Controlling the synthesis gas composition of a steam methane reformer

Information

  • Patent Application
  • 20080031809
  • Publication Number
    20080031809
  • Date Filed
    July 18, 2006
    18 years ago
  • Date Published
    February 07, 2008
    17 years ago
Abstract
A method for controlling the synthesis gas composition obtained from a steam methane reformer (SMR) that obtains its feedstock as product gas directly from a steam hydro-gasification reactor SHR). The method allows control of the H2/CO syngas ratio by adjusting the hydrogen feed and the water content of feedstock into a steam hydro-gasification reactor that supplies the SMR. The steam and methane rich product gas of the SHR is generated by means of hydro-gasification of a slurry of carbonaceous material and water. The mass percentages of the product stream at each stage of the process are calculated using a modeling program, such as the ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium process. By varying the parameters of solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio, a sensitivity analysis can be performed that enables one determine the optimum composition of the slurry feedstock to the SHR to obtain a desired syngas ratio output of the SMR. Thus one can adjust the hydrogen feed and the water content of feedstock into the SHR that supplies the SMR to determine the syngas ratio output of the SMR.
Description

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

For a more complete understanding of the present invention, reference is now made to the following descriptions taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawing, in which:



FIG. 1 is a flow diagram of the process of this invention;



FIG. 2 is a flow diagram of the mass balance of the process; and



FIG. 3 is a sensitivity analysis using the ASPEN PLUS™ modeling program showing various conversions and the syngas ratio when parameters of solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio are varied.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

This invention enables one to control of the H2/CO ratio output of an SMR by adjusting the hydrogen feed and the water content of feedstock into the SHR that supplies the SMR. The steam and methane rich product gas of the SHR is generated by means of hydro-gasification of the slurry, which is a mixture of carbonaceous material and water. This product gas, a mixture of methane rich gas and steam, where the steam is present as a result of the superheating the water in the feedstock, serves as an ideal feed stream for the SMR.


The mass percentages of the product stream at each stage of the process are calculated using a modeling program, such as the ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium process. By varying the parameters of solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio, a sensitivity analysis can be performed that enables one determine the optimum composition of the slurry feedstock to the SHR to obtain a desired syngas ratio output of the SMR. Thus one can adjust the hydrogen feed and the water content of feedstock into the SHR that supplies the SMR to determine the syngas ratio output of the SMR.


Impurities are removed from the SHR product stream, such as fine particles of ash & char, hydrogen sulfide and other inorganic components. These impurities must be removed in order to prevent poisoning of the catalyst used in the SMR. Conventionally, a combination of particulate filters, a solvent wash (amines, Selexol™, Rectisol™), and hydro-desulphurization by means of the Claus process are used for this purpose. In the Claus process, H2S is partially oxidized with air in a reaction furnace at high temperatures (1000-1400° C.). Sulfur is formed, but some H2S remains unreacted, and some SO2 is made requiring that the remaining H2S be reacted with the SO2 at lower temperatures (about 200-350° C.) over a catalyst to make more sulfur. To maintain the SMR feed stream at high temperatures, a gas cleanup unit is provided that operates at process pressures and at a temperature above the steam condensation point. The unit is located between the SHR and SMR.


More particularly, a process is provided for converting carbonaceous material to synthesis gas of a desired H2/CO ratio, comprising simultaneously heating carbonaceous material in an SHR in the presence of a predetermined ratio of hydrogen and water in the form of steam, at a temperature and pressure sufficient to generate a stream of methane and carbon monoxide rich gas product, which can be called a producer gas, the ratio of hydrogen and water being determined by a modeling program, such as the ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium process. In accordance with the invention, by varying the parameters of solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio, a sensitivity analysis is performed that enables one determine the optimum composition of the slurry feedstock to the SHR to obtain a desired syngas ratio output of the SMR. Impurities are removed from the producer gas stream substantially at the process temperature and pressure, and the resultant producer gas is subjected to steam methane reforming in an SMR under conditions whereby synthesis gas comprising hydrogen and carbon monoxide is generated having a hydrogen/carbon monoxide ratio determined by the ratio of hydrogen and water in the SHR.


