(Not Applicable)
(Not Applicable)
(Not Applicable)
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates generally to the field of Stirling machines connected to a reciprocatable body that is a component of an associated apparatus, the associated apparatus being a load such as a linear alternator driven by a Stirling engine or a prime mover such as a linear motor that drives a Stirling heat pump (cooler), and more particularly relates to an improved link between the piston of the Stirling machine and the reciprocatable component body, for allowing improved optimization of both the Stirling machine and the associated apparatus.
2. Description of the Related Art
Stirling machines have been known for nearly two centuries but in recent decades have been the subject of considerable development because they offer important advantages. Modern versions have been used as engines and heat pumps for many years in a variety of applications. In a Stirling machine, a working gas is confined in a working space comprised of an expansion space and a compression space. The working gas is alternately expanded and compressed in order to either do work or to pump heat. Each Stirling machine has a pair of pistons, one referred to as a displacer and the other referred to as a power piston and often just as a piston. Some Stirling machines have multiple sets of these pistons. The reciprocating displacer cyclically shuttles a working gas between the compression space and the expansion space which are connected in fluid communication through a heat accepter, a regenerator and a heat rejecter. The shuttling cyclically changes the relative proportion of working gas in each space. Gas that is in the expansion space, and/or gas that is flowing into the expansion space through a heat exchanger (the accepter) between the regenerator and the expansion space, accepts heat from surrounding surfaces. Gas that is in the compression space, and/or gas that is flowing into the compression space through a heat exchanger (the rejecter) between the regenerator and the compression space, rejects heat to surrounding surfaces. The gas pressure is essentially the same in both spaces at any instant of time because the spaces are interconnected through a path having a relatively low flow resistance. However, the pressure of the working gas in the work space as a whole varies cyclically and periodically. When most of the working gas is in the compression space, heat is rejected from the gas. When most of the working gas is in the expansion space, the gas accepts heat. This is true whether the Stirling machine is working as a heat pump or as an engine, as discussed below. The only requirement to differentiate between work produced or heat pumped, is the temperature at which the expansion process is carried out. If this expansion process temperature is higher than the temperature of the compression space, then the machine is inclined to produce work so it can function as an engine and if this expansion process temperature is lower than the compression space temperature, then the machine will pump heat from a cold source to a warm heat sink.
Stirling machines can therefore be designed to use the above principles to provide either: (1) an engine having a piston and displacer driven by applying an external source of heat energy to the expansion space and transferring heat away from the compression space and therefore operating as a prime mover driving a mechanical load, or (2) a heat pump having the power piston cyclically driven by a prime mover for pumping heat from the expansion space to the compression space and therefore capable of pumping heat energy from a cooler mass to a warmer mass. The heat pump mode permits Stirling machines to be used for cooling an object in thermal connection to its expansion space, including to cryogenic temperatures, or heating an object, such as a home heating heat exchanger, in thermal connection to its compression space. Therefore, the term Stirling “machine” is used to generically include both Stirling engines and Stirling heat pumps.
Until about 1965, Stirling machines were constructed as kinematically driven machines meaning that the piston and displacer are connected to each other by a mechanical linkage, typically connecting rods and crankshafts. The free piston Stirling machine was then invented by William Beale. In the free piston Stirling machine, the pistons are not connected to a mechanical drive linkage. A free-piston Stirling machine is a thermo-mechanical oscillator that is an energy transducer converting energy between thermal and mechanical forms of energy. One of its pistons, the displacer, is driven by working gas pressure variations and pressure differences in spaces or chambers in the machine. The other piston, the power piston, is either driven by a reciprocating prime mover when the Stirling machine is operated in its heat pumping mode or drives a reciprocating mechanical load when the Stirling machine is operated as an engine. Free piston Stirling machines offer numerous advantages including the ability to control their frequency, phase and amplitude, the ability to be hermetically sealed from their surroundings and their lack of a requirement for a mechanical fluid seal between moving parts to prevent the mixing of the working gas and lubricating oil.
