the high-speed bearing, and for each corresponding working condition i, the fatigue life of the high-speed bearing is Li turns, and under the working condition, the high-speed bearing runs for Ni turns, wherein Ni<Li.
Preferably, in step 4, the reliability test load level is determined according to the following characteristics:
Characteristic 4.1: different distribution characteristics of damage contribution of the high-speed bearing are involved;
Characteristic 4.2: selection of the reliability test load level should include the typical working conditions of the load spectrum of the electric drive system in the whole life cycle, and at the same time, the damage contribution should be high; and
Characteristic 4.3: the reliability test load spectrum includes extreme load working conditions.
Preferably, the extreme load working conditions include the extreme speed and the maximum torque of the high-speed bearing motor of the electric drive system.
Preferably, in step 4, steps of determining the time proportion relation of different typical load levels are as follows:
step 4.1: transferring a load frequency near a target load working condition to a given target load based on a principle of a consistent overall action frequency, so as to obtain a time proportion under all typical load levels; and
step 4.2: dynamically adjusting the time of each load working condition from the perspective of damage to meet a total damage target of the high-speed bearing in the whole life cycle load spectrum of the electric drive system.
Preferably, in step 6, compilation contents of the reliability test load spectrum comprise:
Content 6.1: The reliability test load spectrum of the high-speed bearing should cover a variable amplitude loading history of the high-speed bearing under the multiple working conditions during actual operation;
Content 6.2: In the process of compiling the reliability test load spectrum, extreme load working conditions should be considered according to a motor limit speed and a maximum torque; and
Content 6.3: During determination of time of acceleration or deceleration in the process of transfer between load working conditions of different grades, slopes of a load rising stage and a falling stage are extracted based on an original load history, and the time when the reliability test load level rises or falls is determined based on a slope distribution model.
The present invention has the technical effects: the reliability test load spectrum constructed by the present invention is correlated to an actual failure mode of the high-speed bearing, which can effectively verify a reliability level of the high-speed bearing and provide support for high-quality development of the high-speed bearing of the electric drive system.
In order to more clearly explain the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings needed in the embodiments will be briefly introduced below. It is apparent that the drawings in the following description are only some embodiments of the present invention, and for those of ordinary skill in the art, other drawings can be obtained according to these drawings without making creative labor.
Next, the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described with reference to the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. It is apparent that the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of them. Based on the embodiments in the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by those of ordinary skill in the art without creative work are within the protection scope of the present invention.
In order to make the above-mentioned purposes, features and advantages of the present invention more obvious and easier to understand, the present invention will be described in further detail below with reference to the drawings and specific implementations.
present invention is shown in
Step 1: based on the load data of 300,000 km in the whole life cycle of the electric drive system, joint distribution of rotation speeds and torque loads is counted, and the number of rotating turns of the bearing under different rotation speed and torque levels in the original load spectrum is obtained:
The joint distribution of the rotation speeds and the torque load is counted; the load data of 300,000 km is divided into different load levels; action frequencies under different load levels are counted; and the numbers of bearing rotation turns under the different load levels are calculated according to the frequency distribution characteristics of each load level, wherein part of the load data is shown in
Step 2: a high-speed bearing balance equation is constructed:
By construction of a balance equation of the high-speed bearing under joint loads, a contact load of the bearing under different rotation speed and torque levels is determined.
Force bearing conditions and models of high-speed bearings at both ends of an electric drive system motor are different, and their contact loads are different. The bearings at both ends of an input shaft are taken as the research object. When the load is driving forward, the bearing far away from the motor side bears an axial load and a radial load, while the bearing near the motor side bears the radial load. When the load is driving in the opposite direction, the bearing far away from the motor side bears the radial load, while the bearing near the motor side bears the radial load and the axial load.
The construction of the balance equation of the high-speed bearing under the joint loads in step 2 comprises the following sub-steps:
Step 2-1: in a balance equation of the high-speed bearing under a radial load, considering bearing centrifugal force, if Qi and Qe are contact loads between a steel ball and inner and outer rings of the bearing respectively, then:
Q
ej
−Q
ij
=Fe (1)
In equation (1), Qi is the contact load between the steel ball and the bearing inner ring; Qe is the contact load between the steel ball and the bearing outer ring; j is the number of the bearing steel ball; and Fe is the centrifugal force of the steel ball:
F
e=½mDmωm2 (2)
In equation (2), m is the mass of the steel ball; Dm is the average diameter of the bearing; and ωm is revolution angular velocity of the steel ball.
