Controlling gas discharge lamp intensity with power regulation and end of life protection

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6232727
  • Patent Number
    6,232,727
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, October 7, 1998
    26 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 15, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A method and apparatus for controlling the operation of a gas discharge lamp including regulation of power provided to the lamp for maintaining a preselected illumination intensity, automatic lamp shut down for preventing a catastrophic failure of the lamp, and automatic selection of operating frequencies for increasing efficiency and extending useful life of the lamp. An appropriate quality factor Q is achieved by including a low pass filter followed by a high pass filter in the lamp network so as to allow deep dimming of the lamp. Preferably, the arc power delivered to the lamp network is sensed and regulated. By sensing the arc power instead of only the lamp current, the illumination intensity of the lamp is accurately regulated. Further, the lamp ballast is automatically shut down near the end of the lamp's useful life, before operation in partial rectification. Preferably, power to the lamp is shut off based on the arc power entering the lamp network instead of relying only on the voltage of the lamp to avoid unnecessarily shutting down the lamp. The lamp network is automatically operated at an appropriate frequency selected from among a plurality of predetermined frequencies according to the lamp's present mode of operation including: preheating, starting, and continuous operation. Preferably, each frequency is optimized for the particular lamp and for the particular mode of operation.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The invention relates to the field of control circuits for gas discharge lamps. In particular, the invention relates to control circuits for gas discharge lamps that monitor and regulate the power provided to the gas discharge lamps.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Gas discharge lamps, such as conventional fluorescent lamps, offer substantial improvements over incandescent lamps, including higher energy efficiency and longer life. A drawback to fluorescent lamps, however, is that they can be difficult to control. This is due, in part, because they have “negative resistance.” This means that the operating voltage decreases as current through the lamp increases. Therefore, circuits for supplying power to fluorescent lamps generally require a electronic ballast to maintain operating stability of the circuit and to provide an ability to dim the lamp.




During a typical manufacturing process for gas discharge lamps, the lamps are optimized to provide a maximum light output with a minimum amount of energy consumption. Different capacity gas discharge lamps having different lumen outputs are each designed for a different optimum voltage level. The benefits of high energy efficiency and long lamp life require that the ballast provide the gas discharge lamp with the optimum lamp voltage and which appropriately control the current for adjusting the light output of the lamp.




A conventional non-adjustable ballast provides a fixed lamp voltage and lamp current for a lamp with a specific lumen output. As a gas discharge lamp ages, however, the lamp deteriorates which causes the impedance of the lamp to increase. When such a lamp is operated with a non-adjustable ballast, this deterioration causes the lamp output to become increasingly dim over time. Accordingly, even though the non-adjustable ballast is initially optimized for the particular lamp, over time, the lamp output becomes increasingly dim and efficiency decreases.




A prior alternative to a conventional non-adjustable ballast is an adjustable fixed ballast. The adjustable fixed ballast allows the lamp current and lamp voltage to be adjusted by the user in an attempt to optimize a particular gas discharge lamp for a specific light output intensity. This allows gas discharge lamps of different capacities to be used in conjunction with identical ballasts. However, as stated above, the impedance of gas discharge lamps increases over time. Thus, over time, the gas discharge lamp will produce an increasingly dimmer light output and efficiency decreases. Therefore, optimization will be lost unless the user re-adjusts the ballast.




An approach to some of the problems associated with an adjustable fixed ballast is an electronic self-adjusting ballast. A common technique by which such a self-adjusting ballast regulates a gas discharge lamp is by sensing and controlling the current in the lamp. One problem with regulating only the lamp current is that the light output of the lamp is more closely related to the arc power of the lamp than to the lamp current. The arc power is equal to the product of lamp current and lamp voltage. Lamp voltage, however, is dependent on the temperature of the lamp. Therefore, if only current is regulated, the arc power and, hence, light output, will vary with the temperature of the lamp.




Another problem associated with gas discharge lamps is safety. When the gas discharge lamp is near the end of its useful life, the gas discharge lamp can continue to operate in a condition of partial rectification. When operating in partial rectification, there is a high cathode fall voltage in the region of a depleted cathode. Accordingly, operation in partial rectification causes excessively high power dissipation in the region of the depleted cathode. Further, when only lamp current is regulated, increases in the impedance of the lamp caused by aging results in increased power dissipation. As a result of these factors, portions of the gas discharge lamp can reach excessive temperatures. This can present a dangerous fire hazard and can cause the glass envelope of the lamp to shatter. This can pose an immediate safety hazard for persons in the vicinity of the lamp.




Although gas discharge lamps tend to be more efficient than their incandescent counterparts, it is advantageous for gas discharge lamps to operate in a dimmed mode. By operating in a dimmed mode, the light intensity from the gas discharge lamp can be adjusted according to the needs or tastes of the user. Unfortunately, prior control circuits for gas discharge lamps, especially small diameter lamps such as the T


4


, generally cannot operate in a dimmed mode below approximately 40% of the lamps' rated illumination output without the lamp extinguishing itself or flickering excessively.




A prior art electronic ballast and network for gas discharge lamps is described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,315,214 and shown in FIG.


1


.

FIG. 1

illustrates a prior art circuit which controls the illumination intensity of the lamp by controlling the current passing through the lamp. This prior art circuit also shuts off the lamp circuit when the lamp voltage exceeds a preselected threshold. Further, this prior art circuit utilizes a low pass filter at the output lamp network to allow the lamp to be dimmed. These features of operating of the circuit shown in

FIG. 1

are disadvantages for the following reasons. Because the lamp current remains constant, the illumination intensity of the lamp will vary with impedance changes caused by aging of the lamp. Further, by sensing lamp voltage to determine when to shut down, in the case of a removed or unlit lamp, this prior art lamp circuit does not protect the lamp from circumstances when the lamp current remains constant and the lamp voltage rises thus causing excess power to dissipate into the lamp. Finally, this prior art lamp circuit does not allow the lamp, especially a small diameter lamp such as the T


4


, to be dimmed below approximately 40% without extinguishing itself or excessively flickering because of a high quality factor Q lamp network.




