Copolymers and their reaction products with amines as fuel and lubricant additives

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6512055
  • Patent Number
    6,512,055
  • Date Filed
    Friday, May 4, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 28, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
Copolymers I carrying functional groups and comprisinga) 20-60 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated C4-C6-dicarboxylic acid or an anhydride thereof,b) 10-70 mol % of at least one oligomer of propene or of a branched 1-olefin of 4 to 10 carbon atoms, having an average molecular weight Mw of from 300 to 5000, andc) 1-50 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated compound which is copolymerizable with the monomers a) and b),a process for their preparation, oil-soluble reaction products obtainable therefrom by reaction with an amine and the use of said reaction products as additives for lubricants and fuels.
Description




DESCRIPTION




The present invention relates to novel copolymers I carrying functional groups and comprising




a) 20-60 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated C


4


-C6-dicarboxylic acid or an anhydride thereof,




b) 10-70 mol % of at least one oligomer of propene or of a branched 1-olefin of 4 to 10 carbon atoms, having an average molecular weight M


w


of from 300 to 5000, and




c) 1-50 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated compound which is copolymerizable with the monomers a) and b),




and furthermore a process for the preparation of these compounds I. The present invention also relates to oil-soluble reaction products II obtainable from the copolymers I by reaction with an amine, a process for the preparation of said reaction products, the use of the compounds II and fuels and lubricants which contain these compounds.




WO-A 90/03359 describes polymers which are used as additives in lubricating oils and have dispersant properties for sludge particles and solid particles present therein. Moreover, the polymers have viscosity index-improving properties, ie. they ensure that the viscosity of a lubricating oil which contains this compound decreases to a substantially smaller extent than that of oils without such an additive when the temperature is increased.




These polymers are composed of two monomer groups, ie. on the one hand of maleic acid or fumaric acid or derivatives of these compounds and on the other hand of an olefin whose molecular weight is sufficiently large for the polymer prepared from these monomers to be oil-soluble. The olefin must carry at least 20% of alkylvinylidene groups.




The polymers disclosed in the publication have properties which are not satisfactory for all applications; in particular, the viscosity-temperature behavior of lubricating oils which contain these polymers as additives is unsatisfactory.




Furthermore, the dispersing effect of this class of compounds is not satisfactory for all industrial applications.




It is an object of the present invention to provide additives for lubricating oils, which additives do not have these disadvantages.




We have found that this object is achieved by the copolymers defined at the outset.




We have also found a process for their preparation, reaction products II obtainable from these copolymers I by reaction with an amine, a process for the preparation of said reaction products and the use of the reaction products II. We have furthermore found lubricants and fuels which contain these compounds.




The embodiments which are particularly advantageous for the use of the copolymers I as intermediates for the preparation of lubricating oil additives are described below.




Copolymers I are composed of monomers a) to c).




Monomer a)




Suitable monomers a) are monoethylenically unsaturated dicarboxylic acids of 4 to 6 carbon atoms, such as maleic acid, fumaric acid, itaconic acid, mesaconic acid, methylenemalonic acid, citraconic acid, maleic anhydride, itaconic anhydride, citraconic anhydride and methylenemalonic anhydride and mixtures of these with one another. Maleic anhydride is preferred.




Monomer b)




Suitable monomers b) are oligomers of propene or of a branched 1-olefin of 4 to 10 carbon atoms. These oligomers are composed of at least 3 olefin molecules. Their average molecular weight M


w


is from 300 to 5000 g/mol. Examples of these are oligomers of propene, of isobutene and of branched isomers of pentene, hexene, octene and of decene, the copolymerizable terminal group of the oligomer being present in the form of a vinyl, vinylidene or alkylvinylidene group. Oligopropenes and oligopropene mixtures of 9 to 200 carbon atoms and in particular oligoisobutenes, as obtainable, for example, according to DE-A 27 02 604, are preferred. Mixtures of the stated oligomers are also suitable. The molecular weights of the oligomers may be determined in a conventional manner by gel permeation chromatography.




Monomer c)




Suitable monomers c) are all those monomers which are copolymerizable with the monomers a) and b).