As shown in
In equation (3), δr is a relative radial displacement between inner and outer rolling paths of the bearing; Pd is a radial internal clearance of the bearing; δmax is a total elastic deformation at the contact position between a rolling body and the inner and outer rings of a radial load action line; and s is a load distribution parameter of the bearing, where s is calculated as follows:
In equation (4) δr is a relative radial displacement between the inner and outer rolling paths; and Pd is a radial internal clearance of the bearing.
A contact load Qij of the inner ring of the bearing is:
In equation (6), Qmax is a maximum contact load between a ball and the rolling path; and Kn is a contact stiffness coefficient between the roller and the rolling path.
A radial contact load is:
Q
rj
=Q
iψcos ψj (7)
In equation (7), Qv, is a contact load at different position angles ψj;
According to the mechanical balance equation of the bearing, the radial contact load is obtained. The mechanical balance equation of the bearing is:
In equation (8), Fr is the radial force borne by the bearing.
In step 2-2, according to the balance equation of high-speed bearing under the radial load and the axial load, when the bearing bears both the radial load and the axial load, the inner and outer rings will produce relative displacements, including an axial displacement δa and a radial displacement δr. As shown in
After the bearing is loaded, a circumferential radius Ri where a curvature center of an inner ring rolling path groove is located is:
R
i=0.5Dm+(ri−0.5Db)cos α0 (9)
In equation (9), Db is the diameter of the bearing ball; Dm is the average diameter of the bearing; and ao is an initial contact angle between the ball and the rolling path.
The circumferential radius Ro where a curvature center of an outer rolling path groove is located is:
R
o=0.5Dm−(re−0.5Db)cos α0 (10),
At any angular position ψ, the distance r between the curvature centers of inner and outer ring grooves is:
r=[(GDb sinαo+δa)2+(GDb cosαo,+δr,cosψ)2]1/2 (11),
In equations (10) and (11), rn is the curvature radius of the rolling path groove; G=fe+fi31 1, fn is a curvature radius coefficient of the rolling path groove; fn=rn/Db, wherein n=i and e, which respectively represent the inner ring and outer ring of the bearing; and δa and δr represent the relative axial displacement and relative radial displacement of the inner and outer rings of the bearing respectively;
Dimensionless quantities are introduced:
The following equations are set:
N=sinαo+
L=cosαo+
In equations (14) and (15), N and L are dimensionless quantities. Equations (14) and (15) are substituted into Equation (11), so that:
r=GD
b(N2+L2)1/2 (16 ),
The total deformation δψ, obtained by the contact between the steel ball and the inner and outer rings at the position ψ is:
δψ=GDb[(N2+L2)1/2 −1] (17),
According to equation (1), the contact load Qψ of the bearing inner ring is:
In equation (18), Kp is an elastic deformation constant of bearing point contact;
At this time, the contact angle αψ between the steel ball and the ring at any angular position can be obtained as follows:
According to balance conditions, if the radial load and the axial load acting on the bearing are Fr and Fa respectively, then:
Equations (20) and (21) are nonlinear equation systems of unknown numbers
Step 3, a life and damage of the high-speed bearing are analyzed. As for a calculation method of the bearing life, the present invention adopts an ISO standard improved based on a Lundberg-Palmgren bearing life theory, which needs to calculate an equivalent dynamic load and a rated static load of the bearing. According to the rated life theory of bearings, the rated life L10 of the ball bearing is:
L
10=(Li−ε+Le−ε)−1/ε (22),
In equation (22), ε is ta life index; Li is the rated life of the inner rolling path; and Le is the rated life of the outer rolling path;
The rated life of the inner rolling path is:
The rated life of the outer rolling path is:
In equations (23) and (24), Qcuj and Qcvj are the rated dynamic loads of the rings; and Qμj Qvj refer to the equivalent dynamic loads of the rings;
A rated dynamic load calculation equation is:
In equation (25), m represents the rated dynamic loads of the inner and outer rings of the bearing respectively; f is a curvature radius coefficient of the rolling path groove; γ is a bearing structural parameter; γ=Db cos α/Dm, where α is a contact angle; and Z is the number of rollers;
The equivalent dynamic load Qμi of the inner rolling path is:
The equivalent dynamic load Qvj of the non-rotating outer rolling path is:
In equations (26) and (27), j is the number of the bearing ball and Z is the total number of the balls;
As for a calculation method of bearing damage, the present invention adopts a Palmgren-Miner linear cumulative damage rule, and the life of the rolling path is L1 under a working condition of an equivalent dynamic load P1. If the bearing runs for N1 turns under the working condition, the equivalent damage of the bearing under the working condition P1 is: D1=N1/L1. If the bearing experiences a random road load and, under the equivalent loads P1,P2, . . . , Pn, runs for N1,N2, . . . ,Nn turns in sequence, the damage D caused by the random road load to the bearing is:
In equation (28), n is a set of working conditions of the bearing, and for each corresponding working condition i, the corresponding fatigue life of the bearing is Li turns. However, under the working condition, the bearing only runs for Ni turns, wherein Ni<Li
In the present embodiment, the model of the bearing near the motor side is 6208/C3, and the cumulative distribution result of the damage contribution of the 6208 bearing is obtained by calculating the damage contribution of the bearing under different rotation speeds and torque levels. As shown in
Statistics are conducted on the cumulative damage intensity of the 6208 bearing under the different rotation speeds and torque levels respectively. As shown in
In the present embodiment, the model of the bearing away from the motor side is 6308/C3, and the cumulative distribution result of the damage contribution of the 6308 bearing is obtained by calculating the damage contribution of the bearing under different rotation speeds and torque levels. As shown in
Step 4: a reliability test load level and a time proportion relation of each typical load level are determined: The reliability test load level is determined according to the principle of covering different distribution characteristics of bearing damage contribution.
