The present invention relates to the structure and design of an apparatus providing heat exchange between relatively hot gas and relatively cold air in air preheaters for a fired burner. More specifically, the invention is concerned with heat transfer from the hot exhaust gasses that contain corrosive content, such as sulfur and other chemicals, to the cool air while preventing corrosion of the metal heat transferring tubes. The heated air is utilized for combustion purposes.
An air preheater is a device generally designed to heat air prior to using the air for combustion in a combustion fired heating system, such as a boiler. The primary objective of an air preheater is to increase the thermal efficiency of the process. Air preheaters are commonly used in large boilers found in thermal power stations producing electric power from, e.g. fossil fuels, biomasses or waste. Preheating the air can be achieved by utilizing the heat from the exhaust gasses in the flue. Air preheaters recover the heat from the boiler flue gas which increases the thermal efficiency of the boiler by adding heat to the combustion air.
A tubular type of air preheater for use in steam generators in thermal power stations consists of straight tube bundles which extend through the gas outlet or air inlet ducting of the boiler, which tubes are open at each end outside of the ducting. The tubes are located inside the ducting, and the hot furnace exhaust gasses pass through or around the preheater tubes, transferring heat from the exhaust gas to the air inside the preheater. Ambient air is forced by a fan through a first end of the ducting located at one end of the preheater tubes, and the heated air emerges into another set of ducting, which carries the heated air to the boiler furnace for combustion.
The most common flow arrangement for the tubular air preheater is counterflow with gas passing vertically through the tubes and air passing horizontally in one or more passes outside of and in contact with the tubes.
Generally known preheater units comprise a plurality of heat exchange tubes that are placed horizontally in the flue gas duct. The heat exchange units on different height levels are connected to each other by air ducts located outside the flue gas duct. In other configurations the flue gas flows are inside the heat exchange tubes, and the heat exchange tubes are vertical.
In either configuration, the temperature of the ambient air at the inlet side of the preheater unit is significantly lower than at the air outlet side. The cold ambient air at the inlet side can cause a considerable cooling effect, due to the heat transfer coefficient of the air flow at the point of inflow being substantially higher compared to the developed flow deeper in the air duct. Moreover, the ambient air forced across the heat exchange tubes is not substantially warmed at the point of inflow into the heat exchanger.
This strong cooling of the metal heat exchange tubes at the air inlet can cause the surface of the heat exchange unit at the inlet end to drop below the acid dew point of chemicals in the flue gasses in contact with the tubes. One of the most serious problems with tubular air preheaters is dew point corrosion. If the metal temperature within the tubes drops below the acid saturation temperature, usually between 190° F. (88° C.) and 230° F. (110° C.), but sometimes at temperatures as high as 325° F. (169° C.), then the risk of dew point corrosion damage to the tubes from the chemicals in the flue gas becomes considerable. For example, the dew point of hydrochloric acid (HCl) is around 175° F., sulfuric acid (H2SO4) is around 325° F., and phosphoric acid (H3PO4) is around 225° F. The low temperatures throughout the operating cycle create an extremely corrosive environment for all the commonly used types of carbon steel tubes. When the service life of the air preheater tubes falls to less than five years, the operation and maintenance cost of the air preheater dramatically diminishes the gross margin of the entire operating facility.
Tube failures caused by high corrosion rates allow combustion air to short-circuit the boiler and go directly up the chimney. The induced draft and forced draft fan amperage is increased to push/pull more air through the system until the boiler capacity decreases due to the lack of combustion air reaching the boiler. Also, all of the downstream pollution control systems are negatively affected and the most, if not all, of the environmental headroom is lost. Both of these effects can force the unit to be taken off line to plug tube failures or clean the air heater. The tube failures and fouling force the boiler to 1) burn more fuel; 2) reduce the net electricity sold because the increased fan load creates parasitic losses; 3) increase the amount of greenhouse gasses entering the environment; and 4) decrease the gross margin of the facility.