Therefore, what is needed is a control circuit for a gas discharge lamp that overcomes these disadvantages.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is a method and apparatus for controlling the operation of a gas discharge lamp including regulation of power provided to the lamp for maintaining a preselected illumination intensity, automatic lamp shut down for preventing a catastrophic failure of the lamp, and automatic selection of operating frequencies for increasing efficiency and extending useful life of the lamp. The invention also provides an appropriate quality factor Q for the lamp network so as to allow the lamp to be dimmed to low levels, referred to as “deep dimming” or “architectural dimming,” while maintaining operation of the lamp. An example of a gas discharge lamp is a commercially available fluorescent lamp commonly used in office, factory and commercial retail settings.




Preferably, the present invention measures the arc power delivered to the lamp network and regulates the power received by the lamp. By sensing the arc power instead of only the lamp current, the present invention accurately regulates the illumination intensity of the lamp. This is true despite the impedance of the lamp changing due to aging and despite the lamp voltage being affected by temperature changes. Further, the present invention preferably also automatically shuts down the lamp ballast near the end of the lamp's useful life and before operation in partial rectification occurs. Preferably, power to the lamp is shut off based on the arc power entering the lamp network instead of relying only on the voltage of the lamp. This avoids unnecessarily shutting down the lamp.




In addition, the present invention also automatically operates the lamp network at an appropriate frequency selected from among a plurality of predetermined frequencies. The appropriate frequency is selected according to the lamp's present mode of operation including: preheating, starting, and continuous operation. Preferably, each frequency is optimized for the particular lamp and for the particular mode of operation.




Further, the preferred embodiment of the present invention includes a lamp network that has a low pass filter followed by a high pass filter coupled to the lamp in series. As the lamp is dimmed, the lamp goes into a region of high negative resistance and is more prone to being extinguished or excessively flickering. This configuration of the lamp network results in a lower the quality factor Q and allows the lamp to continue operation during deep dimming.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

illustrates a prior art schematic diagram showing an electronic ballast controller integrated circuit.





FIG. 2

illustrates a first embodiment of the present invention showing a circuit for regulating power received by a gas discharge lamp to maintain a constant illumination and for shutting down the lamp before partial rectification occurs based on power received by the lamp.





FIG. 3

illustrates a second embodiment of the present invention showing a circuit for regulating current received by a gas discharge lamp to maintain a constant illumination and for shutting down the lamp before partial rectification occurs based on power received by the lamp.





FIG. 4A

illustrates a preferred embodiment of the present invention showing a first portion of a circuit for regulating power received by a gas discharge lamp to maintain a constant illumination, dimming the lamp to a low level, shutting down the lamp before partial rectification occurs, and selecting a proper operating frequency.





FIG. 4B

illustrates a preferred embodiment of the present invention showing a second portion of the circuit referenced in FIG.


4


A.





FIG. 5

illustrates a timing chart showing three different phases of operation for the preferred embodiment.





FIG. 6

illustrates the equivalent circuit of the lamp network shown in the preferred embodiment of FIG.


4


B.





FIG. 7

shows the equivalent circuit shown in the lamp network of FIG.


6


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT





FIG. 2

illustrates a first embodiment of a power regulating circuit according to the present invention which controls a level of power provided to a gas discharge lamp


290


for controlling an illumination intensity of the lamp


290


. The level of power provided to the lamp


290


is sensed by providing a regulated voltage to a lamp network


300


and by sensing current leaving the lamp network


300


. The power provided to the lamp network


300


is controlled by adjusting a switching frequency of an inverter which comprises switches


310


and


320


. Further, the power regulating circuit illustrated in

FIG. 2

automatically shuts off power to the lamp


290


near the end of the useful life of the lamp


290


so as to avoid a potentially dangerous catastrophic failure of the lamp


290


. This accomplished by disabling a power factor correction circuit (PFC)


200


when regulation of the power provided to the lamp fails to prevent the power from exceeding a predetermined level. These features of power regulation and automatic shutoff are not affected by variations in the temperature of the lamp


290


.




In

FIG. 2

, the PFC circuit


200


has two output terminals across which a regulated direct-current voltage VDC


1


is provided for supplying the lamp network


300


and the lamp


290


with power. The voltage VDC


1


is preferably between 380 and 460 volts. An AC power source (not shown) supplies power to the PFC circuit


200


. A first output terminal of the PFC circuit


200


is coupled to a first terminal of the switch


310


. A second terminal of the switch


310


is coupled to an input terminal of the lamp network


300


and to a first terminal of the switch


320


. A second terminal of the switch


320


is coupled to a first terminal of a resistor


210


and to a first terminal of a resistor


220


, thereby forming a node N


1


. A second terminal of the resistor


210


is coupled to a second output terminal of the PFC circuit


200


and to a ground node. A second terminal of the resistor


220


is coupled to a positive terminal of a capacitor


230


, to a positive input terminal of a comparator


240


and to a negative input of an amplifier


270


, thereby forming a node N


2


. A negative terminal of the capacitor


230


is coupled to the ground node.




The lamp network


300


has two output terminals. A first output terminal of the lamp network


300


is coupled to a first terminal of the lamp


290


. Additionally, a second output terminal of the lamp network


300


is coupled to a second terminal of the lamp


290


.




As mentioned, the present invention senses the current received by the lamp network


300


for regulating a level of power provided to the lamp


290


and for providing automatic shut off of power to the lamp


290


when the lamp


290


reaches the end of its useful life. Because the voltage VDC


1


is regulated, the current from the lamp network


300


which flows through the resistor


210


, is representative of a level of power provided to the lamp network


300


.




Accordingly, a voltage V


N1


developed across the resistor


210


at the node N


1


is representative of the level of instantaneous power provided to the lamp network


300


. The voltage V


N1


, however, is affected by the present condition of the switches


310


and


320


.




In combination, the capacitor


230


and the resistor


220


form a low pass filter such that the resulting voltage V


N2


at the node N


2


represents the average value or DC value of the voltage at the node N


1


. Accordingly, the voltage V


N2


is representative of the level of power provided to the lamp network


300


averaged over several cycles of the switches


310


and


320


(i.e. power delivered to the lamp=VDC


1


*V


N2


/R


210


).




