The present invention relates to a continuous flow system and method. In particular, the present invention relates to a continuous flow system and method for simulating an oral environment.
An understanding of biotic and abiotic contributions to oral health and disease has been limited by the complexity of oral environments, as demonstrated by the plethora of interacting microorganisms inhabiting oral biofilms and a unique adaptation of each species to the composition of the biofilm and abiotic factors such as redox, pH and temperature, and the contents of nutrient and non-nutrient substances, including dissolved gases, in ambient fluids.
Static cultures of oral microorganisms, both single-species and mixed, are not expected to create an environment that emulates fluidic conditions of a normal human mouth. While flow systems for monitoring the growth of cells over time are known, none of those are suitable to sufficiently simulate an oral environment. Typically, the ex-vivo oral plaque samples are transferred to pre-sterilized well plate microfluidic (WPM) flow cells which fail to account for the complexity of the oral environment. A primary impediment associated with the WPM flow cells is that each cell consists of only a single flow channel constrained by a small diameter. The fixed channel design of known simulators is also a disadvantage because branching the flow path within the simulator is often required for experimental design. As a result, known oral environment simulators do not sufficiently reflect the composition of a biofilm in an actual oral environment, and are limited with respect to their ability to reproduce oral microbe growth patterns, rates of nutrient depletion, and responses of biofilms to changing environmental conditions.
Based on previously published data collected in vivo, (see e.g. Busher & van der Mei (2006), Clinical Microbiol. Rev. 19: 127; Nance et al. (2013), J. Antimicrob. Chemotherapy 68: 2550; Gupta (2014), “Viscometry for Liquids: Calibration of Viscometers”, Springer; Purcell (1977), Amer. J. Physics 45:3; Dawes et al., (1989), J. Dent. Res. 68: 1479), the ranges of fluidic parameters of a normal oral environment (during awake period) are known. The parameters are positively inter-correlated so that values higher than the normal range occur temporarily during meal consumption, values lower than the range occur only in certain regions of the mouth or during the night sleep. Specifically, three aspects of fluidic conditions have been suggested to influence the biofilm growth, namely dilution rate, shear stress and fluid velocity. Dilution rate (typical values of 11.1-19.0 h−1) exerts selection pressure on cells in suspension (plankton) as well as provides exchange of fluids in the proximity of the biofilms. Shear stress (normal values 0.001-0.5 dyn cm−2) drives adhesion and release of cells to and from a wetted surface, such as the surface of a tooth. Fluid velocity (normal values 0.8-7.6 mm min−1) in the proximity of the biofilm is a close correlate of the shear stress while in vivo, the existing methods allow for its more accurate estimate.
The reduced cross-sectional profile of a single flow channel in WPM flow cells leads to difficulties in modeling realistic dilution rate, shear stress and fluid velocity. For example, as the cross-sectional area of a channel is reduced, the effect of excessive dilution rates and shear stress is exacerbated by other physical phenomena, such as viscous forces dominating over inertial forces, and temperature and pressure-driven generation of micro-bubbles. The result is skewed biofilm growth profiles relative to an actual oral environment.
There is a growing awareness of the fundamental health impact of the complex microbial ecology that co-exists with the human body. However, systems and apparatuses are required to approximate conditions in subsets of microenvironments found in the mouth. Contrary to current setups, the system described herein can emulate the environment of the mouth by integrating a range of functions encountered in the living organism.
Effective simulation of oral conditions is critical to gain an understanding of interactions between abiotic and biotic factors which contribute to maintenance of oral health and/or onset of oral disease. A multitude of features can define a realistic modelling of an oral environment, including types and quantities of cells introduced into the flow system, types and availability of introduced nutrients, viscosity of ambient fluids, flow rate and resulting shear force, three-dimensional space availability for formation of a biofilm, degree of disturbance of the simulated environment during its operation, and abiotic factors.
A first aspect provided is a continuous flow system for passing fluid over a biofilm to simulate an oral environment, the continuous flow system comprising: a flow cell housing comprising: a base defining a longitudinal axis; and a plurality of channels defined by a plurality of channel walls supported by the base, the plurality of channels distributed adjacent to one another along the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels extending transverse to the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels having an inflow connection location for receiving the fluid into the channel and an outflow connection location for exporting the fluid from the channel; a plurality of removable channel connectors, each channel connector defining a connecting channel fluidly coupling a pair of the plurality of channels by connecting the outflow connection location of an upstream channel of the plurality of channels and the inflow connection location of a downstream channel of the plurality of channels; an upstream inflow adaptor fluidly connected to the flow cell housing for removably connecting to an inflow conduit defining an inflow channel; and a downstream outflow adaptor connected to the flow cell housing for removably connecting to an outflow conduit defining an outflow channel; wherein at least one of the plurality of channel walls is for supporting growth of the biofilm, the plurality of channels is for receiving the fluid via the inflow conduit from a reservoir positioned upstream of the flow cell housing, and the outflow channel is for receiving the fluid from the plurality of channels.
A further aspect is a method of passing fluid over a biofilm to simulate an oral environment within a flow cell having a plurality of channels defined by a plurality of channel walls supported by a base defining a longitudinal axis, the plurality of channels distributed adjacent to one another along the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels extending transverse to the longitudinal axis of the base, the method comprising: fluidly coupling an inflow channel defined by an inflow conduit to a reservoir containing fluid; fluidly coupling the inflow channel to a first channel of the plurality of channels; fluidly coupling the first channel of the plurality of channels to a second channel of the plurality of channels using a channel connector, the channel connector fluidly coupling the first channel to the second channel via a connecting channel defined by a wall of the channel connector; fluidly coupling an outflow channel defined by an outflow conduit to the second channel of the plurality of channels; and passing the fluid from the reservoir to the inflow channel such that the fluid flows from the inflow channel to the first channel, from the first channel to the second channel, and from the second channel to the outflow channel to promote growth of the biofilm.