Free-piston Stirling machines designed and operated in either the engine mode or the heat pumping mode are capable of being, and have been, connected to a diverse variety of associated apparatuses. Free-piston Stirling engines provide output power in the form of mechanical reciprocation and therefore can be linked as a prime mover to drive mechanical loads as the associated apparatus. These loads include linear electric alternators, compressors, fluid pumps and even Stirling heat pumps. Similarly, free-piston Stirling machines operated in a heat pump mode can be driven as a load by other prime movers as the associated apparatus, including linear motors and Stirling engines.
Stirling machines are often connected to a linear motor or linear alternator. Both an electric linear motor and an electric linear alternator are the same basic device. At times they are referred to collectively as motor/alternator or similar term since both have many identical characteristics. They have a stator, ordinarily having an armature winding, and a reciprocating component body that ordinarily includes magnets, usually permanent magnets, that can reciprocate within the armature winding. The power piston of the Stirling engine is connected to the reciprocating component body of the linear alternator to reciprocate the magnets within the armature winding and thereby generate electric power. Similarly, when a Stirling machine is operated in a heat pumping mode and driven by a linear electric motor, the reciprocating component body of the linear electric motor is connected to the power piston of the Stirling heat pump. Whether the Stirling machine is operated as an engine or a heat pump, the power piston of the Stirling machine is, in the prior art, directly connected to the reciprocating component body of the linear motor or alternator by a rigid or fixed connection or link. Consequently, the piston of the Stirling machine and the reciprocating component body of the linear alternator or linear motor reciprocate as a unit at the same frequency and the same amplitude of oscillation. This direct connection is typically accomplished by mounting the magnets to a magnet carrier or framework that is mounted to the power piston, but sometimes they are connected by a connecting rod. Other combinations of a free-piston Stirling machine and an associated apparatus also have the power piston of the Stirling machine linked by a rigid connection to the reciprocating body of the associated apparatus so that they reciprocate as a unit.
Although the prior art discloses a large quantity of combinations of a free-piston Stirling machine and an associated apparatus,
The operating frequency of a combination like that shown in
Whenever a free-piston Stirling machine is connected to an associated apparatus that is either a load that it drives or a prime mover that drives it, the combination involves a connection and interaction of two dynamic systems. An engineer designing such a combination typically attempts to optimize one or more characteristics of the combination by finding an optimum operating point for the combined system. One characteristic that is important to optimization is the amplitude of oscillation. Unfortunately, because the dynamic systems are so different, it is not unusual for the optimum operating point for each system to be different from the optimum operating point for the other system. Since the optimum operating points of the two systems do not coincide, the traditional approach is to make the best available engineering compromises and tradeoffs between the two systems.
For example, the design of a high power electrical generating system, in which a free-piston Stirling engine drives a linear alternator, involves the interaction of the dynamics of the thermodynamic cycle of the engine and the dynamics of the electromagnetic alternator system. Optimum linear power densities occur at higher amplitudes of alternator oscillation. However, modifying the design of free-piston Stirling engine so that it provides a greater amplitude of oscillation that is closer to the optimum alternator operating amplitude, eventually leads to a free-piston Stirling engine that can not reciprocate the alternator effectively. In other words, the operating amplitude for optimum alternator operation does not coincide with the operating amplitude for optimum free-piston Stirling engine operation.
The necessity for engineering compromises and tradeoffs resulting from the lack of coincidence of the optimum operating amplitude of reciprocation for each of two interconnected but very different dynamic systems also applies to other combinations in which a free-piston Stirling machine is connected to an associated apparatus. The traditional direct, rigid connection of the piston of the free-piston Stirling machine to its load or prime mover limits the engineer to combined systems in which both have the same operating amplitude of reciprocation.
It is therefore a purpose and feature of the present invention to provide an improvement in a free-piston Stirling machine connected to an associated apparatus that is a load or prime mover, wherein the improvement permits the free-piston Stirling machine and the associated apparatus to operate at different amplitudes of oscillation and thereby allow better optimization of each.