A user-adjustable attenuator


260


is coupled to a positive terminal of the amplifier


270


.




The attenuator


260


preferably provides a voltage in a range from 0 to 10 volts. As explained herein, adjustment of the voltage provided to the amplifier


270


by the attenuator


260


adjusts the illumination intensity of the lamp


290


.




An output from the amplifier


270


is coupled to an input terminal of a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO)


280


. The VCO


280


has two output terminals, OUTA and {overscore (OUTA)}.




A first output terminal OUTA of the VCO


280


is coupled to control the switch


310


. A second output terminal {overscore (OUTA)} of the VCO


280


is coupled to control the switch


320


. The voltage levels at the terminals OUTA and {overscore (OUTA)} are complementary in that one, and only one, of the switches


310


and


320


is on (closed) at any one time while the other is off (open).




The power provided to the lamp network


300


is regulated according the frequency at which the VCO


280


operates the switches


310


and


320


. More particularly, the power is inversely related to the frequency over a certain range of frequencies. The frequency of the VCO


280


is controlled according to a difference between the voltage level V


N2


at the node N


2


and a voltage provided by the attenuator


260


. Further, a feedback loop is formed by the amplifier


270


, the voltage controlled oscillator


280


, and the switches


310


and


320


for regulating the voltage V


N2


at the node N


2


. Thus, by controlling the voltage at the node N


2


in a feedback loop, the power provided to the lamp


290


is controlled such that the user selected illumination intensity output for the lamp


290


is maintained despite variations in temperature of the lamp or impedance changes caused by aging.




A negative input terminal of the comparator


240


is biased to a predetermined threshold voltage VTH


1


. An output terminal of the comparator


240


is coupled to set input terminal S of an RS flip flop


250


. An output terminal Q of the RS flip flop


250


is coupled to a disable switching in the PFC circuit


200


and the VCO


280


thereby disabling the PFC circuit


200


and the VCO


280


. A reset input R on the RS flip flop


250


is coupled to an under-voltage (UV) signal for re-setting the flip flop


250


. The RS flip flop


250


delivers lamp shut off signal DISABLE


1


to the PFC


200


and the VCO


280


when the voltage at the positive terminal of the comparator


240


exceeds the predetermined threshold voltage VTH


1


.




These elements of the present invention automatically shut off the lamp


290


when the lamp nears the end of its useful life. For example, operation in partial rectification can trigger shut down of the lamp


290


. To implement this function, the DC voltage at the node N


2


is supplied to the comparator


240


. When the voltage V


N2


at the node N


2


exceeds the predefined threshold voltage VTH


1


, this indicates that the power provided to the lamp


290


can no longer controlled to an appropriate level due to deterioration of the lamp


290


. Accordingly, the comparator


240


sets the RS flip flop


250


, which in turn deactivates the PFC


200


and the VCO


280


, thereby shutting off power to the lamp


290


. The predefined threshold voltage VTH


1


is preferably set at a level higher than a typical, normal voltage at the node N


2


during safe operation of the lamp


290


such that the comparator


240


provides the signal to shut off power to the lamp


290


only when the voltage at the node N


2


reaches unsafe levels.




In the preferred embodiment, the output terminal Q of the RS flip flop


250


disables the PFC


200


and the VCO


280


by disabling a clock signal (not shown) utilized for controlling switching in the PFC circuit


200


and the VCO


280


. When the PFC


200


and the VCO


280


are shut down, the voltage VDC


1


falls to low level and little or no power is supplied to the lamp network


300


or to the lamp


290


.





FIG. 3

illustrates a second embodiment of a power regulating circuit according to the present invention which controls a level of power provided to a gas discharge lamp


510


for controlling an illumination intensity of the lamp


510


. This feature of power regulation is accomplished by measuring the current received by the lamp


510


via a diode


500


. Similar to

FIG. 2

,

FIG. 3

also incorporates an automatic shutoff feature which prevents the lamp


510


from operating in partial rectification so as to avoid catastrophic failures of the lamp


510


toward the end of its useful life. The feature of automatic shut off is accomplished by measuring the power consumed by the lamp


510


by sensing the current leaving a lamp network


520


and the corresponding voltage. These features of power regulation and automatic shutoff are not affected by variations in the temperature of the lamp


290


.




In

FIG. 3

, the PFC circuit


400


has two output terminals across which a regulated direct-current voltage VDC


2


is provided for supplying the lamp network


520


and the lamp


510


with power. The voltage VDC


2


is preferably between 380 and 460 volts. An AC power source (not shown) supplies power to the PFC circuit


400


. A first output terminal of the PFC circuit


400


is coupled to a first terminal of the switch


530


. A second terminal of the switch


530


is coupled to an input terminal of the lamp network


520


and to a first terminal of the switch


540


. A second terminal of the switch


540


is coupled to a second terminal of the lamp network


520


, to first terminal of a resistor


410


and to a first terminal of a resistor


420


, thereby forming a node N


3


. A second terminal of the resistor


410


is coupled to a second output terminal of the PFC circuit


400


and to a ground node. A second terminal of the resistor


420


is coupled to a positive terminal of a capacitor


430


, to a positive input terminal of a comparator


490


, thereby forming a node N


4


. A negative terminal of the capacitor


430


is coupled to the ground node.




The lamp network


520


has two output terminals. A first output terminal of the lamp network


520


is coupled to a first terminal of the lamp


510


. Additionally, a second output terminal of the lamp network


520


is coupled to a second terminal of the lamp


510


.




An anode terminal of a diode


500


is coupled to the second terminal of the lamp


510


via a current transformer such that a voltage associated with the second terminal of the lamp


510


is not shared with the anode terminal of the diode


500


. Instead, the anode terminal of the diode


500


receives a current representative of a current that flows through the lamp


510


.