In a specific process, for converting municipal waste, biomass, wood, coal, or a natural or synthetic polymer to synthesis gas, the carbonaceous material is simultaneously heated in the presence of both hydrogen and steam, at a temperature of about 790° C. to about 850° C. and pressure about 132 psi to 560 psi whereby to generate a stream of methane and carbon monoxide rich producer gas. Impurities are removed from the producer gas stream substantially at the process temperature and pressure, following which the resultant producer gas is subjected to steam methane reforming under conditions whereby to generate the desired synthesis gas ratio of hydrogen and carbon monoxide. For example, the required H2:CO mole ratio of a Fischer-Tropsch reactor with a cobalt based catalyst is 2.1:1. By appropriate adjustment, as described below, of the H2/H2O ratio, a H2/CO mole ratio range of about 3 to 1 can be achieved to provide an excess of hydrogen, which can be separated and fed into the SHR to make a self-sustainable process, i.e., without requiring any external hydrogen feed. The synthesis gas generated by the steam methane reforming can be fed into a Fischer-Tropsch reactor under conditions whereby a liquid fuel is produced. Exothermic heat from the Fischer-Tropsch reaction can be transferred to the hydro-gasification reaction and/or steam methane reforming reaction.



FIG. 1 is a flow diagram of a SHR to SMR process in which a desired H2/CO ratio output of an SMR is obtained by adjusting the hydrogen feed and the water content of feedstock into the SHR that supplies the SMR. An internally generated hydrogen feed 10 is fed into an SHR 12 along with a carbonaceous feedstock 14 and water 16, which are heated to 750° C. at 400 psi in the SHR 12. The resulting producer gas is directed to a gas clean up filter 18, e.g. a candle filter assembly, at about 350° C. at about 400 psi. From there, after removal of sulfur and ash, the effluent is directed to an SMR 20 where synthesis gas is generated and fed to a Fischer-Tropsch reactor 22., from which pure water 24, and diesel fuel and/or wax 26 is obtained. A portion of hydrogen is diverted from the SMR 20, at 28 to be fed back to the HGR 12. Heat 30 from the Fischer-Tropsch reactor 22 is used to supplement the heat at the SMR.


Operating the unit above the bubbling temperature of the water allows the water to be present as steam in the gaseous product stream from the SHR, thereby enabling the process to retain most of the sensible heat in the effluent stream. The following example will illustrate the invention.


EXAMPLE

A mass balance process flow diagram is shown in FIG. 2. The mass percentages of the product stream at each stage of the process are provided in the figure. ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium process modeling was used to calculate these values. ASPEN PLUS™ is a commercial computer modeling program that allows a process model to be created by specifying the chemical components and operating conditions. The program takes all of the specifications and simulates the model, executing all necessary calculations needed to solve the outcome of the system, hence predicting its behavior. When the calculations are complete, ASPEN PLUS™ lists the results, stream by stream and unit by unit, and can present the data in graphical form with determining ordinate and abscissa


As shown in FIG. 2, an SHR feedstock of hydrogen and 41% coal slurry results in the production of synthesis gas with a 3.4:l mole ratio of hydrogen to carbon monoxide in the SMR. The required feed hydrogen for the SHR can be supplied through external means or by internal feedback of a portion of the hydrogen produced in the SMR. In a particular example, a slurry of 41% coal, 52% water and 7% hydrogen is used, obtained following the procedures of Norbeck et al. U.S. Ser. No. 10/911,348. This results in an output from the SHR to the cleanup filter of a gaseous mixture containing 32 wt % CH4, 2 wt % H2, 2 wt % CO, 3 wt % CO2, 51 wt % H2O, 4 wt % ash, 5 wt % char, and 1 wt % other impurities.


In this example, the filter is operating at 300° C. and 28 atmospheres of pressure. Any filter capable of operating at the process temperature can be used at the gas cleanup station. One such commercially available filter is a candle filter, which is well known to the art. See, for example U.S. Pat. No. 5,474,586, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference. An available gas cleanup unit that can be used in this invention is what is known as a candle filter in which a series of candle-shaped filters are carried in a filter vessel. The candle filters are made of stainless steel metal frit to remove fine particulate matter (ash, inorganic salts and unreacted char) from the gas stream. The slurry is fed into the vessel at a bottom inlet and filtrate is taken out at a top outlet. Particulate matter is taken from another outlet as cake. Sulfur impurities existing in the SHR product gas, mostly in the form of hydrogen sulfide, are removed by passing the product gas through a packed bed of metal oxide sorbents in the gas cleanup unit, particulate matter being taken from a cake outlet.


