The present disclosure is concerned with improving and maintaining the health of patients suffering from dysphagia by providing especially adapted nutrition. In particular, the disclosure relates to the formulation and processing of new food thickeners with improved viscosity adaption over extended periods of time.
Dysphagia is a common health problem, the term describing a range of mechanical disorders that affect the safety, efficiency, or quality of eating and drinking. In dysphagia, every swallowing attempt bears the danger of choking and aspiration of liquids or food particles into the lung. Hence, dysphagia patients have an increased risk of developing aspiration pneumonia, which may even lead to death. Furthermore, dehydration, malnutrition, and often a reduced quality of life are direct consequences of dysphagia.
For example, dysphagia patients are often afraid to consume foods that appear too thin to them because they fear to choke. This fear is particularly pronounced with respect to liquids and often leads to reluctance to eat or drink and may therefore lead to dehydration and malnutrition.
In particular in elderly patients, senses like smell and taste are often already decreased. In such a situation, even slight dysphagia may lead to complete food refusal followed by consequences such as weight loss, dehydration and further reduction in general health.
In the transport of a food or liquid bolus during swallowing, the saliva plays an important role in lubricating the mouth and aids the formation of a cohesive bolus. This swallowing process is significantly affected by material flow properties, i.e. viscosity. Accordingly, when patients experience difficulties in swallowing, it is crucial to comply with clinically required levels of viscosity of liquid/semisolid products for use in nutrition for such patients. This is typically achieved by addition of food thickeners.
Currently available commercial food thickener products are often starch-based. These starch-based thickeners are safe, easy to use and thus widely applied to reach adequate viscosity levels in food preparations, such as drinks, for treatment of individuals suffering from dysphagia.
However, during consumption, individuals suffering from dysphagia often spill saliva into their food and, additionally, may take very long time to consume their foods/drinks. Also, during bolus formation, the food is mixed with saliva. One drawback of starch thickened patient nutrition is that contact with saliva may lead to a fast decrease of the viscosity of the thickened nutrition.
Thus, there is a general need for products suitable to maintain a required level of viscosity over prolonged periods of time and up to and during the actual swallowing process, e.g. over the entire duration of a meal. Moreover, it is desirable, to provide thickener products that are suitable for preparing hot and cold foods and drinks. It is also desirable that thickener products are suitable to be used for a wide variety of food types, such as vegetarian and meat containing products. Additional needs in the art which are addressed by the invention will become apparent hereinafter.
In a first aspect, the present disclosure relates to a food thickener composition for adding to a nutritional product comprising
In a second aspect, the present disclosure relates to a food thickener composition for adding to a nutritional product comprising
In particular, the present disclosure relates to a food thickener composition for use in the nourishment of dysphagia patients, in the treatment of dysphagia as well as in the treatment or prophylaxis of malnutrition or dehydration in dysphagia patients.
In a third aspect, the present disclosure relates to the use of a polyphenol as a viscosity stabilizer for food thickener compositions.
In a fourth aspect, the present disclosure relates to a nutritional composition comprising such a food thickener composition.
In a fifth aspect, the present disclosure relates to a method for thickening patient food comprising the following steps:
“Dysphagia” as used herein refers to diagnosed abnormalities, such as difficulties, in the swallowing process.
“Starch” is a polysaccharide carbohydrate found in various natural sources, such as corn, maize, wheat, rice, potato and tapioca. Starch is comprised of two polysaccharides, amylose and amylopectin. Amylose is comprised of long unbranched chains of D-glucose units bound in alpha (1,4) linkages. Amylopectin is a highly branched structure, also made up of D-glucose units.
“Modified starch” as used herein refers to starch obtained from natural sources after having been subjected to a modification process. The modification process can be a chemical process (such as partial acid hydrolysis, partial enzymatic hydrolysis, alkali treatment, oxidation/bleaching or derivatization processes (such as etherification, esterification, cross-linking, dual modification)) or a physical process (such as heat/moisture treatment, pregelatinization).
Food grade starches are subjected to a modification process mainly to increase paste consistency, smoothness and clarity, and to impart freeze-thaw and cold storage stabilities. In addition to this, modified starches have good stability against acid, thermal and mechanical degradation. In the context of this invention, modified starches are food grade natural starches that are modified in either of the above modification processes and can be obtained in numerous suppliers. Preferred starch thickeners are chemically modified starches, such as chemically modified maize or tapioca starch.