A further aspect is a continuous flow system for passing fluid over a biofilm to simulate an oral environment, the continuous flow system comprising: a flow cell housing comprising: a base defining a longitudinal axis; and a plurality of channels defined by a plurality of channel walls supported by the base, the plurality of channels distributed adjacent to one another along the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels extending transverse to the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels having an inflow connection location for receiving the fluid into the channel and an outflow connection location for exporting the fluid from the channel; an upstream inflow adaptor connected to the flow cell housing for removably connecting to an inflow conduit defining an inflow channel for directing the fluid to the plurality of channels; a downstream outflow adaptor connected to the flow cell housing for removably connecting to an outflow conduit defining an outflow channel for receiving the fluid from the plurality of channels; and a removable reservoir fluidly connected to the plurality of channels via the inflow conduit for supplying the fluid to the plurality of channels; wherein at least one of the plurality of channel walls is for supporting growth of the biofilm, the plurality of channels receives the fluid from the reservoir via the inflow conduit, and the outflow channel receives the fluid from the plurality of channels.
A further aspect is a continuous flow system for passing fluid over a biofilm to simulate an oral environment, the continuous flow system comprising: a flow cell housing comprising: a base defining a longitudinal axis; and a plurality of channels defined by a plurality of channel walls supported by the base, the plurality of channels distributed adjacent to one another along the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels extending transverse to the longitudinal axis of the base, each channel of the plurality of channels having an inflow connection location for receiving the fluid into the channel and an outflow connection location for exporting the fluid from the channel; the fluid passed over the biofilm during a first stage of operation to produce a first stage shear stress at a first pre-determined shear stress range, a first stage fluid velocity at a first pre-determined fluid velocity range, and a first stage dilution rate at a first pre-determined dilution rate range; the fluid passed over the biofilm during a second stage of operation to produce a second stage shear stress at a second pre-determined shear stress range, a second stage fluid velocity at a second pre-determined fluid velocity range, and a second stage dilution rate at a second pre-determined dilution rate range, at least one of the second pre-determined shear stress range, the second pre-determined fluid velocity range and the second pre-determined dilution rate range being outside of the respective corresponding first pre-determined shear stress range, first pre-determined fluid velocity range, and first pre-determined dilution rate range.
Other advantages of the invention will become apparent to those of skill in the art upon reviewing the present specification.
Embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein like reference numerals denote like parts, and in which:
It will be appreciated that for simplicity and clarity of illustration, where considered appropriate, numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the exemplary embodiments described herein. However, it will be understood by those of ordinary skill in the art that the embodiments described herein can be practiced without these specific details. In other instances, well-known methods, procedures and components have not been described in detail so as not to obscure the embodiments described herein. Furthermore, this description is not to be considered as limiting the scope of the embodiments described herein in any way, but rather as merely describing the possible implementations of various embodiments that can be varied as known by a person of ordinary skill in the art.
Referring to
Herein the term “fluid” encompasses any liquid medium. For example, a fluid can be a liquid consisting essentially of a single liquid compound (e.g. deionized water) or more than one liquid compound (e.g. an aqueous ethanol solution). In other embodiments, a fluid can be a solution consisting of one or more liquid solvents and one or more solid solutes. For example, the fluid can be a nutrient broth for providing nutrients to cells. The nutrient broth can contain for example one or more amino acids, salts and sugars dissolved in water. In further embodiments, a fluid can consist of a liquid medium containing particles which are not dissolved (i.e. a suspension). An example of a suspension is a mixture of water and fluorescent beads. In certain embodiments, the fluid is a suspension containing cells. For example, a fluid can be a suspension comprising one or more species or sub-species of cells, or a dispersed sample of dental plaque, mixed in a nutrient broth solution. In one particular embodiment, a fluid comprises natural saliva. In another embodiment, a fluid comprises an artificial saliva composition. In particular embodiments, a fluid contains molecules for probing a biofilm established on the interior surface of a channel wall 55. For example, the fluid can contain molecular probes (e.g. labelled with fluorescent or radioactive moieties) capable of recognizing and binding to molecular targets on the surface of or within cells of the biofilm, or in the extracellular matrix surrounding the cells of the biofilm. In other embodiments, the fluid can contain one or more non-labelled compounds for altering the biofilm to observe a response of the cells in the biofilm to the one or more compounds. Non-limiting examples of compounds that can be contained in a fluid include proteins, amino acids, nucleic acids, sugars, polysaccharides, nucleosides, lipids, and drugs/pharmacological compounds.
Herein the term “cell” encompasses any biological unit capable of reproduction. The term “cell” contemplates both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. For example, a cell can be a bacterial cell, a plant cell, an animal cell including human cells, a fungus hypha or yeast cell. In one particular embodiment, a cell is a microorganism which is associated under healthy or diseased conditions with an oral biofilm. Non-limiting examples of cells include Bacteroides sp., Campylobacter rectus, Candida albicans, Capnocytophaga gingivalis, Centipeda periodontii, Citrobacter sp., Clostridium difficile, Corynebacterium matruchotii, Enterobacter cloacae, Enterococcus faecalis, Fusobacterium nucleatum, Hemophilus parainfluenzae, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Lachnospiraceae g.sp., Lactobacillus sp., Peptococcus prevoti, Peptostreptococcus anaerobius, Porphyromonas endodontalis, Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia, Prevotella loescheii, Prevotella melaninogenica, Propionibacterium sp., Selemonad aremidis, Stomatococcus mud, Stomatococcus mucilaginosus, Streptoccoccus infantis, Streptococcus cristatus, Streptococcus gordonii, Streptococcus mitis, Streptococcus mutans, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Treponema denticola, and Veillonella sp.
Herein the term “biofilm” refers to any assemblage of cells adhering to the inner surface of the flow cell and to one another. In one embodiment, the biofilm comprises cells which are microorganisms. The biofilm may be comprised of both living and dead cells embedded in the matrix. Typically cells of a biofilm are embedded within or associated with a self-produced matrix of extracellular polymeric substances. For example, the extracellular matrix can include polysaccharides, eDNA, and proteins.
