Controllable magnetorheological fluid temperature control device

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 10222143
  • Patent Number
    10,222,143
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, November 22, 2017
    7 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 5, 2019
    5 years ago
Abstract
Method for controlling heat transfer between two objects. In one embodiment, the method includes flowing a current through an electromagnet disposed about a container holding magnetorheological fluid to bias a first conductive element against a first end of the container and a second conductive element against a second end of the container to align particles in the magnetorheological fluid such that first conductive element is conductively coupled to the second conductive element; and reducing the current through an electromagnet such that the first conductive element is biased away from the first end of the container and the second conductive element is biased away from the second end of the container to break the alignment of the particles in the magnetorheological fluid such that the first conductive element is not conductively coupled to the second conductive element.
Description
BACKGROUND

The present invention relates to a method and apparatus to control heat transfer between two objects, and more specifically, a method and apparatus to control heat transfer using a system of manipulating magnetorheological fluid.


Electronic devices perform tasks, which are becoming more complicated and computationally intensive with each passing year. In response to the requirements placed on these electronic devices, semiconductor die need to perform at ever-increasing levels of performance. To provide the increased performance, successive generations of electronic devices include semiconductor die having smaller design rules which enable higher data speeds with the tradeoff of generating more heat in successively smaller spatial volumes. Further, as semiconductor die to the larger electrical device becomes more densely packed. This dense interconnection circuitry may become a physical obstacle to remove heat from the semiconductor die and contributes to the heat generated by the electrical device. Heat is often removed from the electrical device as materials making up the electrical device may be altered by temperatures above a certain threshold and these temperatures may adversely change electrical characteristics of the materials. For example, power leakage through transistors on logic circuitry may occur as the temperature is increased and data integrity issues may occur when memory cells are exposed to temperatures outside their operating range. Also, removing heat may reduce extreme temperature fluctuations in the electrical device, which can damage components through expansion and contraction when power is cycled on and off.


Conventional heat transfer approaches for semiconductor die include passive air convection, forced air conduction, and/or thermal sinks. However, these approaches are becoming less effective given the greater amounts of heat being generated in reduced spatial volumes. A known inefficiency in server and other electronic cooling is the underutilization of heat sinks based on chip usage. For example, when one processor is being used at fully capacity and another adjacent processor is not being used, the heat sink volume of the unused processor is being wasted.


Thus, an apparatus and method for heat to be transferred between two objects when desired are needed.


SUMMARY

According to one embodiment, a method that includes biasing, using an electromagnet, a first conductive element against a first end of a container and a second conductive element against a second end of the container to align particles in a magnetorheological fluid in the container such that the first conductive element is conductively coupled to the second conductive element. The method also includes biasing, using the electromagnet, the first conductive element away from the first end of the container and the second conductive element away from the second end of the container so that the first conductive element is not conductively coupled to the second conductive element.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS


FIGS. 1A-1C illustrate one embodiment of a temperature control device during different stages of a current being supplied therein.



FIG. 2 illustrates one embodiment of the magnetic flux lines generated through the temperature control device of FIGS. 1A-1C.



FIG. 3 illustrates another embodiment of a temperature control device, as disclosed herein.



FIG. 4 illustrates a method of controlling temperature using the temperature control device of FIGS. 1A-1C, according to one embodiment.



FIGS. 5A-5D illustrate one embodiment of a temperature control device during different stages of a current being supplied therein.



FIG. 6 illustrates one embodiment of the magnetic flux lines generated by the first electromagnet and the second electromagnet of the temperature control device illustrated in FIGS. 5A-5D.



FIG. 7 illustrates a method of controlling temperature using the temperature control device of FIGS. 5A-5D, according to one embodiment.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION


FIG. 1A illustrates one embodiment of a temperature control device 100 to control heat transfer between two objects. The temperature control device 100 may include a container 102, at least one biasing element, an electromagnet 108, and a plurality of conductive elements 110, 112. The container 102 includes a first end 114 and a second end 116. The first conductive element 110 is disposed at the first end 114 of the container 102. The second conductive element 112 is disposed at the second end 116 of the container 102. In some embodiments, the first and second conductive elements 110, 112 impinge on the container 102.