“Ready-to-use” refers to the final form of nutrition, e.g. foods, drinks or nutritional compositions, as served to a patient or any other subject in need thereof. The term may be used in connection with patient food, nutritional compositions and patient nutrition.
“Nutritional composition” herein refers to a synthetically produced food composition. Nutritional compositions as used herein typically are provided in the form of powder, drinks, gels, energy bars and the like. Thus, nutritional compositions are artificial nutritional products obtained by mixing/dissolving ingredients whereby said ingredients are typically provided in solid form (e.g. powders) or liquid from. The term “nutritional compositions” excludes “patient food”, i.e. non-modified natural food products, such as meat, vegetables, fruits in their natural form and conventionally prepared (e.g. cooked) meals or drinks like tea, coffee or juices. “Patient nutrition” as used herein refers to nutrition intended for individuals suffering from a medical condition. Patient nutrition may be provided in the form of conventionally prepared meals (patient food) or in form of nutritional compositions as defined above. Herein, patient nutrition is intended for individuals having difficulties swallowing, in particular dysphagia. “Polyphenol” refers to a structural class including natural, synthetic or semi-synthetic, organic chemicals characterized by the presence of multiple phenol structural units being covalently bound to each other, either directly or via other chemical subgroups. As used herein “semi-synthetic” refers to compounds obtained by chemical synthesis using starting materials isolated from natural sources, such as plant material or bacterial or cell cultures. Typically, polyphenols comprise >12 phenolic hydroxyl groups. Preferably, polyphenols have a molecular weight of 500-4000 Da and/or comprise 5-7 aromatic rings per 1000 Da. The polyphenols used herein are typically provided in form of plant derived polyphenols, such as plant extracts. Such plant extracts may for example be obtainable by solvent extraction using ethanol, methanol or their mixtures with water.
“Viscosity stabilizer” as used herein refers to compounds having the ability of reducing or preventing an unintended change in viscosity of thickened nutritional products for a certain period of time. For example, a viscosity stabilizer may dampen the decrease in viscosity of thickened nutritional products. Suitable viscosity stabilizers are polyphenols and may be selected from tannic acid, green tea extract, grape seed extract, red wine extract, and black tea extract, flavonols, quercetins (such as quercetin, rutin), flavones (such as luteolin, scutellarein, eupafolin), flavanones, proanthocyanidins (such as catechin, catechin hydrate, catechin gallato, epicatechin gallato, epicatechin gallate, theaflavin) and tannins (such as strictinin). Preferred viscosity stabilizers herein are phenolic plant extracts. Particularly preferred are tannic acid, green tea extract, grape seed extract, red wine extract, and black tea extract and mixtures thereof.
“Tannins” as used herein refers to a water-soluble group of polyphenols. Typically, tannins are obtained from plants. Tannins are often characterized by their ability to precipitate proteins. Herein, it will be distinguished between hydrolysable and non-hydrolysable (condensed) tannins. “Tannic acid” as used herein refers to a species of the group of tannins (genus). For example, tannic acid refers to the hydrolysis products of hydrolysable tannins. Exemplary hydrolysable tannins are glucose tannins in which one or more of the hydroxyl groups of glucose are esterified with gallic acid and/or meta-digallic acid. Commercial tannic acid may for example be extracted from any of the following: Tara pods (Caesalpinia spinosa), gallnuts from Rhus semialata or Quercus infectoria or Sicilian Sumac leaves (Rhus coriaria).
“Thickener composition” as used herein refers to a food grade composition suitable to thicken various nutritional products.
“Starch” as used herein refers to a food grade starch or modified starch which is used in nutritional products.
“Starch-based thickener” refers to a thickener composition comprising at least 50 wt %, at least 70 wt % or at least 90 wt % of starch. A starch-based thickener may for example also comprise up to 45 wt % of cellulose.
“Cellulose” refers to food grade cellulose or modified cellulose which is used in nutritional products.
“Cellulose-based thickener” refers to a thickener composition comprising at least 50 wt %, at least 70 wt % or at least 90 wt % of cellulose. A cellulose-based thickener may for example also comprise up to 45 wt % of a starch.