Referring to
In cross-section, the channel wall 55 can define any shape, examples of which include circular, oval, rectangular and hexagonal. The surface of a channel wall 55 defining a channel 25 can be smooth or rough. For example, the surface of the channel wall 55 can define ridges or small bumps that protrude into the channel 25. In the embodiment shown in
The surface of a channel wall 55 defining a channel 25 is typically configured to facilitate the formation and maintenance of a biofilm 31 (see
Compounds can be applied to the surface of a channel wall 55 defining a channel 25 in any way known to a person of ordinary skill in the art. For example, solutions containing one or more compounds can be introduced into the channel 25 for a period of time to facilitate adhesion of the one or more compounds to the channel wall 55. The solution can be subsequently removed from the channel 25 (e.g. by aspiration) and the coated channel 25 then washed with an appropriate buffer. Alternatively, where the channels 25 are at least partly defined by the wall of a commercially available conduit, microscope slide or coverslip, the wall of the commercially available conduit, microscope slide or coverslip can be pre-coated with one or more compounds such that when the commercially available conduit, microscope slide or coverslip is incorporated into a flow cell 20, the channel wall 55 facilitates adhesion of microbes and thereby formation of a biofilm 31.
Referring to
The number of channels 25 defined by a flow cell housing 5 of a continuous flow system 10 can vary. For example, in
Referring to
As used herein, “around”, “about”, “approximately” or “substantially” shall generally mean within 20 percent, preferably within 10 percent, and more preferably within 5 percent of a given value or range. Numerical quantities given herein are approximate, meaning that the term “around”, “about”, “approximately” or “substantially” can be inferred if not expressly stated.
The base 15 can be configured to facilitate gas exchange between media contained within a channel 25 of the flow cell 20 and the ambient environment. For example,
The plurality of channel walls 55 can be supported by the base 15 in any way known to an ordinary-skilled person. For example, the outer surfaces of channel walls 55 of conduits or tubes can be affixed to a top surface of the base 15 using an adhesive. In other embodiments (see
In one embodiment, the base 15 defines a longitudinal axis (referenced by “L” in
The base 15 can further define a transverse axis (referenced by “T” in
As is shown in
One or more of the plurality of channels 25 can extend along one or more transverse axes between the first side (“C” in
Further, the relative angle of adjacent channels 25 along the longitudinal axis of base 15 can vary. For example, in
Referring to
Each channel connector 50 can be a hollow tube fluidly enclosed in cross-section and open at either end. In certain embodiments, each channel connector 50 is shaped with one or more bends or curves. For example, as shown in
The connecting channel 52 defined by each channel connector 50 can be fluidly coupled at a first end to an outflow connection location 18 of an upstream channel 25 and fluidly coupled at a second end to an inflow connection location 16 of a downstream channel 25. The channel connector 50 can fluidly connect an upstream channel 25 and a downstream channel 25 in any way known to an ordinary-skilled person. For example, referring to
The fluid coupling mediated by an adaptor 54 between channels 25 of the flow cell 20 can for example be by frictional (i.e. removable) engagement between the wall of the adaptor 54 and the chamber wall 27, the channel wall 55, or the wall of a channel connector 50. A wall of the adaptor 54 (e.g. via friction arm 59) can for example be configured to engage the inner surface of the chamber wall 27 (see
Channel connectors 50 can be used to fluidly couple any number of channels 25 of a flow cell housing 5. For example,
It will be understood that fluid connection of channel connectors 50 to a flow cell housing 5 can transform the flow cell housing 5 from a group of isolated channels 25 into a flow cell 20 defining a series of fluidly coupled channels 25 for facilitating the flow of fluid from an upstream position to a downstream position. For example, in
As will be understood, the connecting channel 52 is defined by the interior surface of a wall of the channel connector 50. In certain embodiments, the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 comprises a surface material which is less suitable to formation of a biofilm by cells introduced into the flow cell 20. Accordingly, the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 defining connecting channel 52 can be made of a material (e.g. glass) that is different from the material on the interior surface of a channel wall 55, and thereby facilitate less biofilm growth per unit area per unit time relative to the interior surface of channel wall 55. In certain embodiments, the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 facilitates less biofilm growth per unit area per unit time relative to the interior surface of channel wall 55 because the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 is made of a material that is not conducive to biofilm formation while the interior surface of the channel wall 55 is made with a material that is conducive to biofilm formation. In certain embodiments, the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 facilitates less biofilm growth per unit area per unit time relative to the interior surface of channel wall 55 because the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 is not coated and the interior surface of the channel wall 55 is coated with a coating that is conducive to biofilm formation (e.g. with a coating exhibiting hydrophilic and/or adhesive properties). In certain embodiments, the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 facilitates less biofilm growth per unit area per unit time relative to the interior surface of channel wall 55 because the interior surface of the wall of the channel connector 50 is coated with a coating that is not conducive to biofilm formation. For example, the interior surface of the wall of a channel connector 50 can be coated with a hydrophobic compound.
By providing for connectors 50 which are generally not amenable to biofilm formation (i.e. having walls with an interior surface facilitating less biofilm growth per unit area per unit time relative to the interior surface of channel wall 55), the present disclosure provides the further advantage of connectors 50 which can be reused with ease to configure a channel 25 of a desired length. That is, by using connectors 50 having interior surfaces which discourage/do not facilitate adhesion and growth of cells introduced into a flow cell 20 incorporating the connectors 50, the connectors 50 can be easily removed from the flow cell 20, cleaned, sterilized (e.g. by autoclaving) and re-incorporated into fresh flow cells 20.
