IVAX, et al v. Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company, complaint filed Aug. 30, 2000, Civil action 00-3219, U.S. District Court for the Southern Distric of Florida. |
Complaint, Glaxo Wellcome Inc. v. Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing, Civil Action No. 1:99CV00536, filed Jun. 25, 1999, United States District Court, Middle District of North Carolina, Durham Division. |
Bowman, P., Letter to EPO re, Opposition to EP 0372777, dated Aug. 18, 1994, submitted in Japanese Opposition to 2786493. |
Tsuda, et al., “Manufacturing Method for Medicine”, vol. 2, Medicine Development Basic Course XI, pp. 540-553, Nov. 15, 1971, (K.K. Chijin Shokan, Shinjuku, Tokyo. |
Fukai, et al, Today's New Medicine, pp. 196-345, Apr. 30, 1988, (Yakugyo Jifosha, Japan). |
Awatsu, et al, Study of New Medicine, 5th Revised Edition, pp. 281-286, May 20, 1987, (Hirokawa Shoten, Tokyo). |
Nippon Glaxo Product Literature, “Becotide 50 Inhaler, Becotide 100 Inhaler” , Revised Jan. 1996 and Feb. 1995. |
“Dielectric Constants of Organic Compounds”, Table of Compiled Information submitted Jul. 11, 1996 in Opposition to European Patent EP 0499344. |
Dictionnaire Vidal, 55th Ed., 1979, pp. 392—Chibro-Plast, 1195, 1926—Spray 1000, 1927, 2238-2240— |
Ventoline Aerosol-doseur (O.V.P., Paris). |
Anderson, Philip O. “Chlorofluorocarbons in Medicines”, American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, vol. 47, Jun. 1990, pp. 1382-1385. |
“3M's Airomir HFA system ready,” SCRIP No. 1926, p. 30, May 27, 1994. |
Neumüller, Dr. Otto-Albrecht, Rompps Chemie-Lexikon, 8th Ed.,p. 3898, 1987 (Franckh's Publication House, Stuttgart, Germany). |
Newhouse, M.T., “Metered Dose Pressuruized aerosols and the Ozone Layer”, Eur. Respir. J. vol. 2 pp. 1232-1233 (1990). |
Sanders, Paul A. Ph.D. “Spray Characteristics,” Handbook of Aerosol Technology, Second Edition, Chapter 9, pp. 145-164 (1979) (Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York). |
“Fluorocarbon/Ozone Alternatives to Fully Halogenated Chlorofluorocarbons: The Du Pont Development Program”, Dupont Update, Mar. 1987, Dupont Freon Products Division. |
“Du Pont to drop CFCs—Atochem & Allied link,” Manufacturing Chemist, May 1988, p. 17. |
Spauschus, H.O., “HFC 134a as a Substitute Refrigerant for CFC 12”,Int. J. Refrig., 1988, vol. 11, Nov. (based on paper presented 18 to 21 Jul. 1988). |
“Les Substituts F 22—F 502, FC 142b, F 123-F134a, FC 141b”, Atochem Product Information, dated Oct. 1988. |
Dorvault, F., L'Officine, 20th Ed., (1978), pp. 547-548 (Editions Vigot, Paris, France). |
Dexa-Rhinospray© Spray Doscur, product labeling, Aug. 1970, (C. H. Bochringer Sohn Ingelheim AM Rhein, Germany). |
Pedersen, Henrik et al., “CFC-Gasser I Medicinske Spray,” Ugeskr Laeger, 151/12, Mar. 1989,, pp. |
Reiner, E., “Fluorocarbons and Ozone”, Symposium on Vapor Phase Soldering, Sunnyvale, CA, Apr. 4, 1988. |
James, D.H., “Important Information on CFC Issue,” Western Union Mailgram letter from DuPont to propellant customer, Dick Bunning, Mar. 24, 1988. |
“Minutes of the Metered Dose Pharmaceutical CFC Meeting Held at 3M Company on Jan. 24, 1989,” submitted in the U.K. High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent Nos. 0,372,777,0,499,344,and 0,553,298). |
Kelly, S.W., “Opportunities for Alternaives to CFCs in the Aerosol Sector,” Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) report, submitted in the U.K. Hight Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent Nos. 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298). |
“Use of Alternative Propellants in Medicinal Pressurized Aerosols,” Research Disclosure, 30161, May 1989, p. 341. |
European Patent Office Technical Board of Appeals Decision, dated Apr. 8, 1999, re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Chronology P 134(a),” submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Du Pont Commercializes CFC Alternative,” Chemical Marketing Reporter, Oct. 3, 1988 (Schnell Publishing Co.). |
“The quest for ‘ozone friendly’ gases,” Financial Times, Nov. 11, 1988 (London). |
“ICI Annouces ‘Ozone Friendly’ Production Plants,” ICI News Release, Nov. 22, 1988 (ICI Americas, Wilmington, Delaware). |
Schoon, N., “ICI to build new ‘ozone-friendly’ chemical plants,” Independent, Nov. 23, 1988. |
“Witness Statement of Ian Smith,” with attachments, submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Witness Statement of John Frederick David Mills,” with attachments, submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Witness Statement of Kay Monaghan,” with attachments, submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Witness Statement of Stuart Kelly,” submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