“Gum” as used herein refers to a food grade gum which is used to thicken nutritional products, e.g. to Xanthan or Gellan gum or to a vegetable gum such as gum Arabic, guar gum or agar.
“Food grade” as used herein refers to components that are fit for human consumption not injurious to health (e.g. safe food according to Article 14 of the regulation (EC) No 178/2002 on general food law).
“Additives” are typically present in an amount of less than 15 wt % based on the total weight of the thickener composition.
A composition “consisting of” a number of ingredients or components is to be understood as comprising no other than the named ingredients or components. In case ranges for amounts of ingredients or components are given, the individual amount of all ingredients or components within the composition has of course also to be adapted such that the sum of all amounts of all present ingredients or components adds up to 100 wt %.
Swallowing is a complex mechanism using both skeletal muscle (tongue) and smooth muscles of the pharynx and esophagus. In particular, swallowing comprises three phases:
Each phase is controlled by different (neurological) mechanisms. The autonomic nervous system coordinates this process in the pharyngeal and the esophageal phases.
The oral phase is voluntary and mainly controlled by the medial temporal lobes and limbic system of the cerebral cortex with contributions from the motor cortex and other cortical areas. The oral phase comprises the formation of the bolus. Herein, bolus refers to food being ready to enter the pharyngeal phase. During bolus formation, food is contacted with saliva from the salivary glands and chewed (i.e. broken down by the teeth). This part of the swallowing process, in particular the bolus formation, is significantly affected by material flow properties, such as viscosity. When ready for swallowing, the bolus moves towards the back of the tongue.
Once the bolus reaches the palatoglossal arch of the oropharynx, the pharyngeal phase, a reflex often also referred to as gag reflex begins. The reflex is initiated by touch receptors in the pharynx as a bolus of food is pushed to the back of the mouth by the tongue and subsequently is coordinated by the swallowing center in the medulla oblongata and pons. For the pharyngeal phase to work properly all other egress from the pharynx must be occluded—this includes the nasopharynx and the larynx. When the pharyngeal phase begins, other activities such as chewing, breathing, coughing and vomiting are concomitantly inhibited.
At the end of the pharyngeal phase the bolus moves down towards the esophagus by pharyngeal peristalsis which takes place by sequential contraction of the superior, middle and inferior pharyngeal constrictor muscles. The velocity through the pharynx depends on a number of factors such as viscosity and volume of the bolus.
Like the pharyngeal phase of swallowing, the esophageal phase of swallowing is under involuntary neuromuscular control. However, propagation of the food bolus is slower than in the pharynx. The bolus enters the esophagus and is propelled downwards first by striated muscle (recurrent laryngeal) then by the smooth muscle. The upper esophageal sphincter relaxes to let food pass, after which various striated constrictor muscles of the pharynx as well as peristalsis and relaxation of the lower esophageal sphincter sequentially push the bolus of food through the esophagus into the stomach.
Abnormalities in swallowing in any of the above described phases will be referred to as dysphagia. Dysphagia is typically developed as a consequence of weakness or complete lack of coordination in the mouth and throat muscles. More specifically, abnormalities of the pharynx and/or oral cavity may lead to oropharyngeal dysphagia, whereas abnormalities of the esophagus may lead to esophageal dysphagia.
Typical causes of dysphagia are stroke, motor neuronal diseases, Parkinson's disease, cerebral palsy, head injuries, multiple sclerosis, surgery to the head and neck or myasthenia gravis. For example, swallowing becomes a great concern for the elderly since strokes and Alzheimer's disease can interfere with the autonomic nervous system.
Generally, patients suffering from dysphagia are at an increased risk of impaired nutritional status, aspiration pneumonia, dehydration and a generally reduced quality of life.
More specifically, in dysphagic patients, every swallowing attempt bears the danger of choking and aspiration of liquid or food particles into the lung. Hence, dysphagia patients have an increased risk of developing aspiration pneumonia, which may even lead to death. Furthermore, dehydration, malnutrition, and often a reduced quality of life are direct consequences of dysphagia.
Particularly in elderly patients, senses like smell and taste are often already decreased. In such a situation, even slight dysphagia may lead to complete food refusal followed by consequences such as weight loss, dehydration and further reduction in general health. It has however to be understood that abnormalities in swallowing are not necessarily limited to elderly patients.