Typically the cross-sectional profile of a connecting channel 52 through a channel connector 50 is different than the cross-sectional profile of a channel 25 through a channel wall 55. In particular, typically a connecting channel 52 is of a greater cross-sectional area than a channel 25. For example, a channel connector 50 can have inner diameter 1.6 mm and be 32 mm long. By providing for a larger cross-sectional area of the connecting channel 52 relative to the channel 25, the present disclosure facilitates ease of handling of the removable connectors 50 when removing, cleaning, autoclaving, and reusing them.
Further, when a channel connector 50 fluidly couples adjacent channels 25, in certain embodiments the connecting channel 52 defined by the channel connector 50 is oriented in a different plane than the channels 25. For example, in certain embodiments the channel connector 50 when fluidly coupling adjacent channels 25 can define an arc that is not parallel with the plane of the channels 25 defined by channel walls 55. For example, the arc defined by the channel connector 50 when fluidly coupling adjacent channels 25 can be at an angle that is greater than 0° and equal to or less than 90° with respect to the plane of the channels 25.
Typically each channel 25 of a flow cell 20 is fluidly coupled by a connecting channel 52 directly to an adjacent channel 25. However, the present disclosure contemplates that channels 25 that are not directly adjacent along a longitudinal axis of the base 15 can be directly fluidly coupled by a connecting channel 52. For example, in
Further, contemplated herein is a continuous flow system 10 where a channel 25 can be directly fluidly coupled to more than one other channel 25. For example, the flow path of fluid through channels 25 of a flow cell 20 can be regulated by fluidly connecting a 3-way stopcock (not shown) to a chamber wall 27 such that one opening of the stopcock is fluidly coupled to a channel 25 (e.g. via a chamber 29) and the remaining two openings of the stopcock are each fluidly coupled to a different connecting channel 52 defined by two respective channel connectors 50. Each channel connector 50 can in turn be fluidly connected (e.g. by a frictional fit) to a different chamber wall 27, or alternatively to a second 3-way stopcock. For example, the chamber wall 27 defining the “b” chamber 29 in
As will be understood, by regulating the position of the valves of the first 3-way stopcock, the flow of fluid in the flow cell 20 can be directed alternately between the different connecting channels 52 defined by the different channel connectors 50 attached to each nozzle of the 3-way stopcock. For example, the valves of the 3-way stopcock fluidly connected to the chamber wall 27 defining the “b” chamber 29 can be positioned to facilitate the flow of fluid through the first channel connector 50 into the “c” chamber 29, or alternately the valves can be reversed to facilitate the flow of fluid via the second channel connector 50 into the “e” chamber 29. Where the valves are positioned to facilitate the flow of fluid to the “e” chamber 29, the valves of the second 3-way stopcock fluidly connected to the chamber wall 27 defining the “e” chamber 29 can also be positioned to facilitate the flow of fluid from the “b” chamber 29 into the “e” chamber 29. Further, given the nature of a 3-way stopcock to inhibit flow to the second nozzle when receiving flow from the first nozzle, the fluid entering the “e” chamber 29 via the second channel connector 50 is inhibited from back-flowing via the third channel connector 50 to the “d” chamber 29. Therefore, the flow path of fluid in the flow cell 20 can be regulated by the use of valved 3-way stopcocks fluidly connected to channel connectors 50.
Therefore, it will be understood that one or more channel connectors 50 for fluidly coupling channels 25 can be removable from the flow cell housing 5. Providing for removable fluid connections between multiple channels 25 of a flow cell housing 5 confers flexibility to a flow cell 20 in order to generate multiple alternate flow paths for fluid. In a further example, channel walls 55 defining two or more adjacent channels 25 can be seeded with an identical fluid containing cells (e.g. provided by a hydraulic pump 70; see
Referring to
In certain embodiments, each of the inflow conduit 30 and the outflow conduit 40 can comprise tubing made of one or more materials which are flexible. For example, each of the inflow conduit 30 and outflow conduit 40 can be a flexible tube made of polyurethane, nylon, PVC, polyethylene, or silicone. In one particular embodiment, the inflow conduit 30 and outflow conduit 40 can each be a flexible tube comprising silicone. For example, the inflow conduit 30 and outflow conduit 40 can comprise Manosil® silicone tubing (Thermo-Fisher, Waltham, Mass., USA).
The inflow conduit 30 and outflow conduit 40 can be fluidly connected to the flow cell housing 5 (e.g. via a chamber wall 27 or channel wall 55) in any way known to an ordinary-skilled person. For example, referring to
Referring to
As shown in
In one embodiment, the flow interrupter 90 is reusable. For example, the flow interrupter 90 can be made of glass that is autoclavable such that the flow interrupter 90 can be sterilized between uses. In other examples, the flow interrupter 90 can be made of plastic or another material that can be sterilized using chemicals or UV radiation. In other embodiments the flow interrupter 90 is not reusable. For example, the flow interrupter 90 can be pre-sterilized and disposable.
Therefore, use of a flow interrupter 90 further lessens the likelihood that fluid from a source reservoir 80 will be contaminated by fluid backflowing from a channel 25. Other aspects of the continuous flow system 10 which reduce the likelihood of contamination of the system 10 include the use of components which are autoclavable, such as channel connectors 50, flow interrupter 90, and reservoirs 80, 81.