Examples of these are linear 1-olefins of 2 to 40, preferably 8 to 30, carbon atoms, such as decene, dodecene, octadecene and industrial mixtures of C


20


-C


24


-1-olefins and C


24


-C


28


-1-olefins.




Other suitable monomers c) are monoethylenically unsaturated C


3


-C


10


-monocarboxylic acids, such as acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, dimethacrylic acid, ethylacrylic acid, crotonic acid, allylacetic acid and vinylacetic acid, among which acrylic and methacrylic acid are preferred.




Vinyl and allyl alkyl ethers where the alkyl radical is of 1 to 40 carbon atoms are also suitable, and the alkyl radical may carry further substituents, such as hydroxyl, amino, dialkylamino or alkoxy. Examples are methyl vinyl ether, ethyl vinyl ether, propyl vinyl ether, isobutyl vinyl ether, 2-ethylhexyl vinyl ether, decyl vinyl ether, dodecyl vinyl ether, octadecyl vinyl ether, 2-(diethylamino)ethyl vinyl ether, 2-(di-n-butylamino)ethyl vinyl ether, and the corresponding allyl ethers.




A further group of monomers comprises C


1


-C


40


-alkyl esters, amides and C


1


-C


40


-N-alkylamides of monoethylenically unsaturated C


3


-C


10


-mono- or dicarboxylic acids, such as ethyl acrylate, butyl acrylate, 2-ethylhexyl acrylate, decyl acrylate, dodecyl acrylate, octadecyl acrylate and the esters of industrial alcohol mixtures of 14 to 28 carbon atoms, ethyl methacrylate, 2-ethylhexyl methacrylate, decyl methacrylate, octadecyl methacrylate, monobutyl maleate, dibutyl maleate, monodecyl maleate, didodecyl maleate, monooctadecyl maleate, dioctadecyl maleate, dimethylaminoethyl acrylate, diethylaminoethyl acrylate, dibutylaminoethyl methacrylate, acrylamide, methacrylamide, N-tert-butylacrylamide, N-octylacrylamide, N,N′-dibutylacrylamide, N-dodecylmethacrylamide and N-octadecylmethacrylamide.




Vinyl and allyl esters of C


1


-C


30


-monocarboxylic acids may also be copolymerized with the monomers a) and b). Specific examples of these are vinyl formate, vinyl acetate, vinyl propionate, vinyl butyrate, vinyl laurate, vinyl stearate, vinyl pivalate, allyl acetate, allyl butyrate and allyl stearate




N-vinylcarboxamides of carboxylic acids of 1 to 8 carbon atoms, such as N-vinylformamide, N-vinyl-N-methylformamide, N-vinylacetamide, N-vinyl-N-methylacetamide, N-vinyl-N-ethylacetamide, N-vinyl-N-methylpropionamide and N-vinylpropionamide, are also suitable. Other examples are N-vinyl compounds of nitrogen-containing heterocycles, such as N-vinylimidazole, N-vinylmethylimidazole, N-vinylpyrrolidone and N-vinylcaprolactam.




Mixtures of the stated monomers are also suitable as building blocks for the copolymers.




Preferred among these monomers are acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, C


16


-olefins, C


20


-C


24


-olefins, C


14


-C


20


-alkyl vinyl ethers and C


14


-C


20


-alkyl esters of monoethylenically unsaturated C


3


-C


6


-mono- and dicarboxylic acids.




The compolymers I contain the monomers a) to c) in amounts of from 20 to 60 mol % of monomer a), from 10 to 70 mol % of monomer b) and from 1 to 50 mol % of monomer c).




The copolymers may be prepared by all known conventional polymerization processes, for example by mass, emulsion, suspension, precipitation and solution polymerization. All stated polymerization processes are carried out in the absence of oxygen, preferably in a nitrogen stream. The conventional apparatuses, for example autoclaves and kettles, are used for all polymerization methods. Mass polymerization of the monomers of groups a) to c) is particularly preferred. It may be carried out at from 80 to 300° C., preferably at from 120 to 200° C., the lowest polymerization temperature to be chosen preferably being at least about 20° C. above the glass transition temperature of the polymer formed. The polymerization conditions are chosen according to the molecular weight which the copolymers are to have. Polymerization at high temperatures gives copolymers having low molecular weights, whereas polymers having higher molecular weights are formed at lower polymerization temperatures.