The invention is an improved combination of a free-piston Stirling machine, including its reciprocatable power piston, drivingly linked to an associated apparatus having a reciprocatable component body that is part of a mechanical load that the Stirling machine drives or part of a prime mover that drives the Stirling machine. The improvement is at least one spring connected to and drivingly linking the piston to the component body while having no rigid connection linking the piston to the component body. The substitution of the spring drive linkage for the rigid drive linkage allows the power piston and the reciprocatable component body of the associated apparatus to reciprocate at different amplitudes of oscillation. Therefore, the Stirling machine and the associated apparatus can be optimized at different amplitudes of piston and component body oscillation thereby accommodating the difference in the amplitudes at which the two very different dynamic systems operate optimally.
In describing the preferred embodiment of the invention which is illustrated in the drawings, specific terminology will be resorted to for the sake of clarity. However, it is not intended that the invention be limited to the specific term so selected and it is to be understood that each specific term includes all technical equivalents which operate in a similar manner to accomplish a similar purpose.
The prior art illustrates many different kinds of springs. These include coil springs, planar springs and gas springs which may be used in embodiments of the invention. Springs have the common characteristic that, as they are displaced from their relaxed state by an applied force, they store energy and they apply a force that is a function of their displacement. Most commonly, the force applied by a spring is a linear function of the spring displacement. That relationship is conventionally expressed by a proportionality constant known as a spring constant k. Many springs, such as coil springs, not only apply an axial force to the bodies to which they are connected, but also apply a torque to those bodies as a result of rotation, around the axis of the spring as the spring is displaced, of one end of the helical spring relative to the other end. However, that torque can be canceled by using two identical springs with oppositely wound helical coils. Consequently, it is preferred that there be an even number of springs, such as springs 36 and 38, connected to and drivingly linking the piston 40 to the reciprocatable component body 42 for canceling any torque force exerted by the springs when an axial force is applied to them. Of course any number of springs could be used and designed so the sum of the torque of all of them is close to zero.
The Engineering
The purpose of the invention is to permit the design of a combination of a free-piston Stirling machine drivingly linked to an associated reciprocating apparatus in which the piston of the free-piston Stirling machine can oscillate in reciprocation at a different amplitude of oscillation than the amplitude of oscillation of the reciprocating component body of the associated apparatus. The purpose of providing a structure that allows these reciprocating masses to oscillate at different amplitudes is to permit the free-piston Stirling machine and the associated reciprocating apparatus to be operated at different amplitudes when they are better optimized at different amplitudes. In order for engineers to be able to design embodiments of the invention that allow the different amplitudes of oscillation, it is necessary that the engineers know the relationships between the physical parameters and operating variables of the embodiments. Although the derivation of these relationships is given at the end of this description, some practical results are first discussed.
The ratio of the amplitudes of oscillation of the piston of the Stirling engine and the component reciprocating body of the associated apparatus is:
wherein the variables are:
and wherein the structural parameters of the combination free-piston Stirling machine and the drivingly linked associated apparatus are:
ωn—the natural frequency of oscillation of the component reciprocating body which is
ks—the spring constant of the spring that drivingly links the piston of the free-piston Stirling machine to the component reciprocating body of the associated apparatus;
m2—the mass of the component reciprocating body of the associated apparatus;
cc—the critical damping constant cc=2√{square root over (ksm2)} of the component reciprocating body of the associated apparatus; and
cl—an equivalent damping constant for damping of the reciprocating component body.