To overcome the described dew point corrosion problem, it is common in the industry to either add more steam or gas air preheaters upstream of the tubular air heater, or to substitute the tube metallurgy to a more corrosion resistant material. If one chooses to add preheaters upstream of the air heater, these preheaters are typically used at startup and low load to increase the air inlet temperature. In most air heaters the metal temperature is above the acid dew point at full load. In the subset of tubular air heaters, the acid dew point occurs downstream in the pollution control systems. This method consumes significantly more energy to preheat the incoming ambient air in the heat exchange system.
The most common materials used to substitute for carbon steel to make the heat exchange tubes are austenitic stainless steel, and martensitic stainless steel. These stainless steels all have low thermal conductivity. This causes the slow heating of the metal tubes, causing the tubes to “sweat” and trap fly ash during the operation of the system. The ashes can quickly fill the tubes, eventually requiring removal of the tubes from service. The austenitic stainless steels also have a high coefficient of thermal expansion. This causes the heat exchange tubes to crack near the tube sheets after repeated cycling.
There lacks a durable apparatus and method for resolving the dew point corrosion problem effectively and still maintain the thermal efficiency of the heat exchanger in the system.
The present invention uses a low-cost, double-wall carbon steel tubing structure to reduce corrosion rates and significantly reduce fly ash fouling by raising the metal temperature of heat exchanger tubes above the acid dew points of the corrosive species present in the exhaust gasses. The system utilizes inner liners together with the outer tube structure to change the thermodynamics of the system and to maintain the temperature of the tubes above the dew points of the corrosive acids. The thermal efficiency of the system, however, is not significantly changed by using the newly structured tubes. The present invention also saves energy and improves the service life of the heat exchange tubes.
The features of the present invention which are believed to be novel are set forth with particularity in the appended claims. The invention may best be understood from the following detailed description of currently illustrated embodiments thereof, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein like numerals refer to like parts, and in which:
In a common counterflow heat exchange system, the hot gasses and the ambient air to be heated are flowing in different directions during the exchange heat process. The hot gasses come into the system with a higher temperature and leave the system at a lower temperature. The ambient air comes into the system with a temperature lower than when the air leaves the system. A variety of single and multiple gas and air path arrangements are employed to accommodate plant layouts.
At the ambient air inlet end of the system in most of the present designs for preheaters, both the ambient air forced into the system and the hot exhaust gasses are typically at their lowest temperature point in the entire process, which is normally below the dew point for the corrosive chemicals in the exhaust gasses. This is also where all the dew point corrosion is most likely to take place. Also, in the scenario where the hot exhaust gas is still above the dew point, the temperature of the metal tubes may still be relatively cold. When the cold metal comes into contact with the corrosive vapors in the exhaust gasses, vapors condense as corrosive acid liquids to cause corrosion, and the liquid traps ashes.
The inner liner 101 passes heat from the hot gasses in path 104 through the sealed air portion 107 to the outer surface of tube 103 by radiation. The outer surface of tube 103 can be sufficiently heated because of the high thermal conductivity of the materials used for the liner 101 and outer tube 103. The ambient air outside outer surface of the outer tube 103 picks up heat from contact with the outer surface of outer tube 103, instead of directly drawing heat from the inner liner 101. While the heat transfer from the outer surface of the outer tube 103 to the ambient air would be high, the presence of the intermediate layer of air 107 protects the inner liner 101 from too high a rate of heat loss and super cooling. This maintains the temperature of the metal surfaces of liner 101 contacting the exhaust gas above the dew point temperature. The use of inner liners 101 of a predetermined length, less than the length of the tubes 100, in only a small section of the tubes 100, such as section 210 in