The copolymerization is preferably carried out in the presence of compounds which form free radicals. Up to 10, preferably from 0.2 to 5, % by weight, based on the monomers used in the copolymerization, of these compounds are required. Examples of suitable polymerization initiators are peroxide compounds, such as tert-butyl perpivalate, tert-butyl perneodecanoate, tert-butylperethylhexanoate, tert-butylperisobutyrate, di-tert-butyl peroxide, di-tert-amyl peroxide, diacetyl peroxydicarbonate and dicyclohexylperoxydicarbonate, or azo compounds, such as 2,2′-azobisisobutyronitrile. The initiators may be used alone or as a mixture with one another. Redox coinitiators may also be present. In the mass polymerization, they are preferably introduced into the polymerization reactor separately or in the form of a solution. The monomers a), b) and c) may be copolymerized at above 200° C. also in the absence of polymerization initiators.




In order to prepare low molecular polymers, it is often advantageous to carry out the copolymerization in the presence of regulators. Conventional regulators, such as C


1


-C


4


-aldehydes, formic acid and organic SH-containing compounds, such as 2-mercaptoethanol, 2-mercaptopropanol, mercaptoacetic acid, tert-butyl mercaptan, n-octyl mercaptan, n-dodecyl mercaptan and tert-dodecyl mercaptan, may be used for this purpose. The polymerization regulators are generally used in amounts of from 0.1 to 10% by weight, based on the monomers.




In order to prepare copolymers having a higher molecular weight, it is often advantageous to carry out the polymerization in the presence of chain extenders. Such chain extenders are compounds having diethylenically or polyethylenically unsaturated groups, such as divinylbenzene, pentaerythrityl triallyl ether, esters of glycols, such as glycol diacrylate, glyceryl triacrylate and polyethylene glycol diacrylates. They may be added in the polymerization in amounts of up to 5% by weight.




The copolymerization may be carried out continuously or batchwise. The molecular weights of the products are as a rule from 1000 to 50,000 g/mol.




The copolymers I may be reacted with amines of the formula HNR


1


R


2


to give the nitrogen-containing reaction products II. R


1


and R


2


may be identical or different. Suitable amine components are




ammonia,




aliphatic and aromatic, primary and secondary amines of 1 to 50 carbon atoms, such as methylamine, ethylamine, propylamine, di-n-butylamine and cyclohexylamine,




amines in which R


1


and R


2


, together with the nitrogen atom to which they are bonded, form a common ring which may contain further heteroatoms, eg. morpholine, pyridine, piperidine, pyrrole, pyrimidine, pyrroline, pyrrolidine, pyrazine and pyridazine,




amines which carry hydroxyalkylene and polyoxyalkylene radicals and in which R


1


and/or R


2


are











where R


3


is C


2


-C


10


-alkylene and m is an integer of from 1 to 30, such as ethanolamine, 2-aminopropan-1-ol and neopentanolamine,




polyoxyalkyleneamines which carry terminal amino groups and in which R


1


and/or R


2


are











where R


3


, R


4


and R


5


are each C


2


-C


10


-alkylene, m has the abovementioned meanings and R


6


and R


7


are each hydrogen, unsubstituted or hydroxyl- or amino-substituted C


1


-C


10


-alkyl or C


6


-C


10


-aryl, such as polyoxypropylenediamines and bis(3-aminopropyl)tetrahydrofurans.




Preferred amine components d) are polyamines in which R


1


and/or R


2


are a radical of the formula V











where R


3


, R


6


and R


7


have the abovementioned meanings and n is an integer of from 1 to 6. Suitable polyamines are ethylenediamine, propylenediamine, dimethylaminopropylamine, diethylenetriamine, dipropylenetriamine, triethylenetetramine, tripropylenetetramine, tetraethylenepentamine, ethylaminoethylamine, dimethylaminoethylamine, isopropylaminopropylamine, ethylenedipropylenetetramine, 2-diisopropylaminoethylamine, aminoethylethanolamine, ethylenepropylenetriamine, N,N,N′,N′-tetra(3-aminopropyl)ethylenediamine, 2-(3-aminopropyl)cyclohexylamine, 2,5-dimethyl-2,5-hexanediamine and N,N,N′,N″, N″-penta(3-aminopropyl)dipropylenetriamine.