A cathode terminal of the diode


500


is coupled to a positive terminal of a capacitor


440


, to a first terminal of a potentiometer


450


, and to a negative terminal of an amplifier


460


, thereby forming a node N


5


. A negative terminal of the capacitor


440


and a second terminal of the variable resistor


450


are coupled to the ground node. A current through the lamp


510


develops a voltage across the potentiometer


450


, thereby forming a voltage V


N5


at the node N


5


. The voltage V


N5


is smoothed by the capacitor


440


and potentiometer


450


and is, therefore, representative of a level of current supplied to the lamp


510


over several cycles of the switches


530


and


540


. This potentiometer


450


, however, is user adjustable so as to vary this voltage level. Because the voltage VDC


2


is regulated, the voltage V


N5


is representative of a level of power provided to the lamp


510


.




A positive terminal of the amplifier


460


is biased to a voltage VC. Preferably, the voltage VC is approximately 1 volt. An output terminal of the amplifier


460


is coupled to an input terminal of a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO)


470


. The VCO


470


has two output terminals, OUTB and {overscore (OUT)}B. A first output terminal OUTB and is coupled to control the switch


540


. Further, a second output terminal {overscore (OUT)}B is coupled to control the switch


530


. The voltage levels at the terminals OUTB and {overscore (OUT)}B are complementary such that one, and only one, of the switches


530


and


540


is on (closed) at any one time while the other is off (open).




The power provided to the lamp network


520


is regulated according the frequency at which the VCO


470


operates the switches


530


and


540


. More particularly, the power is inversely related to the frequency over a certain range of frequencies. The frequency of the VCO


470


is controlled according to a difference between the voltage level V


N5


at the node N


5


and a voltage VTH


2


. Thus, the illumination intensity of the lamp


510


is adjustable by the user adjusting the potentiometer


450


. Further, a feedback loop is formed by the amplifier


460


, the VCO


470


, and the switches


530


and


540


for regulating the voltage V


N5


at the node N


5


. Thus, by controlling the voltage at the node N


5


in a feedback loop, the power provided to the lamp


510


is controlled such that the user selected illumination intensity output for the lamp


510


is maintained despite variations in temperature of the lamp or impedance changes caused by aging.




A negative input terminal of the comparator


490


is biased to a predetermined threshold voltage VTH


2


. An output terminal of the comparator


490


is coupled to set input terminal S of an RS flip flop


480


. An output terminal Q of the RS flip flop


480


is coupled to a disable switching in the PFC circuit


400


and VCO


470


thereby disabling the PFC circuit


400


and the VCO


470


. A reset input R on the RS flip flop


480


is coupled to an under-voltage (UV) signal for re-setting the flip flop


480


. The RS flip flop


480


delivers lamp shut off signal DISABLE


2


to the PFC


400


and the VCO


470


when the voltage at the positive terminal of the comparator


240


exceeds the predetermined threshold voltage VTH


2


.




These elements of the present invention automatically shut off the lamp


510


when the lamp nears the end of its useful life. For example, operation in partial rectification can trigger shut down of the lamp


510


. To implement this function, the DC voltage at the node N


4


is supplied to the comparator


490


. When the voltage V


N4


at the node N


4


exceeds the predefined threshold voltage VTH


2


, this indicates that the power provided to the lamp


510


can no longer controlled to an appropriate level due to deterioration of the lamp


510


. Accordingly, the comparator


490


sets the RS flip flop


480


, which in turn deactivates the PFC


400


and the VCO


470


, thereby shutting off power to the lamp


510


. The predefined threshold voltage VTH


2


is preferably set at a level higher than a typical, normal voltage at the node N


4


during safe operation of the lamp


510


such that the comparator


490


provides the signal to shut off power to the lamp


510


only when the voltage at the node N


4


reaches unsafe levels.




In the preferred embodiment, the output terminal Q of the RS flip flop


480


disables the PFC


400


and the VCO


470


by disabling a clock signal (not shown) utilized for controlling switching in the PFC circuit


400


and the VCO


470


. When the PFC


400


and the VCO


470


are shut down, the voltage VDC


2


falls to low level and little or no power is supplied to the lamp network


520


or to the lamp


510


.




A circuit, shown in

FIGS. 4A and 4B

, which in addition to the functions of power regulation and automatic power shut off, implemented by the circuits illustrated in

FIGS. 2 and 3

, operates gas discharge lamps


620


,


624


more efficiently by preferably utilizing one of a plurality of predetermined switching frequencies for switches


602


and


604


. Preferably, each of these predetermined frequencies is designed for a different mode of lamp operation, such as preheating, starting or continuous operation. Additionally, each of these frequencies which is associated with a corresponding mode of lamp operation is preferably adjustable to maximize the lamp's efficiency and longevity. Further,

FIGS. 4A and 4B

also display a circuit which operates the attached lamp in the continuous operation mode at as low as 5% or lower of it's rated light output. This feature is referred to as “deep dimming” or “architectural dimming” and provides increased flexibility and efficiency for the lamp user.




In

FIG. 4A

, a power factor corrector (PFC) circuit


600


has two output terminals across which a regulated direct-current voltage VDC


3


is provided for supplying a lamp network


601


(

FIG. 4B

) and the lamps


620


,


624


(

FIG. 4B

) with power. A first output terminal of the PFC


600


is coupled to a first terminal of a switch


602


. A second terminal of the switch


602


is coupled to a first terminal of a switch


604


and to a node A which also corresponds to the node A located in FIG.


4


B.




A node B in

FIG. 4A

corresponds to the node B located in FIG.


4


B. The node B is coupled to a second terminal of the switch


604


, a first terminal of a resistor


628


, and a first terminal of a resistor


630


, thereby forming a node N


10


in

FIG. 4A. A

second terminal of the resistor


628


is coupled to a second output terminal of the PFC


600


and to a ground node. A second terminal of the resistor


630


is coupled to a positive input terminal of a comparator


634


, a negative input terminal of an amplifier


638


, and a positive terminal of a capacitor


632


, thereby forming a node N


12


. A negative terminal of the capacitor


632


is coupled to ground. A negative terminal of the comparator


634


is biased to a voltage VTH


3


. The current from the lamps


620


,


624


flow through the resistor


628


and establishes a voltage V


N10


at a node N


10


. The resistor


630


and the capacitor


632


form a low pass filter. As a result of this low pass filter, the voltage V


N12


at node N


12


is a DC or average voltage. The positive terminal of the comparator


634


and the negative terminal of the comparator


638


both sense V


N12


. Because the voltage VDC


3


is regulated, the voltage V


N12


is representative of a level of power provided to the lamps


620


,


624


.