In one embodiment, the temperature control device 100 includes a first biasing element 104 and a second biasing element 106. While embodiments of the present disclosure are described having two biasing elements, it is noted that other embodiments may include any number of biasing elements in a variety of configurations and arrangements, such as more than two biasing elements, only one biasing elements, or even no biasing elements. The first biasing element 104 is coupled to the first conductive element 110. The first biasing element 104 is configured to move the first conductive element 110 relative to the container 102. The second biasing element 106 is coupled to the second conductive element 112. The second biasing element 106 is configured to move the second conductive element 112 relative to the container 102. In the embodiment shown in FIG. 1, the first and second biasing elements 104, 106 are coaxial with the first and second conductive elements 110, 112. The temperature control device 100 may further include a third conductive element 122 and a fourth conductive element 124. The third conductive element 122 may be coupled to the first biasing element 104, opposite the first conductive element 110. The fourth conductive element 124 may be coupled to the second biasing element 106, opposite the second conductive element 112. The first conductive element 110, the first biasing element 104, the second conductive member 112, and the second biasing member 106 form compliant sections that permit the ends 114, 116 to move closer together.


The electromagnet 108 is disposed about the container 102. In one embodiment, the electromagnet 108 may be a solenoid disposed around the container 102, although other embodiments are possible. The electromagnet 108 is coupled to a controller 120. The controller 120 is configured to provide a current through to the electromagnet 108 to generate a magnetic field about the container 102. For example, the generated magnetic field may be parallel to the container 102.


The container 102 may contain a fluid 118. The fluid 118 may be a magnetorheological fluid (MR fluid) 118. The MR fluid 118 contains a plurality of ferromagnetic particles 126. Initially, the particles 126 are randomly distributed throughout the MR fluid. The particles 126 are configured to align with magnetic flux lines of a magnetic field when a magnetic field is generated about the container 102. The alignment of the particles 126 is configured to conductively couple the first conductive element 110 to the second conductive element 112 such that heat may be transferred through the temperature control device 100. For example, when the power source 120 provides a current to the electromagnet 108 to generate a magnetic field about the container with magnetic flux lines parallel to the container, the particles 126 in the MR fluid 118 will align with the magnetic flux lines in a parallel arrangement to conductively couple the first conductive element 110 to the second conductive element 112. The container 102 may be a flexible container that is configured to be constricted responsive to movement of the first conductive element 110 and the second conductive element 112 against the first end 114 and the second end 116, respectively.


In the embodiment shown in FIG. 1A, the biasing elements 104, 106 are in a relaxed initial position. The biasing elements 104, 106 are in the relaxed positions because no current is provided to the electromagnet 108. When no current is provided to the electromagnet 108, particles 126 in the MR fluid 118 are not aligned. Thus, the first conductive element 110 is not conductively coupled with the second conductive element 112.



FIG. 1B illustrates one embodiment of the temperature control device 100 when a current, I, is provided to the electromagnet 108. In operation, the controller 120 provides a current, I, to the electromagnet 108. Responsive to providing current I to the electromagnet 108, a magnetic field is generated within the container 102.



FIG. 2 shows an enlarged view of the container 102 of the temperature control device 100 depicting the magnetic field. The magnetic field generated within the container 102 contains flux lines 202 parallel to the container 102. The particles 126 in the MR fluid 118 align with the flux lines 202 to create a parallel arrangement of particles 126. The alignment of the particles 126 in the direction of the magnetic field increases the heat transfer in the axial direction due to the different in thermal conductivity of the MR fluid 118.


Referring back to FIG. 1B, the magnetic field pulls the first biasing element 104 towards the first end 114 of the container 102 and the second biasing element 106 towards the second end 116 of the container 102. As a result, the first biasing element 104 biases the first conductive element towards the first end 114 of the container 102 and the second biasing element 106 biases the second conductive element towards the second end 116 of the container 102. The biasing of the conductive elements 110, 112 constricts the flexible container 102. Constricting the flexible container 102 reduces an initial area 148 of the flexible container 102 between the first conductive element 110 and the second conductive element 112. A reduced area 150 results in an increased concentration of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118.


The magnetic field generated by the electromagnet 108 influences the particles 126 to align with the magnetic flux lines. The magnetic field, in addition to the reduced area 150, creates a plurality of chains 128 of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118. The chains 128 are aligned with the magnetic flux lines, parallel to the container 102, and coaxial to the conductive elements 110, 112. The chains 128 conductively couple the first conductive element 110 to the second conductive element 112. By conductively coupling the first conductive element 110 to the second conductive element 112, heat is transferred through the temperature control device 100. For example, heat may be transferred in the direction illustrated by line 130. In FIG. 1B, the rate of heat transfer is not at its maximum. As illustrated, a plurality of particles 126 remain scattered in the MR fluid 118 because only moderate current is provided to the electromagnet 108.