Active sorbents include, but are not limited to, Zn based oxides such as zinc oxide, sold by Süd-Chemie, Louisville, Ky. Porous metal filter elements are available from Bekaert in Marietta, Ga. in the appropriate forms and sizes, such as Bekpor® Porous Media-which is made from stainless steel sintered fiber matrix with a pore size of 1. These sorbents and filter elements allow the effects of pressure drop and gas-solid mass transfer limitations to be minimized. At a pressure of 28 atm., temperatures in the range of 300° C. to 500° C. and space velocities up to 2000/hr have been used in the desulphurization of SHR product gas. The hydrogen sulfide content of the gas is diminished by means of sulfidation of the sorbents to levels low enough to avoid the deactivation of the SMR catalyst. The used sorbents in the gas cleanup unit can either be replaced with fresh sorbents or regenerated in-situ with diluted air in parallel multiple sorbent beds.


The output of the SHR-cleanup unit is a methane rich, producer gas containing 36 wt % CH4, 2 wt % H2, 2 wt % CO, 3 wt % CO2, and 57 wt % H2O, having a steam to methane mole ratio of 1:4. The output of the SHR is fed to the SMR, which is operating at 800° C. and 28 atmospheres to yield synthesis gas having a mole ratio of H2 to CO of 3.4, and containing 4 wt % CH4, 14 wt % H2, 58 wt % CO, 3 wt % CO2, and 21 wt % H2O.


The syngas ratio obtained from the SMR can be adjusted by varying the solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio in the SHR feedstock. Sensitivity analysis was performed using the ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium modeling tool by varying these parameters. The results are in FIG. 3, showing various conversions and the syngas ratio when parameters of solid to water ratio and hydrogen to carbon ratio are varied. The solid lines () represent the percentage of carbon converted to CH4 (mole CH4/mole Cin). The long dashed lines () represent the percentage of carbon converted to CO (mole CO/mole Cin). The dotted lines () represent the percentage of carbon converted to CO2 (mole CO2/mole Cin). The dash-dot-dot-dash lines () represent sustainable H2, and the short dashed lines () represent the syngas ratio of H2/CO (mole H2/mole CO).


The last parameter is of key interest in this invention. FIG. 3 clearly demonstrates that the final syngas ratio can be adjusted by adjusting the water to solid ratio (represented as H2O/ Cin mass ratio in FIG. 3) and the hydrogen to carbon ratio of the feedstock. Thus, an optimum composition of the slurry to obtain a sustainable hydrogen feedback and the desired syngas ratio for the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (2.1:1) was found to be 3.1 when the mole ratio of hydrogen to carbon in the feed was set to one.


More generally, the process of this invention can produce composition of synthesis gas having a H2:CO mole ratio range of 1:1 to 6:1. The resulting effluent is a synthesis of gases rich in hydrogen, carbon monoxide, and steam. Hydrogen produced in the SMR is recycled back to the HGR. Consequently, no outside source of hydrogen is needed to maintain steady state operation. The HGR and SMR processes, therefore, may be considered to be chemically self-sustaining. The remaining synthesis gas is then available for the production of fuels and process heat.


In an embodiment of the invention, the synthesis gas is fed to a Fischer-Tropsch reactor in a process that can produce a zero-sulfur, ultrahigh cetane value diesel-like fuel and valuable paraffin wax products. The absence of sulfur enables low pollutant and particle emitting diesel fuels to be realized. Useful by-products can be produced, foe example, purified water, which can be re-cycled to create the slurry feed into the process. The Fischer-Tropsch reactions also produce tail gas that contains hydrogen, CO, CO2, and some light hydrocarbon gases. Hydrogen can be stripped out of the tail gas and recycled either to the HGR or the Fischer-Tropsch reactor. Any small amounts of other gases such as CO and CO may be flared off.