The above parameters and variables are conventionally known except for the equivalent damping constant cl. The equivalent damping constant cl is a physical parameter that is a characteristic of an associated apparatus such as a linear motor or alternator. In the case of a linear motor/alternator, the equivalent damping constant cl represents damping of the motor/alternator by power consumption in the motor/alternator circuit. It allows the damping force on the motor/alternator reciprocating body, which results from that electrical power consumption, to be expressed as the product of a damping constant cl and the velocity {dot over (x)}2 of the motor/alternator reciprocating body. The equivalent damping constant cl is defined by:
wherein i is motor/alternator current, {dot over (x)}2 is the velocity of the reciprocating component body and α is the motor constant. The motor constant α is a parameter that represents a physical characteristic of a motor/alternator and is known to those skilled in the art to be defined by:
Similarly,
which is the differential rate of change of motor/alternator current with respect to the velocity {dot over (x)}2 of the reciprocating component body, is a physical parameter that is a characteristic of a motor/alternator. Motor/alternator current is proportional to the velocity of the reciprocating component body, such as the typical reciprocating magnets.
is the proportionality constant. Although di and d{dot over (x)}2 are each operating variables, their ratio is a slope of a graph of i vs. {dot over (x)}2. Therefore, α and
are both constant values that are physical characteristics of each particular motor/alternator that can be designed into it.
The above equation I is conveniently expressed in terms of dimensionless ratios, specifically the amplitude ratio
the frequency ratio
and the damping ratio
For operation at the resonance (natural) frequency ωn, equation I simplifies to
This equation defines the operating amplitude ratio for operation at resonance of an embodiment of the invention that has the structural parameters ks, m2 and cl related as described by equation V. In other words, this equation describes the structural/physical relationships that give the amplitude ratio
if operated at resonance. Of course a combination of a free-piston Stirling machine and an associated apparatus can be operated slightly off its resonant frequency ωn. In that case the amplitude ratio will decrease from the ratio given by equation V as illustrated in
The Mathematical Derivation
1. Model for Piston and Alternator
m
1
{umlaut over (x)}
1
+c
1
{dot over (x)}
1
+k
1
x
1
+c
2({dot over (x)}1−{dot over (x)}2)+ks(x1−x2)=F1=P(t)A eq. (1)
m
2
{umlaut over (x)}
2
+c
2({dot over (x)}2−{dot over (x)}1)+ks(x2−x1)=F2 eq. (2)
where m1 is the piston mass, m2 is the alternator moving component mass, P(t) is the pressure change in the compression space (B in
m
1
{umlaut over (x)}
1
+c
1
{dot over (x)}
1
+k
s
x
1
−k
s
x
2
=P(t)A eq. (3)
m
2
{umlaut over (x)}
2
+k
s
x
2
−k
s
x
1
=F
2 eq. (4)
The alternator/motor load, F2, is assumed to be a damper because the force exerted on the magnet is proportional to its velocity and closely approximates a free-piston Stirling engine/cooler load in practical examples. Thus the equation (4) will turn to,
m
2
{umlaut over (x)}
2
+c
l
{dot over (x)}
2
+k
s
x
2
−k
s
x
1=0 eq. (5)
Where cl is a linear alternator/motor damping coefficient. Consequently, the system has been simplified to the system of
Since the piston motion is defined in amplitude and frequency and oscillatory pressure change is given,
x1=X1ejwt eq. (6)
P={circumflex over (P)}ejwt eq. (7)
Where: {circumflex over (P)}=P0ejφ
An oscillatory solution to this differential equation is;
x2={circumflex over (X)}2ejwt eq. (8)
Where: {circumflex over (X)}2=X2ejφ
Substituting into eq. (3) and eq. (5) gives:
[(ks−ω2m1)+jωc1]X1−ks{circumflex over (X)}2={circumflex over (P)}A eq. (9)
[(ks−ω2m2)+jωc1]{circumflex over (X)}2−ksX1=0 eq. (10)
These can be solved for x1 and X2, which is in “Appendix” below. We are primarily interested in the amplitude ratio of the piston and alternator, so that the amplitude ratio is expressed using eq. (10). This gives:
The expressions eq. (12) can be transformed in terms of “dimensionless quantities” or ratios only. There appear the frequency ratio and the damping ratio:
Where:
Natural Frequency of the alternator moving component
cc=2√{square root over (ksm2)}: Critical Damping
At resonance point, the amplitude ratio becomes:
From
Therefore, with proper tuning, the amplitude of the alternator can be any desired relation to the amplitude of the piston. The higher alternator amplitude is a great benefit in the high power machine because the optimum linear alternator power densities appear to occur at impractically high amplitudes. Therefore in the case of no spring between the piston and the alternator so they are rigidly connected, a critical factor in obtaining high specific power is related to the interaction of the dynamics of the thermodynamic cycle and the optimization of the alternator. For example, increasing the piston amplitude is favorable to the alternator but, for a given power, leads to a smaller piston diameter. This, in turn, leads to a smaller springing effect. Following this process soon leads the design to a point where the magnet mass cannot be sprung by the engine. Typically, the optimum point for minimum mass of the linear alternator and the engine do not coincide in the conventional machine for high power applications. The invention, however, helps to get the desired alternator amplitude regardless of the dynamics of the free-piston Stirling machine.