The heat transferring tubes 212 are made from carbon steels that have high thermal conductivity. The heat transferring tubes 212 are aligned parallel to each other in the direction substantially perpendicular to the direction of air flow in air inlet 202. A top tube sheet 214 and a bottom tube sheet 216 hold the tubes 212 to maintain their positions. Each heat transferring tube 212 has a very thin outer wall, and the thin walls form conduits for the gasses to flow through the tubes 212. The hot exhaust gasses 208 enter into the tubes 212 of the air preheater 200 from the top or bottom, and flow inside the tubes 212 to the top of the preheater 200. The tubes 212 are heated as described in conjunction with the tube 100 shown in
There should be as rapid and as turbulent a flow of the ambient air to pick up as much heat as possible from the metal outer surfaces of the tubes 212. However, if the rapid heat capturing causes the outer surface temperature of tubes 212 to drop below the dew point, then, for example, the corrosive sulfur trioxide which is present in the gas 208 will condense as sulfuric acid and will cause corrosion. The outer surfaces of heat transferring tubes 212 adjacent to the ambient air inlet 202 have the highest rate of contact with the ambient cool air. Therefore, the tubes 212 adjacent to the air inlet 212 are lined with liners 101 (
Shaded area 210 in
The vertical length of the lined portion 210 of the tubes 212 extends at least no shorter than the width of the first air path 204 to fully contact all the cool air in path 204 entering the system through air inlet 202. The liners 101 do not terminate just at the lowest point of the air inlet 202, but extend further a short distance 220 toward the bottom of the tubes 212. The temperature of the metal tubes 212 at the bottom of distance 220 is above the dew point. The extended portion 220 of the liners 101 is to prevent the joint of lined and unlined portions of the tubes 212 adjacent to the lowest point of the air inlet 202 from forming a heat-sink at the bottom of liner 101. This heat sink is to be avoided since the sink would take heat from the metal surfaces of tubes 212, possibly causing the metal tube temperature to drop below the dew point. By calculation and experimentation, the liners 101 in the embodiment of
The hot exhaust gasses from boilers are directed into the air preheater 300 through the top of a first set of the heat exchanging tubes 312a as shown at the left side of
Super cooling caused by rapid heat exchange can take place at the air inlet end 302 of the heat exchange system of
As explained in the description of
The vertical length of the lined tubes in area 314 are fully extended no shorter than the width of air inlet 302 to fully contact all the cool ambient air entering the system. The liners 101 (
Hot exhaust gasses 408 enter into the system in the embodiment of
All of the initially cool air forced into the heating system 400 by a fan passes through a portion of tubes 414 that are lined (
Additional protections are provided to prevent corrosion of the cold end tube sheet 416 as well. Tube sheet 416 at the cold end in the embodiment shown in
To connect one end of tube 603 to an abutting end of tube 605, a hollow extension member 601 is partially and frictionally inserted into one end of tube 603. The remaining part of the extension member 601 is frictionally inserted into one end of tube 605. The connecting line 623 in
While several particular embodiments of corrosive resistant air preheaters of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that changes and modifications may be made without departing from the true spirit and scope of the present invention. It is the intent of the appended claims to cover all such changes and modifications as fall within the true spirit and scope of the invention.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2735660 | Craig | Feb 1956 | A |
2838287 | Kuhner | Jun 1958 | A |
2854220 | Vaughan | Sep 1958 | A |
3170512 | Smith | Feb 1965 | A |
3802497 | Kummel et al. | Apr 1974 | A |
4029142 | Van Beukering | Jun 1977 | A |
4034803 | Reed et al. | Jul 1977 | A |
4191246 | Cassell | Mar 1980 | A |
4371027 | Jacobsen | Feb 1983 | A |
4483391 | Gilbert | Nov 1984 | A |
4646816 | Rothstein | Mar 1987 | A |
4693233 | Meith | Sep 1987 | A |
4858684 | Brucher et al. | Aug 1989 | A |
5400588 | Yamane et al. | Mar 1995 | A |
7681922 | Galatello Adamo | Mar 2010 | B2 |
20040191709 | Miller | Sep 2004 | A1 |
20120073483 | Ojanpera | Mar 2012 | A1 |
20130062044 | Nickull | Mar 2013 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
S59137794 | Aug 1984 | JP |
Entry |
---|
Dewpoint Corrosion of a Coastal Biomass Power Boiler Air Heater. |
Water Purification Handbook, Cold End Deposition and Corrosion Control. |
Babcock & Wilcox Economizers and Air Heaters. |
Hydrocarbon Processing, Cold end corrosion: causes and cures. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20140352931 A1 | Dec 2014 | US |