FIG. 1C illustrates the temperature control device 100 according to one embodiment. In FIG. 1C, maximum current is provided to the electromagnet 108. The maximum current increases the strength of the generated magnetic field. The increased magnetic field pulls the first biasing element 104 further towards the first end 114 of the container 102 and the second biasing element 106 further towards the second end 116 of the container 102. The first biasing element 104 biases the first conductive element 110 further towards the first end 114 of the container 102 and the second biasing element 106 biases the second conductive element 112 further towards the second end 116 of the container 102. The additional biasing of the conductive elements towards the ends 114, 116, respectively, further constricts the flexible container 102. Further constricting the flexible container 102 reduces the area 150 of the flexible container to an area 152. The reduced area 152 results in a larger concentration of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118 as compared to the concentration of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118 in areas 148, 150.


The increased magnetic field generated by the electromagnet 108 influences more particles 126 to align with the magnetic flux lines. The magnetic field, in addition to the reduced area 152, creates a greater plurality of chains 128 of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118. The increased number of chains 128 increases the conductive coupling between the first conductive element 110 and the second conductive element 112. At maximum current, heat transfer is at its greatest and the number of particles 126 scattered is minimized.


The current provided to the electromagnet 108 may be reduced to decrease the rate of heat transfer through the temperature control device 100. Reducing the current through the electromagnet 108 reduces the strength of the magnetic field. The first and second biasing elements 104, 106 begin to relax when the strength of the magnetic field is reduced. The first conductive element 110 and the second conductive element 112 move back to the initial positions. The container 102 expands, thus increasing the reduced area 152 back to the initial area 148. The expansion of the container 102 breaks the chains 128 of particles 126 in the MR fluid 118. The rate of heat transfer through the temperature control device 100 is decreased because breaking the chains of particles 126 in the MR fluid conductively uncouples the first conductive element 110 from the second conductive element 112. To stop heat transfer through the temperature control device 100, the power source 120 provides no current to the electromagnet 108 resulting in the biasing elements 104, 106 moving back to an initial relaxed position and the reduced area 152 of the container 102 expanding back to the initial area 148, and returns to the state depicted in FIG. 1A.


The embodiments shown in FIGS. 1A-1C illustrate a certain level of displacement between the conductive elements via the biasing elements. However, those skilled in the art will appreciate that in another embodiment, it may be preferred to accept a lower maximum displacement. This may be done by including only one biasing element.



FIG. 3 illustrates another embodiment of a temperature control device 300. It should be understood that other configurations of the temperature control device may be utilized. For Example, FIG. 3 illustrates another embodiment of the temperature control device wherein the biasing elements need not be axially aligned with the conductive member 110, 112. The temperature control device 300 includes a plurality of biasing elements 302, 304, 306, 308. The first biasing element 302 and the second biasing element 304 are coupled to the first conductive element 110. The biasing elements 302, 304 are not axially aligned with the conductive element 110. The third biasing element 306 and the fourth biasing element 308 are coupled to the second conductive element 112. The biasing elements 306, 308 are not axially aligned with the conductive element 112. The biasing elements 302, 304 are configured to bias the first conductive element 110 relative to the container 102. The biasing elements 306, 308 are configured to bias the second conductive element 112 relative to the container 102.



FIG. 4 illustrates a method 400 of transferring heat through a temperature control device, such as the temperature control device of FIGS. 1A-1C. The method begins at block 402. At block 402, a controller provides a current to an electromagnet disposed around a container containing MF fluid. The electromagnet generates a magnetic field about the container. The magnetic field causes a first biasing element to bias a first conductive element positioned on one end of the container towards the container, and a second biasing element to bias a second conductive element positioned on a second end of the container towards the container. The movement of the first conductive element and the second conductive element constricts the container. Particles in the MR fluid align themselves with the magnetic flux lines in the magnetic field to form chains of particles. The constriction of the container increases the concentration of the chains in the MR fluid. The alignment of the particles conductively couples the first conductive element to the second conductive element. The conductive coupling allows heat to transfer through the temperature control device. The amount of heat transfer may be controlled by adjusting the current provided to the electromagnet.


