The present disclosure relates generally to containers used in a Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP)ing systems for consolidating wastes, such as radioactive wastes. The present disclosure also relates to methods of consolidating such wastes by using containers that have controlled collapse characteristics.
Use of metal containers for Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP)ing of metal powders is common industry practice. The HIP containers are either regular shapes such as a cylinder or more complex where they are the shape of the final product only larger to accommodate the shrinkage from going from a metal powder to a final dense product. When dealing with non-radioactive materials, the particle size and shape of metal powders can be finely controlled during their manufacture to give high packing densities when being filled into the metal HIP containers. As a result, the HIP container collapses are usually only of the order of 30-40%, which leads to a symmetric and controlled collapse that can be consistently predicted. As a result, when working with metal powders and non-radioactive materials, it is conceivable to model HIP container collapse to prevent container distortion.
With the application of HIP technology to treatment of radioactive waste; however, the same control of the starting product is not possible. The powder properties such as particle size and shape are largely unpredictable. It is not unusual that packing densities can be as low as 15-25% of the theoretical final density, leading to possible volume reductions of 75% or more. Additionally, the chemistry of the radioactive waste forms is highly variable. As a result, modeling and predicting HIP container collapse is neither practical nor viable for a wide range of wastes, including radioactive material, where powder characterization is difficult, if not impossible.
Coupled with the foregoing limitations of the collapse characteristics of the HIP container are the problems associated with the material being processed. As the powdered waste fills the HIP container, at a lower density than the theoretical final density, the difference in the starting density to the final density means the container shrinkage (volume change) will need to be accommodated.
To solve the foregoing problems associated with variations in the starting fill densities due to packing efficiency or different powder morphology, the amount of shrinkage and therefore final container dimensions will be different. The Inventor has developed a HIP container that will collapse to the same diameter every time irrespective of the starting packing density of the powder. The height may vary slightly but well within the tolerances of the over-pack disposal canister. The Inventor has also developed a predictable method of consolidating waste, including nuclear waste, using the disclosed HIP container. The disclosed container and method are directed to overcoming one or more of the problems set forth above and/or other problems of the prior art.
In one embodiment, there is disclosed a container for the consolidation of waste material, such as nuclear containing waste, comprising: an outer cylinder; and an inner cylinder comprising internal compression plates that are configured to resist collapse during consolidation. The described container enables one to control the size of the consolidated container to a predictable shape and dimension upon hot isostatic pressing. As indicated, the container may be one that is sufficient to hold and consolidate a variety of toxic, hazardous, or radioactive liquid or powered waste materials without the release of radioactivity.
In another embodiment there is disclosed a method of producing a consolidated article. In an embodiment, the method comprises filling a container with material to be consolidated, the container comprising an outer cylinder; and an inner cylinder comprising internal compression plates that are configured to resist collapse during consolidation. In an embodiment, the method comprises collapsing the container by applying heat and/or pressure to consolidate the material in the container and to produce a consolidated article having a predictable shape and/or dimension.
Aside from the subject matter discussed above, the present disclosure includes a number of other features such as those explained hereinafter. Both the foregoing description and the following description are exemplary only.
The accompanying figures are incorporated in, and constitute a part of this specification.
It has been demonstrated that the new HIP-Container overcomes a number of key issues raised with the prior art. With reference to
As stated above, with radioactive ceramic and glass ceramic waste forms, this is not possible since it would require wall thickness of the container of 4″ or more to prevent buckling. As a result, the approach for radioactive wastes has been to design HIP container that allows for large volume changes, two approaches have been taken. These have been referred to as the “bellows” design (see
The bellows design for HIPing compacts is based on the expectation that the container collapse is predominately axial and therefore more predictable in terms of the final diameter. However, the detrimental and potential risks are related to pinhole failure of the HIP container. Pinhole failure of the container is where a defect in either the metal container or in a weld (more likely), allows high pressure gas to enter the container and then as the heating of the container and contents occur the pinhole either closes up entirely or reduces. At the end of the HIP cycle peak temperature and pressure hold points the pressure is reduced along with the temperature. The rate at which the gas vents from the pressure vessel will be higher than the rate it can escape from the container and if the hole is sealed it cannot escape at all. The resulting pressure differential causes the container to expand, this expansion can cause damage to the furnace and in extreme cases potential damage the pressure vessel.