Polyamines which contain a heterocyclic radical as a structural component, such as aminoethylpiperazine, are also preferred.




Mixtures of different amines may also be used as the amine component.




The novel reaction products II are obtained in a conventional manner by reacting copolymers I with the stated amines. The molar ratio of the components depends on the number of acid or anhydride groups in the copolymer I. This may be determined in a known manner, for example by titration with a strong base. In general, from 0.1 to 3 equivalents of acid or anhydride groups in the polymer are used per mole of amine. As a rule, the starting materials for the reaction are mixed and are heated to 30-200° C. The reaction is preferably carried out under an inert gas atmosphere and may be effected in the presence or absence of solvents. Examples of inert solvents are aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons, such as toluene and xylene, as well as mineral oils. The progress of the reaction can be monitored by IR spectroscopy.




The nitrogen-containing reaction products II may be used as additives for lubricants and fuels.




The lubricants are additive-containing synthetic, semisynthetic and mineral oils, preferably those which are used as engine oils. The synthetic oils comprise synthetic esters and polymers of α-olefins. The reaction products II are added to the lubricants in general as a concentrate in an inert solvent, such as a mineral oil. These concentrates may contain further conventional additives, such as rust inhibitors, antiwear agents, detergents, antioxidants and pour point improvers.




The reaction products II are added to the lubricants in amounts of from 1 to 15, preferably from 0.5 to 10, % by weight.




In fuels such as gasoline or diesel fuel, the reaction products II are used as detergents for keeping the intake system clean. Owing to their dispersant properties, they also have an advantageous effect on engine lubricants which they may enter during operation of the engine. From 20 to 5000 ppm, particularly preferably from 50 to 1000 ppm, based on the fuel, are added for this purpose.











EXAMPLES




1. Preparation of the copolymers I




General preparation method




The monomers b) and, if required, c) (initially taken) were heated to 150° C. in a gentle stream of nitrogen in a reactor, and the monomers a) (in liquid form as a melt at about 70° C.) and, if required, c) (feed) are metered in in the course of 4 hours and a solution of di-tert-butyl peroxide, dissolved in 25 g of o-xylene, in the course of 4.5 hours at 150° C. Heating was then continued for a further hour at 150° C.




The molecular weight of the copolymers was determined with the aid of high-pressure gel permeation chromatography. The eluent used was tetrahydrofuran. Calibration was carried out using polystyrene fractions having a narrow distribution.




Details of the reactions are shown in Table 1.















TABLE 1













Monomers



















b)










a) MA*




Oligoisobutene




c)





Molecular























Amount








Amount






Method of




Peroxide




weight






Ex.




[g]




Mol %




[M


w


]




[g]




Mol %




[g]




Type




Mol %




addition




[g]




[g/mol]

