The likelihood of accidental air-borne contamination of the continuous flow system 10 (e.g. during supply of fresh nutrient media to the source reservoir 80, removal of used media from the outflow reservoir 81, or when using a source reservoir 80 that is open to the atmosphere) can further be reduced by applying a shield 79 to cover and shield a joint (i.e. opening) of a reservoir 80, 81 with the outer surface of the shielding. Such an arrangement is shown in
Referring to
In certain embodiments, the source reservoir 80 can be open to the environment. As described, above, the likelihood of accidental air-borne contamination of the source reservoir 80 can be reduced by applying a shield 79 to cover and shield a joint (i.e. opening) of a source reservoir 80 with the outer surface of the shielding. Such an arrangement is shown in
The source reservoir 80 can fluidly connect to an inflow conduit 30 to supply fluid to inflow channel 32 and thereby to flow cell 20. In one embodiment, the source reservoir 80 fluidly connects to the inflow conduit 30 via a hydraulic pump 70. For example, a reservoir tube 82 fluidly coupled to fluid in the source reservoir 80 (see
The outflow reservoir 81 can fluidly connect to outflow conduit 40 to receive fluid from the outflow channel 42 of flow cell 20. For example,
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
In operation, the first 3-way stopcock can be open between the syringe 88 (acting as reservoir 80) and upstream inflow conduit 30a. The second 3-way stopcock 86 can be open between the upstream inflow conduit 30a and downstream inflow conduit 30b extending to the flow cell 20. By placing the syringe in the linear pump and exerting force on the plunger of the syringe 88 via the linear pump, a constant rate of fluid can be administered to the upstream inflow conduit 30a and thereby to the downstream inflow conduit 30b via the second stopcock 86 and to the channel 25 (not shown). For example, a flow rate of 0.2 ml/min of fluid can be administered for 10 minutes. After delivering the contents of the syringe, the first stopcock 86 can be closed and the flow of fluid (e.g. nutrient media) resumed by switching the second 3-way stopcock to connect the outflow from source reservoir 80 (i.e. via flow interrupter 90) to the flow cell 20. The vertical outlet of the first 3-way stopcock can be used for releasing pressure during the fill of the extension tubing with nutrient medium before the use of syringe 88. When used repeatedly during one assay, this outlet may be protected by an air filter 85 (e.g. HEPA filter). In one particular embodiment, the linear pump is a Fusion Touch Pump capable of outflow at a rate of between to 0.0001 μl/min to 102 ml/min and the 3-way stopcock withstands 200 psi of pressure. The linear pump, 3-way stopcocks and syringe are available for example from SAI Infusion Technologies, Illinois, USA. It will be understood that when two alternative pumps are operated on the opposite sides of a 3-way stopcock (e.g. linear vs. peristaltic) caution should be used not to actuate both pumps simultaneously.
A hydraulic pump 70 can be used to deliver any type of fluid to a flow cell 20. For example, the hydraulic pump 70 can deliver a fluid containing cells for seeding channel walls 55 with cells for forming a biofilm (i.e. inoculation of channels 25 by culture flow). Inoculation of a flow cell 20 by culture flow lessens the likelihood of contamination during seeding compared to a system which requires manual seeding of a surface (e.g. by pipetting fluid directly into a channel or into a reservoir connected to a channel). This is especially the case for systems which are implemented in a microplate and require removal of a lid of the microplate to access and seed an interior surface of the microplate, since it is well-known that removal of the lid of the plate and the movements of a user pipetting liquid into the plate makes the microplate vulnerable to contamination of the seeded cells. In contrast, by providing for a continuous flow system 10 which is fluidly enclosed during seeding, the risk of contaminating seeded cells is dramatically reduced.
In other embodiments, a linear pump in combination with a syringe can be used to deliver fluids containing molecules for probing a biofilm established on the interior surface of a channel wall 55. For example, the fluid can contain molecular probes (e.g. labelled with fluorescent or radioactive moieties) capable of recognizing and binding to molecular targets on the surface of or within cells of the biofilm, or in the extracellular matrix surrounding the cells of the biofilm. In other embodiments, the fluid can contain non-labelled molecules for contact with the biofilm in order to observe the response of the cells in the biofilm to the ingredients. Non-limiting examples of compounds contained in the fluid introduced into a channel by hydraulic pump 70 include one or more of proteins, amino acids, nucleic acids, sugars, polysaccharides, nucleosides, lipids, and drugs/pharmacological compounds.
The hydraulic pump 70 can be connected to the source reservoir 80 in any way known to a person of ordinary skill in the art. For example, the source reservoir 80 can be operably connected to the hydraulic pump 70 by reservoir tube 82, which can be made of one or more materials which are flexible, amenable to autoclaving, and have no known effect on microbial growth. For example, reservoir tube 82 can be a flexible tube made of silicone or Tygon. In one particular embodiment, the reservoir tube 82 can each be a flexible tube comprising silicone. For example, the reservoir tube 82 can comprise Manosil® silicone tubing (Thermo-Fisher, Waltham, Mass., USA).
Further, the connection between the reservoir tube 82 and hydraulic pump 70, and between hydraulic pump 70 and inflow conduit 30, can be facilitated in any way known to a person of ordinary skill in the art. In one particular embodiment, couplers purchased from Bio-Rad (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Ltd, Hercules, Calif.) are used.
It will be understood that the presently described continuous flow system 10 incorporates features which inhibit contamination of the system 10 while simultaneously providing for the ability to establish and monitor a biofilm containing defined species of cells (e.g. bacterial cells). For example, the continuous flow system 10 described herein facilitates a removable seeding mechanism which accommodates precise control over the quantity, type and timing of cells introduced into one or more channels 25 while inhibiting contamination of resulting biofilms. For example, by providing for a removable side-flow attachment 83 (see
Contamination of the continuous flow system 10 is further inhibited by providing a source reservoir 80 which can supply fresh and sterile fluid (e.g. nutrient medium) to channels 25 without the need to directly access the reservoir 80 or channels 25 (e.g. by pipetting fresh medium directly into the system) to regulate the flow of the fluid. For example, as described above, a hydraulic pump 70 can be used to precisely regulate the flow rate of fluid into the channels 25. In addition, when employing a side-flow attachment 83, a stopcock can be used to temporarily halt the flow of fluid from a source reservoir 80 in order to facilitate flow of fluid into the channels 25 from a syringe 88. Configuring the source reservoir 80 to be removable from the continuous flow system 10 further facilitates aseptic control over the content of fluid introduced into channels 25. For example, a first source reservoir 80 can provide a first nutrient medium to channels 25 for a set period of time, following which a second source reservoir 80 can be used as a source of a second nutrient medium into channels 25. In certain embodiments, the second source reservoir 80 can be a sterile syringe 88 containing dyes or fluorescent probes for examining biofilm activity.