An output terminal of the comparator


634


is coupled to set input terminal S of a flip flop


636


. A reset terminal R of the flip flop


636


is coupled to a voltage UV. An output terminal Q of the flip flop


636


is coupled to a terminal “C” to disable switching in the PFC


600


.




An attenuator


640


is coupled to a positive terminal of the amplifier


638


. The attenuator


640


is preferably configured to supply from 0 to 10 volts. An output terminal of the amplifier


638


is coupled to an input terminal of a voltage-to-current converter


642


. An output terminal of the voltage-to-current converter


642


is coupled to a first terminal of a switch


644


. The voltage to current converter


642


takes a voltage V at the input terminal of converter


642


and provides a current I at the output terminal of converter


642


where the current I is inversely proportional to the voltage V. A second terminal of the switch


644


is coupled to a control terminal of an oscillator


646


, a first terminal of a switch


650


, a first terminal of a resistor


652


, a positive terminal of a capacitor


660


, and a first terminal of a switch


658


.




An output terminal OUTC of the oscillator


646


is coupled to control the switch


604


. An output terminal {overscore (OUT)}C of the oscillator


646


is coupled to control the switch


602


. The voltage levels of OUTC and {overscore (OUT)}C are complementary in that one, and only one, of the switches


602


and


604


is on (closed) at any one time while the other is off (open). An input terminal of a current source


648


is coupled to a voltage VCC. An output terminal of the current source


652


is coupled to a second terminal of the switch


650


. Additionally, a second terminal of the resistor


652


is coupled to a first terminal of a resistor


654


. A second terminal of the resistor


654


is coupled to a first terminal of a switch


656


. A second terminal of the switch


656


is coupled to a second terminal of the switch


658


.




Finally, an input terminal of a current source


662


is coupled to the voltage VCC. An output terminal of the current source


662


is coupled to a negative input terminal of a comparator


668


, a negative input terminal of a comparator


670


, a first terminal of a resistor


666


, and a positive terminal of a capacitor


664


. A negative terminal of the capacitor


664


and a second terminal of the resistor


666


are coupled to ground. A first positive input terminal of the comparator


668


is preferably biased to 4.75 volts. Additionally, a second positive input terminal of the comparator


668


is also preferably biased to 1.25 volts. A first positive input terminal of the comparator


670


is preferably biased to 6.75 volts. Additionally, a second positive input terminal of the comparator


670


is also preferably biased to 1.25 volts. A first output terminal of the comparator


668


is coupled to control line the switch


650


. A second output terminal of the comparator


668


is coupled to control line the switch


658


. The second output terminal of the comparator


668


produces signals that are complementary to signals produced by the first output terminal of the comparator


668


. A first output terminal of the comparator


670


is coupled to a control line for the switch


656


. A second output terminal of the comparator


670


is coupled to a control line for the switch


644


. The second output terminal of the comparator


670


produces signals that are complementary to signals produced by the first output terminal of the comparator


668


.




In

FIG. 4B

, the node A is coupled to a first terminal of an inductor


606


. A second terminal of the inductor


606


is coupled to a first terminal of a capacitor


608


and a first terminal of a capacitor


614


. A second terminal of the capacitor


608


is coupled to a center tapped lead of an autotransformer T


2


. A first terminal of a capacitor


612


is coupled to a first end terminal of the autotransformer T


2


. A first terminal of a primary winding


617


of a filament transformer T


1


is coupled to a second end terminal of the capacitor


612


, a first terminal of a capacitor


680


, a first terminal of a first secondary winding


618


of the transformer T


1


, and a first terminal of the lamp


620


. A second terminal of the first secondary winding


618


is coupled to a second terminal of the lamp


620


. A second terminal of a third secondary winding


623


of the transformer T


1


is coupled to a first terminal of a lamp


624


, a second end terminal of the autotransformer T


2


, a second terminal of the capacitor


614


, and the node B which corresponds to the node B found in FIG.


4


A.




A second terminal of a second secondary winding


622


is coupled to a third terminal of the lamp


620


and a third terminal of the lamp


624


. A second terminal of the capacitor


680


is coupled to a first terminal of a capacitor


682


. A second terminal of the capacitor


682


is coupled to a first terminal of the second secondary winding


622


of the transformer T


1


, a fourth terminal of the lamp


620


, and a fourth terminal of the lamp


624


. A first terminal of a third secondary winding


623


of the transformer T


1


is coupled to a second terminal of the lamp


624


. Further, a first terminal of a capacitor


619


is coupled to a second terminal of the primary winding


617


of the transformer T


1


.




By the oscillator


646


controlling the frequency of opening and closing the switches


602


and


604


, the power to a lamp network


601


is regulated. Further, a feedback loop is formed by the amplifier


638


, the oscillator


646


, and switches


602


and


604


. Thus, by monitoring the current flowing through the lamp network


601


which is sensed at the node N


10


, the oscillator


646


automatically maintain the user selected illumination intensity output from the lamps


620


,


624


.




The circuit in

FIG. 4A

also automatically shuts off the lamps


620


,


624


when the lamps


620


,


624


near the end of their useful lives. To achieve this function, the DC voltage V


N12


at the node N


12


is supplied to the comparator


634


. When the voltage V


N12


at the node N


12


exceeds the predefined threshold voltage VTH


3


, the comparator


634


sets the RS flip flop


636


, which in turn deactivates the PFC


600


and the oscillator


646


thereby shutting off power to the lamps


620


,


624


. The predefined threshold voltage VTH


3


is preferably set at a level higher than a typical, normal voltage at the node N


12


during safe operation of the lamps such that the comparator


634


gives the signal to shut off power when the voltage at the node N


12


only reaches unsafe levels. The output terminal Q of the RS flip flop


636


disables the PFC


600


and the oscillator


646


by disabling a clock signal (not shown) utilized for switching in the PFC


600


and the oscillator


646


. With the clock shut down, little or no power is supplied to the lamp network


601


or the lamps


620


,


624


.