1.1




98




50




1000




900




45




29.6




C


20-24


-1-Olefin




5




Initially taken




10.3




3500






1.2




98




47.4




1000




900




42.7




50




Lauryl acrylate




9.9




Feed




11




3600






1.3




98




50




1000




900




45




22.4




C


16


-1-Olefin




5




Initially taken




10.2




3800






1.4




98




50




1000




900




45




29.5




Octadecyl vinyl




5




Initially taken




10.2




3900













ether






1.5




98




50




1000




900




45




11.1




N-Vinylpyrrolidone




5




Feed




10.1




3300






1.6




135




51.8




1000




765




28.8




100




2-Ethylhexylacrylate




19.4




Feed




10




4300






1.7




135




39




1000




765




21.7




100




Acrylic acid




39.3




Feed




10




5800






1.8




135




56.2




1000




765




31.2




100




Stearyl acrylate




12.6




Feed




10




4800






1.9




98




50




1000




500




25




148




C


20-24


-1-Olefin




25




Initially taken




7.5




4800






1.10




108




41.7




1000




612




23.1




80




Methacrylic acid




35.2




Feed




8




5200






1.11




135




41.1




1300




765




17.5




100




Acrylic acid




41.4




Feed




10




4800






1.12




135




44




1300




765




18.8




100




Methacrylic acid




37.2




Feed




10




5600






1.13




135




44.5




1200




765




10.7




100




Acrylic acid




44.8




Feed




10




9800






1.14




135




47.9




2300




765




11.6




100




Methacrylic acid




40.5




Feed




10




10800 











*Maleic anhydride













2. Preparation of the oil-soluble reaction products II




General preparation method




A polymer according to Examples 1 was initially taken in xylene at 70° C., and an amine or polyamine was added and the mixture was refluxed until the expected amount of water of reaction had separated off. After the solvent had been removed, the product was obtained in the form of a pale yellow to amber-colored, viscous residue. The IR absorption bands of the products were at about 1770 and 1700 cm


−1


. The reactions carried out are shown in Table 2:

















TABLE 2












Polymer





Molar ratio








according





anhydride







Ex.




to Example




Amine component




content:amine





























2.1




1.1




Aminoethylpiperazine




1.5:1  







2.2




1.1




Triethylenetetramine




3:1







2.3




1.1




Etherdiamine 230




1:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜230 g mol


−1


)







2.4




1.1




Etherdiamine 230




2:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜230 g mol


−1


)







2.5




1.1




Etherdiamine 400




1:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜400 g mol


−1


)







2.6




1.1




Etherdiamine 400




2:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜400 g mol


−1


)







2.7




1.1




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.8




1.1




Aminoethylpiperazine




1:1







2.9




1.1




Dimethylaminopropylamine




1:1







2.10




1.1




Dimethylaminopropylamine




1.2







2.11




1.2




Dimethylaminopropylamine




1:1







2.12




1.2




Dimethylaminopropylamine




1:2







2.13




1.2




Aminoethylpiperazine




1:1







2.14




1.2




Aminoethylpiperazine




2:3







2.15




1.2




Triethylenetetramine




3:1







2.16




1.2




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.17




1.2




Etherdiamine 230




2:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜230 g mol


−1


)







2.18




1.2




Etherdiamine 230




1:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜230 g mol


−1


)







2.19




1.2




Aminoethylpiperazine




1.5:1  







2.20




1.3




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.21




1.3




Triethylenetetramine




3:1







2.22




1.4




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.23




1.4




Triethylenetetramine




3:1







2.24




1.5




Triethylenetetramine




1:1







2.25




1.5




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.26




1.6




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.27




1.6




Triethylenetetramine




3:1







2.28




1.7




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.29




1.7




Aminoethylpiperazine




  1:1.5







2.30




1.9




Etherdiamine 400




2:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜400 g mol


−1


)







2.31




1.9




Etherdiamine 400




1:1









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜400 g mol


−1


)







2.32




1.9




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.33




1.10




Triethylenetetramine




2:1







2.34




1.10




Etherdiamine 400




1:2









(polyoxypropylenediamine,









M˜400 g mol


−1


)







2.35




1.10




Aminoethylpiperazine




  1:1.5







2.36




1.11




Aminoethylpiperazine




  1:1.5







2.37




1.11




Bis(aminopropyl)piperazine




2:1







2.38




1.12




Aminoethylpiperazine




  1:1.5







2.39




1.12




Bis(aminopropyl)piperazine




2:1















3. Comparison




Comparative additive VI: reaction product of the copolymer according to Example 6 of WO-A 30/03359 and triethylenetetramine TETA




The stated starting materials were reacted similarly to Examples 2, in a molar ratio of 1:1.




Comparative additive V2: reaction product of the copolymer according to Example 6 of WO-A 90/03359 and TETA




The stated starting materials were reacted as in Examples 2, in a molar ratio of 2:1.




4. Testing of the viscosity-temperature behavior




The additives were tested in a concentration of 6% by weight in a 5 W-30 engine oil:


















Additive









according




Viscosity 100° C.




Viscosity −25° C.






to Example




[mm


2


s


−1


] Ubbelohde




[mPas] CCS




Solubility
















7.55




1900











2.28




9.71




2940




clear






2.33




9.79




3065




clear






V1




9.00




3100




cloudy






V2




9.19




3200




cloudy














The novel additives are superior to those of the prior art not only at high temperature, owing to their viscosity-increasing effect, but also at low temperature for the desired property, ie. very low viscosity.