Management of dysphagia as used herein refers to a part of the treatment of dysphagia which does not directly relate to treating the cause of dysphagia, but ameliorating and/or controlling its symptoms. Management of dysphagia commonly comprises the prescription of texture-controlled diets; such diets include, for example, pureed foods and drinks of higher viscosity. The rationale behind altering or modifying the consistency of foods and/or drinks is to change the rate at which food is transported through the pharynx and, thus, to reduce the risk of aspiration. Ideally, the most appropriate modification of food consistencies should follow from a clear assessment of the swallowing problem. However, this is not possible in all cases and quite often health care professionals rely on national guidelines for the dietary management of dysphagia patients. To give some examples, the national guidelines given by the British Dietetic Association provides a subjective explanation of three different consistencies, “Nectar”, “Honey” and “Pudding”, according to which foods/drinks should be texturally modified in dysphagia management.
The American Dietetic Association, on the other hand, defines ranges of viscosity for different consistencies at a single shear rate of 50 s1 and 25° C. The proposed rage of viscosities are: (1) Thin: 1-50 centipoise; (2) Nectar-like: 51-350 centipoise; (3) Honey-like: 351-1750 centipoise; (4) Spoon-thick (pudding): greater than 1750 centipoise.
In any case, pureed foods are often of unappetizing and non-adjustable consistency, hence there is a general need of controlling the viscosity of such foods.
When a person eats and drinks, saliva is mixed into the bolus in the mouth. The presence of or contact with saliva typically leads to a decrease in the viscosity of food and drinks. In particular, in nutrition comprising starch-based thickeners, a decrease in viscosity over time after contact with saliva is often observed. This can for example result in the following problems:
Consequently, the present invention relates inter alia to the development of novel compositions, such as powdered and/or instant compositions for use in preparing nutrition for dysphagia patients.
It is desirable that such compositions are suitable for cold and hot nutritional compositions, drinks and foods. Furthermore, it may be desirable that nutritional products after having been thickened with compositions according to the present disclosure may be stored for a while before being served to a patient suffering from dysphagia. Accordingly, it may be desirable that the thickened nutrition is freeze-stable and may be re-heated. Moreover, it may be desirable to provide food thickener compositions that are suitable for vegetarian, vegan and omnivore nutritional products. In particular, it may be desirable to provide thickener compositions which are adapted for use with compositions comprising animal protein or vegetable protein or mixtures thereof.
The polyphenol viscosity stabilizer, the thickener composition and the nutritional compositions herein are suitable for use in treatment including management of dysphagia with respect to swallowing problems associated with any of the oral phase, pharyngeal phase and/or esophageal phase. The polyphenol viscosity stabilizer, the thickener composition and the nutritional compositions herein are particularly suitable for use in treatment of dysphagia with respect to swallowing problems associated with any of the oral phase and/or pharyngeal phase.
The nutrition or thickener composition of the present disclosure may comprise starch or modified starch. For example, the starch may be food grade starch that can be commercially obtained from numerous suppliers. Besides starch from potatoes, suitable starches may be arrowroot, maize-, corn, rice, sago, katakuri, wheat and tapioca starch. For example a suitable starch is maize starch. Preferably, the starch is selected from the group consisting of modified starches.
Suitable modified starches are oxidised starch, mono-starch phosphate, di-starch phosphate, phosphorylated di-starch phosphate, acetylated di-starch phosphate, acetylated starch, acetylated di-starch adipate, hydroxypropylstarch, hydroxypropyl di-starch phosphate, starch sodium octenyl succinate, acetylated oxidised starch.
In a preferred embodiment, the starch is chemically-modified maize or tapioca starch.
The thickener composition of the present disclosure may comprise gum. For example the gum may be a food grade gum such as gum Arabic, agar, guar gum Gellan or Xanthan gum. Xanthan gum is especially preferred.
The cellulose herein may be non-modified cellulose, but preferably is chemically-modified cellulose. Preferred chemically-modified celluloses herein are alkylated celluloses (celluloseethers) including methyl cellulose, ethyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl cellulose, hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC), methylethylcellulose, carboxymethylcellulose. [0061] HPMC is considered very suitable as it passes essentially unchanged through the gastrointestinal tract following oral administration. HPMC exerts functional changes in food products without undergoing or initiating chemical changes that would alter the nutritional value of the food products.