Three modes of operation for the circuit disclosed in

FIG. 4A

are graphically shown on the chart of FIG.


5


. Below, Table


1


shows the corresponding state of the switches


650


,


658


,


656


and


644


relative to the three operating modes of the lamps


620


,


624


.
















TABLE 1











Preheating




Starting




Continuous Operation





























Switch 650




ON




OFF




OFF







Switch 658




OFF




ON




ON







Switch 656




ON




ON




OFF







Switch 644




OFF




OFF




ON















When the circuit illustrated in

FIGS. 4A and 4B

is off, the current source


662


is off. Accordingly, a voltage V


C664


across the capacitor


664


is discharged through the resistor


666


to a level below 1.25 volts. Upon start-up at time t


0


, the current source


662


turns on, which slowly increases the voltage across the capacitor


664


. Eventually, at the time (t


1


), the voltage V


C664


reaches 4.75 volts. Thus, between the times t


0


and t


1


(preheating mode), the comparators


668


,


670


control the switches


650


,


656


to be on (closed), and the switches


658


,


644


to be off (open). Under these conditions, the current source


648


charges the timing capacitor


660


at a rate appropriate to set the frequency of the oscillator


646


for preheating the lamps


620


,


624


. Note that the timing resistor


652


affects this preheating frequency as does a dead time characteristic of the oscillator


646


. Because the switch


658


is open, however, the resistor


654


does not affect the preheating frequency.




During preheating, the filaments inside the lamps


620


,


624


are warmed to their emission temperature while, the voltage supplied to the lamps


620


,


624


is sufficiently low to prevent the lamps from igniting. Preheating the lamps


620


,


624


prior to ignition is important to prolong the useful life of the lamps


620


,


624


.




Eventually, at the time t


2


, the voltage V


C664


reaches 6.75 volts. Thus, between the times t


1


and t


2


(starting mode), the frequency of the oscillator


646


is no longer influenced by the current source


648


. Rather, because the switches


656


and


658


are both closed, the frequency of the oscillator


646


is influenced by the resistor


654


. As a result, during the starting mode the frequency at which the switches


602


and


604


are operated is reduced significantly. This significantly increases the voltage level supplied to the lamps


620


,


624


so as to ensure ignition.




Then, once the voltage V


C664


has exceeded 6.75 volts, (after the time t


2


), the continuous operation mode is entered in which the comparators


668


,


670


control switches


644


,


658


to be closed and the switches


656


,


650


to be open. Under these conditions, the frequency of the oscillator


646


is no longer influenced by the resistor


654


. Rather, because the switch


644


is closed, the frequency of the oscillator


646


is influenced by a feedback signal I


operate


which is provided to the oscillator


646


by the voltage-to-current converter


642


. The continuous operation frequency results in a lower power being provided to the lamps


620


,


624


in comparison to the starting mode, so that the lamps


620


,


624


draw an appropriate level of power to keep the illumination intensity at the preselected level desired by the user.




In the preferred embodiment, the capacitor


660


has a value of 1.5 nF, the resistor


652


is 14.5 Kohms and the resistor


654


is 73.1 Kohms. Further, during the preheating mode, the switches


602


,


604


are preferably operated at 70 KHz. During the starting mode, the switches


602


,


604


are preferably operated at 50 KHz. In addition, during the continuous operation mode, the switches


602


,


604


are operated between 42.3 KHz for maximum intensity to a frequency which results in deep dimming to 5% or less of the maximum rated output for the lamps


620


,


624


. It will be apparent, however, that other component values and frequencies can be selected.




Returning to

FIGS. 4A and 4B

, another important feature of this circuit allows the lamps


620


,


624


to operate when they are deeply dimmed down to 5% or less of the lamps' rated illumination output. Compact lamps are known for their characteristic of driving themselves into an area of high negative resistance when dimmed and causing an associated lamp network to have an increased quality factor Q. This increased quality factor Q caused the lamps to extinguish or flicker excessively when they were dimmed. As stated herein, prior circuits attempted to solve this problem by utilizing a low pass network to allowing dimming down to 40%.




Recall the lamp network


601


illustrated in

FIG. 4B

includes the capacitors


608


and


612


; the transformer T


1


; the autotransformer T


2


; and the inductor


606


. The configuration of this lamp network as shown in

FIG. 4B

provides a lower quality factor Q than the prior art while the attached lamps are being dimmed. In fact, the lamps can be deeply dimmed down to 5% or lower and still operate without excessively flickering or extinguishing. The lamp network


601


provides a low pass filter followed by the autotransformer T


2


and capacitors


608


,


612


which acts as a high pass filter. This network combination of first the low pass filter, followed by the high pass filter, allows the lamp network


601


to have a lower quality factor Q while the coupled lamps


620


,


624


are being dimmed. For example, as seen through the nodes A and B of the lamp network


601


, the capacitor


614


and inductor


606


are configured to act as a low pass filter which is followed by the autotransformer T


2


acting as a high pass filter. As a result of the lamp network


601


, the lamps


620


and


624


are configured to have signals pass first through a low pass filter and then through an autotransformer acting as a high pass filter. This allows the lamps


620


,


624


to be dimmed down to less than 5% of their rated illumination and still operate satisfactorily.





FIG. 6

illustrates an equivalent circuit for the lamp network


601


described above and illustrated in FIG.


4


B. Where appropriate, the same reference numbers are utilized to describe common elements. An impedance R


L




700


replaces the lamps


620


and


624


; the capacitors


619


,


680


, and


682


; and the transformer T


1


which are outside the lamp network


601


and found in FIG.


4


B. As stated before, the unique lamp network


601


shown in

FIG. 4B

retains a low quality factor Q even while the lamps are deeply dimmed.




A transformer T


3


is shown as a conventional transformer with a primary winding


609


and a secondary winding


611


. In

FIG. 6

, the transformer T


3


produces an equivalent result as the autotransformer T


2


(

FIG. 4B

) and is merely substituted for the autotransformer T


2


as shown in FIG.


4


B. To overcome the shortcomings of the prior art, the transformer T


3


is a part of a high pass filter which follows a low pass filter formed by the inductor


606


and the capacitor


614


.