2. Power Output
In the conventional linear alternator system, the moving component of a linear alternator is connected to the piston rigidly. This gives the following governing equations.
Then power at the piston and the alternator can be obtained from:
From the definition of orthogonality:
αi,{dot over (x)}=P(t)A,{dot over (x)}−c{dot over (x)},{dot over (x)} eq. (21)
Pout=α{dot over (x)},i−Ri,i eq. (22)
Substituting (21) into (22):
Pout=P(t)A,{dot over (x)}−c{dot over (x)},{dot over (x)}−Ri,i=∫pdv−c{dot over (x)},{dot over (x)}−Ri,i eq. (23)
Thus power output is obtained by subtracting mechanical and electrical losses from the pv work. In the system with a spring between the piston and the alternator, we have two equations of motion for a piston, expressed by p and a moving component of the alternator, expressed by s.
Then power can be obtained in the same way:
−ksxs,{dot over (x)}p=P(t)A,{dot over (x)}p−cp{dot over (x)}p,{dot over (x)}p eq. (27)
αi,{dot over (x)}p=ksxp,{dot over (x)}s eq. (28)
Pout=ksxp,{dot over (x)}s−Ri,i eq. (29)
As discussed in the section 1, there is a phase shift between the piston amplitude and the alternator amplitude. Thus we can see that:
x
s
,{dot over (x)}
p
=x
s
x
p cos(90+φ)=−xsxp sin φ
x
p
,{dot over (x)}
s
=x
s
x
p cos(90−φ)=xsxp sin φ eq. (30)
Therefore power output has the same form as (23), which means there is no additional loss in the new system with a spring installed between the piston and the moving component of alternator.
Pout=P(t)A,{dot over (x)}−cp{dot over (x)}p,{dot over (x)}p−Ri,i=∫pdv−cp{dot over (x)}p,{dot over (x)}p−Ri,i eq. (31)
3. Appendix: Exact Solutions of (3) and (4)
[(ks−ω2m1)+jωc1]X1−ks{circumflex over (X)}2={circumflex over (P)}A eq. (9)
[(ks−ω2m2)+jωcl]{circumflex over (X)}2−ksX1=0 eq. (10)
By expressing X2 in terms of x1,
From (32) and (33), we can get the same amplitude ratio form as (11). Assuming no damping in the system and the same resonance frequency in two moving components, this system has the same solution form as that of the undamped dynamic vibration absorber.
When:
The solution is:
This detailed description in connection with the drawings is intended principally as a description of the presently preferred embodiments of the invention, and is not intended to represent the only form in which the present invention may be constructed or utilized. The description sets forth the designs, functions, means, and methods of implementing the invention in connection with the illustrated embodiments. It is to be understood, however, that the same or equivalent functions and features may be accomplished by different embodiments that are also intended to be encompassed within the spirit and scope of the invention and that various modifications may be adopted without departing from the invention or scope of the following claims.