At block 404, the current provided to the electromagnet is reduced to reduce heat transfer through the temperature control device. Reducing the current weakens the strength of the magnetic field about the container. The decreased strength results in the biasing elements biasing the first and second conductive elements away from the container. The concentration of chains of particles in the MR fluid is reduced due to the reduction in magnetic flux lines and the expansion of the container holding the MR fluid. The amount of heat transferred through the temperature control device may be reduced to zero if current is no longer provided to the electromagnet. When current is no longer applied to the electromagnet, the first and second conductive elements are moved back to their initial positions. Additionally, the chains of particles in the MR fluid are broken, and the particles are randomly scattered. As such, there is no longer a conductive coupling between the first and second conductive elements.


Blocks 402-404 may be repeated to vary the amount of heat transferred through the temperature control device.



FIG. 5A illustrates one embodiment of a temperature control device 500 to control heat transfer between two objects. The temperature control device 500 may include a container 502, a plurality of conductive elements 504, 506, a first electromagnet 508, and second electromagnet 510. The container 502 includes a first end 512 and a second end 514. The first conductive element 504 is disposed at the first end 512 of the container 502. The second conductive element 506 is disposed at the second end 514 of the container 502.


The electromagnet 508 is disposed about the container 502. The electromagnet 508 may be, for example, a solenoid disposed about the container 502. The electromagnet 508 is coupled to a controller 520. The power source 520 is configured to provide a first current to the electromagnet 508 to generate a magnetic field about the container 502. For example, the generated magnetic field may be parallel to the container 502.


The container 502 may be a flexible container that is configured to be constricted responsive to movement of the first conductive element 504 and the second conductive element 506 against the first end 512 and the second end 514, respectively. The container 502 may contain a fluid 516. For example, the fluid 516 may be an MR fluid. The MR fluid 516 contains a plurality of particles 518. The particles 518 may be magnetic. Initially, the particles 518 are randomly distributed through the fluid 516. The particles 518 are configured to align with magnetic flux lines of a magnetic field when the magnetic field is generated about the container 502. The alignment of the particles 518 is configured to conductively couple the first conductive element 504 and the second conductive element 506 such that heat may be transferred through the temperature control device 500. For example, when the power source 520 provides a current to the electromagnet 508 to generate a magnetic field about the container with magnetic flux lines parallel to the container, the particles 518 in the MR fluid 516 will align with the magnetic flux lines in a parallel arrangement to conductively couple the first conductive element 504 to the second conductive element 506.


The second electromagnet 510 is positioned perpendicular to the electromagnet 508. In the embodiment shown in FIG. 5, the second electromagnet 510 is positioned above the electromagnet 508. The second electromagnet 510 is coupled to the controller 520. The controller 520 is configured to provide a current through the second electromagnet 510 such that a magnetic field is generated. The magnetic field generated by the second electromagnet 510 is orthogonal to the magnetic field generated by the electromagnet 508. In one embodiment, the second electromagnet 510 may be replaced with a permanent magnet.


In the embodiment shown in FIG. 5A, a current has not been provided to the electromagnet 508. When no current is provided to the electromagnet 508, the particles 518 in the MR fluid 516 are randomly scattered and not aligned. Thus, the first conductive element 504 is not conductively coupled with the second conductive element 506. As such, heat cannot be transferred through the temperature control device 500.



FIG. 5B illustrates one embodiment of the temperature control device 500 when a current, I1, is provided to the electromagnet 508. The power source 520 provides the current I1 to the electromagnet 508. Responsive to providing a current to the electromagnet 508, a magnetic field is generated through the electromagnet 508.



FIG. 6 shows an enlarged view of the container 502 of the temperature control device 500 depicting the first magnetic field 600. The first magnetic field 600 contains flux lines 602 parallel to the container 502. The particles 518 in the MR fluid 516 will align with the flux lines 602 to create a parallel arrangement of particles 518. Referring back to FIG. 5B, the magnetic field influences the particles 518 to align in the direction of the flux lines 602. The particles 518 form a plurality of chains 524 that conductively couple the first conductive element 504 to the second conductive element 506. By conductively coupling the first conductive element 504 to the second conductive element 506, heat may be transferred through the temperature control device 500. The direction of heat transfer is illustrated by line 526. Because only moderate current has been provided to the electromagnet 508, a plurality of particles 518 remain scattered in the MR fluid 516. Thus, the rate at which heat is transferred in FIG. 5B is not at its maximum.