5. Testing of the dispersing effect




To test the dispersing effect, a spot test was carried out, as described in Les Huiles pour Moteurs et la Graissage des Moteurs, A. Schilling, vol. 1, page 89 et seq., 1962. 3% strength by weight mixtures of the additives in a sooty diesel oil were prepared for this purpose. The dispersions thus obtained were developed on a filter paper in the same way as a chromatogram. The scale of values ranged from 0 to 1000: the higher the value achieved the better was the dispersing effect of the additive.




Sample preparation:



















Additive




10 min at





10 min at




10 min at






according




RT with-




10 min at RT




250° C. without




250° C.






to Example




out water




1% of water




water




with water











2.28




635




632




650




682






2.33




636




634




679




675






V1




583




593




511




603






V2




570




686




605




558











RT = room temperature













In all cases, the novel additives exhibit a substantially better dispersing effect than the prior art additives.



Claims
  • 1. A copolymer I carrying functional groups and comprisinga) 20-60 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated C4-C6-dicarboxylic acid or an anhydride thereof, b) 10-70 mol % of at least one oligomer of propene or of a branched 1-olefin of 4 to 10 carbon atoms, having an average molecular weight Mw of from 300 to 5000, and c) 1-50 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated compound which is copolymerizable with the monomers a) and b).
  • 2. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1, which contains an oligoisobutene as the monomer b).
  • 3. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1 or 2, obtainable frommonoethylenically unsaturated C3-C10-monocarboxylic acids, linear 1-olefins of 2 to 40 carbon atoms or vinyl or alkyl allyl ethers where the alkyl radical is of 1 to 40 carbon atoms as monomer (c).
  • 4. A process for the preparation of a copolymer I carrying functional groups, as claimed in claim 1, comprising subjectinga) 20-60 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated C4-C6-dicarboxylic acid or an anhydride thereof, b) 10-70 mol % of at least one oligomer of propene or of a branched 1-olefin of 4 to 10 carbon atoms, having an average molecular weight Mw from 300 to 5000, and c) 1-50 mol % of at least one monoethylenically unsaturated compound which is copolymerizable with the monomers a) and b), to free radical polymerization.
  • 5. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1, wherein monomer (a) comprises maleic anhydride.
  • 6. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1, wherein the oligomer contains a copolymerizable terminal group in the form of a vinyl, vinylidene or alkyl vinylidene group.
  • 7. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1, wherein the oligomer is an oligopropene or an oligopropene mixture of 9-200 carbon atoms.
  • 8. A copolymer as claimed in claim 1, wherein the oligomer is a mixture of oligoisobutenes or a mixture of oligopropenes and oligoisobutenes.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
43 30 971 Sep 1993 DE
US Referenced Citations (18)
Number Name Date Kind
3755169 Adams et al. Aug 1973 A
4184993 Singh et al. Jan 1980 A
4240916 Rossi Dec 1980 A
4298630 Kapuscinski et al. Nov 1981 A
4503182 Durand et al. Mar 1985 A
4575382 Sweeney et al. Mar 1986 A
4664676 Dennis et al. May 1987 A
4780111 Dorer et al. Oct 1988 A
5009805 Perner et al. Apr 1991 A
5034018 Gutierrez et al. Jul 1991 A
5238466 Guiterrez et al. Aug 1993 A
5286263 Schaffer et al. Feb 1994 A
5733993 Yu et al. Mar 1998 A
5747619 Denzinger et al. May 1998 A
5792729 Harrison et al. Aug 1998 A
5814706 Yu et al. Sep 1998 A
6200640 Kneip et al. Mar 2001 B1
6284716 Gunther et al. Sep 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (12)
Number Date Country
3233775 Mar 1984 DE
27 02 604 Aug 1984 DE
WO 9003359 Apr 1990 DE
0009170 Feb 1980 EP
0009185 Feb 1980 EP
113904 Jul 1984 EP
137413 Apr 1985 EP
306991 Mar 1989 EP
306992 Mar 1989 EP
2028522 Sep 1970 FR
2065676 Jan 1981 GB
2097800 Nov 1982 GB
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
Abstract, Showa JP 59068393 AZ Apr. 18, 1984.
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 08/605073 US
Child 09/848281 US