There is a large increase in voltage across the lamps when they are dimmed which also indicates an increase in quality factor Q when operated from prior art circuits. However, to supply this increasingly large voltage to the lamps as they are dimmed, a low quality factor Q is needed. To overcome this performance contradiction, the high pass filter formed by the transformer T


3


and capacitors


608


and


612


follows the low pass filter formed by the inductor


606


and the capacitor


614


. It will be apparent, however, that this transformer T


3


of the high pass filter can be substituted for another element which has the necessary inductive reactance to act as the shunt element for the high pass filter.




An input quality factor Q


in


of the lamp network


601


is seen through the nodes A and B. The high pass filter formed by the transformer T


3


and capacitors


608


and


612


lowers the output quality factor Q


out


of the lamp network


601


. Instead of being driven directly by the inductor


606


and the capacitor


614


, the lamps, which are represented by the impedance R


L




700


, are driven by the series capacitor


612


which decreases its Q as the lamps are dimmed. To appropriately shape the frequency response of the lamp network


601


, the input quality factor Q


in


of the low pass filter is made larger than the output quality factor Q


out


of the high pass filter.




As the lamps


620


and


624


are dimmed, the output quality factor Q


out


decreases. The transformation between parallel capacitive reactance and series capacitive reactance is shown in Eq. 1 below.










X

para





C


=


X

series





C




(

1
+

1

Q
out
2



)






Eq. (1)













Accordingly, an equivalent parallel reactance X


ParaC612


of the capacitor


612


in series becomes larger.




The parallel reactance X


ParaC612


of the capacitor


612


is then combined with a reactance of the secondary winding


611


of the transformer T


3


and then transformed onto a side of the primary winding


609


. The parallel reactance X


ParaC612


combined with the reactance of the secondary winding


611


of the transformer T


3


and then transformed onto the same side as the primary winding


609


is shown in FIG.


7


and labeled reactance X


T


.




An input quality factor Q


M


of the high pass filter is shown below in Eq. 2 and given by:










Q
M

=


(



R
PRI


R
M


-
1

)


1
/
2






Eq. (2)













The input quality factor Q


M


of the high pass filter is very small. The reactance of the capacitor


608


is given by Eq. 3:








X




C608




=Q




M




*R




M


  Eq. (3)






According to the above Eqs. 2 and 3, a reactance X


C608


of the capacitor


608


is also very small which allows the reactance X


T


to be positioned in parallel with the capacitor


614


as seen in FIG.


7


.




As the impedance


700


gets larger and the reactance X


T


becomes more inductive, the combined reactance of X


T


and the parallel reactance X


ParaC612


becomes larger thus causing the input quality factor Q


in


of the lamp network


601


to be lowered.




As a result of the low pass filter created by the inductor


606


in conjunction with the capacitor


614


followed by the high pass filter created by the transformer T


3


, the overall quality factor Q of the lamp network preferably remains low during deep dimming. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art to select components such as resistors, capacitors, and inductors with appropriate values depending on the desired response for the overall quality factor Q for the lamp network


601


.




The present invention has been described in terms of specific embodiments incorporating details to facilitate the understanding of the principles of construction and operation of the invention. Such reference herein to specific embodiments and details thereof is not intended to limit the scope of the claims appended hereto. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that modifications may be made in the embodiment chosen for illustration without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.




Specifically, it will be apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art that the device of the present invention could be implemented in several different ways and the apparatus disclosed above is only illustrative of the preferred embodiment of the invention and is in no way a limitation. For example, it would be within the scope of the invention to vary the values of the various components and voltage levels disclosed herein.