Although the present invention and its advantages have been described in detail, it should be understood that various changes, substitutions and alterations can be made herein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims. Moreover, the scope of the present application is not intended to be limited to the particular embodiments of the process and apparatus described in the specification. As one of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciate from the disclosure of the present invention, processes and apparatuses, presently existing or later to be developed that perform substantially the same function or achieve substantially the same result as the corresponding embodiments described herein may be utilized according to the present invention. Accordingly, the appended claims are intended to include such processes and use of such apparatuses within their scope.


REFERENCES



  • 1. Van der Laan, G. P., Thesis, University of Groningen, Netherlands, 1999.

  • 2. Sheldon, R. A., Chemicals from Synthesis Gas, 1983 and FT Technology: Studies in surf Science and Catalysis, ed. Steynberg, A., Dry, M. E., Vol 152, 2004.


Claims
  • 1. A process for converting carbonaceous material in a water containing slurry to synthesis gas having a desired ratio of hydrogen to carbon monoxide in the synthesis gas, comprising: providing a predetermined ratio of hydrogen to slurry water to a steam hydro-gasification reactor;simultaneously heating the carbonaceous material in the presence of both said hydrogen and steam, at a temperature and pressure sufficient to generate a stream of methane and carbon monoxide rich gas product;removing impurities from the producer gas stream; andsubjecting the resultant producer gas to steam methane reforming under conditions whereby synthesis gas comprising said desired ratio of hydrogen and carbon monoxide is generated.
  • 2. The process of claim 1 wherein at least part of said slurry water is provided in the form of steam.
  • 3. The process of claim 1 wherein the ratio of hydrogen to slurry water is determined by analysis of the effect on the synthesis gas ratio of (a) the ratio of solid content of the carbonaceous material to the slurry water and (b) the ratio of the hydrogen to carbon content of the carbonaceous material.
  • 4. The process of claim 3 wherein said analysis is a sensitivity analysis using a modeling computer program that relates the synthesis gas ratio of hydrogen to carbon monoxide to conversion ratios of the carbon content of the carbonaceous material.
  • 5. The process of claim 4 wherein the computer program is a modeling program.
  • 6. The process of claim 5 wherein the computer program uses the ASPEN PLUS™ equilibrium process.
  • 7. The process of claim 1 wherein the steam methane reforming is conducted under conditions whereby the composition of synthesis gas produced has a H2: CO mole ratio range of 1.1 to 6.1.
  • 8. The process of claim 1 wherein steam methane reforming is conducted under conditions whereby the composition of synthesis gas produced has a H2: CO mole ratio of 3:1.
  • 9. The process of claim 1 wherein the carbonaceous material comprises municipal waste, biomass, wood, coal, or a natural or synthetic polymer.
  • 10. The process of claim 1 in which synthesis gas generated by the steam methane reforming is fed into a Fischer-Tropsch reactor under conditions whereby a liquid fuel is produced.
  • 11. A process for converting municipal waste, biomass, wood, coal, or a natural or synthetic polymer, in a water containing slurry to synthesis gas, comprising: providing a predetermined ratio of hydrogen to slurry water to a steam hydro-gasification reactor, the ratio of hydrogen to slurry water being determined by analysis of the effect on the synthesis gas ratio of (a) the ratio of solid content of the carbonaceous material to the slurry water and (b) the ratio of the hydrogen to carbon content of the carbonaceous material that would produce synthesis gas comprising hydrogen and carbon monoxide at a H2:CO mole ratio range of 1:1 to 6:1;simultaneously heating carbonaceous material in the presence of both said hydrogen and steam, at a temperature of about 790° C. to about 850° C. and pressure about 132 psi to 560 psi whereby to generate a stream of methane and carbon monoxide rich gas product;removing impurities from the producer gas stream substantially at said temperature and pressure;subjecting the resultant producer gas to steam methane reforming under conditions whereby to generate synthesis gas comprising hydrogen and carbon monoxide at a H2:CO mole ratio range of 1:1 to 6:1; andfeeding synthesis gas generated by the steam methane reforming into a Fischer-Tropsch reactor under conditions whereby a liquid fuel is produced.
  • 12. The process of claim 11 comprising transferring exothermic heat from the Fischer-Tropsch reaction to the hydro-gasification reaction and/or steam methane reforming reaction.