Alternatively, the “dumb-bell” design reduces the amount of expansion on pinhole failure but does not eliminate it. In addition, the final size is highly variable depending on the starting packing density of the contents. The height to diameter ratios of the final shape can vary significantly depending on the material being processed. Furthermore, the “dumb-bell” shape undergoes significant distortion or buckling of the canister walls during consolidation. This variability makes it difficult to optimize the filling of the over-pack as these tend to be a fixed size for transportation and disposal. For example, if a HIP container is oversized it will not fit in the internal diameter of the disposal over-pack container, leading to the need for an alternative container for disposal which may be difficult or costly.
Alternatively, if the final HIPed container is considerably smaller it will not be efficiently packed in the over-pack container, which can increase the cost of disposal with more over-packs required. The other approach is to allow for the starting size of the HIP container to fit into the “over-pack” thus assuming worst case and no shrinkage occurs. This leads to the benefits of volume reduction by the HIP process for radioactive waste being negated for final disposal.
Unlike the prior art, the disclosed HIP container is designed to collapse to a predetermined size or within a dimensional window that allows for efficient packing of the disposal over-pack. One benefit of this design is that it allows the final shape of a HIPed radioactive waste-form block to be a right cylinder so that it can be inserted into a cylindrical “over-pack” disposal canister. For example, in the U.S. these canisters are typically two (2) feet diameter×ten (10) feet (or 15 feet) long. If the ideal final shape of a product is a right cylinder, and the metal powder was non-radioactive, one would start with a right cylinder and then be able to calculate shrinkage and the metal container wall thickness to prevent distortion.
In an embodiment, there is described a container for the consolidation of material under elevated pressure and temperature conditions. As used herein, “under elevated pressure and temperature conditions” means above standard pressure and temperature conditions, such as by hot-isostatic pressing. For example, in one embodiment, such conditions include temperatures ranging from 800 to 1400° C., such as 1000 to 1250° C., pressures ranging from 10 to 300 MPa, such as 50 to 200 MPa, for a time ranging from 8 to 14 hours, such as 10 to 12 hours. A more detailed description of HIP conditions that can be used herein is provided in U.S. Pat. No. 8,754,282, which is herein incorporated by reference in its entirety.
In an embodiment, the container may comprise an outer cylinder and an inner cylinder comprising internal compression plates that are configured to resist collapse. In an embodiment, these compression plates are configured to resist collapsing during consolidation by arranging the plates in rows and with predetermined spacing, axially, radially, or both.
While the container described herein can be used to consolidate any type of material, in various embodiments the material comprises solid or liquid hazardous, toxic, or radioactive waste, and the container is configured to hold such waste without releasing it to the environment. In one embodiment, the material comprises a solid waste, such as a particulate material comprising hazardous, toxic, or radioactive materials.
In an embodiment, the material to be consolidated comprises liquid waste, including but not limited to spent fuel pond sludge, a radioactive sludges, or other toxic sludges or slurries. The described solid or liquid materials may comprise at least one element typically found in the foregoing wastes, such as magnesium, plutonium, aluminum, graphite, uranium, and other nuclear power plant decommissioning wastes, zeolitic materials, and contaminated soils.
In an embodiment, the inner and outer cylinders are made from a metal comprising steel, nickel, titanium, aluminum, copper, alloys thereof, or combinations thereof. In an embodiment, the inner cylinder has at least one different characteristic from the outer cylinder. For example, the different characteristic may comprise one or more of malleability, corrosion resistance, or wall thickness. In an embodiment the outer cylinder has a wall thickness that is thicker than the inner cylinder.
In an embodiment the inner cylinder comprises a layer that is chemically reactive with the material located in the container. For example, the layer may comprise titanium in an amount sufficient to (i) react with oxygen that degases from the waste material being consolidated, (ii) control the redox of the powdered waste material, or (iii) combinations thereof.