FIG. 5C illustrates the temperature control device 500, according to one embodiment. In FIG. 5C, maximum current is provided to the electromagnet 508 by the first power source 520. The maximum current increases the strength of the magnetic field about the container 502. The number of chains 524 of particles 518 formed in the MR fluid 516 is at its maximum, and the number of particles 518 that remain scattered are minimized. The increased number of chains 524 increases the conductive coupling between the first conductive element 504 and the second conductive element 506. At maximum current, heat transfer through the temperature control device 500 is at its greatest.



FIG. 5D illustrates the temperature control device 500, according to one embodiment. The controller 520 reduces the current provided to the electromagnet 508 to decrease the rate of heat transfer through the temperature control device 100. To reduce alignment of the particles 518 in the MR fluid 516, the controller 520 reduces the current I1 in conjunction with providing a current I2 to the second electromagnet 510. The controller 520 provides the current I2 to the second electromagnet 510 to generate a magnetic field substantially perpendicular to the magnetic field generated by the electromagnet.



FIG. 6 illustrates an enlarged view of the container 502 with both the first and second magnetic fields provided through the container 502. The second magnetic field 604 contains magnetic flux lines 606. The magnetic flux lines 606 are substantially perpendicular to the magnetic flux lines 602.


Referring back to FIG. 5D, the current I2 may be pulsed to the second electromagnet 510 during a gap in the current I1 provided to the electromagnet 508. Pulsing the current I2 forces some or most of the particles 518 in the MR fluid 516 out of alignment from the chains 524. The decrease in current I1 provided to the electromagnet 508 continues to move the particles 518 to a lesser state of alignment. When the current I1 provided to the electromagnet 508 is zero, the particles 518 in the MR fluid 516 will align with the magnetic flux lines 606, to form chains 528. The chains 528 conductively uncouple the first conductive element 504 from the second conductive element 506. Heat transfer through the temperature control device 500 is thus decreased. For example, heat transfer through the temperature control device 500 may be reduced by 50%.



FIG. 7 illustrates a method 700 of controlling heat transfer through a temperature control device, such as the temperature control device 500 as illustrated in FIGS. 5A-5D. The method 700 begins at block 702. At block 702, the controller provides a first current to an electromagnet. The electromagnet is disposed about a container holding MR fluid. The electromagnet generates a magnetic field about the container. A first conductive element is positioned on a first end of the container. A second conductive element is positioned on a second end of the container. When the magnetic field is generated, magnetic particles in the MR fluid align themselves with the magnetic flux lines of the magnetic field. The alignment of the particles in the MR fluid creates a plurality of chains. The plurality of chains in the MR fluid conductively coupled the first conductive element to the second conductive element. As such, heat may be transferred through the temperature control device. The amount of heat transfer may be controlled by adjusting the current provided to the electromagnet.


At block 704, the controller provides a second current to a second electromagnet. The second electromagnet is disposed perpendicular to the first electromagnet. The second electromagnet generates a second magnetic field. The second magnetic field is perpendicular to the first magnetic field. To reduce the amount of heat transfer through the temperature control device, the second current is pulsed to the second electromagnet during a gap in the first current provided to the first electromagnet. The pulsing of the current forces most of the particles in the plurality of chains out of alignment. The first current provided to the first electromagnet is decreased to continue to move the particles to a lesser state of alignment. The first conductive element is conductively uncoupled from the second conductive element when the first current goes to zero, and the plurality of particles for a plurality of horizontal chains, aligning with the magnetic flux lines of the second magnetic field.


Blocks 702-704 may be repeated to vary the amount of heat transferred through the temperature control device.


EXAMPLE

An example using the temperature control device 100 of FIGS. 1A-1C is disclosed herein. The temperature control device is used to control the heat transfer between a central processing unit (CPU) heat sink connected to a heat sink on a Peripheral Component Interconnect Express (PCIe). The temperature control device may be connected between the CPU heat sink and the PCIe. When the CPU is being used at full capacity and the PCIe is not being used, the full volume of the heat sink connected to the PCIe is not being used. It is desirable for the CPU to use the extra surface area of the PCIe heat sink while the PCIe is not being used.


The temperature control device allows the CPU to use the extra surface area of the PCIe heat sink by transferring heat from the CPU heat sink to the PCIe heat sink. For example, the CPU heat sink may be coupled to the third conductive element of the temperature control device and the PCIe heat sink may be connected to the fourth conductive element of the temperature control device. When it is desirable to use the extra surface area of PCIe heat sink, the first power source provides a first current to the electromagnet. The electromagnet then generates a magnetic field, which influences the first and second biasing elements to bias the first and second conductive elements towards the first and second ends of the container holding MR fluid. The particles in the MR fluid align with the magnetic flux lines of the magnetic field to form chains of particles. The chains conductively couple the first conductive element to the second conductive element so that heat may transfer through the temperature control device. Thus, the heat generated by the CPU can be transferred to the PCIe heat sink to utilize the extra surface area of the PCIe heat sink.