Transcript pages excerpted from U.K. Patent Courts trial, Jun. 1997, submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“Expert Report of Dr. Ian J. Smith,” submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
Expert Report of John Sciarra, submitted in European Patent Office Opposition proceedings re European Patent EP-B-0 372 777 (Riker Laboratories, Inc.). |
“ICI Despatch Note,” indicating shipment of 134a to 3M (U.K.), submitted in the U.K. High Court of Justice, Chancery Division, Patents Court, before the Honorable, Mr. Justice Jacob, combined cases CH/96/3771 and CH/96/3773 (re European Patent Nos, 0,372,777, 0,499,344, and 0,553,298). |
Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences decision dated Sep. 23, 1997, ex parte Purewal, Wilkinson, Lambert, Smith, Donnell, and Kuepper, Appeal No. 95/3256, U.S. application No. 08/041,276 for “Analgesic Formulations.” |
Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences decision dated Jul. 31, 1995, ex parte Schultz and Schultz, Appeal No. 94-2879, U.S. application No. 07/769,547 for “Beclomethasone Solution Aerosol Formulations.” |
Block, P., “The UN focuses on ozone levels,” Chemical Week, May 13, 1987, pp. 8 and 12. |
New Scientist, p. 22, Apr. 23, 1987. |
Journal of Aerosol Medicine, vol. 4, No. 3, pp. 181-187, 1991. |
Aerosol Age, Jul. 1988, pp. 32-33 and 42-43. |
Handbook of Aerosol Technology, 2nd Ed., p. 30-35, 166-167 and 232-233, 1979. |
Medical Device Technology 5, 21-25, 1991. |
K. Thoma, Aerosol—Moglichkeiten und Probleme einer Darreichungsform, Werber-und Vertriebsgesellschaft Deutscher Apotheker m.b.H., Frankfurt a.M., 1979, 153-161. |
K. Thoma, Pharma Technologie, Concept Heidelberg, 1984, 94-102. |
H-FCKW 123 und H-FKW 134a, Frigen-Information KT 08/88. |
T. Nelson, Alternative Formulations to Reduce CFC Use in U.S. Exempted and Excluded Aerosol Products, Report No. EPA-600/2-89-061; Nov. 1989. |
Aerosol Age, Jul. 1988, pp. 28-31. |
Physicians' Desk Reference, 40th Edition 1986, Medical Economics Company Inc. at Oradell, NJ. |
“Comparison of Output Particle Size Distributions from Pressurized Aerosols Formulated as Solutions or Suspensions”, R.N. Dalby and P.R. Byron, Pharmaceutical Res., vol. 5, No. 1 (1988) p. 36. |
The Theory & Practice of Industrial Pharmacy, Leon Lachman et al., 3rd Ed., Lea & Febiger 1986, Chapter 20, p. 597, 599 and 603. |
Chemical and Engineering News, Nov. 24, 1986, p. 52. |
Handbook of Aerosol Technology, Second Edition (1979), pp. 30, 32, and 33. |
U.S. Senate Hearing, May 12-14, 1987, pp. 487 and 347. |
The Theory and Practice of Industrial Pharmacy, 2nd Edition, 1976, Lea & Fabiger, Philadelphia, pp. 270 and 276-280. |
“CFC Propellant Substitution: International Perspectives”, Pharmaceutical Technology International, 1989, Fischer et al., pp. 16-18. |
Aerosol Age, Nov. 1989, pp. 6,8. |
Aerosol Age, Nov. 1989, p. 12. |
Manufacturing Chemist, Nov. 1989, p. 8. |
Aerosol Age, Nov. 1989, pp. 16-19. |
Aerosol Age, Nov. 1989, pp. 24-26. |
International Journal of Refrigeration, 1988, 11, 389 (Spauschus, Nov. 1988). |
Manufacturing Chemist, Feb. 1988, p. 9. |
Processing, Dec. 1988, p. 7. |
Manufacturing Chemist, Sep. 1988, p. 9. |
Manufacturing Chemist, Jun. 1988, p. 3. |
Aerosol Age, Jul. 1988, pp. 28-31. |
New Scientist, May 26, 1988, pp. 56-60. |
Aerosol Age, Aug. 1988, pp. 32-39. |
Research Disclosure, vol. 162, 1977, p. 70 (#16265). |
European Patent Office Opposition Division decision, dated Apr. 10, 1996. |
Jacob, J., United Kingdom Patents Court decision, dated Jun. 30, 1997. |
Anderson, A., “Depletion of Ozone Layer Drives Competitors to Cooperate,” Nature, vol. 331, No. 6153, p. 201 Jan. 21, 1988. |
“Acceptable CFC is Consortium Target,” Rubber & Plastics, Feb. 1988. |
“ICI Caution on CFC 22,” Chemistry and Industry, p. 132, Mar. 7, 1988. |
Shabecoff, P., “Some Concerns See No Success Till 90's” New York Times, pp. D1 and D6, Mar. 31, 1988. |
“ICI Goes It Alone on HCFC 22 Withdrawal,” Manufacturing Chemist, p. 19, Apr. 1988. |
Wright, P., “High-Tech Called into a Grave Ozone Layer Crisis,” The Times, Apr. 5, 1988. |
“French/US CFC Substitutes Venture,” Chemistry and Industry, p. 243, Apr. 18, 1988. |
“CFCs: The Search for ‘Ozone Friendly’ Alternatives,” Process Engineering, pp. 33-34, Jul. 1988. |
“ICI Pioneers ‘Ozone Benign’ Production,” Telegraph, Nov. 23, 1988. |