In an embodiment the internal compression plates comprise a material that has a higher strength than the inner cylinder, the outer cylinder, or both, such that it resists collapse and deformation under hot isostatic pressing conditions, wherein the material comprises a metal, ceramic, graphite or combinations thereof.
In an embodiment the internal compression plates are curved to match the radius of the inner and outer container and are positioned between the inner and outer cylinders.
In an embodiment the internal compression plates are configured to touch at least one other compression plate during hot isostatic pressing. For example, the internal compression plates may comprise right angled edges. In the same or another embodiment, the internal compression plates have angled or recessed edges to cause interlocking or guide the plates to slide over each other during hot isostatic pressing.
In an embodiment the container described herein may comprise a liner configured around the compression plates that help lock the plates into position.
There is also disclosed a method of producing a consolidated article using the container described herein. For example, in an embodiment, the method comprises filling a container with material to be consolidated, such as hazardous, toxic, or radioactive waste. As previously described, this method uses a container comprising: an outer cylinder; an inner cylinder comprising internal compression plates that are configured to resist collapse during consolidation. The method may further comprise collapsing the by applying heat and/or pressure to the container, such as by hot isostatic pressing.
During the consolidation step the internal compression plates cause the container to collapse in a predictable manner while consolidating the material in the container to produce a consolidated article having a predictable shape and/or dimension. As used herein, “having a predictable shape and/or dimension” means, inter alia, that the consolidated article has straight walls that allow the HIPed can to be more readily inserted into a disposal canister.
In an embodiment, the method further comprising evacuating and sealing the container prior to consolidating.
In an embodiment, the method further comprises configuring the plates to resist collapse during consolidation are lined up in rows and with predetermined spacing both axially and radially.
In an embodiment, the configuring comprises positioning the compression plates between the inner and outer cylinders.
In an embodiment, the method further comprises reacting the material to be consolidated with at least one material located on or within the inner cylinder. For example, the method of reacting comprises (i) reacting with oxygen that degases from the waste material being consolidated, (ii) controlling the redox of the powdered waste material, or (iii) combinations thereof.
The disclosed elements of this design are configured to include an outer and inner cylinder, with inner plates lined up in rows and with predetermined spacing both axially and radially, as shown in
In one embodiment, the inner and outer shells are made from metal such as stainless steel, nickel, titanium, mild steel, aluminum, copper or other. They may be the same composition or different to each other depending on potential intent or function. For example, the inner layer may serve to be more or less reactive with the composition of the contents, such as being made from titanium to react with any excess oxygen or to control the redox of the calcine/powdered contents. The outer may be made of a more malleable alloy to allow for greater deformation or of a metal to be more corrosion resistant such as stainless steel.
In one embodiment, the outer layer will generally be of thicker wall thickness than the inner liner as it is the primary structural member of the container and its function is to maintain its shape during handling and filling of the HIP container. The thick outer wall will also resist buckling or creasing as has been observed in the commercially available HIP containers. After the hot isostatic pressing the container will be still a right cylinder with minimal buckling and creasing. This will lead to a number of benefits, including: symmetrical shape for ease of handling and loading into over-pack for disposal; and minimal creasing/buckling, which will allow for ease of external cleaning and decontamination if required.
In an embodiment, consolidating a HIPed can that has straight walls, as described throughout this disclosure, allows the HIPed can to more easily be inserted into a disposal canister. There is also disclosed an embodiment in which the outer HIP canister can be engineered such that the outer can becomes the final disposal canister. In this embodiment, the outer can wall can be engineered such that outer walls remain straight and because the high integrity of the can, the can becomes the disposal canister. This embodiment would negate the need for it to be overpacked into a disposal canister, unlike a thin walled can such as a bellows or Dumbbell, described above, that will not have the durability or the structural integrity to be considered a disposal canister.
The internal compression plates will typically be made of a higher strength material that resists collapse and deformation under HIP compression conditions. The compression plates can be curved to match the radius of the inner and outer cylinder. In one embodiment, they can be made from a metal, light weight ceramic, graphite or combinations of these.