When the PCIe card usage is increased, the amount of heat transferred from the CPU to the PCIe heat sink may be decreased. To decrease the amount of heat transferred, the current provided to the electromagnet may be reduced to decrease the number of chains of particles formed in the MR fluid and to expand the container of MR fluid. By alternating between increasing and decreasing the current provided to the electromagnet, the user may more effectively control the heat transfer from both the CPU heat sink to the PCIe heat sink and back from the PCIe heat sink to the CPU heat sink.


While the foregoing is directed to embodiments of the present invention, other and further embodiments of the invention may be devised without departing from the basic scope thereof, and the scope thereof is determined by the claims that follow.

Claims
  • 1. A method, the method comprising: biasing, using an electromagnet, a first conductive element against a first end of a container and a second conductive element against a second end of the container to align particles in a magnetorheological fluid in the container such that the first conductive element is conductively coupled to the second conductive element; andbiasing, using the electromagnet, the first conductive element away from the first end of the container and the second conductive element away from the second end of the container so that the first conductive element is not conductively coupled to the second conductive element.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, wherein flowing a current through the electromagnet disposed about the container induces stress in a first biasing element to bias the first conductive element and in a second biasing element to bias the second conductive element.
  • 3. The method of claim 2, wherein reducing the current through the electromagnet relaxes the first biasing element to bias the first conductive element away from the first end of the container and relaxes the second biasing element to bias the second conductive element away from the second end of the container.
  • 4. The method of claim 1, wherein the container is flexible such that biasing the first conductive element against the first end of the container and the second conductive element against the second end of the container constricts the container.
  • 5. The method of claim 4, wherein constricting the container results in the alignment of the particles in the magnetorheological fluid.
  • 6. The method of claim 1, wherein flowing a current through the electromagnet generates a magnetic field parallel to the container.
  • 7. The method of claim 1, further comprising: reducing a current flowing through the electromagnet to bias the first and second conductive elements when a maximum current input is reached.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/833,240, filed Aug. 24, 2015, which is a continuation of co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/818,722, filed Aug. 5, 2015, which is related to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/818,733, titled “Controllable Magnetorheological Fluid Temperature Control Device”, filed Aug. 5, 2015. The aforementioned related patent applications are herein incorporated by reference in their entirety.

US Referenced Citations (28)
Number Name Date Kind
1731664 Hudd Oct 1929 A
3006611 Isham Oct 1961 A
5138973 Davis et al. Aug 1992 A
5165242 Chang Nov 1992 A
5247800 Mruzek et al. Sep 1993 A
5248636 Davis et al. Sep 1993 A
7628198 Ouyang Dec 2009 B2
7861769 Ouyang Jan 2011 B2
7886816 Ouyang Feb 2011 B2
8011424 Murray Sep 2011 B2
8336611 Ouyang Dec 2012 B2
8730674 Dede et al. May 2014 B2
9952006 Barron Apr 2018 B2
9964365 Barron May 2018 B2
20030020463 Carlson et al. Jan 2003 A1
20030041600 van den Berg et al. Mar 2003 A1
20040210289 Wang et al. Oct 2004 A1
20050079132 Wang et al. Apr 2005 A1
20060081413 Minto Apr 2006 A1
20060210410 Mokler Sep 2006 A1
20090218087 Oshima Sep 2009 A1
20090277608 Kamins et al. Nov 2009 A1
20110297394 VanDelden Dec 2011 A1
20140208731 Shepherd et al. Jul 2014 A1
20170038102 Barron et al. Feb 2017 A1
20170038164 Barron et al. Feb 2017 A1
20170038165 Barron et al. Feb 2017 A1
20170038166 Barron et al. Feb 2017 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
101726212 Jun 2010 CN
101726212 Jun 2010 CN
H05248788 Sep 1993 JP
3082195 Aug 2000 JP
2003-232596 Aug 2003 JP
2013-245840 Dec 2013 JP
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
List of IBM Patents or Applications Treated as Related.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20180106560 A1 Apr 2018 US
Continuations (2)
Number Date Country
Parent 14833240 Aug 2015 US
Child 15820526 US
Parent 14818722 Aug 2015 US
Child 14833240 US