Claims
  • 1. A method of controlling an illumination intensity of a gas discharge lamp comprising the steps of:a. in a variable frequency ballast circuit, sensing a power drawn by the lamp; b. comparing the power drawn by the lamp to a reference signal; c. adjusting a frequency of the ballast circuit; and d. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 2. A method of preventing a catastrophic failure in a gas discharge lamp comprising the steps of:a. in a variable frequency ballast circuit, sensing a power drawn by the lamp; b. comparing the power drawn by the lamp to a maximum threshold reference signal; c. halting operation of the variable frequency ballast when the power drawn by the lamp exceeds the maximum threshold reference signal; and d. dimming the lamp using a low pass filter: and a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 3. An apparatus for controlling an illumination intensity of a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast circuit for sensing a power drawn by the lamp; b. means for comparing the power drawn by the lamp to a reference signal wherein the means for comparing is coupled to the ballast circuit; and c. means for adjusting a frequency of the ballast circuit in response to an input from the means for comparing wherein the means for adjusting is coupled to the ballast circuit; and d. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 4. The apparatus according to claim 3 further comprising a frequency circuit for optimizing a plurality of operating frequencies and selecting from the plurality of operating frequencies including:a. means for optimizing the plurality of operating frequencies with respect to a plurality of modes such that each operating frequency is optimized for the ballast circuit functioning in a particular mode of operation; and b. means for selecting a proper operating frequency from among the plurality of operating frequencies.
  • 5. The apparatus according to claim 4 wherein the plurality of modes comprises a starting mode, a preheating mode, and a continuous operation mode.
  • 6. An apparatus for controlling an illumination intensity of a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast for providing electric power to the lamp; b. a sensing circuit coupled to the frequency ballast for sensing an amount of power drawn by the lamp and forming a signal representative of the power; c. a generating circuit coupled to the sensing circuit for generating a reference signal; d. a comparator circuit coupled to the generating circuit for comparing the signal representative of the power to the reference signal; e. an adjusting circuit coupled the comparator circuit for adjusting an operating frequency of the variable frequency ballast in response to a difference between the signal representative of the power and the reference signal circuit; and f. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 7. The apparatus according to claim 6 further comprising a circuit for preventing a catastrophic failure which includes:a. a circuit for generating a maximum threshold level; b. a comparator for comparing the maximum threshold level to the signal representative of the power; and c. means for disabling the variable frequency ballast if the signal representative of the power exceeds the maximum threshold level.
  • 8. The apparatus according to claim 6 wherein the adjusting circuit for adjusting the operating frequency of the variable frequency ballast comprises a voltage controlled oscillator.
  • 9. The apparatus according to claim 6 further comprising means for adjusting the reference signal for modifying the illumination intensity.
  • 10. The apparatus according to claim 6 further comprising means for adjusting the signal representative of the power for modifying the illumination intensity.
  • 11. An apparatus for preventing a catastrophic failure of a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast for providing electric power to the lamp; b. a sensing circuit coupled to the frequency ballast for sensing an amount of power drawn by the lamp and forming a signal representative of the power; c. a generating circuit coupled to the frequency ballast for generating a maximum threshold level; d. a comparator coupled the generating circuit for comparing the maximum threshold level to the signal representative of the power; e. means for disabling the variable frequency ballast if the signal representative of the power exceeds the maximum threshold wherein the means for disabling is coupled to the frequency ballast and f. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 12. A circuit for disabling a lamp ballast circuit comprising:a. an input node for receiving a current signal proportional to a power signal provided to a lamp network by the lamp ballast circuit; b. a resistor having two terminals, a first resistor terminal coupled to the input node; c. a capacitor having two terminals, a first capacitor terminal coupled to a second resistor terminal and a second capacitor terminal coupled to a ground potential, wherein the capacitor forms a comparison voltage at the first capacitor terminal; d. a comparator having a positive input coupled to the first capacitor terminal and a negative input coupled to a threshold voltage; e. a latch coupled to the comparator, for receiving and holding a comparison output signal from the comparator wherein the latch is coupled to disable the lamp ballast circuit when the comparison voltage exceeds the threshold voltage; and f. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 13. A circuit for regulating power to a lamp ballast circuit comprising:a. an input node for receiving a current signal proportional to a power signal provided to a lamp network by the lamp ballast circuit; b. a resistor having two terminals, a first resistor terminal coupled to the input node; c. a capacitor having two terminals, a first capacitor terminal coupled to a second resistor terminal and a second capacitor terminal coupled to a ground potential, wherein the capacitor forms a comparison voltage at the first capacitor terminal; d. a comparator having a positive input coupled to an adjustable reference voltage formed by an attenuator and a negative input coupled to the first capacitor terminal; e. a voltage controlled oscillator with an oscillator input coupled to the comparator and an oscillator output coupled to the lamp network wherein the voltage controlled oscillator adjusts a frequency of the power signal such that a selectable level of illumination from the lamp network remains constant; and f. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 14. A circuit for dimming a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. an inverter coupled to the gas discharge lamp; and b. a lamp network coupled between the inverter and the gas discharge lamp wherein the lamp network receives power from the inverter and delivers the power to the gas discharge lamp, the lamp network comprising a low pass filter followed by a high pass filter thereby enabling deep dimming of the lamp.
  • 15. A circuit for selecting and optimizing an operating frequency for a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast coupled to the gas discharge lamp; b. means for optimizing a plurality of operating frequencies such that each operating frequency is optimized for the ballast and the gas discharge lamp functioning in one of a plurality of operation modes wherein the means for optimizing is coupled to the frequency ballast; c. means for selecting a proper operating frequency from among the plurality of operating frequencies wherein the means for selecting is coupled to the frequency ballast; and d. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
  • 16. The circuit as claimed in claim 15 wherein the plurality of operation modes include a preheat mode, a starting mode, and a continuous operation mode.
  • 17. An apparatus for controlling an illumination intensity of a gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast circuit for sensing a current through the lamp; b. a frequency controller coupled to the variable frequency ballast circuit for adjusting a frequency of the ballast circuit in response to the current; and c. a lamp network coupled to the frequency controller wherein the lamp network has a low pass filter followed by a high pass filter.
  • 18. An apparatus for controlling an illumination intensity of a gas discharge lamp and disabling the gas discharge lamp comprising:a. a variable frequency ballast circuit for sensing a current through the lamp; b. a frequency controller coupled to the variable frequency ballast circuit for adjusting a frequency of the ballast circuit in response to the current; c. a sensing circuit coupled to the ballast circuit for sensing a power drawn by the lamp; d. a comparator circuit coupled to the sensing circuit for comparing the power drawn by the lamp to a predetermined threshold; e. a disabler circuit coupled to the comparator circuit for halting operation of the ballast circuit when the power drawn exceeds the predetermined threshold; and f. a lamp network circuit for dimming the lamp further comprising: (A) a low pass filter; and (B) a high pass filter coupled to the low pass filter wherein the high pass filter follows the low pass filter such that the lamp network has a low quality factor.
US Referenced Citations (37)
Number Name Date Kind
3611021 Wallace Oct 1971
4207498 Spira et al. Jun 1980
4210846 Capewell et al. Jul 1980
4251752 Stolz Feb 1981
4277726 Burke Jul 1981
4414493 Henrich Nov 1983
4441054 Bay Apr 1984
4453109 Stupp et al. Jun 1984
4495446 Brown et al. Jan 1985
4498031 Stupp et al. Feb 1985
4523131 Zansky Jun 1985
4528482 Merlo Jun 1985
4572988 Handler et al. Feb 1986
4585974 Stupp et al. Apr 1986
4604552 Allay et al. Aug 1986
4612479 Zansky Sep 1986
4686427 Burke Aug 1987
4698554 Stupp et al. Oct 1987
4700113 Stupp et al. Oct 1987
4717863 Zeiler Jan 1988
4723098 Grubbs Feb 1988
4739227 Anderson Apr 1988
4763239 Ball Aug 1988
4893059 Nillsen Jan 1990
4920299 Presz et al. Apr 1990
4935669 Nillsen Jun 1990
4952849 Fallows et al. Aug 1990
5048033 Donahue et al. Sep 1991
5049790 Herfurth et al. Sep 1991
5111118 Fellows et al. May 1992
5315214 Lesea May 1994
5381076 Nerone Jan 1995
5705894 Krummel Jan 1998
5770926 Choi et al. Jun 1998
5808422 Venkitasubrahmanian et al. Sep 1998
5883473 Li et al. Jun 1998
5962981 Okude et al. Oct 1999