In one embodiment, the internal compression plates are sandwiched between the inner and outer shells. Their position can be arranged either by welding, adhering or using a mesh to align and locate their position. This maintains the spatial arrangement during fabrication. In one embodiment, the assembly is put together resulting in the layered construction shown in
The HIP container according to the present disclosure is designed so that when the compression plates touch during the shrinkage of the main body of the container during the HIP cycle, they will resist any further collapse and therefore control the size of the HIP container to a predictable shape and dimension. A representation of this is shown in
In various embodiment, the compression plates may either have right angled edges so that when they touch they butt up to each other or they may be angled or recessed so as to cause interlocking or guidance to slide over each other in a prescribed way.
Variants: Hydroforming Variant
Taking the fabrication method described above, once assembled a hydrostatic pressure can be applied to the inner liner. In one embodiment, this hydrostatic pressure will cause the liner to form around the compression plates helping to lock the plates into position. As the liner is comparatively thin in relation to the outer liner, the pressure applied is such it will only cause the inner liner to form around the plates. The benefit of this design is to provide initiation points that allow the deformation of the inner liner, both in the axial and radial directions.
In an embodiment, the liner hydrostatically formed in situ to conform to the plates is shown in
Alternatively, the hydrostatic pressure can be applied to both sides of the inner and outer shells causing them to mold around the plates. This may provide some benefit in some circumstances to initiate the shrinkage of the container during HIPing.
In one embodiment, the HIP container may comprise a “dumbbell-shape,” but further comprising inner and outer shell plates that are placed at regular spacing's around the diameter. In one embodiment, the inner and outer shell plates that are placed around the diameter of the dumbbell container as a continuous ring.
Casting Variant
In another embodiment, the outer liner and compression plates are not made using the previously described hydroforming technique but via casting. The casting of outer liner and compression plates as one unit has several advantages over the methods described above. One such advantage is it removes the need to locate the compression plates in array before inserting an inner liner. A disadvantage is that the plates and the outer are limited to the same material.
Also, it may be possible to cast in either the base or the top lid, or both. The casting in both lids would preclude the use of the inner liner but this may not be needed for all waste types.
Regardless of how they are made, in various embodiments, the internal compression plates described herein can be configured to match the shape of the container. For example,
Variant of Pressure Relief:
As previously noted, one limitation of the commercially available HIP containers described in the prior art is related to entrapped gas. The trapping of gas inside a HIP-container could lead to uncontrolled expansion, and as shown in the example of the bellows HIP container, have catastrophic failure. To avoid such a problem, there is disclosed a pressure relief system that can be incorporated into the body of the HIP container. It is desired that the pressure relief system will allow gas to escape, but will not lead to release of the radioactive contents.
In one embodiment, the pressure relief system described herein would take the form of a sintered metal or ceramic filter covered by thin metallic or ceramic membrane. The porous sintered filter will face the inside of the HIP container and the membrane will be on the outside face of the container. In filling and evacuating the HIP container the membrane provides a seal supported by the underlying porous filter. During HIPing process if gas is present, the membrane will prevent the porous metal or ceramic filter from collapsing. In addition, if the pressure rises above the design pressure of the membrane, the membrane will rupture thereby releasing the excessive gas. In one embodiment, the rupture pressure will be designed so as to prevent any deformation of the HIP container. In addition, the filter will prevent the escape of any radioactive particulate material into the HIP.
If no gas is present inside the HIP container described herein, the sintered metal or ceramic filter can be chosen so that it will densify to form a solid plug. In another embodiment, rather than selecting a material that will densify at the HIP conditions used, the material may be specifically selected not to densify at the HIPing pressure and temperature.
It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications and variations can be made to the disclosed alloy and method of forming the alloy into a finished part without departing from the scope of the disclosure. Alternative implementations will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice disclosed herein. It is intended that the specification and examples be considered as exemplary only, with a true scope of the disclosure being indicated by the following claims and their equivalents.
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/424,042, filed on Nov. 18, 2016, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4834917 | Ramm | May 1989 | A |
20140221720 | Moricca | Aug 2014 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190198185 A1 | Jun 2019 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62424042 | Nov 2016 | US |