The selection of the reliability test load level should include typical working conditions in the 300,000 km load data, and meanwhile, damage contribution should be high. The reliability test load spectrum also includes extreme load working conditions.
During the determination of the time proportion relation of each typical load level, for a working condition with a given target rotation speed and a given torque, firstly, a load frequency near a target load working condition is transferred to a given target load based on the principle of a consistent overall action frequency, so as to obtain a time proportion of all typical load levels, and then, the time of each load working condition is dynamically adjusted according to the principle of consistent damage so as to meet a total bearing damage target in the load data of 300,000 km.
According to the cumulative distribution characteristics of 6208 bearing damage contribution, the damage contribution is higher when the torque is −107 Nm and −86 Nm. Therefore, the damage contribution under different rotation speeds when the torque is −107 Nm and −86 Nm respectively is counted separately, and ladder diagrams of the damage contribution are drawn, as shown in
According to the cumulative distribution characteristics of 6308 bearing damage contribution, the bearing damage contribution is higher when the torque is positive and the rotation speed is between 1000 rpm and 5000 rpm. Based on the characteristics of 6308 bearing damage distribution, according to the damage contribution distribution under different torques and the same rotation speed, the torque load level with higher damage contribution can be selected under the given rotation speed.
As shown in
As shown in
Step 5: a damage target of the bearing in the whole life cycle is determined:
In the process of compiling the bearing reliability test load spectrum, in order to determine the total running time of the reliability test load spectrum, it is necessary to make clear the damage target of the bearing in the 300,000 km load data, so as to determine the number of cycles of test working conditions.
As shown in Table 1, damage values and total damage targets of the bearing under a single cycle of 300,000 km load data in the whole life cycle are counted.
Step 6: a reliability test load spectrum is compiled:
The reliability test load spectrum of the bearing should cover a variable amplitude loading history of the bearing under various working conditions in an actual operation process. When the lower rotation speed rises, the torque rises at the same time, and the working conditions of middle rotation speeds and high torques are assessed; when the higher speed rises, the torque drops, and the working conditions of high rotation speeds and low torques are assessed; and meanwhile, when the torque rises, the rotation speed drops and service conditions such as the working conditions of low rotation speeds and high torques are assessed. In addition, the 300,000 km load data includes the highest torque of 369 Nm and the motor limit speed of 16000 rpm. These extreme working conditions should be considered in the process of compiling the reliability test load spectrum.
As for the time of acceleration or deceleration stage in the transfer process between the typical working conditions, slopes of a load rising stage and a falling stage are extracted from an original load history. Based on a slope distribution model, the time of rising or falling among various reliability test load levels can be effectively selected. As shown in Table 2, there are 21 load working conditions grades and bearing endurance working conditions grades after matching the time of each grade. Among them, 10 s and 20 s are taken as transition loading time between each load change. 1100h is taken as the total target time of the reliability test load spectrum, and finally a single cycle duration of 7800 s and 507 cycles are compiled. The time history of the working condition of a single reliability test cycle is shown in
According to the acting effect of the load spectrum with the whole life cycle of 300,000 km, the 6208 bearing is prone to failure at first. In the process of compiling the reliability test load spectrum, the damage target of the 6208 bearing should be mainly met first. The damage of the finally compiled 1100h reliability test load spectrum is compared with that of the load spectrum with the whole life cycle of 300,000 km. As shown in
The above-mentioned embodiments only describe the preferred modes of the present invention, and do not limit the scope of the present invention.
Without departing from the design spirit of the present invention, all kinds of variations and improvements made by those of ordinary skill in the art to the technical solution of the present invention should fall within the protection scope determined by the claims of the present invention.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
202010786198.6 | Aug 2020 | CN | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/CN2021/110328 | 8/3/2021 | WO |