It will be understood that the continuous flow system 10 described herein operates by passing fluid through the flow system 10 from upstream positions to downstream positions via a particular flow path. In one embodiment a flow path is defined by the flow of fluid from the upstream source reservoir 80 to the downstream outflow reservoir 81. For example, the flow path can define the flow of fluid from the source reservoir 80 downstream to the hydraulic pump 70 (e.g. via the tube 82 fluidly coupled to fluid in the source reservoir 80) downstream to the flow interrupter 90, downstream to the inflow channel 32 defined by the inflow conduit 30, downstream to the chamber 29 defined by the chamber wall 27, downstream to a channel 25 defined by channel wall 55, downstream to a connecting channel 52 defined by a channel connector 50, downstream to one or more further channels 25 defined by channel walls 55, each of the one or more further channels 25 fluidly connected by a further connecting channel 52 defined by a further channel connector 50, downstream to an outflow channel 42 defined by an outflow conduit 40, downstream to the outflow reservoir 81. In some embodiments, the flow interrupter 90 can be absent. In other embodiments, the source reservoir 80 and the hydraulic pump 70 can be consolidated, such as when a syringe is used to both contain the fluid and pump the fluid into a channel 25 via one or more inflow conduits 30.
Typically, prior to use of a continuous flow system 10, the temperature of the flow cell 20 and/or fluid (e.g. seeding medium and/or nutrient media) is equilibrated to a temperature (e.g. 37° C.) compatible with the seeding and growth of a biofilm. Referring to
Once channel walls 55 have been seeded with cells to establish a biofilm, the biofilm can be treated or manipulated in various ways. For example, in embodiments (e.g.
By providing for removable connectors 50 to fluidly couple channels 25 adapted to support biofilm growth, the present continuous flow system 10 facilitates flexible and adaptable seeding of channel walls 55. For example, as shown in
As will be understood, following seeding of one or more channel walls 55 with cells to form a biofilm, the biofilm can be permitted to grow for an indefinite amount of time by providing the cells with nutrient medium delivered from source reservoir 80. A further advantage of the presently described continuous flow system is that the cross-sectional profile of channels 25 is amenable to the development of a biofilm comparable to that which exists in an oral cavity. In particular, the cross-sectional profile of each channel 25 is large enough (e.g. in one embodiment, a height of at least 400 μm and a width of at least 3.8 mm) to accommodate significant biofilm formation while maintaining shear stress and/or cell residency times at levels comparable to those in an oral cavity.
Referring to
Based on previously published data collected in vivo, (cited below) the ranges of fluidic parameters of normal oral environment (during awake period) are known. Specifically, three aspects of fluidic conditions have been suggested to influence the biofilm growth, namely shear stress, fluid velocity and dilution rate. These parameters are correlated such that, for a particular cross-section of channel 25, increased fluid velocities tend to result in increased shear stress and increased dilution rate. Further, the parameters can be positively inter-correlated so that values higher than the normal range occur temporarily during meal consumption, values lower than the range occur only in certain regions of the mouth or during the night sleep. The present continuous flow system 10 facilitates regulation of shear stress, fluid velocity and dilution rate within channels 25 to advantageously simulate actual values of these parameters in oral cavities.
Moreover, as the cross-sectional area of the tubing in an oral simulator is reduced, the effect of excessive dilution rates and shear stress can be exacerbated by other physical phenomena, such as viscous forces dominating over inertial forces, and temperature and pressure-driven generation of micro-bubbles. Contrary to known WPM flow cells, a further advantage of the presently described system 10 is that it is well-suited for extending the range of fluidic parameters to lower or higher values due to a wide range of flow rates (e.g. 120 μL h−1 to 2.4 L h−1) available with the peristaltic pump (i.e. hydraulic pump 70) used. As a result, the system 10 can be used to simulate various manipulations to an oral biofilm, such as for example contact of the biofilm with an instrument (e.g. toothbrush), rinsing of the biofilm, and/or selecting microorganisms in the biofilm which have a relatively high capacity to adhere to the biofilm.
Shear stress (typical oral values of 0.0010-0.5 dyn·cm−2) drives adhesion and release of cells to and from a wetted surface (e.g. surface of a tooth or channel wall 55) capable of supporting biofilm formation. The present continuous flow system 10 can advantageously approximate in vivo values for shear stress. In contrast, published data from WPM flow cells are approximately 20× higher than the lower-bound values achieved with the system 10. In certain embodiments, shear stress values within a channel 25 of the presently described continuous flow system 10 can be 0.0024-3.00 dyn·cm−2, preferably 0.0024-2.00 dyn·cm−2, and more preferably 0.0024-0.36 dyn·cm−2.
In certain embodiments, ranges of shear stress in a channel 25 of the system 10 differ depending on a stage of operation of the system 10. For example, at a first stage of operation the channel 25 can receive fluid (e.g. by the action of hydraulic pump 70 pumping the fluid into channel 25 via inflow conduit 30) exhibiting a shear stress value within a pre-determined first range of shear stress values. At a second stage of operation, the rate that the fluid is received into the channel 25 can be modified (e.g. by manually regulating the rate of pumping by hydraulic pump 70) such that the channel 25 receives fluid exhibiting a shear stress value within a pre-determined second range of shear stress values, the second range of shear stress values being outside of the first range of shear stress values. A first stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by the action of hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) cells into a channel 25 of the system 10 at pre-determined shear stress values within a first range that facilitates attachment of the cells to a channel wall 55 (i.e. seeding the channel wall 55 to form a biofilm). This first stage of operation of the system 10 can simulate shear stress values in an oral cavity during “normal” periods of oral biofilm establishment and growth. A second stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by the action of hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) nutrient media into the channel 25 at pre-determined shear stress values within a second range, which can be higher than and fall outside of the first range, in order to simulate forces which act in oral cavities to potentially disrupt an established biofilm (i.e. cause drifting of cells in the biofilm). For example, at the second stage, the second range of shear stress values can simulate shear stresses applied to an oral biofilm by an instrument such as a toothbrush when the instrument contacts the biofilm.
Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined first range of shear stress in the channel 25 during the first stage of operation are 0.0024-0.36 dyn·cm−2, 0.024-0.5 dyn·cm−2, 0.024-0.6 dyn·cm−2, and 0.024-0.7 dyn·cm−2. Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined second range of shear stress in the channel 25 during the second stage of operation are 0.36-0.5 dyn·cm−2, 0.5-1.0 dyn·cm−2, 0.5-2.0 dyn·cm−2, 0.6-1.5 dyn·cm−2 and 0.7-2.0 dyn·cm−2.
Fluid velocity (typical oral values of 0.8-7.6 mm·min−1) in the proximity of an in vivo oral biofilm is closely correlated with shear stress. The present continuous flow system 10 can advantageously approximate the upper bound of the in vivo range for fluid velocity. In contrast, WPM flow cells produce values for fluid velocity which exceed the lower-bound values achieved by the system 10 described herein by at least 20-fold. In certain embodiments, fluid velocity values within a channel 25 of the presently described continuous flow system 10 can be 1.32-1650 mm·min−1, preferably 1.32-1100 mm·min−1, more preferably 1.32-198 mm·min−1, and most preferably 1.32-7.6 mm·min−1.
In certain embodiments, ranges of fluid velocities in a channel 25 of the system 10 differ depending on a stage of operation of the system 10. For example, at a first stage of operation the channel 25 can receive fluid (e.g. by the action of hydraulic pump 70 pumping the fluid into channel 25 via inflow conduit 30) exhibiting a fluid velocity value within a pre-determined first range of fluid velocity values. At a second stage of operation, the rate that the fluid is received into the channel 25 can be modified (e.g. by manually regulating the rate of pumping by hydraulic pump 70) such that the channel 25 receives fluid exhibiting a fluid velocity value within a pre-determined second range of fluid velocity values, the second range of fluid velocity values being outside of the first range of fluid velocity values. A first stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) cells into a channel 25 of the system 10 at pre-determined fluid velocity values within a first range that facilitates attachment of the cells to a channel wall 55 (i.e. seeding the channel wall 55 to form a biofilm). This first stage of operation of the system 10 can simulate fluid velocity values resulting from for example normal or stimulated salivation in an oral cavity during periods of oral biofilm establishment and growth. A second stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) nutrient media into the channel 25 at pre-determined fluid velocity values within a second range, which can be higher than and fall outside the first range, in order to simulate forces which act in oral cavities on an established biofilm. For example, at the second stage, the second range of fluid velocity values can simulate fluid velocities present while rinsing a biofilm in an oral cavity (for example, with mouthwash).
Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined first range of fluid velocity in the channel 25 during the first stage of operation are 1.32-100 mm·min−1, 1.32-150 mm·min−1 and 1.32-200 mm·min−1. Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined second range of fluid velocity in the channel 25 during the second stage of operation are 100-200 mm·min−1, 150-500 mm·min−1, 200-500 mm·min−1, 200-1000 mm·min−1 and 100-1500 mm·min−1.
Dilution rate (typical oral values of 11.1-19.0 h−1) exerts selection pressure on cells in suspension (plankton) as well as provides exchange of fluids in the proximity of a biofilm in an oral cavity. The present continuous flow system 10 can advantageously approximate the upper bound of the in vivo range of dilution rate. In contrast, WPM flow cells typically produce dilution rate values that exceed the lower-bound values achieved by the system 10 described herein by at least 6×. Dilution rates within a channel 25 of the presently described system 10 can be 4-5000 h−1, preferably 10-3500 h−1, more preferably 10-600 h−1, and most preferably 11.1-19.0 h−1.
In certain embodiments, ranges of dilution rates in a channel 25 of the system 10 differ depending on a stage of operation of the system 10. For example, at a first stage of operation the channel 25 can receive fluid (e.g. by the action of hydraulic pump 70 pumping the fluid into channel 25 via inflow conduit 30) exhibiting a dilution rate value within a pre-determined first range of dilution rate values. At a second stage of operation, the rate that the fluid is received into the channel 25 can be modified (e.g. by manually regulating the rate of pumping by hydraulic pump 70) such that the channel 25 receives fluid exhibiting a dilution rate value within a pre-determined second range of dilution rate values, the second range of dilution rate values being outside of the first range of dilution rate values. A first stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) cells into a channel 25 of the system 10 at pre-determined dilution rate values within a first range that facilitates attachment of the cells to a channel wall 55 (i.e. seeding the channel wall 55 to form a biofilm). This first stage of operation of the system 10 can simulate dilution rate values resulting from for example normal or stimulated salivation in an oral cavity during periods of oral biofilm establishment and growth. A second stage of operation of the system 10 can involve introducing (e.g. by hydraulic pump 70 via inflow conduit 30) nutrient media into the channel 25 at pre-determined dilution rate values within a second range, which can be higher than and fall outside of the first range, in order to simulate forces which act in oral cavities on an established biofilm. For example, at the second stage, the second range of dilution rate values can be pre-determined to simulate a fluid velocity value produced while rinsing a biofilm in an oral cavity (for example, with mouthwash). In other examples, the second range of dilution rate values can be pre-determined to select for species of microorganisms which are capable of adhering to a surface (i.e. channel wall 55) within the range of pre-determined dilution rate values (i.e. select against species of microorganisms which are incapable of adhering to the surface within the range of pre-determined dilution rate values). Therefore, by providing for a second range of dilution rate values outside of the first range of dilution rate values, the system 10 can select for particular species of microorganisms that adhere relatively strongly to a biofilm.
Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined first range of dilution rates in the channel 25 during the first stage of operation are 4-600 h−1, 10-600 h−1 and 11.1-600 h−1. Non-limiting values defining the pre-determined second range of dilution rates in the channel 25 during the second stage of operation are 600-1000 h−1, 600-3500 h−1, and 600-5000 h−1.
We used published data on the normal un-stimulated saliva secretion (Elishoov et al. 2008, Arch. Oral Biol. 53:75) and the volume of saliva in mouth before swallowing (Lagelof & Dawes, 1984, J. Dent. Res. 63:618) and estimated the dilution rate prevailing in the human oral cavity during “awake period” as approximately D≦20 h−1 (not calculated by the above authors). Compared with available data on maximum growth rates of bacterial species found in the human biome, this value is about 10× higher than bacteria can attain (as “planktonic cells”; data compiled from more than 12 published papers; see Table 1). Since both the oral cavity dilution rates and bacterial growth rates are expressed in the same physical units (h−1), these data mean that the saliva flow greatly exceeds the potential of bacterial cells suspended in saliva to sustain their numbers (as “planktonic cells”).
Pseudomonas natrigenes
Vibrio parahaemolyticus
Escherichia coli
Klebsiella pneumoniae
Bacillus subtilis
Our research of oral bacterial strains in continuous-flow systems during recent years (Legner & Cvitkovitch; unpublished data) showed that the rate of initial biofilm formation increases with the dilution rate of the fluids. In the light of the above published data, this suggests that the selection pressure proportional to the dilution rate of saliva gives a great advantage to the sedentary (surface attached) as compared to the suspended (planktonic) way of life of oral microorganisms.
With this information in mind, we assembled a continuous-flow system that would advantageously emulate oral cavity conditions for our strains and most importantly for any sample of oral microbiome freshly isolated from a patient's oral cavity (i.e., ex-vivo microbiome). A combination of the Ibidi Slide VI0.4 (i.e. base 15 containing channels 25 defined by channel walls 55) with Bio-Rad™ Econo Gradient pump (i.e. pump 70) allowed for a good approximation of the above-specified conditions. A single-channel 25 volume of Ibidi Slide (i.e. base 15) is 30 μL and the minimum flow rate of the pump 70 (with the inner diameter of pump tubing being 0.8 mm) is 600 μL per hour which results in D=20 h−1, if considering a single channel 25 to be a continuous-flow vessel. While, arguably, prevailing laminar streaming in the channel 25 may cause substantially higher values of D at any given point of the channel 25, practical implementation of the system sustained massive biofilm formation of both single oral isolates and entire plaque samples (Wenderska, Legner, Cvitkovitch; Huang, Legner, Finer; unpublished data). Moreover, connecting the Ibidi channels 25 (using silicone tubing as channel connectors 50) in series of up to 6 units allowed us to visualize and quantify a gradient of biofilm and extracellular matrix mass decreasing from a single-point nutrient supply (inflow to the Channel 1) towards the outflow from the system (Channel 6).
Another parameter to watch for while simulating oral conditions is the shear stress under which oral biofilms (the plaque) exist. A shear stress during normal salivation is reported to be 0.001 to 0.5 dyn·cm−2, while the shear stress during e.g. biting an apple (stimulated salivation) is known to be at 2.0 dyn·cm−2 (Busher & van der Mei 2006; Clinical Microbiol. Rev. 19: 127).
When application to oral plaque conditions is attempted using the WPM flow cells (e.g. BioFlux™) systems, the effort is made to simulate actual shear stress values. However, a disadvantage of known systems is that the shear stress they generate only marginally overlaps with the normal salivation values (the lower bound of reported range for BioFlux™ is at 0.2 dyn·cm2; Nance et al. 2013; J. Antimicrob. Chemotherapy 68:2550). Contrary to known systems, the presently described continuous flow system 10 can advantageously give rise to a lower bound of available range of shear stress values of 0.01 dyn·cm−2, which is well within normal oral salivation conditions.
Table 2 shows the results of a comparison of shear stress in the proximity of a submerged surface between Ibidi channels 25, a BioFlux™ system, and a rotating disc reactor.
The excessive downscaling of channel cross sections of known systems (e.g. BioFlux™) is associated with a substantial decrease of the Reynolds number (cf. Gupta 2014, Viscometry for Liquids: Calibration of Viscometers; Springer) so that the viscous forces begin to dominate over inertial forces (Purcell 1977; Amer. J. Physics 45:3). This is also exacerbated by other physical phenomena, such as Henry's Law (temperature and partial pressure driven generation of micro bubbles). As a result, in known systems (e.g. BioFlux™) the WPM flow cell applications for ex vivo plaque samples require constant microscope control to detect frequent obstructions to the flow. Contrary to these known systems, in the presently described continuous flow system 10, flow obstructions are rare providing for a more reliable simulation of oral biofilm conditions.
The success of simulating conditions in vivo can also be assessed by comparing fluid velocities above the biofilm. Table 3 compares data for both our system and BioFlux™ microfluidics with values estimated for unstimulated saliva film flow over the inner surfaces of three oral regions (Dawes et al., 1989, J. Dent. Res. 68: 1479). While the fluid velocity in an embodiment of our system (i.e. Ibidi flow cell at 600 μL h−1) is within the range of the highest unstimulated flow in vivo (on lingual side of teeth), the fluid velocities calculated from published data on the BioFlux™ system are out of this range.
While the exemplary embodiments have been described herein, it is to be understood that the invention is not limited to the disclosed embodiments. The invention is intended to cover various modifications and equivalent arrangements included within the spirit and scope of the appended claims, and scope of the claims is to be accorded an interpretation that encompasses all such modifications and equivalent.
This application is a continuation of PCT/CA2016/000123, filed Apr. 21, 2016, the entire contents of which is hereby incorporated herein by express reference thereto.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | PCT/CA2016/000123 | Apr 2016 | US |
Child | 15159128 | US |