Suitable polyphenol viscosity stabilizers are polyphenols and may be selected from tannic acid, green tea extract, grape seed extract, red wine extract, and black tea extract, flavonols, quercetins (such as quercetin, rutin), flavones (such as luteolin, scutellarein, eupafolin), flavanones, proanthocyanidins (such as catechin, catechin hydrate, catechin gallato, epicatechin gallato, epicatechin gallate, theaflavin) and tannins (such as strictinin). Preferred viscosity stabilizers herein are phenolic plant extracts. Particularly preferred are tannic acid, green tea extract, grape seed extract, red wine extract, and black tea extract and mixtures thereof.
The weight ratio of polyphenol viscosity stabilizer to starch within the thickener composition may be at least 0.001:1 or 0.002:1, preferably at least 0.010:1 or at least 0.015:1, more preferably at least 0.020:1 or at least 0.030:1, for example at least 0.100:1. Advantageously, the weight ratio of polyphenol viscosity stabilizer to starch within the thickener composition does not exceed 0.200:1.
The thickener composition herein may comprise a polyphenol viscosity stabilizer, a starch and/or a cellulose.
In a first exemplary embodiment, the thickener composition may be starch based, free of cellulose and, in a first example, comprise or consist of
In a second example of the first embodiment, the thickener composition may be starch based, free of cellulose and comprise or consist of
In a second exemplary embodiment, the thickener composition may be cellulose based and, in a first example, comprise or consist of
In a second example of the second embodiment, the thickener composition may be cellulose based and, in a first example, comprise or consist of
In a third exemplary embodiment, the thickener composition may be starch based and, in a first example comprise or consist of
In a second example of the third embodiment, the thickener composition may be starched based and comprise or consist of
In a fourth embodiment, the thickener composition may be starch based and comprise a polyphenol viscosity stabilizer, a starch, a cellulose, a gum and optionally one or more additives.
In a first example of the fourth embodiment the thickener composition may comprise or consist of
In a second example of the fourth embodiment the thickener composition may comprise or consist of
It has been found that the thickener composition when comprising a cellulose, is particularly suitable for warm patient food or warm nutritional compositions, e.g. having a temperature of more than 40° C. Nevertheless, the patient food/nutritional compositions may be left to cool after thickening.
Moreover, it has been found that the thickener composition when comprising a cellulose is particularly suitable to prepare patient food or nutritional compositions comprising animal protein.
A nutritional composition may comprise protein, fat and carbohydrates in a predetermined and controllable amount. Optionally, such a nutritional composition may comprise further components such as dietary fibre and/or further ingredients known as food additives.
Typically, proteins are included in the nutritional compositions as amino acid source. The proteins included may be from different sources such as vegetable or animal sources. Suitable proteins can be selected from the list consisting of milk protein, such as casein or whey protein, soy protein, pea proteins and hydrolisates thereof. Amino acids may as well be added in their chemical form or in the form of peptides.
Fat from different sources, such as animal and vegetable fat, may be included in the nutritional composition. The fat may include fatty acids, such as polyunsaturated fatty acids, monounsaturated fatty acids and polyunsaturated fatty acids. Suitable fatty acids may be selected form the group consisting of caproic acid (C6:0), caprylic acid (C8:0), capric acid (C10:0), lauric acid (C12:0), myristic acid (C14:0), palmitic acid (C16:0), palmitoleic acid (C16:1w7), stearic acid C18:0, oleic acid (C18:1w9), linoleic acid (C18:2w6), a-Linolenic acid (C18:3w3), eicosapentaenoic acid (C20:5w3), docosahexaenoic acid C22:6w3 and mixtures thereof. In addition to said fatty acids, C6-C12 medium chain triglycerides may be added. Typical carbohydrate sources may be selected from the list consisting of maltodextrine, glucose syrup, sucrose, starch, isomaltolose, fructose and mixtures thereof.
In addition, the nutritional composition herein may comprise ingredients specifically as dietary fibres. Suitable dietary fibres may be selected from the group consisting of cocoa powder, inulin, wheat dextrine, cellulose, microcrystalline cellulose, soy polysaccharides, tapioca dextrine, xanthan, fructooligosaccharides, galactooligosaccharides, at least partially hydrolized guar gum, acacia gum, pectin, oat fibre, poly dextrose, resistant starch, hemicellulose and mixtures thereof. A nutritional composition according to the present disclosure may for example comprise water, sucrose, milk protein, vegetable oils, emulsifier (such as soya lecithin), maltodextrin, inulin (for example obtained from chicory), vitamins, mineral and trace elements in predefined amounts. In addition, thickeners and optional ingredients as specified below may be added.
The nutritional compositions will typically be provided in an oil-in-water emulsion (0/W). Such an emulsion may be adapted to have an energy content of 0.5-5 kcal/mL, preferably between 1 and 3 kcal/mL, most preferred between 1.5 and 2 kcal.
Nutritional compositions optionally comprise food additives. Food additives may for example be selected from the group consisting of choline, beta-carotene, lutein, lucopene, caffeine, lecithin, taurine, carnitine, myo-inositol, stabilisers, emulsifiers, colorants, aroma and mixtures thereof. Aromas may be caramel, vanilla, yoghurt, chocolate, coffee, cappuccino or fruit aromas.
A typical nutritional composition herein comprises the thickener composition described herein and the following nutrient profile:
Moreover, the nutritional composition typically comprises water and optionally further food additives.
The present disclosure also relates to a method for thickening patient food comprising the following steps:
a. providing the patient food in liquid or fluid form, e.g. by pureeing;
b. adding the thickener composition described herein;
c. mixing the thickener composition with the patient food.
The thickener composition as described herein may be used to prepare a soaking solution to be served with or used on cake, biscuits, bread or the like. A typical soaking solution will comprise 50-150 mL liquid, such as water, fruit juice or coffee and about 520 g of thickener composition. The soaking solution should be mixed thoroughly, e.g. by whisking, before use. Cake, biscuits, bread or the like may be soaked in the soaking solution and may be put in the refrigerator for about 2 hours before serving.
1. A food thickener composition for adding to a nutritional product comprising or consisting of
Thickened solutions for this study were prepared in three different stages (Nectar, Honey, and Pudding according to the definition of the National Dysphagia Diet (NOD), published in 2002 by the American Dietetic Association) in 100 mL of tap water. The thickened solutions were mixed using a whisk until smooth consistency solutions were obtained. After preparation, the solutions were left to stand for 15 minutes to recover the correct viscosity.
As shown in
To study the inhibition effect of the polyphenol viscosity stabilizer, the same thickener as used in example 1 was reformulated with different concentrations of tannic acid as viscosity stabilizer. The concentration of the viscosity stabilizer was calculated in weight percent based on the total weight of the solution. As shown in
To study and compare the viscosity stabilizing capacity of different viscosity stabilizers, viscosity measurements were carried out on samples with a specific concentration of several viscosity stabilizers. The concentration was 0.2 wt % with respect to the total weight of the thickened solution.
This experiment was carried out to verify if the effect of artificial saliva is similar to that of real saliva. As shown in
Generally, it is believed that the use of polyphenol viscosity stabilizers e.g. in the newly formulated thickener powders helps to improve and maintain the safety and health of dysphagia patients by stabilizing the viscosity of starch thickened patient nutritional product and thereby helping to avoid and/or reduce risks associated with swallowing a non-suitable food consistency.
The National Dysphagia Diet (NOD), published in 2002 by the American Dietetic Association, aims to establish standard terminology and practice applications of dietary texture modification in dysphagia management. The proposed terms for liquids and correlating viscosity ranges, at 25° C. and a single shear rate of 50 s−1, are: (1) Thin: 1-50 cP; (2) Nectar-like: 51-350 cP; (3) Honey-like: 351-1750 cP; (4) Pudding-like: >1750 cP. The viscosity measurements were carried out using a HAAKE MARS Advanced Modular Rheometer (Germany) fitted with helical ribbon mixer geometry and a small cylindrical cup. The (thickened) solution was loaded to the rheometer and measurement was started 10 minutes after loading. The saliva solution was added once the torque became constant with respect to time. All measurements were carried out at constant temperature of 20° C.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
13161643.5 | Mar 2013 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2014/056131 | 3/27/2014 | WO | 00 |